Listening to Ian Chappel doing his dissection on a cricket team is always a pleasure, his analytic views, uncompromising comments is always spot on, see how correct he was on not picking Khawaja as a opener in Hobert. He may be sometimes harsh but mostly correct in his analysis.
he's brilliant.... always been his fan since time immemorial.... that's exactly how one should analyse game and comment. i hope idiots [sorry, i meant manjrekars, chopras, karthiks (murali) etc and etc] have seen this, but shameful enough to continue.
I think it's harsh on Leach. He's suffering partially because Root and Silverwood doubt him and set him negative fields, and he's just carried the drinks for a year without playing. Then he gets brought back into an Ashes series where the Aussies are after him, his own skipper doesn't rate him, and he's trying to defend less than 200 runs. If he'd come into this series after a solid year in the side, overs under his belt and Root had faith in him you'd see a different bloke
You probably would see a different bloke. And people are harsh. But also, what's in his arsenal as a spinner? Adequate spin, but next to no drift, minimal revs it seems-two thing you need in Aus as a spinner.
Mate, a good test player doesn't give a rat's f**k about what his captain, coach, fans think about him or rate him. He goes out there and performs, delivers for his country. Leach is the most useless cricketeer i've ever seen! This English side is so bad that they don't have a decent test match spinner to perform. What a nightmare for English cricket fans! Lol
Not only that but they played him in Brisbane which was a totally unsuitable pitch. Broad should have played there and Leach should have played in Adelaide.
When we rip the best players out of the side to play the limited overs game it leaves large holes to fill.. in truth England are playing a side of reserves with the exception of 2 or 3 bowlers and a couple of batsmen.. this Australian side in my honest opinion are nothing special.. they’ve had much better sides in the past but yes they’ve ‘done enough’.. to score a pretty poor first innings and beat our lot by an innings speaks volumes.. Roy, Bairstow, Morgan should be in there and not throwing the bat in limited overs
I'm picking Sam Billings to play in the fifth test - he's been on fire for the Sydney Thunder in the Big Bash and would be a great inclusion for the international side!
Matt Renshaw is a great shout. Was very solid when Aus batting were struggling and only Smith was scoring runs. Very unlucky to miss out. Renshaw will come good in Eng and Asia. But Boland's gotta play.
Love the way two Aussies are so insightful about England's problems - they can see and highlight the obvious freely. Pick your best side, pick your best Wicketkeeper, Silverwood is not a Test Coach, Root is not a Captain and definitely not a Test Captain. I can imagine the uproar in Aussie if we made the England set-up the Aussie set-up. Archer is a big miss (just watch him against the Aussies on here) but look at how he was handled and overbowled by Root which then supposedly led to the injury problems
Yeah I was pleasantly surprised by how much attention and knowledge they displayed about our problems. Silverwood has to go now, Buttler's test career must be over, the ECB need to reinstate Ed Smith or someone else outside the team as a selector to prevent groupthink, we need to play more county games in the summer and not April and October, and go for a someone like Kirsten or another big name Test level coach. I would even be open to the idea of Eoin Morgan being test captain and Buttler taking over the one-day sides. I know Morgan's test batting record is not great, but his leadership would more than make up for that. But will the ECB do all of the above it?? Very unlikely. Instead they'll sign another mega TV deal for the Hundred and pat themselves on the back.
Ian Chappell is right, he is a good decision maker, that's why he was such a great captain. I always respect his opinions, seems harsh but not never biased, he believes in his opinions, Usman failed in both innings of Hobart.
Im a kiwi so don't normally get involved in Aussie family discussions, but I think Chappell is wrong here about Khawaja - he just scored 2 centuries - put him in the team somewhere, please. OK he failed in Hobart 1st innings, but so did Warner and Smith. By the way, I do agree with Chappell about Renshaw, he should be in the team also.
Khawaja has ripened into the world class player that Australia has always hoped. With is fitness and discipline he could play to 40 - look at Anderson. Its just that he has taken this long to become the complete package. He is head and shoulders above Marcus Harris in talent and he averages big runs at opening. He must be opener for Hobart and Australia looks formidable with Warner, Smith, Labschagne and Khawaja.
Absolutely correct Gil however langer has always been critical since khwaja gave his views regarding rift between coach and players. That is the reason harris getting enough chances despite khwaja is by far better than him. Now aus mngment saying harris has done well to make ball old so that middle ordr could score runs.
The agenda against khawaja is incredible. Ian doesn’t really rate him in general and now he’s being stubborn imo. How can someone be dropped after scoring back to back tons
There's no proof Marnus is better than Khawaja overseas. He scored 3 50's in England but still has to prove himself in other 9 test playing countries especially in India. Khawaja for me is the 2nd best all condition batter in Australia after Smith.
