I'm Concerned... Vocal Coach Reacts to IU 'Love wins all' Recording
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.พ. 2024
- Get started learning to sing with my method for free with Singr: singr.tv/justin
Get exclusive reactions, request & connect w me: / justinburke
Instagram: / iamjustinburke
My music: • Justin Burke's Music
Thanks for hanging with me on TH-cam! See you in the next vid :)
-J - เพลง
She has been active for 15 years. In isolation this may look tough, but she knows what she’s doing.
He’s a professional vocal coach, he knows what he’s talking about too😂 no need to shield a grown ass woman from constructive criticism aimed at helping her sustain a long career
@@mylittlepeonies8693 bold to assume that she doesn’t have a vocal coach of her own either.
I never heard of him before. What is his credential. She is an all rounder well experienced artist with a lot of commitment and timeline. Not everybody are the same. However shes been complimented by other vocal coaches reaction video that i watch... if she didnt show behind the scene recording nobody notice she was sick. Most reaction are complimenting her outstanding vocal...Thats why i m asking.. BTW he diffinitely need to improve his presentation skill by watching other utubers/vocal trainers reaction too...many have gave negative feedback on his way of reactions.
he is being presumptuous believing he knows more than her professional staff ,that has been with her for more than decade does@@mylittlepeonies8693
I love how he keeps saying there's "new technologies" like IU's living under a rock. maybe this guy's just concerned, to me it looked like selling products though, specially with that ad jumpscare in the middle of the video.
She had filmed a brutal mv in freezing temperatures for two days before this, then after she flew to the Milan fashion show, got her hair dyed, flew to LA and made two more mvs back-to-back, returned to Korea, dyed her hair back, and made another mv. In a recent video she talked of the Korean concept of sacrificing yourself to create a good product.
Her longevity has already gotten her a 15+ year career…. I don’t think new technology is needed 😂
Not sure if u realize but IU is in charge and is very close to these people giving her their thoughts as she respects them..kind alike family this point. She extreme perfectionist and had to meet deadline for the mv track..
Absolutely, she is doing this of her own will - she has an incredibly tight schedule and the recording had already been postponed many times.
Please understand she has been in this game for quite some time and is well seasoned. She is not a newcomer in this industry being taken advantage of. She is in charge and knows her limits and limitations. Highly respected, hats off to this Queen.
She said in an interview she’d already rescheduled it several times. She’s in charge here and has worked with the main guy for 15+ years. She’s been producing her vocals herself since before the palette album which was many years ago. She can sing long concerts for multiple days and says it doesn’t hurt her throat at all the next day. I get that you’re selling your coaching products, but I think you can assume she’s taking care of her voice with warmups etc off screen…
Let's stop the argument here, guys. She has been a wall, a part of the turbulent and harsh history of kpop and has maintained her position as the queen of kpop for more than ten years now. She has it all: talent, experience, ethics, standards. Why is she the national artist of Korea because she is loved by almost everyone not only for her beautiful voice but also for her music? Her music is deep and colorful. She is also a talented music producer and musician with a unique musical mindset. Especially her lyrics are really meaningful. and each song carries a different message. She is history, the queen of KPOP, the wall of Korean music.
IU is the number 1 solo artist in Korea. Her musical achievements and awards are so numerous that even famous boy and girl groups that tend to go international have to dream of. In her country, she has been number 1 for a long time. She knows how to protect herself to stand at the top of glory for so long. With someone so talented not only in music but also in cinema, advertising, fashion... like Then we should protect her best. It's a gift from God to the public who love Korean music and other people like us.
In Korea, people listen to IU's music like they eat kimchi every day. IU is IU, she is simply the Korean public's own music genre, so listening to IU's music is a necessity just like what we do. pay taxes. Her music is guaranteed by all the biggest charts in Korea. An artist who is considered a national artist like in Korea is very rare. Furthermore in the history of KPOP Only she alone dares to face countless boy and girl groups from generation to generation that have not only been buried but have also risen to the top and shine until today.
I myself am a music lover outside of Korea, having lived in Korea for 5 years and really like her warm personality. She is the most charitable person in the Korean entertainment industry and does charity work frequently. from year to year.
A talented, strong-willed person. A woman who is steadfast in her musical philosophy and has an extremely kind heart, so she is loved and protected...
