If,Santa dresses up in red, disregards private property, redistributes the wealth.. Avoids big oil for alternative form of transportation... oh deer, he is a Communist.
Don’t talk to the Elves about wealth re distribution & unionization (rights and plight of the workers) Saint Nick has them working for peanuts, figuratively and literally
LOL Redistribution of wealth is socialist. Communism is no private wealth at all. Neither socialism nor communism care much for the environment. Santa is where the reindeers are, probably Northern Sweden. So a socialist plus probably a follower of Swedish infant Greta Thunberg !
I don't think it was a specifically anti-KKK parade due to the "No War Bases" sign. Rather what I think they were trying to tell us was that the emotionally weak yet politically involved are communists, just not in the most literal sense of the word.
Nice comprehension. The commentator clearly said "we take his word for it" if he exclaims he's a communist. He also said if people support organizations with communist teachings, they might be communist. Please learn how to listen.
In other words, the way to spot communists is if they admit they are communists. Because the video clearly left out anything that would help spotting a communist who actually hides the fact he's a communist. Please learn how to comprehend.
You seem to be forgetting the fact you used the word "might". The video clearly states to take the statement of declaration at face value, regardless of the persons state, i.e. jocular or drunk, seen as the scene is set in a bar. The fact he didn't say "might" in this instance pretty much invalids your little quip. Liberally interchanging words isn't factual.
If he says hell to capitalism, has an image of karl marx plastered in every corner of his house, openly declares he is a communist then he may perhaps be a communist but we will never know
it's true though. Democracy is about pawning off responsibility to the populace so the politicians can't be held accountable for their shitty job. Propaganda then serves the purpose of making the people believe that the politicians act according to the will of the people and also reforming the opinion of the people towards the given policy. In essence, democracy needs propaganda since the majority of any population is too retarded to actually form opinions and will gobble up whatever their tv tells them to
Chomsky for sure, and not true. While any government wants its viewpoint supported, in authoritarian systems propaganda is the _only_ way to advance this; there is no space for independent media. A government in a democratic society needs a core of genuine support.
@@user-mb3dx5fl9f I completely agree. The modern "left" fouls the political name used to address those who only wanted to be free from 18 hours of constant factory work and still have no money to move up. Now these uneducated mobs, who got so drunk on peace, want gender to be a political matter. Actual socialist and communists try to make clean toilets for sick children in developing countries, and that act contributes more to the world than whatever the "modern left" got in mind.
What we have is better than what anywhere else on the planet has. Communism has proven to be destructive in every large scale implementation. It's not opinion, it's history.
@@pauljohnson3851 No it isn't. Being a fascist these days is what it always has been, supporting bigoted ideologies that marginalizes and hurts people.
@@pauljohnson3851 When you realize the West has been inundated with fascism you start to see how nothing has really changed people who are critical of capitalism get seen as crazy communists
Lol cept the mother has the right to teach HER kids good social behavior. No one (especially government) has the right to tell me to share any of MY belongings.
The Newspaper - "Philadelphia cops beat up phone strikers; 11 arrested" Law enforcement has been upholding the status quo of the rich for a very long time.
If he blasts the Soviet national anthem at full volume, regularly quotes Karl Marx, directly and unquestionably states and explains his communist beliefs in full detail, and has a hammer and sickle on everything he owns, you might be able to consider that he could theoretically reasonably be somewhat communist under some definition.
@@21stcenturyfossil7 Next they're gonna give the workers more rights! And then black people! And then the homosexuals! Dear God now they can exist freely without me being able to lynch them for existing!
So basically, in seventy odd years it seems nothing much has changed in governmental perception of the general public’s common sense. They’ll always think we’re stupid …
Having anti-capitalist feelings and wanting to rid the tired workers of their bourgeoisie oppressors? Have a Snickers. You’re not you when your hungry.
What I got from this: In the U.S. you are free to speak and have an opinion. Unless that opinion is the wrong opinion. In which case you have no rights.
Freedom of speach is an absurd concept the moment you realize someone has to enforce it. Once more that things like advocacy for terrorism, spreading sensitive information, hate speach, and obviously critique of the government, somehow arent allowed this freedom. Someone draws the line but theu dont tell you where it is. The soviets were honest: you say shit about the government and we break your ankles (and even then, after stalin that wasnt really enforced). Anything else is ok. Thats why filmaking in the usa was so oddly terrified (insert George Lucas interview abt the USSR) that they might say the wrong thing, imply the wrong kind of message, attract the wrong interests. As such they had that rule book i cant remember, about what is and isnt allowed on screen. Jewish character? Might be a communist. Something to do with dr. King and the black movement? Might be a commie. A character thinks women should vote (even though they can)? Offff, i dont know about that. USSR? None of that, if there is a good party memeber character you can do whatever the hell it is you want. Though most of their art was often in the realm of the experimental, the snow queen, hell, guest from the future has the government as the antagonists. I even know one Bulgarian author who had a book that was debated on if it should be banned because it was anti-communist. He didnt go to a gulag, no no no, they were debating on if they should censor it. I may remember him, but if i dont, the other one is fine too. Meanwhile you suggest affordable health-care in the States and now you are Adolf Stalin, bringer of the apocalypse. Do they even hate Adolf these days?
I think what's actually scary about this particular propaganda film is the "may be a communist" bit. That bit of fear and anxiety it instills--when you're not sure who is and who isn't--is most effective at keeping people mistrustful. It wouldn't work as well if the narrator said "most likely a communist" or "most definitely a communist".
