When I got my last dog it wasn't me choosing anything. I sat down with the litter. Was messing with all of them. Then one just walked right up to me, laid on my foot and fell asleep. He chose me. I finished petting the others, picked him up and took him home. The greatest dog one could ask for.
Absolutely right. It's the one who makes eye contact and chooses you. Goes for cats too. Our son and his wife went to a rescue group to get a kitten. In a room otherwise full of small kittens that were playing only with each other, one two-year-old cat wouldn't leave them alone, and he was the one who took the ride home. :)
That’s how my most special of dogs came into our family. My husband went to a friend with puppies, while he was watching the small group of available ones, one puppy kept following him while all the others were ignoring him. Of course he accepted her choosing, and she turned out to be such a loving, loyal gift. We are approaching the anniversary of her passing now. She was with us for 15 years. I miss her very much. My newest puppy isn’t so well behaved, though I love her own personality. My Daisy May spoiled us I must say though.
@@davethewife7628 Me too. Dogs are wonderful and I've had at least one, and as many as three, all my life. In fact, I would avoid those who don't like dogs. Something is missing.
This was my first dog, Wyatt (RIP). We at an event, and he laid sleeping in my lap for what seemed like hours before I handed him back (couldn't take him home with me yet, too early/young). As I was holding him (facing me) to hand back, his eyes locked on with mine... and it was like there was a connection. He was the best dog anyone could ask for, in-tune and sync with me, for his entire life.
They are rescues . Born to an abandoned dog. I’ve managed to find homes for both parents and all but one pup at this point . Got them vaccinated … papa gets neutered soon . Trying to do the right thing .
Interesting theory on how to pick a pup, might be right even. What’s more interesting to me is the reams of storyline people took the time to write in response to your film. At this moment wars and changes to the world are consuming the internet, yet here are your subscribers tenderly describing their own moment when they met Rex or Hailey and how they each knew that they were “the one”. God bless ‘em! Peace and long life.
I have had numerous dogs over the course of my life, I’m 67 years old now. I’m sure this is one way to test a dog’s temperament, but I’m not sure it’s the only indication of a dog’s personality. I adopted my little girl dog at 5 months old from a neighbor who had to move, and couldn’t keep her. From day one she absolutely refused to be turned on her back….that being said…..she is house broken to the point that even if she has an upset stomach she insists we take her out, she has never tried to sneak human food even when it’s been close enough for her to reach on her own, she has always had lots of energy, but has never been aggressive towards kids or other dogs. She is now 19 years, and 6 months old, and has been the biggest blessing…..absolutely loyal, and loving. At her age we realize the time is quickly approaching that she won’t be with us much longer…she has spoiled us with her goodness so much so that I can’t imagine ever getting another dog. If someone only used this method in this video to select their pet she never would have been chosen!
Definitely! If you want to help and save a dog then do it. Don't go searching for features like you're buying an appliance. Any dog will be a good dog if you put in the work to educate and take care of him. I only had stray dogs and cats my whole life and they were chosen on a "they need me" basis. All of them were a blessing!
@@akalizzy84. Same here, my cats and dogs all showed up and we kept them. Loved every one of them and they all had their own individual personalities. ❤❤🐾🐾
Depends what you're choosing the dog for. A completely submissive dog is often not going to sustain their confidence for certain jobs like an assistant dog. Being a more dominating dog like yours probably was doesn't mean they're not easy to train or not likely to be as loyal. It only really means they're not quite as genuinely submissive, and so in a perceived life or death situation they're more likely to defend themselves. The only reason I can think of for wanting a more submissive dog would be if you're concerned about absolute safety around children before any training, nurturing or bonding occurs
Two years ago, I picked up two abandoned puppies, around 2-3 months old. They were sisters, almost identical in appearance but with completely different personalities! At first, I didn’t think about keeping a dog (although I had always dreamed of it, it never came to realization), so I started looking for a new home for the little girls. One was quiet and calm, always walking behind my feet on walks. The other one was a playful rascal, who explored everything around her during walks, always rushing somewhere, and at home, she tried to play with everything in her path. She never sat still in my arms; instead, she would try to climb onto my head! For several weeks, a few people came to meet the puppies. Eventually, a calm one was taken by a suburban couple. A little while later, a girl agreed to take the mischievous one and said she would come back in a couple of days. In the end, I couldn’t give her away because I realized that this playful rascal had found a permanent place in my heart. My beloved bundle of joy, the kindest of dogs! This test helps reveal a puppy's personality, but the choice is ours - which temperament resonates with our heart!
When I picked my malinois from all the puppies, she was the furious en smallest. She had to stand her ground for everything. She was grumpy to the dad and other dogs. Nobody wanted her. Lots of training and love she was the perfect dog. She never needed a leash, listened perfectly. I biked everywhere in the city centre of Amsterdam without a leash. Most important thing is training your puppy! Patience and love!