@@sherafgantareen6340 younger players are massively over rated in cricket. its super obvious khawaja is a better player than harris. even if khawaja only stays in the team for 2 years harris can then come back and will probably be a better player for it. no harm done to anyone and australia will be stronger overall. looking to the future isnt always the best idea imo. just pick ur best players. hopefully harris will be the best opener we have in a couple of years. cause right now hes not.
@@punjabigundaa kawaja has failed in the sub continent.hes not a proven player of spin bowling... don't put him in the same category as Smith as an all condition player!!!
“Joe Root isn’t a cricket captain” - not often I agree with an Aussie, but this is spot on. England are on the floor as a result of woeful decisions and inadequate personnel
Given my name I believe it's mandatory to continue this thread. Joe Root is a nice guy, and top level batter. The only reason he is captain is that he is the only England player guaranteed selection. He seems to have very little feel for the state of a game, and is too much of a nice guy when hard on-field decisions need to be made. ChappellI is mostly right about cricket matters, except his negative view of Khawaja, and any player from Vic.
I have a lot of time for Ian Chappell as he is a cricket great and probably one of the best captain the game has ever seen. However, it is quite clear he doesn't like Khwaja. It is personal. Both times Khwaja came out to bat English bowlers had Australia in trouble, there was a slide of wickets. Broad and Wood had their tails up and Khwaja made sure Australia didn't lose any more wickets and then when he got set he went on to attack. Compare that to when Head came out to bat in Gabba there was a decent score behind him, it was no pressure batting. Khwaja's both innings at SCG were master class and he quite clearly looked Australia's most assured batsman the whole series. If you call this English bowling line up mediocre you are essentially calling two bowlers with 1100 wickets between them mediocre and a fast bowler that clocks 150 quite regularly. England is currently having some deeper discussions around racial bias in their cricket due to Yorkshire, perhaps Australia should do the same as the short handedness shown to Khwaja over his career lacks common sense otherwise.
I don't think it's a case of Chapelli not liking Khawaja. I think he is reading the selection options correctly. If that was a 24yo Khawaja last week he might have given a different assessment.
Listening to Chapel on Khawaja before his twin hundred and now after, is the same argument. I think Chapel does not like Khawaja... To say his hundreds is base on liking for the pitch, and England's reason but doesnt say the same for Head and others seem unfair. I could be wrong
I think that this series has shown that the current approach isn’t working. Foakes needs to come in, Stokes to take over from Root and we need to find a way to get Crawley and Pope’s confidence up. Archer and Stone back in the team would help. Ian Chappell seems to have it right.
Phil Tuffnel is obviously the batting and fielding coach. How many POMS would make the Aussie side? That’s the question that will sort out how dominant the Aussies are.
One who doesn't want Muslim players to get into the australia team and when Khawaja does well. Oh England are just crap. Yeah that's why the top order failed in the second innings
Lol he says its too much to move uzzie to opener even though his avg as an opener say he can yet wants Renshaw to open who has been batting in the middle order for Qld over both Harris and Uzzie.
To beat australia you need to play in agressive attacking style of cricket. Loved the way crawley played. Couple more of those people and they could have won
Archer not being fit to come is a management issue. There are other England players who are here but unfit also. I keep hearing that the England team management have been preparing for this tour for years. Clearly, the management have failed. Failed the players, failed England, and failed Cricket.
If only Eng had couple more who played like Crawley in Sydney then they could have won. Another note. You should reserve comment on Cummins until Aus play SA and tour sub continent. Another worry, should be burn out. When Imran, Akram did that they did not have a packed schedule and $ making opportunities through franchise cricket. Didn't Khawaja struggle in India? It is inevitable that teams like Aus, India can afford "horses for courses" type of playing XI. This is where it is leading. Chappeli keeps on saying India is difficult wrt Hazlewood. OTOH, India has a decent pace battery. How did those guys manage? Well, someone has to be captain for England. Also, quicks can win games in Aus. But, did India have blokes who can bowl at 140K+ when they toured last year..?
England do not have proper openers, infact world over quality openers are missing in all test teams. Whenever teams had strong opening batters, they have performed brilliantly.
One of the problems is that Stokesy is still not well.He had some very deeply affecting personal problems back home,from which I do not think he has recovered. He is such a power house and talisman that his value to the team is incalculable. I suspect he needs more time to rest and recover from his personal problems to reemerge as the brilliant all rounder he was and is .Good luck Stokesy,a few of us have been to that dark place but it gets better.
Same. I saw all these idiots on Twitter, mostly Gen Y snowflakes crying about how negative Chappell is on the ABC radio. Oh negative, negative, its too much reality for my weak brain. Keep it positive. England have been garbage and hard to find anything positive. One idiot even claimed his six year old daughter was listening when Chappell apparently said Santa was not real. Dont know what that was about but my advice for anyone in the public eye is to ignore idiots on Twitter and sail on regardless
He is "Sage" category,,distinctly remember his recommendations for Sehwag before Indian tour of Australia when whole India was against selecting him,,Vengsarkar chairmen of selectors later admitted to Sehwag in the side due to Ian's persuasive observations,,even then,Sehwag got to play only in second test,,boy o boy,how he proved Ian right,,Sage category,,any cricket enthusiast should listen what he says carefully,,
Good to listen to Ian’s view. England are a poor side, we do not have sufficient batting and lack the sort of bowlers who can bowl a side out cheaply. I expect Australia will win in Hobart, a demoralising judgement for me to make.
