U so right, maybe it was the going home part, but we all know going home isn't true! Lol 😂😆 Elgin still didn't understand that. The entity doesn't grant u nothing good, not even for your own good deeds as Elgin think hes done.
@@Angel81773biblical angels are described as looking terrifying to humans, so, I can see where he might think that. But, she tried to drown him and he’s just being naive.
i think he stood there just because he genuinely thought he is doing the right thing and he thought he can take however much torture he must to save everyone, i don't think he's a inherently bad person, just like sarah isn't
Here's an observation from an old who lived in the 70s-- The jeans Julie is wearing at the end are definitely from 1978. I know because I had a pair of those, probably Jordache jeans. Her haircut is also very late 70s. It looks like Julie the Storywalker went back to 1978, when Victor and his family arrived at the town.
In the last scene, where Jim is killed, Julie is wearing the exact same outfit she had on when she first entered the town, in season one, ep one. (I was born in 1967 btw)
Ethan said "No one can change the story once it's been told". When she appeared in front of Jim, she told him "you need to run...I think this is when it happens...I need to change the story". That's Future Julie coming back to a story that's already been told and trying to change it.
I fell in love with Sara this episode 😂 That’s the first time I went crazy with an outburst on this show I was jumping around in joy for her 😂 sadly 🤦🏿♂️ considering the circumstances 😂
I think Tabby and Jade were apart of the group who chose to sacrifice their children for eternal life, but they tried to back out when it was too late, so instead they told them the story that they poured into the roots. But because their daughter was still sacrificed, they get eternal life, they are reincarnated again and again
@ reincarnation and the failure to save their kid again and again is their punishment for defying whoever made them that agreement. I assume it’s someone like the MIY(man in yellow) or BIW who can see and know everything even without being seen present, so he wouldn’t simply let them defy, actions have consequences
@@hungrynebsthis is a spot on observation. There are more monsters than children even doubled up so where are the other monsters from? Are there other ways to become one? Or are there more children…
They probably wanted eternal life but did not know they had to sacrifice their kids & when they tried to back out was told its too late. Now their punishment is eternal life through reincarnation & always ending up in Fromville.
So the cycle is definitely restarting. And I think it’s setting up for Ethan to be the new victor. I’m still curious to know if something was protecting victor or as a balance. They leave him alone. For those 40 years. Until a new cycle is about to start. Basically giving one kid a chance to get things right.
The BIW must have a father. The father is likely an evil entity that sacrificed his kids life, such as man in yellow. I think the prev massacre, was explained due to the release of the monsters following the sacrifice. But after the talesmen are in play, the MIY could be to blame for the next massacre, which seems to be starting.
The monsters have no blood. It would make more sense to say he has Elgin and the girl that got shot by the cop at Colony House, Fatima actually drank their bloods that nurtured the monster, allowing it to grow
@@nichi403Well, i dont think smiley is boyd's grandson cos Elgin even said it's not fatima's child.More like surrogate mother, i think?.Still dont know how they can put it inside her belly
@@kristingallo2158she’s a bit annoying but in this episode I could understand why she was yelling at all of them. What you do seeing a group of the “main characters” torturing some kid?
Jim was on his farewell tour the past 2 episodes. This finale was WILD!!! We got answers but 50 MORE questions. I cant wait for season 4. NGL...this episode mind effed me. And I absolutely fell in love with Sarah for the screwdriver. And Smiley is baaaack. And not the kimono lady being the creepy Silent Hill midwife...just wild.
Loved the finale; Sara came in clutch, I cried with the scene with Victor and Henry, Jade and Tabitha remembering, Fatima's delivery and the ending with Jim. Great episode, can't wait for season 4.
The funniest dry humor was Henry asking Victor " how's jasper? Anything interesting to say?"😂😂😂 and when Fatima got mad and kicked that can! 😂 made my foot hurt.Eloise was probably the person walking around outside those cabins , you know the last time Jim helped a house fell on him 😂 Tabitha isn't Miranda she WAS Miranda like she said example if Tabitha dies and is reincarnated and her name is Chris she's going to have Tabitha's memories not Miranda's that's why Tabitha can't play the violin like Miranda could
Great theory, but I disagree with the memory part. We saw Tabatha visualizing the little girl from long ago in the other village, so it must’ve been another host’s memory further back than Miranda. So if she gets reincarnated again she could probably see the past of Tabatha, Miranda or other past hosts. It’s all up to the writers at the end though 😂
@@nunyabusiness3516lmao I was thinking that too. She reminds me of the granny monster that killed that mom and daughter in the first episode of the show.
I don’t see Sara as a monster. I see her as someone who knows how to get things done. Because Elgin coughing up the fact that he knew that Fatima was in the cellar helped Boyd get there in time to see that the thing Fatima was carrying was smiley That is significant.
i think that the man in yellow is the one in control of everything. he's the one who promised the original townsfolk immortality. he didn't fully tell them the conditions and consequences of this ritual and not only did it take the lives and souls of their children but also theirs. sure you can live forever but under the condition of you being this soulless monster
@@shainaelise2694 i'm still super unsure about the kimono lady 😭 in a way it can seem like she protected everyone by isolating fatima so smiley can be reborn, if that was done in town there would've been lives lost. it makes me wonder if everything that they have experienced so far keeps happening
Omg! Nailed it as always Anthony! So Julie's time travelled several times trying to change the story (her dad dying)... She'd probably go into the ruins to try to change the past. The short hair shows it's been more than once. Are Randall and Marielle story walkers too? 🤔
I think Randall is Martin. The beard hides his scar. He must story walk and eventually gets captured. And he having a vendetta towards boyd infects him with the worms that in turn become the cicadas that infest him
@sunnysidesouffle8348 worms (lava) that mature into cicada... But I don't think Randall knows about Abby like Martin did... How does these all connect?! Thinking of a connection between the ritual, the ruins, the monsters, kimono lady????, the reincarnation, the children, how does Smiley's born again(lived differently (could run), death and resurrection save them... Elgin wasn't lying afterall 🤥
I always say to pay attention to everything Ethan says!! lol He's was "chosen" by the BIW just like Victor and now he's starting to lose his memories, has insider info, and is pretty much becoming the new Victor. I also find it very interesting MIY came out of the RV where Ethan almost died when he arrived. I have theories but somehow BIW, Victor and Ethan all are connected. Great breakdown!!
