Is Russian culture uncomfortable with the concept of happiness? - BBC REEL
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 พ.ค. 2020
- Nobel Prize writer Svetlana Alexievich has interviewed hundreds of people in Russia for her upcoming book about love. In these excerpts, Alexievich tries to find out why Russian culture seems to be so uncomfortable with the concept of happiness and explores the possibility of living a full life without ever being in love.
Excerpts from the film Lyubov - Love in Russian by Staffan Julén and Svetlana Alexievich
#bbcreel #bbc #bbcnews
I know plenty of happy Russians. I think this is a bit of a stereotype. Although cocaine is probably harder to come by in Russia.
In my Russian classes as a teenager and in the many many Russian books I've read,this seems so accurate a theme, unfortunately. Well covered,BBC.
I can also find hundreds of unhappy people in any country and manipulate that as a majority stat.
Yes there is some very unhappy people in Europe that have had their children murdered by migrants recently, but the corrupt BBC won't report on that!!
You never have read Russian poetry.
Have not read Russian history.
You speak of things you know nothing about
We often forget to love ourselves first in pursuit to love & to be loved.
i’m ethnic Armenian grow up in Russia then moved to cyprus
i think this video is so far from Russia and Russian people!!! they knows how to be happy!!!
even in a poor villages
this video is something wired!!!!!! each country has a different stories
they found these two people who are in a deep depression just it!!!
We know how to fun, but be happy so far from have fun... You can't just be happy if you always have fun... For real happyness you must grieve well sometimes... Without feeling bad you can't feel good.
I wasting my time on a computer games and it's fun but i can't be happy because i... Because i just waste time! I do nothing to make my dreams come true, i don't improving myself... Some of my comrades, as i understand, feel like this too.
this video is pure propaganda
I think that she's struggling more with the idea that she's deserving of love rather than love itself.
It is filosofy work of Svetlana on the subject: "What is love?". How she can write about emotions which she never felt? To write book by woman "What feel the man" will have the same true. People in Russia don't love less than in other countries, but they are more truly in their feelings. They will never say:" I am happy, everything is great", if there is not. It is difference. But it is nothing connected with love. Mentality of Europe countries is to in any difficult situation try to smile and always say :" Everything is great". It is not happiness, it is style of behavior. And people in Russia always try to share their happiness and pain with their close people and friends. I see here more love than in frases "I am great", "Everything is perfect" and ect. But will be interesting to read this book.
By your own standards, you cannot write of the European countries experience if you are not of those countries.
A Pole myself, I fully understand the whole happiness thing. I think the problem is in words. We of course can be happy, smiling, laughing, having a good time etc. What she means by "happiness" is IMHO "being successful/fulifilled and feeling it's deserved". So basically it's about living without the stigma of imperfection, showing with one's life that a heaven is possible here. But it goes against our religious traditions (and history). We are to suffer, and we will, and we even should. Suffering is dignity. Life is suffering. So happiness - in the sense I'm talking about - seems suspicious, immoral, stupid. And with the whole media schtick of showing people who are happy because they've purchased something, it's in a way natural to lean towards suffering as a more noble, thoughtful way of living. However, I can't forget the Book of Job. He, after the whole ordeal God ahd put him thru, was rewarded not with heaven but with a new and successful life. I mean - the lesson here should be "you have the right to be happy, and happy about it - even though it won't last." But still.
In a modern world we all are unhappy.
Not comparing love to sunstroke would be a start.
Yes, that was very telling. Love happens like a heatstroke. Eww.
Какая прекрасная девушка!
Well the answer is clear. We are not so keen on taking happy pills like people in the west. We see life as it is and not through the pink glasses. Read bible. Life is a journey, filled with struggles. In a way it is a test. We dig deeper. Read about russian sole. But to be honest this video is not special. You find that kind of conversations near each house where grandmothers sit and talk.
No wonder Russians are realistic and that the concept of happiness has faded away in their mindset, since they have been through a lot in the course of their history, I can say they had the most hardships of all nations in the history of the planet, they lost so many people and they are proud that they have endured it and still survived.
Their mindset is accustomed to suffering and enduring hardships, and they will always fight trough anything until the very last atom of energy.
milutinke what about the jews? maybe a similar concept applys to them because of their history. i always feel that israels jews somehow are very sensitive and anxious as a nation. not ready to feel happy yet. in a way similar.
also germans with their recent history somehow carry an unspoken heavyness of guilt. barely recognisable but compared to the lightness of other ethnies suddenly visible.
