If you enjoy this video please let me know and I can get her on as a guest again, she's too high profile to appear on camera but she has a lot of insight into China having grown up there. Thank you so much for all of your support, you're all bloody awesome!: patreon.com/serpentza
Yes. It was very interesting to listen to her perspective. I completely agree with the point that we need to cut China off at the root. To bring back manufacturing of all types to not only bring back jobs but in times of Covid, we cannot rely on China. How can we as individuals do more to move in this direction? Thanks for your channel Serpentza!
Great saying, too shame this also apply to people who only get their world view from channel similar to this one and never knew the other side of argument. You sounds like an educated person, don't cage yourself in this comfort zone, go see the world with your own eyes, not other's eyes.
@@yudilai6704 i dont think china is going to let me in and see their secrets. Or are you saying these channels are all lies. Well let us see for ourselves. Let us in. Lets have some transparently
@Philip Nguyen Well, one thing I don't like this video is the fact obedience to teacher and parents is idea passed down by Confucian thousands years ago, it's part of culture, not from CCP. CCP certainly does some injustice, but blaming something they didn't do is just not right. Truth is truth, I need to correct that. Second I just think this channel only expose negative side, you all need to see what argument the pro-china channel have and at least listen arguments from both side to gather full information before making judgement.
@@Geoduct123 yeah, China is not transparent, then how do you think Serpienza got all his top secret and information on China (since China is not tranparent, is Serpienza's information credible, where did he get his source? the thing is, since most of you only get to know China through his channel, he basically can say what ever he wants). Anyway I digress. You don't have to know the top secret to understand this channel is bias. All you need is simply a semester as exchange student in china. Many university have study abroad program. Just apply then you can go to China.
"The western world is not equipped or prepared to deal with the level of psychological manipulation.." Absolutely true. I lived in China for ten years myself. I tell people back home about these things, its hard for them to process the anecdotes and experiences I've had over the years. Thank you for posting this video, and everything else you do.
As a child of Chinese immigrants, I can confirm that a lot of this is true. It's frustrating. They never think about stuff and question things, they just accept it as truth. When I question back the reasoning for this and that - they see it as being closed minded because I'm thinking back. It's a broken system but I guess my parents had to follow it otherwise there lives would be ruined.
@Martin Purcell At least in the Western countries, people don't outright try to suppress the other views and instead try to argue over them openly and fairly. As long as one's arguments make sense, they can be heard. That is still much better than in China any day!
What I cannot take in, is that nobody in China (except perhaps the students who have traveled the world) are willing to give their lives in the fight for their own countries future. Everybody seems to be thinking only of themselves, and their immediate family. I hope I would fight and even die for my great """ great grand daughter's freedom (or move out of there as soon as possible, which I guess many have done) as my great great """ grand father did in our own civil war. Where is their courage to do something about it?
@Deos Manufacturing and factory jobs I guess. Sadly most consumers either don't want or can't pay much higher prices than they pay for stuff now, so it's not that simple. And neither do people want to work in factories for shitty pay.
@@thewholetruth4192 such utter bullshit, if you understood capitalism(capitalism is self sustaining) it can't eat itself, it's crony capitalism that is the cause of many problems exacerbated by too much welfare and too much government
I honestly used to think China was an okay place but after watching many of your videos and being educated on China, I now see how terrible the government is. Thanks serpentza!
No one wants China to be evil. The CCP are to blame. I only have love and sympathy for the ordinary people of China having to live under the foot of the corrupt CCP
Winston, please bring her on as a guest again. I really enjoyed the interaction between you two and her insight growing up in China. I have been watching you on TH-cam for years. This is my favorite video from your channel! Keep up the good work!!
I am Chinese, but I left China at age 7. I'm glad the truth is finally getting out. The world should disengage with China until the CCP collapse and the Chinese people are free.
@Skip Roche สคิพ The shock I had was the toilet water splashed on my butt. We don't have that in China, so it stinks, but we don't have poop water on my butt( it is a trade off, once I got used to it I actually prefer splashes instead of stinky smells). By the way, i didn't escape, I immigrate out, because china doesn't limit your freedom as long as you don't have bad record. It's harder to get into US. then getting out of China. I don't like how people always make china sound like a prison.
I truly want to believe that it’ll be that easy... however, after believing in these values for 70 years, do you think that the fall of them will lead to the freedom of people? Once they fall, people will need decades to get rid of the mentality... the problems are also so deep rooted in the society...
I used to believe this was just American exaggeration about CCP working on their own people’s minds. Then I met many mainlanders, here in Hong Kong, and... no they don’t exaggerate. This is scarily true.
There’s some sort of censorship going on in TH-cam, my comments keep getting deleted.. my comments involved Tibet , Uighur and culture revolution, and C c P don’t know which one triggers it?
Welcome to my life as a Venezuelan American. The authoritarian government in Venezuela tries to play mind games with us. I know this game that China, Cuba, Venezuela, etc. play, very well. Keep these videos going.
@@pvn2474 If you pretend there is anything remotely like what communist countries do in terms of brainwashing and manipulation in the west, then you're brainwashed, dishonest, or dumb. Stop with this "the west is just the same" nonsense because it's blatantly false.
@@linuxatheist5361 Yeah, I agree. While the west does do really shady stuff, at least you have the LIBERTY to to express your opinion most of the time.
i am just scared for africa. As an east African, I've been to most countries in this region and the Chinese influence is overwhelming from Djibouti all the way down to Zambia .
When I taught at a university in China, I basically had to give a lesson on critical thinking and what I expected from my students. ... and I still had to remind them once every couple of lessons.
30 years ago the US should have been watching their back instead of running in head 1st with little regard for what would happen down the road. Now untangling the mess is near impossible without major losses.
I think arrogance was a factor. With the breakup of the USSR, America/ the West thought communist countries would open up when they saw the trappings of democracy, freedom of speech and free market. This doesn't mean countries in the West don't have some traits of communism. Banking would be an example, they are protected by governments, often at the detriment of the citizens. This is also a deeper and more complex problem of the way governments/ the economy/ and banking are intertwined, it's much more palatable for a high number of individuals to go bankrupt, than even a tiny drop in growth. Inflation is really just a river for wealth to flow from individuals to the banks (It costs money to store savings in a bank with essentially zero interest). Went a little off track there, hopefully it wasn't just a rant. But who doesn't enjoy a little rant once in a while? 😉
@D Theresa That's true (let's not talk about IBM [US] in WWII). On the flip side, it's only been a little over 60 years (75 if you want to be exact) since the end of WWII yet any animosity between the allies & Germany & Japan has long since been dropped (there's that Back to the Future 1985 reference that "all the best stuff's made in Japan"). China has gone the opposite way to Japan. instead, they've moved backwards and now look more like 1930's Germany. As a Brit!🙄 With a keen interest in WWII seeing the way China is acting now (this exploded [wrong term] on the 75 anniversary of the closure of Auzwhitz) the parallels between them are pretty terrifying: 1# Concentration camps, check! 2# Burning Books, check! 3# Growing nationalism/ hatred, Check! #4 Seizing foreign territories, Check! (With HK (HK is gone, claiming township of territory everywhere, and if they thought they could take Taiwan they would!), #5 CCP is acting like the SS secret police, Check! - That's just off the top of my head! I believe Jinping is more dangerous than Hitler. Hitler gets a lot of stick, but he wasn't a total 6astard/ psychopath as he dispised chemical/ biological weapons (he had them, and so did the allies...), but there was some sense of a gentleman agreement in place. An unspoken treaty if you will. Before WWII broke out there was never this level of aggregation. I believe a lot of this growing aggression is because they're getting desperate ("appear strong when you are weak, appear weak when you are strong" - paraphrasing Sun Tzu, they wrote the book on military strategy), and desperate people do desperate things. That's before we add communism to the mix. That's my take on things...
yorkaturr Yea I experienced it in Rumania. Same crud all over the world, and now they’re trying it in the USA. When you’ve seen it before, it is so obvious. What is dangerous is all the ignorant people who believe the propaganda.
@@cupcakechronicles4551 The Indians have Pakistan on one side and China on the other. I can see why they are paranoid and might grow hateful towards China as the CCP influences the other nations to turn against India.
Watching you since 5k subs and seeing how you are now the voice China needs right now is amazing. You've come so far since beer girl times and the cultural shock. Really happy to see you keep making truthful videos.
Love your videos! I have lived in North America all my life, so your videos help give me a perspective from a different point of view. Keep up the amazing work
I am a Chinese born and raised but I left before Winston came to China. I left at the end of JIang Zemin's reign, 2002. Back then propaganda was there but was not extreme as it is now. As far as I can recall the CCP was pretty mild in foreign politics. But there were a lot of war stories being taught in school in favour of the CCP. One of them is about 5 red army soldiers holding off hundreds of Japanese soldier from the top of a mountain and another one is the "infamous" 雷锋. Can't say everything was bad with the Chinese education system, but I do have to agree with that is being said in the video. It just beats the individualism and critical thinking straight out of your ass. When I say beat it out of you, I mean literally. I have had fair share of beating by the teachers because I didn't agree with them. The funny thing is, as after I came to the west, and was able to easily access all the information I wanted the Chinese propaganda being exercised seems just like house of cards, fragile. I think closing off China from accessing western media is the best thing CCP can do for itself and the worst thing they have done to the Chinese people.
