I wish I found an archive with their videos, so I could pluck out that part. It wasn't straight from the movie, there were those tiny sounds of bells right after "Mordor", and the sound design was just different.
Loved this, thank you for crafting it! The one section I didn't quite follow was the period after Gondor's reconquista of Umbar in III.1810, which you describe as one of Gondorian neglect. I've always thought that Umbar must have been fortified and resumed being a bastion of Gondorian strength, given the relatively free hand later kings and commanders of Gondor felt they had during the long Wainrider Wars. A free hand, as in they were less concerned about the southern borders of the kingdom. There's a couple of references to this dynamic in 'Cirion and Eorl', published in Unfinished Tales. Anyway, awesome video and I'm looking forward to exploring more of them!
I’m re watching every video you posted I’ll be honest I’ve watched Lotr about 5 time threw and watched hobbit 3 time threw and I played the 2 lego games and I thought why not learn everything I can I don’t really watch tv anymore but hey you live you learn you laugh
First lore video for the new start! The new intro is different from the old one but refreshing and epic. Umbar is one of my favourite factions throughout the ages of Middle-Earth, and you guys have made it sound much more heavenly and descriptive, rather than the evil and dirty corsairs we saw in the movies. I feel like there is definitely some difference between this new channel and HotA. Keep up the great work and continue providing us with such enjoyable and reliable videos!
Can you tell us more about the Land of the Sun towards east of middle earth and the Dark Lands? Thank you for taking time to share stories of the places and characters of Tolkien's stories.
"Civil War" - I stumbled on the Brohirrim about two days before the evolution to TBS. What magic lay here that I immediately bought a HOTA sweatshirt? I'll be supporting on Patreon soon as well. You guys rock, thank you for this comfy place.
Finnaly the KINGS HAVE RETURNED, great video but can you pls sometimes use Build me an army....Aragorns line is magnificent but Build me an....has becomed your classic, CIVIL WAR!!!
I’m super glad to hear that older content will still be covered along with new, I loved all of it as soon as I found the old channel, so I can’t wait for what is to come
Wow, I am so glad you will continue your content over lotr. It is amazing. The quality of the video video was wonderful and even tho it always is quite a lot to take in, at least two things always stick with me. I found the banner in the bottom left a bit distracting, though could live with it. I don't know how much effort it makes to somehow link the artwork otherwise, but I thought I'd give some feedback in this awesome video.
I feel like you should start back at the beginning with the music of illuvitar, valar, melkor, the forming of arda, and things like that.....just one fan’s opinion
I agree, and they do it in chronological order like you said. Although, I doubt this would happen since the most popular videos would be made first. And the most popular videos tend to be about characters from the main movies, for example the most viewed video of the old channel if I am not mistaken was “what was thranduil doing before and after lotr?”
Civil War I miss the entro. Good luck with the new channel. If Aragorn hadn't put fear into the enemy, and respect in his allies the second time he destroyed their fleet wouldn't have been as awesome.
A very interesting subject. This was one of your last videos, right? I also hear a lot of fairly new things. I think I have read everything. But where do I read more about Umbar's past and, for example, the Kin Strife? Surely that will be mainly in the 'HoMe' books or appendices if I remember? Thanks guys
Well done! (video and new channel)! and Godspeed looking ahead for great lotr lore. Greatly appreciated your tremendous focus and efforts (the last year especially- covid and everything ) on the little or gentle good things of life- for me, Lord of the Rings lore, and a sense of wonder and imagination vs a world crazy with fears and greed. It has been live saving to get away from all the crap in the world by sojourn in Middle Earth :) and I am grateful for your dedication and ability to overcome and adapt. Looking forward to more opportunities to sojourn in Middle Earth! And as requested- civil war. The line is held! The Broken Sword!
@Tree Star I agree. But there are so many people who haven’t subscribed to this channel from the old one. I’m having a hard time understanding that one.