''They had the most hardships of all nations in the history of the planet'' > tell that to the dozens of nations they occupied!
trildi as example?
@@trildi Are you confused with the Americans or the British ...
@@LizVerkannt вообще на русской крови вся эта история с евреями выехала. не было бы русской крови уплачено, и мир был бы другим, и про лагеря смерти, неосвобожденные русским солдатом, никто бы не узнал.
Interesting
happiness and unhappiness are purely subjective things. Someone is unhappy because they have soup without meat, and someone has small diamonds
Thanks for this! Why all the dislikes!? Btw, I think the sentiment expressed by the journo is LaRochefould not Voltaire... St Augustine had profound things to say about love!
What is the soundtrack in the beginning?
Very strange title. Feels like the author of the video was implying some specific answer and even used a sad music to manipulate our feelings...
Hate it when journalists do that!
That's cap. Look at me, I'm happy 😌
I wish to connect with Ms. Alexievich, how can I get her email?
Excellent, it's not only applicable for Russians but humanity as a whole
@@caduceussucks4523 ok bot
I live in Romania and I am very happy :)))
“My God , how sad our Russia is !” A.S. Pushkin
oh wow.. she's pretty...
Oh god she's ugly... Open your eyes
You will know love when you have a child! You Love them so much and their happiness mean more to you than your own.
The Russian literature does not help if you are looking for happiness. It is the main part of the heritage that keeps on pulling Russian backward to a psychological and philosophical attitude towards life that is depressing. You got a lock on deep literature, but be careful of what you wish for: It is a double-edged sword. Unless Russian literature break with Russian literary tradition, you will keep on reproducing literature that may be great, but one-sided, i.e, deeper and deeper towards the abyss. Create frivolous literature for a change.
Asfor 'happiness' it's for children isn't it? That's why adolescence is so hard, when happiness starts to be replaced by stress and anxiety, and people start to drink and take drugs.
Doctors think it depends on pharmaceutical drugs, anti depressants and so on.
No one can tell you how to live, you have to figure it out yourself but if you spend it chasing happiness you might find it's a chimera.
Anyway the Russian president wants to abolish happiness altogether, even for children..
is BBC Reel saying i am not happy ok i from russia and is happy for what i have this video make me smile
"Bread tastes better when we eat it together." This may mean that the reason it tastes better is the competition over who would grab the crustier part, not sharing the good parts. It is basically competing couched as sharing. This competition underlies the need to share.
Are the BBC redactors uncomfortable with the concept of smartness?
I don't why, but it very difficult for me watch!!
Знаменитые высказывания - бьет значит любит
To me, this was quite depressing.
Does anyone know whether this book was published yet? I believe Svetlana had to leave Belarus.
Russian culture is apparently uncomfortable with the concept of normality. It's still a long way to happiness...
Very probing discussion. Love is the union of souls. Whoever lives in love lives in God, and God in them.
see en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anna_Karenina_principle
Have you looked at their leader?
They just need someone to love them to death! Instead of disappointing them constantly! Freedom of speech without fear of prosecution, more sunshine, cheaper rent, higher paying jobs and more women in power than men! I bet they would be smiling all the way to the bank! They need hope!
They sound so tormented. That's how imagine purgatory to be like. But, it is not only them, I've heard many brits here in the US say that they hate how happy Americans are. They just want to be left alone with their drink. I also have a friend who is Dutch-American and he's miserable most of the time, the only relationship he has that can be considered close to love or happiness is to his glass of vodka. 😂 People love their alcohol.
Brain scans and chemical analysis seem to indicate that there are three physical systems of love, each with its separate neural pathways, separate region of the brain, and different brain hormone activated and dispersed. Buddhism two and a half millennia ago discussed unhappiness and said it offered a cure. Here, our ex cold war enemies bare their souls to offer a window into our shared humanity.
Meu Deus abençoe a todos envolvidos no video e familias e todos aqui nos comentarios e familias em nome do Senhor Jesus Cristo🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏7777777...
As Russian, i say - this video looks like a delirium.
something like this th-cam.com/video/BCxCRI2Qv6U/w-d-xo.html ... Угу.