How good would this earth be if there were many warm people like that, there would be no more war, no violence, no discrimination, no discrimination... I hope all of you, whether you love them or not Even if you love someone, you will live a happy and joyful life.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Justin, I understand your genuine concern for her. I know that this is just your point of view as a vocal coach, but I wish you keep in mind that IU is for sure not a person who lacks knowledge about what she should do as a singer, especially about warming up or taking care of her voice. She certainly is well-versed about what is good or bad for her. As an example, there IU's "Good Day" which is a high three-key song. And at her latest concert, IU told everyone that it would be her last time singing it in her concert because she has to protect her throat now. So yeah, she takes care of her voice just fine. I agree that it wasn't ideal to sing when she wasn't fit enough, however, for this song, she had her reason to record in that condition.
With that knowledge, I wish you could focus more on how she was doing her best despite everything. Anyway, thank you so much for taking your sweet time talking about IU. Not just her MV, I'm happy that you paid attention to her recording video as well!
You know that her "Good Day" song doesn't sound healthy as well, right? The 3 high note parts? It's not good to tolerate her to sing using bad techniques because it's destroying her voice when they force her to do it. Just listen to the difference between healthy and unhealthy belt. You'll be shock with the difference.
@@yevgenyalekhinelargo1662 that's why she usually didn't do that part live expect for special performances. anyway that was years ago and now she's grown ass 30 year old veteran in industry who's careers is in it's 15th year. she has the money and resources to hire the best to take care of her voice, people more qualified than this dude for sure.
@@jwo122He was just expressing concern for her voice given her bad cold and strenuous singing. What's with the rudeness? His opinions are worthless just because he isn't as popular as IU?
@fabtins1993 sure showing concern is great but his uneducated options are not appreciated when he connects those concerns and opinions into promoting himself and his job stating how he can teach better techniques to protect ones vocals like IU doesn't know better. her vocal cords are worth millions and probably even ensured. she has resources that this guy can only dream about and yet here he is acting like he knows better. I've been watching this dude's reaction videos on and off since he first got started. he used to be genuine and sincere about his reactions back them but now he comes off pretentious.
I understand that you’re coming at this with the perspective of being a voice teacher, but there’s something a little bit condescending about your continuous comments about her needing a vocal coach or needing to do warm-ups when you actually have no idea what she did before this session or what kind of support she has outside of this specific clip. She is 30 years old, she has been a singer for 15+ years and she is notoriously self-directed and incredibly involved when it comes to producing and recording her albums. There is no reason to assume that she was not taking every precaution in terms of maintaining her health and her voice. She had already postponed this recording session multiple times due to her health, but had to record the song as it was needed for the music video for a pre-release. I think you might consider looking at her as a colleague with a similar level of knowledge to your own as opposed to someone in need of guidance.
He’s not condescending, he’s a professional vocal coach and it’s his job to listen to people and evaluate their voice to help them improve their technique so they can maintain their voice to have a lengthy career. Most idols, no matter how long they’ve been around for, do not get proper vocal training and understanding of how to sing in a way that’s healthy and sustainable. You need to stop babying grown ass adults and understand the difference between someone hating and constructive criticism from a professional
@@mylittlepeonies8693 I never said he was hating. I said he was being condescending and I stand by that.
Also, if this was done right after shooting the MV when she caught the flu. I believe she said that she had to cancel 2/3 times in the behind-the-scenes. There is a moment from this that was included in the behind-the-scenes at 4:50. I know he saw it because I saw his reaction to that scene. He should remember that it was bitterly cold and you could see the cold weather was having an effect on her. I do agree with you. We don't know what she did to get herself ready to sing. Are they supposed to film everything for the general population? Even if it was filmed they decided not to include it.
@@mylittlepeonies8693op never said "hate" chill, they were right, since reaction started he was like "omg ahe needs warm up", like where the hell it was said sge didn't do warm up? He repeated it like three times in first three minutes...
I think her illness actually helped with the fragile sound the song needed.
Maybe IU already warmed up her voice, they just didn't show it? But I love love love IU and her singing voice❤❤❤ IU has been on this line of work for a long time and I love that❤❤
I'm sure, that IU is doing the vocal warm up, whenever she does recording.. She won't be where she is now if she's not aware of the basics, which is the warm up..
16:59 another youtuber reacted to this and at that moment she even noticed how IU was not hacking too much when coughing compared to other person with colds and coughing their lungs out. She noted IU was kinda repressing the way she cough to somehow not create more damage to her throat or something.
Totally agree....
