@@tomlinson6367 the top right part of the map but you have to be at chapter 6 and complete a few missions, also after you complete the first part do the second part right away or she'll die
@@Dagger_323 Thing is, that pretty much makes John's sacrifice meaningless. That's the point. Jack becomes exactly what his family tried to save him from. The moment he kills Ross he becomes a murderer. An outlaw. So yeah....no Redemption after all.
Cmenshooter I actually enjoyed that the most seeing all the people you met, and the fact at the end of the game you he him looking at an eagle flying around symbolizing his son.
Plus that look of regret on johns face as he leaves. If dutch hadn't capitalized on eagle flies anger and manipulated him he might've still been alive.
Ive never been sadder about a game characters death because Arthur and John and everyone else felt alive you got to see his last moments and saw how he felt Arthur Morgan was a true warrior
The other day I came across the young guy who Arthur sees throwing stones in the lake , he’s upset because a girl he likes doesn’t like him if I remember correctly. When you see him whilst playing as John he’s once again throwing stones in the lake but this time he’s angry because although he ended up with the girl, shes turned out to be a nightmare lol he blames his meeting with Arthur because he told him to go after her haha
honestly I only go low honor with arthur because I just can't bring myself to make John go bad. I mean, RDR1 fully established his character and while he wasn't afraid to kill people, canonically he's a good man for the most part, it just makes me feel really bad making John do bad things.
I really did wish John had an brush encounter with Mary Linton at Arthur's grave. Just visiting the grave with no words unsaid just feels empty knowing all what Arthur did for John and what Arthur sacrificed.
I would say sometimes silence is more powerful. If gives you space to think and reflect. I actually cried in front of Arthur's grave. Then I emptied my revolver's chamber towards the sky. And then I got drunk. Probably a good way to remember him.
@@bigde131 You hear him say it to Charles when they're riding together in one mission. I believe it was while they were trying to find the campsite next to the lake near Rhodes. If you remember, Charles asks why Arthur gives John so much shit, and Arthur responds with how John left them all for a year and he still hasn't gotten over it.
Also if you dont hunt the boar with the veteran and Arthur and wait till you go with John and he will show you the fish Arthur caught and the wolf he killed with his bare hands. It's a nice and sad story.
I didn't even intend to let it play out that way. I was going to the old man but then got distracted and finished the story. I'm glad it played out that way. It was way better.
This game made me love Arthur so much, and it made me love John even more than I did before. John has such a good heart, especially going to see everyone Arthur had made some kind of impact on. It's honestly beautiful, and watching all of these brings a tear to my eye because I still am, and always will be completely invested in these characters.
Darl I feel bad for you, I usually try to avoid things about a new game that isn’t like a blind playthrough while I’m also playing the first time, some people just don’t care or expect everyone to have already known things, though if you ask me in this case, it was sorta obvious Arthur had to go before the events of the 1st game.
Some other encounters I wish John had with the people Arthur helped or interacted with 1: The German Family 2: Mary Linton 3: Edith & Archie Downes 4: Brother Dorkins 5: Penelope Braithwaite & Beau Gray (a letter would be fine from them addressed to Arthur but picked up by John) That's about it really Edit: also would be cool to see where Trelawny and Ms. Jones went after chapter six.
Yes to all but I'd maybe change the Downes to also send a letter as opposed to meeting John. In their last meeting Arthur told them to leave and gave them money. Why they would return to the area after that kinda seems odd. The German Family would be nice to see like in say Blackwater or something, Mary at Arthur's grave and Dorkins in St. Denis
I always find Rains Fall’s encounter so sad, he is just so empty and lost. I’m sure plenty of people feel the exact same way, it’s a very realistic reaction for when a family member dies
Same here, I think it's because is missable if you go too far on the epilogue, which sucks. How the hell Rockstar didn't make a Stranger Meeting or just pin pointed these encounters on the map? It is the goddamn gang members and important people from the history.