We watched ours playing with her siblings. There was one who just sat and watched the others run about. Others who were just manic and rushed about not stopping for anything. Our gorgeous girl was really curious, did chase her brothers but liked to be chased too, she stopped to sniff the flowers. Best of all she was interested in coming to see us. She came over, had a good interaction with us, listened when we said things even if she didn’t yet know what they meant. We always say that she chose us. We never thought to turn her upside down!
My first dog, and all since was a Beagle. He was one of a litter of five. He was the first one to notice me and came over, sniffed and licked my hand. The, the other four rushed over, knocking him out of the way and into their bowl of water. His paw caught the edge causing the bowl, and the water, to flip over onto him. Sad, drenched and knocked out of the way by four female puppies…I knew he was the dog for me. Sixteen great years!
I went to chose a golden retriever puppy. The litter was in a back yard and I watched them at play. They were 7 weeks but wouldn't be allowed to leave until the end of their 8th week. All the puppies were active, and I could see immediately that one female, larger than the rest was a bully. She really threw her weight around and stole toys from the other puppies. One puppy, however, preferred to stay closer to the breeder and me, and he found a pinecone and laid down just to my left, to gnaw on it. The bully female saw him, ran over and took the pinecone from his mouth. He did not show any sign of resource guarding and just let her take it. However, as she got about 5 feet away, he jumped up, ran after her and quickly stole the pinecone right out of her mouth, then ran back towards me and got behind me to lay down and play with it again. The female puppy looked too surprised to go after him and she went back to the pile of puppies playing with each other. That, no resource guarding...but...also, confident enough to go get his 'toy' back, impressed me, as well as his wishing to be near humans more than the littermates. I picked him up at the middle of week 9. He's 9 years old now, I named him AU (Au being the chemical name for gold, but it sounds like Hey You to most folks...and that's an inside joke for me, because back in the 1970's I had a dog named Hey You). AU has been the most gentle, smart dogs I've owned. Training him was almost effortless, and he's naturally gentle with children, other animals and loves people. This, even though I live alone, have no kids around, and he doesn't see other dogs/cats that often. I think I got the best of the litter that day.
I can't believe alll the negative comments. People thinking their ownership of a few dogs makes them an expert. Ready to shoot down anything they're unfamiliar with. I used this exact method, along with a couple of other tests, to select my first Toller. Tollers are a high-energy, very intelligent breed that I fell in love with at first sight. This test of submissiveness was one of the most important for me, along with another one that tested the pup's interest in humans and other dogs. I chose the puppy that was in the middle of the extremes on both tests, and he was the best dog in the world for his entire life. (Well, except for the time he ripped open all the Christmas presents looking for chocolate.) Of course you need to train your dog to bring out their best. Of course different people appreciate different things about their pets. I think the person who believes that dogs' personalities change is off base. But starting with a cooperative, responsive dog is a huge plus. Going solely on emotion gets people in trouble time and again. Maybe not YOU. But why turn down an idea that's sensible and meant to make things easier for everyone?
I agree with some things you say but disagree with your tone and overall reaction to "negative" comments. I didn't write any comments but want to respond to you. Your repetitive "of course its like this, of course its like that" statements mock people who took the time to contribute to the discussion, share parts of their lives, share stories of their pets, give their opinions after monetizing this video with their time viewing it. Disagreement does not equate to negativity. If you were expecting a Dodo channel type of comments section full of "aw cute overload omg thank you for your kindness stranger" then you should calibrate your expectations, and be open to disagreement before clicking the comments section. Secondly, you use the term "pet expert" as if pet expertise is a solid study of science without differing approaches, controversial training styles, evolving practices from new research, competing philosophies on animal welfare and rights, and so on. Third, you dismiss people commenting as "simple owners[hip]," but actually do not know if some people had or have careers connected to animal behaviour, animal training, shelter management, or vet services. Fourth, the "pet expert" in the video should have, in my view, taken 15 seconds to make sure her vdieo doesn't seem to de-value dogs with temperaments other than a single one: totally submissive. Doing that likely wouldn't have pushed some to defend their pets as a beloved family member and as a creature of equal value to any other regardless of temperament. No this is not an "of course it's obvious" fact. The communication shortcomings of the video and your disrespect to people who give the video life are both awful.
I cant count how many dogs my family and I have rescued. Mostly middle aged to old but a couple of pups too. All shapes, sizes, personalities, backgrounds. And we hardly ever met any of them before we got them. They only needed to fulfill one criteria and that is to be not too bad with other dogs. And everyone of them have been perfect, even the naughty ones 😂 Such a diversity of personalities. All beautiful.
Such cute puppies 😍 Thank you for treating them with love and care. Just because this wouldn't necessarily be how I would choose a dog doesn't mean it's wrong. If someone isn't experienced with dogs and needs a more mild tempered puppy for kids etc I think its a great method!
