Could Antonio Brown Have CTE? Doctor Reacts to Media Speculation
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 พ.ค. 2024
- UPDATE: Antonio Brown has been released by the New England Patriots
Antonio Brown has been released by the Oakland Raiders before their NFL season has even started. After all of the controversy surrounding Antonio Brown's behavior this offseason, many people have speculated if he has CTE (chronic traumatic encephalopathy).
FOLLOW ME:
b_sutterer?lang=en
REFERENCES:
-Asken BM, Sullan MJ, DeKosky ST, Jaffee MS, Bauer RM. Research Gaps and Controversies in Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy: A Review. JAMA Neurol. 2017;74(10):1255-1262.
-Stern RA, Daneshvar DH, Baugh CM, et al. Clinical presentation of chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Neurology. 2013;81(13):1122-1129.
DISCLAIMER: Content not intended to be taken as medical advice. Opinions are my own and do not represent those of my employer. I have not personally treated or evaluated the individual(s) discussed in this video. Content used with educational and transformative intent within Fair Use Guidelines
Content owned and produced by Brian Sutterer LLC 2019
#NFL #AntonioBrown - กีฬา
Something's wrong with him because after Burfict popped him, he's been acting a fool ever since
David Jenkins I’ve been saying that for the longest
that hit was disgusting.
INTOtheVOID11 Makes zero sense. Who do you think Tomlin is? A superhero?
Well ok let's say that he's got CTE after that hit... CTE is a chronic degenerative condition which means it won't make his behavior change immediately as you claim
@@dr.murder2690 sounds like we don't know enough about it yet to say that for certain, different cases could affect people differently. Also maybe the other guys who've been proven to hav3 CTE were actually exhibiting signs right away and nobody noticed because they were incremental changes or there was another factor in life that the behaviour was mistakenly attributed to. I think he's just being a modern day superstar athelete but it's possible
CTE and Florida Man is a scary combination.
Very
True😂😂🤣🤣
😂
This aged well
Hoping Vincent Jackson didn’t fall victim
2020 update he definitely does
Yeah he truly does
It just keeps getting worse
It’s sad bc he doesn’t want to believe it, he keeps tricking himself into thinking he’s ok
No doubt
After the runnin video just recently, ya for sure.
What about Aaron Hernandez? He had CTE at age 27
They showed his Brain and I was Horrified how bad it looked.
The Aaron Hernandez case would be deem an isolated incident given the lack of research and resources. It's STATISTICALLY insignificant. You should watch the entire video to avoid posting a poorly thought out rebuttal.
danilo ventura either way fool. If he had it at 27, there’s a good possibility AB has it too. The nigga ain’t dead so we won’t know.
many things can cause CTE and many cases of it will never impact anyone. Aaron’s LSD and PCP use could also have had something to do w/ it. Dude was allegedly a killer in his teens. Gettin paid doesn’t change you. Only makes you more of what you already are.
@@tionlover : Reread what I wrote and then articulate a cohesive thought my dude... The fuck is your position? I never said he may not be suffering from it, I merely stated that STATISTICALLY it would be highly unlikely. There've been more ball players diagnose with psychological issues as apposed to physiological...
Aaron Hernandez wasn’t even 30 and had “one of the worst cases” just saying
Aaron Hernandez's father used to regularly beat him as a child. As such his brain trauma may have started even before he started playing football.
I think Hernandez was hit way more than Brown
Tyler Sash is another that comes to my mind, killed himself at 27 and had severe CTE IIRC
Hernandez played tight end and brown played wide receiver. Te’s would be more at risk than wr’s
Blaine Gabbert #GabOnEm #HOF #GOAT you obviously didn’t see the hits brown was taking from the bengals.
My madden 20 player probably has cte, hes in his rookie year and has been sacked 8 times per game
Gassicus 😂
Ooof that’s tuff
Slide wtf
You have CTE for buying that shit game
jason asuncion lmaoooo
Play basketball. Much more money and an ankle injury is much better than a freaking brain injury.
Marl Kalone You're actually right...