"...and if your neighbor says, 'feed the poor' and throws the money changers out of your places of worship, he might just be a Communist..." Jesus: ...
Since when communists care about food lol half of China millions of Russians and polish and other nation literally starved to death and on a good Sunday they be in lines for a bread and some water not to mention working to death inside the gulag
in all honesty, I truly wonder how drastically history has been rewritten prior to the internet and how much we conform to this rewritten history thinking it's the truth
History cannot be rewritten and decent historians get through the tons of propagande in the sources. Many written source should be taken with a grain of salt as propaganda exists as long as there is society but written sources are not the only ones we have; and not all written sources are propaganda. So read relevant articles and books and look for agendas and you'll see how much we actually know about the past that is not rewritten
@@vralshrazmra4551 He he he, well done, you have somehow managed to revealed me as the true communist and have foiled my evil plan to give free health care and education to capitalist west.
0:09 "If he openly declares himself to be a Communist, we take his word for it." But I thought you couldn't trust those Communists. So if one of them says they are a communist, they must *not* be.
This is so informative. Every time I passed a stand with "Down with Imperialists" written on the back with someone who looks and shouts suspiciously like Lenin, I just thought they were Mormons or Boy Scouts. Thanks, guys.
@@gaelanwhite8842 If they own a company in the SnP 500, excuse their wealth with "a small loan of 1 million dollars", avoid taxes, bribe politicians and regularly get government bailouts, they might be a capitalist.
Using the knowledge gained in Vietnam, it can be determined that if they run upon being fired at, they’re a communist, and if they don’t run, then they’re a very brave communist.
@J S if you believe the data from the wiki, it follows that the troops of the South Vietnamese army had an army of 800 thousand people in 1968, and by 1975 as many as one and a half million, and at the end of the war 1 million of them were captured by the Viet Cong
Still is as a matter of fact. Look at terf island and who is waving the trans flags and the red banners. Look at Palestine. The resistance to capitalism is such a defining aspect of communism that, no matter how much slander, you cant scrub it off. Now for the economic aspects of the ideology, socialist states and the like, the lies are very effective. "I see the idea and morale behind communism, and i support its progressive elements, but muh human natur no food 3 gazillion". Because liberals have yet to grasp the political economy and their ignorance spans 3 centuries.
The KKK are a controlled opposition organization. Democrats are the KKK and Black Lives Matter..Then they call Republicans KKK members..see how the Communist game works?
“You mean right wing ideologies-founded on the idea of hierarchy as natural and just, and that some people really are superior to others-are racist?” “Always have been.”
@@Mrcake0103 but people are superior and inferior to each other, various human subspecies have differing qualities. Hierarchy is natural in every species, and most species are full of dead weight.
@@hiredmurderer6228 Communism is bad. Very bad... It looks good, utopian even, but it is truely a horrid way of living... Anyone who says otherwise, really dont know what they are talking about. I could give you so many examples, but there is a much easier way. It has never ever worked anywhere... It ALWAYS results in less freedom and more poverty. Always. Which is not that strange, but it does take a bit of mental intelligence to understand why...
@@tommcewan7936 I'm guessing this only happened because the government had so much control over information. Nowadays they're so afraid of the public they no longer have any real convictions.
Reread 1984 btw it better describes america than the soviets. Orwell was a communist himself and the “proles” described in 1984 perfectly parody the average American. While Winston himself is part of the ruling senate that’s why he sees it from a different perspective
Well, I mean, the Daily Worker was openly Communist. And after the fall of the USSR it was revealed that they'd been sending money through various front groups in Hollywood to the tune of 2 million dollars annually for about 5 decades. Argue if they're a threat or not all you like, but there was provably lots of Soviet communist influence in the US during the cold war.
See the trick they did was they managed to disguise western propaganda behind the term “experts”. So these days its not propaganda, because the information you get comes from “experts”, doesnt matter where these people got that information in the first place and who pays them, all you need to do is switch your brain off and mindlessly drink the kool aid western mainstream media feeds you and happily cheer on the next atrocity done in the name of the international rules based order
@@user-vn6no3ci4f Yeah, historically, the state has been nothing but an enemy for workers' rights. When laborers protested the brutal conditions, they were assaulted and killed by police- the enforcement arm of the state.
The composition of every frame is beautiful. I do not know why nowadays the ads from US army seem not care about composition (it is not because of budget since they have helicopters in ad).
In the late 1980's / early 1990's I worked a Maryland National Bank as a computer programmer. We had a guy on our team that was a card-carrying Communist, for real. And I asked him one time, I said, "Jack, you're a avowed Communist, a member of the party, yet you work at a bank, the most capitalist of all companies save the stock market." Before I could ask a question he cut me off and said, "the irony is not lost on me. What I do in my free time is my own business. What I do at work pays my bills. If being a teacher paid as well as a computer programmer, I would have been a teacher." He was a great guy and a pretty good programmer.
He's gotta eat somehow. But we don't know if half of his salary goes to supporting local communists or just locally helping the most disadvantaged groups.
Sounds like he lacked the courage of his convictions. "Just doing my job" is not a valid excuse. When you get to the pearly gates, Ol' St. Pete is going to "just do his job."
@@SpencerWilliamsIV Honestly I think it's the opposite. The bills are high because of the unregulated real estate market. The jobs pay little because capitalist shareholders do everything in their power to give the workers as little as possible. Paying bills just gives you more reasons to want a different economic system.
