I still Respect Ustad Javed GHAMIDI حفظہ اللہ ! BUT no Compromise on Ahl-ul-Bait علیھم السلام ! Well needed CLIP. Keep on doing Dawat-e-HAQ of ISLAM without Firqawariyat. May ALLAH guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! TRUTH Lovers ko SALAM ! ! !
Badi film hain engineer sahab. Koi inko jahil bolde to wo bazari zuban. Khud dusron ko jo b bolden waha justification or shariat le ae. Ye hain inke adaab, ikhlaaq or ilmi ikhtilaaf 😀
@@MuhammadUsman-vx7dd bhai unho ne har cheez ko compare kar ke dikhaya hai... ke unho ne gamdi sahb ke baray mai apne sab se naram alfaz istmal kie jo gamdi sahb ke bayan pe ho sakte the... aur jin ke jahil bolne ki ap bat kar rahe hain...wo khud dusro ko aysi hi batain bolte hai to engineer sahb ne btaya hai ke dekhi bazari zuban to fir apki bhi hai...
@@mhabbijee9357 compare kar k dikhaya engr sb ne k main jo b boldun dusron ko kutta, daddu, nasbi, jahil wo sab jaiz hain lekin meri harkaat ki waja se koi muje jahil, rafzi, gustakh kehde to wo bazari zuban, najaiz, bad ikhlaqi ha. Tabhi to film hain ye puri 😄
@@muhammadsubhanakram5323 Har shaksh se ikhtalaf kia jaa sakta hai siwai Allah or Rasool. Agar koi is pe qayem rahe to samajh lo us ne inko nabi ke barabar khara ker dia
@@shakilahmad8246 khulfai e rashideen sa ikhtilaf ais Liye nhi kar rhe, q k woh Nabi peace be upon him ki sunnatey follow kartay thay , aunko follow ais Liye kar rhe hai without Kisi apni soch lagai k woh Allah ka Nabi peace be upon him ko Zindagi par chalay . Apnay tou boht koi ulti example di hai .
Nouman Ali Khan, Waheedudin Khan, and Ahmad Javaid are international speakers who appreciates work of Javed Ghamidi. Great scholar Waheedudin even said that I am bigger in age but Ghamidi is bigger in Ilm. Only non-sect ulema appreciates work of Ghamidi sahab because sect considers everyone outside them Ghumrah and Ghamidi sahab doesn’t belong to any sect. Also in Baba video, Ghamidi sahab mentioned ulema by name that you condemn NOT only Bukhari aur Muslim. He respects and values work of Sufi ulema (Ghazali, Shah Wali Ullah) or Fiqh Ulema (Ahmad Raza Bareveli, Ashraf Ali Thanvi). He critique their research but never their personalities. Or in your words, he doesn’t multiply their work by Zero. For political system, what Ghamidi sahab said that traditional political system and transfer of power was relevant till Khilafat of Umar (ra). After Umar (ra) that system has its failure because of vast expansion of Muslim empire. We know there was era of Fitna from Usman (ra) ruling period. There were rebels from Busra, Kufa, Misar… Muwaiya (ra) had no option but to adopt Mulokiat to stop bloodshed, civil war and anarchy. What Ghamidi sahab appreciated was Muwaiya (ra)skills of politics and long term vision of governance. We might not have our religion as we know it now has the empire broken up in pieces. Its known Muwaiya (ra) ruling period was of peace and prosperity. Please reply
Sahi farmaya aap nay....sahi baat samajnay , jaanay aur maanay kay liye dimaag aur niyat saaf honi chahiye...Truth is bitter but it is always better...stay blessed
@@shahzadkhanacma Ali is biased towards personalities & based his little knowledge under their spell. He can not infer on logic. He can not differentiate & analyze conditions faced by Muawya & Khulfa Rashid. He always compare personalities in terms of chastity & then make one better than other which is not his jurisdiction.
With due respect... You have not listened Ghamidi saab completely... Both matters are different... Ghamidi Sahib says that khulafa Rashideen ruled on their unmatchable character and honesty but this system had some "administrative " faults. For example some people demanded resignation of Hazrat Usman RA. Now issue was that how to remove the caliph or to retain it? So when it could not resolved, sword was the decision maker. Same in case of Hazrat Ali RA and Hazrat Muawiya RA, where sword decided the fate. So Ghamidi sahib highlighted these shortcomings in the system despite there was no match with Caliphs' morality and character. In 2nd case, he says that if Hazrat Muawiya had not handed over the charge in his family then again there were chances of big internal war among Muslims. So he looks at the matter as administrative issue. If you think that there could not be administrative shortcomings in ruling by Caliphs, then your approach is different. So bear the difference and keep emotions aside .. Respect the difference Thank you
Obviously i was already in doubt that saying these words to scholar like ghamidi saahab is nothing else but is the matter of enigneer Ego...as he cant stand infront of ghamidi saahab in any subjects any topic of islam. He Got very weak arguements here , which can easily be replied by ghamidi saahab but he will never reply..He is not only the ocean of knoweldge but also got greatest Attitude a muslim can have. GHAMIDI SAAHAB IS LEGEND.
@@AZ-je9hg Kisi ne lesson nahin dia. agar koi kahay khulafa e rashedeen ne jahaz ijaad nahin kia tou wo lesson dena nahin hoga. Agar koi kahay khulafa e rashedeen ko computer ka kuch nahin pata tha tou ye lesson dena nahin hoga. issi tarha unke daur main koi nizam murattab nahin hua ye lesson dena nahin hay. ye aik haqeeqat hay. Na ye unki zimedari thi koi. waqt k saath saath systems bantay chalay gaye. Jaisay science k dunya main waqt k saath sath taraqqi hui waisay hi Imraniyaat/social science main bhi hui. is main lesson dena kahan se a gaya.
afsos, you called ghamdi jahil. he did not agreed with mawia but he said in due circumstances his way was the right way at that time nor he degraded khulfai e rashideen. rather then heal the wound you took the path of other stereotype molvies to whom you regards as babey.