After Smiley died, how soon did they come up with that plan to bring him back? Remember, they just walked away. And coincidence Smiley is the only monster we've seen run, die, and come back to life
Im gonna say it...not impressed with this season. The whole reincarnation angle is BS. Still basic questions not answered just more layers of mystery on top of layers of questions. To be honest i thought Jim was gonna croak it thr way hes been portrayed the last half of the season...would have preferred the man in yellow to have killed Tabitha
Everyone keeps pointing out that he ran but I think ALL of them can run. They used to be human. They choose not to run. It’s a game to terrorize and hunt them. They want to see the fear so they play games. That female monster made out with the colony house guy before killing him. The grandma walked swiftly thru the hall chasing Julie and Ethan. I don’t think he ran because she was at the tree not because he has some special power.
Yes. Everyone who is missin an eye now is tied into this moment. The guy drink blood had a messed up eye, and so did the confederate soldier from season 1.
I've been thinking about this show all day...lol! After much thought, I believe the From series is a another of many modern retellings of ancient Egyptian mythology. This idea struck me when Sara gouged out Elgin's eye. The name El suggests divinity, and I think Elgin symbolizes Horus. In Egyptian mythology, Seth gouges out Horus's left eye, paralleling Sara's actions. Seth also kills his brother, again aligning with Sara. Boyd, whose name means "yellow," clearly represents Ra, the sun god and life-sustainer. Boyd enables the townspeople's survival and battles chaos-symbolized by the man in yellow and his monsters-in the underworld (the town) at night, just as Ra fights Apep in Duat (the underworld) at night. Tabitha represents Isis, the goddess of family, while Jim aligns with Osiris, Isis's husband and protector. Victor embodies Thoth, the keeper of knowledge and secrets, and recorder of events. I can show so many more parallels. Given Jim's symbolic role as Osiris, I know Season 4 will be intense. In the myths, Osiris's death triggers major events, so Jim's death probably will too. I can't wait!
I still don’t get how the people that end up in Fromville are determined. Are they automatically drawn there due to experiencing traumatic life events?
Jim was a good guy. It's so annoying how everyone hates on him. He just wanted to protect his family. His wife was never loving or affectionate with him. She also always dismissed his feelings.
Mirabatha gave us the monsters’ origins with is crazy. The fact that Ethan is able to flat out tell Julie her role in all of this was also crazy. There’s a chance that the end of the episode wasn’t the first time we saw future Julie. Some of the bad things we have seen across the the seasons may have been because of her time traveling.
Now I have my tinfoil hat on. What if Julie time-traveled and made it back to the real world and wrote The Cromenockle book to help Ethan help her? I'm just thinking out loud and wondering how he knows about Storywalking and other things. This show makes my head spin!
@@lindawebb5379I think that’s a bit of a stretch. Why go through all that trouble. I feel like Julie isn’t the kind of person to make mystery clues to solve. She’d be more direct.
Excellent analysis! I LOVE those new names: Tabiranda and Jristopher!! 🤣🤣👍 SO FUNNY! Anyway, here are a few things I noticed (great catch on the second Mabuse, btw): When my beloved Smiley returned (WOOOO!!!), he was standing up in this red, jellyfish-like sack. So, I think that giant red monster in the cave drawings is a depiction of what the monsters look like before they are reborn. However, since it was HUGE, maybe it was the Man in Yellow in his true form showing the original townspeople that he can, in fact, give them immortality. The white stick figures surrounding the 7 sacrificial stones are probably the monsters before they turned into monsters, and the two white stick figures that are separate from the group are probably the original Jade and Tabitha. Once they sacrifice their children, you see them as red stick figures on the other side. They seem to be gathered under what looks to be the root cellar (see cave drawing picture). This makes sense because Smiley was resurrected in the cave underneath the root cellar. Again, we see the two separate white stick figures: original Jade and Tabitha!
Martin is Boyd ( many incarnations in the future) who has managed to gather Intel and knows how to kill the entity. He was imprisoned ( soul removed from the story) after they realized what he was doing, that's why he mentioned Abby. He only wanted to die by passing his soul to Boyd while giving the the memories (intel) on events and how to kill the entity. Boyd will remember his past lives memories moving forward and go on the offensive in season four and five. So essentially, the logistics man figured out how to deliver the package to the right person at the right time.
17:14 Boyd is saying that that’s his house that they were going to, but there’s no boat there, but in Boyd’s memory, he never saw the house with the boat. They surprised him with the boat on the way there.
10:16 I wonder if Fatima had given birth at the C House for instance during the day…would they have been able to kill baby Smiley? Once they saw it was a cocoon and not a baby, could they have killed it before he grew full size? It didn’t take long. Or could he only be born in the darkness? Dang you Elgin!!