Take your catches and you'd be half way there. Averages over the series: Warner 33 Smith 30 Labuschagne 41 But if England took just one of the catches they've dropped off Labuschagne and he averages 28. Make 25% more runs. Take ya bloody catches and 5 no ball wickets isn't gonna help anyone.
Mark Taylor, Michael slater, ian healy, mark nicholas, david Lloyd, nusser hussain, Michael atherton🎙️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
England lacked self confidence and self belief they never once looked to be on top of the Aussies didn’t show any grit or resilience. Their performance in the last test was a joke. Ian chapel is an institution of cricket love his commentary and analysis
Sorry Chappelli but I don’t agree with you about Khawaja. He has to play for Australia. Head will obviously come back so Harris has to be dropped. I’m an England fan and even I can see that. I hope we show the fight that we saw at the SCG. The only trouble is that I don’t know who will be fit to play!!
When Australian team defeated Pakistan in test series badly Ian Chappelle suggested Australian team to avoid playing Pakistan now what his stance on England defeat in Australia
Ashes is big Series To be honest Pakistan Plays very bad in Australia Way Bad then they play at any where in the World But idont like this comment its disrespectful
Even that is not much convincing. Eng needs to find a charismatic captain somehow In the coming years in the current squad I don't see any one being captain material.
@@jagadishtsgowda I was saying most teams wins are extremely skewed towards success at home. Look at India right now, still making in South Africa to a mediocre team with six quota players. It’s very very hard to consistently win away from home
Nice to listen to taylor chapell England have been poor But lets be honest they had no chance before the ashes even started No preperation, no red ball cricket for all of them since september pandemic bubble for two years which meant quite a few players were reluctant to travel Australia are a decent side but put the shoe on the other foot and they would struggle also
Rarely do selectors cop anything but vitriol...but George Bailey can sit back thinking he's done a good job so far. So we can now trust in his decision for Hobart knowing that no matter what he decides, half of us will not like it. Too many to fit into an XI
Selectors drop renshaw because he struggle in domestic in that time but last summer against India selectors pick Joe burn who struggle in shield cricket in that time that's shows last few years selectors making very calls
I'm not sure I agree with Chappell's argument that you can't drop a guy on Shield form. They're selected on Shield form, so why not? I could easily argue that (apart from on tour), the side for each match is selected independently of the previous match - it's just that usually, if a guy is deemed good enough to be selected and then doesn't make a hash of it, they are generally considered good enough to be selected for the next match. But back to the point - if a Test player goes back to Shield after some middling scores at the end of a series, and fails to display improved form, what is the justification for continuing to pick him for the next Test? You can see he's out of form. Few players manage to be in form for Tests while simultaneously being out of form for First Class. Prolonged lack of runs at Shield level very much should be taken into consideration for a Test player, just as a prolonged series of scores should be taken into consideration for a non-Test player. In any case, he's factually incorrect that Renshaw wasn't dropped for poor form. He averaged 25 from his previous 12 innings at Test level, and was trending downwards.
If you’d told me at the start of the series that England would limit both Smith and Warner to below a 40 average I’d have fancied our chances. Our batters however are just completely inept and have been for a long time. It’s only because of Root having an almost ATG year things would have looked even worse before this series.
common man , admit, you cannot face australian bowlers on those conditions right now. You can send any team in the world there , australians will trash them . Very simply you cannot face those bowlers. England , you are doing good. Invite a team to england and thrash them , you will feel better.
How good it is that cricket moved from channel 9. This channel refused to recognise diversity in their commentary team and they got old and stale. The Mark Nicholas experiment didn’t work. Cricket will not come back to channel 9 in Chappel’s lifetime.
No Bronx Channel 9 is still the best coverage thats ever existed agree off late they lost that tinge of 1980s or 1990s of even till mid millenium but better than Corrupt Fox.
This aged well haha. 12 months lates Uzzie smashes another 1000 runs, career average 80 as an opener and 45 average more than Chappelli or Tubby. So much for cant bat in asia. Meanwhile Head is on fire with a player of the series and a few man of matches. Same Head that Ian reckons isnt even Test quality.
Opener is specialized volunteer position. Australia did not bat to long. Smith and Labs are not getting enough runs. They had enough chances Carey and Harris dropped catches. Lyon is not taking enough wickets on these grassy pitches.