Aap ko sun kay acha lagta tha aur aisa mehsoos hota tha ki Ghamidi sahab kay alaawa bhi koyi ilim wala banda hai, magar aisay alfaaz ghamidi sahab kay liye use karna aur bina pura sonaye aur samajnay kau bagair..ufff Allah raham karray....You all are sailing in the same boat...May Allah guide us and give long life and good health to Mr javeed ahmad ghamidi sahab
Listen to Mufti Abu Layth (dont go for his looks or his jokes, just judge him on his knowledge and approach) he is the only scholar i often listen to other than ofcourse the Great Ghamidi sb
Lahza bata deta ha ki jahil kaun ha. Ya ek tariqa ye bhi ha ki zee- shaur log kis taraf khade hote hn ye dekh liya jaye. Ghamdi sahab ne baat karne aur ikhtalaf karne aur shaistgi se baat karne ka tariqa eejad kiya ha! Aisa tariqa jo abse pahle kisi muslim aalim ke pas nahi tha. Hats off ghamdi sahab!
Most appreciative approach of Ghamdi sb is that he does not analyse anything standing just on one side rather he looks at things in the perspective of the person saying/doing something, also in the perspective of time and history. Sees things with open mind. Trains his followers in this way. Never gets harsh. He is a great scholar of this time.
ghamdi sahab is indeed full of wisdom, iv never seen him to give an extremist opinion. its saad to see engineer sahab that you seem to a man of knowledge and logic but still you used such derogatory word.
Alhamdolillah comment section main Ghamidi sahib ke itne ziada himayati Dekh Kar sukoon hua ke ab log daleel aor ikhlas ko follow karte hain na ke jazbat aor ihsasat se mutasir nazrya ko. Ap pehle bare narm mizaj te lekin aj ap ne molvion wali zuban use ki hai
most of his lectures are circulating around political conflict between sahaba and contraversial issues in islam.he is far from DAWAT of quran.just an emotional person , true dawat of islam is to call people for good deeds and AKHRAT oriented life in this world, he is hero of IQ level people, sorry these words are somewhat hard
You overestime on your own intelligence. When has mirza sahab claimed to give dawat, he picks those 'controversial' issues and gives his educated opinion on the matter, same as ghamidi sahab, if some religious matters make people emotional or they are considered 'controversial', does that mean they should not be discussed to get to the truth/right way under the interpretation of Islam???? Ghamidi "students" should stop thinking they and ghamidi sahab are "geniuses" and come with mantaq/logic if they have any.
BEG PARDON ! PUBLICLY This is complete zahil approch . I am your student , i learned many things from you You always complaint about ulma's language . But in the case of ghamidi sb. You cross red line Sir, you must apologise from him . Calling someone zahil uzaad , is respect ! Sir , i never expected this from you .
کیا یہ واقعی ایک علمی کتابیں شخص کی گفتگو ہے؟ کیا واقع ہی غامدی صاحب نے صحابہ پر طعن کیا ہے؟ ایک ایسے امر واقعہ کو بیان کرنا۔ جس کے صحابہ کرام شرعی مکلف بھی نہ تھے صحابہ پر طعن کہلاتا ہے؟ کیا غامدی صاحب نے جو مؤقف اختیار کیا ہے اس کی پوری وضاحت بیان نہیں کی؟ کیا وہ اس کو خالصتا دینی مسئلہ سمجھتے ہیں یا سیاسی مسئلہ؟ حقیقت یہ ہے کہ مرزا علی صاحب کا رویہ بتاتا ہے کہ وہ اپنے فہم کو عقل کل سمجھتے ہیں اور انہوں نے اپنی اصلاح کے ہر دروازے بند کر لیے ہیں اور اس زعم میں مبتلا ہیں کہ انہوں نے کبھی تکبر نہیں کیا حالانکہ ان کا رویہ ہر بیان میں یہ بتا رہا ہوتا ہے کہ ان سے بڑا کوئی عالم اس روئے زمین پر پیدا ہی نہیں ہوا۔ اور جب مرزا صاحب پر انکے اخلاقی رویوں کے متعلق اعتراضات کئے جاتے ہیں تو اس کے جواب میں دوسرے علماء کے ایسے ہی غلط رویوں کو بطور دلیل اور اپنے برے رویوں کے جواز کے طور پر پیش کر دیتے ہیں۔ بڑا مشکل نظر آتا ہے کہ مرزا صاحب اپنی اصلاح پر بھی غور فرمائیں گے۔
اور میں مرزا صاحب کی اس صلاحیت کا اعتراف کرتا ہوں کہ وہ اپنی ہر بد اخلاقی کا دفاع کرنا خوب جانتے ہیں کوئی نہ کوئی جواز نکال لیتے ہیں۔ تعجب ہوتا ہے کہ جب وہ حضرت عمر علیہ السلام کی سخت مزاجی جو کہ ایک ذاتی اور شخصی اور فطری معاملہ ہے کو اپنی بداخلاقی کے جواز کے طور پر پیش کرتے نظر آتے ہیں) (واضح رہے کہ بداخلاقی صرف یہی نہیں ہے کہ آپ کسی کو گالی نکال دیں جیسا کہ مرزا صاحب خیال کرتے ہیں )
They don't understand Ghamid. Ghamidi is very high level scholar. So you are a fool wasting time to make them understanding something they can't. I struggled 3 years..to understand what Ghamidi says...it is so difficult to grasp... because of the narrow Religious culture we live in. So brother...no offense...I don't call you...fool...in real sense... you understanding😃 Salam to you may God bless me and you too...and good persons
@@NSNCNB میں کسی شخصیت پر تبصرہ کرنے سے پہلے اس کو اچھی طرح سے جان لینے کو اپنے لئے ضروری سمجھتا ہوں میں نے مرزا صاحب کو بہت عرصہ تک سمجھنے کی کوشش کی ہے اور ان کی بہت سی باتوں سے اتفاق بھی کرتا ہوں۔ لیکن ان کے رویے سے اور ایک خاص تضحیک اور تنقیص والے اسلوب سے ہمیشہ اختلاف رہا ہے۔ ایک عالم دین یا صحیح معنی میں دین کے طالب علم کا یہ انداز اور رویہ کبھی بھی نہیں ہو سکتا۔ اور اب میں پوری طرح محسوس کرتا ہوں کہ مرزا صاحب اپنی علمی استعداد و حدود سے تجاوز کر رہے ہیں۔ آج تبصرہ اس لیے کرنے پر مجبور ہوا ہوں کہ میں اسے اپنا دینی فریضہ سمجھتا ہوں اور اس لیے بھی کہ مرزا صاحب ایک عوامی شخصیت بن چکے ہیں اگرچہ ان کے مخالفین بھی بہت کثرت سے ہیں۔
@@NSNCNB you are right that Ghamidi sahab is great scholar but you know what! it is also difficult to grasp Engineer sahab's behaviour . JazakAllah .!!