It's a story about good versus evil. The good is the boy in white. Evil is the man in yellow. I believe the person who told the story to the children that gave them hope, the hope that turned into the roots of the tree was the boy in white. The man in yellow doesn't control everything in that world. I believe the talismans came from the boy in white. The man in yellow lost control of the world because of the hope of the children that created the roots of the tree. The entity doesn't feed on hope. That's a lie the entity told Boyd before he broke the music box. The entity feeds off of anger, fear, hate. The man in yellow killed Jim because he was angry that Tabitha and Jade remembered. It was the price paid for the knowledge Tabitha and Jade just received by remembering who they were
I get being Confused how Victor doesn’t remember the important things. But he was a kid alone for 40years with more trauma than the Teletubbies. He found if he forced himself to forget he wouldn’t be sad anymore. It happens in real life all the time minus the 40years alone in fromville lol
I think the people who are killed out of balance can come back. So kind of like if the monsters jump turns. Or when they die they can choose a benefit for the residents so Tian Chen chose food but Khatri wanted to stay and advise Boyd. That's why Sara cut out Toby's tongue because he probably would've chosen to advise Jade
Jim came in clutch to solve the bottle tree numbers....RIP Jim. He pissed off Man in Yellow by helping solve the mystery. I think Man in Yellow will hang Jim's dead body from the bottle tree...as a warning to the town just like in Tabitha's and Jade's visions. Breaking Bad Boyd can use Elgin as a scape goat for Tilly's murder and Fatima's kidnapping.
When Julie popped up at the end with the short hair saying I think this is when this happens and she said something about seeing if she can change the story, I think that’s the first time she goes back to the ruins and time travels technically the second time
I'm with you @lasagnabeans4656! I think the Julie at the end is a much more experienced "story walker" and has been trying to change things for a while. The key thing is I bet she needs to find what small things she can change that will have a big impact on the future, like when she threw the rope to Boyd
I still think there’s a reason why the creature that was egging Elgin on, and that was in the room with Fatima is dressed in a kimono. None of the other monsters are dressed in Japanese attire.
victor is also mentally and emotionally stunted....i also feel like many MANY years being there has all those memories suppressed...that happens in real life, with people who have trauma Edit: also, with eloise, he said he didnt know, because they were only pieces, and her face wasnt there...did you even watch it? he buried who he believed to be his sister
But why see the man in yellow now?? Is it bc Jim figured out the musical notes? That would be my guess. Knowledge comes at a cost... but if that's true why only now? And the MIY, BIW, Komo lady can all appear any time of the day they want to.
@@agatastevens Maybe the music is very important. Because Jim isn't the only one got answers. Why not kill Boyd a long time ago, he found the talisman?
Yes!! It’s giving, can you let my daughter be in the show 😂 Them keeping her first name concealed must mean something. Maybe she will have a bigger role in S4
Is it just me or did Kenny say acosta's first name when she busted in the house and heard Boyd upstairs torturing Elgin? I coulda swore Kenny called her Danny or something I'll have to rewatch it
Not sure if I commented on the video before. After this s03e10, I was thinking when rewatching - Julie heard screams until she was in the ruins, after that no screaming , Randal hear bugs, cicadas, maybe if he do something too he will stop hearing it. My theory now is that they hear stuff when they are not following the script of the time loop/time paradox. things need to happen because they happened already. If you understand what I am saying.
Why is it that Miranda and Christopher are the only ones reincarnated? And if the evil entity doesn't want the children saved; why do they keep letting them back into Fromland?
Jade, Tabitha/Christopher and Miranda are the only reincarnated ones because like Tabitha said they were there from the beginning. they are part of the original community and are the only ones that did not willingly sacrificed their own child. they were the ones who sang the children lullabies and the ones who gave them hope the same hope that the children used to pour in the roots of that trees, probably that hope made the original couple (Jade and Tabitha) reincarnated. it's their form of immorality. unlike the other townsfolk that obtained their immortality in a twisted way becoming the monsters. the children's power of hope is the one that keeps the reincarnation on happening, they are different powers. good and bad if you will. the evil entity can't do something about it, it can only stop the process of making the "reincarnated couples" from saving the children.
I don’t think that everything in the town is trying to hurt them. There are things that are trying to help them, but unfortunately, they have to figure out which is which and what they’re being told to do.
Okay, but who was the granny monster’s kid? How did she end up with a young one to sacrifice lol? She looks ancient. I figured the sacrificed kids were all supposed to be pretty young.
Now that Jim died in the daytime; Boyd doesn't have to tell the town that Fatima killed Tillie. Maybe they will stop suspecting a fellow town member for her murder.
I agree. If it was future Julie, she would appear older, even just a little. Maybe the new haircut was supposed to portray maturity but I don’t see it. Also, I don’t see any salons in fromville, how did she dye her hair much darker black, than her natural brown? I thought it when I watched this scene. That’s Julie, but not our timelines Julie
@@Belle-hi4blcoffee grounds I think can be used as temporary hair dye. Also, someone could've packed some hair dye in their luggage. Who knows? Also, also, I think Julie cuts her hair out of grief when she hears about what happens to Jim
Now I wonder if Fatima and Elgin will have some type of connection with Smiley. Because Fatima birthed him and Elgin supplied his own blood. We'll see!
I think the boy in white got jaded (ha!) by being too direct with the residents due to Christopher rejecting his instruction in the previous round. I think the BiW is now letting the residents mostly figure things out on their own so that they are more receptive when he finally does choose to get involved
Initially I thought Fatima is going to convert into a creature. Then they showed the pregnancy angle and they said no baby. Again I thought she is going to become a creature. Then they added a twist with Komo lady n then I thought maybe the baby would be a devil destined to rule this world. But they made a smiley of that baby😂
When Tabitha was in the hospital and she looked out the window, her reflection was that of a young blond girl. I was confused that they never brought that up. Now I think I understand, if I'm correct. Now that we know that Tabitha was there from the beginning, I think the reflection is her original self, before the reincarnations. I also think that Jade's music playing, is what brought the man in yellow. Just like the music box, every time the music stops playing, something terrible happens. The man in yellow made it a point to say how good Jade's music playing is.
If he does then they need to put Sarah and Fatima in there for killing people. Elgin didn’t actually harm anyone. I think what was happening to Fatima was going to happen no matter what.
@@EJaramillo Yes. And all that "save Fatima before it's to late" was unnecessary because she wasn't in any real danger nothing bad happend to her after giving birth to Smiley. So Sara basically killed Elgin for nothing
So..lets say what Boyds wife said about having to die in order to wake up was true..imagine in season 4, we get to see that from Jim's perspective...waking up in the real world. Also, what ever happened to the dog? Or was the dog actually the boy in white?
