Mine as well. I love their ballad songs the most!!! only thing missing is Jessica's angelic voice because Jessica's voice was the best in their ballads
Oh my gee!! Taeyeon, Seohyun, Tiffany and Sunny high notes are amazing! I must say Seohyun-ie you really improved a lot, those high notes + emotions, i'm getting chills. As usual Taeyeon did an awesome job, i got chills every time she opens her mouth. This is my favourite song in the album, but too much TTS, how I wish it was distributed properly. Really want them to perform this on music shows!!!!!!!
@2:04 if you listen carefully, you'll hear Seohyun's amazing harmonizing with the girls and then afterwards her perfect high notes. She used to struggle with these kinds of notes because of her bad breath techniques but now she just slays every single note, really appreciate her impressive improvement ❤
Seohyun has drama filming before this fanmeet starting and has to go back filming drama after this fanmeet ended. She must be so tired yet her voice still sound so beautiful also her high note 👏
I agree when people say Tiffany is awesome only when she sings in lower notes. Yes, she's more suitable that way. But I disagree if people say she cannot sing or poor singer. Fany has a husky voice which for me is very unique and catchy. Do all singers have to be able to sing high notes perfectly only to be called by you as a "singer"? Regardless, Fany is always bright, beautiful, classy, friendly, and most of all, she's very hardworking!
My biased is Seohyun.. she slayed so hard in this song.. which I love so much.. but, I still cannot deny that Tiffany husky voice add the emotional in it (Do not bash her pplez, she really sound good, I can't deny..) & also Sunny sweet voice (I'm melting).. not to forget Taeyeon powerful voice (as always).. well, ofc other members also did so good in here too.. Overall, I love Seohyun, Tiffany and sunny voice the most.. their part is so good in my 👂...
Tiffany slayed i know u guys won't compliment her so yeah Fany i love u and thank u for improving each new day even if people love ignoring u and sleeping on u. Wat a queen. Seohyun sounds so good am happy she got a lot of lines!
myong2206 Taeyeon strained and went off pitch too :) Neither was Seohyun at her best (but she was the best out of the three). Also , belts aren't really Tiffany's best. In Lady Marmamalde , she did a great job there. Which shows she just needs to work on consistency.
Am I the only one who likes Tiffany's voice??? I don't know how another fans can saying bad about Tiffany. Are you a truly sone? Or you hate only her? As a sone I support all members. As sone I don't hate anyone. I just hope that SNSD will be perform for a long time♡
fleur but most of the "fans" said that her voice is terrible, annoying and blah blah Tiffany proofed many times, that she can sing. And she sing great. For example IJWD accapella ver, Beaming Effect concert...
Yuliya Stream yes to be honest she surprised me for this one performance (i just wanna dance accoustic ver.). But do you know why? Because she didn't shout, no even once. She did the high parts in falsetto, which she manages to do great. What we need to understand is that whether we like her voice color or not (which is totally subjective, the same goes for every other member), we know shouting isn't singing, and shouting hurts vocal chords (we don't need to be a specialist to know that by the way :))
fleur I don't know why you try explain me about shouting 😅, because I know about this😂 I didn't tell nothing about technique. I tell about comments from "fans". I don't know about you, but I enjoy this perfomance. This perfomance very beautiful and emotional
Yuliya Stream yes but why do you think "fans" as you call them say that? Even if they say "i don't like her voice/singing" don't you think they mostly mean her "technique"? Yes I enjoyed the audio version a lot but the live is just meeh
SNSD made SONEs enter "Into The New World" and today on 9th October 2017, our "One Last Time" with OT8. I was there at their 10th Anniversary because I feared our biggest fear will come true. To the best years of my life, thank you SNSD. Once A SONE, Forever A SONE.