Thank you for the concern and input. But I am very sure that she did her warm ups and warm down before and after the recording they just did not show it here. And I am also sure that she has a vocal coach that is taking care of her voice as well. She has been in the industry for 15-16 years singing and acting plus she is one of the most beloved kpop artist in South Korea. You should listen to her “Golden Hour” concert. Her vocals are phenomenal.💜💜💜
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😮 pooo
Def not typical for IU - it's not like she's recording sick all the time. She was a real trooper here. Also very reasonable to assume her warm up just wasn't shown on camera
I can sense your genuine concern throughout the reaction, it's beautiful!
Please understand that delivery may be a little difficult due to the use of a translator.
First of all, I am enjoying watching the reaction video.
Thank you for frequently uploading videos about IU.
I thought there might be some misunderstandings in this video, so I wrote down a few things.
IU may look young, but she is a professional with nearly 17 years of experience and is someone who thoroughly manages her conditioning in order to be able to sing to her fans for a long time to come. If you only watch the recording production video of Love Wins All, you may misunderstand the situation, but I am writing this to let you know that this was a special situation and a choice made for the fans.
IU has held concerts every year since 2011, and when she was unable to hold concerts in 20-21 due to COVID-19, she performed solo through a TV music broadcast program in 2020. (Recording time: 14 hours) Also, since 2015. Starting with 'Chatshire', he is the producer who directly produces and takes overall responsibility for albums and has the authority to make decisions. He is also a singer who debuted in 2008 and has been active as a singer for nearly 17 years without a long gap.
The longest gap before this album was 1 year and 5 months, and other than that, we released music or albums within 11 months to 1 year and 1 month at the longest. However, the preparation period for this album was only 2 years and 2 months, which was the longest gap as a singer since debut. Although I filmed 2 movies and 1 drama, I reset the album work and produced it with a different concept. In a recent interview, IU said that she wanted to give her fans who had been waiting for a long time something to hear as soon as possible, so she chose the quickest way and path she could. As a vocal coach, I fully understand the desire to apply and convey what you think is a better method. However, IU chose this because, although her own throat health was important, she thought the fans' waiting was more important than that. Of course, the fans were also worried, but IU seems to be the person who supports them even more because she is like this.
The longest gap before this album was 1 year and 5 months, and other than that, we released music or albums within 11 months to 1 year and 1 month at the longest.
However, the preparation period for this album was only 2 years and 2 months, which was the longest gap as a singer since debut. Although I filmed 2 movies and 1 drama, I reset the album work and produced it with a different concept. In a recent interview, IU said that she wanted to give her fans who had been waiting for a long time something to hear as soon as possible, so she chose the quickest way and path she could.
As a vocal coach, I fully understand the desire to apply and convey what you think is a better method.
However, IU chose this because, although her own throat health was important, she thought the fans' waiting was more important than that. Of course, the fans were also worried, but IU seems to be the person who supports them even more because she is like this.
Thank you for reading this long article.
think she had deadline ..this was 2 days after finished filming with Vfor mv
She is the producer of the song and the album, she is the one who decided to do it, she already postponed three times because she was sick the whole time, she is a professional singer for almost 16 years, she is the leader of all her projects! You really don’t need to worry about her. She has already had the skills to become a vocal coach for a long time. She uploaded this video to show her professional side and make her fans laugh. Of course she warmed up!!! She is neither a rookie nor just a singer, but a very experienced singer who is famous for her vocals. She can even coach others' vocals. I don't know why you think like that just because it's not in the video. This is an edited video with only the singing and funny parts selected. If you watch the video, you can see that she is taking the lead and making decisions. The male voice is not the producer, she is the producer. The man only helps her because she needs to sing. They are old team friends. You can just enjoy her funny jokes and incredible vocal even in bad conditions. I appreciate your kind and caring heart, but I'm perplexed by your reaction...
it is still worrying? is he wrong for being concerned? she may be an experienced singer, and she may have warmed up, but it still is VERY concerning and NOT recommended to sing while you are sick. it's a widely known fact. everyone knows she had to meet a deadline, and everyone knows she is experienced, but his point is it is concerning to overwork your voice while it is vulnerable. you people in the comments are taking his reaction so deep and serious like you know iu personally it is hilarious.
