Polaris Ranger XD 1500 VS. Can-Am Defender Limited
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ก.ค. 2024
- In today's video, Jay takes us around the 2023 Can-Am Defender Limited donated by Agee Farms. We take time to go through each machine throughly and see how the Defender stack up to the ALL NEW 2024 XD 1500 from @PolarisORV
Interstate 69 Motorsports - Home of the Best Value in the USA!
1703 West Main Street
Union City TN 38261
731-885-1792
i69motorsports.com - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
I noticed nothing mention about price.. Defender MSRP 29900.. Ranger XD MSRP 45000.. That in itself is beyond ridiculous. And what do you get for an extra 15k. 1 inch of extra ground clearance. Can change the air from your face to your feet. A power port in the bed. A slightly bigger bed. 1000lbs extra tow capacity and 500 extra payload. And a few other things that in my opinion dont justify an extra 15k. For that kind of money i can buy a small 4x4 pickup, put a 6 inch lift on it with some good AT tires and have WAY more towing more payload more comfortable and be able to drive it down the highway. It is a nice rig no doubt but way over priced.
You took the words right out of my mouth.
This not a good comparison.
My defender still rocking the same belt at 4,600 km. On 32” xtr 370 tire. Same a-arm bushings also. !!! Drove hard but well maintained
@@jimfleury6349How do those XTR370's ride? I got a Defender XMR and am looking at switching to those tires?
I only have 500 k on them so far running 11 lbs rides better than expected. No vibrations (after proper camber and alignment)
Great sidewall bite corners way better than stock bighorns just a little heavier tire. All in I really like them.
@@jimfleury6349 Ok I got some big, knobby stock mud tires on now and they ride pretty crappy on the trail. Probably switch to the 370's next year.
My buddy owns a dealer and they are selling every 1500 they can get
I have done extensive maintenance on can am and Polaris machines. A former trade that I did for many years I was a master mechanic. This youngster talking about packages is all fine and dandy. One thing he is not talking about is the huge price difference between the two. Polaris $45000 really. My experience the Can am products at least in the mountains of Wyoming hold up far superior to Polaris cheap mostly Chinese parts. If you buy Polaris you are buying a very high cost in maintenance. I for one am finished with Polaris.
I’m on my 3rd Defender and have never had one single problem with any!!💪💪💪
Just luck. their front-ends disitigrate, power-steering failures, shock-blowouts, & Diff failures are plauging them.
Should have mentioned the price comparison. Just think what you could do to the Defender with $15,000 of add-ons or upgrades.
I wouldn’t own another Polaris if they gave it to me!!
Yes you would if they gave it to you!!!
It’s definitely not a fair comparison and a big difference in the price a fair comparison would be a full enclosed cab Ranger Limited, or whatever you call it not the new 1500 which is a very expensive machine. A true comparison would be your lower version and not the 1500. Thank you.
Def should of mentioned the price differences
So he basically took a 45k loaded utv and picked out all the places that the canam didn’t have upgrades………. Poor attempt at bashing competition.
Great thorough comparison.
I'd take a can am any day over a piece of junk Polaris 💯😎👍
Who's #1 in sales
@@stevebishop4843 Polaris?
Is it bad ?
Polaris is like ford, they are so innovative but have more recalls and problems than any other.
Don’t forget to add the Polaris poor quality, poor reliability and an endless recalls.
The can ams ain't much better. Coolant issues and starting issues
@@Travidedo any of them have any quality anymore especially for the price you can get a pretty nice jeep
@@ML-bf7vwI mean sure but what good is a jeep to me? When ATVs are the only thing allowed in the trails in Newfoundland. Law was passed few year ago banning trucks etc in trails.
@@Travidethey will probably go after the atv’s next.
@@ML-bf7vwimagine thinking a jeep is a quality vehicle 🤡
Should be comparing the defender to a Northstar xp 1000 not the 1500
Thanks man
I will keep my polaris northstar ultimate and when that takes a shit I will buy a jeep gladiator polaris is pricing itself out of the market I have owned 6 polaris rangers and the one I have now is the last one period.
Do miss the Polaris Victory Brand Motorcycles. For these prices I'd take a dirt bike. Be interesting to see how pure BEV especially from Tesla starts to impact all of this ICE Platform effort. Kubota still rules to work segment but as for play USA versus Canada definitely game on absolutely.
My dealer carries brands and I looked at them over the weekend, the Polaris has a much quieter and sealed cab, the doors close tight and they also lock. The can am doors did not fit tight rattled and don’t lock. I did not like how far forward the can am doors open it’s like you had to step back and around to get in after you open the door. I’m sure Kenny is a more reliable machine but the Polaris seems to be a better design cab for hvac. If I wasn’t concerned with a COI would definitely probably go with the Can-Am.