He said i dnt support that but at that time if that was not done then ummha has torne into pieces. He is right he said 10 time he is against it he never support it but when it was done then u have to accept it in order to find the best solutions.
First- ghamdi sahab is not jaahil, he is a gem for the ummah (he is a scholar in its true sense), yes he may have wrong conclusions on certain things based on his knowledge Second- you are also a gem for this ummah 🇮🇳
He is absolutely Jaahil & promoter of Taghoot But, Gem and Scholar for those Who wants to perform Haram, Immoral, Satanic activities Under the name of Islam So such low & cheap people Use such ignorant, Taghootis to get Halal stamp For every Declared Haram & Immoral activity by Allah SWT in Islam So, These people are those about whom Allah SWT says, "They want to defeat Allah SWT in the verses of Allah SWT (By giving wrong conclusions in support of Haram & Satanic activities by taking some verses out of context, or by playing with meaning of the words). Such Taghoot & Satan Supporters would indeed find the company of their big father, Satan in Aakhirah, InshAllah..!!! May Allah SWT save innocent & ignorant people from such pawns Taghoot & Satan
*Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) neither talked in an insulting manner nor did he ever speak evil intentionally. He used to say, "The most beloved to me amongst you is the one who has the best character and manners."* (Bukhari #3759) Engineer Ali not only crossed the line (which is possible in anger or mistake), but when given a chance to take back (rujoo), his ego prevented him again to follow the Sunnah/behaviour of our Prophet (saw).. This ego-istic and rude attitude itself proves that "Hadith" is not the same as "Sunnah".. because a master of Hadith like Engineer still fails to recall and apply the amaly "Sunnah" of the Prophet (saw) of his character, which is more seen in the attitude, humbleness, tolerance and patience of (for example) Javed Ahmed Ghamidi.
Matlab ye badla le rahe k ghamidi sb k kisi sathi ne in k khilaf baat ki to inho ne Ghandi sb ko ase kaha.Boht hi immature ha engineer bhai.Hum log akhlaq p kaam nhi karte bas darhi parde ko adopt kar k dil ko tasalli dete k hum religious hai.
Ustad e Mohtram Ali mirza sahib ap plzzz parda valy moakif pr ghamidi sahib ko properly rebutal kryn ku k jin dlaaaeeeel ko ap ly kr aaty han rebutal k liye un sb ka reply ghamidi sahib ne apny 23 aetrazat ki series ma diya hua ha jisy sun kr insaan satisfy hotaa ha unhii k point of view se to plzzzz ap properly rebutal kryn jesy ap ne pul sirat valy topic pr kiyaa. plzzz replyyy krynn ku k i dont knoww any other source to contact u.
Engineer bhai is not the only one, aksar Ghamidi sahab ki baat ko twist kar ke unhain gaali dene ka maaza lia jata ha. Engineer sahab ke pas qayamat tak ka time ha video poori imandari se sun lain.
Allah Pak Ali Bhai ko or Ali Bhai ki poori team or viewar umat e Muslim ko apni hefzo aaman me rakhye shaht tondrasti jaazaye kheir Aalla zindgi ata frmaye Aameen 🙏🙏🙏
Political unrest started in the reign of 3rd caliph and it was not properly managed and dealt with and after that real chaos ensued… It became abundantly clear that there was no agreed upon formula to transfer the power… This problem became more apparent towards the end of the reign of Ameer Mauvia the world at that time knew only one way of transferring the power in huge empires like this… At same time if there would have been any other claimants to the leadership they would all have been because of the hereditary reasons and no real democratic reasons, so, what happened was, howsoever regrettable, but inevitable…
Ali point of View is very weak against ghamdi sahab you can’t even approach the wisdom of islam that ghamdi sahab have. Lower your edi Mr Ali Mirza if you really want to understand islam
rebuttal k chkr mn kya ksi ki tazheek b kr skty kya?? problem srf yh hai k ghamdi shb ny sayedna ameer mawiya (RA) ki tareef kr d jo apko hzm nai horhi...
Syedna ameer muavia ney rasool k khalifa k khilaf talwar uthai thee unki tareef krna he rasool ki tazheek hy. Humse esi koi cheez hazm ni hoti jo Rasool k khilaf ho. Ghamidi sahb tumko mubarak ho. Or haan aik bt zrur Ye engineer he hy jiski wja sey mene ghamibi sahb ki ghanto slow slow baatein sunna shuru ki hein smjhay. Bht kuch wo sahi bhe kehte hein. Kalti shabash.
Yeah he is legend because he presenting Islam in your wish ful thinking. He changes the Basis principal of Islam that is reason you liked him. Shame on you brother.
I don't agree with Ali bhai in this issue. We all know ghamidi sb. is not a nasbi... if ali bhai just criticize his belief on ameer i sham without using harsh words that was enough. Because Ghamidi sb. Is a great personality.
آپ نے غامدی صاحب کے ساتھ بہت زیادتی کر دی ، میں چاہتے ہوئے بھی اب آپ کو نہیں سن سکتی۔ میں اس شخص سے کیسے دین کی بات سیکھ سکتی ہوں جس کی گفتگو اس قدر نچلے درجے کی ہو۔اللھ نے آپ کو ذہانت دی اور آپ نے اس تحفے کو اپنے غرور سے ملیا میٹ کر دیا۔
Ali bhai you need to apologise publicly. You are wrong in this regards. I've seen Ghamdi saab videos on this topic and he didn't say anything like you have mentioned.
Salaam. May be when Ali bhai gets older he might realise the wisdom of Javed Ghamdi’s explanation of Ameer Muawia’s situation. We can’t judge our politicians honesty with all the media coverage. Yet we want to come to a conclusion on who is right in our historic in fighting of Muslims Ummah They have earned what they have done you will earn what you have done.