Just cause she’s been in the industry for a long time doesn’t mean she could be a vocal coach, those are very different things lol it also doesn’t mean she won’t push way beyond her limit and that’s just not healthy in the long run, which he, as a trained professional, is pointing out
I don't know IU personally but, if I can believe in her own words, I know she's very careful with her health. She had problem with her hears and she consulted a doctor, she didn't take the initiative, so I'm pretty sure she won't do something inconsiderate... I'm pretty sure she has a vocal coach, too: she always speaks about how the singing lessons help her to improve her singing, and she is constantly surrounded by expert musicians. I'm glad that people are concerned about her health, but I think that in this case is a little too much 😬
@@chaseatlanticontop I said I appreciate his worrying but I’m just saying it’s unnecessary and I don’t like spreading misinformation like she doesn’t have a vocal coach or she is not taking care of her health or she is not the leader. I didn’t take his reaction too deep he is the one who take this video way too deep. I’m not IU but all of her fans know that she is very good at taking care of her health for example, she even try not to drink alcohol or soda for her vocal health. She even changed her vocal technique for the long run. Isn’t it very carful behavior? Of course she knows that it’s not recommended to sing while she’s sick. Like you said, everyone knows it. She probably doesn’t do like this usually, she probably thought it’s a rare and unexpected situation so she would like to share for fun. Look at her constantly making jokes in the video. Plus, We all know we shouldn't work when we're sick. However, there are times when you have no choice but to work. This applies to all professions.
@@chaseatlanticontop TH-cam videos have tremendous influence. People who don't know IU well and see this video will think that she is ignorant of her health, that her company forces her to work, and that she doesn’t have a vocal coach. I do think that part can be a problem. I just wrote down the facts. It is wrong to spread such false information without looking into it or knowing the situation. I just wrote down the facts. This is an easy fact everyone knows even if we don’t know IU personally. You are the ignorant and hilarious one.
drama 촬영도 있고
다음 곡들 MV촬영으로 미국까지 넘어가야해서 아파도 녹음을 진행해야 했어요😂
Well, all IU fans definitely has the same concerns with you regarding her health, and i thank you for wishing her well.
I defo agree that this recording condition is super terrible, but she must have a very strong and unavoidable reasons to do so, it is evident from the concerns from her staff even tho they soften it with jokes.
And i believe its only for this song, so hopefully they can minimize the impact.
Lastly, i believe she already do basic warm ups properly, just that part is less interesting hence they left it out of this video cut, otherwise she wont last until the end of recording. I mean, her career is very long already and full of ups and downs, so for her to go this far she must have taken a very careful care of her vocal cords and not skipping on the basics.
She Knows what she is doing... she has been doing this for a VERY long time.
Debuted in 2008... so 16 yrs in Sept. And the People she has around her have been with her for YEARS as well(Manager, Producers, Musicians, etc)
She is HER OWN BOSS, it's her label and NO one can tell her what to do.
She knows herself and her voice. She had already rescheduled... and her schedule is VERY tight.
I know you're selling your volcal program... and if you don't know what you're doing it can be an issue. This she is a PROFESSIONAL and knows what she is doing.
Yessssss I've been waiting for this video!!!
You have got to listen to IU’s song My Sea. Her voice is beautiful in that song. She shows you the her lower register.
Justin. IU debuted at 15 years old. She has tons of experience and knows her limits. You do not need to be concerned! You should watch a concert or an interview. She’s so awesome
She already suffer from some health issues and she recorded this song when shee just finished her MV in the cold whether and gone to Milan fashion week and then she started to record this . she's some1 who works hard throughout her career that's how she's been no 1 soloist for her 16 years of career.if you see her songs like My sea , good day,dear name, hold my hand she registered her high note very clearly.she just tired but when you listen lwa it won't show any struggle and she sang with such an Emotion and that's reached many audience heart 💜
Thank you so much ❤❤❤
So def did warm up before, they just filmed the recording part. The kpop industry is big on vocal training, so def sure she did what needs to be done. The main concern here is that she is sick, like real sick, it was mentioned she has flu, that's what making it hard for her to record the song.
I am Sure you did not mean anything negetive with your comments and only concern for her wellbeing in case of her being overworked by her company which happens to many idols is K Pop filed. But for your information her company is very supportive and open minded when it comes to her crafts.
As everyone said she knows what she is doing, she is one of the best in K Pop when it comes to vocal techniques and trying various new experiment with her voice. As all fans know she has the longest live concert duration after PSY which last to 5 to 6 hours solo, which is a hards task for even goups to perform. I am sure such an amazing artist would have a professional vocal warm up & warm down routine which alow her to put up live performance as good as her records for continues concerts.