Старые маразматики, не грузите девочку, не портите ее будущее! У нее все нормально с восприятием! Это у вас депресняк! Нет образца счастья! Все рамки губят самое большое счастье! Легкость и беззаботность- это нормально! Не грузите вы нас!
Девочка, беги ты от родителей в свою собственеую жизнь!!! Не будь ты такой хорошей! Не позволяй им, тебя раздавить этим столетним депресняком!!! ❤️💋
😅
А что касается Любви, то я верю лишь в такое - th-cam.com/video/CSRUEhLJAd0/w-d-xo.html
И верю и знаю.
Вот уж с такой достоевщиной как в видео - проблем не имею...
Its an illusion & not all its cracked up to be.
Unhappiness means profit. Doesn't matter whether it's unter capitalism or communism
This applies to human beings,not just Russian. It is when people keep searching happiness from external sources.
короче, русские - это учихи
And Russian cities overview from quadrocopters :
Peterburg th-cam.com/video/4EoUz39nPMM/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/xx0Os4sOquc/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/1DwggMpeIT4/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/eMEH6LG9_iQ/w-d-xo.html
Moscov
th-cam.com/video/S_dfq9rFWAE/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/Hv3fH5_u0qU/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/AfWP8jDx-Ik/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/B8Iee1Ckidc/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/HLXpIs17Fjk/w-d-xo.html
Pskov
th-cam.com/video/6DzuKE2YwUM/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/L4tzo5ipcHM/w-d-xo.html
Novgorod
th-cam.com/video/PEk3uIqUEA8/w-d-xo.html
Tula
th-cam.com/video/rrKWdkttEz0/w-d-xo.html
Kursk
th-cam.com/video/l8dfpYCvbtc/w-d-xo.html
Tver
th-cam.com/video/-iy0cmxtFHc/w-d-xo.html
Vladimir
th-cam.com/video/TEov7X-vnkM/w-d-xo.html
Kazan
th-cam.com/video/G8lK5g_AMe4/w-d-xo.html
Volgograd (Stalingrad)
th-cam.com/video/CtfA1blloks/w-d-xo.html
Ioshkar-Ola
th-cam.com/video/4tpzu7vs_WQ/w-d-xo.html
Ekaterinburg
th-cam.com/video/1OFp1NO-FW4/w-d-xo.html
Rostov-na-Donu
th-cam.com/video/M0apxj0oRYM/w-d-xo.html
Orel
th-cam.com/video/QeYX0K0QxEY/w-d-xo.html
Krasnoyarsk
th-cam.com/video/cdrGROvCT9M/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/US1jpbWwU1A/w-d-xo.html
Yaroslavl
th-cam.com/video/W5czGfY4D8U/w-d-xo.html
Novosibirsk
th-cam.com/video/m8zk_evi-W8/w-d-xo.html
Piatygorsk
th-cam.com/video/mCbpA5IlTHA/w-d-xo.html
Nizhny-Novgorod
th-cam.com/video/llbLjduXutg/w-d-xo.html
Irkutsk
th-cam.com/video/jhUpgQi4Yjw/w-d-xo.html
Cheliabinsk
th-cam.com/video/6nVyXceKi0E/w-d-xo.html
Kaliningrad
th-cam.com/video/n5khzHb9-O4/w-d-xo.html
Sochi
th-cam.com/video/u2mn3-x0Bec/w-d-xo.html
Sevastopol
th-cam.com/video/Vn5FsKDxA4Y/w-d-xo.html
Yalta
th-cam.com/video/ime3ZofmqYU/w-d-xo.html
Archangelsk
th-cam.com/video/sX1To0fFrpQ/w-d-xo.html
Vladivostok
th-cam.com/video/xK23RHXXlJ4/w-d-xo.html
@ Pilum 1000
Thank you for the list.
Very nice.
It's cold there... Most of the time!
@thesky322 On Twitter
Current Location : Miami, FL - Earth
Putin is Happy..I guess
why does he poison people then
Would a happy person be so desperate to receive more and more wealth and wish to live in his imaginary world?
In modern Russia, a popular trend has recently become that our country is poor and squalid and "it's time to get out of here." Everyone blames the almost authoritarian government, corruption, and simply the fact that everything is "bad"in our country. Today we will try to consider the advantages of living in Russia according to foreigners who have visited Russia and Russian emigrants who have been living abroad for a long time.