Ustad e Mohtram Ali mirza sahib ap plzzz parda valy moakif pr ghamidi sahib ko properly rebutal kryn ku k jin dlaaaeeeel ko ap ly kr aaty han rebutal k liye un sb ka reply ustad e mohtram ghamidi sahib ne apny 23 aetrazat ki series ma diya hua ha jisy sun kr insaan satisfy hotaa ha unhii k point of view se to plzzzz ap properly rebutal kryn jesy ap ne pul sirat valy topic pr kiyaa. plzzz replyyy krynn ku k i dont knoww any other source to contact u.
Best scholar of ISLAM when it comes to character and mannerism is Javed Ahmed Ghamidi but I do disagree with him on some issues . Love you Ali Bhai for the sake of Allah swt please try to be cool
It's a common pattern i am observing from Engineer, He attaches himself with some known personality to gain popularity from other person's following then he rejects him and his thought processes and uses derogatory words for him and tries to ridicule him.. I have been listening to him for the last 7 to 8 years, he does this to every person or his "every Teacher". Ghamdi Sahb is a genius, I dont think Engineer can ever reach that intellect,
Ali bhai me india se hoon.pahle me bhi ek firke se juda hua tha par Allah ka fazal or karam se aapki or gamidi saab ki video dekh kar Allah ne mujhe tofik di or ab me apne aap ko sirf musalman kehta hoon.par is masle pe ho sakta hai ki aap dalail me gamidi saab se zyada mazboot houn par is jagah aap galat Hain gamidi saab bhi aapki kai baton se ikhtlaf karte hain par kabhi unki zaban par aapke liye ya kisi or ke liye koi galat alfaz nahi aaya.aap ek achche Alim hai par achha insaan banne ke liye apko gamidi saab se sikhe ki zarurat hai.allah Hafiz
Bht afsos hua ustaz engineer muhammad ali mirza sb k rawaiye p. Allah pak ap pr karam kry. Qk ap tohmat ke jurm ke murtakib ho rhy hyn. Ghamidi sb ny na hazrat abu bakar o umar ko degrade kiya na hi wo hazrat ali as k bary mn bughz rkhty hyn. Please sir, like traditional ulama don't become biased and listen his point of view without being biased to ameer muawiya.
Inna lilah e wainna elahe rajeon....engineer sahab ne sabit kiya hai woh khud jahil aur ujjad honay kay saath saath ganwar bhi hain bahut shouq se inko suna kartay tha aainda na kabhi sunonga na kisiko kisko sun-nay ka kahon ga.
Ghamdi sahab ke alawa sabhi aalim tang dil, intolerent aur daroga malum hote hn, jo kisi ko bhi daante, bura kahne, fatwa lagane ka haq rakhte hn. Pata nahi ye tang dili aati kahan se ha.
Engineer Saheb instead of condemning Ghamidi Saheb and his opinion, refute his daleel on which his opinion is based with your daleel. That is how true scholars behave.
For Gaamdi followers ..he is not a prophet he is just scholar.. so we have to understand that follow him only in the boundary of qurano sunna..not his personal openion..simply
معزرت کے ساتھ، یہ کوئی طریقہ نہیں ہے اختلاف کرنے کا، آپ نے فرد کے اوپر تبصرھ کیا ہے نہ کہ فکر یا نظریے پر، اگر آپ نے تنقید ہی کرنی تھی تو بتاتے کہ انکی اس بات میں یہاں یا اس جگہ خرابی ہے اور یہ میری صحیح بات ہے اور اسکی بنیاد یہ ہے بس اتنا ہی کرنا تھا۔ لیکن اپنے اخلاقی حدود سے تجاوز کیا ہے جو کہ گناہ ہے۔ اور آپ نے جاھل بول کے اس کے تمام استدلال کو زیرو سے ضرب دیا ہے۔ اور یہ کہنا کہ فلاح تو یہ کرتا ہے اور میں نے اس سے ہلکی بات کی ہے تو یقین جانیں قیامت کے دن اللہ تعالیٰ آپ سے یہ نہیں پوچھیں گے کہ فلاح نے کیا کہا، بلکہ آپ سے آپکے بارے میں جو رویہ آپ نے اختیار کیا اس کے بارے میں پوچھا جائے گا۔ آپ کسی کے مکلف نہیں ٹھہرائے جائیں گے۔
Jumaa jumaa 8 din hua hai beta ko paida huye aur ghamidi sahib ko jaahil bolta hai, pura clip ka zayeja lene chahiye isko ki ghamidi sahib ne pura pasmanzar bayan karke jo baat boli hai usme Zara bhi khulta e rashideen ki tauhin hai aur na hazrat muaviya ki inper ko barotari.
Engineer bhai ni ye alfaz bilkul galat use kie hi, sir Javed ni apni ek rai di thi koie galt bat nhi ki thi esi jis si sahaba ki tohen huie ho, par dosri molviyon ki tarh Ali Bhai bhi apni galti tasleem nahi kar rahi, or khud ko hi sahi samj rahi hi. Allah hum sub ko hidayadt ata kari.
Mere hisab se to Nasbi, Rafzi hi bahter tha Ali bhai ne kha-mkha jahil jaise halke alfaaz bole . Aise soch rakhne wale ko Rafzi ,Nasbi hi bolna chahiye👍😂
Ghamidi Sahib ne jo baat ki us video me comparison of two systems tha. Wo kon sa nizaam he jo written form me chora gaya - Ager chora gaya to wo kider he? Is question me to koi bi be-adabi wali baat nahi he ? Ye baat he ke Ghamidi Sahib Ameer Muawia ka dafah really kerte hain aor shaed boht ziada
پہلے تو اختلاف کرنا سیکھیں، بات مذہب پہ کر رہے ہیں اور اتنا معیوب انداز کہ کبھی سکول بھی نہ گئے ہوں۔ ایک پڑھا لکھا بندہ جب ایسے بات کرے تو بھر توجہ تربیت یا دماغی صحت کی طرف چلی جاتی ہے، جو نہیں ہونا چاہیے۔۔۔ ہمیں بھی اس موضوع پہ غامدی صاحب سے اختلاف ہے لیکن اس کو لیکر، ان کی باقی علمی خدمات کو بھول کر، توں تڑاک پہ آ جانا خود جہالت کہی جاسکتی ہے۔۔۔
جب کوئی بندہ اپنی اوقات سے باہر نکل جاتا ہے تو پھر اس طرح کے غلطیاں سرزد اس سے ہوتی ہیں اور دوسری مجلس میں غامدی صاحب کو نمبر ون عالم بھی اپنے منہ سے ہی بولا جاتا ہے اب چاہے مرزا جہلمی رجوع کرے یا نہ کرے عوام کو اس کی علمی قابلیت کا پتہ چل گیا ہے
I still Respect Ustad Javed GHAMIDI حفظہ اللہ ! BUT no Compromise on Ahl-ul-Bait علیھم السلام ! Well needed CLIP. Keep on doing Dawat-e-HAQ of ISLAM without Firqawariyat. May ALLAH guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! TRUTH Lovers ko SALAM ! ! !