I heard about this years ago. It works. I generally let the puppy pick me, but I always do the back test. There have been a few times where the puppy was pick out for me and they have been excellent dogs (maybe lucky, but it comes down to teaching right from the beginning; teach often, handle often, get better results).
I sat down and got mauled by 7 Newfoundland pups, but the one that climbed up into my lap and licked my face like he already knew me and was glad to see me again chose me. I'm just glad I was able to realize it. 😁
As an 8 year old I chose my first kitten when she came to me and I think she climbed into my lap. It’s been so long but I do recall she “picked me”. All her siblings were there too but she came to see me.
I've had 2 Jack Russell's because I love terriers. Both acted like they could care less if I took them home...all attitude! I didn't care. I fell in love and that was it.
Meanwhile I had the sassiest pup of the litter claim me by sitting on my lap. She still does that wherever she sees me sit on the ground, but she's 6,5 years old and 80 pounds now. Love that dog.
You have to be wary of "tests." Years ago there was a puppy test that claimed that if you tugged on the puppy's tail and he turned and tried to nip you he was a "biter." Puppies were even euthanized for doing that, even though it was essentially a play nip. Terrible.
I chose my GSD because he bit me. I was checking out the pups and all were very mellow up to that point, he was the runt and was apparently just chilling, then I went to pet him and he just turned around and bit me. Then I was like "you're a little shit, you're coming home with me!". He grew up to be HUGE, btw, bigger than the breed standards. My Phalcon was a good boy, if a little shit to the very end. I miss him.
This is a great video. We had a litter at home and I wasn't going to keep a pup. The other three all had lovely homes to go to. One morning I came downstairs and the three girl pups were barking like mad and jumping up to the bars of their pen. The only boy just sat there calmly and really stared into my eyes. I thought, he wants to stay with us! The decision was made and it was the right one. He is the kindest most loving little dog, very good with our other animals and little children and a best friend to the adults.
That's so cute, but my street dog puppy would never let you do that. He would have ripped up your arms. He's now 2 years old and mellow . But it's a cute idea. And puppies love cuddles 😍.
People mistakenly choose a dog by breed‼️ It's all about PERSONALITY ‼️I personally look for a calm and curious dog...it saves a lot of time in training‼️
That's a ridiculous statement. Are you seriously suggesting a chilled out Belgian Shepard and a chilled out English Bulldog are gonna require the same thing just because they are both the most chilled of a litter? Or a pug or border collie are going to be equal fits just based on personality. Nope breed matters a Lot. Yep we can pick the calmest or more curious puppy but genetics are important. It would be cruel to get lets say a Border Collie and think you can mould it to be a lap dog, just as it would be cruel to get a pug and bring it for jogs with come on now please
@@marietighe6328^ this lmao. Breed matters, whether people like it or not. If you don't know any breeds of a mix, then you'll have to rely on personality I suppose?
One of my corgis bit me on the nose and drew blood (she was a tiny puppy) when we first met. She turned out to be a wonderful girl. I think this gives some people ideas on what to look for in a puppy. I see the puppy (after 4 of them) and I know I am taking it home!
I conducted psychometric testing with the litter I was choosing from. The winning candidate now drives himself to the country park and has a picnic, instead of chasing a ball. He then kicks back and beats me at chess.
I do something similar, I turn them on their back when they're on the ground and try to hold them there for about 15 seconds. Dogs can still be house trained even if they're wiggly or don't want to stay on their back. The difference is that they may not be as cuddly as the dogs that can stay on their back the longest.
I'd always let my pets choose me. It's an automatic bond that is bigger than any other bond you can ever get with a pet. I'd never choose myself, surely I have my preferences in the gender but if a puppy of the opposite gender walked right up to me I'd let her choose me. Last time I was lucky because out of ten puppies there were only two males and one of them chose me
Actually mine didn't like holding him like a baby when he was puppy but he's 1 and half year old now he loves being hold like this and he's one of best temperament dog u will ever find he's sweet never bit anyone always calm around children I think this is not the only way to find a dogs temperament ...All puppies and dogs are different its more about how they are raised if u raise them with lot of positive attitude they will be positive they do what u teach
I’ve never seen the upside test to determine temperament before, that is interesting! Makes sense! On an aside, couldn’t help notice the planted kisses. I kiss my dogs (9 and 8.5yo) often. Do they understand that it’s a sign of affection or do they just tolerate this idiosyncratic behaviour from “dad”?
Never chosen a pet all of them where given to me by the "universal distribution system" even the birdies and fish (was dumped in a plastic box next to a dumpster). They all have/had different personalities and we respected that only rules were dont be agressive and dont pee in the house 😂. All of them were/are pure joy and part of the family. Unless you need a work dog I don't really think that thi's the best way to choose a pet. Puppies also change when they grow up,they don't always mantain the same personality, some mellow quite drastically and some only stop being blazerunners at senior age. And funny enough some do the exact opposite from sweet shy puppy to tasmanian devil energy 😅.