The Russian Federation is a huge country. Naturally, the standard of living in Moscow and Saint Petersburg differs from that of Novosibirsk or Krasnodar and Saratov. Nevertheless, the life of every Russian is a weekday with its own troubles and long-awaited weekends. Well, let's look at the advantages of life in our country through the eyes of our emigrants, just foreigners and migrants working here.
Public transport
For certain historical reasons, public transport in Russia is one of the most developed in the world. Both large and small cities in Russia have lines of city buses, trams, and trolleybuses. Bus transport between small towns and villages is highly developed. The Russian metro is one of the best in the world, and it's not just in Moscow. This applies, at least, to its cleanliness and operation in General. For example, in the same United States, public transport is very poorly developed, and the metro either works intermittently, or it is impossible to stay in it. In Western countries, it is impossible to imagine everyday life without a car. Although this trend is now gaining momentum in Russia. Here are the statistics: In Russia, as of July 1, 2019, there are 306 passenger cars per one thousand inhabitants.
Free education and medicine
No matter how much dirt and lies are poured on our country, there are free kindergartens in Russia where parents pay only for food, free schools, and free libraries. They are the majority, because the education system in Russia is state-owned and is not planted with a huge number of private schools and kindergartens, as in the United States. For the most part, medical care is provided free of charge, and ambulance services in Russia are completely free of charge. In Russia, the population undergoes free medical examination and in principle does not pay even for the same x-ray, except if you went to a private clinic. Russian medicine has many haters, even among its population, who complain about waiting lists and say: "but abroad... But there they are treated better and in General, the medicine is better...". Although, if they ever got sick in the same USA or another country, they would decide that it would be better to sit in line. In Western countries, the "best" medicine that does not slip from the lips of our fans of everything "foreign" is available to a narrow circle of people who have a wide purse. About medicine in some countries of Asia, Latin America, and even more so, Africa-it is better to keep silent.
The Internet
In Russia, many cafes and eateries, parks and squares, and even public transport, have free Internet. But, many Western cities-such can not boast. Or it is, but the Internet speed is low. In Russia, the Internet is very fast and very cheap. In Russia, you will have enough 1 thousand rubles to enjoy high-speed Internet and there will be no restrictions, such as all sorts of packages, after the exhaustion of which, you will have to buy a new one to return to the original speed. Many will talk about punishments for various statements and misinformation on the Internet. But Russia is not the only one here, even in Germany, the lights of democracy - there are such restrictions. And Russia will definitely not reach the level of China. It has already formed its own Internet culture and the state media, government agencies and the economy as a whole are tied to the Internet.
Delicious food
In Russia, very tasty products, as they are grown on farms. In Russia, the culture of fast food is not so widespread, and cooking at home is a whole culture, tradition and ritual. And, say, in the West, people eat in a diner, and at home they rarely cook food, but heat it in the microwave, namely, purchased semi-finished products. If in Russia, semi-finished products have more natural origin, then abroad, as the foreigners themselves claim, they are tired of unnatural food. And in the same China, there are doubts about the naturalness of products. But, about dairy products in the countries of the West and East, you can generally write a separate article.
Really liked that she has a Dostoevsky portrait hanging on the wall behind her!
They're happy when drinking vodka, beat the women while singing patriotic songs.
Because they miss the real Russia the Empire of the Czarist Russia.
Mario Makiling - probably not because most of their ancestors were serfs until Tzar Alexander ended the institution, which also resulted in many people being thrown off their land.
no one misses The Empire. there are more people who prefer REAL democracy or communism.
@@anastasiiaiurkova8897 we both Russians but u know I'd prefer Empire. That would be really better than live in Putin's tyranny. (Yeah guys most of Russians think that Putin sucks, we want Naval'nyy to be our president.) Putin didn't help us in this time of quarantine, he is absolutely worthless. A lot of people don't have any money or food and masks because of Putin's greed. Also he stiled about 70% of Russian money with his mafia friends...
@@rifa_sempaioppa8458 I'd rather you guys not have the empire back for the sake of relationship between America and Russia. I do hope you guys figure things out though but I also want America and Russia to be allies rather than so tense. I think the people of Russia and America have alot in common
never took out a loan
Doomer Capital
Please translate in Hindi oppisson in youtube 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
The nature of life is that everything will perish.
