Our official ratings: Sofia Pizza Shoppe: Max - 8.1 Sid - 8.5 Village Square Pizza: Max - 7.6 Sid - 7.9 Scarr’s Pizza: Max - 8.8 Sid - 8.5 Prince Street Pizza: Max - 9 Sid - 8.9 Patsy’s Pizzeria: Max - 8.2 Sid - 8.3 All of these slices were amazing and we thoroughly enjoyed all of them! Our favorite was probably Prince Street, but Scarr’s and Sofia were not far behind! And Patsy’s definitely gets the award for most classic. Let us know, what is your favorite slice in Manhattan? Or anywhere! 😁🍕
Are all of these places cash only? I definitely didn't know that NYC has some good pan pizza places. Besides Village Square and Patsy's, did the others have many topping options or was it primarily cheese and pepperoni? Thanks for sharing!
Scarr’s and Patsy’s were cash only. As is Joe’s from our other video. Everywhere else took cards! It’s mostly cheese and pepperoni at Scarr’s and Prince Street. Sofia had a few other options. Village Square has some exotic ones like vodka sauce and buffalo chicken!
Joe’s is another absolute classic! Probably a solid 7.8 for our rating. You can’t go wrong at any of these places, it is just the BEST pizza!! Prince Street was our favorite, Scarr’s not far behind. We just recently learned that Scarr’s is temporarily closed, hopefully they open back up soon!
Our official ratings:
Sofia Pizza Shoppe: Max - 8.1 Sid - 8.5
Village Square Pizza: Max - 7.6 Sid - 7.9
Scarr’s Pizza: Max - 8.8 Sid - 8.5
Prince Street Pizza: Max - 9 Sid - 8.9
Patsy’s Pizzeria: Max - 8.2 Sid - 8.3
All of these slices were amazing and we thoroughly enjoyed all of them! Our favorite was probably Prince Street, but Scarr’s and Sofia were not far behind! And Patsy’s definitely gets the award for most classic.
Let us know, what is your favorite slice in Manhattan? Or anywhere! 😁🍕
When you know the video is gonna be good so you save it for a chill moment in bed.
Love that 😁👏
Getting ready to go to New York soon. This is great information
So glad it’s helpful, thanks for watching!
New York City is KING of Pizza!!!
Could not agree more!! 😋🍕🗽
🍕❤ love from The Netherlands 🇳🇱
Thanks for watching!! 🇳🇱❤️
Are all of these places cash only? I definitely didn't know that NYC has some good pan pizza places. Besides Village Square and Patsy's, did the others have many topping options or was it primarily cheese and pepperoni? Thanks for sharing!
Scarr’s and Patsy’s were cash only. As is Joe’s from our other video. Everywhere else took cards! It’s mostly cheese and pepperoni at Scarr’s and Prince Street. Sofia had a few other options. Village Square has some exotic ones like vodka sauce and buffalo chicken!
💙💙💙💙
❤️🍕
Also, how would you rate Joe's from your last video? Curious to see where they one stacks up in the mix.
Joe’s is another absolute classic! Probably a solid 7.8 for our rating. You can’t go wrong at any of these places, it is just the BEST pizza!! Prince Street was our favorite, Scarr’s not far behind. We just recently learned that Scarr’s is temporarily closed, hopefully they open back up soon!
Why do you put pepper and garlic powder on each slice prior to tasting it
I don’t think we did that for each slice, did we? Only Patsy’s? I think we thought the garlic was Parmesan actually 😂 it was good though!