Hey so this is something I noticed on the first scene of this episode…it’s very subtle butttt in that map of the town that’s given a closeup view (Boyd and Kenny Scene) there is a moving truck with the first word scratched off. Pretty sure it was supposed to say “Rendez-move” but Rendez was cut off. I little Easter egg I presume.
Why is Elgin fully trusting the same ”angel” that tried to drown him 😂
U so right, maybe it was the going home part, but we all know going home isn't true! Lol 😂😆 Elgin still didn't understand that. The entity doesn't grant u nothing good, not even for your own good deeds as Elgin think hes done.
My main question is, why does Elgin think that kimono woman is an angel? I thought angels aren't supposed to look like zombies.
@@Angel81773biblical angels are described as looking terrifying to humans, so, I can see where he might think that. But, she tried to drown him and he’s just being naive.
He is a good guy but stupid at the same time.And didnt he learn or hear from people about Sara that hear 'things'?. Still he chose the same path
"I just started to like Jim again" ME TOOOOOO!!!!
Yes I wasn’t ready lol
Deuces, Jim
Jim finally stopped acting like the main character and they kill him 😢
SAME poor Jim
I said the same thing! 😂 just when he became likeable.
Henry, Jim, and Jade are Tabitha's husband. She's for the spiritual streets😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
N😮 wonder one had to go. Victor needs Henry. Jade has to save the ashy babies. Bye bye Jim.
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
You forgot Christopher.
I think Tillie had more answers than she was telling. The town did not want her to tell people.
Elgin is just sitting there, I thought he'd try to escape.
Big Ole sleepy self, Boyd didn't even have his gun 😂
I thought he was about to fight when he came out of the room with his bag packed after Kenny and Ellis said he couldn't leave but no😂😂😂
I thought he'd pull "a jump out the window" - but he was just a good boy sitting and waiting 🥹
i think he stood there just because he genuinely thought he is doing the right thing and he thought he can take however much torture he must to save everyone, i don't think he's a inherently bad person, just like sarah isn't
Here's an observation from an old who lived in the 70s--
The jeans Julie is wearing at the end are definitely from 1978. I know because I had a pair of those, probably Jordache jeans. Her haircut is also very late 70s. It looks like Julie the Storywalker went back to 1978, when Victor and his family arrived at the town.
In the last scene, where Jim is killed, Julie is wearing the exact same outfit she had on when she first entered the town, in season one, ep one. (I was born in 1967 btw)
Ethan said "No one can change the story once it's been told".
When she appeared in front of Jim, she told him "you need to run...I think this is when it happens...I need to change the story". That's Future Julie coming back to a story that's already been told and trying to change it.
I fell in love with Sara this episode 😂
That’s the first time I went crazy with an outburst on this show I was jumping around in joy for her 😂 sadly 🤦🏿♂️ considering the circumstances 😂
@BYABTheApex I never thought I would agree regarding Sara. You're right, she was on a whole different level ....
Yep. She redeemed herself. That means she will die in the next episode
I'm confused why
I'm sorry but you are very sadistic 😢
Sometimes a crazy job requires a crazy person.
I think Tabby and Jade were apart of the group who chose to sacrifice their children for eternal life, but they tried to back out when it was too late, so instead they told them the story that they poured into the roots. But because their daughter was still sacrificed, they get eternal life, they are reincarnated again and again
But the people who sacrificed the children were the monsters. They don't die. Even when Smiley died, we see him coming back.
@ reincarnation and the failure to save their kid again and again is their punishment for defying whoever made them that agreement. I assume it’s someone like the MIY(man in yellow) or BIW who can see and know everything even without being seen present, so he wouldn’t simply let them defy, actions have consequences
@@hungrynebs that's so true! I think you're spot on
@@hungrynebsthis is a spot on observation. There are more monsters than children even doubled up so where are the other monsters from? Are there other ways to become one? Or are there more children…
They probably wanted eternal life but did not know they had to sacrifice their kids & when they tried to back out was told its too late. Now their punishment is eternal life through reincarnation & always ending up in Fromville.
🚨The monster that recognized Julie in the beginning must be from a time that she went back time traveling!🚨
Yep!
Yess
wait whennn
@@FortuneFavorsTheBoId Season 1 episode 1, the first monster that she encountered.
I always wondered who the heck those young monsters were from the first season. It’s all circling back.
4:36 But once Jim became a more understanding person, it was inevitable that he would become a red-shirt guy.
in the end, he still completely ignored his daughter and went back into his clueless protector mode
That’s just what being a father is
"THE ALPHA IS BACK, AND SHOWING ASS CRACK!" Sir....the way I just cackled! 🤣🤣🤣
Boyd's face that scene...😆this mf again 🍑
😂😂
So the cycle is definitely restarting. And I think it’s setting up for Ethan to be the new victor. I’m still curious to know if something was protecting victor or as a balance. They leave him alone. For those 40 years. Until a new cycle is about to start. Basically giving one kid a chance to get things right.
And maybe the boy in white is one of the “victors” from the past. Like at one time he was the chosen survivor and he failed.
The BIW must have a father. The father is likely an evil entity that sacrificed his kids life, such as man in yellow. I think the prev massacre, was explained due to the release of the monsters following the sacrifice. But after the talesmen are in play, the MIY could be to blame for the next massacre, which seems to be starting.
@@Kb-gh2rkmaybe he was the first
My theory too is Victor was the Boy in White's replacement as last boy witness in town, Ethan is set to replace Victor.