Hey Winston oh, that was a great interview. I can't begin to imagine how difficult that would be and then as you grow older and find out that everything was a lie what that does to your confidence as a person. Wow she was really Brave to tell you everything that happened to her and what she went through. Thank you for sharing and please tell her we wish her all the best. And we are really happy to see you guys go out and about at different locations in California. All our best to you Shelley and Hugo
WTF, I am offended. Why would you think Chinese work against America's interest, can you provide some evidence. This is a pretty heavy accusation, it put all Chinese American's reputation on the line. Are you going to say Muslim immigrants secretly work for their "Holy War" next? Why are you polarizing America, are you some kind of Russian spy that tries to polarize the UNITED States? What part of word "United" do you not understand?
What kind of hope did this channel give you? I am curious, this channel seems pretty negative, can you explain how you get the hope out of negative information?
@@yudilai6704 Lying to yourself that everything is okay, and everything is positive --- That is the fountain of real hopelessness. Admit the negative things, and be goddamn better. That is true hope. Of course, you might not be able to understand, based on your understanding of hope. You don't want hope, you want illusion that everything is fine. Because the moment you admit there is negative, you realize, deep down, you're desperate.
The opening footage is precious! Enjoy being a parent the most challenging and pleasurable years of your life. Thank God you guys made out of China when you did. Peace be with you and yours.
Information like this needs to come into the awareness of people all over the world. They need to understand who they're dealing with, it's the first step to healing. Get her on again, she's knowledgeable and very succinct in her explanations, nice to hear!
It’s absolutely true that they are always loyal to the CCP no matter they get a green ,red or blue passport.We should treat them in the same manner the way they treat us.Why should we give them the same privileges when our people are struggling to get basic rights from the regime.Ponder over it.
Hans Chinese as your best friend today, then getting a signal from some leaders boss, or any CCP agents... He/She becomes your ennemy in less than 1 second!
I think you get it confused. The westerners in china are residents, not citizens, just like the resident here in the US they have many restriction, for example, a lot of jobs are not available for residence. In addition, there are also glass ceiling for Chinese ethnic citizen in US that prevent them from applying in critical position, unequal treatment really goes both way.
I was involved in a Chinese exchange program here in the US where I worked as a student aid and I always felt like the students were lacking creativity and critical thinking. Very interesting that you both pointed that out as well.
Broke up with my Chinese then girlfriend and the madness started. Contacted my employer, Asian coworkers, friends and family back home, Facebook friends, even paid money to one guy back in my home country to help. He accepted the payment, but that was their doom. Found out about it and now had huge leverage on them. You either leave me alone or I involve the police (I'm in the U.S.). Counted on their "save face" thing and it worked.
By all means have that guest back again. You are fortunate to have found her. I know literally dozens of Canadians who taught in China with me who either can't or won't see or say anything negative about life there. Most people just can't grasp the truth that what happens in China can happen here and are unaware that our institutions are already wobbling under the sheer weight and genius of Chinese propaganda. The west has become intellectually fat and lazy, and can't comprehend that China is watching us trash and burn our own history with glee. Our current flirtation with Socialism/Communism is a direct result of 4 decades of indoctrination. Keep up the good work.
Early upload today? Niiiiice. Gonna grab the lunch, enjoy, and comment afterward. This is mainly an initial comment to help promote interaction for the algorithm.
Then I question why did our business men go in in teh first place? To get rich and they f.. dont' care about us normal americans.. and you dear is stupid as f..k.
Faced between China and the U.S. , i knew which was the right choice. CANADA! Chinese endoctrination start in kindergarten. Every morning, Salute to the flag and national anthem.
@@whatwhatwhat51 I've never ever been forced to sing the anthem, I will on July 4th cause it's hype but we can never turn to the same blind nationalism as China
@momentinpassing Every group of people ever has committed a misdeed at once irrelevant comment
4 ปีที่แล้ว +1
@momentinpassing Look, you benefit from all the social services nations provide, and all the infrastructure they put into place. If you don't want to benefit from them then move off to an island and start your own colony, or..be grateful and show a little support to the nation that's given you the opportunities that you have
Thank you and your friend. Over the past seventy years, only few westerners realize the evils of the Chinese communist party. But people like you are really helping China and let people around the world knowing what’s really happening in China except the Chinese food and Kongfu.
Your insights into China come at the very right time. Our German coward government was appeasing the dragon, just like they appease every bad thing, because they are 3vil themselves. I'm really looking forward to the other topics. Your respectful and truthful way to cover all this is really something of great value to me, because truth must be told in order for changes to be able to happen. I think, you are doing a very important thing for the Chinese people! Greetings from Germany and God bless you and your family.
@@KingslayerMax For months our chancellor found no words for Hongkong and they regularly don't speak up regarding the human rights issues - to maintain "good relationships" aka business. Germany and the EU are becoming more and more centralist states, opposition is branded as right wing extremists. They more and more are using the same tactics like the CCP is using them or like they have been used in the socialist GDR, where Merkel was an agent for propaganda in their youth organization and she studied in Moscow, which not everyone could do. She is a communist at heart.
The problem with Germany is that, due to their past, it’s taboo to discuss differences between different peoples, and thus they assume everyone is just like them.
This ''Woman'' is Brilliant ! Your sense of the situation is spot on, everyone needs to hear what you have to say. Its an immense obstacle to overcome, and the level of indoctrination will become more severe as tensions heat up.
@@vodkawhisperer3923 I don't think she is observant, I think she is just holding grudge on the strict, harsh education that she went through because she didn't do so well. I think she blame the government for her failure in school.
@@muajin 🤣 wake up kiddo. Who runs all media, academia, major cities, etc? Trumps opposition are literally fascist communists. They will criminalize facts like "men are not women."
Her opinion is the same as mine. I am Chinese but since my mother has citizenship of another country, I was lucky enough to be accepted into an international primary school. I enjoyed my early schooling years, made a lot of friends, and was a very confident child. However, from secondary school, I entered a state-run one (ironically because of my outstanding academic performance) and I was severely bullied for three years because of my bluntness, to the extent that I couldn't speak in front of more than 3 persons. I left China in high school and slowly rebuilt my confidence since then. If you are educated in a Western way, you will be more outspoken and stright forward with your thoughts. That makes you a target in Chinese schools.
@Frogsquatch until covid i worked at a TH-cam channel based company, it's just the term burned into my head sadly is all but i take your point positively
s8v0t2 Well all I can think of is... imagine being brainwashed and then having to re-learn everything when your 20. It doesn’t sound like she’s had an easy time. I emphasise with her on that. Maybe not just like her but I would be angry too.
man, they re scared of me (thinking that i am a disease carrier) everywhere now: metro, elevator etc. They try to do similar manipulations in Russia (where i m from), but it's not working, I live in China for over 5 years now, just started my channel, can't fully share everything that I want to say in my video blog , but at least something relevant
I can imagine how that would affect a person living in China for so many years. I got to know some Chinese people here in Arkansas who came here from China and mentioned how tough it was and how parents there don't want to feed their babies milk produced there in China.
Hi Winston, loving all of your videos, i have only just started to watch your channel, Laowhy86 and the other channels you have since the lock down but i have binge watched a lot of them. i am from Oxford in England but i am currently living in Ho Chi Minh , Vietnam and have been here since 2007. i am half way through my 14th year. i married a Local Vietnamese Women and have 2 children. i also bought property here in Vietnam. My job is a little different to 85% of the other foreigners here in Vietnam. I restore antique furniture/French polisher. i came from England to teach the Vietnamese workers on how to make new furniture look antique and old and we manufacture reproductive antique furniture. I loved your video on the different categories of foreigner video you did. i feel i can relate to a lot of what you and Laowhy say any many of your videos. Vietnam's Government is not has bad has the Chinese government , it has if they only really push the propaganda when they are having a bad time or someone in the governments having a bad day. (if you understand what i mean). hope to speak with you and Laowhy sometime if ever you are free and if you are ever back in Vietnam i would love to meet up with if you ever wanted to. love to the family and keep up the great content. Stay awesome.
@love n sweet2008 you are definetly not a Vietnamese ! And you are not living in Vietnam otherwise you would not talk nonsens about racism. Everybody who lived in south east asia knows very well about racism there and Vietnamese hates Chinese! And many in south east asia are racists and hates foreigners. So dont tell people nonsens! And China is very racist about foureigners you talk big shit man
Ben Weston, your comment started off really good and then I had difficulty working out what you are trying to say, round about where you say "i feel i can relate to a lot of what you and Laowhy say...."
If they did, they would blast her picture all over the internet and doxx the shit out of her like they do to anyone who challenges the communist agenda of all the MSM outlets.