Badi film hain engineer sahab. Koi inko jahil bolde to wo bazari zuban. Khud dusron ko jo b bolden waha justification or shariat le ae. Ye hain inke adaab, ikhlaaq or ilmi ikhtilaaf 😀
جزاک اللہ خیرا
@@MuhammadUsman-vx7dd bhai unho ne har cheez ko compare kar ke dikhaya hai...
ke unho ne gamdi sahb ke baray mai apne sab se naram alfaz istmal kie jo gamdi sahb ke bayan pe ho sakte the...
aur jin ke jahil bolne ki ap bat kar rahe hain...wo khud dusro ko aysi hi batain bolte hai to engineer sahb ne btaya hai ke dekhi bazari zuban to fir apki bhi hai...
@@mhabbijee9357 compare kar k dikhaya engr sb ne k main jo b boldun dusron ko kutta, daddu, nasbi, jahil wo sab jaiz hain lekin meri harkaat ki waja se koi muje jahil, rafzi, gustakh kehde to wo bazari zuban, najaiz, bad ikhlaqi ha. Tabhi to film hain ye puri 😄
@@MuhammadUsman-vx7dd chalo bhai ap na mano... wama alina ila blag
دعوت و تبلیغ کا کام کرنے والا، قرآن اور سنت کا نام لینے والا،خود کو علمی کتابیں کہنے والا آج تضحیک و تنقیص اور تنقید میں فرق کرنے سے قاصر نظر آتا ہے
True
Good
if Engineer is not a slave of his ego, he will apologize for calling Ghamdi as jahil. Ghamidi is the top notch islamic researcher of the century
yeh bat aus par hoti tou ap ego kahti , woh khulfai-e-rashideen ka against bat karnay par aunka yeh action aya hai .
@@muhammadsubhanakram5323 Har shaksh se ikhtalaf kia jaa sakta hai siwai Allah or Rasool. Agar koi is pe qayem rahe to samajh lo us ne inko nabi ke barabar khara ker dia
@@shakilahmad8246 khulfai e rashideen sa ikhtilaf ais Liye nhi kar rhe, q k woh Nabi peace be upon him ki sunnatey follow kartay thay , aunko follow ais Liye kar rhe hai without Kisi apni soch lagai k woh Allah ka Nabi peace be upon him ko Zindagi par chalay .
Apnay tou boht koi ulti example di hai .
😂😂😂😂😂 Thuski phuski 😂😂😂😂
yesss
Nouman Ali Khan, Waheedudin Khan, and Ahmad Javaid are international speakers who appreciates work of Javed Ghamidi. Great scholar Waheedudin even said that I am bigger in age but Ghamidi is bigger in Ilm. Only non-sect ulema appreciates work of Ghamidi sahab because sect considers everyone outside them Ghumrah and Ghamidi sahab doesn’t belong to any sect.
Also in Baba video, Ghamidi sahab mentioned ulema by name that you condemn NOT only Bukhari aur Muslim. He respects and values work of Sufi ulema (Ghazali, Shah Wali Ullah) or Fiqh Ulema (Ahmad Raza Bareveli, Ashraf Ali Thanvi). He critique their research but never their personalities. Or in your words, he doesn’t multiply their work by Zero.
For political system, what Ghamidi sahab said that traditional political system and transfer of power was relevant till Khilafat of Umar (ra). After Umar (ra) that system has its failure because of vast expansion of Muslim empire. We know there was era of Fitna from Usman (ra) ruling period. There were rebels from Busra, Kufa, Misar… Muwaiya (ra) had no option but to adopt Mulokiat to stop bloodshed, civil war and anarchy. What Ghamidi sahab appreciated was Muwaiya (ra)skills of politics and long term vision of governance. We might not have our religion as we know it now has the empire broken up in pieces. Its known Muwaiya (ra) ruling period was of peace and prosperity.
Please reply
Mawiya Was a tyrant ruler who conspired and Rebelled against Amir Ul Mumineen Maula Ali A.S.
Best 👍💯💯❤
Sahi farmaya aap nay....sahi baat samajnay , jaanay aur maanay kay liye dimaag aur niyat saaf honi chahiye...Truth is bitter but it is always better...stay blessed
Engineer should apologize for his statement, but seemingly he has been under his ego
Exactly, he is arrogant
درست کہا
Ghamidi sahib kisi point pe bilkul galat ho saktay hain magar Alhamdulillah un k level ka ikhlaaq kisi ka nahi, engineer sahib ka tou bilkul bhi nahi.
Jahan takabbur hoga wahan akhlaaq ka kya kaam😊
Ghamidi shb is blessing. Allah engineer sahb ki hidayat de ,in ko ache kamom ka ajr de aur gunah maf farmae
yess
Watch honestly again gamadi sahab's point of view
Ali bhai is well enteric but a man with tiny mind and very little wisdom. He can not understand and will not even come out of his little well
@@shahzadkhanacma Ali is biased towards personalities & based his little knowledge under their spell. He can not infer on logic. He can not differentiate & analyze conditions faced by Muawya & Khulfa Rashid. He always compare personalities in terms of chastity & then make one better than other which is not his jurisdiction.
With due respect...
You have not listened Ghamidi saab completely...
Both matters are different...
Ghamidi Sahib says that khulafa Rashideen ruled on their unmatchable character and honesty but this system had some "administrative " faults. For example some people demanded resignation of Hazrat Usman RA. Now issue was that how to remove the caliph or to retain it?
So when it could not resolved, sword was the decision maker. Same in case of Hazrat Ali RA and Hazrat Muawiya RA, where sword decided the fate. So Ghamidi sahib highlighted these shortcomings in the system despite there was no match with Caliphs' morality and character.