Maybe the BiW is a story walker too
With Smiley being reborn (Boyd's grandson), his last words to Smiley is soo ironic "my blood, is your blood"😮
The monsters have no blood. It would make more sense to say he has Elgin and the girl that got shot by the cop at Colony House, Fatima actually drank their bloods that nurtured the monster, allowing it to grow
@@nichi403Well, i dont think smiley is boyd's grandson cos Elgin even said it's not fatima's child.More like surrogate mother, i think?.Still dont know how they can put it inside her belly
@@mamakginting9084supernatural town doing supernatural things
It's been real From Family! @The Movie Blog thank you for your hard work, keep doing you, and your mother is watching over you. ❤
when everyone rushes upstairs we find out Acosta's name is Danny....
Danieloise
She needs to go to the box
What are you talking about?
Yeah the captions said "Dani"
@@kristingallo2158she’s a bit annoying but in this episode I could understand why she was yelling at all of them. What you do seeing a group of the “main characters” torturing some kid?
Who else thought the man in yellow was going to impale Jim to the RV with the wood?
Such a good episode
Jim was on his farewell tour the past 2 episodes. This finale was WILD!!! We got answers but 50 MORE questions. I cant wait for season 4. NGL...this episode mind effed me. And I absolutely fell in love with Sarah for the screwdriver. And Smiley is baaaack. And not the kimono lady being the creepy Silent Hill midwife...just wild.
Loved the finale; Sara came in clutch, I cried with the scene with Victor and Henry, Jade and Tabitha remembering, Fatima's delivery and the ending with Jim. Great episode, can't wait for season 4.
I cried too! Victor's actor killed it 😭
Are you okay? Who cries this much? Maybe seek professional help
@@shalinalewis2957 I cried with disappointment when Fatima birthed smiley. There is literally thousands of other ways he could have come back.
Or maybe grow some empathy @@veryonlineman
This episode finally gave us sooo much to chew on!
Excellent breakdown!
I love your vocabulary and banter. You brought a smile and giggle to my face a few times while watching your video. So entertaining! 😂👌🏾
The funniest dry humor was Henry asking Victor " how's jasper? Anything interesting to say?"😂😂😂 and when Fatima got mad and kicked that can! 😂 made my foot hurt.Eloise was probably the person walking around outside those cabins , you know the last time Jim helped a house fell on him 😂 Tabitha isn't Miranda she WAS Miranda like she said example if Tabitha dies and is reincarnated and her name is Chris she's going to have Tabitha's memories not Miranda's that's why Tabitha can't play the violin like Miranda could
Great theory, but I disagree with the memory part. We saw Tabatha visualizing the little girl from long ago in the other village, so it must’ve been another host’s memory further back than Miranda. So if she gets reincarnated again she could probably see the past of Tabatha, Miranda or other past hosts.
It’s all up to the writers at the end though 😂
@@seal2721 Her name is spelled Tabitha*** not Tabatha.
Tilly died so there would be a reason for Fatima to hide and give birth to Smiley.
👍🏾
That's why Tilly is still sus AF. That and she has the bone structure of the monsters 😂😂😂
@@nunyabusiness3516lmao I was thinking that too. She reminds me of the granny monster that killed that mom and daughter in the first episode of the show.
@@bigdurksExactly 😂😂😂😂
@@bigdurks i also thinking the same thing
I don’t see Sara as a monster. I see her as someone who knows how to get things done. Because Elgin coughing up the fact that he knew that Fatima was in the cellar helped Boyd get there in time to see that the thing Fatima was carrying was smiley That is significant.
Sarah is the Don of the show. She gets the job done that no one else can. Victor did say that she’s the scariest person in town!
@@Lisa7841 hell yeah I hope they let her off for messing Elgin up, Boyd too
Sarah and Elgin are the same person. Except Elgin has a conscious.
i think that the man in yellow is the one in control of everything. he's the one who promised the original townsfolk immortality. he didn't fully tell them the conditions and consequences of this ritual and not only did it take the lives and souls of their children but also theirs. sure you can live forever but under the condition of you being this soulless monster
I agree, and I think the kimono lady was his wife, since she facilitated Smiley's resurrection.
@@shainaelise2694 i'm still super unsure about the kimono lady 😭 in a way it can seem like she protected everyone by isolating fatima so smiley can be reborn, if that was done in town there would've been lives lost. it makes me wonder if everything that they have experienced so far keeps happening
What does Boyd think he's going to do with the gun in the tunnels? He needs to figure out what kind of weapon can actually harm the monsters.
I was thinking the same thing, lol
Same. I said unless he's planning to cut himself again, I don't know what a lantern and a gun will do.
I think Boyd will get tortured since smiley looks like he saw him.
@@nunyabusiness3516are they impacted by fire? That lantern might hurt sum'n
Why didn't future Julie know that all she had to do was tell Jim that Tabitha was hurt or in danger and he would come running to town?
She probably thought he would just come with her because she's his daughter
Lmao! so true
Because nothing is ever that simple in Fromville.
She was so scared of her dad dying, she didn’t have a plan on how to get him running.
Because Future Julie is apparently just of slow as present Julie and still speaks in riddles.
Omg! Nailed it as always Anthony! So Julie's time travelled several times trying to change the story (her dad dying)... She'd probably go into the ruins to try to change the past. The short hair shows it's been more than once. Are Randall and Marielle story walkers too? 🤔
I think Randall is Martin. The beard hides his scar. He must story walk and eventually gets captured. And he having a vendetta towards boyd infects him with the worms that in turn become the cicadas that infest him
@sunnysidesouffle8348 worms (lava) that mature into cicada... But I don't think Randall knows about Abby like Martin did... How does these all connect?! Thinking of a connection between the ritual, the ruins, the monsters, kimono lady????, the reincarnation, the children, how does Smiley's born again(lived differently (could run), death and resurrection save them... Elgin wasn't lying afterall 🤥
I like the theory that Martin is Boyd
@@SamM-hg1yn Boyd is black
@@yusavelli0448 Reincarnation is not bound by race
I always say to pay attention to everything Ethan says!! lol He's was "chosen" by the BIW just like Victor and now he's starting to lose his memories, has insider info, and is pretty much becoming the new Victor. I also find it very interesting MIY came out of the RV where Ethan almost died when he arrived. I have theories but somehow BIW, Victor and Ethan all are connected. Great breakdown!!