What will Root do as a captain if his batsmen keep failing him. Is it not so painfully obvious that the batsmen need backing, only then will they improve
Renshaw not opening for Queensland yes renshaw can still get back in to the team as a middle order batsman because he play spin well and Australia play test series in Pakistan,india,Sri Lanka in this year but I think if Australia want to pick a young opner they must pick young henery hunt,or Bryce Street .I don't will pucvoski is a opner he should bat at no6 or no5
The Aussies have an impressive team be interesting to see if they are as good away from home plus they are playing a broken down English team who really do not want to be on tour,do not go tripping over your heads lads my old ma and her pals could beat that English team lmao.
It’s nuts to drop Khawaja..will they drop smith, labuschange or head if they have scored twin hundreds..it’s is totally a ploy to remove Asian representation in the team..
A cantankerous git at times but Chappell's opinions are often interesting and listenable, both on cricket and other subjects. Fully agree with him on Ben Foakes. A better keeper and batsman than Butler. What he's done wrong to be overlooked who knows? He's done nothing wrong when he's been selected in the past. Agree, they've badly missed Archer and Stone who would have been perfect in Australian conditions. Not sure where he's coming from with Dom Bess. He's done little when given his chances in the test team. Very erratic and expensive at times.
England bowlers need to give the batsmen a chance? How about their batsmen try scoring some runs and taking some catches and give their bowlers a chance.
Listening to Ian Chappel doing his dissection on a cricket team is always a pleasure, his analytic views, uncompromising comments is always spot on, see how correct he was on not picking Khawaja as a opener in Hobert. He may be sometimes harsh but mostly correct in his analysis.
he's brilliant.... always been his fan since time immemorial.... that's exactly how one should analyse game and comment. i hope idiots [sorry, i meant manjrekars, chopras, karthiks (murali) etc and etc] have seen this, but shameful enough to continue.
Great discussion covering a lot of the important conundrums facing both teams.
Two very good captains. Two very good experienced cricket brains.
True that
I think it's harsh on Leach. He's suffering partially because Root and Silverwood doubt him and set him negative fields, and he's just carried the drinks for a year without playing. Then he gets brought back into an Ashes series where the Aussies are after him, his own skipper doesn't rate him, and he's trying to defend less than 200 runs. If he'd come into this series after a solid year in the side, overs under his belt and Root had faith in him you'd see a different bloke
You probably would see a different bloke. And people are harsh. But also, what's in his arsenal as a spinner? Adequate spin, but next to no drift, minimal revs it seems-two thing you need in Aus as a spinner.
He's not strong enough to stand up for himself which is what Chappelli is saying.
Mate, a good test player doesn't give a rat's f**k about what his captain, coach, fans think about him or rate him. He goes out there and performs, delivers for his country. Leach is the most useless cricketeer i've ever seen! This English side is so bad that they don't have a decent test match spinner to perform. What a nightmare for English cricket fans! Lol
Not only that but they played him in Brisbane which was a totally unsuitable pitch. Broad should have played there and Leach should have played in Adelaide.
When we rip the best players out of the side to play the limited overs game it leaves large holes to fill.. in truth England are playing a side of reserves with the exception of 2 or 3 bowlers and a couple of batsmen.. this Australian side in my honest opinion are nothing special.. they’ve had much better sides in the past but yes they’ve ‘done enough’.. to score a pretty poor first innings and beat our lot by an innings speaks volumes.. Roy, Bairstow, Morgan should be in there and not throwing the bat in limited overs
I'm picking Sam Billings to play in the fifth test - he's been on fire for the Sydney Thunder in the Big Bash and would be a great inclusion for the international side!
Matt Renshaw is a great shout. Was very solid when Aus batting were struggling and only Smith was scoring runs. Very unlucky to miss out. Renshaw will come good in Eng and Asia. But Boland's gotta play.
Ian Chappell straight forward thats what i love about him
Love the way two Aussies are so insightful about England's problems - they can see and highlight the obvious freely. Pick your best side, pick your best Wicketkeeper, Silverwood is not a Test Coach, Root is not a Captain and definitely not a Test Captain. I can imagine the uproar in Aussie if we made the England set-up the Aussie set-up. Archer is a big miss (just watch him against the Aussies on here) but look at how he was handled and overbowled by Root which then supposedly led to the injury problems
Yeah I was pleasantly surprised by how much attention and knowledge they displayed about our problems. Silverwood has to go now, Buttler's test career must be over, the ECB need to reinstate Ed Smith or someone else outside the team as a selector to prevent groupthink, we need to play more county games in the summer and not April and October, and go for a someone like Kirsten or another big name Test level coach. I would even be open to the idea of Eoin Morgan being test captain and Buttler taking over the one-day sides. I know Morgan's test batting record is not great, but his leadership would more than make up for that. But will the ECB do all of the above it?? Very unlikely. Instead they'll sign another mega TV deal for the Hundred and pat themselves on the back.