Never mentioned defender glove box on driver side.
I own a 2019 Ranger XP 1000 Northstar with tracks for the winter. I use it up northern Alberta for work. I have never blown a belt, have changed out 2 for wear. Running tracks in deep snow is a big load on the CVT. I have had multiple clutch problems with it, some where recalls, a couple I had to pay for. Wheel Bearings now have all been changed. 1 rear axle was changed as it was making funny noises in the rear end. The Bushings in the mounts from sub frame to main frame have worn out 3 times. Just changed out the O2 sensor when it wouldn't start last week. In hind site, I should have bought extended warranty. I will be buying another brand next year or the year after. Maybe the new Kawasaki or I would like a Honda if they made a nice cab like Cam Am and Polaris. I work with guys running Defenders on tracks in the winter also. They have there issues too. The Defender does start at -38 C, Ranger is done at -32 C . I previously owned a 2009 Rhino Sport 700. Never used it in the winter due to no enclosed cab, but it was a great machine for 10 years, only replaced battery once, and did the wheel bearing and tie rod ends in year 10. Great machine but the engine noise drove me crazy. Polaris needs to pull their head out of there ass on the pricing of the new 1500, it is Ridiculous.
I just got eyes in the new Kawasaki. It’s a great looking machine. Things I liked. Rear hitch at level with box for easier hitch up. Nice seats. Control knobs for for hvac seemed good. Nice sounding engine. It purrred. Kawasaki quality. Normal doors not suicide which is dumb why other manufacturers do it I have no idea, front locking diff, Led headlights. . Don’t likes. No turf mode. Dinky tires. The rear tailgate felt flimsy both opening and closing. No pop out front window for more air flow. Lack of storage. Like basically none. No winch Canada model and no gps Canada model at same price point. So now I’m back looking at the canam. Moving to alberta soon. I do have a Polaris and I’m keeping that. The Polaris ranger asks a premium for stuff the canam has for 3k lower. But ranger is a bit smaller. I really wanted the Kawasaki but it fell short and to outfit it I basically should buy the Polaris North Star then.
What about the transmission and rear-end? I know the military hated Polaris for that.
I think it’s funny, Polaris has had endless issues while can am is still out working. I’m buying a side by side, not another truck.
love the po;aris. I have a 2019 1000 general. For the price difference i would take the can am
This comparison is like comparing ford vs Toyota reliability over gimmicks . Ranger makes accessory updates easier that’s it
Prices of sxs these days is ludicrous they are right there with automobiles prices
Exactly should be half their prices.
Great video but maybe you should compare two machines that are close in comparison!!!
Is isn’t quite apples to apples comparison without mentioning the price point
Above the drivers dash display the cover lifts up for USB ports and phone holder and I do believe a 12 volt power plug also. I just got a can am defender H9 2023 base price was 19,900. Add the other sealed cab parts, windshield, doors, blinkers, back window. Heater and other stuff to it and price goes to 32 k this doesn't include the pod lights, stereo backup lights, and other features as a pavement queen wants in her UTV ( my wife) for trail, road and farm use. If you add all the extras up the price is ridiculously stupid. She could have just jacked up a small pickup truck. I said it when I bought it at the dealership and will say it again Can Am your paying for the name. Ironically I have a Honda 700-4 2020 and am thinking about upgrading it to the Ranger. Or a Ginda 1000-4 good thing both dealerships are within a few miles of each other
like allways, great presentation..15 inch longer wheelbase and cabinspace behind the seats for drystorege, then it woud be perfect...plus 100 more hp the he will be best rally-offrod performer
Isn't the Polaris almost 15k more?
That's the price of a very good 4x4 pickup
The can am boys are big mad. Look the defender is great but the 1500 is just a step up. It’s ok
for 15k more you get an inch ground clearance a few more electronics. Noticed how he never mentioned the price. 30k vs 45k. And the Can Am wont spend 6 months a year in the shop like Polaris will.
You can tell you are very partial toward Polaris 😂, but everyone has there favorites, I’ve owned 1000 ranger xp crew( bought from y’all) and defender lone star crew, both have there pluses, ranger turns a lot tighter, dash is a little nicer, love the gauges, defender alot smoother, led headlight is a easy 50 dollar fix, seats are beautiful, mine has alot more ground clearance than ranger, machine is more comfortable than ranger, ranger does have better 4wd system, hate the visco lock on defender, I do love the climate control single knob on defender, my 2 cents, like both machines
I got the Defender XMR for the smart Lok. Much better then visco.