Ydu Senu Even 'liberal' Western outlets like CBC and CNN are beginning to take note of China's human-rights abuses. Maybe the long honeymoon with Chinese capitalism (under the ironic CCP brand-name) is nearing its end. If so, praise the Lord. Praise Him regardless, because he will not allow the wicked to prosper forever. Btw do you remember that Donald trump called Xi a 'great man'?
@@SirPunch2Face A crash course in history and political science is recommended. CNN is a liberal-centrist outlet; in fact some of their favorite guests are moderate Republicans 9hardly Marxist firebrands). Don lemon is an ex-Republican. Opposition to Donald Trump does not equal communism. Indeed it was Trump who praised Xi as a 'great leader'. He did not hesitate to invest in the USSR during the 1980s, which also showed them up as not-so very communist after all. Anyway, eternal salvation is not determined by partisan loyalty. It says that 'if you confess with your mouth jesus as Lord, and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved' (Romans 10:9). Unfortunately, loyalty to the CCP is NOT compatible with salvation, and it's pretty obvious why. Following the CCP to the end can only assure one of a place in hell. Yet God is willing to forgive the repentant sinner.
If Winston says he’s working for himself what’s the visa he’s got so he can stay in US that’s my biggest question knowing that it’s not easy to get a working visa and lots of abuse with people overstaying tourist or student visas in US. I think someone is sponsoring his visa because if he’s working for himself doing what exactly?
That's his private life, he doesn't need to tell us everything. Why should he explain himself to his TH-cam audience?. If I was him I wouldn't tell anyone a thing about my private life also, especially in this day and age where one person tries to ruin another persons life just because they're jealous or simply don't like their videos.
Okiebryan Wow such a smart reply not. He’s afraid to say what he’s doing in US because basically if he’s here illegally or using a visa illegally he can be in big trouble but he doesn’t say what his job is how he got in US he’s not from America so it just doesn’t make any sense to me that’s why I ask and I’m an American citizen so I would like to know
Okiebryan also I’ve seen enough of his bazaar videos where he acts like the Chinese government is spying on him constantly well he can say what he wants about the government says he’s not in the country but I’m sure if he was doing these anti-government videos while living in China he would’ve been deported or in prison because the Chinese government doesn’t take kindly to derogatory statements about the government. And his wife’s family could be in jeopardy for anything he says about the Chinese government. I lived there for a while but it makes no sense how Winston always makes himself act or seem like he’s so important he’s not I heard how he came to the country with no money and living on the streets really who does that
I teach Chinese kids for a living and yeah, I tend to agree, they seem to be completely incapable of critical thinking or questioning anything. I don't ask them to criticize the CCP or anything like that, but I will ask them what their opinions on certain subjects are and they always give either the same answer, or the answer they think *I* want to hear. It's sad when I go day after day doing the exact same thing with these kids and I can never really get them to tell me how they *really* feel about anything. American kids never shut up, they'll tell you how they feel about every little thing on the planet, changing their minds often, but Chinese kids always have this sort of pre-programmed answer in mind and that's pretty much it. I often wish I could get through to them to get them to think more in-depth about subjects, but I realize that I'm up against their *entire* schooling system and constantly being trained *against* the sort of dialogue that I seek to establish. It's frustrating for sure.
And I don't want to overgeneralise stuffs, but the general public in China, I mean in Mainland PRC, are also pretty evil. (Disclaimer: I never mean ALL! I have good friends who are in it from China as well, as there are always exceptions to the norm.). They are not purposely evil overall, but they have been poisoned with the very simple single value: money! Have you heard of the tens of cases a year at least that drivers would reverse the car to hit the person again if (s)he was already knocked on the ground and fell unconscious! It was simply because of MONEY! The law says that the driver needs to pay for the medical cost of the injured, so they chose to kill the person to avoid that probably large amount of compensation needed! You should get what I mean here… So you can see, Mainlanders only concern about money. In that way, they wouldn't care about what the government is doing, and would become very easy to be controlled! With that guiding principle in their minds, except the very few extraordinary and 'outcast' people, nothing is important except money, and nothing is more important than wealth! And that's why you have seen those far-below-standard dangerous constructions and infrastructures, those poisonous baby formula milk products (not only ONCE, but MULTIPLE TIMES for God's sake!!! 🙈). We have to realise that not only the CCP Government is evil, but its people, at large, have been indoctrinated and trained to be heartless, for the easy control by CCP. SO, when we say that Chinese from PRC are doing this or that damages to the civilised western world, we have to be very clear that not only CCP is the wicked giant, but unfortunately the Chinese people, although as victims of brainwashing themselves, have been commiting the bad stuffs themselves. And who suffer most after all?! We other Asians! Because in the eye of Westerners, they can't easily distinguish us just by seeing our appearances, and not only Hongkongers, but also Japanese, Koreans, Vietnamese alike, have been thought to be Chinese, and sometimes discrimination or even bullying happened. We plead for a better understanding of the differences between Asians, and hopefully people can really get to know the person first before deciding whether (s)he is a brainwashed Chinese (usually a little pink) or not.
I teach them too (in an international high school for PRC citizens). Personally, I think it is more that they are taught to carefully consider how their actions, thoughts, and words will benefit them (either financially or give them guanxi) in a system totally different from the west. Giving your views more often than not does not result in favorable outcomes for them personally. It's more like they are afraid they will be denied limited resources by being too demanding or standing out. But to be fair, both you and I are generalizing. Everything seems to be about money and personal glory, rather than morality and "living a life according to your values" like we have been taught to do. Honestly, I talk to their parents though, If I were them, I'd be scared to challenge them too. Most of my parents rule with an iron fist and aren't afraid to emotionally damage their kids if they think doing so will result in them getting a high paying job after college. Plus every school that isn't 100 percent international has to have certain mandatory subjects, like Chinese Political Science. They have to take an exam to get a Chinese HS diploma and politics is on that test, just like it is on GaoKao. Every politics teacher I've met was a stuck up asshole who will do whatever they can to point out how blameless the government is and how fucked up the US is. I don't get into arguments over stupid shit with brainwashed co-workers though, so I just try to teach my own students the truth, if they are capable of understanding it, and try to move on with my life. It's a pretty good paycheck and soon I'll have enough to buy a house and leave China. Besides, a lot of my kids walk away with a less skewed version of history and global politics, even if I am not teaching those subjects. I'm proud of helping the kids that care enough to learn from me over the years.
My brother supports the CCP, when I argue with him, he says that I was brainwashed by the Western media, well I said that I think the Chinese people were the ones brainwashed he said that I was distorting the truth, then I argued back saying that at least here I have free speech and I can say whatever I want without going out to "drink tea" with the police. So after that he started insulting me, arguing with arguments that make no sense, he is also an ultra nationalist and he says that the democracy in Western countries is fake and we are being braiwashed. Well I think I will let him be...
This was terrific! I'd enjoy much more from her - and things are getting pretty spicy between US & China. USA too permissive for many decades now - I say reel it back in!
I'm from Scotland, i meet a young Chinese girl and was showing her our town all was good till I mentioned I was an S.N.P member we advocate a free Scotland, the conversation went very quiet and she said to me I shouldn't be against London rule I should be more loyal to London, that was it she walked off on me as I tried to explain it was our democratic rite to seek independence
she was right though. There can be no United Kingdom without Scotland. In that case the whole country would have to reform and split back into England and Scotland.
@@Kvothe1994 we were an independent country till some free mansions and beer barons meet in Edinburgh and bribed sitting members of Edinburgh parliament to vote for a union a totally undemocratic process where our assent is removed and a portley fixed sum is paid annually to buy us off,
Please don't try and give the impression that Brainwashing is unique to China, Russia ,or South Africa for that matter. Every country has its own form of Brainwashing but in Western countries the art is more subtle.
These days I feel like most of the brain washing is coming from communists though and people compromised or linked to them. Communists aren't just in China
I studied in China until 10th grade, and I am so sorry for your experience. My education in China was not even this brainwashing; most people still kept their wits to them.
I live in a fairly rural, mostly agrarian, state here in the US and I see A LOT of Chinese people but never out and about. My small city has a few Chinese-style restaurants and the staff is primarily Chinese with differing levels of English proficiency. There are some beauty and nail salons run by Chinese immigrants as well as massage, chiropractic and acupuncturists. I recently went to hospital and saw a group (dozen or so) of Chinese people being given a tour with a translator. However, we never see these Chinese people out in the community. I never see them shopping in the stores. I never see them in the parks. I've never seen their kids in schools other than University. I've never seen any attempt to integrate or mingle within the community. Even in University, the few Chinese students there seem very unwilling, or at least hesitant, to socialize, at all, with non-Chinese students.
That is a common observation - where do they all live? Usually in upscale communities they can be seen walking. This may be a result of there appearing to be more than there really are. More likely though is packed in small apartments!
when PUBG came out a few years back, being in Australia we would be paired with SE Asia and Asian server's so iv played alot of games with the Chinese and SE Asian's, i find that se a's are inquisitive and have an interest in learning and sharing cultural idea's and friendship. Most of the Chinese however just rant Guilo, or China #1,....(not to mention cheating/hacking is not frowned upon in there culture) it's on a fanatical level when put into an environment like that.