@@bruno5137 Ben foakes is better player he should be innthe team . Atleast give him a go when they've backed burns for 30 tests with 30 average
Archer got farmed last ashes before Joe root put him to the sword
Ian Chappell is right, he is a good decision maker, that's why he was such a great captain. I always respect his opinions, seems harsh but not never biased, he believes in his opinions, Usman failed in both innings of Hobart.
Ian and Mark sharing great knowledge and wisdom in this discussion.
Chapelli.... Love to hear u.. Stay healthy.. God bless you..
I recall a English Captain David Gower said it is not Cricket playing against Ian Chappelle it was blood and guts warfare
Ian Chappell nailed it with regards to English players. LOL
Im a kiwi so don't normally get involved in Aussie family discussions, but I think Chappell is wrong here about Khawaja - he just scored 2 centuries - put him in the team somewhere, please. OK he failed in Hobart 1st innings, but so did Warner and Smith. By the way, I do agree with Chappell about Renshaw, he should be in the team also.
Khawaja has ripened into the world class player that Australia has always hoped. With is fitness and discipline he could play to 40 - look at Anderson. Its just that he has taken this long to become the complete package. He is head and shoulders above Marcus Harris in talent and he averages big runs at opening. He must be opener for Hobart and Australia looks formidable with Warner, Smith, Labschagne and Khawaja.
Absolutely correct Gil however langer has always been critical since khwaja gave his views regarding rift between coach and players. That is the reason harris getting enough chances despite khwaja is by far better than him. Now aus mngment saying harris has done well to make ball old so that middle ordr could score runs.
Khawaja is a class batsman...but Chappell hates him..Harris failed
Usman is a great batsman....but once Chappell doesn't like a player that's it...they are terrible for ever...
The agenda against khawaja is incredible. Ian doesn’t really rate him in general and now he’s being stubborn imo. How can someone be dropped after scoring back to back tons
I agree. Chappelli is sounding like a silly old man here.
And how can someone (Harris) keep his spot after constant failures.
There's no proof Marnus is better than Khawaja overseas. He scored 3 50's in England but still has to prove himself in other 9 test playing countries especially in India. Khawaja for me is the 2nd best all condition batter in Australia after Smith.
@@sherafgantareen6340 younger players are massively over rated in cricket. its super obvious khawaja is a better player than harris. even if khawaja only stays in the team for 2 years harris can then come back and will probably be a better player for it. no harm done to anyone and australia will be stronger overall. looking to the future isnt always the best idea imo. just pick ur best players. hopefully harris will be the best opener we have in a couple of years. cause right now hes not.
@@punjabigundaa kawaja has failed in the sub continent.hes not a proven player of spin bowling... don't put him in the same category as Smith as an all condition player!!!
Great conversation between two of our very best captains.
“Joe Root isn’t a cricket captain” - not often I agree with an Aussie, but this is spot on. England are on the floor as a result of woeful decisions and inadequate personnel
Yea . Is it Root or is it all the hangers on in the dressing room? I think England out smarted themselves in the first two tests
Given my name I believe it's mandatory to continue this thread.
Joe Root is a nice guy, and top level batter. The only reason he is captain is that he is the only England player guaranteed selection.
He seems to have very little feel for the state of a game, and is too much of a nice guy when hard on-field decisions need to be made.
ChappellI is mostly right about cricket matters, except his negative view of Khawaja, and any player from Vic.
What eng don't have any other consistent player who could be in contention for captaincy
Who’d you have as skipper?
I have a lot of time for Ian Chappell as he is a cricket great and probably one of the best captain the game has ever seen. However, it is quite clear he doesn't like Khwaja. It is personal. Both times Khwaja came out to bat English bowlers had Australia in trouble, there was a slide of wickets. Broad and Wood had their tails up and Khwaja made sure Australia didn't lose any more wickets and then when he got set he went on to attack. Compare that to when Head came out to bat in Gabba there was a decent score behind him, it was no pressure batting. Khwaja's both innings at SCG were master class and he quite clearly looked Australia's most assured batsman the whole series. If you call this English bowling line up mediocre you are essentially calling two bowlers with 1100 wickets between them mediocre and a fast bowler that clocks 150 quite regularly. England is currently having some deeper discussions around racial bias in their cricket due to Yorkshire, perhaps Australia should do the same as the short handedness shown to Khwaja over his career lacks common sense otherwise.
I don't think it's a case of Chapelli not liking Khawaja. I think he is reading the selection options correctly. If that was a 24yo Khawaja last week he might have given a different assessment.
Couldn’t agree more with you, Jibran. Strange ageist reservations against Khawaja. Pick your best XI imo.
Good analysis, thank you Mark. I always think Joe root is one of the best batter in the world 🌎 but not my Captain.
Chappelli, leader of men. Still my leader.
Really Chappell, you don't see Khwaja playing the next match..lol
as an opener
@@FrenchCutcricket I know its a small sample size of 7 innings but he does average 90 odd as an opener.