I robbed Pearson, cause i was on the Challange to rob 4 stores in 1 day & i was running out of time.. last thing he said was "Abigail, must be proud", but i was like " *I NeEd MoRe MuHnE* "
these interactions are so lovely to me. tilly’s especially gets me emotional, and when you add in the letter she sends, where she calls john and abigail the only real family she has aside from her husband and daughter, it’s just so bittersweet. there’s a hidden dialogue where tilly talks about dutch and hosea taking her in, and arthur says “you were the sweetest little thing we ever saw. and the saddest.” tilly really was their little sister, and im glad she got to reunite with at least one of her brothers before he passed.
It must've really changed John's perspective when he read Arthur's journal. All these people he was helping and meeting and what he had been through. He never shared these thoughts with anyone.
Wish I knew where Karen or Trelawney went. I know that Trelawney has a family so he probably went somewhere with them, but it would be good if we also found them in game
You can find trewlany at his house in Saint Denis giving gifts to his children. Well, you don't see him but you can hear dialogue from his house. Sorry, I can't remember where
Fun fact: Mary-Beth’s haircut is the similar to Ms. Grimshaw’s after her death. Shows how they may have their disagreements, they both cared and loved each other
The last encounters with Charlotte kind of sucked. After you eat a meal with her and get sick, she just cuts you off and becomes distant, then you see her one last time and treats you like a passing stranger. Then you die. I figure she cut herself off from it because she knew you didn't have long and didn't want to go through losing another person she felt close to. Rip bro
Ya know? I find it so wholesome that you had John wear Arthur’s Hat for these interactions. It’s like part of Arthur passed on to John (not in a player-sense, but like a literal sense)
Anthony de Lange you can find him in saint denis, he looks all messed up and dirty like he's homeless but he's wearing the same clothes and talks about how he is still looking for gavin but it's been so long since he's seen him that he doesnt even remember how he even looks like
this game just hits a different part of me. I will never get tired of the amount of time these people spent developing these characters and their personalities. They did such a good job that I will get to certain missions and hold off on playing them for the sole reason that a main character dies. I hope they all know how much of an impact something like their voice has had
Tillys interaction was weird, like it felt more rushed than the others, other than that the other ones were great. It makes me sad SPOILERS FOR FIRST GAME That John dies in the first game. All these people must have been hearbroken after hearing about it.
Sandman ah yes good old bill the scumbag idiot who is basically a slightly younger uncle, Dutch the man with a plan before he kicked the can (flying like an eagle, ironic is it not), and Javier escualla, who essentially (even though it’s racist) became a real greaser, god why did they make him such a punk in rdr1 but in the prequel he is the most charming and lovable character of the gang, in my opinion (no I’m not saying he is better than Arthur or John, there just great for different reasons.)
I had full honor as arthur and completed most of the game as him done all honorable things When i meet rains fall as john i had a little more than half honor. Somehow after the encounter i got full honor
it was so nice of Rockstar to go all the way to give an aftermath to all the characters we've all grown to love and see how things have changed for them after the fall of Dutch's gang and Arthur's death. it felt weird to play as John when he died but then obviously realised that the first game is set after the events of this one so it made sense. Charlotte's one to me was the most special. if Arthur hadn't died from TB or had it in the first place, he would've lived happily with her considering Mary no longer wanted him. but seeing John interact with everyone else again was interesting to see. i mean to me as the player, it felt like seeing old friends but for John's case, it truly was! fucking well done, Rockstar.
This epilogue truly just makes me want to forget that the end of rdr1 ever happened like in my mind Abigail and John are living on their ranch until they're old
4 years late I know lmao but I can imagine Pearson seeing John walk in with the hat, and saying "Arthur?" In a massively confused an happy tone, but it turns to somber joy when he learns it's John. Joy seeing John okay. Somber knowing that Arthur is gone. I'd imagine Pearson then saying. "He really was the best of us. He gave all he had, and more it seems."
I got a question, do you think when John was dying in red dead redemption 1, he thought of Arthur? About how this whole peaceful life wouldn’t have happened if it wasn’t for his brother?
In my first playthrough, i was really surprised to bump into Mary Beth.. what a great way to see how the other characters ended up. It was nice how John knew Mickey was talking about Arthur.
Imagine, if lenny still alive in this era and leave the gang for good..... he can be a better man, better 27 years old man who can become a successful lawyer or something else, also i wanna see if sean and karen get married, kieran, he might be on somebody.!