Very interesting interview. As someone who has not lived in China but who follows the media and has (at least in my own opinion) a certain amount of common sense, I could not agree more. I would definately like to hear more from your guest. She seems very competent and very experienced about China. So, yes, I would love you to have her as a guest in future videos/audios. Although I already told how I appreciate your channel in an older comment, I want to add: Your channel is a very rare and valuable thing because there are not many people who have such an inside view into the Chinese society, who speak the language and who have actually lived their everyday life in China for such a long time. Your statements have weight and I am thankful that you take all the negatives that come along with it and still make the problems public. At the time mainly problems, but people forget how you also praised the positive sides of China and how you love China and it's people - why in the world would you have lived in China for so long if you wouldn't like it's people. But of course, once you put your finger on a foul spot, it oozes out and all the good things you said are immediatley kind of forgotten. That's sad but that's how things seem to function. Voices like yours are making the difference. I have become an intense follower of your channel (and Cmilks and Vivi's - whom I both found via your videos). Thumbs up and keep on going.
chinese people spread out to the whole world. they have a strong relationship all around the world. here in ASEAN, most of them are rac1sm but they always play as a V1ct1m. in Malaysia, they proudly said: "i am malaysia-chinese" . also the same thing in Singapore and Indonesia.
She's talking a lot of good points. She saying cut them off and that's 100% agreeable but at the same time there are more than enough reasons to do so and just the latest is the corona pandemic. For not handling the outbreak better by notifying other nations of the situation.
Dennis Hink *Last time I checked, the USA did not subjugate Tibet, Mongolia, Hong Kong, nor build artificial island/military bases in the Philippines Sea, nor release a global pandemic (again). Checkmate, tool.*
@ They invaded Tibet, placed the Uighurs in concentration camps, have live organ harvesting practices for the Falun Gong and dissenters, destroy churches and have tried to rewrite the bible and Quran to benefit the CCP, and intentionally spread a virus to the rest of the world using their own people. Bush and Obama are not in control anymore, Trump is president and has not been involved in anything that you've mentioned. Meanwhile, Xi is probably racking up more organs and dead people and is president for life in China.
This is amazing. Can I have a source for this information? The both of you who because I'm an American and of course I know what America has done and I'm not proud of it and do think it's wrong but I'd like to know more of Chinas history as well.
@ Last time I checked any protest in China regarding the policies of the CCP will get you imprisoned or worse. You have no idea what you're talking about... CCP is your god.
China has done a lot of arm twisting and encroachment into its neighbouring countries' territory We in India have had to deal with this bullying for a long time. Please make a video on this.
The part about the educational system method from China sounds very similar to the one in Japan... 😔 I've been in Japan for 16 years now and have 2 daughters, and I am really thinking to move out for the sake of their future because of the same issues the lady has mentioned. Great job you're doing serpentza!! 😉👍
No clue what's she is talking about with lies being taught in international schools in China... . There is a big difference between international schools and private bilingual schools. Having spent time in international schools in China during my school education, we didn't have any of that at all. We stuck strictly to the curriculum we did(one of the major international ones) even the incorrect bits(for example the invention of the compass)
I totally agree with you William I taught in an international private school in Shanghai and I think what this woman is saying is completely bizarre to me
Yeah... But they were probably suspicious of why a grown man was filming young pupils. If I did that in Norway someone would call the police on me immediately.
@Camz C yeah, flood is getting worse each year, but that's how it is for natural disaster all around the globe. The forest fire in California is getting worse each year
If you enjoy this video please let me know and I can get her on as a guest again, she's too high profile to appear on camera but she has a lot of insight into China having grown up there.
Thank you so much for all of your support, you're all bloody awesome!: patreon.com/serpentza
As a dude who likes 95% of your stuff, and watches 100%, all of these videos that are a little different, are always welcome.
Bring her in!
Public schools here full of brainwashing too they teach hate white people communism is great tear down capitalism
You should get Vinny the Poo on for an interview.
Yes. It was very interesting to listen to her perspective. I completely agree with the point that we need to cut China off at the root. To bring back manufacturing of all types to not only bring back jobs but in times of Covid, we cannot rely on China. How can we as individuals do more to move in this direction? Thanks for your channel Serpentza!
“Birds born in a cage think flying is an illness.”
Great saying, too shame this also apply to people who only get their world view from channel similar to this one and never knew the other side of argument. You sounds like an educated person, don't cage yourself in this comfort zone, go see the world with your own eyes, not other's eyes.
@@yudilai6704 操你吗五毛
@@yudilai6704 i dont think china is going to let me in and see their secrets. Or are you saying these channels are all lies. Well let us see for ourselves. Let us in. Lets have some transparently
@Philip Nguyen Well, one thing I don't like this video is the fact obedience to teacher and parents is idea passed down by Confucian thousands years ago, it's part of culture, not from CCP. CCP certainly does some injustice, but blaming something they didn't do is just not right. Truth is truth, I need to correct that. Second I just think this channel only expose negative side, you all need to see what argument the pro-china channel have and at least listen arguments from both side to gather full information before making judgement.
@@Geoduct123 yeah, China is not transparent, then how do you think Serpienza got all his top secret and information on China (since China is not tranparent, is Serpienza's information credible, where did he get his source? the thing is, since most of you only get to know China through his channel, he basically can say what ever he wants). Anyway I digress. You don't have to know the top secret to understand this channel is bias. All you need is simply a semester as exchange student in china. Many university have study abroad program. Just apply then you can go to China.
"The western world is not equipped or prepared to deal with the level of psychological manipulation.."
Absolutely true. I lived in China for ten years myself. I tell people back home about these things, its hard for them to process the anecdotes and experiences I've had over the years. Thank you for posting this video, and everything else you do.
Same applies to Russia, although the methods are slightly different.
Be one with Yuri!
Westerners still think this psychological manipulation is untrue and merely a conspiracy theory
@Benaiah Ahmadinejad Life is a cycle. No king rules forever.
I wish it will come sooner because the chinese one dont look fun
As a child of Chinese immigrants, I can confirm that a lot of this is true. It's frustrating. They never think about stuff and question things, they just accept it as truth. When I question back the reasoning for this and that - they see it as being closed minded because I'm thinking back. It's a broken system but I guess my parents had to follow it otherwise there lives would be ruined.
Where do you live now?
its mostly Asian culture. You dont question your parents. You dont rebel.
@Martin Purcell That's just straight up false.
@Martin Purcell At least in the Western countries, people don't outright try to suppress the other views and instead try to argue over them openly and fairly. As long as one's arguments make sense, they can be heard. That is still much better than in China any day!
What I cannot take in, is that nobody in China (except perhaps the students who have traveled the world) are willing to give their lives in the fight for their own countries future. Everybody seems to be thinking only of themselves, and their immediate family. I hope I would fight and even die for my great """ great grand daughter's freedom (or move out of there as soon as possible, which I guess many have done) as my great great """ grand father did in our own civil war. Where is their courage to do something about it?
We're not dealing with an opponent, we're dealing with an enemy.
western isn't just America, bring jobs back to the rest of the west.
@Deos Manufacturing and factory jobs I guess. Sadly most consumers either don't want or can't pay much higher prices than they pay for stuff now, so it's not that simple. And neither do people want to work in factories for shitty pay.
it's vulture capitalism at its late stages. capitalism is eating itself because it has nothing left to fester on!
@@thewholetruth4192 Damn
@@ninjal7588 They could raise wages and people could buy less then they are used to do now.
@@thewholetruth4192 such utter bullshit, if you understood capitalism(capitalism is self sustaining) it can't eat itself, it's crony capitalism that is the cause of many problems exacerbated by too much welfare and too much government
I honestly used to think China was an okay place but after watching many of your videos and being educated on China, I now see how terrible the government is. Thanks serpentza!
Since it is just minority respective, not on an entire view, have a visit in Shanghai or Beijing , you got the real view of China
Watch China Uncensored for some truth!
No one wants China to be evil. The CCP are to blame. I only have love and sympathy for the ordinary people of China having to live under the foot of the corrupt CCP
@@deejaye2647 go to see China yourself to see the truth!
You should take a visit there and see it for yourself.
Winston, please bring her on as a guest again. I really enjoyed the interaction between you two and her insight growing up in China. I have been watching you on TH-cam for years. This is my favorite video from your channel! Keep up the good work!!
I am Chinese, but I left China at age 7. I'm glad the truth is finally getting out. The world should disengage with China until the CCP collapse and the Chinese people are free.
like iraq
@Skip Roche สคิพ The shock I had was the toilet water splashed on my butt. We don't have that in China, so it stinks, but we don't have poop water on my butt( it is a trade off, once I got used to it I actually prefer splashes instead of stinky smells). By the way, i didn't escape, I immigrate out, because china doesn't limit your freedom as long as you don't have bad record. It's harder to get into US. then getting out of China. I don't like how people always make china sound like a prison.