@The Broken Sword And to ruse from the ashes, HOTA develops into a Beautiful, Stunning, Powerful & Magical weapon as fierce as Narsil ever was!!! Missed you Guys!! I am SO happy that you are back!! I've never pressed the Subscribe Button so fast!
I had always thought that the fragility of the Gondor egos were ripe for harvesting a rebellious civil war that would hurt itself more than provide a solid shield wall that could defend the lands, as was their promise.
I think if the umbaran (umbarian? umbaren?) fleet had not been destroyed by aragorn in many years before the siege of minas tirith, the losses unflicted on gondor’s coastline by the corsairs would have been more devastating, and perhaps pelargir could have been captured or maybe even destroyed. In the end, it might not have entirely made a difference as Aragorn and the grey company do lead an enormous OP ghost army that is essentially invincible, so I don’t think minas tirith would have fallen. However, I think if the corsairs had the naval power they had before Aragorn burned it all down, they probably would have been raiding gondor’s coastline many years earlier, and before the time when the council of Elrond takes place. Since Gondor was already busy defending against Sauron’s forces on land by osgilith and guerilla-style in “occupied” ithilien, they might have been stretched too thin and perhaps could have lost pelargir, really weakening Gondor. In terms of gondor’s long-term survival, I think it could be argued that aragorn’s raid proved a wise decision.
Umbar and it's occupation and amalgamation into the Dunedain of the south is the center piece of the Sea Kings of Gondor, also the rivalry between Dol Amroth and Umbar is ancient.
For a city that we never see in the lord of the rings a lot happened there. I hope we see it in the Prime series. I love the new design and labels on the pictures.
We've just hit 2000 likes!! Civil war video will be coming in the next few weeks :D
The blade that's was broken wil return in all his splender as in the old days and It wil reunite the people of arnor and Gondor
I love narsil :)
And here I was about to post Civil War in the comments. Nice one!
Link?
civil wat let´s goo!!
Gondor and their conflict with the Haradrim, umbar and corsairs is perfect material for films and series! Good job Good Job!
YES!!! You are back!!! I was horrified... like HORRIFIED when you disappeared from TH-cam. SO GLAD YOU ARE BACK!!!
Durin be with you, brothers!
I miss ‘Build me an army, Worthy of Mordor’ but it just goes with the changeover I suppose. But I shall miss it.
I wish I found an archive with their videos, so I could pluck out that part. It wasn't straight from the movie, there were those tiny sounds of bells right after "Mordor", and the sound design was just different.
Same but the new one will grow on us in time.
@@crabbuckets7506 No
:D
@@ReiyaLintense ok ok my bad bruh chill 🤣
Perhaps that was exactly what caused one of the strikes 🤔
"Civil war"
I would also like to see the video of the lesser known villains of lotr!
Loved this, thank you for crafting it! The one section I didn't quite follow was the period after Gondor's reconquista of Umbar in III.1810, which you describe as one of Gondorian neglect. I've always thought that Umbar must have been fortified and resumed being a bastion of Gondorian strength, given the relatively free hand later kings and commanders of Gondor felt they had during the long Wainrider Wars. A free hand, as in they were less concerned about the southern borders of the kingdom. There's a couple of references to this dynamic in 'Cirion and Eorl', published in Unfinished Tales. Anyway, awesome video and I'm looking forward to exploring more of them!
The real fans have already gathered here. I'm sure our other fellows will follow. Happy to start again on a fresh page, Let's goooooo!!!
I came across your TH-cam content, and let me say I love your videos. I’m starting from here and going to watch every single one. Day by day. 😁
Congratulations on releasing your first video on the new channel, I really enjoyed it o7 Oh, and CIVIL WAR please ; )
Civil War
I miss "Build me an army worthy of Mordor"😓
funny thing, I TOTALLY heard it at the beginning!