When Rain Falls said "My people aren't a tribe, we're bunch of families" It's similiar to Dutch gang "his people aren't a gang, they're bunch of criminals or people trying to live their lives"
Real Talk - It's difficult watching Chief Rains Fall and realizing how Native Americans have never had a happy ending - in this game or in real life. Other Than Real Talk - Little known fact, Tilly Jackson married a lawyer named Johnson; her family eventually moved from St Denis to San Andreas and Carl Johnson was one of her descendants. Even less known fact: Mary Beth became a very successful writer and married an Englishman she met at a book signing; she eventually moved to England and her descendants are Dan and Sam Houser, creators of Red Dead Redemption Two.
Meeting all of the other gang members feels like when you run into an old friend. You talk about the old days, what your current situation is, and that you should talk more some time, and then that moment never happens.
Arthur saves Johns life. John says "you're my brother". Tells Mary Beth how much he thinks of him. Tells other how Arthur saved him. Comes across a crazy drunk on the street... "He was good and bad. Im not sure what he was in the end"... ???? Damn John. Dude was your "brother" and saved your life. You can maybe keep some stuff to yourself lol
The times I cried in RDR2: When Arthur was thinking back and cinematically riding along the road, a bunch of quotes there. When Charles and Sadie left :( When Arthur’s horse died, and when ARTHUR DIED. And I cried when Micah died *out of joy*
If you get drunk in valentine late in the game and black out, Arthur will wake up shouting for lenny before reality sadly comes in. I would have loved it if in those encounters people mistook John for arthur while wearing his hat
the miss tilly and mary beth ones are so incredible and make me emotional! in my mind they visit john and abigail from time to time and they remain friends. that would be awesome
“Be well, live a life, don’t look back” an advice from greatest character of all video games I’ve ever played. That’s how you leave others to think of you when you are gone. Had something good done!
If you go by Horseshoe Overlook at 3am as John, you see Arthur's ghost riding his horse then disappears in the trees. It was so crazy when it happened because it only happens if you're drunk at Horseshoe Overlook, John goes "Arthur?!" then he vanishes and John passes out
Guys if you want to play with arthur again so restart game in new slot and play until chapter 4 where kieran dies and you can play with both characters if you want to play with arthur so reload game to new slot if you want to play with john so reload game to old slot.
Very interesting how once the gang members who leave and survive end up conforming and living happy lives in civilization. Dutch always was trying to get away from society and talking about how their way of life was what it meant to truly be free. Very cool to see that Dutch was holding them back from living life to their fullest, makes sense seeing how much of a narcissist he was.
![⭐️( ลอยกระทง 2024 ) Ver. แดนซ์ Remix BY [ ดีเจกิต รีมิกซ์ ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rMWOLhgXUHc/mqdefault.jpg)
"Any friend of Arthur's is a friend of mine". I like that.
When I was doing that mission she was walking back into her home with the rabbit and i clicked r2 on accident and shot her dead
What’s her name? It doesn’t rlly show
@@muhammadthien5167 charolett
@@tomlinson6367 the top right part of the map but you have to be at chapter 6 and complete a few missions, also after you complete the first part do the second part right away or she'll die
@@splash_067 that's some dark souls stuff
honestly the epilogue makes me so happy but then I remember that RDR happens and then I get depressed again.
Well epilogue happens in 1907 and Red Dead 1 happens in 1911-12 if i remember right. So he had some happy years of peace at least.
QuackSpeed same man same
Take solace in the fact that Jack fills Ross with a half dozen pieces of lead in retribution for John’s death.
Dieserkarma everyone should who played the first game. Ross was the true son of a bitch.
@@Dagger_323 Thing is, that pretty much makes John's sacrifice meaningless. That's the point. Jack becomes exactly what his family tried to save him from. The moment he kills Ross he becomes a murderer. An outlaw. So yeah....no Redemption after all.
Rains fall was the saddest
Cmenshooter I actually enjoyed that the most seeing all the people you met, and the fact at the end of the game you he him looking at an eagle flying around symbolizing his son.