I like that it tries an olive branch of "may" to doing one or multiple of these things but that feeling tell us if you do all these things consistently then it stands to reason
What the narrator is trying to say is that benign causes such as anti KKK activism have infiltrated by forces working against America, the banner calling for an end of US overseas bases is testament to that.
As the old adage goes"Never ever trust a communist" meaning the statement said by the communist "I am a communist" is a lie since communists don't tell the truth meaning they aren't a communist
I was waiting for the whole "means of production being redistributed between working classes" thing, but it never came out. I start to suspect this movie might be a little mislead on what communism is
![บุกร้านไอศกรีม VJ วุ้นเส้น !!!! [ดูคลิปเต็มหน้าช่อง] #Short | PANG ORNHIRA](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g549nEhKZdc/mqdefault.jpg)
If he waves the banner of the Soviet Union, that's a big red flag.
I thought that was China.
@@matthewmcclary7855 Yeah, but the Soviet flag and the Chinese flag are pretty dang similar. Both are big red flags.
@@gunsgalore7571 now I remember. The flag of the USSR.
😂
hahahhaaa
If your parrot keeps repeating "down with the capitalists"
The owner might be a communist.
Owner?
No, comrade. Not owner.
Communists don't believe in the private ownership of property, so the parrot must belong to all of the proletariats.
fuck the owner, the parrot is the commie
Possibly, the parrot is a communist.
😂😂😂
If,Santa dresses up in red, disregards private property, redistributes the wealth.. Avoids big oil for alternative form of transportation... oh deer, he is a Communist.
We’re going to have to launch a special military operation of our own to the North Pole.
Don’t talk to the Elves about wealth re distribution & unionization (rights and plight of the workers) Saint Nick has them working for peanuts, figuratively and literally
He doesn’t redistribute wealth
LOL Redistribution of wealth is socialist. Communism is no private wealth at all. Neither socialism nor communism care much for the environment.
Santa is where the reindeers are, probably Northern Sweden. So a socialist plus probably a follower of Swedish infant Greta Thunberg !
oh deer lol
*Tries to show communists as “evil and anti-American”
*Shows communists holding an anti-KKK parade.
🤣🤣🤣🤣Like WTF!
well the kkk is prety american.
that *was* evil and anti-american to them!
Based af
I don't think it was a specifically anti-KKK parade due to the "No War Bases" sign. Rather what I think they were trying to tell us was that the emotionally weak yet politically involved are communists, just not in the most literal sense of the word.
What I got from this: If somebody is a communist, he may be a communist.
TheAntiParadox Only if they do all these activities over a period of time. Then he/she MUST be a communist.
+Javier Campos A capitalist spie
+Grim Mantis apparently I don't know how to fucking spell spy
Grim Mantis Hey there, pinko.
Iggy Montpellier wtf is a pinko?
"I am a communist, down with imperialism!"
He might be a communist.
xxlCortez Lolololo
Nice comprehension. The commentator clearly said "we take his word for it" if he exclaims he's a communist. He also said if people support organizations with communist teachings, they might be communist. Please learn how to listen.
In other words, the way to spot communists is if they admit they are communists. Because the video clearly left out anything that would help spotting a communist who actually hides the fact he's a communist. Please learn how to comprehend.
You seem to be forgetting the fact you used the word "might". The video clearly states to take the statement of declaration at face value, regardless of the persons state, i.e. jocular or drunk, seen as the scene is set in a bar. The fact he didn't say "might" in this instance pretty much invalids your little quip. Liberally interchanging words isn't factual.
Watch 0:25 - 0:36 part, then try again.
If he says hell to capitalism, has an image of karl marx plastered in every corner of his house, openly declares he is a communist then he may perhaps be a communist but we will never know
Who can say really? He might not be a communist, it's too hard to tell
Probably an edgelord and not a real communist, wouldnt sell out his parents during the purge like a real commie.
marxists arent communist theyre cringe
@@supercool1312 🤦♂️
"Therefore propoganda is vastly more important for democratic societies"
The opening line
it's true though. Democracy is about pawning off responsibility to the populace so the politicians can't be held accountable for their shitty job. Propaganda then serves the purpose of making the people believe that the politicians act according to the will of the people and also reforming the opinion of the people towards the given policy. In essence, democracy needs propaganda since the majority of any population is too retarded to actually form opinions and will gobble up whatever their tv tells them to
I believe that's Noam Chomsky.
yes he is@@steinmodus8943
Chomsky - A famous MIT anarchist who is VEHEMENTLY anti-communist and associated with Epstein.
Chomsky for sure, and not true. While any government wants its viewpoint supported, in authoritarian systems propaganda is the _only_ way to advance this; there is no space for independent media. A government in a democratic society needs a core of genuine support.
My cat may be communist. He keeps saying, " Mao, Mao !"
🤣🤣🤣🤣
My dog might be a communist! He keeps saying *Союз нерушимый республик свободных-*
Everyone knows cats are anarkitties.
Interestingly, 'mao' is also a cat in Mandarin
sam o'nella academy
If he's got a big beard, wrote a book called Das Kapital and is called Karl, he might be a communist
Hah. That one was at least somewhat sane. His modern followers are a way more horrifying and wilder tribe.
@@user-mb3dx5fl9f who are you referring to?
@@Doctor_Straing_StrangeMarx was a pretty sane guy compared to today's left.
@@user-mb3dx5fl9f I completely agree.
