A Revolution in Zimbabwe? A Zimbabwean Writer Takes on Julius Malema

Nomazulu Thata, a Zimbabwean writer, has penned an open letter to Julius Malema, the leader of South Africa’s Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) party, published by The Zimbabwean on August 10, 2024. In this letter, Thata offers a critical analysis of Malema’s recent call for a revolution in Zimbabwe, cautioning that such an action, if not meticulously planned, could lead to significant instability across the southern African region. In the letter, Thata expresses her concerns about the feasibility of a revolution in Zimbabwe, arguing that the conditions in the country are not conducive to such a movement. She points out the lack of a strong opposition on the ground, particularly highlighting Nelson Chamisa, the leader of the Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC). Thata argues that Chamisa, despite his rhetoric, is disconnected from the grassroots and lacks the practical knowledge needed to lead a successful revolution. She describes him as being too "posh" to engage in the rough and tumble of street protests and questions his ability to bring about meaningful change under the CCC's leadership. Thata goes on to compare Zimbabwe with other African nations such as Sudan, Kenya, and Nigeria, where recent political changes have occurred. She uses Sudan as a cautionary example, where the overthrow of President Omar al-Bashir led to chaos due to a lack of a clear plan for the future. In her view, Zimbabwe could face a similar fate if a revolution is attempted without careful planning and strong leadership. In the letter, she also critiques the suggestion that Vice President Dr. Constantino Chiwenga could replace President Emmerson Mnangagwa, calling it "tired thinking" and arguing that Chiwenga lacks the qualifications and moral integrity to lead the country. Thata expresses disbelief that some educated Zimbabweans support Chiwenga's ascension, questioning their motives and highlighting the potential dangers of such a leadership change. Thata further emphasizes the importance of internal forces driving any revolutionary movement in Zimbabwe, rather than relying on external influences like Malema's encouragement. She argues that without a strong, organized internal movement, any attempt at revolution could result in a regional disaster rather than the desired change. In conclusion, Thata expresses deep skepticism about the possibility of a successful revolution in Zimbabwe under current circumstances, acknowledging that while miracles can happen, the situation in Zimbabwe remains dire. Her letter, published in The Zimbabwean, offers a sobering perspective on the challenges facing Zimbabwe and serves as a stark reminder of the complexities involved in pursuing revolutionary change in Africa.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @globalreport-360