Cmenshooter You can really see the weight of his sadness on him
Plus that look of regret on johns face as he leaves. If dutch hadn't capitalized on eagle flies anger and manipulated him he might've still been alive.
YEAH FUCK CAPITALISM (it's horrible) but im capitalist :/
@@imarealone_0076 sad thing is dutch aint even done exploiting the native americans
Ive never been sadder about a game characters death because Arthur and John and everyone else felt alive you got to see his last moments and saw how he felt Arthur Morgan was a true warrior
In my head, there is a great afterlife in the red dead universe.
There should have been a achievement called "Family Reunion"
That would be awesome!
The description of the achievement would've been a spoiler lol
@@tinest6485 we can aleast make a secret one
@@ghostcreeper243 ah true
I thought the same, bro. 😃
The other day I came across the young guy who Arthur sees throwing stones in the lake , he’s upset because a girl he likes doesn’t like him if I remember correctly. When you see him whilst playing as John he’s once again throwing stones in the lake but this time he’s angry because although he ended up with the girl, shes turned out to be a nightmare lol he blames his meeting with Arthur because he told him to go after her haha
THE MASK PLAGUE same
when he called arthur a bastard, I blew his head off
@@NullReserve who wouldn't
@@NullReserve 🤣
@@The__General a person who can handle the slightest insult or criticism to the protagonist of a video game
Wow I’m impressed you have a high honour playing as John when I finished the epilogue I used it as an excuse to go on mirderous rampages
Murderous*
@@cadez8386 Just save before you go on a murderous rampage, then you can keep the benefits of high honour
honestly I only go low honor with arthur because I just can't bring myself to make John go bad. I mean, RDR1 fully established his character and while he wasn't afraid to kill people, canonically he's a good man for the most part, it just makes me feel really bad making John do bad things.
Tommy Phillips a bit too late now lmao
Oh I became a downright bastard when I played as John. Felt so good also. Really enjoyed killing that guy looking for Gavin...
I really did wish John had an brush encounter with Mary Linton at Arthur's grave. Just visiting the grave with no words unsaid just feels empty knowing all what Arthur did for John and what Arthur sacrificed.
If you have 100% completion, you'll unlock a piece of dialogue.
@@wadesalvius1645 nice to know !
@@wadesalvius1645 Thx for the info.
I would say sometimes silence is more powerful. If gives you space to think and reflect. I actually cried in front of Arthur's grave. Then I emptied my revolver's chamber towards the sky. And then I got drunk. Probably a good way to remember him.
Nah. Fuck Mary.
Man, john be like "damn arthur, why u so good to everyone but you mad with me when you still alive"
because he always had to say that it was him when entering a campsite.
I mean,that's how older brothers are
John hurt Arthur a lot when he left them. He couldn’t quite get over that I think.
@@bigde131 You hear him say it to Charles when they're riding together in one mission. I believe it was while they were trying to find the campsite next to the lake near Rhodes. If you remember, Charles asks why Arthur gives John so much shit, and Arthur responds with how John left them all for a year and he still hasn't gotten over it.
@@guilhermebrasil8333 so true I'm gunna cry now
Also if you dont hunt the boar with the veteran and Arthur and wait till you go with John and he will show you the fish Arthur caught and the wolf he killed with his bare hands. It's a nice and sad story.
it was awesome seeing those trophys, suck how it ends though.
I didn't even intend to let it play out that way. I was going to the old man but then got distracted and finished the story. I'm glad it played out that way. It was way better.
I think I was actually sadder when Hamish died than when some gang members did.
@@GrostyBoi same
@@GrostyBoi It death was definitely as sad as Hosea's.
Charlotte's encounter is the best, literally made arthur a hero.
" he found me at my lowest point and he lifted me up "
"i don't talk about him much, but i think about him"
HEARTBREAKING ALERT
" he saved my life... he gave his."
"that doesn't suprise me one bit."
damn, that's heavy.
1,000th like :0
This game made me love Arthur so much, and it made me love John even more than I did before. John has such a good heart, especially going to see everyone Arthur had made some kind of impact on. It's honestly beautiful, and watching all of these brings a tear to my eye because I still am, and always will be completely invested in these characters.
"He saved my life. He gave his."
"That doesn't surprise me one bit."