In 2nd case, he says that if Hazrat Muawiya had not handed over the charge in his family then again there were chances of big internal war among Muslims.
So he looks at the matter as administrative issue. If you think that there could not be administrative shortcomings in ruling by Caliphs, then your approach is different.
So bear the difference and keep emotions aside ..
Respect the difference
Thank you
Obviously i was already in doubt that saying these words to scholar like ghamidi saahab is nothing else but is the matter of enigneer Ego...as he cant stand infront of ghamidi saahab in any subjects any topic of islam.
He Got very weak arguements here , which can easily be replied by ghamidi saahab but he will never reply..He is not only the ocean of knoweldge but also got greatest Attitude a muslim can have. GHAMIDI SAAHAB IS LEGEND.
Engineer bhai Ghaidi Sahb ilam ke bahut ounchay muqam per haj 🙏 Bhai.
Ur Student/follower from Quetta
İtne bhi oonche nahi ki khulfa e rashidun ko lesson de sakein.
@@AZ-je9hg Kisi ne lesson nahin dia. agar koi kahay khulafa e rashedeen ne jahaz ijaad nahin kia tou wo lesson dena nahin hoga. Agar koi kahay khulafa e rashedeen ko computer ka kuch nahin pata tha tou ye lesson dena nahin hoga. issi tarha unke daur main koi nizam murattab nahin hua ye lesson dena nahin hay. ye aik haqeeqat hay. Na ye unki zimedari thi koi. waqt k saath saath systems bantay chalay gaye. Jaisay science k dunya main waqt k saath sath taraqqi hui waisay hi Imraniyaat/social science main bhi hui. is main lesson dena kahan se a gaya.
afsos, you called ghamdi jahil. he did not agreed with mawia but he said in due circumstances his way was the right way at that time nor he degraded khulfai e rashideen. rather then heal the wound you took the path of other stereotype molvies to whom you regards as babey.
Yeah! He is jahil in a sense in that topic
Aap ko sun kay acha lagta tha aur aisa mehsoos hota tha ki Ghamidi sahab kay alaawa bhi koyi ilim wala banda hai, magar aisay alfaaz ghamidi sahab kay liye use karna aur bina pura sonaye aur samajnay kau bagair..ufff Allah raham karray....You all are sailing in the same boat...May Allah guide us and give long life and good health to Mr javeed ahmad ghamidi sahab
Listen to Mufti Abu Layth (dont go for his looks or his jokes, just judge him on his knowledge and approach) he is the only scholar i often listen to other than ofcourse the Great Ghamidi sb
Lahza bata deta ha ki jahil kaun ha.
Ya ek tariqa ye bhi ha ki zee- shaur log kis taraf khade hote hn ye dekh liya jaye.
Ghamdi sahab ne baat karne aur ikhtalaf karne aur shaistgi se baat karne ka tariqa eejad kiya ha!
Aisa tariqa jo abse pahle kisi muslim aalim ke pas nahi tha.
Hats off ghamdi sahab!
Most appreciative approach of Ghamdi sb is that he does not analyse anything standing just on one side rather he looks at things in the perspective of the person saying/doing something, also in the perspective of time and history. Sees things with open mind. Trains his followers in this way. Never gets harsh. He is a great scholar of this time.
You can disagree with others opinion but don’t have right to insult someone or issue a decree against. Sad you said that
Islamically you are allowed to insult people upto a certain degree based on what they do.
Engineer is well within his Islamic right.
ghamdi sahab is indeed full of wisdom, iv never seen him to give an extremist opinion. its saad to see engineer sahab that you seem to a man of knowledge and logic but still you used such derogatory word.
Alhamdolillah comment section main Ghamidi sahib ke itne ziada himayati Dekh Kar sukoon hua ke ab log daleel aor ikhlas ko follow karte hain na ke jazbat aor ihsasat se mutasir nazrya ko. Ap pehle bare narm mizaj te lekin aj ap ne molvion wali zuban use ki hai
Ghamdi is the most moderate person, mirza is no comparison, his language is street music
most of his lectures are circulating around political conflict between sahaba and contraversial issues in islam.he is far from DAWAT of quran.just an emotional person , true dawat of islam is to call people for good deeds and AKHRAT oriented life in this world, he is hero of IQ level people, sorry these words are somewhat hard
You overestime on your own intelligence.
When has mirza sahab claimed to give dawat, he picks those 'controversial' issues and gives his educated opinion on the matter, same as ghamidi sahab, if some religious matters make people emotional or they are considered 'controversial', does that mean they should not be discussed to get to the truth/right way under the interpretation of Islam????
Ghamidi "students" should stop thinking they and ghamidi sahab are "geniuses" and come with mantaq/logic if they have any.
I think Mirza Sahb didnt watch the full video, he may have watched the clip only
BEG PARDON !
PUBLICLY
This is complete zahil approch .
I am your student , i learned many things from you
You always complaint about ulma's language .
But in the case of ghamidi sb.
You cross red line
Sir, you must apologise from him .
Calling someone zahil uzaad , is respect !
Sir , i never expected this from you .
