1:25-1:39 Actually, Ohtani only composed and remixed half of Colors' OST. In Ultimate, he remixed Tropical Resort, Starlight Carnival and Aquarium Park. Sweet Mountain, Planet Wisp and Asteroid Coaster were remixed by Kenichi Tokoi. Therefore, the Planet Wisp remixes didn't have Ohtani's influence.
Kenichi Tokoi (the composer of the original versions of Asteroid Coaster, Planet Wisp, and Sweet Mountain) has remixed these song for ultimate. Not Tomoya Ohtani. Meanwhile, Ohtani remixed the songs he composed like Tropical Resort, Starlight Carnival and Aquarium Park.
I think I'm one of the very few people who like the Planet Wisp Act 1 remix. I 100% agree with why people like the original more, but idk, I just find it funny how it sounds like everyone's about to have a party.
Planet Wisp Act 1 may not be the worst in the lineup, But it's by far my least favorite due to Just how much of a clear misunderstanding there is of what the stage was even supposed to represent. The original was a great showcase of musical storytelling, You had the serene piano and strings to represent nature, slowly being overtaken by the harsh guitar and drums to represent The encroaching industrialization covering up that natural beauty. You shouldn't be listening to freaking dubstep while running through Planet Wisp Act 1. There's a complete dissonance here. (Wrote this before your entry. So yeah pretty much exactly what you said. Lmao)
@@awsomedude23456 Sonic '06 and Sonic Mania. Look, I only put Sonic Mania because it has the Genesis soundtracks and putting all of the classic games on my list isn’t fair so I just put Mania in place of all of them including CD. And Sonic '06 is on it because it has a really good music and the fact the games issues can overshadow it is sad so I put in the light. Now for the other 7 spots, I will not tell.
@@awsomedude23456 well now that you’ve mentioned them, they are on my list. Don’t worry. I think almost every Sonic game has a great soundtrack. Unleashed and Forces are on here. I just wanted to be fair a bit since people always go the same route. Call me uncultured but I at least put Unleashed as everyone would expect. Just not in the top 3 but it’s in 4th place.
We'd be here all day discussing why we agree or disagree with Pup (that or trying to discuss "music terminology"), so I'll say that my only critique is that there's no mention of Kenichi Tokoi. The bass in his compositions (Sweet Mountain, Planet Wisp, Asteroid Coaster, Terminal Velocity) is so crisp. The man just really excels at brass and bass, and each track he composed for Colors had these little tasty nuances (that Ultimate unfortunately did not include). I have no problem with everyone saying "bring Jun back" especially since he is the best composer for the franchise, but Tokoi gets slept on a lot, and he's been involved almost as long as Jun. Adventure, Unleashed, and Colors' soundtracks are as good as they are thanks to him......and several others, but that's an essay discussion. Good video though. SCU's soundtrack has been on my mind lately and today was the right time to hear someone else talk about it.
24:30 If I haven’t heard this song before and someone told me that it was a FamilyJules cover of Terminal Velocity Act 1, I would believe you. That remix is that good!
Buttrock lover loves Buttrock: The List. Kinda takes the suspense away from it but whudduyagonnado? Jun Sunoue was already in last time in Team Sonic Racing, not sure what he’s going on about.
Nothing can top the ost on the DS version. The way the DS made the tracks sound it just gave them all a bit more flavor. Maybe it's my nostalgia talking but I liked the DS version of the ost the best.
i personally have no nostalgia for the ds version but i like it doesnt feel like "just an inferior version of the regular ost" it feels like its own thing, which makes it fun to listen to over the original sometimes
My personal best zone remixes: 1: Terminal Velocity 2: Starlight Carnival 3: Asteroid Coaster 4: Tropical Resort 5: Sweet Mountain 6: Planet Wisp 7: Aquarium Park(the only zone where I prefer the original) But hey that’s just my opinion A GAME (MUSIC?) OPINION
I absolutely hate Tropical Resort Act 1, Planet Wisp Act 1, and all the Sweet Mountain remixes. I also don't care much for the Aquarium Park remixes. Everything else is good. Especially everything Jun Senoue did.
To me I don't like the Aquarium Park remixes. It just sounds like they took the tracks and just added a bunch of loud obnoxious beats and it ruins the flow in my opinion.
I’m actually a really big fan of the percussion in sweet mountain especially because of the solo sample in the rise of the wisps animation. It spread a smile right across my face
@@clarasanchez9565 I think it does to be honest. The original segments represent the nature of Planet Wisp and the more electric remixed parts represent Eggman's takeover of the planet and its mechanical elements. At least that's what I gather from it.