I mean it depends on your abilities. Football is much more a show of athleticism, while basketball requires more skill. Obviously both require skill, but there's a level of finess that ball has that football just doesn't(except maybe as a quarterback) but I agree that the injuries are much healthier
Study finance, yes it's hard but if you make it to Bball you leverage your knowledge, if you don't you are still in finance, if that's too much maybe accounting.
@eoe123321 good pay but an insane amount of games. May be boring to certain athletes but if you like it then it's a great choice
eoe123321 baseball is harder to play, the chances of you becoming Giancarlo Stanton, Mike Trout and etc and landing a fat contract is slim. I’ll take my chances playing bball and getting millions.
Of course he has CTE along with probably 80% of the NFL. These men have been playing football and taking hits since they were 6 or 7 years old.
Boxers get hit more
Bad Cornflakes what does that have to do with anything? This isn’t a competition
Football players hit with far more force, a punch coming from an arm can not compare to sprinting full tilt and getting forcibly stopped.
@@forrestjones1986 yes sir you sre 100% right! Head on full body collisions.
@Avery Jones 🤣🤣
This aged well 2022
Anyone else here after AB took off his jersey and threw away his career?
2022 update it’s now set in stone
Love the empathy you have for the players, not only giving your professional opinion on the matter but also looking out for them personally. I’m sure plenty of people will still speculate about it being CTE but it really could be to the detriment of this person’s well-being at large. Thank you for sticking up for him (even though I hate his guts for joining the Pats! xD)
I’m a high school student who did a year long research project on CTE, as soon as he yelled at the gm this is the only answer that made sense
The first burfict hit gave him CTE and the second burfict hit gave him cerebral palsy.
The Abstract and he been running from the raiders since
And Burfict plays for the Raiders
What hit gave him the inability to speak properly ??? When did that hit happened???
rdw rdw way to be a douchebag
rdw rdw I have no doubt in my mind you’re a white male. As such, I would like for you to think about something that may or may not open your eyes.
Growing up, most people’s first teacher are their parents. Given the history of this country, it should come as no surprise if some black people aren’t the best as it relates to reading and writing.
Did you forget this country had anti-literacy laws aimed directly at blacks, making it illegal for us to read and write? I know some people are going to throw the excuse word around, but it should be seen as a testament that some of us have overcome the hatred of whites and have excelled despite the obvious hurdles.
I’ll end this and say it is really weak for to attack Antonio Brown when all you have to do is look right at the history of your people.
Tom Brady will now play until 90
Omar Rafati lmao
Donte Fonville no you’re wrong he’ll play until he’s 322
crypt swan I was making the chain, wasn’t trying to be funny.
Yep
Infinity at max
It's 2022. Stripping on the sideline and quitting mid-game is fairly "erratic" and "impulsive". I hope he seeks help.
We see semi-nude fans streak the field all the time. They never played football. They likely don’t have CTE. As doc said, it’s important to not ignore other mental issues AB may have that CAN be treated.
@@NT-or9wh
You wrote: "We see semi-nude fans streak the field all the time." *All the time?* It actually seems rare to me, so I Googled: "Do fans streak at sporting events often". Google would like to know my location, lol.😉 If you can find data that backs up your claim, that would be helpful, bc I couldn't find any data on the frequency of streaking. Also, he didn't just strip. He quit his multi-million-dollar job.
I'm also unclear about why you wrote that CTE can't be treated. It can't be officially diagnosed or cured, but it can certainly be treated. There are Alzheimer medications available to treat memory loss, behavioral therapy available to treat mood swings, meditation techniques available to treat impulsive cognition problems, and pain medications available to treat headaches, according to the Cleveland Clinic and Alzheimer Association. We don't just throw 25-year-old men away due to health issues.
Look what Happened to Junior Seau WE HAD NO IDEA!
I'm a MA and a big time sports fan. This channel is fun and interesting. Thanks for the content
@MotorcycleMan Medical assistant
MotorcycleMan motorcycles are gay
Several years ago 3 current and former NHL players committed suicide. There was a lot of talk about CTE being involved. Would love to see a video on that
Yes the old school enforcers the blamed it on painkillers and alcohol but there has to be more to it
I was legitimately thinking he might have CTE.
Did you not watch the video???
@@yungsammysosa6201 It was before I watched the video obviously.