OMG thanks for this. I love seohyun voice in this song 💕 sunny too, sweet n beautiful voice 💕 tae is awesome as always 💕fany, i love her part ~ jigeum neol ilchi anke hae jweo Yeah ~ 💕This song is so emo 😣😢
As expected everybody is gonna pick on Tiffany. She actually sounded fine , Seohyun did the best , and Taeyeon had a bit out shouting and off pitch moments. This isn't easy because the difference in pitch is huge.
Caristalalala Tan Sunny did great too. Sunny & Seohyun was the most stable here. You are right Taeyeon wasn't her best here but Tiffany did mess up at some parts while others were fine.
TimelessGap2 What's the definition of Tiffany messing up? I understand tht Tiffany had difficulties doing belt which she always had. However , everybody only zooms in at her mistakes while they don't even say a thing when other vocalists does it. Taeyeon , Seohyun who had the same note as her didn't do well either. Taeyeon strained as well and it one of her notes she went slightly off and Seohyun who did best didn't really pull it off either. Tiffany needs a bit more time to get used to but so what? She did Sailing so well. So why's everybody saying only she can't sing? I know that Sunny did very well but I was mainly talking about TTS who had belts. Also , this is a mainly TTS song anyways.
Caristalalala Tan I said she messed up on some parts but was fine on others. Yes it was mostly a TTS song and Taeyeon did sound horrible at times Seohyun did mess up a few times too but in general Sunny & her were the most stable. My few co-worker & Kpopper call me the professional fan. She said that I'm the most unbias critic she had ever met. IDC if you're my favorite or least favorite I give credit where it's due & check those that mess up. I will never praise & say you did well when you didn't or vice versa. I said countless times that Fany's kingdom is her low notes and that she struggles a great deal with high but at times she does pull through. I even went on to say that she's not to blame but the line distributor for giving her those lines. She cracks, scream or strain. Taeyeon, Seohyun, Jessica & Sunny also have times when they struggle with notes. I believe as a singer you should challenge yourself but at the same time this can be harmful to her vocal in the long run. I do agree with you that most people only pinpoint times when the girls mess up & make stupid comments while neglecting their greatness and this is wrong. But what I hate the most is when they degrade the others & may up excuses for when their bias is the one who mess up.
Some people are complaining about Tiffany's singing and it's getting annoying. I think she did so well here. Just because Taeyeon and Seohyun sound amazing doesn't mean you have to compare the three and criticize Tiffany's voice. She sounds good on her own, and so do the other girls. Also, this is one of my favorite songs on the album lol 💕
most of the comments are complaining about tiffany, they didn't know that she was actually crying while singing !! I can tell that Yuri,Sunny,Sooyoung and Tiffany were crying just by listening to their voices ..BUT you can check the other fancam for confirmation
Why the hell are most people complaining? Also, seohyun's voice fitted the song most. If other members did her part, youll complain again. Accept the fact that snsd is a group with main and lead vocalist. Main and lead dancer. Im tired if seeing sones complaining. On the other hand, i think you arent sones because if you are, youll love each member and wont say bad and nonsense things about the group. And havent you notice? Sunny's lines increased. Hyoyeon's too. Every mem has 2or more lines. The song is 4 mins, what do you want them to do? Its music. Ofcourse they want the song to be perfect. Dont push it. Why dont you focus on the good things? Where the members excel most? Every girls just cant have it all. Theyre nine. I mean eight. And guys, weve been here, ten years. The group came on top and still, the issue is still about distributting lines? Oh, i saw a hyoyeon dancing on holiday and all night. When it comes to dancing theyre the focused. Cant you see that? Are you blind? You always talkshit about tts. Jelous freaks. Is tts fans complaining about why when it comes to dance, they werent the main focus? Sone, were a family. Im not here from the begginning but im 4 years here. And i know my heart is burried in this group. Dont make a fuss about anything. Theyre all paid fair and get noticed fair so shut up.
Julianne Morillo agree with you. Even in other group you can see vocalist will have more line compare to dance line. And for dance time/break they will more focus on dance line. That why they called dance line and vocal line for a reason. Beside, they choose/distribute line base on whose voice suit those line the most. It's been 10 years, and yet we still argue abt this kind of things. From what i see, dance line distribution is more better in this album compare to previous one. So just be grateful, and keep on supporting.
