He's right you know, remember the Reapers? All the way back during the Ninth Doctor's run? Monsters that show up at particularly nasty paradoxes (like the one he described) and slaughter everything on sight. 15 is in no hurry to meet those things again.
@@Snowman13110 The Reapers showed up again in the comics when 3 Doctors ended up in the same place, at the same time, when they weren't supposed to. So technically, the 10th, 11th, and 12th Doctors also met the Reapers. If you consider that canon, then 15 has even more reason to not summon them again.
Those are the time paradox things anymore they've been kinda retonned. The time paradox thing is what happened after River saved the doctor now where time doesn't start back up
I think people are frustrated that a lot of the baggage is gone from the doctor. But I think that’s good let’s build some new emotional baggage. The whole point of the split with tenant as I saw it was that he will deal with the ramifications of their past while he can move on. And hopefully in his moving on new problems and things will happen that will organically lead to amazing stories that delve into his character again
An adoptee’s worst nightmare. This scene is utterly heartbreaking, but beautifully written, directed, acted, and scored. Being adopted myself, this hit my heart very deeply🥺
@@damienhine1861 Yeah, having that choice taken away from you and being denied the answers about your own life and birth story is such a horrid thought.
@@ThomasPeters2002 that's real. As it happens, I'm an adoptive father. My wife and I have gone to great lengths to help our kids maintain a connection to the past in the best way they can. It's complicated but, we hope, worth it. Speaking of the episode, I think this is definitely foreshadowing. The Doctor explains what would happen because we'll probably see exactly that happening and then they'll have to deal with the consequences.
@@damienhine1861 That’s brilliant, you’re absolutely doing the right thing. And yeah I completely agree, I think the Doctor and Ruby will end up back at that Church.
All those titles from Gallifrey he went into throughout the episode were likely people he knew, he wasn't just giving examples, but likely mentioning the late people of his kind, like when we refer back to someone who passed. But I don't understand why The Doctor went into revealing his name to Ruby and her Mother right away before the scan at the end was complete (Unless he figured it out before The TARDIS finished scanning) but he was so hesitant to reveal his name to Companions he had for longer and closer friends than Ruby (Such as Donna or Clara) which is why I think Ruby has more importance later on, or it's just a weird decision.
This is a *healed* Doctor. Essentially, 14 is resting with Donna, recovering from everything that’s happened to him, and now 15 has a relatively clean bill of mental health. Forget his name, remember how long it took to tell prior companions about the time war? And then how long he stalled before telling them the outcome of that war?
@@randomrazr It's a bit messy, The Doctor watched Gallifrey burn against the Daleks in the Time War (John Hurt) but later, with other incarnations froze it in a single point in time to save them from the Daleks (Mainly Matt Smith), but has been able to revisit the ruins of Gallifrey with The Master (Jodie Whittaker) and from my knowledge that's what's left of Gallifrey until the next story involving it comes along
I know this is a late reply but I think he was going to say "My name was Theta Sigma but then I chose The Doctor", Theta Sigma being his old nickname/the name he had until he chose his title when he was in the academy on Gallifrey.
At first I thought Ruby is Susan's daughter, but too many clues are pointing to River Song and the Pond era. And maybe it is just my imagination but Ruby is like Amy Pond at the first few episodes.
Any time-travelling tv show or movie I’ve ever seen has the same idea. If you go back in time and change ANYTHING, however small, the future is changed completely. It’s a pretty big concept to get your head around.
“We already did an episode where my blonde-companion wanted to go back in time and meet their parent, we got it right the first time, we aren’t doing it again.”
I'm calling it now, Ruby is going to be her own mother or something weird like that, or she'll be the child of the One Who Waits (or she IS the one who waits? Possibly, possibly) It's Doctor Who, anything is possible
most of it has to do with the fact he hasn't done that much on-screen work showing his range of emotions other then "Sex Education" thus folks immediatly see him as just another Diversity hire and for that I say well.....give it 3 to 4 episodes lets see where his range goes!