Maybe just as a musician myself, I'd have put Sweet Mountain 3 a lot higher. Not necessarily because of the music itself, but just 'cause it does a really good job taking what the original did and building on it with little new ideas -- without going so far that it turns into a tug of war between the old and the new. It just does what a remix is supposed to do very well, and I guess I appreciate that. And to me Wisp 2 feels more like a new "Wisp" track than it feels like a remix of the old act 2. While they've got some of the same parts, they're mixed into the song in a way that feels so completely different that comparing it to the original act 2 feels almost like comparing the original act 2 song to act 1 or act 3. It manages to do that without feeling like it's fighting itself the way the act 1 remix did, which is nice I suppose. And, yeah, Terminal Velocity 1 blew me away too, the moment it started up :)
I think Mr Pasquale's Music of Sonic Colors Ultimate give a good example of Colors Ultimate music for how okay (not bad or good) these remixes sounds like.
Sonic Fans when SEGA were planning to sell Super Sonic DLC in Forces for 1$: *TERRIBLE! WHAT A DISGRACE!* Sonic Fans when SEGA sold 3 crappy Planet Wisp remixes for 5$: *This is fine*
@@ChannelPup You can disable the DLC in the DLC shop. That's what I heard, anyway. I never actually bought the music pack, so I never found out myself.
@@mistersp3753 I tried doing that on Xbox, and when trying to boot the game back up, it staight up uninstalled the entire game. So maybe don't for Xbox.
Sonic colors be like: welcome to this amusement park we will help you with your tracks. Sonic colors ultimate be like: oh my god this is too shiny this needs to not be so shiny I’m getting a seizure.
I actually don't think any of the new remixes are bad. Sure, some of them, like the Planet Wisp and Tropical Resort remixes, don't fit the levels as well as the original tracks did, but I don't really mind as long as they're a good listen. And yeah, there are definitely tracks that are better than the originals, like the Asteroid Coaster and Terminal Velocity remixes
In my opinion, I think the new version of Planet Wisp is better than the original. I know a lot of people prefer the piano from the original version, but I love how the new version got more beats
1:25-1:39 Actually, Ohtani only composed and remixed half of Colors' OST. In Ultimate, he remixed Tropical Resort, Starlight Carnival and Aquarium Park. Sweet Mountain, Planet Wisp and Asteroid Coaster were remixed by Kenichi Tokoi. Therefore, the Planet Wisp remixes didn't have Ohtani's influence.
Ohtani did Act 2 of Starlight carnival. The other acts were by Jun Senoue.
Two updates that will make me buy this game:
-Playable Metal as originally intended
-Let us turn off the remixes completely
we cant play as metal sonic, but you do can turn off the remixes
Kenichi Tokoi (the composer of the original versions of Asteroid Coaster, Planet Wisp, and Sweet Mountain) has remixed these song for ultimate. Not Tomoya Ohtani. Meanwhile, Ohtani remixed the songs he composed like Tropical Resort, Starlight Carnival and Aquarium Park.
Egg nega wisp phase 2 fits so well with a boss battle. It's like perfect boss battle music
I think I'm one of the very few people who like the Planet Wisp Act 1 remix. I 100% agree with why people like the original more, but idk, I just find it funny how it sounds like everyone's about to have a party.
I like the remix, but I don't think it fits the level as well as the original.
It’s ok to me, I wouldn’t call it bad but just not my favorite
Sweet mountain act 1 definitely has more of a sonic vibe to it and reminds me of the older sonics
I’m REALLY glad I got the digital deluxe version. I like the remixes just fine, but I definitely prefer the originals.
Planet Wisp Act 1 may not be the worst in the lineup, But it's by far my least favorite due to Just how much of a clear misunderstanding there is of what the stage was even supposed to represent.
The original was a great showcase of musical storytelling, You had the serene piano and strings to represent nature, slowly being overtaken by the harsh guitar and drums to represent The encroaching industrialization covering up that natural beauty.
You shouldn't be listening to freaking dubstep while running through Planet Wisp Act 1. There's a complete dissonance here.
(Wrote this before your entry. So yeah pretty much exactly what you said. Lmao)
I don't hate the remixes I just don't think they fit in the game
Agreed, the Wii version's soundtrack was a lot more cohesive!
I honestly like the soundtrack of both versions. In my opinion, Colors is one of the top 3 Sonic games with the best soundtracks.