Don’t pick the one that comes up, pick me pick me. It will be needy. I know I have one. My husband picked the next one and she was off playing with the toys. She is not needy.
You right, my street dog puppy didn't like being held in any way. Now he's super dog and actually listening to me now, he is 2 years old now 😂. Every dog is different like people. She's thinking of the old way of dog growth.
Depends on the animal. Both my dogs relaxed completely when I held them this way, but they also sensed I was most comfortable holding them like this. My sister’s male dachshund only lets certain people pick him up (not me, only once when I was the only person to bring him downstairs), but he is a cuddly bunny on the couch. You have to learn what your dog likes and they are all do different.
Well is not important to me at all, what the personality is. I just adopt them and take them home and that Is it. Same with the cats. Love my furry friends.
Calm down people. There is no perfect way to pick a dog. Cats have the Cat Distribution Thing going on and I believe dog have their own. I'm more worried about people who have pets but treat them badly.
Dominance Theory has been known scientifically for decades to not be true. The real reasons behind the puppies preferring different carrying positions is more to do with them feeling comfortable or safe, or not, in those positions. The 'quiet' puppy wasn't entirely happy being held upside down, if you look at her facial cues and body language. She is just putting up with it more than the other pup. This maybe due to fear, or trust, or maybe even physical traits that make it less uncomfortable than the male pup. Please can we try to understand animals better than resorting to outdated unproven views - there are lots of free resources on animal behavioural science.
to pick the right pup? they all need a home....any of them will be right with love. This is dumb on the human part. yes, animals do choose, they have brains....
I have done this both ways. Most rent dog is a pointer for obvious reason, the previous was a dumped pup. Both have been great, but no one way is right nor wrong.
@@DChristina yes, totally agree, so far, (through 15 years) I have given 5 rescues a loving, happy home. I currently have a senior rescue, 10 years old, she was kept in a cupboard and wasn't fed. Rescues are the best breed as far I am concerned.
I think this is just plain wrong. Many dogs dont like to be on their back because it's genuinely physically uncomfortable for them and has nothing to do with temperament. Similarly, I had one dog who preferred a sit position and another who preferred a down position. Had nothing to do with their temperament. It was what they found most physically comfortable. Thats not to say that there arent reliable temperament tests out there. But this isnt one of them.
I pick them all up and do this type of process. But ultimately if I can't decide, I put them all down and walk away and the one who cries for me the most is my choice. Because it's most likely to listen to me and wants to bond. This process got me a beagle that lived about 14 years, a Rottweiler that lived to 14 and a chihuahua that lived to 17. All excellent! ❤🐕🦮🐕🦺
When I got my last dog it wasn't me choosing anything. I sat down with the litter. Was messing with all of them. Then one just walked right up to me, laid on my foot and fell asleep. He chose me. I finished petting the others, picked him up and took him home. The greatest dog one could ask for.
Absolutely right. It's the one who makes eye contact and chooses you. Goes for cats too. Our son and his wife went to a rescue group to get a kitten. In a room otherwise full of small kittens that were playing only with each other, one two-year-old cat wouldn't leave them alone, and he was the one who took the ride home. :)
I do this too. Let them pick me. I love dogs and without one i would be miserablex
That’s how my most special of dogs came into our family. My husband went to a friend with puppies, while he was watching the small group of available ones, one puppy kept following him while all the others were ignoring him. Of course he accepted her choosing, and she turned out to be such a loving, loyal gift. We are approaching the anniversary of her passing now. She was with us for 15 years. I miss her very much.
My newest puppy isn’t so well behaved, though I love her own personality. My Daisy May spoiled us I must say though.
@@davethewife7628 Me too. Dogs are wonderful and I've had at least one, and as many as three, all my life. In fact, I would avoid those who don't like dogs. Something is missing.
This was my first dog, Wyatt (RIP). We at an event, and he laid sleeping in my lap for what seemed like hours before I handed him back (couldn't take him home with me yet, too early/young). As I was holding him (facing me) to hand back, his eyes locked on with mine... and it was like there was a connection. He was the best dog anyone could ask for, in-tune and sync with me, for his entire life.
They are rescues . Born to an abandoned dog. I’ve managed to find homes for both parents and all but one pup at this point . Got them vaccinated … papa gets neutered soon . Trying to do the right thing .
❤
Bless your heart madam ❤
Interesting theory on how to pick a pup, might be right even. What’s more interesting to me is the reams of storyline people took the time to write in response to your film. At this moment wars and changes to the world are consuming the internet, yet here are your subscribers tenderly describing their own moment when they met Rex or Hailey and how they each knew that they were “the one”. God bless ‘em! Peace and long life.