@@FlyingAxblade_D20 ditto
Yes!! Such a relief to have this content back once again. Onwards and upwards lads :)
:D
Glad you guys are back!!!! Civil War!
Civil war
Happy to support you guys. Your content is aces.
Great to have you guys back. Once more unto the breach and forward unto dawn, we ride.
Please civil war you are awesome. So far you have done videos i haven't seen anywhere else. people dont understand how the little storys mean so much
Just happy you guys are back
'Civil War'
So happy you guys are pushing forward. Love your videos.
Thanks! :)
I’m re watching every video you posted I’ll be honest I’ve watched Lotr about 5 time threw and watched hobbit 3 time threw and I played the 2 lego games and I thought why not learn everything I can I don’t really watch tv anymore but hey you live you learn you laugh
"Civil War"
Just found this channel, and I am very glad about it. I'm off binging everything now ;-)
Glad you're enjoying the content 😊
Civil war.
So pleased your back.
So glad you guys are back!
Glad to be back! :)
First lore video for the new start! The new intro is different from the old one but refreshing and epic. Umbar is one of my favourite factions throughout the ages of Middle-Earth, and you guys have made it sound much more heavenly and descriptive, rather than the evil and dirty corsairs we saw in the movies. I feel like there is definitely some difference between this new channel and HotA. Keep up the great work and continue providing us with such enjoyable and reliable videos!
Only just found this chaps, but have resubscribed on here. Good luck with this channel.
Thank you 😊
Can you tell us more about the Land of the Sun towards east of middle earth and the Dark Lands? Thank you for taking time to share stories of the places and characters of Tolkien's stories.
Good Luck Guys.....
I almost watched all the videos on your previous channel. Your hardwork will not be wasted. Keep doing this guys...
❤❤❤
Investing in crypto now should be in every wise individuals list, in some months time you'll be ecstatic with the decision you made today
For more information and question contract 👇👇👇👇 WhatsApp
★±1*★7*★6*★0*★5*★8*★9*★*9★0*★8*★0*
Thank you!
King Earnil launching a surprise attack on Umbar, doesnt paint Gondor in a favourable light!
It does make the 'men' more human, though! ^.^
Gondor acting like the real life western Imperialist states. *"Umbar needs some democracy"* lol
Yeah, but it turned into a satanic Theocracy... one knows such things.
@@Aurora2097 satanic? You mean worshiping Morgoth?
@@_semih_ load the freedom catapults!!!
"Civil War" - I stumbled on the Brohirrim about two days before the evolution to TBS. What magic lay here that I immediately bought a HOTA sweatshirt? I'll be supporting on Patreon soon as well. You guys rock, thank you for this comfy place.
Thank you so much for the support! :)
Finnaly the KINGS HAVE RETURNED, great video but can you pls sometimes use Build me an army....Aragorns line is magnificent but Build me an....has becomed your classic, CIVIL WAR!!!
There are no rains of Castamir.
Jokes beside, great topic, great video!
Lol . And now the rayens weep or there hall with not a soul to hear.
I really like the new opening. Happy that you have started a “new” channel and I look forward to the excellent new content.
Civil War.
Civil war. Welcome back❤
Civil War would be an interesting video. I hope this channel grows as strong as the old channel.
🤞🤞🤞
Civil War and welcome back
Oh yeah! The golden years of Gondor! Almost a reflection of old Númenor. Great work!
"Civil War"
Would like to see a video on that.
I’m super glad to hear that older content will still be covered along with new, I loved all of it as soon as I found the old channel, so I can’t wait for what is to come
good luck on the new channel boys, liked and shared
Investing in crypto now should be in every wise individuals list, in some months time you'll be ecstatic with the decision you made today
For more information and question contract 👇👇👇👇 WhatsApp
★±1*★7*★6*★0*★5*★8*★9*★*9★0*★8*★0*
Thanks!
In the war of the ring , the corsair fleet was large enough to transport 5 thousand men , it must have been a considerable fleet.