After Smiley died, how soon did they come up with that plan to bring him back? Remember, they just walked away. And coincidence Smiley is the only monster we've seen run, die, and come back to life
its like they say history always repeats its self once they remembered the story restarted
I wonder if Smiley was the first parent to convince everyone that sacrificing their children was a good idea.
Im gonna say it...not impressed with this season. The whole reincarnation angle is BS. Still basic questions not answered just more layers of mystery on top of layers of questions. To be honest i thought Jim was gonna croak it thr way hes been portrayed the last half of the season...would have preferred the man in yellow to have killed Tabitha
Everyone keeps pointing out that he ran but I think ALL of them can run. They used to be human. They choose not to run. It’s a game to terrorize and hunt them. They want to see the fear so they play games. That female monster made out with the colony house guy before killing him. The grandma walked swiftly thru the hall chasing Julie and Ethan.
I don’t think he ran because she was at the tree not because he has some special power.
@@rsullivan1agreed
The colonial guy, who drinks the blood out of the skull, could he be Elgin in a different cycle? Since everything repeats? Back to theorizing ....
Wasnt he missing an eye??
Yes. Everyone who is missin an eye now is tied into this moment. The guy drink blood had a messed up eye, and so did the confederate soldier from season 1.
@@fitch099 So did the guy who was stuck under a boulder in the root cellar that Jade saw in season 1.
I've been thinking about this show all day...lol! After much thought, I believe the From series is a another of many modern retellings of ancient Egyptian mythology. This idea struck me when Sara gouged out Elgin's eye. The name El suggests divinity, and I think Elgin symbolizes Horus. In Egyptian mythology, Seth gouges out Horus's left eye, paralleling Sara's actions. Seth also kills his brother, again aligning with Sara. Boyd, whose name means "yellow," clearly represents Ra, the sun god and life-sustainer. Boyd enables the townspeople's survival and battles chaos-symbolized by the man in yellow and his monsters-in the underworld (the town) at night, just as Ra fights Apep in Duat (the underworld) at night. Tabitha represents Isis, the goddess of family, while Jim aligns with Osiris, Isis's husband and protector. Victor embodies Thoth, the keeper of knowledge and secrets, and recorder of events. I can show so many more parallels. Given Jim's symbolic role as Osiris, I know Season 4 will be intense. In the myths, Osiris's death triggers major events, so Jim's death probably will too. I can't wait!
Wow solid references!
@@Mk-kr1bi Thank you!
I still don’t get how the people that end up in Fromville are determined. Are they automatically drawn there due to experiencing traumatic life events?
Yeah we need to find out why those ppl.
Maybe they are all descendants of the original inhabitants
@@uniqcorn1 I never thought of that😳
But all the people that came in the bus? That's so random.
I was so happy to see jim go.. next up julie ,her brother ,boyds goofy son,fatima,and finally boyd !
🤣😂🤣😶
Nahhh
Bro wants the main characters gone
Not Boyd !
Jim was a good guy. It's so annoying how everyone hates on him. He just wanted to protect his family. His wife was never loving or affectionate with him. She also always dismissed his feelings.
Mirabatha gave us the monsters’ origins with is crazy. The fact that Ethan is able to flat out tell Julie her role in all of this was also crazy. There’s a chance that the end of the episode wasn’t the first time we saw future Julie. Some of the bad things we have seen across the the seasons may have been because of her time traveling.
Now I have my tinfoil hat on. What if Julie time-traveled and made it back to the real world and wrote The Cromenockle book to help Ethan help her? I'm just thinking out loud and wondering how he knows about Storywalking and other things. This show makes my head spin!
@@lindawebb5379I think that’s a bit of a stretch. Why go through all that trouble. I feel like Julie isn’t the kind of person to make mystery clues to solve. She’d be more direct.
Ethan has definitely been dropping gems. Nobody listened to him cause he’s a kid referencing a book … 😮
Excellent analysis! I LOVE those new names: Tabiranda and Jristopher!! 🤣🤣👍 SO FUNNY!
Anyway, here are a few things I noticed (great catch on the second Mabuse, btw): When my beloved Smiley returned (WOOOO!!!), he was standing up in this red, jellyfish-like sack. So, I think that giant red monster in the cave drawings is a depiction of what the monsters look like before they are reborn. However, since it was HUGE, maybe it was the Man in Yellow in his true form showing the original townspeople that he can, in fact, give them immortality. The white stick figures surrounding the 7 sacrificial stones are probably the monsters before they turned into monsters, and the two white stick figures that are separate from the group are probably the original Jade and Tabitha. Once they sacrifice their children, you see them as red stick figures on the other side. They seem to be gathered under what looks to be the root cellar (see cave drawing picture). This makes sense because Smiley was resurrected in the cave underneath the root cellar. Again, we see the two separate white stick figures: original Jade and Tabitha!
I love your randomly inserted jokes 🤣 ❤️
Was Elgen once the one eyed civil war soldier?
and the one eyed skull cup blood drinking colonial ghost.
@@RedDogForge And the one eyed guy stuck under the boulder in the root cellar from season 1.
Martin is Boyd ( many incarnations in the future) who has managed to gather Intel and knows how to kill the entity. He was imprisoned ( soul removed from the story) after they realized what he was doing, that's why he mentioned Abby. He only wanted to die by passing his soul to Boyd while giving the the memories (intel) on events and how to kill the entity. Boyd will remember his past lives memories moving forward and go on the offensive in season four and five. So essentially, the logistics man figured out how to deliver the package to the right person at the right time.
I like Martin being Boyd, makes sense
17:14 Boyd is saying that that’s his house that they were going to, but there’s no boat there, but in Boyd’s memory, he never saw the house with the boat. They surprised him with the boat on the way there.