Knowing God created the world and into him you will return. Knowing life is a test will give you peace. Being grateful for what you have will give you happiness.
If you believe in achievement and purpose you carry a heavy load Guilt from religions do this too you must feel you owe people something unrealistically . If happiness comes it isn't going to be effort that makes it happen Taoism isn't a religion and is only a chronicle of human lives for the sake of wisdom alone It states that 'your way that is weighable isn't your real way.' that if you make an effort to do something you are lying to yourself Some quotes release effort this way "Scatter things and then you will gather them' Because in nature you cannot force yourself with effort usually without paying to some extent for your physical effort. "A good traveler isn't concerned to get there' because you make no effort you have more energy if you are present . If your house is empty you are useful if your house is full you are not useful because if empty you can be yourself and not worry about measurements . Taoism actually came from Trypillia a female based society before the Egyptians many years. They were an agricultural society who went to different societies around them for wisdom and some of these quotes are that old. Taoism believes we rotate even should there be an after existence Another quote is ' if you keep doing what you are doing you might get there' which does give repose . Tao doesn't believe in force of effort due it causes you stress and only hurts others unnecessarily Example if you enjoy hurting others the Tao believes we are babies in the womb even after death That should you enjoy hurting other's it would be you you would hurt They believe we are deaf , dumb and blind to nature and the essence of life However if you knew where the seed of life goes your genius. When people have died also they always state they are in the dark and see perhaps loved ones a light or lights yet always in the dark. This is like the Mother who keeps her babies in her womb and so are we to the Tao. If it were true that you have enemies in an after life in Tao that enemy if cruel and hurtful would only hurt themselves .
Милая девочка... Когда она придет, любовь, с этим мигом счастья, ты это сразу поймешь. И тогда будешь готова умереть. Это очень просто. Но это чувство мимолетное. Нет вечного счастья с кем-то. Есть чувство осознания, что ты это испытала, это подтверждение твоей исключительности. И не слушай бред старых депрессивных христианских теток. Схватить, удержать, иметь всегда с одним человеком-бред.
Счастья тебе. Ты классная.😘😘😘
Russians are among the most generally kind and loving people I've ever met in my life. As many wise men have noted, nothing flees your grasp quicker when you try to grab it than "happiness". We are made in the image of God, Who is a Trinity. In other words, at the root of all reality there is unselfishness. As St. Paul said Christ taught "It is better to give than to receive." The Orthodox Church and Saints teaches us how to live this way
Communism does that to humans.
it is not communism lol
it is our goverment who is corrupted and not honest with their people
also it's our society that is very judgemental
Aleksandr Ivanov I will not dare to lecture a Russian on his own literary history, but depending on your age, I would expect you to agree (also on a global scale) that communism has brought wall-to-wall misery everywhere it has been tested.
Going back to Mother Russia, there is perhaps a melancholy in your spirit and some of your literature has depicted it, thus reinforcing. I’ve sometimes wondered if it was the climate, the land, history or a combination of these. Any thoughts?
75 летие победы коммунизма над фашизмом. Коммунизм это оккупация свободных стран. Полное или частичное уничтожение населения оккупированных стран. Полное или частичное выселение целых наций, народов в Сибирь, Среднюю Азию, Казахстан. Внесудебные казни, расстрелы, пытки. Переделывание истории. И это всё победа...? Это не победа, это победа империи зла. Праздновать и радоваться нечему.
9 мая это день скорби над всеми теми кто не вернулся с войны, над всеми теми чьи жизни загублены, над всеми теми чья память и честь были затоптаны империей зла - СССР и правопреемницей Руссистской, человеканенавистнической, откровенно фашистской России.
Если бы не СССР, твою родню нацисты на мыло бы пустили...откуда таких деградантов берут...
Russians are happy when comrade Stalin says so.