Imagine finding this video before beating the game tho...
Yeah it hurt... Quite a bit, it's my fault damnit
Darl I feel bad for you, I usually try to avoid things about a new game that isn’t like a blind playthrough while I’m also playing the first time, some people just don’t care or expect everyone to have already known things, though if you ask me in this case, it was sorta obvious Arthur had to go before the events of the 1st game.
@@SSlash yeah all this did was confirm it, it's my fault TH-cam automatically picks videos and I shoulda clicked off
I just had to stay up all night on a TH-cam binge
Darl aww, you’re okay girl....
(You better a read that in Arthur’s voice lol)
Some other encounters I wish John had with the people Arthur helped or interacted with
1: The German Family
2: Mary Linton
3: Edith & Archie Downes
4: Brother Dorkins
5: Penelope Braithwaite & Beau Gray (a letter would be fine from them addressed to Arthur but picked up by John)
That's about it really
Edit: also would be cool to see where Trelawny and Ms. Jones went after chapter six.
I believe Karen eventually died from her alcoholism and Trelawny ended up in New York.
@@mandemarso I thought it was Swanson who went to New York where he taught his ministry?
@@frankhorriganfromfallout2 it was Swanson
I guess trelawny got back to his family in st. Denis
Yes to all but I'd maybe change the Downes to also send a letter as opposed to meeting John. In their last meeting Arthur told them to leave and gave them money. Why they would return to the area after that kinda seems odd. The German Family would be nice to see like in say Blackwater or something, Mary at Arthur's grave and Dorkins in St. Denis
I thought Mary-Beth was really cute and hoped you could make something happen with her while playing as Arthur
Nah she was like his lil' sister.
Moisty Bacon depends on how you look at it I suppose. It would’ve been nice to at least have the option
Moisty Bacon i felt that was some sort of connection between the two. Well on Mary’s behalf since Arthur didn’t want to fool around because of Isaac
they’re Western , incest is always an option , so don’t pull the “his little sister” bs
@@_dmbfanz_4959 *sweet home alabam plays in the distance*
I always find Rains Fall’s encounter so sad, he is just so empty and lost. I’m sure plenty of people feel the exact same way, it’s a very realistic reaction for when a family member dies
When I went to Pearsons store in my game, we skipped all introductions and he just acted like I already had been there, it was weird
Same. Also he has a wife named Ethel now. Glad he found someone
I rob pearson
@@sasa1417 me too
@@sasa1417 BEAST
Same here, I think it's because is missable if you go too far on the epilogue, which sucks. How the hell Rockstar didn't make a Stranger Meeting or just pin pointed these encounters on the map? It is the goddamn gang members and important people from the history.
Mary Beth is my favourite. She's just the cutest and John mentioning Arthur was very beautiful.
Rains Fall was very heartbreaking...
This is John Marston living the great legacy left by his great friend Arthur Morgan.
"You’re welcome to take anything."
*Takes Everything in House*
I gotta Say Pearson is my favorite Gang Member because he gets so much shit and I love the personality of his character
Mmm and he makes the stew. That was the shit
Yeah he was a real homie
Charles is my favorite and Dutch
I robbed Pearson, cause i was on the Challange to rob 4 stores in 1 day & i was running out of time.. last thing he said was "Abigail, must be proud", but i was like " *I NeEd MoRe MuHnE* "
xD
You can't even rob him wtf
Butch you’re lying you can’t even rob Pearson I’ve tried to do it
@@bilfy130 tf ? I robbed the shit out of him 🤣😂
@@Dankster-yo8xv i can do a video about it on my channel 🤣, i did rob him
these interactions are so lovely to me. tilly’s especially gets me emotional, and when you add in the letter she sends, where she calls john and abigail the only real family she has aside from her husband and daughter, it’s just so bittersweet. there’s a hidden dialogue where tilly talks about dutch and hosea taking her in, and arthur says “you were the sweetest little thing we ever saw. and the saddest.” tilly really was their little sister, and im glad she got to reunite with at least one of her brothers before he passed.
It must've really changed John's perspective when he read Arthur's journal. All these people he was helping and meeting and what he had been through. He never shared these thoughts with anyone.