Nothing is worth chancing altering destiny or changing one's past of curiosity trying to say hello to someone from your past. The effect could cause painful repercussions across time and space. Curiosity this may already have happened it seems in the way you are watching that event on Ruby Rd there may be other tardis on the other side of the church out of shot just behind the church. If theories are saying that a doctor is there also, but is it not possible it's someone else who travels in a tardis which is possibly the Rani or Romania, or is The Master ( Missy) just a thought if the doctor can bio-regeneration so can Missy or any Gallifrian. And are the Gallifrians truly gone with the fact of bio-regeneration it possible they've survived the Cybermen ordeal in some bizarre regeneration process similar to the doctor's new bio-regeneration process? In fact is possible this process is the only time the doctor has regenerated this way the fourth doctor before him is the third but there is a missing regeneration between the second and the third doctor one unseen regeneration process did say the Gallifrian's interfere with more than what is going on to separate one into two as a failsafe process the third doctor would go on while other would do some missions for Gallifrey. Of course later the third eventually regenerates into a fourth doctor. The second eventually vaded from reality, but is that true or did he regenerate too? Mysterious figures in the Whoinverse ( DoctorDona and Bio matter Regeneration Crisis and Bio-regeneration, Missy and River Song and Romania and Susan Foreman and A Doctor formerly called Ruth who may be Ruby's adopted Nan? And what about Jenny)
While not a bad theory, I don't think we'll see Bi-generation again for a VERY long time if at all since it's very much hinted that it was only possible because of the Toymaker's presence and his reality warping shenanigans
I believe that's a 9 not a 0. It says she is 19 years +3 hours old. It's a little fuzzy so it's hard tot tell but I believe the actress and the character are supposed to be the same age.
Earlier in the episode, it mysteriously snows in the middle of a spaceship- just like the snow on her birthday. The Doctor is scanning her to make sure she's really human- which she appears to be, so there is something deeper going on.
You know eventually she will find outt who her birth mother is , also snow powers bit like Elsa from frozen . We also need to solve the mystery of Mrs Flood her neighbour.
I think her mom is Rose, the outfit the hair, and the carefree personality. Plus, it's a coincidence that Ruby was born literally one week before Rose meets the Doctor, it would explain why the 15th Doctor would be interested in who the hooted figure was, and why there's no record of Ruby's mom or Dad. And it would tie in with this being "Season 1"
@@Brand-New-Adventures While it would technically work- I don't see RTD pulling a "Rose had a daughter and just forgot to mention it the whole time." Plus she doesn't seem like the type to leave a baby at the steps of a church.
What is bs about it? He is explaining it correctly and is right. He can't take her there. Like he couldn't go back to see Amy and Rory when he lost them because of the paradox it would cause.
Hey man, seen your other comments. Can I just ask that you go? We don’t want you here. You don’t want to be here. It’s a mutually beneficial arrangement for us all if you just fuck off. Thanks.
@@chazo1367there’s no reason he couldn’t go back for Amy and Rory… the show just said he couldn’t… sure he couldn’t go back exactly when they got sent back but he could have gone back like a year after they got sent back
He's right you know, remember the Reapers?
All the way back during the Ninth Doctor's run?
Monsters that show up at particularly nasty paradoxes (like the one he described) and slaughter everything on sight.
15 is in no hurry to meet those things again.
plus he can’t go back either because he became part of events when he went back to save baby ruby from the goblins so they’re double screwed
@@mrscsi6472 Yeah, that too.
Shit use are right
@@Snowman13110 The Reapers showed up again in the comics when 3 Doctors ended up in the same place, at the same time, when they weren't supposed to.
So technically, the 10th, 11th, and 12th Doctors also met the Reapers.
If you consider that canon, then 15 has even more reason to not summon them again.
Those are the time paradox things anymore they've been kinda retonned. The time paradox thing is what happened after River saved the doctor now where time doesn't start back up
Ruby: why can’t I go back?
Doctor: Giant bats will eat people
Ruby: … wha?
Doctor: GIANT BATS WILL EAT PEOPLE RUBY!
Ruby: but… why?
Doctor: GIANT BATS-
Ruby: okay, okay fine…
Heh, tell your mum not to slap me? Is that a Jackie Tyler reference?
“Prove it, stitch this mate!”
- Jackie Tyler
@k-boi420 9th Doctor: 900 years of time and space, and I've never been slapped by someone's mother. 🤣
And Martha's, too.
Didn't Donna's mum also slap him, too? Besides the Christmas special slap that is.
@@michaelhughes7718 The only time I Remember was when David was the 14th Doctor
I think people are frustrated that a lot of the baggage is gone from the doctor. But I think that’s good let’s build some new emotional baggage. The whole point of the split with tenant as I saw it was that he will deal with the ramifications of their past while he can move on. And hopefully in his moving on new problems and things will happen that will organically lead to amazing stories that delve into his character again
given what happened when the doctor took rose to see her dad.....he prob didnt want a repeat of that AGAIN
An adoptee’s worst nightmare. This scene is utterly heartbreaking, but beautifully written, directed, acted, and scored. Being adopted myself, this hit my heart very deeply🥺
You mean being told she can't go back to see her birth mother?