There is a difference between being highlighted as the main vocalist and taking up most of the song. After 10 years of being in the biz, one would think that the line distribution would be better. The Lion Heart Album had better distribution than this. 10th anniversary should be about everyone, not highlighting 3 members. TTS sing the high notes, which should have already emphasized their main vocalist status, but nope, they have all the longest and most stood out parts. There shouldnt be a song where the distribution is so obviously unfair. referring to the dancing, so far, thats one song...in which they were just placed in the center...thats nothing comparing to TTS singing the most for every single song in this album. each of the TTS member can give up 1 minute of singing and it would not make a difference in their popularity but it makes a huge difference for the rest of the members. For this song particularly, it is prob the best song on the album, yet, 2 members had less than 5 seconds...some of the lines that TTS sang were not hard or too high for them to be distributed more evenly to the rest, and it would not hurt the song either
Seohyun undoubtedly did the best here, Taeyeon and Sunny were amazing as well, if only the line distribution was a little better, anyway this is still the best song from the album to me ❤
Ngl, she's the talented on the group. But Tiffany one last time on last Chorus is a heaven in my ear, you know what? Sometimes taeyeon high notes wasnt clean like Seohyun, theres a vibrato there, but seo didn't, it's smooth like,
FANY AHHH IM ALWAYS FALLING IN LOVE IN UR HUSKY AND UNIQUE VOICE SINCE 2008 !!! I know ur singing skill improve a lot !! Thank you for ur always work and practice so fucking hard
OMG their voices in songs like this make me cry, the voice of Taeyeon is amazing in all aspects, the accompaniment of Tiffany with Tae .... wow without words, THE BEST!!!💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
There have been thousands of heartbreaking goodbye pop songs but for me this is my favorite. It’s so simple and emotional. And the fact that this is the only time it will ever be performed live makes it that much more powerful.
Haters 》》》》 Tiffany... bla... bla... blaaa... Tiffany 》》》》still beautiful, down to earth, rich, famous, member of GG, one of the main vocalist... Tiffany Young Hwang... Daebak!!!
Tiffany never become a main vocalist. Since the beginning it's only Jessica and Taeyeon, and now it's only Taeyeon. SeoSunTiff always as a lead. Don't say bcs there's TTS that means they're the main, duh. And SM never announce or give clue/candidate for the replacement main vocalist. Delulu fans~
listening to this after playing my holiday night album for the 1st time since i bought it.. i didnt know this is the last time i'll be hearing 8 of them.. i'm so sad i just love how TTS harmonized perfectly... why!!!! i hate you SM!!!!
I don’t know why but I cry when I listen to this, they’re so amazing and are family, I guess it just gets to me that they’ve done so much and have gone so far, all together forever
My fave song fro the album. It s very beautiful and they all sound amazing! Seohyun is killing it!!! Taeyeon as well,as always. Plus,stop talking about Jessica. She was kicked out 3 years ago and she didn t even sang this song,it s pure ot8. So why are you talking about her here? Go at Into the new world or other ot9 song. Jesus.
Dandyu Trash That's her only weakness but when she does do low notes she does more justice than Tiffany with high notes yet SM keeps giving Fany high notes. Why is that?
TimelessGap2 Because Tiffany is a good vocalist. I don't see why you have to only nit pick Tiffany when SeoTae also got a hell lot more lines. Okay? I get that Sunny can get a lot better if she was given time to shine , but this doesn't mean everytime a member doesn't get enough lines (or you think so) , it is Tiffany's fault. Tiffany can do high notes , fools. You're not going to believe it even if you hear it like during her birthday party or Moon and Sunrise cover because you're just gonna make excuses.
HaHaHappyXD I disagree. Seohyun did really well because it sounded less strained but it was flat. Taeyeon on the other hand was kinda out of the place and strained to belt that note , like Tiffany.