Great to see ya guys back. Would love to see more about the Civil War
Wow, I am so glad you will continue your content over lotr. It is amazing.
The quality of the video video was wonderful and even tho it always is quite a lot to take in, at least two things always stick with me. I found the banner in the bottom left a bit distracting, though could live with it.
I don't know how much effort it makes to somehow link the artwork otherwise, but I thought I'd give some feedback in this awesome video.
Civil War! I am glad to see you guys rebound from the HOA channel take done. Thanks!
I love all the new graphics and the new channel so far. So excited for the new content. I hope you do more on these lesser known areas and events 😁
Glad you're enjoying the content 😊
CIVIL WAR
keep the great content coming
Good luck lads, and brilliant start off to hopefully another very successful TH-cam channel
Much appreciated! :)
Glad to see that you're back--great content, as always. A video on the civil war, please.
I feel like you should start back at the beginning with the music of illuvitar, valar, melkor, the forming of arda, and things like that.....just one fan’s opinion
I agree, and they do it in chronological order like you said.
Although, I doubt this would happen since the most popular videos would be made first. And the most popular videos tend to be about characters from the main movies, for example the most viewed video of the old channel if I am not mistaken was “what was thranduil doing before and after lotr?”
Civil War
I miss the entro. Good luck with the new channel.
If Aragorn hadn't put fear into the enemy, and respect in his allies the second time he destroyed their fleet wouldn't have been as awesome.
Welcome back! So happy to see you in YT again and please do "Civil War"
Thanks! Glad to be back :)
Great video as always! I would love a video about the beginnings of Rohan and how they came to be allies with Gondor through the ages.
Good to see you guys back 🤘
Glad to be back! :)
Thank you, the Second Age lore is pretty scarce and this fills in some holes.
Very good!
Can't wait for your history on the Civil War!
Loving the look of the video, glad to have you guys back.
Glad to be back :)
I'm so used to the old intro, but this one is even better! : )
I wish you guys all the best with the new channel! :)
Oh and i‘d love to hear about the gondor civil war!
well done guys :) fab as always
A very interesting subject. This was one of your last videos, right?
I also hear a lot of fairly new things. I think I have read everything. But where do I read more about Umbar's past and, for example, the Kin Strife? Surely that will be mainly in the 'HoMe' books or appendices if I remember?
Thanks guys
Well done! (video and new channel)! and Godspeed looking ahead for great lotr lore. Greatly appreciated your tremendous focus and efforts (the last year especially- covid and everything ) on the little or gentle good things of life- for me, Lord of the Rings lore, and a sense of wonder and imagination vs a world crazy with fears and greed. It has been live saving to get away from all the crap in the world by sojourn in Middle Earth :) and I am grateful for your dedication and ability to overcome and adapt. Looking forward to more opportunities to sojourn in Middle Earth! And as requested- civil war. The line is held! The Broken Sword!
Thank you so much! 😊
Can’t wait for new 10k subs live streams!
@Tree Star you are very right.
@Tree Star I agree. But there are so many people who haven’t subscribed to this channel from the old one. I’m having a hard time understanding that one.
It's great to see you guys back!
Investing in crypto now should be in every wise individuals list, in some months time you'll be ecstatic with the decision you made today.
For more information and question contract 👇👇👇 WhatsApp
@The Broken Sword
And to ruse from the ashes, HOTA develops into a Beautiful, Stunning, Powerful & Magical weapon as fierce as Narsil ever was!!! Missed you Guys!!
I am SO happy that you are back!! I've never pressed the Subscribe Button so fast!
😁😁😁
The lords of Lore have returned. Great videos lay ahead.
"Civil War" And is good to have you back here on TH-cam. Best of luck in the future. 😍❤👍
Thanks! 😊
Its weird to not hear Build me an army, Worthy of Mordor but i am so happy that you are back and couldn't wait to see videos of you!