There are psychological reasons for any aggression. And if the behavior is repeated, if a certain pattern of behavior is observed generation after generation, there must be an explanation. As you know, every nation has certain patterns of sexual behavior due to genetics. Someone by nature has a strong potency, someone has a weaker potency, this is transmitted by certain genes. The question is why Russian women send men away from themselves, and Ukrainian women follow their men to war, hold on to men to the last. Why do Russians need to prove something to someone all the time, it's like a demonstration of a penis. And the Ukrainians are fine, they have no need to show off at all. Look at tiktok, Ukrainian soldiers are either dancing or joking or playing with animals, i.e. Ukrainians do not have a factor of some kind of inferiority, they never need to prove anything, they just kill in cold blood. I'm trying to explain in purely scientific language. I looked at the statistics, the length of the penis is almost the same for Russians and Ukrainians, but the volume of the penis is much larger of Ukrainians.
*BECAUSE THOSE, WHO HAVE SINNED ENOUGH IN PREVIOUS LIFE, NEXT TIME WILL INCARNATE IN RUSSIA*
Russia is a vast void of sad and miserable country. Though, this video is very thought provoking and reflective.
They become very happy once they drink some vodka, the only thing they really need...
Зачем вы этим достоевским запад грузите? Это чистый плагиат. Кому надо, тот возьмет в руки оригинал.
Негодная передача. Девочка-ангел. Оторваться от сиськи-и пубертет позади. Всем везде давно все эти темы понятны. А о счастье вам никто персонально не докладывает, чтобы его, это счастье сберечь. Вы, мадам, портите все своей энергией. Ничего не истончается, все есть. Вы просто депрессивно стареете. Как ужасна ваша передача. Не грузите молодежь вашей завистью. Просто ужас, что вы изрыгаете. Ипохондры руцкие
The brutal persecution of religious minorities in Russia Must end! Russia must respect religious Freedom.
No. We don’t want to turn on country into another Germanistan and Britanobad
To everyone who reads comments.
I read all the comments below and I am the 100 th comment.
You came here to find out about happiness or give advice.
I have some advice that may help you.
1. Happiness is fleeting because is is based on luck. Look up the word it is hapless, by chance.
God's Joy
To live in the Creator's Joy is not luck or fleeting.
Yes it is in a Christian book but the Creator created you and it speaks to all that will read it.
2. Vitamin D deficiency causes extreme depression.
So dose, B complex deficiency and vitamin C deficiency.
3. Liver related depression caused by deficiency and causes depression.
4. SAM-e helps make the 40,000 neurotransmitters that are used in the brain the heart and the gut.
SAM-e repairs joint function, liver function, and improves mood.
SAM-e replaces all 40,000 neurotransmitters so that your brain in your heart work correctly. You will think more clearly and feel more affinity towards situations.
SAM-e repairs DNA damage at 12 to 1600 mg.
MAKE SURE YOU TAKE WITH FOLIC ACID.
Make sure you read up on it. Take it before bed, and do not operate machinery.
I know from personal experience this works, as I've used it on myself, and I helped others with it, and I hope to help you with it now.
I am not a doctor but I hope this works for you cuz it did for me.
If they refrained from invading other countries, perhaps they would experience greater happiness. This is a minor point, but one on which we can all agree - aggression does not lead to happiness. It is unfortunate that the Russians appear to be lagging behind the modern world, which is quite embarrassing.
Russians need to be open and also USA should not ban citizens of a county.
Wdym by that?
Russia is best country
Um, everyone roots for their own team. There is nothing wrong with that.
Справка кратко :
Преступления России :
Поволжских немцев, корейцев, западных украинцев, латышей, эстонцев, литовцев, евреев, все вышеперечисленные нации репрессированны и частично высланы Россией. Черкессов, карачаевцев, балкарцев, крымских татар, калмыков, Чеченцев, ингушей, полностью репрессировали и выслали поголовно без права на возвращение всё той же Россией.
Это всё произошло во время второй мировой войны.
Всё то что делала царская Россия на протяжении истории со всеми нациями вокруг золотого русского кольца и всё то что Советская Россия после войны и не описать в маленьком формате.
История базируется на фактах, а факты вещь упрямая. Историю не переделать и не заболтать.
Поэтому все вокруг бегут от России, и не хотят с ней иметь ничего общего.
Русский мир он страшен, коварен, беспощаден, бесправен и кровав.
ровно как твой мир?)
Read the Quran. No matter how hard we try it, this world will never be perfect even for the richest fabulous powerful people in the world. Why? Because this is so temporary. Read the Quran. I beg you.
I rad it. Now I’m 200% atheist. Before reading it I was 100%.
👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
state Department propaganda )))))))))))
symptomatic comment
👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