The modern "left" fouls the political name used to address those who only wanted to be free from 18 hours of constant factory work and still have no money to move up. Now these uneducated mobs, who got so drunk on peace, want gender to be a political matter. Actual socialist and communists try to make clean toilets for sick children in developing countries, and that act contributes more to the world than whatever the "modern left" got in mind.
But if he wears a red coat, he is either a communist or he is Santa Claus. Giving out the sweat of his elves labour, yep, Santa is a communist.
Americans : we are the country of freedom of speech and opinions
Also americans :
You “may be a communist”
Technically they could be communists, this video is just encouraging people to ostracize communists
What we have is better than what anywhere else on the planet has.
Communism has proven to be destructive in every large scale implementation. It's not opinion, it's history.
“Don't get so tolerant that you tolerate intolerance.”
Bill Maher
I mean all americans are just hypocritical savages so I'm not surprised, if it were up to me they'd all get 1940s german style showers
I like how they tried to paint freedom of speech, criticizing the government, fighting racism as bad thing by saying it's a "Communist" thing 😂😂😂😂
they still do though
Oh say can you see!
Nowadays freedom of speech is considered "fascism"
It was the 50s after all. We were still pretty hyped up off of world war 2.
@@AhkoGojak except now they call you a fascist, even if you aren't racist.
I like how being a communist just meant “criticising the government” half the time.
that's basically what being a fascist means these days
@@pauljohnson3851 No it isn't. Being a fascist these days is what it always has been, supporting bigoted ideologies that marginalizes and hurts people.
@@pauljohnson3851 When you realize the West has been inundated with fascism you start to see how nothing has really changed people who are critical of capitalism get seen as crazy communists
i mean it basicly still is lol, communist if youre left leaning, fascist if you are right leaning
@@pauljohnson3851 I don't remember communists storming the US capital building or refusing to accept democratic election results.
If a mother tells her kids to share, well.... Let's just say that's a _red_ flag.
This comment is underrated
You're using red flag, are you a communist?
They are OUR kids
@@warlordofbritannia perfect counter
Lol cept the mother has the right to teach HER kids good social behavior. No one (especially government) has the right to tell me to share any of MY belongings.
And worst of all, he could be any one of us. He could be in this very room! He could be you! He could be me! He could even be…
...that houseplant!
Right behind you
Bruce Wayne
A communist
See, red!
The Newspaper - "Philadelphia cops beat up phone strikers; 11 arrested"
Law enforcement has been upholding the status quo of the rich for a very long time.
Welp.. It's a “communist publication”, {squealing }so..
@@maazkalim so..?
By the intent of US Armed Forces, those news dispatches aren't trustworthy - if not necessarily ‘not newsworthy’.
If he blasts the Soviet national anthem at full volume, regularly quotes Karl Marx, directly and unquestionably states and explains his communist beliefs in full detail, and has a hammer and sickle on everything he owns, you might be able to consider that he could theoretically reasonably be somewhat communist under some definition.
Are you sure, I mean those red bastards are tricky.
😂😂😂😂😂
@Yannis Karageorgiou Certainly, a big leap foward
This sounds like some rando on a certain Reddit
Sounds like a really stupid agent of the german "Verfassungsschutz" who tried much to hard to play a communist.
TH-cam recommends me these kind of videos, I must be a communist
Denis China please step this way sir, I have a helicopter waiting.
Correction, youtube is a communist.
Augusto Pinochet general where are you taking him, may i ask
Something Negative Augusto Pinochet did this "funny" thing of taking communists and other opositors to helicopter rides and then pushing them off
I don’t like communist, my dad said they’re mean to their people and they steal
"Down with Imperialists!"
Wasn't that kinda the catchphrase of Americans for the revolutionary war?
That's a good point and makes a lot of sense. Stop it please.
😂
protester: “end kkk terror”
narrator: they may be a communist
Yep. That's where it starts. The Commies are masters of the Slippery Slope,
@@21stcenturyfossil7 Next they're gonna give the workers more rights! And then black people! And then the homosexuals!
Dear God now they can exist freely without me being able to lynch them for existing!
@@gabrielegenota1480 ...and next thing you know, PUBLIC HEALTHCARE FOR ALL!
@@tommythecat4961 CHRIST ALMIGHTY-
THE ABILITY TO NOT DIE FROM SICKNESS WITHOUT HAVING TO GO BANKRUPT?
DISGUSTING
@@gabrielegenota1480 what do you expect from COMMUNISTS
"If they have a flag of the Soviet union, then that's a big red flag"
Ok I'll see myself out
Oh that’s my type of humour! 😂
😂😂😂
😂
You forgot your trophy for the Best dad joke of the year award 🏆
dady is that you
So basically, in seventy odd years it seems nothing much has changed in governmental perception of the general public’s common sense. They’ll always think we’re stupid …
That time when Captain Obvious joined the propaganda department
This is the kind of stuff you'd expect to hear in satire
Now you understand how boomers think
This isn't satire?
Sounds like something a communist would say
@@crypt2939 nope this is legit
@@crypt2939 back in I think the 50s people were scared that the communist were going to take over the US
"if he/she shares a kit kat amongst siblings and friends"
"They may be a communist"
I mean if you share your kit Kat you deserve to be in jail
Having anti-capitalist feelings and wanting to rid the tired workers of their bourgeoisie oppressors? Have a Snickers.
You’re not you when your hungry.
☺
😂😂😂
This doesn't even make sense.