I don't see why you guys have to hate or bash certain members just enjoy this amazing song and leave the negativity out. We should be helping out girls and showing our support not bringing them down you guys.
![[Girls' Generation - All Night] Comeback Stage | M COUNTDOWN 170810 EP.536](/img/n.gif)
Seohyun's voice fit this song perfectly, she slayed hard, especially those high notes ♡
Indeed ❤️
Autotune
@@СНСАЛЕКСАНДАРВУЧИЋ most singer do that, it's better than Lypsinc like gen 4
This has to be my favourite off the album 💗💗
Beth Ashworth mine tooo 😍😍😍
Mine as well. I love their ballad songs the most!!! only thing missing is Jessica's angelic voice because Jessica's voice was the best in their ballads
SNSDrulz i agree. Taengsic used to support each other really well.
me too🙆
Beth Ashworth Agree
TAEYEON HIGH NOTES! Got me SHOOK to the core. And seohyun freaking slayed the first high note
i love TAESEO good job you control your voices 😍
Seohyun... i love her hightnote. it's so success. and she improve day by day
Seohyun is slaying this song! Im happy they gave her most of the highnotes in this one
oh my god seohyun and taeyeon's voices!!
Oh my gee!! Taeyeon, Seohyun, Tiffany and Sunny high notes are amazing! I must say Seohyun-ie you really improved a lot, those high notes + emotions, i'm getting chills. As usual Taeyeon did an awesome job, i got chills every time she opens her mouth. This is my favourite song in the album, but too much TTS, how I wish it was distributed properly. Really want them to perform this on music shows!!!!!!!
iknowright Seohyun is a queen ♡
Sunny has a high note on this song?
Seohyun voice is so sweet and powerful wow
seohyun voice very amazing, my fav member in SNSD
My favorite is still Taeyeon, but it IS a close call.
Seohyun makes the best high note on the chorus ♡ She's the best ♡
On the high note, but she's got a way to go before she's going to catch Taeyeon's power and emotion.
@2:04 if you listen carefully, you'll hear Seohyun's amazing harmonizing with the girls and then afterwards her perfect high notes. She used to struggle with these kinds of notes because of her bad breath techniques but now she just slays every single note, really appreciate her impressive improvement ❤
서현 목소리 노래에 너무 잘 어울려요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 1절 후렴 무한반복중
SEOHYUN voice for this song👍👍👍👍
Seohyun you Slay again! What the!!!! Im sooooo proud of youuuuu😍😍😍💪🏻🔥
Seohyun did very well.
Taeyeon voice omggg a voice veryyyy pretty
Seohyun has drama filming before this fanmeet starting and has to go back filming drama after this fanmeet ended. She must be so tired yet her voice still sound so beautiful also her high note 👏
I agree when people say Tiffany is awesome only when she sings in lower notes. Yes, she's more suitable that way. But I disagree if people say she cannot sing or poor singer. Fany has a husky voice which for me is very unique and catchy. Do all singers have to be able to sing high notes perfectly only to be called by you as a "singer"? Regardless, Fany is always bright, beautiful, classy, friendly, and most of all, she's very hardworking!
Taeyeon's high note is amazing!!
And sunny voice is sooooo beautiful..
Best song on the album, and my Seolady slayed it 😍😍😍
Seohyun😘😘😘
I love how they zoom in when Seohyun's part came.
SEOHYUN HIGHNOTE OMG
I'm no music expert but I love it when tiffany does a high note and it resonate/echos. It's so her
Seohyun unnie? why so amazing!
Seohyun
My biased is Seohyun.. she slayed so hard in this song.. which I love so much.. but, I still cannot deny that Tiffany husky voice add the emotional in it (Do not bash her pplez, she really sound good, I can't deny..) & also Sunny sweet voice (I'm melting).. not to forget Taeyeon powerful voice (as always).. well, ofc other members also did so good in here too..