I truly want to believe that it’ll be that easy... however, after believing in these values for 70 years, do you think that the fall of them will lead to the freedom of people? Once they fall, people will need decades to get rid of the mentality... the problems are also so deep rooted in the society...
Mai Ly and we love to have you here. ❤️
It would be the kindest thing for the greatest number.
I used to believe this was just American exaggeration about CCP working on their own people’s minds. Then I met many mainlanders, here in Hong Kong, and... no they don’t exaggerate. This is scarily true.
This is typical thing for socialist and communists. They tried doing it in Venezuela, but it didn't take, but they're still trying.
Chinese culture are too crap to exclude commnist too, cuz it exists in china for almost 100 years
There’s some sort of censorship going on in TH-cam, my comments keep getting deleted.. my comments involved Tibet , Uighur and culture revolution, and C c P don’t know which one triggers it?
scary is the exact correct truth
Keeps a great job serpentza our African brother and don't worries about Hater's because we love you
It's not bad to hating a hate spreader this guy is a hater😂😂
Love all this truth telling.
Thus nose sizes start to shrink. :D
Welcome to my life as a Venezuelan American. The authoritarian government in Venezuela tries to play mind games with us.
I know this game that China, Cuba, Venezuela, etc. play, very well.
Keep these videos going.
And the US is not playing games? Mind games? And Europe?
@@pvn2474 Nah, we just have a sense of humour and enjoy fcuking with people when they act like d!cks. 😉
pvn2474 *100 bolívares han sido depositados en su cuenta de banco* ¡viva Bolívar! ¡viva Chavéz! ¡viva Maduro! ¡fuera yanquis, hands off Venezuela!
@@pvn2474 If you pretend there is anything remotely like what communist countries do in terms of brainwashing and manipulation in the west, then you're brainwashed, dishonest, or dumb. Stop with this "the west is just the same" nonsense because it's blatantly false.
@@linuxatheist5361 Yeah, I agree. While the west does do really shady stuff, at least you have the LIBERTY to to express your opinion most of the time.
i am just scared for africa. As an east African, I've been to most countries in this region and the Chinese influence is overwhelming from Djibouti all the way down to Zambia .
I pray for your countries , that they don’t become Chinese puppet states
D Theresa yeah right
What about Europe and all the African influence there
Without China, who will build you railroads, housing, farms? They are helping make progress, at fraction of cost of western price.
Ronald D a fraction of the quality too
very well said, thanks to this American woman! As a native Chinese, I can testify that what she said is all true.
Thanks!
Please stand with Hong Kong!
We are trying our best to tell the whole world about how evil CCP has been, to its own people!
Hongkong is still part of China .
@@gracesutton1359 Shame on you little pinko.
Pinko?
@@gracesutton1359 One country, two systems
When I taught at a university in China, I basically had to give a lesson on critical thinking and what I expected from my students. ... and I still had to remind them once every couple of lessons.
30 years ago the US should have been watching their back instead of running in head 1st with little regard for what would happen down the road. Now untangling the mess is near impossible without major losses.
I think arrogance was a factor. With the breakup of the USSR, America/ the West thought communist countries would open up when they saw the trappings of democracy, freedom of speech and free market.
This doesn't mean countries in the West don't have some traits of communism. Banking would be an example, they are protected by governments, often at the detriment of the citizens. This is also a deeper and more complex problem of the way governments/ the economy/ and banking are intertwined, it's much more palatable for a high number of individuals to go bankrupt, than even a tiny drop in growth. Inflation is really just a river for wealth to flow from individuals to the banks (It costs money to store savings in a bank with essentially zero interest).
Went a little off track there, hopefully it wasn't just a rant. But who doesn't enjoy a little rant once in a while? 😉
30 years ago China was a different beast.
Most of this behaviour is because of Xi Jinping turning the country fascist
Big companies don’t care as long as they make the biggest profit.
US elites were going to split the profit from 1billion Chinese cheap labor with the CCP slave masters. Money was too hard to resist.
@D Theresa That's true (let's not talk about IBM [US] in WWII). On the flip side, it's only been a little over 60 years (75 if you want to be exact) since the end of WWII yet any animosity between the allies & Germany & Japan has long since been dropped (there's that Back to the Future 1985 reference that "all the best stuff's made in Japan"). China has gone the opposite way to Japan. instead, they've moved backwards and now look more like 1930's Germany. As a Brit!🙄 With a keen interest in WWII seeing the way China is acting now (this exploded [wrong term] on the 75 anniversary of the closure of Auzwhitz) the parallels between them are pretty terrifying: 1# Concentration camps, check! 2# Burning Books, check! 3# Growing nationalism/ hatred, Check! #4 Seizing foreign territories, Check! (With HK (HK is gone, claiming township of territory everywhere, and if they thought they could take Taiwan they would!), #5 CCP is acting like the SS secret police, Check! - That's just off the top of my head!
I believe Jinping is more dangerous than Hitler. Hitler gets a lot of stick, but he wasn't a total 6astard/ psychopath as he dispised chemical/ biological weapons (he had them, and so did the allies...), but there was some sense of a gentleman agreement in place. An unspoken treaty if you will.
Before WWII broke out there was never this level of aggregation. I believe a lot of this growing aggression is because they're getting desperate ("appear strong when you are weak, appear weak when you are strong" - paraphrasing Sun Tzu, they wrote the book on military strategy), and desperate people do desperate things. That's before we add communism to the mix.
That's my take on things...
Having experienced the Soviet Union, I can relate.
yorkaturr Yea I experienced it in Rumania. Same crud all over the world, and now they’re trying it in the USA. When you’ve seen it before, it is so obvious. What is dangerous is all the ignorant people who believe the propaganda.
Leonard V I’d say a big difference is that the Overton window in India will still always be 100x larger than WHATS found in China
@@cupcakechronicles4551 The Indians have Pakistan on one side and China on the other. I can see why they are paranoid and might grow hateful towards China as the CCP influences the other nations to turn against India.
I clicked so fast, I love my weekly fix of Surpenza! You have such a beautiful family and such a talented wife. You two will do so well in the US
I have met many Chinese people in California, and I concur with this video.
We have to strip Chinese people of their US citizenship if they continue to have loyalty to China
lol America is already too late, don’t kid yourseld
@@paradigmshift7541 It isn't too late to resist their influence.
4:14 summa it up "America is Evil" China numba#1
I crown U Perfect - Stay in China!
Watching you since 5k subs and seeing how you are now the voice China needs right now is amazing. You've come so far since beer girl times and the cultural shock. Really happy to see you keep making truthful videos.
Love your videos! I have lived in North America all my life, so your videos help give me a perspective from a different point of view. Keep up the amazing work
This was really interesting and I'm not sure there are so many commentaries on this? Great upload! Can't wait to hear more from her perspective :)
I am a Chinese born and raised but I left before Winston came to China. I left at the end of JIang Zemin's reign, 2002. Back then propaganda was there but was not extreme as it is now. As far as I can recall the CCP was pretty mild in foreign politics. But there were a lot of war stories being taught in school in favour of the CCP. One of them is about 5 red army soldiers holding off hundreds of Japanese soldier from the top of a mountain and another one is the "infamous" 雷锋. Can't say everything was bad with the Chinese education system, but I do have to agree with that is being said in the video. It just beats the individualism and critical thinking straight out of your ass. When I say beat it out of you, I mean literally. I have had fair share of beating by the teachers because I didn't agree with them.
The funny thing is, as after I came to the west, and was able to easily access all the information I wanted the Chinese propaganda being exercised seems just like house of cards, fragile. I think closing off China from accessing western media is the best thing CCP can do for itself and the worst thing they have done to the Chinese people.
Hey Winston oh, that was a great interview. I can't begin to imagine how difficult that would be and then as you grow older and find out that everything was a lie what that does to your confidence as a person. Wow she was really Brave to tell you everything that happened to her and what she went through. Thank you for sharing and please tell her we wish her all the best. And we are really happy to see you guys go out and about at different locations in California. All our best to you Shelley and Hugo
100% on point .. especially, the Chinese who have become citizen here in the USA and silently working against America's interest.
Check it out - ‘nazi’ attitudes (here, general xenophobia) are adaptive.
WTF, I am offended. Why would you think Chinese work against America's interest, can you provide some evidence. This is a pretty heavy accusation, it put all Chinese American's reputation on the line. Are you going to say Muslim immigrants secretly work for their "Holy War" next? Why are you polarizing America, are you some kind of Russian spy that tries to polarize the UNITED States? What part of word "United" do you not understand?
@@yudilai6704 There's plenty of evidence; there are tons of Chinese spies in the US and occasionally one gets caught.
Yudi Lai Hahahah u da bot!!!!! Go back to China commi
Winston, you give hope to a lot of people in this comments section. There is no higher gift. Thank you.
What kind of hope did this channel give you? I am curious, this channel seems pretty negative, can you explain how you get the hope out of negative information?