Are we gonna just ignore the bedsheet ghost in the final frame? Yes? Okay.
🤣👻🤣
Fuck yeah! Down with military, take my word that I'm a communist.
What I got from this: In the U.S. you are free to speak and have an opinion. Unless that opinion is the wrong opinion. In which case you have no rights.
Freedom of speach is an absurd concept the moment you realize someone has to enforce it. Once more that things like advocacy for terrorism, spreading sensitive information, hate speach, and obviously critique of the government, somehow arent allowed this freedom. Someone draws the line but theu dont tell you where it is. The soviets were honest: you say shit about the government and we break your ankles (and even then, after stalin that wasnt really enforced). Anything else is ok.
Thats why filmaking in the usa was so oddly terrified (insert George Lucas interview abt the USSR) that they might say the wrong thing, imply the wrong kind of message, attract the wrong interests. As such they had that rule book i cant remember, about what is and isnt allowed on screen.
Jewish character? Might be a communist. Something to do with dr. King and the black movement? Might be a commie. A character thinks women should vote (even though they can)? Offff, i dont know about that.
USSR? None of that, if there is a good party memeber character you can do whatever the hell it is you want. Though most of their art was often in the realm of the experimental, the snow queen, hell, guest from the future has the government as the antagonists. I even know one Bulgarian author who had a book that was debated on if it should be banned because it was anti-communist. He didnt go to a gulag, no no no, they were debating on if they should censor it. I may remember him, but if i dont, the other one is fine too. Meanwhile you suggest affordable health-care in the States and now you are Adolf Stalin, bringer of the apocalypse.
Do they even hate Adolf these days?
"If TH-cam recommended you this video, you may be a communist."
Ironically, I am leftist lol
I'm communist (russian libertarian socialist) and i'm watching this video OwO
And proud of it
@@greggblade810 solidarity forever! 🛠️💪
Well, shit.
If he trains spiders to seize the means of production, he might be an arachno-communist.
How do I train spiders ?
@@JoJo23saucisse I dunno, ask an arachno-communist.
If they deliberately put a bi flag on their pfp, they (might) be bi
I liked this joke on a spiritual level I'm unable to express.
This is the best political joke I've ever heard.
I think what's actually scary about this particular propaganda film is the "may be a communist" bit. That bit of fear and anxiety it instills--when you're not sure who is and who isn't--is most effective at keeping people mistrustful. It wouldn't work as well if the narrator said "most likely a communist" or "most definitely a communist".
This is actually very true! We sometimes make fun and dismiss some things as being stupid or idiotic but its actually extremely strategic.
"...and if your neighbor says, 'feed the poor' and throws the money changers out of your places of worship, he might just be a Communist..."
Jesus: ...
that's why centrists are superior over both capitalism and communism
Je sus: ... the world’s first communist
I’m not even socialist, but the idea that “End the KKK” was considered a subversion of American national policy is just laughably absurd
Yeah, imagine if white supremacy was ever national policy, thank goodness that never hap…
*looks at Jim Crow*
Oh.
If someone is black, or Catholic, or just a decent human being in general...
THEY MIGHT BE A COMMUNIST!
KKK is a nationalist organization so...
Democrats made about as much sense back then as they do today so we can't be too surprised.
@@AccountInactive yeah i mean republicans working with kkk members, at least they're honest with it
"When I give food to the poor, they call me a saint. When I ask why the poor have no food, they call me a communist.” - Dom Helder Camara
Since when communists care about food lol half of China millions of Russians and polish and other nation literally starved to death and on a good Sunday they be in lines for a bread and some water not to mention working to death inside the gulag
It's a fair question. Do they spend their welfare on shoes or crack instead of food? If so, then it's not societies fault..
When one is joking around about starving, he's pretty loony enough to think seriously
tbf, one is an action, and the other is a question that has zero action to it.
@@philosophyversuslogic lol joking about starving nah nah I'm just telling history like always yall leftists always love to rewrite history right lol
in all honesty, I truly wonder how drastically history has been rewritten prior to the internet and how much we conform to this rewritten history thinking it's the truth
History cannot be rewritten and decent historians get through the tons of propagande in the sources. Many written source should be taken with a grain of salt as propaganda exists as long as there is society but written sources are not the only ones we have; and not all written sources are propaganda. So read relevant articles and books and look for agendas and you'll see how much we actually know about the past that is not rewritten
I'll bet this is where Jeff Foxworthy got his 'you might be a redneck if...' skit.
“I don’t know man, I think the US should get out of Vietnam.”
Narrator: “Did you hear that? Sounds like someone is a communist…”
Bla bla bla, M'urika bla bla bla Vietnam, is all I got, I am sorry but I don't speak communist.
@@Anonerak2 then you may be a communist...
@@Anonerak2 Are you okay?
@@kshitizsaini3022 Did you hear that? Was that a whoosh over your head?
@@vralshrazmra4551 He he he, well done, you have somehow managed to revealed me as the true communist and have foiled my evil plan to give free health care and education to capitalist west.
0:09 "If he openly declares himself to be a Communist, we take his word for it." But I thought you couldn't trust those Communists. So if one of them says they are a communist, they must *not* be.
I am Communist cause I'm living a Communist's country.
But how can one say communists are to be distrusted if they are not communists?
but if they arent communists then u have to take their word for it so they are
@@zubrifikusummuk if they are then they’re not and if they’re not then they are. what’s not to get
Bad attempt at sophistry, OP.