@@damienhine1861 Yeah, having that choice taken away from you and being denied the answers about your own life and birth story is such a horrid thought.
@@ThomasPeters2002 that's real. As it happens, I'm an adoptive father. My wife and I have gone to great lengths to help our kids maintain a connection to the past in the best way they can. It's complicated but, we hope, worth it.
Speaking of the episode, I think this is definitely foreshadowing. The Doctor explains what would happen because we'll probably see exactly that happening and then they'll have to deal with the consequences.
@@damienhine1861 That’s brilliant, you’re absolutely doing the right thing. And yeah I completely agree, I think the Doctor and Ruby will end up back at that Church.
@@damienhine1861whether this side plot delivers is completely up to Russel.
All those titles from Gallifrey he went into throughout the episode were likely people he knew, he wasn't just giving examples, but likely mentioning the late people of his kind, like when we refer back to someone who passed. But I don't understand why The Doctor went into revealing his name to Ruby and her Mother right away before the scan at the end was complete (Unless he figured it out before The TARDIS finished scanning) but he was so hesitant to reveal his name to Companions he had for longer and closer friends than Ruby (Such as Donna or Clara) which is why I think Ruby has more importance later on, or it's just a weird decision.
This is a *healed* Doctor. Essentially, 14 is resting with Donna, recovering from everything that’s happened to him, and now 15 has a relatively clean bill of mental health.
Forget his name, remember how long it took to tell prior companions about the time war? And then how long he stalled before telling them the outcome of that war?
I think he was going to say "Doctor Who" cos that's (at least suggested) canonically the name he went with before the Doctor
so is gallifrey still like oblierated and the time lords dead....again at this ppoint?
@@randomrazr It's a bit messy, The Doctor watched Gallifrey burn against the Daleks in the Time War (John Hurt) but later, with other incarnations froze it in a single point in time to save them from the Daleks (Mainly Matt Smith), but has been able to revisit the ruins of Gallifrey with The Master (Jodie Whittaker) and from my knowledge that's what's left of Gallifrey until the next story involving it comes along
I know this is a late reply but I think he was going to say "My name was Theta Sigma but then I chose The Doctor", Theta Sigma being his old nickname/the name he had until he chose his title when he was in the academy on Gallifrey.
At first I thought Ruby is Susan's daughter, but too many clues are pointing to River Song and the Pond era. And maybe it is just my imagination but Ruby is like Amy Pond at the first few episodes.
I thought she might be river and the doctor's child and because of their dynamic River couldn't tell him she had his child
I have an odd feeling Ruby is somehow Susan's Granddaughter/Daughter
That's what I've been saying Susans daughter
Nah, I think Ruby is one of the Toymaker's children.
He never said it was impossible for her to see her birth mother on Ruby Road
My guess is still that Ruby is the hooded figure. Idk how it'll turn out but I just know.
She literally steps Infront of the doctor..
I like the time travel thing where you change something and it creates a different timeline separate from the original
Any time-travelling tv show or movie I’ve ever seen has the same idea. If you go back in time and change ANYTHING, however small, the future is changed completely. It’s a pretty big concept to get your head around.
Glad we finally get a alien companion haven't had one in decades
We don’t know if she is alien yet if she is she’s probably half alien,or she could be full alien we don’t know
Didn't we get Nardole in 2016?
@@fireflygaming8764he was more cyborg I think
@@bitlost2809cyborg alien
“We already did an episode where my blonde-companion wanted to go back in time and meet their parent, we got it right the first time, we aren’t doing it again.”
I'm calling it now, Ruby is going to be her own mother or something weird like that, or she'll be the child of the One Who Waits (or she IS the one who waits? Possibly, possibly)
It's Doctor Who, anything is possible
The Doctor: We can never create a paradox of that scale.
The trickster: You sure about that?
what the blinking flip
I dont get how people look at this and say he isnt good as the Doctor. Ncuti has already passed 10/14 in my books. He is Fantastic for the doctor.
Don’t take it personally. These people who say that are just trolls and and people who have never watch this show before.
He is a good doctor and I have watched for so long
most of it has to do with the fact he hasn't done that much on-screen work showing his range of emotions other then "Sex Education" thus folks immediatly see him as just another Diversity hire and for that I say well.....give it 3 to 4 episodes lets see where his range goes!