Good point!!
I don't think Ethan is forgetting, I think he is just a child experiencing forgetting someones face after a long enough time from them passing.
The monsters have two ways into town🤯
10:16 I wonder if Fatima had given birth at the C House for instance during the day…would they have been able to kill baby Smiley? Once they saw it was a cocoon and not a baby, could they have killed it before he grew full size? It didn’t take long. Or could he only be born in the darkness?
Dang you Elgin!!
It's a story about good versus evil. The good is the boy in white. Evil is the man in yellow. I believe the person who told the story to the children that gave them hope, the hope that turned into the roots of the tree was the boy in white. The man in yellow doesn't control everything in that world. I believe the talismans came from the boy in white. The man in yellow lost control of the world because of the hope of the children that created the roots of the tree. The entity doesn't feed on hope. That's a lie the entity told Boyd before he broke the music box. The entity feeds off of anger, fear, hate. The man in yellow killed Jim because he was angry that Tabitha and Jade remembered. It was the price paid for the knowledge Tabitha and Jade just received by remembering who they were
Love your humor:) Great Review!!!
"Finally speaks pokemon" LMAOOOO IM CRYING
I get being Confused how Victor doesn’t remember the important things. But he was a kid alone for 40years with more trauma than the Teletubbies. He found if he forced himself to forget he wouldn’t be sad anymore. It happens in real life all the time minus the 40years alone in fromville lol
I'm starting to understand that now too @Morris3720! It makes me wonder how many things that I've forgotten 🤔
I think the people who are killed out of balance can come back. So kind of like if the monsters jump turns. Or when they die they can choose a benefit for the residents so Tian Chen chose food but Khatri wanted to stay and advise Boyd. That's why Sara cut out Toby's tongue because he probably would've chosen to advise Jade
This the from we know and love great episode 💪🏽💪🏽
Jim came in clutch to solve the bottle tree numbers....RIP Jim. He pissed off Man in Yellow by helping solve the mystery. I think Man in Yellow will hang Jim's dead body from the bottle tree...as a warning to the town just like in Tabitha's and Jade's visions. Breaking Bad Boyd can use Elgin as a scape goat for Tilly's murder and Fatima's kidnapping.
When Julie popped up at the end with the short hair saying I think this is when this happens and she said something about seeing if she can change the story, I think that’s the first time she goes back to the ruins and time travels technically the second time
I'm with you @lasagnabeans4656! I think the Julie at the end is a much more experienced "story walker" and has been trying to change things for a while. The key thing is I bet she needs to find what small things she can change that will have a big impact on the future, like when she threw the rope to Boyd
I still think there’s a reason why the creature that was egging Elgin on, and that was in the room with Fatima is dressed in a kimono. None of the other monsters are dressed in Japanese attire.
They also don't have the same emaciated skeletal frames either.
What are your thoughts on that?
victor is also mentally and emotionally stunted....i also feel like many MANY years being there has all those memories suppressed...that happens in real life, with people who have trauma
Edit: also, with eloise, he said he didnt know, because they were only pieces, and her face wasnt there...did you even watch it?
he buried who he believed to be his sister
Great episode
Victor says "mom fell down. Not " your mom fell down."
But why see the man in yellow now?? Is it bc Jim figured out the musical notes? That would be my guess. Knowledge comes at a cost... but if that's true why only now? And the MIY, BIW, Komo lady can all appear any time of the day they want to.
Kimono****
Anthony TMB you’re retelling is so hilarious😂😂 I’m gonna miss coming here on Sunday’s to get my Fromily Companion fix😢
Why is the man in yellow blaming Jim for what Tabitha is doing? Why didn't he go after Tabitha and Jade?
Because its always the husbands fault!! Even if he's not around when shit goes down its his fault! (Any married man over 40 should know this!!)
@@michaellamont250😂😂😂😂
Maybe because Jim was the one to figure out the music notes connection. 🤷♀️
@@agatastevens Maybe the music is very important. Because Jim isn't the only one got answers. Why not kill Boyd a long time ago, he found the talisman?
@@Calinotch06maybe there's an unknown reason he can't get rid of Tabitha and Jade
The “old man” is the boy in white… because… “I dont think he was really a little boy “
Acosta's role is so redundant that it makes me think someone persuaded the director to give her a part.
nah. if she wasn’t talking shit. sara doesn’t take elgins eye
@@Jsztke Boyd could have taken a pee break and Sara takes that chance to go to Elgin XD.
I find her character to be irrelevant.
She must be related to the director lol
Yes!! It’s giving, can you let my daughter be in the show 😂
Them keeping her first name concealed must mean something. Maybe she will have a bigger role in S4
What is the story behind the brand Mabuse on the paddles that Randall was going to use? I don't follow.
There’s a story about a character named Mr. Mabuse. The Man in Yellow seems loosely based on him.
The man in yellow looking damn badass. I already started loving the character. 🥶🤯
I didn't love that disgusting Martin-style shirt. Why is his shirt so filthy??
@nunyabusiness3516 it's your problem. Cause everyone is happy with his look.
Is it just me or did Kenny say acosta's first name when she busted in the house and heard Boyd upstairs torturing Elgin? I coulda swore Kenny called her Danny or something I'll have to rewatch it
Yes
It was in the subtitles as well DANI
Oh ok lol I thought I heard it
I heard the same. I think he called her Dani because I remember wondering who he was talking to
That means they became friends off screen
yup, this episode is good enough for me until 2026
Finally some damn answers 😂
they answers were always there from the beginning
5:10 LMAO NOT JIM COLE 🤣🤣🤣
Not sure if I commented on the video before. After this s03e10, I was thinking when rewatching - Julie heard screams until she was in the ruins, after that no screaming , Randal hear bugs, cicadas, maybe if he do something too he will stop hearing it. My theory now is that they hear stuff when they are not following the script of the time loop/time paradox. things need to happen because they happened already. If you understand what I am saying.