Yes the smartloc is a lot better, I’ll end up changing mine to halo locker, just had to take a break for a while on it
Kinda funny how the comparison isn’t even the same type of vehicle. Can am vs the all new Ranger xd it should be ranger xp 1000 NorthStar
lol dude is getting ratio’d in the comments. Thought I wanted a Polaris but now I’m thinkin can am with upgrades
I got a can am defender and a ranger 1000. Can am all the way no comparison. And just wait til can am comes out with there 1500 to rival it.
The price of all of these things is crazy. They are priced at truck prices. With no accident crumple zones on trun signals horn side impact bars 75 mph cruise speed ect. If your going to price this high you better start adding some stuff.
Agreed. As a consumer. I’m feeling ripped off. These are worth 20 25k tops. Loaded
I have a 2024 Canam Defender, and I'll take it over a POLARIS any day! He forgot to mention the 2 USB's in the compartment in front of the driver, as well as the shorter turning radius of the Defender.
I have owned 3 polaris vehicles, and both of them were NOT RELIABLE!
you owned 3 but both were unreliable?
LMFAO
@@jupitersteam8321
Is that guy Matthew McCanaughey's Son? All Right, All Right, All Right. LOL
Jay has just informed us that he’s now going to be selling Lincoln’s as well, so let him know if you need anything, all right?😂
Not even a fair comparison. You are obviously bias toward Polaris. I have owned both brands and will take CanAm any day.
Polaris seems to be a company designed to get the CEO the largest bonus for cost cutting.
What was the price differences?
15K
Yeah prices are a big deal…. I’ll keep my CFMoto Uforce XL spend some one the accessories, build it to how I want it and buy a trailer and still be $5-8k less than the Defender (that has the same specs), or $20-25k less that the 1500 (I would rather buy a Jeep)
But to each their own
The price on this toy can’t be as much as truck, they clearly missed the boat on this.
Why would you be comparing a 1500 Ranger to a 1000 Defender??? Apples to Oranges! I guess you were scared to compare all of the shortcomings of the 1000 Ranger to the superior HD 10 Defender. If you are going to perform comparisons in the future I suggest that you use comparable machines. Otherwise, what’s the point!!! What a waste of time watching this!
Next time, compare a 2024 to a 2024.. you are not comparing the same type of vehicle..
Comparing a $40k machine to a $30k machine lol! I can make that Defender 10x the machine of that crappy Polaris with $10k lol.
Camera man could do better, couldn't see some of the things you was talking about
Can Am is a much superior built machine! My XMR has been a great machine!
My man. My man. V twin motor that can am puts in there 4x4 quads. Compared to a 1500cc motor and a automotive style cvt with a steel ribbed belt (like in Nissan cars and etc). Come on now lol. That’s not to fair now lol.
This shouldn't really even be a comparison since these aren't even same class machines. Compare the can am to the ranger 1000 would be a much better video. Might as well buy a Rubicon when you start looking at these new Polaris machines, probably cheaper, and more durable. 50k for a sxs is absolutely insane. Even 30k for a defender or ranger 1000 is ridiculous, but im still gonna buy one probably 😂
You couldn't give me a piece of poo - laris.
Fit, finish, and comfort in Can-Am is far superior.
Another thing to add about the defender, this shift very poorly, the strength it takes to make them shift at different times is absolutely ridiculous, this is not a one off either, I work for a company that has and rents a large # of these units for work, hundreds of shift cables busted, as well as the steel bracket in behind bent, zero parts available to fix for months at times, they are a piece of sh.., door cable/stopper for the door when it opens is very light cable, when this breaks and it will, the door will over travel and bend the hinges and the door will not close. sometimes its out 2-3 inches where the latch is, you will have to take the door off and bend the hinges back and reinstall the door and realign. Very poor door latch system, I've had the door open just driving, this will bust the cable and your hinges are bent again. Put a heavy gauge piece of cable for the door stop. The amount of body and cage flex is unreal, the creaks and groans is pathetic for what their asking price is. Junk
Yes sir, I experienced all of this with my 2021 Defender Limited. Also had issues with the power windows and the AC unit not working consistently.
I looked at both machines today. I’ve owned 2 can am defender max limiteds and a Polaris crew max. I loved all the machines. Never had any trouble from any of them. This new 1500 is pretty special though. Everything feels better built on it from the can am. The doors feel much sturdier, they actually lock. What in the hell is can am thinking about not having locking doors? Are they stupid? Also, can am has missed the mark on the navigation display. How outdated are they? Polaris is changing the game and I guess Can am is living in the past.