If somebody eats exclusively vegetables and fruit, they may be vegan
In the very beginning of the video You can hear Noam chomsky. Can you tell me what documentary this video is from?
"If he declares himself a communist, hr may be a communist"
I mean, he's not wrong.
@Phytom and I’m the assassinator of the American president.
If he looks at you in a long time, he might be a communist.
@Phytom What’s up Brandon
The real answer is: "does he have pink hair?"
that's not a quote from the video dipshit
"People should have freedom of political views, unless we don't agree with them"
This is so informative. Every time I passed a stand with "Down with Imperialists" written on the back with someone who looks and shouts suspiciously like Lenin, I just thought they were Mormons or Boy Scouts. Thanks, guys.
Remember kids, only evil communist filth want to stop imperialism.
You naive, naive fool! They were Rotarians. Or Masons. Or Elks.
Your welcome
damn are you 23 now?
😂😂 bruh thank you 🙏
The US Constitution starts with „We the people“, which sounds communistic, so the USA must be communistic.
'Live free or die' was forgotten by George Washington after owning his 600th slave. I think that it was meant to be a constitutional monarchy.
As a communist, i can confirm all this.
I don't know but i may be a communist.
Vladimir Lenin I don't think you are
Vladimir Lenin
Hmmmm...
Good question. Stalin, Trotsky what do you two think the answer is ?
Trotsky told me Lenin was right about party organisation and was a good communist. Stalin dug the grave of the revolution.
U gave me a good laugh
no shit! 0oO
Me: *scratches off lottery ticket*
Mom: yay, we won!
Me:
she might be a comunist
Nice profile pic.
@@User_5tjk42gj9 I wish you had a nice profile picture like he has...but here we are.
@@fakedungeonmaster5740 turn her in and keep all the money for yourself 😂
Ok, that was good.
0:56 Marching against 'KKK Terror'.
Not gonna lie, those Communists sound incredibly based.
I want a parody of this called "How to Spot a Capitalist".
Make it so, universe.
I bet Soviet Union did something similar.
If he says he'll mow your lawn for five dollars, then uses those five dollars to then by stocks in big tobacco, then he might be a capitalist.
"If you support the KKK, you must be a capitalist"🤪
@@gaelanwhite8842 If they own a company in the SnP 500, excuse their wealth with "a small loan of 1 million dollars", avoid taxes, bribe politicians and regularly get government bailouts, they might be a capitalist.
If he is against universal healthcare, free education to poor kids, hates trains and subways, against school uniforms, he might be a capitalist
Using the knowledge gained in Vietnam, it can be determined that if they run upon being fired at, they’re a communist, and if they don’t run, then they’re a very brave communist.
@@hawks-wings I mean, they won, so I'd say it was worth it
@@xoaking1862 Who won?
@J S It was not only the United States that fought for South Vietnam
@J S if you believe the data from the wiki, it follows that the troops of the South Vietnamese army had an army of 800 thousand people in 1968, and by 1975 as many as one and a half million, and at the end of the war 1 million of them were captured by the Viet Cong
@J S in Vietnam at the same time and there were fewer Chinese in Vietnam on the side of the Viet Cong than Americans
I remember watching this in class and my classmates were always joking "They might be a communist."
now they are
and they will be hunted
Passing the blame to others, common commie move....
Hey if you're serious, what year was it was this the 50s or 60s?!?
@@imdavidbaby M C M L 1950
"if he/she share a common interest in meme culture"
"They might be a communist"
My only problem with this is in this time period having human right for anyone but white guys was considered communist by the federal government.
And we need to go back to those times. 👨🏿Ooh-ooh-aah-aah!
Still is as a matter of fact. Look at terf island and who is waving the trans flags and the red banners. Look at Palestine. The resistance to capitalism is such a defining aspect of communism that, no matter how much slander, you cant scrub it off. Now for the economic aspects of the ideology, socialist states and the like, the lies are very effective. "I see the idea and morale behind communism, and i support its progressive elements, but muh human natur no food 3 gazillion". Because liberals have yet to grasp the political economy and their ignorance spans 3 centuries.
Where is this from? That is Noam Chomsky talking at the beginning. What documentary or film is it?
"If he openly declares to be a Communist, they *may* be a Communist"
I mean, yeah, technically speaking you are correct
Yeah that's kind of a given. We didn't need a short to tell us that.
I mean he could be lying too
I can say:
I AM A COMMUNIST
but that doesn't mean I am really
The man in the video actually said, “If he openly declares himself to be a Communist, we take his word for it.”
@@DonTornado i dont care, i just want free likes because watching virtual numbers go up increases my dopamine
Hard to be sure. You can't trust a communist.
If you were involved in the Soviet Union space program you may be a kosmonaut
If you are slave to Russian cabbage you are cole slav. If you are a flower of cabbage you are cole flower.
Or a Space Dog Communist.
Underrated
What full documentary is this clip from?
Does anyone know what the title of this is and where/if I can find a full version of it?
"End KKK terror"
"But there are others that may work more... silently..."
💀
The more things change, the more they stay the same, huh?
All blacks are communist you know XD
(That wath some poeple think during this periode)
The KKK are a controlled opposition organization. Democrats are the KKK and Black Lives Matter..Then they call Republicans KKK members..see how the Communist game works?
It's typical for commies even today to hold such messages. Commies are in toilets as where they've always been.
Commies infiltrated numerous civil rights groups. One can be for civil rights without being a commie.