He very well could have it. Chris Henry was 26 and Aaron Hernandez was 27 and they both had it when they died.
Rashad Paige nah it’s called “the way to become a free agent” he just created a blueprint.
@@bruceguillory2453 that's FACTS!
Who’s here after he got released by the patriots
Who’s here cause he turned himself into the police 😂
@@blackopsbros1234 bruhhhh😂😂
Bear fan here. Our Dave Duerson acted similarly during his final years...
As a Pat’s fan. I’m watching this after we Acquired him. Thank you Doc for the wonderful content.
Why am I just seeing this !!!!!! Thank you for making this video
First question I asked myself after he walked off the field mid-game yesterday.
Whether he has cte or not he could still have a traumatic brain injury
This channel is gold
Thank you Doctor
Who else is here after the meltdown after the New York Jets- Tampa Bay game?
Really loved the way you presented everything. I’ve had four Grade 3 concussions, one with a seizure. so out of interest I read up on CTE in the NFL and NHL. He’s an outlier but Aaron Hernandez was diagnosed with Stage 3 CTE at 27 with no recorded concussions in the NFL.
Will forever love these videos
Best channel I have subscribed in a long time. Good job doc.
Thanks!
He definitely has Major issues he’s very unstable
We keep getting even young high school athletes coming into clinic for concussions, some with really slow progress. It kinda makes me glad I didn’t play football in high school.
Are you glad you don't travel in any type of vehicle? Have you decided to walk everywhere you go yet? Are you encouraging kids not to go to school because random school shootings that results in death? Lmao. It's 101 things you do consistently with more risk than football everyday my genuis and cautious friend. I can continue with things such as the food you eat, air you breathe, exercises, location, and even the sex you have.
Adnan A that was me a week ago:( I can’t play anymore
flyazzplayboy the difference is with football, you can pretty much guarantee your brain is going to be affected negatively, it’s a matter of how badly your brain is affected
@@flyazzplayboy guess i might as well do heroin because everything is dangerous yeah?
@@schizoposting My point was people pick and choose different things to do that's dangerous everyday without much thought. Again the perfect example is driving, I don't hear many people saying I'll never drive or ride again, when it's actually more dangerous than football... And oh yeah, those same type of people put their love ones in cars as infants.
Thank you for your informative advice!
Very relevant today
I am a Steelers fan and I am sorry to say that this makes sense
It was all a game to get released and sign with the Patriots....
He's not even close to intelligent enough to come up with such a plan, and too emotionally child-like to actually put it in action.
@@nickstl77 So just dumb luck that he acts bizarre gets released from a terrible team and gets signed by the best team the same day? Too coincidental...he wanted out maybe not specifically the Patriots but a SB contending team
@@nickstl77 if he acts like a normal person in nwe then it was a scam
@@nickstl77 He doesnt have to, Bill could do everything for him.
😂
Love your videos. Godspeed
WOW....Well said!
Any chance youd do a 6 month update on this with his behavior just getting more wild
Damn I never thought of CTE as a possibility
You never thought that a sport that routinely encourages players to play through concussions very early on in their life (teens-early 20's) might give someone severe brain damage?
Agreed, you make great videos.
I love that you can get better commentary and analysis about something like this on TH-cam compared to a professional news organization like ESPN
This title made me laugh😂😂
Erik Pelle was 18 years old when he died after his 4th concussion. His Brian was filled with gathered tau protein and it was determined he had CTE. He had only made it to High school football, so let us not dismiss this In Antonio Brown because he is young.
I agree he left in the middle of a game today 90 percent of nfl players have it
Yo long time viewer here just gotta say your beats in the videos are always fire
Thanks! All from epidemic sound
I love and truly appreciate how much he advocates for mental health
Us: does AB have CTE?
Patriots: sign him!
Hey Brian I know this isn’t “sports related” but I was wondering if you could make a video pertaining to Kevin Hart’s recent car accident and explain his injuries that have been reported, Thank You.
Need a part 2
Been here since 13k !!! So proud
Woo appreciate you!!