Overall, I love Seohyun, Tiffany and sunny voice the most.. their part is so good in my 👂...
SEOHYUN KILLEEEED IT
My hyoyeon still can make yoona laugh/smile during their ballad song, so cute how she's trying to peak at the screen as she forgot her lyrics 😂❤️
one of my favorite in this album 😍😍
finally my UB #seohyun have the most line...
Tiffany slayed i know u guys won't compliment her so yeah Fany i love u and thank u for improving each new day even if people love ignoring u and sleeping on u. Wat a queen. Seohyun sounds so good am happy she got a lot of lines!
I'll admit, i use to give Tiff a hard time, but she has improved. She has more to work on, (everyone does) but she deserves some credit.
i love her but she cracked + strained both the high notes
myong2206 Taeyeon strained and went off pitch too :) Neither was Seohyun at her best (but she was the best out of the three). Also , belts aren't really Tiffany's best. In Lady Marmamalde , she did a great job there. Which shows she just needs to work on consistency.
Love Miyoung 💙
yes that's why we youngones are alone and it really hurts hearing bad words to our fany from so called "sone". she doesnt deserve it
Tiffany's voice is amazing 🤍
Seohuyn 😍
Am I the only one who likes Tiffany's voice???
I don't know how another fans can saying bad about Tiffany. Are you a truly sone? Or you hate only her?
As a sone I support all members. As sone I don't hate anyone.
I just hope that SNSD will be perform for a long time♡
Yuliya Stream man I actually like her voice. It's not about preference . It's about technique. And shouting isn't one.
fleur but most of the "fans" said that her voice is terrible, annoying and blah blah
Tiffany proofed many times, that she can sing. And she sing great.
For example IJWD accapella ver, Beaming Effect concert...
Yuliya Stream yes to be honest she surprised me for this one performance (i just wanna dance accoustic ver.). But do you know why? Because she didn't shout, no even once. She did the high parts in falsetto, which she manages to do great. What we need to understand is that whether we like her voice color or not (which is totally subjective, the same goes for every other member), we know shouting isn't singing, and shouting hurts vocal chords (we don't need to be a specialist to know that by the way :))
fleur I don't know why you try explain me about shouting 😅, because I know about this😂
I didn't tell nothing about technique. I tell about comments from "fans".
I don't know about you, but I enjoy this perfomance.
This perfomance very beautiful and emotional
Yuliya Stream yes but why do you think "fans" as you call them say that? Even if they say "i don't like her voice/singing" don't you think they mostly mean her "technique"?
Yes I enjoyed the audio version a lot but the live is just meeh
Seohyun ... good
How about VERY good!
SNSD made SONEs enter "Into The New World" and today on 9th October 2017, our "One Last Time" with OT8. I was there at their 10th Anniversary because I feared our biggest fear will come true. To the best years of my life, thank you SNSD. Once A SONE, Forever A SONE.
OMG thanks for this. I love seohyun voice in this song 💕 sunny too, sweet n beautiful voice 💕 tae is awesome as always 💕fany, i love her part ~ jigeum neol ilchi anke hae jweo Yeah ~
💕This song is so emo 😣😢
Really.. exactly as i thought
Seohyunniieeee💕💕💕💋
As expected everybody is gonna pick on Tiffany. She actually sounded fine , Seohyun did the best , and Taeyeon had a bit out shouting and off pitch moments. This isn't easy because the difference in pitch is huge.
Caristalalala Tan Sunny did great too. Sunny & Seohyun was the most stable here. You are right Taeyeon wasn't her best here but Tiffany did mess up at some parts while others were fine.
TimelessGap2 What's the definition of Tiffany messing up? I understand tht Tiffany had difficulties doing belt which she always had. However , everybody only zooms in at her mistakes while they don't even say a thing when other vocalists does it. Taeyeon , Seohyun who had the same note as her didn't do well either. Taeyeon strained as well and it one of her notes she went slightly off and Seohyun who did best didn't really pull it off either. Tiffany needs a bit more time to get used to but so what? She did Sailing so well. So why's everybody saying only she can't sing? I know that Sunny did very well but I was mainly talking about TTS who had belts. Also , this is a mainly TTS song anyways.