Listening to Chapel on Khawaja before his twin hundred and now after, is the same argument. I think Chapel does not like Khawaja... To say his hundreds is base on liking for the pitch, and England's reason but doesnt say the same for Head and others seem unfair. I could be wrong
I'm Victorian but even i have to admit Harris has had his chance (for now). Chappell seems to have something againt Khawaja as another said.
He hates Muslims in general.
I absolutely love Chappelli.
I think that this series has shown that the current approach isn’t working. Foakes needs to come in, Stokes to take over from Root and we need to find a way to get Crawley and Pope’s confidence up. Archer and Stone back in the team would help. Ian Chappell seems to have it right.
Mark Taylor❤️ one of my fav commentators🎙️
Phil Tuffnel is obviously the batting and fielding coach. How many POMS would make the Aussie side? That’s the question that will sort out how dominant the Aussies are.
Miss these guys commentating 9's TV coverage of test cricket, 7 just doesn't stack up
Always great to hear Ian Chappell talk about cricket, or anything actually 🙂
GOLDEN WORDS "whatever is coming down just play" I love it. I love the truth
Keeping the game simple is the hardest thing with cricket. Ian keeps it sensible and simple, that's why he was one of the greats.
I'm with Chapelli. Root a fantastic batsman but not a captains bootlace. Bit of OZ negative bias but it's still true.
Listening to Chappell commentate reminds me of listening to a grand parent telling you the same story over and over.
A racist grandparent
One who doesn't want Muslim players to get into the australia team and when Khawaja does well. Oh England are just crap. Yeah that's why the top order failed in the second innings
He does seem to think its still 1975. This makes him forthright and wary of authority… as long as it isn’t his own.
A lack of preparation has hindered us all series. Also bad decision making.
@@mrkipling2201 and playing a majority of second string batsmen..
I'd get rid of Root and Silverwood as Captain and Coach just on the basis of them keeping Buttler in the test side for so long.
Excellent view point by Ian Chappell what a great man he is and his understanding of the cricket....
Disagree. He’s well past it
Lol he says its too much to move uzzie to opener even though his avg as an opener say he can yet wants Renshaw to open who has been batting in the middle order for Qld over both Harris and Uzzie.
Laughable. Makes me think all cricket selection is who you like...
To beat australia you need to play in agressive attacking style of cricket. Loved the way crawley played. Couple more of those people and they could have won
Yep, Crawley was damn annoying. Exactly as he should be.
@@AndrewBlucher I'm myself very disappointed by the performance of our team in south africa. But credit to sa they played the ball not names .
This men is just a gem 👍👍👍👍👍
Whenever lan talks cricket, it always thoughtful and loaded with common sense. That's why he was a great captain and player.
I just love when he say " go and keep the technique in the corner" 😂😂
what a conversation. mindblowing. actually, i am not surprised.
I am fully agree remarks of great Ian cappel sab
Excellent discussion
Ian chapel can't keep his personal likes and dislikes away from his reviews.
Such good analysis of englands poor selection, and we’re badly missing archer and stone
Archer not being fit to come is a management issue. There are other England players who are here but unfit also.
I keep hearing that the England team management have been preparing for this tour for years.
Clearly, the management have failed. Failed the players, failed England, and failed Cricket.
Best Cricket program on Planet Earth.
If only Eng had couple more who played like Crawley in Sydney then they could have won.
Another note. You should reserve comment on Cummins until Aus play SA and tour sub continent.
Another worry, should be burn out. When Imran, Akram did that they did not have a packed schedule and $ making opportunities through franchise cricket.
Didn't Khawaja struggle in India?
It is inevitable that teams like Aus, India can afford "horses for courses" type of playing XI. This is where it is leading.
Chappeli keeps on saying India is difficult wrt Hazlewood. OTOH, India has a decent pace battery. How did those guys manage?
Well, someone has to be captain for England. Also, quicks can win games in Aus. But, did India have blokes who can bowl at 140K+ when they toured last year..?
Agreed. 👍👍
England do not have proper openers, infact world over quality openers are missing in all test teams. Whenever teams had strong opening batters, they have performed brilliantly.
One of the problems is that Stokesy is still not well.He had some very deeply affecting personal problems back home,from which I do not think he has recovered. He is such a power house and talisman that his value to the team is incalculable. I suspect he needs more time to rest and recover from his personal problems to reemerge as the brilliant all rounder he was and is .Good luck Stokesy,a few of us have been to that dark place but it gets better.
Chapel you old twart, khawaja deserves to open averages 96+. You old twart why would we continue with Haris?
Bro Khawaja is Muslim Ian hates Muslims
The thumbnail gives me hope that there's still plenty of people other than myself that loves to hear Ian Chappell talk cricket.