Update: AB just got released from the Pats 😕
Tee P good
Update: super bowl champion with the bucs
What about Aaron Hernandez? He was relatively young and his behavior was incredibly erratic. I don’t know if Antonio Brown is just going through a phase, using harmful drugs, or if he has CTE but there is something there and I truly hope that he gets the help that he needs.
He was brutally beaten as a child
Like the back ground music at the intro
Good videos cause you bring understanding to CTE but at the same time you dont say he does or does not have
Thanks !
The film on it of the famous dr from Nigeria, great film
ab is not all the way there, he should be checked out ASAP!!
HotHandz Hammond there’s not way to be checked for CTE unless you are dead.
Can you do a video on conditioning? Similar to JCVD "breaking" his leg kicking down a tree (I think in kickboxer). From my understanding conditioning is good as the hard bone can come back stronger, but once the soft bone is affected there is a point of no return resulting in irreparable damage to the bone structure.
Saef Ali It works but it causes mad arthritis and shit later
Informative. Thank you.
Can we bring this up again for AB after his recent walkout possibly?
This is too logical, i was hoping for a case to tell me that Brown may have this
Points very well taken, Dr. Sutterer! We ought to be careful about tossing around such weighty, diagnostic terms like CTE. Also, whether or not he has CTE - determined at some point in the future, when he's passed away - may not really matter as far as the present is concerned. Still, I do worry that AB has some neurological condition, not just from the Burfict hit but also from regular football play, that's steadily worsening and affecting his behavior. So while we cannot diagnose CTE in living people, there are powerful tools available right now to examine how well the brain is functioning. e.g. Would a PET scan, or other neurological tests, be useful in AB's case? How about a full-on psychiatric examination as well, as you suggest? After you posted your video, the New England signed AB immediately after his release, so it's on that organization to look further, if it wishes, into what was really going on with AB, i.e. behaviorally, mentally and neurologically. Perhaps AB himself should request such an examination - for the sake of his health and career - so something can be done, if in fact there is any abnormality, however small.
do the raiders player head injury from last night doc! that guys thigh went down right onto the top of his head... scary.
I been saying this a long time ago!!!
so my question is, if u meet someone late in their years that have cte, would u technically not really know the real person that they are. and basically you have sort of a different relationship with them than what u would if they didn't have cte? like you would know a completely different person than what their childhood friends or school friends know? idk weird question... my bad
Not sure why you'd apologize for that, it's an interesting thought
Crown Royalty93 Don't apologize. This is actually a very good question that can apply to other mental illnesses too.
Electric Wolf i met an old middle school friend a few weeks back, wasn't the same person he use to be. he was hilarious, always brightened the room. could put a smile on a grumpy old mans face. when i met him he was rude, no personality, seemed agitated about a lot of things. than his sister told me he suffered a few concussions from all his years of boxing. brain injury's are so intresting
Good job Doc! By the way, is your blood pressure high? I’m asking because I noticed your ears are red. Every time my blood pressure sky rockets......I swear I can feel my ears getting hot.
Here’s a question I have after watching your video.Do you think there could be a correlation between Alzheimer’s and head injuries in a patients life? I’m just wondering how many doctors ask early stage Alzheimer’s patients or their families if they’ve ever had head injuries in the past and how many? CTE has brought up these reverse questions for me. Is Alzheimer’s really a change in brain chemistry or is it the result of trauma?
Aaaaand he just got signed to the Pat's. His tantrums were probably all staged so he could get to NE. Whata joke
Louis palko I’m sorry but that is the dumbest thing I have heard
@@liltequito4167 Not really, its actually super smart on ABs part. He gets a bag at NE and a ring, probaly
Chronic Super_yt no it’s not, who wants to play for the raiders when you could play for a team like the pats
You’re giving him way too much credit. He’s just an idiot with a big ego. He wouldn’t have allowed a trade to the raiders to begin with if that was the case..
Frederik Brandt he wanted to get traded to the pats but the Steelers wouldn’t trade him there thus they traded him to the raiders. He acted up there to get his way it doesn’t seem that crazy
He hasn’t been the same since that hit from Burfict in the Wildcard game
very good information i still think ab is showing early signs tho.
Medical student here and I have been practicing boxing for 3 years. Could you make a video about boxing and cte or other neurodegenerative diseases? I think many people would be interested and there is few info available. Do you think that someone could have some of the cte symptoms on a small degree from a young age?