I have had numerous dogs over the course of my life, I’m 67 years old now. I’m sure this is one way to test a dog’s temperament, but I’m not sure it’s the only indication of a dog’s personality. I adopted my little girl dog at 5 months old from a neighbor who had to move, and couldn’t keep her. From day one she absolutely refused to be turned on her back….that being said…..she is house broken to the point that even if she has an upset stomach she insists we take her out, she has never tried to sneak human food even when it’s been close enough for her to reach on her own, she has always had lots of energy, but has never been aggressive towards kids or other dogs. She is now 19 years, and 6 months old, and has been the biggest blessing…..absolutely loyal, and loving. At her age we realize the time is quickly approaching that she won’t be with us much longer…she has spoiled us with her goodness so much so that I can’t imagine ever getting another dog. If someone only used this method in this video to select their pet she never would have been chosen!
Definitely! If you want to help and save a dog then do it. Don't go searching for features like you're buying an appliance. Any dog will be a good dog if you put in the work to educate and take care of him. I only had stray dogs and cats my whole life and they were chosen on a "they need me" basis. All of them were a blessing!
@@akalizzy84. Same here, my cats and dogs all showed up and we kept them. Loved every one of them and they all had their own individual personalities. ❤❤🐾🐾
A different standard for potential working dogs.
Depends what you're choosing the dog for. A completely submissive dog is often not going to sustain their confidence for certain jobs like an assistant dog. Being a more dominating dog like yours probably was doesn't mean they're not easy to train or not likely to be as loyal. It only really means they're not quite as genuinely submissive, and so in a perceived life or death situation they're more likely to defend themselves. The only reason I can think of for wanting a more submissive dog would be if you're concerned about absolute safety around children before any training, nurturing or bonding occurs
Two years ago, I picked up two abandoned puppies, around 2-3 months old. They were sisters, almost identical in appearance but with completely different personalities! At first, I didn’t think about keeping a dog (although I had always dreamed of it, it never came to realization), so I started looking for a new home for the little girls. One was quiet and calm, always walking behind my feet on walks. The other one was a playful rascal, who explored everything around her during walks, always rushing somewhere, and at home, she tried to play with everything in her path. She never sat still in my arms; instead, she would try to climb onto my head!
For several weeks, a few people came to meet the puppies. Eventually, a calm one was taken by a suburban couple. A little while later, a girl agreed to take the mischievous one and said she would come back in a couple of days. In the end, I couldn’t give her away because I realized that this playful rascal had found a permanent place in my heart. My beloved bundle of joy, the kindest of dogs!
This test helps reveal a puppy's personality, but the choice is ours - which temperament resonates with our heart!
When I picked my malinois from all the puppies, she was the furious en smallest. She had to stand her ground for everything. She was grumpy to the dad and other dogs. Nobody wanted her. Lots of training and love she was the perfect dog. She never needed a leash, listened perfectly. I biked everywhere in the city centre of Amsterdam without a leash. Most important thing is training your puppy! Patience and love!
We watched ours playing with her siblings. There was one who just sat and watched the others run about. Others who were just manic and rushed about not stopping for anything. Our gorgeous girl was really curious, did chase her brothers but liked to be chased too, she stopped to sniff the flowers. Best of all she was interested in coming to see us. She came over, had a good interaction with us, listened when we said things even if she didn’t yet know what they meant. We always say that she chose us. We never thought to turn her upside down!
That sounds like a great dog based on the description. Sounds like a thoughtful sweet girl!
My first dog, and all since was a Beagle. He was one of a litter of five. He was the first one to notice me and came over, sniffed and licked my hand. The, the other four rushed over, knocking him out of the way and into their bowl of water. His paw caught the edge causing the bowl, and the water, to flip over onto him. Sad, drenched and knocked out of the way by four female puppies…I knew he was the dog for me. Sixteen great years!
I went to chose a golden retriever puppy. The litter was in a back yard and I watched them at play. They were 7 weeks but wouldn't be allowed to leave until the end of their 8th week.
All the puppies were active, and I could see immediately that one female, larger than the rest was a bully. She really threw her weight around and stole toys from the other puppies.
One puppy, however, preferred to stay closer to the breeder and me, and he found a pinecone and laid down just to my left, to gnaw on it. The bully female saw him, ran over and took the pinecone from his mouth. He did not show any sign of resource guarding and just let her take it. However, as she got about 5 feet away, he jumped up, ran after her and quickly stole the pinecone right out of her mouth, then ran back towards me and got behind me to lay down and play with it again. The female puppy looked too surprised to go after him and she went back to the pile of puppies playing with each other.
That, no resource guarding...but...also, confident enough to go get his 'toy' back, impressed me, as well as his wishing to be near humans more than the littermates. I picked him up at the middle of week 9.
He's 9 years old now, I named him AU (Au being the chemical name for gold, but it sounds like Hey You to most folks...and that's an inside joke for me, because back in the 1970's I had a dog named Hey You). AU has been the most gentle, smart dogs I've owned. Training him was almost effortless, and he's naturally gentle with children, other animals and loves people. This, even though I live alone, have no kids around, and he doesn't see other dogs/cats that often. I think I got the best of the litter that day.