Same. I saw all these idiots on Twitter, mostly Gen Y snowflakes crying about how negative Chappell is on the ABC radio. Oh negative, negative, its too much reality for my weak brain. Keep it positive. England have been garbage and hard to find anything positive. One idiot even claimed his six year old daughter was listening when Chappell apparently said Santa was not real. Dont know what that was about but my advice for anyone in the public eye is to ignore idiots on Twitter and sail on regardless
He is class. Straightforward. Never holding back and sharp 👍
He is "Sage" category,,distinctly remember his recommendations for Sehwag before Indian tour of Australia when whole India was against selecting him,,Vengsarkar chairmen of selectors later admitted to Sehwag in the side due to Ian's persuasive observations,,even then,Sehwag got to play only in second test,,boy o boy,how he proved Ian right,,Sage category,,any cricket enthusiast should listen what he says carefully,,
Just superb
As an Englishman, I completely agree with everything Greg said about the England team.
Ian Chappell is a master visionary!
Ian chapel Voice Reminds me the time When i was a school boy 😥
Good to listen to Ian’s view. England are a poor side, we do not have sufficient batting and lack the sort of bowlers who can bowl a side out cheaply. I expect Australia will win in Hobart, a demoralising judgement for me to make.
Take your catches and you'd be half way there. Averages over the series:
Warner 33
Smith 30
Labuschagne 41
But if England took just one of the catches they've dropped off Labuschagne and he averages 28.
Make 25% more runs. Take ya bloody catches and 5 no ball wickets isn't gonna help anyone.
@@realMaverickBuckley righty said. Marnus somehow gets lucky all the time .
Mark Taylor, Michael slater, ian healy, mark nicholas, david Lloyd, nusser hussain, Michael atherton🎙️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
England lacked self confidence and self belief they never once looked to be on top of the Aussies didn’t show any grit or resilience. Their performance in the last test was a joke.
Ian chapel is an institution of cricket love his commentary and analysis
Renshaw doesn't even open for his shield team anymore
Sorry Chappelli but I don’t agree with you about Khawaja. He has to play for Australia. Head will obviously come back so Harris has to be dropped. I’m an England fan and even I can see that. I hope we show the fight that we saw at the SCG. The only trouble is that I don’t know who will be fit to play!!
Yeah well-the old bloke looks like he was right.
@@peterpiper482 Bruh one game. Are we gonna drop everyone except Head and Green, because they’re the only ones who did well with the bat?
When Australian team defeated Pakistan in test series badly Ian Chappelle suggested Australian team to avoid playing Pakistan now what his stance on England defeat in Australia
Ashes is big Series
To be honest Pakistan Plays very bad in Australia Way Bad then they play at any where in the World
But idont like this comment its disrespectful
He’s right about Root…it’s all home victories…when the pressure is on away from home …he’s just not inspiring
Even that is not much convincing. Eng needs to find a charismatic captain somehow In the coming years in the current squad I don't see any one being captain material.
Tbf that’s true of pretty much every test team now
@@HkFinn83 nah.
@@HkFinn83 don't agree with that. India has problem of plenty captain materials, Kohli, Rahane (come back series win in Aus) and Rohit
@@jagadishtsgowda I was saying most teams wins are extremely skewed towards success at home. Look at India right now, still making in South Africa to a mediocre team with six quota players. It’s very very hard to consistently win away from home
You try to give the video more brightness it will be great if you do
England have not got a clue how to get him out - Mark Wood would have something to say about that
Ian Chappell has always been the greatest expert of cricket - by a mile. And this is the best review of the game out there.
Nice to listen to taylor chapell
England have been poor
But lets be honest they had no chance before the ashes even started
No preperation, no red ball cricket for all of them since september pandemic bubble for two years which meant quite a few players were reluctant to travel
Australia are a decent side but put the shoe on the other foot and they would struggle also
Root is too shy for war. - Pranab Sarkar (that's me), 2017.
4:30 Pujara, Rahane and BCCI: "Never ever, my friend"
Gee I didn’t know Ian wasn’t a fan of Root as captain, he’s never mentioned that before.
He has said it plenty of times on the ABC. I don't bother with the 7 "commentary".
Rarely do selectors cop anything but vitriol...but George Bailey can sit back thinking he's done a good job so far. So we can now trust in his decision for Hobart knowing that no matter what he decides, half of us will not like it. Too many to fit into an XI
Selectors drop renshaw because he struggle in domestic in that time but last summer against India selectors pick Joe burn who struggle in shield cricket in that time that's shows last few years selectors making very calls
England need to think beyond Stuart Broad and James Anderson as fast bowlers. Ollie Robinson and Chris Woakes should be given more chances.
I want to hear chappel's view after their series against Pakistan about Cummins captaincy
I'm not sure I agree with Chappell's argument that you can't drop a guy on Shield form. They're selected on Shield form, so why not? I could easily argue that (apart from on tour), the side for each match is selected independently of the previous match - it's just that usually, if a guy is deemed good enough to be selected and then doesn't make a hash of it, they are generally considered good enough to be selected for the next match.