"There are other communists who dont show their real faces"
*Shows video of people protesting against the KKK like its a bad thing
THOUSANDS of murders and rapes each year coming from the googles. If KKK was still a thing this wouldn't happen in the US. LET THAT SINK IN
“You mean right wing ideologies-founded on the idea of hierarchy as natural and just, and that some people really are superior to others-are racist?”
“Always have been.”
@@Mrcake0103 but people are superior and inferior to each other, various human subspecies have differing qualities. Hierarchy is natural in every species, and most species are full of dead weight.
@@Mrcake0103 hiearchy is natural and just.
@@taowroland8697
>subspecies
lol fascist
Had America spent more time debating rather than detaining political opponents it wouldnt be in such disrepair today.
If he plays Red Alert all parts repeatedly and listens to the Soviet March....
Activists : "Make love not war."
Narrator : " They may be a communist."
Communism is when orgy
US logic: Everything thats good,is communist. For that reason,it is bad.
It even sounds like a very cliche and cheap dystopia story.
Yes make love, and let other nations walk all over you.
A pacifist is simply a coward clapping them selfs on the back.
@@truezulu And a warmonger is a weakling trying to be something more than a loser. Like you.
@@hiredmurderer6228 Communism is bad. Very bad... It looks good, utopian even, but it is truely a horrid way of living...
Anyone who says otherwise, really dont know what they are talking about.
I could give you so many examples, but there is a much easier way. It has never ever worked anywhere... It ALWAYS results in less freedom and more poverty. Always. Which is not that strange, but it does take a bit of mental intelligence to understand why...
This is a really good BuzzFeed video.
BuzzFeed is fake news.
Kugee You dirty Commienist.
Fake News then and fake news now.
Just replace communist with racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, Islamophobic etc.
idontknowevenanymore No they would never, maybe liberal social democracy garbadge.
Why did you cut off the ledy's speech, cause now I am curious what was about early 19...
Why there is a ghost at the end?
In Soviet Russia, communist spots you.
☝️😦 ahhhhh...
🤔...hmmm
Especially when lifting weights
Correction: In soviet russia, communists spots us
That is actually very historically accurate not even joking
Underrated and true ! 😂😂😂
I like how they slipped "if we say they're a communist, they're a communist" right in the middle there
Look, the Justice Department wouldn't lie. If you start espousing anti american thoughts that must mean you are a communist too!
“Or organizations labeled communist by the Department of Justice”
You’re right that was sly!
@@52flyingbicycles capitalists fight dirty.
@@tommcewan7936 I'm guessing this only happened because the government had so much control over information. Nowadays they're so afraid of the public they no longer have any real convictions.
Yep, I stamped that sleight-of-mouth at 0:30 - "@@52flyingbicycles".
"Anyone who runs, is a VC. Anyone who stands still, is a well disciplined VC," 😂
Superman, where are you? We need you now. More than ever.
0:00 "propaganda is vastly more important in democratic societies"
Gotta love American freedom
At least they were being honest back then about their true intentions
I think that might be Chomsky criticizing propaganda
@@unlimited8410
Dunno, this seems like it was cut from a more contemporary, retrospective documentary
rofl Communism runs on propaganda. It's the primary fuel.
@@unlimited8410 no that was Noam Chomsky. This seems to be taken from a more recent documentary
“No, comrade. I am not a communist!”
“But I’m definitely still a Cummunist”
...i just like to collect hammers and sickles. honest.
Yes, I can assure you the same thing!
And then John was a zombie
“My Homer is not a Communist. He may be a liar, a pig, an idiot, a Communist, but he is NOT a porn star!”
- Abraham Simpson
i love this! a perfect example of the duck test! (if it quack like a duck, walk like a duck, it must be a duck) used in medical analysis!
I am a communist....."I may be a communist"
same lol
same omggg
+Niko Bellic We'll take your word for it.
Niko Bellic all workers deserve free bowling sessions with Niko -Roman Bellic 2008
Hey! How is Roman?
This is the kind of stuff that an anti-capitalist would write in a novel and we'd roll our eyes saying it was "too on the nose"
Of course, because that's a logical reaction to someone being a dumbass
Reread 1984 btw it better describes america than the soviets.
Orwell was a communist himself and the “proles” described in 1984 perfectly parody the average American. While Winston himself is part of the ruling senate that’s why he sees it from a different perspective
Except that is was written by anti-Democratic capitalists.
Well, I mean, the Daily Worker was openly Communist. And after the fall of the USSR it was revealed that they'd been sending money through various front groups in Hollywood to the tune of 2 million dollars annually for about 5 decades. Argue if they're a threat or not all you like, but there was provably lots of Soviet communist influence in the US during the cold war.
Haha, nose
where is the full video of this docu
It's unfortunate the context, beginning and ending narration on each side of this clip, has been cut. I'd love to hear what it was.
You can look it up, all these propaganda reels are public and most are on YT.
I like the first phrase: "Therefore propaganda is vastly more important in democratic societies"...
Same🤣
That chain-smoker, no?
@@maazkalimChomsky
See the trick they did was they managed to disguise western propaganda behind the term “experts”. So these days its not propaganda, because the information you get comes from “experts”, doesnt matter where these people got that information in the first place and who pays them, all you need to do is switch your brain off and mindlessly drink the kool aid western mainstream media feeds you and happily cheer on the next atrocity done in the name of the international rules based order
The word 'Propaganda' meant a different thing back then, or rather, had different connotations
“If that persons a communist… they may be a communist.”