Wow you wear Arthur’s hat too, I wore it out of Respect for Arthur
Wish I knew where Karen or Trelawney went. I know that Trelawney has a family so he probably went somewhere with them, but it would be good if we also found them in game
You can find trewlany at his house in Saint Denis giving gifts to his children. Well, you don't see him but you can hear dialogue from his house. Sorry, I can't remember where
saint stingy the wise is a hydra agent the dialogue only pops up while Arthur’s still alive. I showed up with John and got complete silence.
Knowing Trelawny, he aprobable fled Saint Denis with his family as soon as he left the gang
Kassafrass Sassafrass Karen drunk herself to death
Karen dead man. She dead
Fun fact: Mary-Beth’s haircut is the similar to Ms. Grimshaw’s after her death. Shows how they may have their disagreements, they both cared and loved each other
It's cool how John knows what Arthur's friends say they knew him and described Arthur, so John automatically knows him.
I remember my brother talking to Rains Fall, and we were both massively shocked by the amount of honor you get just for talking to him!
Its like meeting old classmates after several years. Really heartwarming
Got it felt like I was actually reconnecting with old friends. Love these characters
I miss you Hamish, the man with wooden leg
RipeKiller_32 whyyy u micha
Yes I miss him too
He waz my favorite side charachter i was sad and cried when he passed in the boar hunting mission
The last encounters with Charlotte kind of sucked. After you eat a meal with her and get sick, she just cuts you off and becomes distant, then you see her one last time and treats you like a passing stranger. Then you die.
I figure she cut herself off from it because she knew you didn't have long and didn't want to go through losing another person she felt close to. Rip bro
she doesn't cut you off
I wish that these weren’t random events, but part of story missions because it’s really easy and really annoying that you can miss these encounters.
I love how the honor goes up after meeting rains fall
John: Congratulations!
Tilly: I'm not pregnant I've just gained some weight.
John: Okay I'll catch you later then.
"Well I should get back to it"
Ya know? I find it so wholesome that you had John wear Arthur’s Hat for these interactions. It’s like part of Arthur passed on to John (not in a player-sense, but like a literal sense)
What about the guy who asks for gavin
Anthony de Lange you can find him in saint denis, he looks all messed up and dirty like he's homeless but he's wearing the same clothes and talks about how he is still looking for gavin but it's been so long since he's seen him that he doesnt even remember how he even looks like
He's also acting like he's going insane from all of the searching, stating how he's wasted his life on this endless search.
@@ItsEbro I saw him on Blackwater
Cryptoc same lol
I killed him. I was annoyed hearing his voice after one of Arthur’s coughing attacks and shot him in the head with a bow.
It was raining when I met Rain Falls made the scene even more sad 😢
0:08 Rockstar Editor: "Common guys, fun time is over.."
0:11 Rockstar Editor: "Alright, if you keep doing that, you won't get paid for playing NPCs!"
John: talks to Arthur’s old acquaintances and friends
Train: *ima end this man’s whole conversation*
Rest In Peace, Rip Van Winkle
this game just hits a different part of me. I will never get tired of the amount of time these people spent developing these characters and their personalities. They did such a good job that I will get to certain missions and hold off on playing them for the sole reason that a main character dies. I hope they all know how much of an impact something like their voice has had
2:37 cAtCh yoU LaTEr tHEn
0:12 People casually fall to ground
Tillys interaction was weird, like it felt more rushed than the others, other than that the other ones were great. It makes me sad SPOILERS FOR FIRST GAME
That John dies in the first game. All these people must have been hearbroken after hearing about it.
Tilly ran from me for no reason 😂😂😂
Well of course do u not hear what she said she was waiting for the trolley station, and when John comes it came!
@XX_GAMINGDOGE_XX just trying to be considerate and all that. I hate spoiling shit for people.
@XX_GAMINGDOGE_XX oh nah bro your good. No sweat.
@@themindset4164 I m looking forward to buy the game and I do care about spoilers for some games
He is gonna meet afew more of them in a couple of years...