@@yudilai6704 Lying to yourself that everything is okay, and everything is positive --- That is the fountain of real hopelessness. Admit the negative things, and be goddamn better. That is true hope. Of course, you might not be able to understand, based on your understanding of hope. You don't want hope, you want illusion that everything is fine. Because the moment you admit there is negative, you realize, deep down, you're desperate.
Serpentza, C-Milk and China uncensored man. TH-cam's father, the son and the holy spirit. The Badass Trinity
Yeah, hope we can see more often collabs every once in a while
C-Milk is the son of Serpentza XD
china uncensored man = Chris Chappell
Add Wion too
China uncensored is an arm of the Falun Gong cult which is anti China.
The opening footage is precious! Enjoy being a parent the most challenging and pleasurable years of your life. Thank God you guys made out of China when you did. Peace be with you and yours.
Information like this needs to come into the awareness of people all over the world. They need to understand who they're dealing with, it's the first step to healing. Get her on again, she's knowledgeable and very succinct in her explanations, nice to hear!
It’s absolutely true that they are always loyal to the CCP no matter they get a
green ,red or blue passport.We should treat them in the same manner the way
they treat us.Why should we give them the same privileges when our people
are struggling to get basic rights from the regime.Ponder over it.
An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind
Thats racist m8.
Ww2. Japanese enturnment camps. Thats what happens when people like that
Hans Chinese as your best friend today, then getting a signal from some leaders boss, or any CCP agents... He/She becomes your ennemy in less than 1 second!
I think you get it confused. The westerners in china are residents, not citizens, just like the resident here in the US they have many restriction, for example, a lot of jobs are not available for residence. In addition, there are also glass ceiling for Chinese ethnic citizen in US that prevent them from applying in critical position, unequal treatment really goes both way.
@@justinli5903 Nice one
I was involved in a Chinese exchange program here in the US where I worked as a student aid and I always felt like the students were lacking creativity and critical thinking. Very interesting that you both pointed that out as well.
Broke up with my Chinese then girlfriend and the madness started. Contacted my employer, Asian coworkers, friends and family back home, Facebook friends, even paid money to one guy back in my home country to help. He accepted the payment, but that was their doom. Found out about it and now had huge leverage on them. You either leave me alone or I involve the police (I'm in the U.S.). Counted on their "save face" thing and it worked.
Try using non-pronouns every so often. In your case, even pronouns would improve your clarity.
Very difficult passage to understand.
@Pat McCann > She contacted ...
> I found out about it ...
That should help.
@@russianbotfarm3036 I understood him perfectly well - probably because I am not Russian.
Wow! That is spooky. The exact same thing happened to me back in January 2020 with my ex in Shanghai!
Yes, please bring her on again! This was a very interesting conversation 👏🏻
By all means have that guest back again. You are fortunate to have found her. I know literally dozens of Canadians who taught in China with me who either can't or won't see or say anything negative about life there. Most people just can't grasp the truth that what happens in China can happen here and are unaware that our institutions are already wobbling under the sheer weight and genius of Chinese propaganda. The west has become intellectually fat and lazy, and can't comprehend that China is watching us trash and burn our own history with glee. Our current flirtation with Socialism/Communism is a direct result of 4 decades of indoctrination. Keep up the good work.
Early upload today? Niiiiice. Gonna grab the lunch, enjoy, and comment afterward.
This is mainly an initial comment to help promote interaction for the algorithm.
I hope all the big businesses moves out their manufacturing units out of China in near future. Also some CCP bots disliked his video.
Then I question why did our business men go in in teh first place? To get rich and they f.. dont' care about us normal americans.. and you dear is stupid as f..k.
Do you watch Tik Tok, play frrebie video games etc...But yes we as people should very much put our money where are mouth is.
It should be the other way around, everyone should invade their businesses. Dominate their financial system, then make them civilised.
Even the central bank is corrupted.
@@vincentrj I think because you Americans demand high pay and don't do good on your jobs.
Faced between China and the U.S. , i knew which was the right choice. CANADA!
Chinese endoctrination start in kindergarten. Every morning, Salute to the flag and national anthem.
We sing National Anthem every morning in US too , you're point isn't valid.
@@whatwhatwhat51 I've never ever been forced to sing the anthem, I will on July 4th cause it's hype but we can never turn to the same blind nationalism as China
@momentinpassing Every group of people ever has committed a misdeed at once irrelevant comment
@momentinpassing Look, you benefit from all the social services nations provide, and all the infrastructure they put into place. If you don't want to benefit from them then move off to an island and start your own colony, or..be grateful and show a little support to the nation that's given you the opportunities that you have
Sshhh. Don’t tell too many people
He's South African. A force to be reckoned with. No one can mess with South Africans. ❤️
He's an African American now.
@@agalah408 haha
Freedom Escapism oh yes haha
A Galah as an African myself I agree lol
He is an idiot.
Thank you and your friend. Over the past seventy years, only few westerners realize the evils of the Chinese communist party. But people like you are really helping China and let people around the world knowing what’s really happening in China except the Chinese food and Kongfu.
Your insights into China come at the very right time. Our German coward government was appeasing the dragon, just like they appease every bad thing, because they are 3vil themselves. I'm really looking forward to the other topics. Your respectful and truthful way to cover all this is really something of great value to me, because truth must be told in order for changes to be able to happen. I think, you are doing a very important thing for the Chinese people! Greetings from Germany and God bless you and your family.
It is so freaking sad that most governments bend down to China! It has taken a pandemic for some countries to rethink their relationship with China.
How is the German government appeasing the dragon? Can you please explain
swave158 hopeful & wishful thinking. Germany is in trouble. BIG TROUBLE!!!
Please listen to Peter Zeihan.
@@KingslayerMax For months our chancellor found no words for Hongkong and they regularly don't speak up regarding the human rights issues - to maintain "good relationships" aka business. Germany and the EU are becoming more and more centralist states, opposition is branded as right wing extremists. They more and more are using the same tactics like the CCP is using them or like they have been used in the socialist GDR, where Merkel was an agent for propaganda in their youth organization and she studied in Moscow, which not everyone could do. She is a communist at heart.
The problem with Germany is that, due to their past, it’s taboo to discuss differences between different peoples, and thus they assume everyone is just like them.
This ''Woman'' is Brilliant ! Your sense of the situation is spot on, everyone needs to hear what you have to say. Its an immense obstacle to overcome, and the level of indoctrination will become more severe as tensions heat up.
this so called woman
Why would you put Woman in quotes?
Doctrine Doomsday shes very observant. China doesnt like that.
@@vodkawhisperer3923 I don't think she is observant, I think she is just holding grudge on the strict, harsh education that she went through because she didn't do so well. I think she blame the government for her failure in school.
I also doubt "her" gender
Honestly this is scary..
We have been so used to that already, that we don't find it scary anymore, but disgusting only.
No, many countries have brainwashed their citizens.
@@illuforce ikr! Look at The USA. Trump and Fox news supporters are brainwashed. T.T So obviously it's not only China that does it.
@@muajin Not really. Trump doesn't put people in prison or have them killed.
@@muajin 🤣 wake up kiddo. Who runs all media, academia, major cities, etc? Trumps opposition are literally fascist communists. They will criminalize facts like "men are not women."
Great interview. Keep shining the light. You are a blessing to the world.
*Its quite impressive how consistent Serpentza always has content .I was actually inspired to start vlogging by him.Keep it up.*
Her opinion is the same as mine. I am Chinese but since my mother has citizenship of another country, I was lucky enough to be accepted into an international primary school. I enjoyed my early schooling years, made a lot of friends, and was a very confident child. However, from secondary school, I entered a state-run one (ironically because of my outstanding academic performance) and I was severely bullied for three years because of my bluntness, to the extent that I couldn't speak in front of more than 3 persons. I left China in high school and slowly rebuilt my confidence since then. If you are educated in a Western way, you will be more outspoken and stright forward with your thoughts. That makes you a target in Chinese schools.
I love how your last video is spreading awareness globally. I saw it on the Frustrated Indian TH-cam channel this morning. 👍😎👍
"Your not allowed to be a a nonconformist." That, in essence, is the sum of the problem.
That was very interesting. Please do bring her on-again, would like to hear more of her experiences.
you should have chinese captions! id love for my chinese relatives to be able to understand this video.
Thanks for your continued content dude.
@Frogsquatch until covid i worked at a TH-cam channel based company, it's just the term burned into my head sadly is all but i take your point positively
Enjoyed hearing about her experience. I agree with pretty much everything.
She has a point...but she also sounds like an angry butch who thinks shaving is anti-feminist.
s8v0t2 Well all I can think of is... imagine being brainwashed and then having to re-learn everything when your 20.
It doesn’t sound like she’s had an easy time. I emphasise with her on that.
Maybe not just like her but I would be angry too.
This whole thing feels like watching/reading AOT or some shit. The level of brainwashing and how clueless people are, is extremely scary.
Compating thr CCP to the first king of aot is brilliant.
What is AOT?