But back to the point - if a Test player goes back to Shield after some middling scores at the end of a series, and fails to display improved form, what is the justification for continuing to pick him for the next Test? You can see he's out of form. Few players manage to be in form for Tests while simultaneously being out of form for First Class. Prolonged lack of runs at Shield level very much should be taken into consideration for a Test player, just as a prolonged series of scores should be taken into consideration for a non-Test player.
In any case, he's factually incorrect that Renshaw wasn't dropped for poor form. He averaged 25 from his previous 12 innings at Test level, and was trending downwards.
If you’d told me at the start of the series that England would limit both Smith and Warner to below a 40 average I’d have fancied our chances. Our batters however are just completely inept and have been for a long time. It’s only because of Root having an almost ATG year things would have looked even worse before this series.
common man , admit, you cannot face australian bowlers on those conditions right now. You can send any team in the world there , australians will trash them . Very simply you cannot face those bowlers. England , you are doing good. Invite a team to england and thrash them , you will feel better.
Love Chappell's forthright comments 😂
Gotta love Ian ! Always a straight talker but now with his “seniority “ he has kicked it up to level 13 and enjoys watching people react
I totally agree...I'm from the UK🙄
Good chat
I think Cummings got declaration wrong but he’s new to captaincy and I’m sure he’ll learn.
Chappell doesnt have time for two of the best performers in this series.. Khwaja and Boland...
hmm...makes me wonder why so?
Racist AF
Chappell talking absolute nonsense about Leach. To say he's not a competitor is simply degrading. Very poor
How good it is that cricket moved from channel 9. This channel refused to recognise diversity in their commentary team and they got old and stale. The Mark Nicholas experiment didn’t work. Cricket will not come back to channel 9 in Chappel’s lifetime.
No Bronx Channel 9 is still the best coverage thats ever existed agree off late they lost that tinge of 1980s or 1990s of even till mid millenium but better than Corrupt Fox.
Get rid of Warner and smith to give 2 other batsmen a chance
Did Ian Chappell once captain Dennis Lillee? He may have mentioned it once or twice.
And?
This aged well haha. 12 months lates Uzzie smashes another 1000 runs, career average 80 as an opener and 45 average more than Chappelli or Tubby. So much for cant bat in asia. Meanwhile Head is on fire with a player of the series and a few man of matches. Same Head that Ian reckons isnt even Test quality.
Everything Ian Chappell says is bang on 👍
id ben stokes captain of eng for 5th test???
Make Marnus open with Warner and Khwaja comes one down
Opener is specialized volunteer position. Australia did not bat to long. Smith and Labs are not getting enough runs. They had enough chances Carey and Harris dropped catches. Lyon is not taking enough wickets on these grassy pitches.
What will Root do as a captain if his batsmen keep failing him. Is it not so painfully obvious that the batsmen need backing, only then will they improve
Renshaw not opening for Queensland yes renshaw can still get back in to the team as a middle order batsman because he play spin well and Australia play test series in Pakistan,india,Sri Lanka in this year but I think if Australia want to pick a young opner they must pick young henery hunt,or Bryce Street .I don't will pucvoski is a opner he should bat at no6 or no5
🤔🤔
Green at 7 Carey at 8 two quicks and Lyon and play both head and uzi ... howzat tubby !!
So far, only on Boland and Jhye I disagree with Chappel.
Spot on with Root, he is not a Captain.
💙❤❤💙
The Aussies have an impressive team be interesting to see if they are as good away from home plus they are playing a broken down English team who really do not want to be on tour,do not go tripping over your heads lads my old ma and her pals could beat that English team lmao.
Yep, you are not the only one who is "interested" how they play on tour. They have had it easy here. Things will be tougher in Asia.
It’s nuts to drop Khawaja..will they drop smith, labuschange or head if they have scored twin hundreds..it’s is totally a ploy to remove Asian representation in the team..
Doesnt mind sledging Joe Root's captaincy...
A cantankerous git at times but Chappell's opinions are often interesting and listenable, both on cricket and other subjects. Fully agree with him on Ben Foakes. A better keeper and batsman than Butler. What he's done wrong to be overlooked who knows? He's done nothing wrong when he's been selected in the past. Agree, they've badly missed Archer and Stone who would have been perfect in Australian conditions. Not sure where he's coming from with Dom Bess. He's done little when given his chances in the test team. Very erratic and expensive at times.
Silverwood read to many cricket books and still hasn't got a bloody clue. we need a coach that has played test cricket END OF.
England bowlers need to give the batsmen a chance? How about their batsmen try scoring some runs and taking some catches and give their bowlers a chance.
140 isn't enough? The bowlers are getting all the criticism when it's there batsman that are the problem.
Joe Root's made some questionable decisions but you can't criticise his captaincy when the batsman are playing like under 12's.
@@2partiesnotpreferred226 and the one game where the batsmen gave a fight they got a draw
@@WinThis1 when we’d played 3 test matches and got used to the conditions. Shows how much a lack of warmup games affected us.