“The only people who know what’s going on in Antonio Brown’s head are Antonio Brown and his physicians” after just explaining that we have no test to diagnose CTE in the living.
Aaron Hernandez had it and he only played like 4 years
I think Hernandez was badly beaten often as a kid. Football was just the icing
Robert Cooper it is pretty safe to assume that Hernandez did not require the disease during his time in the NFL, the disease had reached a far too advanced stage when he was found dead. It would be very unlikely that CTE developed at such a quick rate, so it’s more likely that he had already picked it up before he was drafted.
@@schululalala6212 We honestly don't know when he got the disease and how far it can progress
@@jayceonkelly7709 yea he did.
Bc of him being beaten as a child, not football
I like how the bandaid is over his angular gyrus.
Aaron had 2 concussions in high school like out cold type of head injuries.
Yeah you just avoided speaking about Chris Henry. You don't have to be retired to have cte.
Alex Googlehead yep Henry was 23 I believe. It can advance early. Depends on every individual.
SmittyStrikesAgain Also the years they played and the positions they played. Some positions are head banging every play.
So basically: "I don't know"
With that hair you’re looking like David Lynch, man! I like it.
Thanks for being professional and not just throwing around the ‘CTE’ speculation on this man, let’s give him some respect in that way
What's funny is I've gotten some comments saying I should have my license taken away for this video...idk if people just don't watch it or what but I thought I was being appropriate :/
He's straight up borderline personality. He's like my ex-wife. Everything is great UNTIL the switch is flipped, something happens and nothing is acceptable.
AB will be fine there for a few weeks. Then he won't be.
All women have that switch
Damn grown ass males talking like this about women they ain't love you prob
I doubt cte started when he got that big hit. He most likely had it few years from all those small hits in his career it’s just that big hit really brought problems
2:02
I see you’re a man of culture and watch ChubbyEmu videos, as well
I saw the right side of AB's face distorted and kind of dented on videos before the season began.
What hair product do you use? I'm trying to get hair like that.
No cap
He uses Sea Men
@@foodmens Funny
Lol blumaan pre and clay
@@BrianSuttererMD Thanks, man. You should get them to sponsor your videos.
Welp, you have Aaron Hernandez for example
2022 update he definitely does
Yes. No more questions.
I ONLY BEEN SAYING THIS SENSE A BLACK MAN FROM THE HOOD DYES HIS MUSTACHE BLONDE CLEARLY HES NOT RIGHT MENTALLY DAT VONTAZE HIT HE TOOK WAS SERIOUS!!!
EXACTLY
Well he had a concussion in the 2015 playoffs I say prob
The more & more he does the more I believe this video
Just so you know, I'm the one that started the CTE speculation about AB a few weeks ago. I asked the question on numerous youtube threads when no one else was even commenting or considering it
Want a cookie?
No, all his shenanigans with the Raiders were part of an elaborate plan to sign with the Patriots.
He hired social media consultants to find out how to get released as fast as possible.
Still believe that?
Nathanial Meagher did he hire social media to get kicked off the Patriots too?
Short answer: Yes
No, he’s just an idiot. He’s been the exact same way with the Steelers but they were better at keeping it indoors. People were just too oblivious to see that Antonio Brown is just a talented clown with a huge ego.
Dont know if you have done one but you should make a vid on how Mathew stafford could have played the last 4 games last year with a fractured back. True fact
Phillip Adams is the most recent major CTE case.
99% of NFL players have CTE.
I was starting to believe something might be wrong w/A.B., but then he agreed to a contract with the Pats while the ink on his Release paperwork from the Raiders was still wet... In hindsight, his behavior w/the Raiders now seems more like a ploy to get the move he really wanted
I was gonna say this too...he's taking some real shots through his career
Doc this might not be the place but I need some advice I’m super athletic and this weird thing has been happening to my right lower leg for sometime now feels like a gnarly cramp but not almost feels like a tear but not. Ever time I run I feel like I been shot in my leg right under my calf hobbles me for 4 or 5 days goes away then next time I try and job it happen again. No one knows anything HELP🤪