I can't believe alll the negative comments. People thinking their ownership of a few dogs makes them an expert. Ready to shoot down anything they're unfamiliar with.
I used this exact method, along with a couple of other tests, to select my first Toller. Tollers are a high-energy, very intelligent breed that I fell in love with at first sight. This test of submissiveness was one of the most important for me, along with another one that tested the pup's interest in humans and other dogs. I chose the puppy that was in the middle of the extremes on both tests, and he was the best dog in the world for his entire life. (Well, except for the time he ripped open all the Christmas presents looking for chocolate.)
Of course you need to train your dog to bring out their best. Of course different people appreciate different things about their pets. I think the person who believes that dogs' personalities change is off base. But starting with a cooperative, responsive dog is a huge plus. Going solely on emotion gets people in trouble time and again. Maybe not YOU. But why turn down an idea that's sensible and meant to make things easier for everyone?
I agree with some things you say but disagree with your tone and overall reaction to "negative" comments. I didn't write any comments but want to respond to you. Your repetitive "of course its like this, of course its like that" statements mock people who took the time to contribute to the discussion, share parts of their lives, share stories of their pets, give their opinions after monetizing this video with their time viewing it. Disagreement does not equate to negativity. If you were expecting a Dodo channel type of comments section full of "aw cute overload omg thank you for your kindness stranger" then you should calibrate your expectations, and be open to disagreement before clicking the comments section. Secondly, you use the term "pet expert" as if pet expertise is a solid study of science without differing approaches, controversial training styles, evolving practices from new research, competing philosophies on animal welfare and rights, and so on. Third, you dismiss people commenting as "simple owners[hip]," but actually do not know if some people had or have careers connected to animal behaviour, animal training, shelter management, or vet services. Fourth, the "pet expert" in the video should have, in my view, taken 15 seconds to make sure her vdieo doesn't seem to de-value dogs with temperaments other than a single one: totally submissive. Doing that likely wouldn't have pushed some to defend their pets as a beloved family member and as a creature of equal value to any other regardless of temperament. No this is not an "of course it's obvious" fact. The communication shortcomings of the video and your disrespect to people who give the video life are both awful.
I cant count how many dogs my family and I have rescued. Mostly middle aged to old but a couple of pups too. All shapes, sizes, personalities, backgrounds. And we hardly ever met any of them before we got them. They only needed to fulfill one criteria and that is to be not too bad with other dogs. And everyone of them have been perfect, even the naughty ones 😂 Such a diversity of personalities. All beautiful.
Such cute puppies 😍 Thank you for treating them with love and care. Just because this wouldn't necessarily be how I would choose a dog doesn't mean it's wrong. If someone isn't experienced with dogs and needs a more mild tempered puppy for kids etc I think its a great method!
I heard about this years ago. It works. I generally let the puppy pick me, but I always do the back test. There have been a few times where the puppy was pick out for me and they have been excellent dogs (maybe lucky, but it comes down to teaching right from the beginning; teach often, handle often, get better results).
I sat down and got mauled by 7 Newfoundland pups, but the one that climbed up into my lap and licked my face like he already knew me and was glad to see me again chose me. I'm just glad I was able to realize it.
😁
As an 8 year old I chose my first kitten when she came to me and I think she climbed into my lap. It’s been so long but I do recall she “picked me”. All her siblings were there too but she came to see me.
I've got a rescue cat he love's been on my shoulder, I love him
Beautiful pups all❤❤❤❤ hard to choose, they are all so lovely 😍 different personalities indeed but all so lovely ❤❤
I've had 2 Jack Russell's because I love terriers. Both acted like they could care less if I took them home...all attitude! I didn't care. I fell in love and that was it.
Meanwhile I had the sassiest pup of the litter claim me by sitting on my lap. She still does that wherever she sees me sit on the ground, but she's 6,5 years old and 80 pounds now. Love that dog.
You have to be wary of "tests." Years ago there was a puppy test that claimed that if you tugged on the puppy's tail and he turned and tried to nip you he was a "biter." Puppies were even euthanized for doing that, even though it was essentially a play nip. Terrible.
That's so sad 😭
That's actually messed up
They need love
I chose my GSD because he bit me. I was checking out the pups and all were very mellow up to that point, he was the runt and was apparently just chilling, then I went to pet him and he just turned around and bit me. Then I was like "you're a little shit, you're coming home with me!". He grew up to be HUGE, btw, bigger than the breed standards. My Phalcon was a good boy, if a little shit to the very end. I miss him.