Caristalalala Tan I said she messed up on some parts but was fine on others. Yes it was mostly a TTS song and Taeyeon did sound horrible at times Seohyun did mess up a few times too but in general Sunny & her were the most stable. My few co-worker & Kpopper call me the professional fan. She said that I'm the most unbias critic she had ever met. IDC if you're my favorite or least favorite I give credit where it's due & check those that mess up. I will never praise & say you did well when you didn't or vice versa. I said countless times that Fany's kingdom is her low notes and that she struggles a great deal with high but at times she does pull through. I even went on to say that she's not to blame but the line distributor for giving her those lines. She cracks, scream or strain. Taeyeon, Seohyun, Jessica & Sunny also have times when they struggle with notes. I believe as a singer you should challenge yourself but at the same time this can be harmful to her vocal in the long run.
I do agree with you that most people only pinpoint times when the girls mess up & make stupid comments while neglecting their greatness and this is wrong. But what I hate the most is when they degrade the others & may up excuses for when their bias is the one who mess up.
But tbh Snsd is already in their eleventh year, shouldn’t they be improved and idk at least less mistakes?
This song is actually hard to sing...
Some people are complaining about Tiffany's singing and it's getting annoying. I think she did so well here. Just because Taeyeon and Seohyun sound amazing doesn't mean you have to compare the three and criticize Tiffany's voice. She sounds good on her own, and so do the other girls. Also, this is one of my favorite songs on the album lol 💕
Goo Eleutice I think you don't know a bit of music theory and singing...
Goo Eleutice I think she did well except she strained her high note. But we all know she's not good at belting and even Taeyeon strained so.
Who cares about music theory, I like what is pleasing to my ears.
Yohaku Does straining and screaming please your ears? That's a strange taste.
I agree. 😉
seohyun's highnote so good
I really like Tiffany's part at 2:28, it's so beautiful until the end of the song,, this song is my fav song.
Yashhh
Taeyeon tiffany and seohyun voices so good ❤
Seohyun 💗
Sonhos Silenciosos a eterna utt
She really is the best
Sonhos Silenciosos
dasar
most of the comments are complaining about tiffany, they didn't know that she was actually crying while singing !! I can tell that Yuri,Sunny,Sooyoung and Tiffany were crying just by listening to their voices ..BUT you can check the other fancam for confirmation
Seohyun's high notes :) kills me
Why the hell are most people complaining? Also, seohyun's voice fitted the song most. If other members did her part, youll complain again. Accept the fact that snsd is a group with main and lead vocalist. Main and lead dancer. Im tired if seeing sones complaining. On the other hand, i think you arent sones because if you are, youll love each member and wont say bad and nonsense things about the group. And havent you notice? Sunny's lines increased. Hyoyeon's too. Every mem has 2or more lines. The song is 4 mins, what do you want them to do? Its music. Ofcourse they want the song to be perfect. Dont push it. Why dont you focus on the good things? Where the members excel most? Every girls just cant have it all. Theyre nine. I mean eight. And guys, weve been here, ten years. The group came on top and still, the issue is still about distributting lines? Oh, i saw a hyoyeon dancing on holiday and all night. When it comes to dancing theyre the focused. Cant you see that? Are you blind? You always talkshit about tts. Jelous freaks. Is tts fans complaining about why when it comes to dance, they werent the main focus? Sone, were a family. Im not here from the begginning but im 4 years here. And i know my heart is burried in this group. Dont make a fuss about anything. Theyre all paid fair and get noticed fair so shut up.
Julianne Morillo agree with you. Even in other group you can see vocalist will have more line compare to dance line. And for dance time/break they will more focus on dance line. That why they called dance line and vocal line for a reason. Beside, they choose/distribute line base on whose voice suit those line the most. It's been 10 years, and yet we still argue abt this kind of things. From what i see, dance line distribution is more better in this album compare to previous one. So just be grateful, and keep on supporting.