That navigation is 5 grand add on for that and 2 cameras. No thank you Polaris
“The Can-Am still does have the CVT transmission.” So does the Polaris, they just took away neutral and the ease of service of a belt for $15,000 more. Buy a Honda if you don’t want a CVT.
Can Am will last 3 times as long!!!
This is like comparing a pinto to a Lincoln!
I agree. This video would make sense when canam comes out this a comparison.
More like comparing a Lincoln to a Land Rover.
In Canada the ranger xd msrp is 54k 🤮 that’s ridiculous !!!
Why didn't you mention the price difference?
They are getting ridiculous with the price on these ATVs and UTVs hell like someone else said you find a nice use 4x4 for the money they're asking.
Not even comparable, The Defender 1000 limited is comparable to a Ranger xp1000 Northstar
Polaris is too sketchy for me to consider buying. I've seen way too many serious malfunctions from Polaris brand to trust them.
Better add some $ and get the ranger raptor 2024😂😂😂
Two different vehicles. Defender is more comparable (but better) than the Northstar
45k for a pos Polaris, that's ok.
Ranger xd is 10 steps above the can am. Better comparison would be a regular sized ranger and i still think it beats the defender.
Ya, it would be a better comparison. He is basically comparing a 2020 ford ranger to a 2024 ford f150. Lol😂
Not a chance the ranger would beat the defender, I keep riding when others rangers are in the shop. I’ve owned rangers as well and will not ever own one again.
@@UpNorthOutdoors231 lol. Sure
Tech specs. .... price..... and look... im sorry but when i buy a vehicle even utility vehicle it cannot be UGLY... i have to like it, or at least it must be decent looking.... Polaris is ridiculous on price and looking.... Defender just look good, good price, good reliability.... i go for CANAM
My 2017 Polaris has so many issues it’s a joke. I’m afraid to ride it very far from home. I’ll never own another Polaris - too many low quality Chinese parts.
He is so biased he loves everything about Polaris and hated can am and the 15k price difference
Bogus comparison. Should have compared the Can-Am Defender Limited to a RANGER XP 1000 NORTHSTAR EDITION ULTIMATE
All these things cost at least twice what they should. Rip off.
Filming guy. When he’s showing the dash on the defender. Get in there and film instead of hovering by the side window like a peeping Tom.
Count how many time this dude says "Guys" I lost count and had to turn it off GUYS! Learn how to talk if you're going to talk guys, guys, guys!!!!!
Polaris is junk! I handled UTV/ATV acquisitions for a federal agency. We purchased Polaris equipment on numerous occasions and they were always junk. Terrible transmissions, clutches, engines, ergonomics, brakes, wheel bearings, and service, ect. We used our machines very harshly and we would only get a month or two of use from anything Polaris before they fell apart and needed major repairs. Can-Am, Honda, Yamaha, Yanmar, Kawasaki, were all other brands that held up better than Polaris. I hope they have improved their quality but I know for years they were trash. I don’t have a favorite brand, nor do I advocate for a particular brand. I purchased a defender Lone Star in 2020 and it has been great but would have gone Viking had it not been for the amazing deal I was offered. Good luck and happy trails!
You're so full of crap. I was new to the market and bought Polaris atv and a General 4 seat XP deluxe yadda yadda. Both have given me zero problems hundreds of hours and thousand plus miles. Guess I just got luck huh? Yeah right.
Lol, you forgot to leave your disclaimer. Let me help you! His comment was paid for by Polaris, but doesn’t necessarily reflect the views of Polaris or its partners.
@@chrishill1286
Look I don’t care what name it has on it, if it had Ching Ding on the side I would support it if it was well built. You tested 1 congratulations, I have tested hundreds over the last 35 years. Your experience may be due to the conditions you operate in. A pavement princess that is well kept compared to one that is run hard makes a huge difference. I am not being a jerk either, heck PM me and come out to my ranch and see for yourself.
@@joet1669 Saying something is junk is not a result of testing, it's just an opinion of someone who has had trouble in the past.Tests have results, So please share them. Otherwise junk is just an opinion. I take care of mine because its a huge investment, But I have wrung it out that being said I don't jump the dam thing because I have grown up in that sense.
If it is reliability you are looking for, just buy a Honda.
Typical Polaris dealer shitting all over their competitors Pretty ridiculous even doing a video. Not talking about anything positive about the can am even though it's a better product.
Done with Polaris high prices.do not buy polaris
For the price I would by a Jeep.