What are the other 2
@@awsomedude23456 Sonic '06 and Sonic Mania. Look, I only put Sonic Mania because it has the Genesis soundtracks and putting all of the classic games on my list isn’t fair so I just put Mania in place of all of them including CD. And Sonic '06 is on it because it has a really good music and the fact the games issues can overshadow it is sad so I put in the light. Now for the other 7 spots, I will not tell.
@@themaccave08 wow I’m surprised you put mania above unleashed, even forces honestly
@@awsomedude23456 well now that you’ve mentioned them, they are on my list. Don’t worry. I think almost every Sonic game has a great soundtrack. Unleashed and Forces are on here. I just wanted to be fair a bit since people always go the same route. Call me uncultured but I at least put Unleashed as everyone would expect. Just not in the top 3 but it’s in 4th place.
@@themaccave08 ah I see, that makes sense
We'd be here all day discussing why we agree or disagree with Pup (that or trying to discuss "music terminology"), so I'll say that my only critique is that there's no mention of Kenichi Tokoi. The bass in his compositions (Sweet Mountain, Planet Wisp, Asteroid Coaster, Terminal Velocity) is so crisp. The man just really excels at brass and bass, and each track he composed for Colors had these little tasty nuances (that Ultimate unfortunately did not include). I have no problem with everyone saying "bring Jun back" especially since he is the best composer for the franchise, but Tokoi gets slept on a lot, and he's been involved almost as long as Jun. Adventure, Unleashed, and Colors' soundtracks are as good as they are thanks to him......and several others, but that's an essay discussion. Good video though. SCU's soundtrack has been on my mind lately and today was the right time to hear someone else talk about it.
I think NOBODY is surprised that TV1 was in the top spot, they blew it out of the park with that one
24:30 If I haven’t heard this song before and someone told me that it was a FamilyJules cover of Terminal Velocity Act 1, I would believe you. That remix is that good!
Well this is way pass my ear drums cooool.
Thanka to Mr. Pasquale I am no longer able to hate any of this remixes
Sweet mountain act 2 was probably one of my favorites...maybe lol
great list!!
lol if planet wisp is at the bottom, thats all i needed to hear to know i dont care anymore
Idk why but planet wisp for me is actually really good probably cause I have a big bias over edm music
Let the SCU music remixes controversies comments COMMENCE!!!
Buttrock lover loves Buttrock: The List.
Kinda takes the suspense away from it but whudduyagonnado?
Jun Sunoue was already in last time in Team Sonic Racing, not sure what he’s going on about.
I love all the remixes but I do agree that the wisp planet isn't a match for where it is
Nothing can top the ost on the DS version. The way the DS made the tracks sound it just gave them all a bit more flavor. Maybe it's my nostalgia talking but I liked the DS version of the ost the best.
The DS track is pretty good.
i personally have no nostalgia for the ds version but i like it doesnt feel like "just an inferior version of the regular ost"
it feels like its own thing, which makes it fun to listen to over the original sometimes
My personal best zone remixes:
1: Terminal Velocity
2: Starlight Carnival
3: Asteroid Coaster
4: Tropical Resort
5: Sweet Mountain
6: Planet Wisp
7: Aquarium Park(the only zone where I prefer the original)
But hey that’s just my opinion
A GAME (MUSIC?) OPINION
Personally the remixes fall into two categories for me. New take and enchantments
Video 2833 of commenting #BringBackDislikes on every unique video I watch in 2022 (I do not dislike this video).
I absolutely hate Tropical Resort Act 1, Planet Wisp Act 1, and all the Sweet Mountain remixes. I also don't care much for the Aquarium Park remixes.
Everything else is good. Especially everything Jun Senoue did.
Un vrai remix d'un jeu
What about the super sonic theme
Number 6 same
Planet wisp isn’t Otani
I love remixes of Planet Wisp, but it sounds like a bad future remix
17:40 funny, it's because of the piano that I think this is the 3rd worst remix in the game
To me I don't like the Aquarium Park remixes. It just sounds like they took the tracks and just added a bunch of loud obnoxious beats and it ruins the flow in my opinion.
They really ruined the soundtrack
the remixes of sweet mountain are garbage, change my mind
Sweet mother of Christ, what is this video compression?
I’m actually a really big fan of the percussion in sweet mountain especially because of the solo sample in the rise of the wisps animation. It spread a smile right across my face
I like the song. Just not the loud brass of it. I just think it makes the song unbearable to listen to but the rest of the parts are amazing.
@@clarasanchez9565 yeah, especially the beginning of Sweet Mountain Act 3, was awesome until the brass starts playing
Honestly I really like the Planet Wisp Act 1 music. Especially that completely new bit that I can't describe but sounds awesome.
It is REALLY good but just doesn’t fit the peaceful, quiet nature of planet wisp.