@@Ozzianman attack on Titan which is a popular Japanese manga and anime
man, they re scared of me (thinking that i am a disease carrier) everywhere now: metro, elevator etc. They try to do similar manipulations in Russia (where i m from), but it's not working, I live in China for over 5 years now, just started my channel, can't fully share everything that I want to say in my video blog , but at least something relevant
I can imagine how that would affect a person living in China for so many years. I got to know some Chinese people here in Arkansas who came here from China and mentioned how tough it was and how parents there don't want to feed their babies milk produced there in China.
Bonus points for use of the word ‘sheeple’.
Great video stay safe all the best to you and your families.
Hi Winston, loving all of your videos, i have only just started to watch your channel, Laowhy86 and the other channels you have since the lock down but i have binge watched a lot of them. i am from Oxford in England but i am currently living in Ho Chi Minh , Vietnam and have been here since 2007. i am half way through my 14th year. i married a Local Vietnamese Women and have 2 children. i also bought property here in Vietnam. My job is a little different to 85% of the other foreigners here in Vietnam. I restore antique furniture/French polisher. i came from England to teach the Vietnamese workers on how to make new furniture look antique and old and we manufacture reproductive antique furniture. I loved your video on the different categories of foreigner video you did. i feel i can relate to a lot of what you and Laowhy say any many of your videos. Vietnam's Government is not has bad has the Chinese government , it has if they only really push the propaganda when they are having a bad time or someone in the governments having a bad day. (if you understand what i mean). hope to speak with you and Laowhy sometime if ever you are free and if you are ever back in Vietnam i would love to meet up with if you ever wanted to. love to the family and keep up the great content. Stay awesome.
@love n sweet2008 you are definetly not a Vietnamese ! And you are not living in Vietnam otherwise you would not talk nonsens about racism. Everybody who lived in south east asia knows very well about racism there and Vietnamese hates Chinese! And many in south east asia are racists and hates foreigners. So dont tell people nonsens! And China is very racist about foureigners you talk big shit man
Ben Weston, your comment started off really good and then I had difficulty working out what you are trying to say, round about where you say "i feel i can relate to a lot of what you and Laowhy say...."
CNN is not going to interview this woman.
I wouldn't be so sure of that. People are becoming conscious to China's influence. When the economic winds turn, so will public opinion.
If they did, they would blast her picture all over the internet and doxx the shit out of her like they do to anyone who challenges the communist agenda of all the MSM outlets.
Ydu Senu
Even 'liberal' Western outlets like CBC and CNN are beginning to take note of China's human-rights abuses. Maybe the long honeymoon with Chinese capitalism (under the ironic CCP brand-name) is nearing its end. If so, praise the Lord.
Praise Him regardless, because he will not allow the wicked to prosper forever.
Btw do you remember that Donald trump called Xi a 'great man'?
@@SirPunch2Face
A crash course in history and political science is recommended.
CNN is a liberal-centrist outlet; in fact some of their favorite guests are moderate Republicans 9hardly Marxist firebrands). Don lemon is an ex-Republican. Opposition to Donald Trump does not equal communism. Indeed it was Trump who praised Xi as a 'great leader'. He did not hesitate to invest in the USSR during the 1980s, which also showed them up as not-so very communist after all.
Anyway, eternal salvation is not determined by partisan loyalty.
It says that 'if you confess with your mouth jesus as Lord, and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved' (Romans 10:9).
Unfortunately, loyalty to the CCP is NOT compatible with salvation, and it's pretty obvious why. Following the CCP to the end can only assure one of a place in hell. Yet God is willing to forgive the repentant sinner.
are you serious lol. what media outlet actually likes china?
This is really fascinating dude, thanks for posting.
Super happy to have you showing more and more content, cannot wait to see the expose of some issues
If Winston says he’s working for himself what’s the visa he’s got so he can stay in US that’s my biggest question knowing that it’s not easy to get a working visa and lots of abuse with people overstaying tourist or student visas in US. I think someone is sponsoring his visa because if he’s working for himself doing what exactly?
That's his private life, he doesn't need to tell us everything. Why should he explain himself to his TH-cam audience?. If I was him I wouldn't tell anyone a thing about my private life also, especially in this day and age where one person tries to ruin another persons life just because they're jealous or simply don't like their videos.
Didn't he tell you? No? Guess it wasn't any of your goddamned business, then.
Okiebryan Wow such a smart reply not. He’s afraid to say what he’s doing in US because basically if he’s here illegally or using a visa illegally he can be in big trouble but he doesn’t say what his job is how he got in US he’s not from America so it just doesn’t make any sense to me that’s why I ask and I’m an American citizen so I would like to know
Okiebryan also I’ve seen enough of his bazaar videos where he acts like the Chinese government is spying on him constantly well he can say what he wants about the government says he’s not in the country but I’m sure if he was doing these anti-government videos while living in China he would’ve been deported or in prison because the Chinese government doesn’t take kindly to derogatory statements about the government. And his wife’s family could be in jeopardy for anything he says about the Chinese government. I lived there for a while but it makes no sense how Winston always makes himself act or seem like he’s so important he’s not I heard how he came to the country with no money and living on the streets really who does that
As a US Citizen, I am very glad Winston is here. His insight is beneficial to our country. Stay awesome!
I teach Chinese kids for a living and yeah, I tend to agree, they seem to be completely incapable of critical thinking or questioning anything. I don't ask them to criticize the CCP or anything like that, but I will ask them what their opinions on certain subjects are and they always give either the same answer, or the answer they think *I* want to hear. It's sad when I go day after day doing the exact same thing with these kids and I can never really get them to tell me how they *really* feel about anything. American kids never shut up, they'll tell you how they feel about every little thing on the planet, changing their minds often, but Chinese kids always have this sort of pre-programmed answer in mind and that's pretty much it. I often wish I could get through to them to get them to think more in-depth about subjects, but I realize that I'm up against their *entire* schooling system and constantly being trained *against* the sort of dialogue that I seek to establish. It's frustrating for sure.
And I don't want to overgeneralise stuffs, but the general public in China, I mean in Mainland PRC, are also pretty evil. (Disclaimer: I never mean ALL! I have good friends who are in it from China as well, as there are always exceptions to the norm.). They are not purposely evil overall, but they have been poisoned with the very simple single value: money! Have you heard of the tens of cases a year at least that drivers would reverse the car to hit the person again if (s)he was already knocked on the ground and fell unconscious! It was simply because of MONEY! The law says that the driver needs to pay for the medical cost of the injured, so they chose to kill the person to avoid that probably large amount of compensation needed! You should get what I mean here…
So you can see, Mainlanders only concern about money. In that way, they wouldn't care about what the government is doing, and would become very easy to be controlled!
With that guiding principle in their minds, except the very few extraordinary and 'outcast' people, nothing is important except money, and nothing is more important than wealth! And that's why you have seen those far-below-standard dangerous constructions and infrastructures, those poisonous baby formula milk products (not only ONCE, but MULTIPLE TIMES for God's sake!!! 🙈).
We have to realise that not only the CCP Government is evil, but its people, at large, have been indoctrinated and trained to be heartless, for the easy control by CCP.
SO, when we say that Chinese from PRC are doing this or that damages to the civilised western world, we have to be very clear that not only CCP is the wicked giant, but unfortunately the Chinese people, although as victims of brainwashing themselves, have been commiting the bad stuffs themselves.
And who suffer most after all?!
We other Asians! Because in the eye of Westerners, they can't easily distinguish us just by seeing our appearances, and not only Hongkongers, but also Japanese, Koreans, Vietnamese alike, have been thought to be Chinese, and sometimes discrimination or even bullying happened.
We plead for a better understanding of the differences between Asians, and hopefully people can really get to know the person first before deciding whether (s)he is a brainwashed Chinese (usually a little pink) or not.
I teach them too (in an international high school for PRC citizens). Personally, I think it is more that they are taught to carefully consider how their actions, thoughts, and words will benefit them (either financially or give them guanxi) in a system totally different from the west. Giving your views more often than not does not result in favorable outcomes for them personally. It's more like they are afraid they will be denied limited resources by being too demanding or standing out. But to be fair, both you and I are generalizing.
Everything seems to be about money and personal glory, rather than morality and "living a life according to your values" like we have been taught to do.
Honestly, I talk to their parents though, If I were them, I'd be scared to challenge them too. Most of my parents rule with an iron fist and aren't afraid to emotionally damage their kids if they think doing so will result in them getting a high paying job after college. Plus every school that isn't 100 percent international has to have certain mandatory subjects, like Chinese Political Science. They have to take an exam to get a Chinese HS diploma and politics is on that test, just like it is on GaoKao. Every politics teacher I've met was a stuck up asshole who will do whatever they can to point out how blameless the government is and how fucked up the US is. I don't get into arguments over stupid shit with brainwashed co-workers though, so I just try to teach my own students the truth, if they are capable of understanding it, and try to move on with my life. It's a pretty good paycheck and soon I'll have enough to buy a house and leave China. Besides, a lot of my kids walk away with a less skewed version of history and global politics, even if I am not teaching those subjects. I'm proud of helping the kids that care enough to learn from me over the years.