This is a great video. We had a litter at home and I wasn't going to keep a pup. The other three all had lovely homes to go to. One morning I came downstairs and the three girl pups were barking like mad and jumping up to the bars of their pen. The only boy just sat there calmly and really stared into my eyes. I thought, he wants to stay with us! The decision was made and it was the right one. He is the kindest most loving little dog, very good with our other animals and little children and a best friend to the adults.
Great advice.
I woulda choose the first one.
Great info. Thank you! I have a deaf rescued white & red border collie. He's 10 y.o. now. He was 18 months when we adopted him.
@loudloveen Sounds like it was your collie's best day ever when you showed up to adopt!
@@comealongcomealong4480 Aww... Thank you for your lovely message! I really appreciate it!
That's so cute, but my street dog puppy would never let you do that. He would have ripped up your arms. He's now 2 years old and mellow . But it's a cute idea. And puppies love cuddles 😍.
All puppies are good!!!
People mistakenly choose a dog by breed‼️ It's all about PERSONALITY ‼️I personally look for a calm and curious dog...it saves a lot of time in training‼️
That's a ridiculous statement. Are you seriously suggesting a chilled out Belgian Shepard and a chilled out English Bulldog are gonna require the same thing just because they are both the most chilled of a litter? Or a pug or border collie are going to be equal fits just based on personality. Nope breed matters a Lot. Yep we can pick the calmest or more curious puppy but genetics are important. It would be cruel to get lets say a Border Collie and think you can mould it to be a lap dog, just as it would be cruel to get a pug and bring it for jogs with come on now please
@@marietighe6328^ this lmao. Breed matters, whether people like it or not. If you don't know any breeds of a mix, then you'll have to rely on personality I suppose?
Breed matters usually due to traits.
Nonsense! Breed is important as heck
But remember all humans are equal and there are no distinctions between ethnicities r/sarcasm
One of my corgis bit me on the nose and drew blood (she was a tiny puppy) when we first met. She turned out to be a wonderful girl. I think this gives some people ideas on what to look for in a puppy. I see the puppy (after 4 of them) and I know I am taking it home!
I really liked that rambunctious polka dotted spotted one!
This is such great information. Thank you so much I have just subscribed
I love puppies.
I conducted psychometric testing with the litter I was choosing from. The winning candidate now drives himself to the country park and has a picnic, instead of chasing a ball. He then kicks back and beats me at chess.
Great advice, thank you!
I do something similar, I turn them on their back when they're on the ground and try to hold them there for about 15 seconds. Dogs can still be house trained even if they're wiggly or don't want to stay on their back. The difference is that they may not be as cuddly as the dogs that can stay on their back the longest.
You are wonderful!
Sweeties.
So excited.
And i have two dogs that are exactly like those two. The same breed, but so so different characters.
Going to use this to choose my next kitten. ;)
Thank you so much!
We learned this at puppy school 😊
I'd always let my pets choose me. It's an automatic bond that is bigger than any other bond you can ever get with a pet. I'd never choose myself, surely I have my preferences in the gender but if a puppy of the opposite gender walked right up to me I'd let her choose me. Last time I was lucky because out of ten puppies there were only two males and one of them chose me
Actually mine didn't like holding him like a baby when he was puppy but he's 1 and half year old now he loves being hold like this and he's one of best temperament dog u will ever find he's sweet never bit anyone always calm around children I think this is not the only way to find a dogs temperament ...All puppies and dogs are different its more about how they are raised if u raise them with lot of positive attitude they will be positive they do what u teach
Character matters.
I don’t get to choose my dogs, I just take the ones that need me. Adopt or foster, too many dogs out there to be breeding more.
I’ve never seen the upside test to determine temperament before, that is interesting! Makes sense!
On an aside, couldn’t help notice the planted kisses. I kiss my dogs (9 and 8.5yo) often. Do they understand that it’s a sign of affection or do they just tolerate this idiosyncratic behaviour from “dad”?
LOL! Me too! I am guessing both, but mainly affection.
It literally makes NO sense. All it tells you is if the animal likes or tolerates being carried upside down.
I'd love to have one of those babies.
I wish I could get one but they are probably gone to a family by now
I mean your local shelter would appreciate you I’m sure
The puppy will choose you ! Than you know the adoption is o.k
The needy one will choose you, they will choose anyone. 🤣
@@JillLawton-zt8me ?
I think there personality is shaped by how they are treated. So many other aspects than if they lay on their back and don’t wiggle around
Never chosen a pet all of them where given to me by the "universal distribution system" even the birdies and fish (was dumped in a plastic box next to a dumpster). They all have/had different personalities and we respected that only rules were dont be agressive and dont pee in the house 😂. All of them were/are pure joy and part of the family. Unless you need a work dog I don't really think that thi's the best way to choose a pet. Puppies also change when they grow up,they don't always mantain the same personality, some mellow quite drastically and some only stop being blazerunners at senior age. And funny enough some do the exact opposite from sweet shy puppy to tasmanian devil energy 😅.
What breed?