@@clarasanchez9565 I think it does to be honest. The original segments represent the nature of Planet Wisp and the more electric remixed parts represent Eggman's takeover of the planet and its mechanical elements. At least that's what I gather from it.
@@LexVanguard2004 Yeah I feel the same way too
Maybe just as a musician myself, I'd have put Sweet Mountain 3 a lot higher. Not necessarily because of the music itself, but just 'cause it does a really good job taking what the original did and building on it with little new ideas -- without going so far that it turns into a tug of war between the old and the new.
It just does what a remix is supposed to do very well, and I guess I appreciate that.
And to me Wisp 2 feels more like a new "Wisp" track than it feels like a remix of the old act 2. While they've got some of the same parts, they're mixed into the song in a way that feels so completely different that comparing it to the original act 2 feels almost like comparing the original act 2 song to act 1 or act 3.
It manages to do that without feeling like it's fighting itself the way the act 1 remix did, which is nice I suppose.
And, yeah, Terminal Velocity 1 blew me away too, the moment it started up :)
Yeah I agree, along with act 1 that fixes the problems all of the original version of sweet mountain.
Bro complained about planet wisp act 1
I think the problem with the sweet mountain remixes is the midi trumpets
They're terrible in the mix. Completely overpower the other instruments.
Egg nega wisp phase 1 sounds like a final boss in a kingdom hearts game
out all the remixes in the game definitely aquarium park
I think Mr Pasquale's Music of Sonic Colors Ultimate give a good example of Colors Ultimate music for how okay (not bad or good) these remixes sounds like.
Reach for the stars recolored might have been my favorite ngl
Termonal velocity is really the best remix and better than the Original.
Of course turmail velocity would be high on the list...
Sonic Fans when SEGA were planning to sell Super Sonic DLC in Forces for 1$: *TERRIBLE! WHAT A DISGRACE!*
Sonic Fans when SEGA sold 3 crappy Planet Wisp remixes for 5$: *This is fine*
LMAO THATS TRUE, it's also 2 bucks
I wonder how many people paid real money for that music DLC, only to disable it later (assuming they even knew they could).
You can't even disable it. When I bought the game on PS4 I made sure not to get digital deluxe and to just buy the Movie Aura separately.
@@ChannelPup You can disable the DLC in the DLC shop. That's what I heard, anyway. I never actually bought the music pack, so I never found out myself.
@@mistersp3753 I tried doing that on Xbox, and when trying to boot the game back up, it staight up uninstalled the entire game.
So maybe don't for Xbox.
i agree with you on most of this except all of planet wisps tracks, they are all at the top for me with act 2 being the best
Starlight Carnival Act 2 is one of the best on my opinion. Planet Wisp Act 2 is my favorite.
Never beat asteroid coaster as a kid so the mix for that boss + all of terminal velocity were my first experiences with those
Sonic colors be like: welcome to this amusement park we will help you with your tracks. Sonic colors ultimate be like: oh my god this is too shiny this needs to not be so shiny I’m getting a seizure.
like, tomoya ohtani isnt the only composer for sonic games, just saying xd
I FUKING LOVE TERMINAL VELOCITY ITS SO GOOD AND UNDERRATED
terminal velocity = fast crazy gadget
Can I say I'm proud your helping those in Afghanistan
I knew act 1 of terminal velocity would win.
Been Waiting For This
I love this song
He won’t see this comment
I know exactly what you're trying to do, and I'm going to grant you the validation, but just this once.
@@ChannelPup what was I trying to do?
I prefer absolutely none of the remixes to the original, but some are pretty good still,
I bet Werehog Colors would have more of Takahito Eguchi or Larry Hochman in the opening cutscene, in which it is dark and dramatic.
The wheel bosses are Rotatatron and Refreshinator dude XD
Wait so are some of the remixes under a pay wall? I have the base game so I’m not sure what remixes are excluded.
No mention of Super Sonic?
when put footage of PW act 6 during Act 2 music (-:
Damnit Dog you beat me to making this video😡
Well if it makes you feel better, it's flopping hard.
I love Reach for the Stars
I actually don't think any of the new remixes are bad. Sure, some of them, like the Planet Wisp and Tropical Resort remixes, don't fit the levels as well as the original tracks did, but I don't really mind as long as they're a good listen. And yeah, there are definitely tracks that are better than the originals, like the Asteroid Coaster and Terminal Velocity remixes
In my opinion, I think the new version of Planet Wisp is better than the original. I know a lot of people prefer the piano from the original version, but I love how the new version got more beats
Cool....