Talking about her crew, they are basically her second family who have been with her thick and thin through out 15 years. This Recoding had to be done even in this condition only because she had postponed it 2 times prior to this. She also had a tight schedule during this period & also she didn't want to inconvenience her whole crew who worked so hard on this album or dissapoint her fans by delaying her comeback after 2 years. I am sure she had a good rest after this recording session.
형님들 싸우지들 마세요 ㅋㅋㅋ
이 채널주인 형님은 아이유의 목상태가 상하지 않고 최상의 상태를 유지하길 바라는 마음에서 한말들이고
댓글들을 남긴 형님들은 아이유는 16년을 음악업계에서 일한 프로다 알아서 잘할것이다라고 생각해서 한말같은데 서로서로 이해하고 넘어갑시다
Thank you for your video, I really like your work. You explain the whole process so well. In the behind-the-scenes video of this music video, IU, V asked her if she had finished recording the song, IU replied that she had not, due to illness. Apparently, recording this song is so difficult for her. She was in a hurry to release this song. We are also afraid that IU may burn out in this job. I wish her many creative years. I really love IU. ❤
When you hear her vocals in person at a concert, it sounds much more emotional.
Thank you Mr Justin for your great concerns to our IU ,don’t worry about her, she is with people who knows her & help ,inspire her in her singing career.
it's so funny that you think a whole huge pro team of her (a superstar of 15 years) and her company don't know what's good for her and only you, a youtuber know that...
Bro he’s just concerned about her voice. Is that wrong?
Sometimes singing when you are sick makes your voice sounds less powerful but more emotional... but props to IU for doing this. BTW she sounds just fine and gorgeous, its just that she wants the best. Love Queen IU.
Finally i was waiting for this man
Omg I haven’t watched you in ages I can’t tell you how excited I got when your name popped up
Her singing career is longer than your vocal teaching career for sure. Do not doubt her.
We all share your concerns about her condition during the recording. But in a strange way I believe it contributed to the character and situation of the video.
Exactly thats what she and her team said. She sounded better although less energy than the demo
She had already postponed the recording of the song twice because she had been sick recently, and I'm guessing that it was a schedule that she couldn't postpone anymore, or she had a deadline that she had set for herself, and then she caught a cold while filming the M/V in the cold weather, so it was a combination of bad circumstances.
However, one thing to note here is that she confessed in the album introduction interview that she has been fighting a battle with herself every day and has won it. For the average person, it's not easy to clearly say, "I've won my battle with myself every single day," meaning that she's the person she is today because she's overcome situations where others might say, "Why is she doing that?" This is not something that normal circumstances or common sense would understand, because it's her belief. IU is a 16-year artist with his own philosophy.
As a fan, I'm concerned for her, but she's been an artist for so long that she's probably already figured out how to take care of her vocal cords, otherwise she would have had to quit singing already. What we need to do with this video is respect her choice and recognize how hard she's worked.
I think you don't need to be concerned. She has been active for over 15 years and is phenomenal. They didn't show the warm up and cool down but i am certain they know what they are doing 😂
Thanks for your great advice. For your reference, I would like to introduce Big Mama, who has been protecting and maintaining vocal cords well for a long time. Their age range is in their 40s and 50s. Nevertheless, she still boasts beautiful vocals. Please react. You will also be able to see how they take care of their vocal cords.
Dude, she was singing since childhood. Don’t you think she’s aware of all the stuff you were talking about? Being in industry for so many years and still thriving in there is pretty clear proof of mastery and craftsmanship. Don’t be ridiculous
Thank you for voicing out your concern. Iam also worried for her.
she knows what she's doing. bcz she have 15 years experience
Lol I think you should take your advice regarding the delicate balance with commenting and criticism hahahha you got a lot of people riled up with this reaction. Anyways I agree that there's a risk for her to record in this condition and should not be emulated at all, but I'm quite certain she's aware of it too. It has been her main goal to have longevity, she has been in this industry for 15 years after all. But it's also wrong to assume she's does not know how to warm up her vocals properly because you didn't see it in the video. Other than that, I like watching different reactions.
Just for everyone to know, I'm not a vocal coach but I do sing, and we sing sometimes there are keys or tone and pitch that may sound great but we use wrong techniques sometimes, which is also unhealthy if continued. Reasons for that is tiredness, or maybe sick or not your range to contemplate this satisfying voice we want to release. That's why Justin said all things about IU in this recording. Because it might sound good but there are parts that sometimes isn't healthy and the major reason for this (in my opinion) is she's sick. After this, she needs huge rest for real.