Kya allah k rasool mimbar pr beth k esay deen sikhatay thay? Ya phir ye mirza sahb , nabi sey zyada dard rakhtay hein umat ka
کیا یہ واقعی ایک علمی کتابیں شخص کی گفتگو ہے؟
کیا واقع ہی غامدی صاحب نے صحابہ پر طعن کیا ہے؟
ایک ایسے امر واقعہ کو بیان کرنا۔
جس کے صحابہ کرام شرعی مکلف بھی نہ تھے صحابہ پر طعن کہلاتا ہے؟
کیا غامدی صاحب نے جو مؤقف اختیار کیا ہے اس کی پوری وضاحت بیان نہیں کی؟
کیا وہ اس کو خالصتا دینی مسئلہ سمجھتے ہیں یا سیاسی مسئلہ؟
حقیقت یہ ہے کہ مرزا علی صاحب کا رویہ بتاتا ہے کہ وہ اپنے فہم کو عقل کل سمجھتے ہیں اور انہوں نے اپنی اصلاح کے ہر دروازے بند کر لیے ہیں اور اس زعم میں مبتلا ہیں کہ انہوں نے کبھی تکبر نہیں کیا حالانکہ ان کا رویہ ہر بیان میں یہ بتا رہا ہوتا ہے کہ ان سے بڑا کوئی عالم اس روئے زمین پر پیدا ہی نہیں ہوا۔
اور جب مرزا صاحب پر انکے اخلاقی رویوں کے متعلق اعتراضات کئے جاتے ہیں تو اس کے جواب میں دوسرے علماء کے ایسے ہی غلط رویوں کو بطور دلیل اور اپنے برے رویوں کے جواز کے طور پر پیش کر دیتے ہیں۔ بڑا مشکل نظر آتا ہے کہ مرزا صاحب اپنی اصلاح پر بھی غور فرمائیں گے۔
اور میں مرزا صاحب کی اس صلاحیت کا اعتراف کرتا ہوں کہ وہ اپنی ہر بد اخلاقی کا دفاع کرنا خوب جانتے ہیں کوئی نہ کوئی جواز نکال لیتے ہیں۔
تعجب ہوتا ہے کہ جب وہ حضرت عمر علیہ السلام کی سخت مزاجی جو کہ ایک ذاتی اور شخصی اور فطری معاملہ ہے کو اپنی بداخلاقی کے جواز کے طور پر پیش کرتے نظر آتے ہیں)
(واضح رہے کہ بداخلاقی صرف یہی نہیں ہے کہ آپ کسی کو گالی نکال دیں جیسا کہ مرزا صاحب خیال کرتے ہیں )
They don't understand Ghamid. Ghamidi is very high level scholar. So you are a fool wasting time to make them understanding something they can't. I struggled 3 years..to understand what Ghamidi says...it is so difficult to grasp... because of the narrow Religious culture we live in.
So brother...no offense...I don't call you...fool...in real sense... you understanding😃
Salam to you may God bless me and you too...and good persons
@@NSNCNB
میں کسی شخصیت پر تبصرہ کرنے سے پہلے اس کو اچھی طرح سے جان لینے کو اپنے لئے ضروری سمجھتا ہوں میں نے مرزا صاحب کو بہت عرصہ تک سمجھنے کی کوشش کی ہے اور ان کی بہت سی باتوں سے اتفاق بھی کرتا ہوں۔
لیکن ان کے رویے سے اور ایک خاص تضحیک اور تنقیص والے اسلوب سے ہمیشہ اختلاف رہا ہے۔
ایک عالم دین یا صحیح معنی میں دین کے طالب علم کا یہ انداز اور رویہ کبھی بھی نہیں ہو سکتا۔
اور اب میں پوری طرح محسوس کرتا ہوں کہ مرزا صاحب اپنی علمی استعداد و حدود سے تجاوز کر رہے ہیں۔
آج تبصرہ اس لیے کرنے پر مجبور ہوا ہوں کہ میں اسے اپنا دینی فریضہ سمجھتا ہوں اور اس لیے بھی کہ مرزا صاحب ایک عوامی شخصیت بن چکے ہیں اگرچہ ان کے مخالفین بھی بہت کثرت سے ہیں۔
@@NSNCNB you are right that Ghamidi sahab is great scholar but you know what! it is also difficult to grasp Engineer sahab's behaviour . JazakAllah .!!
He said i dnt support that but at that time if that was not done then ummha has torne into pieces.
He is right he said 10 time he is against it he never support it but when it was done then u have to accept it in order to find the best solutions.
First- ghamdi sahab is not jaahil, he is a gem for the ummah (he is a scholar in its true sense), yes he may have wrong conclusions on certain things based on his knowledge
Second- you are also a gem for this ummah
🇮🇳
He is absolutely Jaahil & promoter of Taghoot
But,
Gem and Scholar for those
Who wants to perform Haram, Immoral, Satanic activities
Under the name of Islam
So such low & cheap people
Use such ignorant, Taghootis to get Halal stamp
For every
Declared Haram & Immoral activity by Allah SWT in Islam
So,
These people are those about whom Allah SWT says,
"They want to defeat Allah SWT in the verses of Allah SWT (By giving wrong conclusions in support of Haram & Satanic activities by taking some verses out of context, or by playing with meaning of the words).
Such Taghoot & Satan Supporters would indeed find the company of their big father, Satan in Aakhirah, InshAllah..!!!
May Allah SWT save innocent & ignorant people from such pawns Taghoot & Satan
*Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) neither talked in an insulting manner nor did he ever speak evil intentionally. He used to say, "The most beloved to me amongst you is the one who has the best character and manners."* (Bukhari #3759)
Engineer Ali not only crossed the line (which is possible in anger or mistake), but when given a chance to take back (rujoo), his ego prevented him again to follow the Sunnah/behaviour of our Prophet (saw)..
This ego-istic and rude attitude itself proves that "Hadith" is not the same as "Sunnah".. because a master of Hadith like Engineer still fails to recall and apply the amaly "Sunnah" of the Prophet (saw) of his character, which is more seen in the attitude, humbleness, tolerance and patience of (for example) Javed Ahmed Ghamidi.
اللہ تعالیٰ ہم سب کو ہدایت دے آمین یا رب العالمین
Ameen Ya Rab Al Alameen
Matlab ye badla le rahe k ghamidi sb k kisi sathi ne in k khilaf baat ki to inho ne Ghandi sb ko ase kaha.Boht hi immature ha engineer bhai.Hum log akhlaq p kaam nhi karte bas darhi parde ko adopt kar k dil ko tasalli dete k hum religious hai.
I respect you so much but Ali bhai makes mistakes here.
Ghamidi sb never behave like Ali bhai. That is difference between Aalim and Jaahil
Ustad e Mohtram Ali mirza sahib ap plzzz parda valy moakif pr ghamidi sahib ko properly rebutal kryn ku k jin dlaaaeeeel ko ap ly kr aaty han rebutal k liye un sb ka reply ghamidi sahib ne apny 23 aetrazat ki series ma diya hua ha jisy sun kr insaan satisfy hotaa ha unhii k point of view se to plzzzz ap properly rebutal kryn jesy ap ne pul sirat valy topic pr kiyaa.
plzzz replyyy krynn ku k i dont knoww any other source to contact u.
Engineer bhai is not the only one, aksar Ghamidi sahab ki baat ko twist kar ke unhain gaali dene ka maaza lia jata ha.