- Vladimir Foxworthy
"Here's your sign..."
If you are opposed to the private ownership of the means of production, you might be a communist
If you have to wait 6 years to get a used 1982 Camaro, you may be a RedCommunist
☭ wait its in russian
When your friend is shouting “Karl Marx has great ideas!” They might just be a communist. Might.
Well of course I know him, he's me.
Well, theory confirmed. Shut up nerd
@@cbtillery135 of course someone with a pepe pfp says this
When you open a can of chips in the class, your entire classmate may be a communist.
Hello Comrade, may i have one chip?
@@chinomon Yeah sure, why not..
*Handing out a can of chips to my comrade*
@@danialaifaa1992Comrade!
That action cannot be taken!
This can of chips is state owned!
Mf what is going on with this BASED comment section
Then my whole grades from 1 to 10 were Communist.
If a person defends rights of the workers, then that person is enemy of the state.
Wanna guess why all our jobs fled to China? China is Communist, you know..Unions were working with the Communists to shut us down. It worked.
That's not a wrong statement, that's a truest possible statement
Yeah, we all know the rich own the government
@@user-vn6no3ci4f Yeah, historically, the state has been nothing but an enemy for workers' rights. When laborers protested the brutal conditions, they were assaulted and killed by police- the enforcement arm of the state.
Sadly, I think that's why a lot of pretty decent Americans have been wrongly labeled as Communist.
The composition of every frame is beautiful. I do not know why nowadays the ads from US army seem not care about composition (it is not because of budget since they have helicopters in ad).
in what year did the spot appear?
In the late 1980's / early 1990's I worked a Maryland National Bank as a computer programmer. We had a guy on our team that was a card-carrying Communist, for real. And I asked him one time, I said, "Jack, you're a avowed Communist, a member of the party, yet you work at a bank, the most capitalist of all companies save the stock market." Before I could ask a question he cut me off and said, "the irony is not lost on me. What I do in my free time is my own business. What I do at work pays my bills. If being a teacher paid as well as a computer programmer, I would have been a teacher." He was a great guy and a pretty good programmer.
He's gotta eat somehow. But we don't know if half of his salary goes to supporting local communists or just locally helping the most disadvantaged groups.
Sounds like he lacked the courage of his convictions. "Just doing my job" is not a valid excuse. When you get to the pearly gates, Ol' St. Pete is going to "just do his job."
@@briankleinschmidt3664 it's kind of hard not to participate in capitalism while living in a capitalist society
Everyone wants to be a communist until they have to pay the bills.
@@SpencerWilliamsIV Honestly I think it's the opposite. The bills are high because of the unregulated real estate market. The jobs pay little because capitalist shareholders do everything in their power to give the workers as little as possible. Paying bills just gives you more reasons to want a different economic system.
If she wears a shirt saying "I love communist"
she might be communist
He was referring to the man in the ghost costume at the very end
Tactical assessment: Red Chinese victory-impossible.
to the laogai
How are you everywhere
YOU ARE FUCKING EVERYWHERE DUDE!!, HOLY SHIIIT
ARYAN YURI so is he a communist
Oh no not him
Today I met a guy who was loudly and proudly declaring his love for communism. I can’t be too sure, but I think he might’ve been a communist.
I like that it tries an olive branch of "may" to doing one or multiple of these things but that feeling tell us if you do all these things consistently then it stands to reason
I love how it tries to frame an anti-KKK protest as nefarious😊
Nefarious I tell you!!
What the narrator is trying to say is that benign causes such as anti KKK activism have infiltrated by forces working against America, the banner calling for an end of US overseas bases is testament to that.
Fuck how can I hide now? :/
xD
Shit yeah we need to take down this video before I get exposed
Book it to Cuba, thanks to the lifted embargo I think they might let people travel there pretty soon.
Mr Blank come to my place comerade, you can read Marx while you are in hiding!
Pinochet is coming for you
"If your friend offers to share their chips with you"
"They may be a communist"
My friends don't ask me if I want to share my chips with them or not, they simply take them.
They might be communists
I too want to share the chips of your labor, comrade.
nope but if your friend insist you have to and must share chips then he is a communist .
If he waves a red flag, this is a red flag.
“I’m a communist” “hmmm is he left-leaning???”😂
If a person wears a cardboard sign hanging from their neck with the words "I'm a Communist" printed in Comic Sans font ... they might be a Communist.
Us communists know better than to use that horrible font.
@@northernsines I actually like comic sans…
Comic Sans, communists would never!
@Mr. Squiggles he’s probably a libertarian capitalist in disguise
Not comic sans, COMMUNIST sans
LOL "If he openly claims to be a communist...WE TAKE HIS WORD FOR IT!"
As the old adage goes"Never ever trust a communist" meaning the statement said by the communist "I am a communist" is a lie since communists don't tell the truth meaning they aren't a communist
"if he says he's the president"
"He must be a communist"
"Wait what"
I was waiting for the whole "means of production being redistributed between working classes" thing, but it never came out. I start to suspect this movie might be a little mislead on what communism is
Tried applying this to everyday life. Any extra advice on spotting communists?
My Dog's room has a photo of Lenin hanging on the wall, he may be a communist then.........................Wait, that's my room, Oh shit....
I also have a picture of Lenin in my room. I must be a Communist.
*McCarthyism intensifies
Someone fire up the helicopter, this man gets a free ride.
You may be a communist
sahil singh Lennin was a dog