"she needs a vocal coach in the room" my guy..she's THE vocal coach for her own voice. that girl has been at the top of the industry for more than a decade
I just don’t understand watching a VIDEO - that obviously started when they pushed “record” stopped when they pushed “stop,” re-started when they pushed “record,” etc….and THEN went through the edit process - and making the astonishing assumption that a 15-year veteran of the music industry would disregard vocal basics like warm up, need a vocal coach to achieve what she’s done tens or hundreds of thousands of times. Others have said you were sincere, but I wholeheartedly disagree. I think you were condescending, borderline disrespectful, and definitely dismissive of IU’s ability to know her own talents, her own limits. She’s a grown woman. It’s one thing to recognize the hardship and feel bad about it, but she doesn’t need your “protection” or your “victimization.”
And I say all this as a casual fan of hers, not even one very familiar with her 15 years of experience.
He doesn't know anything about her, and he sure as heck doesn't know anything about how K-pop world works. He's just doing a self-promo in all of these videos, trying to come off as this "perfect vocal coach", even though countless idols would've given him a run for his money. Idk who recommended him this video, but it really isn't working.
It doesn't bother me at all. Thank you for the honest concern, as someone who loves her I wouldn't want her to have to work while sick either. thank you for appreciating IU's effort❤
These people, it's not like she's always sick every time she's recording songs. We can all agree that this is the only time you have seen her record in this kind of condition. She wasn't born yesterday.
저는 진심으로 걱정해주는거 같아서 오히려 보기좋았는데 욕하는사람들도 있네요ㅠㅠ 거만한태도는 어디에도 느껴지지않았어요
그리고 사실 저렇게 아픈데 녹음을 계속진행하는것이 바람직한일이 아닌건 맞잖아요
Yeah, she's a pro and very knowledgeable but I think a lot of fans also want her to work with enough energy. Even the PD was talking about how it's crazy that she's recording, not because of her voice but because she's sick and unwell. In another recording video (day after this one I think) she mentions a headache that gets worse with using her falsetto. It's not just about damage to the vocal cords, she should not have to overwork herself while in pain even if it's her prerogative to do so.
She is a queen of kpop for some reasons and you understand now❤
I appreciate that you were concerned for her. I think we all were. But she knows her voice. I truly believe if she had real concerns about her voice, she would have called it. And she would have the right to do that, as she's the boss and has been for some time. Still, it's good of you to call these sort of concerns out to help more inexperienced singers understand the risks.
IU es muy talentosa
Ella es su propia jefa, aquí estaba contra el reloj por los tiempos del resto del equipo de producción
Don't worry about it too much, It didn't happened many times.. She wasn't in a best condition but it was not the worst during that time... She already postponed her recording schedule few times.
너무 귀여워 미칠거같아
❤❤❤❤❤
How can you believe she hasn't warmed up properly? She has been on the top of her game for 16 years...she knows her vocal instrument and ability better than anyone. IU is a professional and has been and is working with the best vocal coach for a decade...you are being presumptuous and condescending. There is a lot you can learn from this session...and he collaboration with her staff. This is her company and these are her people, they are her family she isn't being pushed by an entertainment company. Why do u believe you know anything she hasn't learned over the years.Bottom line, he is out of his depth and way over his head.
Please do react to the live one!
You are absolutely right!!! Listen...people wanna say that idols choose and they know what they are doing but thats the problem!!!! As humans we push ourselves so hard!!!! And the kpop industry is VERYYYYYYY gruelling!!! There is alot of pressure on these idols and so they will push themsleves to the every edge of total exhaustion!!! This happens with many idols and it is VERY concerning....it must be addressed....they are people befote they are idols and seeing someone not well, pushing themselves is very hard to ignore....so thank you for being direct and showing concern
음...형님이 생각한 k팝 아이돌이 지하 녹음실에서 목에 피가 나도록 연습하는줄 아시나본데 그렇지는 않아요 아이돌 연습생들은 정해진 시간에 보컬 트레이닝을 받고 댄스 연습을 해요
그건 축구나 농구 다른 스포츠계 선수들도 똑같을거라고 봅니다만?
아이돌의 비하인드 카메라에서 늘 땀흘리며 지친 모습으로 연습하는건 춤을 추며 노래하는건 그만큼 어려운일이고 체력을 요구하는 일이기 때문이에요
그게 k팝 산업이 힘든일이고 아티스트들을 힘들게 하는 요인이라면 그럼 더이상 k팝 산업에서 댄스와 노래가 함께하는 모습을 기대하시면 안될듯???