Whatever happened, happened
5:10 not the apology 😂
Future Julie is giving DARK energy. Ifkyk
Fatima had me stressed out. I'm like please sit down and be quiet. How does she know when it's day or night? The monsters might get her.
So Boyd is now Smiley's grandpa
The best series on tv! Fantastic
I Love your names for Jade & Tabatha. Lol.
Why is it that Miranda and Christopher are the only ones reincarnated? And if the evil entity doesn't want the children saved; why do they keep letting them back into Fromland?
Jade, Tabitha/Christopher and Miranda are the only reincarnated ones because like Tabitha said they were there from the beginning. they are part of the original community and are the only ones that did not willingly sacrificed their own child. they were the ones who sang the children lullabies and the ones who gave them hope the same hope that the children used to pour in the roots of that trees, probably that hope made the original couple (Jade and Tabitha) reincarnated. it's their form of immorality. unlike the other townsfolk that obtained their immortality in a twisted way becoming the monsters. the children's power of hope is the one that keeps the reincarnation on happening, they are different powers. good and bad if you will. the evil entity can't do something about it, it can only stop the process of making the "reincarnated couples" from saving the children.
Sarah was tired of the BS and came through like a mob enforcer form the Gambino crime family.
"Cmere Elgin, I just wanna talk" 😂
I don’t think that everything in the town is trying to hurt them. There are things that are trying to help them, but unfortunately, they have to figure out which is which and what they’re being told to do.
Elgin is so dumb, he told on himself.
Okay, but who was the granny monster’s kid? How did she end up with a young one to sacrifice lol? She looks ancient. I figured the sacrificed kids were all supposed to be pretty young.
That's what I've been asking too. Maybe one of the children didn't have one or both of the parents, but one parent and a grandma, or just a grandma 🤷
If Julie can change the past this might not be the last time we see Jim
Now that Jim died in the daytime; Boyd doesn't have to tell the town that Fatima killed Tillie. Maybe they will stop suspecting a fellow town member for her murder.
I think a different Julie comes to Jim. Shorter darker hair, different clothes??
Yes. The future julie
I agree. If it was future Julie, she would appear older, even just a little. Maybe the new haircut was supposed to portray maturity but I don’t see it. Also, I don’t see any salons in fromville, how did she dye her hair much darker black, than her natural brown? I thought it when I watched this scene. That’s Julie, but not our timelines Julie
@@Belle-hi4blcoffee grounds I think can be used as temporary hair dye. Also, someone could've packed some hair dye in their luggage. Who knows? Also, also, I think Julie cuts her hair out of grief when she hears about what happens to Jim
Now I wonder if Fatima and Elgin will have some type of connection with Smiley. Because Fatima birthed him and Elgin supplied his own blood. We'll see!
The clips in between but wait there's more, made me bust out laughing. as always enjoy watching.
Ain’t No Time For Thinking! 😂
NOPE!
I think maybe the man in yellow and what he said about knowledge coming with a cost may be why the boy in white is hesitant to try and help directly
I think the boy in white got jaded (ha!) by being too direct with the residents due to Christopher rejecting his instruction in the previous round. I think the BiW is now letting the residents mostly figure things out on their own so that they are more receptive when he finally does choose to get involved
I dont think Smiley being reborn was a surprise. I suspected this the last two episodes
Initially I thought Fatima is going to convert into a creature. Then they showed the pregnancy angle and they said no baby. Again I thought she is going to become a creature. Then they added a twist with Komo lady n then I thought maybe the baby would be a devil destined to rule this world. But they made a smiley of that baby😂
When Tabitha was in the hospital and she looked out the window, her reflection was that of a young blond girl. I was confused that they never brought that up. Now I think I understand, if I'm correct. Now that we know that Tabitha was there from the beginning, I think the reflection is her original self, before the reincarnations. I also think that Jade's music playing, is what brought the man in yellow. Just like the music box, every time the music stops playing, something terrible happens. The man in yellow made it a point to say how good Jade's music playing is.
Ooooh that was a good point about ethan forgetting things i did not even consider that
OMG you guys were right. I was saying last week Tabitha is not Miranda reincarnated.
No one wanna talk about how the subtitles revealed Acostas first name is Dani
What's to discuss?
@ it was supposedly a big secret
@@daniellesapino ah, big nothing burger.
that was a great episode 🔥🔥🔥🔥
My prediction. Elgin will be place into the box.
If he does then they need to put Sarah and Fatima in there for killing people. Elgin didn’t actually harm anyone. I think what was happening to Fatima was going to happen no matter what.
@@EJaramillo Yes. And all that "save Fatima before it's to late" was unnecessary because she wasn't in any real danger nothing bad happend to her after giving birth to Smiley. So Sara basically killed Elgin for nothing
@@anapapes exactly, I don’t think Elgin is dead but he sure did get maimed by both Boyd and Sarah. Poor kid.
@EJaramillo Yeah yeah maybe he is not dead but either way he didn't deserve what they did to him
@ agreed!!
Just to take the edge off 😂😂😂💀💀💀
Dude- season four Tabitha can now cast Fireball and Magic Missiles.
She's leveled up big-time.
Elgin the same person jade keep seeing with 1 eye
Ricky He also called himself Nightwing for Heavy Spoilers haha
I also think the monsters are the voices in Sara's head
Why can't it be the Man in yellow? We know he was probably the one calling Jim on the phone.
So..lets say what Boyds wife said about having to die in order to wake up was true..imagine in season 4, we get to see that from Jim's perspective...waking up in the real world. Also, what ever happened to the dog? Or was the dog actually the boy in white?
Hey so this is something I noticed on the first scene of this episode…it’s very subtle butttt in that map of the town that’s given a closeup view (Boyd and Kenny Scene) there is a moving truck with the first word scratched off. Pretty sure it was supposed to say “Rendez-move” but Rendez was cut off. I little Easter egg I presume.