Don’t pick the one that comes up, pick me pick me. It will be needy. I know I have one. My husband picked the next one and she was off playing with the toys. She is not needy.
I’ve had dogs all my life ,I don’t pick any of them ,they pick me
❤
❤❤❤❤
I always feel drawn to the saddest looking puppy, or the runt.
I am looking for an untouched border collie puppy. Very young so he can indicate he's interested in me.
Please don’t follow this advice.
It’s way too simplistic of an explanation of something far more complex.
I couldn’t agree with you more. See my comment about my dog… which disproves this method to be the best indication of a dog’s temperament!
You right, my street dog puppy didn't like being held in any way. Now he's super dog and actually listening to me now, he is 2 years old now 😂. Every dog is different like people. She's thinking of the old way of dog growth.
Too bad the pups can't pick Humans for temperament.
Let he or she pick you
I’m honestly shocked……accept each pup on their individual merits & personality…….every living body deserves the best life…….
Animals dont like being turned/held like that.
Depends on the animal. Both my dogs relaxed completely when I held them this way, but they also sensed I was most comfortable holding them like this. My sister’s male dachshund only lets certain people pick him up (not me, only once when I was the only person to bring him downstairs), but he is a cuddly bunny on the couch. You have to learn what your dog likes and they are all do different.
Well is not important to me at all, what the personality is. I just adopt them and take them home and that Is it. Same with the cats. Love my furry friends.
🙏🥰
Works on choosing a wife too😂😂😂
They become like their owner
Calm down people. There is no perfect way to pick a dog. Cats have the Cat Distribution Thing going on and I believe dog have their own. I'm more worried about people who have pets but treat them badly.
Dominance Theory has been known scientifically for decades to not be true.
The real reasons behind the puppies preferring different carrying positions is more to do with them feeling comfortable or safe, or not, in those positions.
The 'quiet' puppy wasn't entirely happy being held upside down, if you look at her facial cues and body language. She is just putting up with it more than the other pup.
This maybe due to fear, or trust, or maybe even physical traits that make it less uncomfortable than the male pup.
Please can we try to understand animals better than resorting to outdated unproven views - there are lots of free resources on animal behavioural science.
to pick the right pup? they all need a home....any of them will be right with love. This is dumb on the human part. yes, animals do choose, they have brains....
Go to a shelter. See how the dog acts there, take it for a walk, get to know it. Problem solved.
Putting a dog on it's back is called alpha rolling and should not be practiced, you can destroy your relationship with a dog if you do that.
Buy them all, then mince up the unwanted ones and make cottage pie....... that's what I was always told!
❤❤❤🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️🥹❤️
Don't shop! Adopt! Stop supporting breeders when MILLIONS of deserving dogs get put down
I have done this both ways. Most rent dog is a pointer for obvious reason, the previous was a dumped pup. Both have been great, but no one way is right nor wrong.
@@billkraemer4710 Morally and humanely, yes one way is right and the other wrong
@@zoeslovely7096okay karen.
Hope these are rescues. If this
Woman breeds them then shame on her because there's more than enough dogs in shelters due to breeders.
Don't, absolutely don't buy from breeders, please choose a rescue 4 legged friend. Cruelty is rife amongst breeders.
You paint with an awful wide brush.
@@billkraemer4710 And with justification, after being told by many people who own dogs and hearing their stories of rescue dogs from puppy farms.
Well then there’s the fact that so many dogs are languishing in shelters needing homes 🐶♥️
@@DChristina yes, totally agree, so far, (through 15 years) I have given 5 rescues a loving, happy home. I currently have a senior rescue, 10 years old, she was kept in a cupboard and wasn't fed. Rescues are the best breed as far I am concerned.
LOL, I assume this is a joke. Personalities change within 6 mos to a year for 90% of cats/dogs.
Too bad you didn't try that with a male puppy for demonstration. Not everyone wants a little girl.
I HAVE ALWAYS FOUND YOU LET THE PUP PICK YOU STAND WITH THE PUPS FOR A FEW MINUTES AND ONE WILL GIVE YOU MORE ATTENTION THAN THE OTHERS TAKE THAT ONE
Please don’t call animals “its”. They are beings, NOT things. 🐾
I think this is just plain wrong. Many dogs dont like to be on their back because it's genuinely physically uncomfortable for them and has nothing to do with temperament. Similarly, I had one dog who preferred a sit position and another who preferred a down position. Had nothing to do with their temperament. It was what they found most physically comfortable. Thats not to say that there arent reliable temperament tests out there. But this isnt one of them.
I always let the dog pick me.
Dogs suck
I pick them all up and do this type of process. But ultimately if I can't decide, I put them all down and walk away and the one who cries for me the most is my choice. Because it's most likely to listen to me and wants to bond. This process got me a beagle that lived about 14 years, a Rottweiler that lived to 14 and a chihuahua that lived to 17. All excellent! ❤🐕🦮🐕🦺