@@Clonest where will it go
I think that ncuti will be a great doctor defiantly the best since ten I never liked capaldi or 11
I’m calling it. She’s a child of the Pantheon
Nothing is worth chancing altering destiny or changing one's past of curiosity trying to say hello to someone from your past. The effect could cause painful repercussions across time and space.
Curiosity this may already have happened it seems in the way you are watching that event on Ruby Rd there may be other tardis on the other side of the church out of shot just behind the church. If theories are saying that a doctor is there also, but is it not possible it's someone else who travels in a tardis which is possibly the Rani or Romania, or is The Master ( Missy) just a thought if the doctor can bio-regeneration so can Missy or any Gallifrian. And are the Gallifrians truly gone with the fact of bio-regeneration it possible they've survived the Cybermen ordeal in some bizarre regeneration process similar to the doctor's new bio-regeneration process? In fact is possible this process is the only time the doctor has regenerated this way the fourth doctor before him is the third but there is a missing regeneration between the second and the third doctor one unseen regeneration process did say the Gallifrian's interfere with more than what is going on to separate one into two as a failsafe process the third doctor would go on while other would do some missions for Gallifrey. Of course later the third eventually regenerates into a fourth doctor. The second eventually vaded from reality, but is that true or did he regenerate too?
Mysterious figures in the Whoinverse ( DoctorDona and Bio matter Regeneration Crisis and Bio-regeneration, Missy and River Song and Romania and Susan Foreman and A Doctor formerly called Ruth who may be Ruby's adopted Nan? And what about Jenny)
To think of it, Ruby very much reminds me of Jenny.
Also, it's Bi-Generetion, not Bio-Generation
While not a bad theory, I don't think we'll see Bi-generation again for a VERY long time if at all since it's very much hinted that it was only possible because of the Toymaker's presence and his reality warping shenanigans
“ what the blinking flip “
what the sigma
Sounds like a future plot point to me 👀
Probably for this season
does anyone notice how it says 10 years old on her scan 2:29
I believe that's a 9 not a 0. It says she is 19 years +3 hours old. It's a little fuzzy so it's hard tot tell but I believe the actress and the character are supposed to be the same age.
Can anybody explain what he was doing at the end there with the scan
.... Scanning her
@@db5094 -_-
But why though...
@@Tythesly83 because she's not normal?
@@db5094Trying to find out who she is and who her birth mom is
Earlier in the episode, it mysteriously snows in the middle of a spaceship- just like the snow on her birthday. The Doctor is scanning her to make sure she's really human- which she appears to be, so there is something deeper going on.
she is so beautiful with amazing sheer hosed legs!!!
You know eventually she will find outt who her birth mother is , also snow powers bit like Elsa from frozen . We also need to solve the mystery of
Mrs Flood her neighbour.
Hmmm, water related.....
In season 2
Shes her own mum
I think her mom is Rose, the outfit the hair, and the carefree personality.
Plus, it's a coincidence that Ruby was born literally one week before Rose meets the Doctor, it would explain why the 15th Doctor would be interested in who the hooted figure was, and why there's no record of Ruby's mom or Dad.
And it would tie in with this being "Season 1"
@@Brand-New-Adventures And the Doctor is her father?
@@OTGGame Not sure how that'll work with the linetimes. Lol
@@Brand-New-Adventures While it would technically work- I don't see RTD pulling a "Rose had a daughter and just forgot to mention it the whole time." Plus she doesn't seem like the type to leave a baby at the steps of a church.
@@Dolthra Well they kinda forgot the Doctor had a granddaughter for years, so anything is possible. Lol
Bruh I can’t take the doctor seriously when he’s wearing that hahahaha
Nothing wrong with it. W 70s clothes
@@shemdellashemygd29 Still goofy
I think he looks great ! Especially with the long coat
Dead taste
@@shemdellashemygd29 triggered
Dr Nonce.
what a load of bs....
What is bs about it? He is explaining it correctly and is right. He can't take her there. Like he couldn't go back to see Amy and Rory when he lost them because of the paradox it would cause.
@@chazo1367 Same with Rose and the 9th Doctor. Caused all sorts of problems with the Reapers showing up. It's just not worth it.
How? It's the same rules as the previous seasons established.
Hey man, seen your other comments. Can I just ask that you go? We don’t want you here. You don’t want to be here. It’s a mutually beneficial arrangement for us all if you just fuck off. Thanks.
@@chazo1367there’s no reason he couldn’t go back for Amy and Rory… the show just said he couldn’t… sure he couldn’t go back exactly when they got sent back but he could have gone back like a year after they got sent back
TOTAL CRAP