Julianne Morillo SARANGHAE 🙆💕
There is a difference between being highlighted as the main vocalist and taking up most of the song. After 10 years of being in the biz, one would think that the line distribution would be better. The Lion Heart Album had better distribution than this. 10th anniversary should be about everyone, not highlighting 3 members. TTS sing the high notes, which should have already emphasized their main vocalist status, but nope, they have all the longest and most stood out parts. There shouldnt be a song where the distribution is so obviously unfair. referring to the dancing, so far, thats one song...in which they were just placed in the center...thats nothing comparing to TTS singing the most for every single song in this album. each of the TTS member can give up 1 minute of singing and it would not make a difference in their popularity but it makes a huge difference for the rest of the members. For this song particularly, it is prob the best song on the album, yet, 2 members had less than 5 seconds...some of the lines that TTS sang were not hard or too high for them to be distributed more evenly to the rest, and it would not hurt the song either
Hence u did not read what I wrote...
don't give it much thought. no one said anything when it was jessica taking up most of the lines in the genie album.
seohyun highnote
Sunny been slaying the low note, she sound so beautiful and sweet *me crying*
From INTW to ONELASTIME. THESE GIRLS ARE REALLY CAPABLE OF MAKING ME CRY. 2021. SEOLADYYY
Seohyun slayed
Seohyunnnnn dammnnn 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
seohyun
Seohyun fits the song perfectly jjang 👍😘
Seohyun undoubtedly did the best here, Taeyeon and Sunny were amazing as well, if only the line distribution was a little better, anyway this is still the best song from the album to me ❤
Ngl, she's the talented on the group. But Tiffany one last time on last Chorus is a heaven in my ear, you know what? Sometimes taeyeon high notes wasnt clean like Seohyun, theres a vibrato there, but seo didn't, it's smooth like,
FANY AHHH IM ALWAYS FALLING IN LOVE IN UR HUSKY AND UNIQUE VOICE SINCE 2008 !!! I know ur singing skill improve a lot !! Thank you for ur always work and practice so fucking hard
OMG their voices in songs like this make me cry, the voice of Taeyeon is amazing in all aspects, the accompaniment of Tiffany with Tae .... wow without words, THE BEST!!!💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
There have been thousands of heartbreaking goodbye pop songs but for me this is my favorite. It’s so simple and emotional. And the fact that this is the only time it will ever be performed live makes it that much more powerful.
Lol at the people complaining about TTS getting too many lines. It's a ballad of course the main vocalists are gonna get more lines.
2:28 tiffany sings like she went thru 11 divorces 😭 her husky voice
I love Tiffany's high note and especially the last line "One last timeeeee" 💕💕💕
When this song suddenly has a new meaning
Nabeela 123456 it suddenly hit me that this song give a new meaning
Haters 》》》》 Tiffany... bla... bla... blaaa...
Tiffany 》》》》still beautiful, down to earth, rich, famous, member of GG, one of the main vocalist...
Tiffany Young Hwang... Daebak!!!
Rika Prasetyanti haters always gonna hate
She's a lead vocalist
Rika Prasetyanti absoulty!!!
True
Tiffany never become a main vocalist. Since the beginning it's only Jessica and Taeyeon, and now it's only Taeyeon. SeoSunTiff always as a lead. Don't say bcs there's TTS that means they're the main, duh. And SM never announce or give clue/candidate for the replacement main vocalist. Delulu fans~
I love Seohyun's voice 💗
Thank you your fancam. LOVE GG SO SO SO SO MUCH
Seohyun slay . 👍🏻👌🏼👏🏼
listening to this after playing my holiday night album for the 1st time since i bought it.. i didnt know this is the last time i'll be hearing 8 of them.. i'm so sad i just love how TTS harmonized perfectly... why!!!! i hate you SM!!!!