Sandman ah yes good old bill the scumbag idiot who is basically a slightly younger uncle, Dutch the man with a plan before he kicked the can (flying like an eagle, ironic is it not), and Javier escualla, who essentially (even though it’s racist) became a real greaser, god why did they make him such a punk in rdr1 but in the prequel he is the most charming and lovable character of the gang, in my opinion (no I’m not saying he is better than Arthur or John, there just great for different reasons.)
I had full honor as arthur and completed most of the game as him done all honorable things
When i meet rains fall as john i had a little more than half honor. Somehow after the encounter i got full honor
Idc this is amazing story telling, like to give someone like Tilly who wasn’t a major character a whole life years later is amazing
And that's why high honor Arthur is my favorite Arthur, you do good things and you are kind to everyone, you get to be remembered as a good person.
it was so nice of Rockstar to go all the way to give an aftermath to all the characters we've all grown to love and see how things have changed for them after the fall of Dutch's gang and Arthur's death. it felt weird to play as John when he died but then obviously realised that the first game is set after the events of this one so it made sense. Charlotte's one to me was the most special. if Arthur hadn't died from TB or had it in the first place, he would've lived happily with her considering Mary no longer wanted him. but seeing John interact with everyone else again was interesting to see. i mean to me as the player, it felt like seeing old friends but for John's case, it truly was! fucking well done, Rockstar.
This epilogue truly just makes me want to forget that the end of rdr1 ever happened like in my mind Abigail and John are living on their ranch until they're old
Rockstar should’ve added a feature that if you wear Arthur’s hat while seeing old gang members they would mention it.
4 years late I know lmao but I can imagine Pearson seeing John walk in with the hat, and saying "Arthur?" In a massively confused an happy tone, but it turns to somber joy when he learns it's John. Joy seeing John okay. Somber knowing that Arthur is gone. I'd imagine Pearson then saying.
"He really was the best of us. He gave all he had, and more it seems."
I got a question, do you think when John was dying in red dead redemption 1, he thought of Arthur?
About how this whole peaceful life wouldn’t have happened if it wasn’t for his brother?
In my first playthrough, i was really surprised to bump into Mary Beth.. what a great way to see how the other characters ended up. It was nice how John knew Mickey was talking about Arthur.
Imagine, if lenny still alive in this era and leave the gang for good..... he can be a better man, better 27 years old man who can become a successful lawyer or something else, also i wanna see if sean and karen get married, kieran, he might be on somebody.!
Man if RDR3 happens Sadie should be the main character. That'd be pretty damn cool
That were Really cool
Dutch should be too. He’s also a badass, ik he’s crazy but he should be playable.
Jack
John's snort after Mary-Beth asks about Dutch is just spectacular. 3:53
When Rain Falls said "My people aren't a tribe, we're bunch of families"
It's similiar to Dutch gang "his people aren't a gang, they're bunch of criminals or people trying to live their lives"
Arthur is now my favorite made up human of all time
The best one has to be mr pearson it was so funny. Can you try to rob him see if he hates you or just makes you robs him
ZeeGaming Plays_ he does get angry but you can’t shoot him
I pointed my gun at him on accident (because it’s red dead) and he ran out the back door
Real Talk - It's difficult watching Chief Rains Fall and realizing how Native Americans have never had a happy ending - in this game or in real life. Other Than Real Talk - Little known fact, Tilly Jackson married a lawyer named Johnson; her family eventually moved from St Denis to San Andreas and Carl Johnson was one of her descendants. Even less known fact: Mary Beth became a very successful writer and married an Englishman she met at a book signing; she eventually moved to England and her descendants are Dan and Sam Houser, creators of Red Dead Redemption Two.
I got the platinum when it realeased . Still to this day I'm finding new stuff. Rip Arthur. I still cry playing this
Me too 😢
Meeting all of the other gang members feels like when you run into an old friend. You talk about the old days, what your current situation is, and that you should talk more some time, and then that moment never happens.
It would also be cool if the ones you meet come to live at Johns house or at least visit every couple of nights
Arthur saved them all and gave his life just for Dutch and the government to be thrown off their trail. A true savior, and a good man.
Talking to Mary Beth about killing animals for fun
I went too every saloon expecting Karen too have an interaction too.....but no she just disappeared
John: Congratulations! (Points at Tilly's belly)
Tilly: I ain't pregnant, just chubby.