Narrator: "Hello and welcome..."
Me: *Sheds a tear of joy*
The channel is finally back on their feet! :D
:D
Civil War. Also, glad to see you guys are back :)
I'm so excited! civil war
Investing in crypto now should be in every wise individuals list, in some months time you'll be ecstatic with the decision you made today
For more information and question contract 👇👇👇👇👇 WhatsApp
★±1*★7*★6*★0*★5*★8*★9*★*9★0*★8*★0*
Great work, guys! Here we go racing back to 300K!
A video on the Civil War would be great!
Civil War
I love your content and I love anything about the Black Numenoreans keep up the great work and please make more on the Black Numenoreans.
Civil war. Love the content guys. Glad you're back!
Thanks! Glad to be back! 😊
Good luck on your new endeavor!
Investing in crypto now should be in every wise individuals list, in some months time you'll be ecstatic with the decision you made today
+1=7=6=0=5=8=9=9=0=8=0
The best of luck with the new channel, and all the videos you make.
Thank you very much!
"Civil war"
These videos of middle earth are my #1 morning ride to work listen.
Thank you guys for citing the artwork! Looking forward to your future vids!
Great first video! Excited for more
welcome back guys the video was awesome civil war
Thanks Jamie :)
Civil war.... Good going on this Number vid. Lots of great info.
Glad to help you rebuild!
I wish you guys all the best in the reincarnation of your awesome channel.
"Civil War"
Thank you! :)
Welcome back!!!
Thanks :)
Yes! to the "Gondorian civil war". This was a great video.
Oh thanks for the reupload, I haven't watched this yet.
Hope you enjoy it! :)
Civil War video sounds cool!
Much interested in the civil war video!
The legends are back 🙏
I had always thought that the fragility of the Gondor egos were ripe for harvesting a rebellious civil war that would hurt itself more than provide a solid shield wall that could defend the lands, as was their promise.
The blade that was broken; shall be reforged. - a nice intro
civil war
It's great that we have you here again guys
Thanks! :)
I think if the umbaran (umbarian? umbaren?) fleet had not been destroyed by aragorn in many years before the siege of minas tirith, the losses unflicted on gondor’s coastline by the corsairs would have been more devastating, and perhaps pelargir could have been captured or maybe even destroyed. In the end, it might not have entirely made a difference as Aragorn and the grey company do lead an enormous OP ghost army that is essentially invincible, so I don’t think minas tirith would have fallen. However, I think if the corsairs had the naval power they had before Aragorn burned it all down, they probably would have been raiding gondor’s coastline many years earlier, and before the time when the council of Elrond takes place. Since Gondor was already busy defending against Sauron’s forces on land by osgilith and guerilla-style in “occupied” ithilien, they might have been stretched too thin and perhaps could have lost pelargir, really weakening Gondor. In terms of gondor’s long-term survival, I think it could be argued that aragorn’s raid proved a wise decision.
"Civil War" Thanks for the video!
Man i love the content of smaller channels
What is the name of the song you guys use for this video?
What's the gondor civil war content called? Your at 5.3 k now lol I need to watch it!😁
Starting again means that I get to see some of the videos I missed the first time round.
Can you make a video about Angmar. Like I know of the Witch King of Angmar but what and where is angmar and why is it soo feared?
Umbar and it's occupation and amalgamation into the Dunedain of the south is the center piece of the Sea Kings of Gondor, also the rivalry between Dol Amroth and Umbar is ancient.
Civil War please
also can you make a playlist about the individual tribes of men?
Sorry to learn you have to completely rebuild. I’ve subscribed and would like to see a video of the CIVIL WAR.
Thank you! 😊
For a city that we never see in the lord of the rings a lot happened there. I hope we see it in the Prime series. I love the new design and labels on the pictures.
"CIVIL WAR"
.
.
.
.
.
.
Civil war, please.