still get goosebumps listening to this
seohyun
seohyunnie ❤
Seohyun 😍
Good job 😉
I don’t know why but I cry when I listen to this, they’re so amazing and are family, I guess it just gets to me that they’ve done so much and have gone so far, all together forever
My favourite from there last album. I cried a lot because some members left sm that time. Thank you for this fancam 💖
damn. taeyeon's live voice gave me freakin goosebumps. she's always on top when it comes on live performances. main vocal indeed. she is amaziiiing
tiffany's voice slayed too. why haters are complaining😑my bias is seohyun and she did the best too.
I love sunny's voice more here, she sounds so beautiful 😍😍😍
My fave song fro the album. It s very beautiful and they all sound amazing! Seohyun is killing it!!! Taeyeon as well,as always.
Plus,stop talking about Jessica. She was kicked out 3 years ago and she didn t even sang this song,it s pure ot8. So why are you talking about her here? Go at Into the new world or other ot9 song. Jesus.
Seohyun part is the best ...
I envy you! I wanna go see the live and hear them performing every single songs live! I'm crying. Thank you for this fancam.
I wasn’t ready for this song. I wasn’t ready to say goodbye. And leave Tiffany alone she sounds amazing as always.
I want Sunny's part in this song. Her voice suits this song.
yeah especially her low note. she's one of the best among member who did great in low note
i don't think she's one best in low notes,she's great in high notes but she's a bit weak on low note.. hope she will show us better.
Charlene Nartea but still she have only a few lines... 🤔🤔
Dandyu Trash That's her only weakness but when she does do low notes she does more justice than Tiffany with high notes yet SM keeps giving Fany high notes. Why is that?
TimelessGap2 Because Tiffany is a good vocalist. I don't see why you have to only nit pick Tiffany when SeoTae also got a hell lot more lines. Okay? I get that Sunny can get a lot better if she was given time to shine , but this doesn't mean everytime a member doesn't get enough lines (or you think so) , it is Tiffany's fault. Tiffany can do high notes , fools. You're not going to believe it even if you hear it like during her birthday party or Moon and Sunrise cover because you're just gonna make excuses.
Seohyun and Sunny are the best on this performance
I love when Tiffany sings after TaeYeon's high note, wow their voice is so amazing 😍😍
I love this Seohyun ft. SNSD 😂
Tiffany's last, "one last time", always hits me so hard
The haters always gonna hate. Tiffany remains the best in my heart
When seohyun sang best and emotional,she left SM
TIFFANY 😍😍
Seohyun sounds EXACTLY like the recording
Taeyeon's chorus made me cry and i fell in love with taeny singing moment last chorus
Seohyun should be about the same level as taeyeon in this performance. Who agrees??
HaHaHappyXD I disagree. Seohyun did really well because it sounded less strained but it was flat. Taeyeon on the other hand was kinda out of the place and strained to belt that note , like Tiffany.
+Caristalalala Tan that's why I say "should be about the same level" NOT "exactly same level"
HaHaHappyXD agree 💟 she sound amazing 👑
@Smells like hypocrisy it is also facts that Taeyeon is better than Seohyun. Maybe you are just a Taeyeon hater or a Seohyun biased.
Smells like hypocrisy hehehe justify
Tiffany is just talented and perfect ❤️
TIFFANY HER VOICE IS JUST SO PERFECT TO BE TRUE T--T THAT ADLIBS ANF THAT HIGH NOTEEE T---T DAMN GIRL T-T
and seohyun has nice voice...😍😍
I miss singer seohyun so much😭❤❤❤❤❤
All night is my freaking jam but I think this is the best song in the album... it's so good!
I don't see why you guys have to hate or bash certain members just enjoy this amazing song and leave the negativity out. We should be helping out girls and showing our support not bringing them down you guys.
Tiffany one last time on last chorus was an heaven ❤
When all of them harmonize i can hear angels singing
This and light up the sky are beautiful songs