Arthur saves Johns life. John says "you're my brother". Tells Mary Beth how much he thinks of him. Tells other how Arthur saved him.
Comes across a crazy drunk on the street... "He was good and bad. Im not sure what he was in the end"... ????
Damn John. Dude was your "brother" and saved your life.
You can maybe keep some stuff to yourself lol
The times I cried in RDR2: When Arthur was thinking back and cinematically riding along the road, a bunch of quotes there. When Charles and Sadie left :( When Arthur’s horse died, and when ARTHUR DIED. And I cried when Micah died
*out of joy*
im so sad arthur didnt end up with mary beth
If you get drunk in valentine late in the game and black out, Arthur will wake up shouting for lenny before reality sadly comes in. I would have loved it if in those encounters people mistook John for arthur while wearing his hat
Every time I heard Arthers name I cried manly tears
the miss tilly and mary beth ones are so incredible and make me emotional! in my mind they visit john and abigail from time to time and they remain friends. that would be awesome
Yeah that's cool and all, but *where's Lenny?*
Maybe this is a joke and I’m getting woooosh, but Lenny dies in chapter 4...
@@mariogomez6021 yeah its a joke
I know I couldn't find him at the camp after chapter 5 weird I'm Sure hes fine
Arthur found Lenny up in the great saloon in the sky
Apollyon he died in chapterul 4
It’s interesting to me the only member of the gang John talked about Arthur with was Mary Beth. Arthur opened up the most to Mary Beth.
You can read in a newspaper that reverend swanson became leader of an ny church
WTF HAPPENED TO KAREN???
Dr. Feelgood I think she died of alcohol poisoning not long after the gang fell
For real where is she
IG: Maharaji_yurin idk but that's what everyone else is saying
@@G0DKING it was in a newspaper clipping
Dr. Feelgood one of the characters (tilly?) says she more then likely drank herself to death
It’s a shame John never meets Mary. Would’ve been a neat encounter
It kinda breaks my heart when she said"We live in a house" And John says us too its just so sad.
it would be nice if arthurs girl mary would have been a person that john bumped into
@Asta Fuckoff but she knows. She was at his grave
I get why, they didn’t want to slow everything down and all, but none of these scenes last as long as I would like.
Arther is one of the best characters ever made in a game 💯
“Be well, live a life, don’t look back” an advice from greatest character of all video games I’ve ever played. That’s how you leave others to think of you when you are gone. Had something good done!
There should’ve been a mission where we bring Sadie to Pearson’s store and watch them both fight 😂
I think Mary Beth had a huge crush on Arthur but she never made a move
Te extrañamos Arthur 😭
I’m about to google translate this bitch
you know the 18/19 the Century was different when saying " I live in a house" feels like a huge step in society
If you go by Horseshoe Overlook at 3am as John, you see Arthur's ghost riding his horse then disappears in the trees. It was so crazy when it happened because it only happens if you're drunk at Horseshoe Overlook, John goes "Arthur?!" then he vanishes and John passes out
The Impartial Savage 2019 and you still attempted to do this
@@Secarstra777 what?
Probably fake
The Impartial Savage shut yo lame ass up
How about you guys stop assuming and actually try it :/
Guys if you want to play with arthur again so restart game in new slot and play until chapter 4 where kieran dies and you can play with both characters if you want to play with arthur so reload game to new slot if you want to play with john so reload game to old slot.
I have to rob Mary-Beths Train xD
how did it go
I robbed rain fall's train ✨
Very interesting how once the gang members who leave and survive end up conforming and living happy lives in civilization. Dutch always was trying to get away from society and talking about how their way of life was what it meant to truly be free. Very cool to see that Dutch was holding them back from living life to their fullest, makes sense seeing how much of a narcissist he was.
I feel so bad for Mickey.. 😭😭
I beat the game on highest honor and I couldn’t help but cry a tear for the greatest and selfless gunslinger who was taken from us too soon.
10:32 that’s why I have bad honor and bounty’s
Jack
Tilly
Pearson
Sadie
Charles
Mary beth
Are sadly the last members of the gang by 1914