K팝 아이돌들도 이제 유명해졌으니 미국 아티스트처럼 앨범 하나내고 돈이 되는 콘서트만 다니며 노래만 부르면 만족하실건가요?
@@user-kb5dx6ft7r if someone who plays sports is sick they dont not play the game.....so why is it not the same for idols????? Would you like to see them push so far that their bodies can completely collapse? Is it not to rest for 1 or 2 days more to recover your health? Idols are not machines....when the body is tired it will shut down....these idols deserves to be treated like humans!!!!!!
@@CeeCee93형님 아이유가 누군가가 밀어붙여서 강제로 녹음했나요?
본인이 괜찮을거 같아서 자발적으로 녹음했는데요?
아이유는 이미 아파서 여러번 일정을 미루었고 더이상은 미룰수 없어서 녹음을 했어요
선수가 아프면 게임을 하지 않죠
하지만 부상이 거의 회복된 상태에서 중요한 경기가 있다면 선수가 팀닥터와 상의해서 게임을 뛰기도 하는데요?
아이유가 힘들어하니 동료 프로듀서도 힘들면 그만두라고 했습니다
어설프게 알고 단편적인 모습만보고 k팝 산업에 대해 부정적인 글을 남긴다면 모르는 사람이 보면 k팝 아티스트들은 전부 혹사당하며 노예처럼 일한다고 받아들일거에요
자신이 단편적인 모습만 보고 k팝 아이돌들은 다 혹사 당하고 있어라고 스스로 판단하고 있는지 생각해보시길 바래요
Your concern is very valid but not really in the case of IU, there is no one above her in her agency.. She is the one making final decisions.. The CEO himself is her old manager, and the whole team is a team she handpicked and worked together for a long time.. So the point is there is no one who can force her to do anything..
She has dropped songs with zero marketing, she has dropped songs at random times (mid night).. She doesn't really care about charting or anything.. She does what she feels like..
So no one forced her, she is working on a kdrama, and was shooting multiple MVs and attending events, and she was following her own schedule.. She pushed the recording several times before this, but ultimately decided to get it done..
@@rythrinx9998난 처음 글을 남긴 형 때문에 마음이 아파
한국은 계발 도산국이 아냐 음악 드라마 영화같은 엔터계는 거의 미국의 수준에 근접했다고 자부해
그럼에도 아직도 우리가 아이돌들과 아티스트들에게 과도한 연습과 트레이닝을 시킨다고 많은 사람들이 생각해
우리에게도 음악협회가 있고 무리한 일정을 강요한다면 고소를 당할거고 무엇보다 아티스트들의 팬들이 참지않아
아이유정도의 업계1위 아티스트가 앨범을 내면 앨범녹음 뮤직비디오 로케이션 콘서트 인터뷰 예능 등등 수많은 일정이 잡혀
그런일들은 수많은 업계사람들이 관련되있고 계속 일정을 미룬다면 그사람들에게 너무 미안해지니까 아이유가 자발적으로 녹음한걸로 보여
슈퍼스타라서 이런 무리한 일정이 잡힌거라 생각해 이건 미국의 슈퍼스타도 똑같을거라 생각해 한국 아티스트라서 그런건 아니란 얘기야
그냥 한국 아이돌이라 쉬지도 못한다는 이런 프레임이 너무 마음 아프게 한다 형
Im sure she has an amazing team behind her including vocal coaches, doctors, nutritionists etc. She is one of if not the richest kpop idol among all.
Well she is richest female kpop idol at present..
Hello there
So hardworking artist and very professional, she got sick in the middle of the shoot out of fatigue, because they want to launch a three music video within a week which is crazy and very rare for the artist 😮
Ok to feel concerned, but your new to IU & you don't realize she's a pro & has been doing this for many years. I'm sure she knows her own limitations & she trusts her team also knowing they have her best interests at heart. Maybe you can learn something from her Justine, every singer handles things differently!!!
By the way his name is Justin not Justine lol
@@natashangalande3413 👍
Justin l would wish if you react to GIDLE behind recording as these girls really incredible..they produce their own music
please react to the audition videos in the vocal survival show ' Build UP' !!
Please react to seventeen super and God of music
Hope that your sincere concern gets to IU
the tea is hot today sheeesh
She def warmed up first, she knows whats she's doing they just don't include that content in the recording
show how much a hard worker they are compare to us americans....oh i feel sick i record next time or concert cancel etc...as for them they record, preform and do concert while sick/injured lol
I do understand Justin's concern, but I also agree that it would be totally incorrect to assume that she doesn't have a warm up routine and that she didn't do so prior to the point where the video picks up.