This is the time I've heard the word "sheeple" applied correctly anywhere.
Fantastic conversation,...FANTASTIC !
Fantastic guest. Please invite her back on for discussions, multiple videos if possible. Great insight in contrast with yours
My brother supports the CCP, when I argue with him, he says that I was brainwashed by the Western media, well I said that I think the Chinese people were the ones brainwashed he said that I was distorting the truth, then I argued back saying that at least here I have free speech and I can say whatever I want without going out to "drink tea" with the police. So after that he started insulting me, arguing with arguments that make no sense, he is also an ultra nationalist and he says that the democracy in Western countries is fake and we are being braiwashed.
Well I think I will let him be...
Thank you!
And congratulations on having critical thinking!
Please stand with Hong Kong!
Good on you mate. Too many Chinese people let their families pressure them into doing/saying things that aren't right.
Being able to question and criticize the government is a part of freedom!
respect .. keep on
This was terrific! I'd enjoy much more from her - and things are getting pretty spicy between US & China. USA too permissive for many decades now - I say reel it back in!
on my journey binge watching ur videos ..... Stay awesome
Great videos and interesting to hear another persons opinion. Looking forward to watching the next videos with her about Hong Kong
Please stand with Hong Kong!
I'm from Scotland, i meet a young Chinese girl and was showing her our town all was good till I mentioned I was an S.N.P member we advocate a free Scotland, the conversation went very quiet and she said to me I shouldn't be against London rule I should be more loyal to London, that was it she walked off on me as I tried to explain it was our democratic rite to seek independence
only fools believe in blind obedience. And any one that tries to mandate blind obedience i am happy to watch them suffer.
she was right though. There can be no United Kingdom without Scotland. In that case the whole country would have to reform and split back into England and Scotland.
@@Kvothe1994 we were an independent country till some free mansions and beer barons meet in Edinburgh and bribed sitting members of Edinburgh parliament to vote for a union a totally undemocratic process where our assent is removed and a portley fixed sum is paid annually to buy us off,
@We Are well then I'm glad the decision is not up to you.
Don't be brainwashed!
I'm immune to brainwashing, both Chinese and American.
Hello Osama! How are you doing in Hell?
🍄☮️❤️
@@millabasset1710 Leftists brainwash the same way the Chinese do :(
lmfao ok osma alaha ackbar :)
Please don't try and give the impression that Brainwashing is unique to China, Russia ,or South Africa for that matter. Every country has its own form of Brainwashing but in Western countries the art is more subtle.
Freedom's Speculum Loony toon
These days I feel like most of the brain washing is coming from communists though and people compromised or linked to them. Communists aren't just in China
Im so pumped for your new vids everytime, cant wait for the next onez
I studied in China until 10th grade, and I am so sorry for your experience. My education in China was not even this brainwashing; most people still kept their wits to them.
I live in a fairly rural, mostly agrarian, state here in the US and I see A LOT of Chinese people but never out and about. My small city has a few Chinese-style restaurants and the staff is primarily Chinese with differing levels of English proficiency. There are some beauty and nail salons run by Chinese immigrants as well as massage, chiropractic and acupuncturists. I recently went to hospital and saw a group (dozen or so) of Chinese people being given a tour with a translator. However, we never see these Chinese people out in the community. I never see them shopping in the stores. I never see them in the parks. I've never seen their kids in schools other than University. I've never seen any attempt to integrate or mingle within the community. Even in University, the few Chinese students there seem very unwilling, or at least hesitant, to socialize, at all, with non-Chinese students.
That is a common observation - where do they all live? Usually in upscale communities they can be seen walking. This may be a result of there appearing to be more than there really are. More likely though is packed in small apartments!
when PUBG came out a few years back, being in Australia we would be paired with SE Asia and Asian server's so iv played alot of games with the Chinese and SE Asian's, i find that se a's are inquisitive and have an interest in learning and sharing cultural idea's and friendship. Most of the Chinese however just rant Guilo, or China #1,....(not to mention cheating/hacking is not frowned upon in there culture) it's on a fanatical level when put into an environment like that.
im always down with some ccp exposure, especially on a friday night! Proost!
Definitely bring her back; we need more of these direct comparisons with people who really understand both systems.
Very interesting interview. As someone who has not lived in China but who follows the media and has (at least in my own opinion) a certain amount of common sense, I could not agree more. I would definately like to hear more from your guest. She seems very competent and very experienced about China. So, yes, I would love you to have her as a guest in future videos/audios.
Although I already told how I appreciate your channel in an older comment, I want to add: Your channel is a very rare and valuable thing because there are not many people who have such an inside view into the Chinese society, who speak the language and who have actually lived their everyday life in China for such a long time. Your statements have weight and I am thankful that you take all the negatives that come along with it and still make the problems public. At the time mainly problems, but people forget how you also praised the positive sides of China and how you love China and it's people - why in the world would you have lived in China for so long if you wouldn't like it's people. But of course, once you put your finger on a foul spot, it oozes out and all the good things you said are immediatley kind of forgotten. That's sad but that's how things seem to function. Voices like yours are making the difference. I have become an intense follower of your channel (and Cmilks and Vivi's - whom I both found via your videos). Thumbs up and keep on going.
chinese people spread out to the whole world.
they have a strong relationship all around the world. here in ASEAN, most of them are rac1sm but they always play as a V1ct1m.
in Malaysia, they proudly said: "i am malaysia-chinese" .
also the same thing in Singapore and Indonesia.
She's talking a lot of good points. She saying cut them off and that's 100% agreeable but at the same time there are more than enough reasons to do so and just the latest is the corona pandemic. For not handling the outbreak better by notifying other nations of the situation.
Dennis Hink *Last time I checked, the USA did not subjugate Tibet, Mongolia, Hong Kong, nor build artificial island/military bases in the Philippines Sea, nor release a global pandemic (again). Checkmate, tool.*
@ They invaded Tibet, placed the Uighurs in concentration camps, have live organ harvesting practices for the Falun Gong and dissenters, destroy churches and have tried to rewrite the bible and Quran to benefit the CCP, and intentionally spread a virus to the rest of the world using their own people. Bush and Obama are not in control anymore, Trump is president and has not been involved in anything that you've mentioned. Meanwhile, Xi is probably racking up more organs and dead people and is president for life in China.
All the points made here, by everyone responding to Muhammad's post, are worth talking about. Please continue everyone.
This is amazing. Can I have a source for this information? The both of you who because I'm an American and of course I know what America has done and I'm not proud of it and do think it's wrong but I'd like to know more of Chinas history as well.
@ Last time I checked any protest in China regarding the policies of the CCP will get you imprisoned or worse. You have no idea what you're talking about... CCP is your god.
China has done a lot of arm twisting and encroachment into its neighbouring countries' territory
We in India have had to deal with this bullying for a long time.
Please make a video on this.
Thank you for a candid discussion that is sorely needed.
Thanks for digging out this nice guest. She knows her ** and expresses it well.
Don't Worry, My Brain is Big so I'm not Easy to be Brainwashed by Anything!!! Yay 😀😁😀
@@venomspidey336 Yay 😎😎😎
I grew up in communism in Eastern Europe. Same concept.
The part about the educational system method from China sounds very similar to the one in Japan... 😔
I've been in Japan for 16 years now and have 2 daughters, and I am really thinking to move out for the sake of their future because of the same issues the lady has mentioned.
Great job you're doing serpentza!! 😉👍
That's sad. Really sad. Nice to see she's doing good for herself.
Great video. I loved seeing the baby and your wife at beginning of the tape....so ADORABLE!!!😃
Damn.
No clue what's she is talking about with lies being taught in international schools in China... . There is a big difference between international schools and private bilingual schools. Having spent time in international schools in China during my school education, we didn't have any of that at all. We stuck strictly to the curriculum we did(one of the major international ones) even the incorrect bits(for example the invention of the compass)
Did you start when you were 4 until you were 18?
I totally agree with you William I taught in an international private school in Shanghai and I think what this woman is saying is completely bizarre to me
@@sephkurai 6 years in two blocks, some in elementary school and some in high school
@@williambruce7943 Perhaps she just had particularly vile teachers in that case.
dude your daughter is gorgeous
Super interesting and uniquely informed insight as always
WInston, keep these coming ! I hope to hear more interviews like this.
Two evil uncles alert on timeline 3:05.
🤦♂️ 😂 😂 😂 hahahahaha I agree!! The fabricated history she mentioned is hilarious!!
Yeah... But they were probably suspicious of why a grown man was filming young pupils. If I did that in Norway someone would call the police on me immediately.
Talk about the collapsing Chinese dams! and floods
@Camz C yeah, flood is getting worse each year, but that's how it is for natural disaster all around the globe. The forest fire in California is getting worse each year
Your daughter is adorable. must take after Sasha. ;)
😂😂
Back handed compliment
She's so cute!
Thank you so much for this interview!
Yeah, the CIA would never be involved in the affairs of other countries. You'd have to be mind-cleansed to believe that.