The companies in Korea that train, market and support their artist invest heavily in them to turn out the best product they can. While EDAM is a smaller company, partly owned by IU, but the largest shareholder is a very large company EDAM was spun off from. All these companies have acting, voice coached, dance and choreo directors, music directors plus musicians on staff (depending on the number of artist they have under contract they can be full time people or under contract themselves with these companies.
In fact the biggest issue with many of these companies in the not to distance past has been the extreme control they have over every aspect of their artist lives.
any chance you'd be down to react to NMIXX's Recording Behind? it's a real treat how they document every single song on their albums in those videos :))
I’m really surprised her voice didn’t crack, especially the really high notes while being sick. I feel bad, but yeah she actually does sound better with this song being sick. I hope she didn’t push herself to do anything else after. 😢
형이 따끔이 한마디해줘
아프면 무리하지말고 쉬라고
우리 지은이 혼꾸녕 나야되😢
I'm sure she warmed up... it's just probably not in the edited version.
React to Enhypen cover BTS’s “I Need U” live
she worked hard to get to where she is now, hope she wont ruin her health
Justin please react to 'tum hi ho' mtv unplugged by Arijit Singh version it is full of energy and high notes you will see other side of Arijit Singh you can also check out 'kabira' mtv unplugged version please react to atleast one song one more song 'uska hi bana'
Also years of experience means NOTHING where your health is concerned....whether she warmed her voice or not she is exhausted and they could of least gave her a day or 2 to rest...we know idols will rather push themselves to the limits than rest but that is where her team should come in and make sure she doesn't push herself too hard.....
She pushed the recording several times because of her health.. mainly she caught the flu while shooting the MV in sub zero temperature.. In her agency/label, there is no one above her, the CEO himself is her ex-manager only.. So she is the one making final decisions on everything.. Specially when she is the producer of the album as well.
Her Solo concerts run 5+ hours, 2nd longest after PSY, its very clear she is very familiar with maintaining her vocal longevity...
Due to her schedule after postponing it several times, she just pushed forward with it, but she knows what she is doing.. as someone who has been not only singing 16+ years but also producing and composing songs..
I believe IU can take care of herself
Lol pretty obvious why he keeps harping on the fact that she needs “exercises” and vocal warm ups and cool downs because he basically makes money selling his vocal technique classes
EXACTLY. That's what his channel is for.
Killing voice Kim Bum Soo came out. I highly recommend it. He is probably the singer who touched Korean people's emotions the most. And he is also one of the wannabe singers that Korean singers respect.
Justin, I wish you could accept the fact you aren't qualified to critique artist who have at least twice your experience, and know themselves way better than you do. Practice humility and respect. Your channel is more about self promotion at others expense.
please reaction on ''Beparwah'' song by coke studio
please reaction Enhypen cover One direction-what makes you beautiful, I think you'll like it because it's so good
Please react on Pablo of Sb19, cover of this song. Thank you
Pls react to babymonster live performance you will be shook
I know you have convern for her but i Just wanted to bring to your notice that she has a routine but the agency usually crops out the part and keeps the main recording as their are many jump cuts there..... she has been in the industry for 30+ years and has faced it multiple times it's just that the recording had a deadline and she had already delayed it for long due to her health and had taken treatment before recording this sessionm
react to nayi soch
Hi, I always watch your reactions. Can you please react to TREASURE Park Jeongwoo - Weight in Gold (Cover) 🙏
IU is a national little sister of the Korean people.
react to bollywood music
The AUDACITY of trying to coach IU 😂😂
She’ acting, it’s just a parody 😂❤
she caught a flu during or before the recording
Please react to RED VELVET KILLING VOICE, BE NATURAL, ONE OF THESE NIGHT, AUTOMATIC And the last thing FEEL MY RHYTHM Recording version. I'm sure you'll like it. This is the group where rappers can sing and vocalists can rap great, while they always sing live and perfectly combine with choreography (FEEL MY RHYTHM PERFORMANCE VIDEO), there is a behind-the-scenes video about preparing for a world tour, it clearly shows how they jump and sing at the same time and their voice does not tremble at all
React to Dream by Babymonster
보컬트래이너 입장에서는 걱정되죠..팬입장에서도 어쩔수 없었다는건 알지만..