Engineer sahab ke pas qayamat tak ka time ha video poori imandari se sun lain.
Allah Pak Ali Bhai ko or Ali Bhai ki poori team or viewar umat e Muslim ko apni hefzo aaman me rakhye shaht tondrasti jaazaye kheir Aalla zindgi ata frmaye Aameen 🙏🙏🙏
#arrestnupursharma#
Ajkal jamare ulema ka yehi problem h ki wo log apni zuban pe lagam ni rakhte
Ghamidi sb never behave like Ali bhai. That is difference between Aalim and Jaahil
Shameful for Engineer. Nonsense talk. Out of context talk.
Didn't expect from you. You should listen to the whole video. He didn't say that. What you're talking about here.
Ustaz Ghamadi provided a comprehensive and unbiased explanation of the matter.
Political unrest started in the reign of 3rd caliph and it was not properly managed and dealt with and after that real chaos ensued… It became abundantly clear that there was no agreed upon formula to transfer the power… This problem became more apparent towards the end of the reign of Ameer Mauvia the world at that time knew only one way of transferring the power in huge empires like this… At same time if there would have been any other claimants to the leadership they would all have been because of the hereditary reasons and no real democratic reasons, so, what happened was, howsoever regrettable, but inevitable…
Ali point of View is very weak against ghamdi sahab you can’t even approach the wisdom of islam that ghamdi sahab have. Lower your edi Mr Ali Mirza if you really want to understand islam
rebuttal k chkr mn kya ksi ki tazheek b kr skty kya?? problem srf yh hai k ghamdi shb ny sayedna ameer mawiya (RA) ki tareef kr d jo apko hzm nai horhi...
G zahir hai koi hadees kay khelaf bat kre ga to hazam nahi hogi hmein. AlhumduLILLAH
Video tu Sahi terra dekh Bhai. Demag set ha ya nahi.
Syedna ameer muavia ney rasool k khalifa k khilaf talwar uthai thee unki tareef krna he rasool ki tazheek hy. Humse esi koi cheez hazm ni hoti jo Rasool k khilaf ho.
Ghamidi sahb tumko mubarak ho.
Or haan aik bt zrur
Ye engineer he hy jiski wja sey mene ghamibi sahb ki ghanto slow slow baatein sunna shuru ki hein smjhay. Bht kuch wo sahi bhe kehte hein.
Kalti shabash.
Ghamdi sahab is legend
Yeah he is legend because he presenting Islam in your wish ful thinking. He changes the Basis principal of Islam that is reason you liked him. Shame on you brother.
Javed Ahmed ghamidi was of view that Muslims were unable to create a democratic system where u can get viewpoint from every Muslim.
Jis ko mazhab tameez na sikha saky us sy kam az kam deen na seekho. Kabhi engr ko sunta tha leken badtameez hony ki waja sy Engr ko sunna chor dia.
Hum kyu na samjay aap nay ussi baat ka badla nahi utara, ussi baat ka tou utara hai Engineer sahab...❤❤
I don't agree with Ali bhai in this issue.
We all know ghamidi sb. is not a nasbi... if ali bhai just criticize his belief on ameer i sham without using harsh words that was enough. Because Ghamidi sb. Is a great personality.
آپ نے غامدی صاحب کے ساتھ بہت زیادتی کر دی ، میں چاہتے ہوئے بھی اب آپ کو نہیں سن سکتی۔ میں اس شخص سے کیسے دین کی بات سیکھ سکتی ہوں جس کی گفتگو اس قدر نچلے درجے کی ہو۔اللھ نے آپ کو ذہانت دی اور آپ نے اس تحفے کو اپنے غرور سے ملیا میٹ کر دیا۔
Ghamdi Sahab bhi ostad hy aur Ali bhai bhi.
Leken Ameer Mavia ke mamly me ham Mola Ali ke sath hyn
Ali bhai you need to apologise publicly. You are wrong in this regards. I've seen Ghamdi saab videos on this topic and he didn't say anything like you have mentioned.
Right
Mere bhai ghamdi sahab ka ja k imam mehdi pe bayan suno wo munkir hain is k bhi or Isa ibn maryam k bhi i have reference video of ghamdi
If you haven’t heard his statements it doesn’t mean Mr Ghamdi hasn’t said it…
Salaam. May be when Ali bhai gets older he might realise the wisdom of Javed Ghamdi’s explanation of Ameer Muawia’s situation. We can’t judge our politicians honesty with all the media coverage. Yet we want to come to a conclusion on who is right in our historic in fighting of Muslims Ummah They have earned what they have done you will earn what you have done.
Ali ibne abi Talib se mauvia ka compere kaise ho sakta he.
Arey bhai,what situation? Koi majburi thi kya waqt k zalim badshah ko? Ya apko majburi hai unki galti ko bhi saheeh qaraar Dene ki
Ustad e Mohtram Ali mirza sahib ap plzzz parda valy moakif pr ghamidi sahib ko properly rebutal kryn ku k jin dlaaaeeeel ko ap ly kr aaty han rebutal k liye un sb ka reply ustad e mohtram ghamidi sahib ne apny 23 aetrazat ki series ma diya hua ha jisy sun kr insaan satisfy hotaa ha unhii k point of view se to plzzzz ap properly rebutal kryn jesy ap ne pul sirat valy topic pr kiyaa.
plzzz replyyy krynn ku k i dont knoww any other source to contact u.
Best scholar of ISLAM when it comes to character and mannerism is Javed Ahmed Ghamidi but I do disagree with him on some issues . Love you Ali Bhai for the sake of Allah swt please try to be cool
to be honest i got inspired by his teachings more than character and mannerism. Ali mirza is not even an average scholar.
Jahil word is used for abu Jahil , I think you do not know the meaning of Jahil in Arabic . It is not a small world it is a very very big world .
Ali mirza always supports Shias and vice versa.
It's a common pattern i am observing from Engineer, He attaches himself with some known personality to gain popularity from other person's following then he rejects him and his thought processes and uses derogatory words for him and tries to ridicule him..
I have been listening to him for the last 7 to 8 years, he does this to every person or his "every Teacher".
Ghamdi Sahb is a genius, I dont think Engineer can ever reach that intellect,
Ali bhai me india se hoon.pahle me bhi ek firke se juda hua tha par Allah ka fazal or karam se aapki or gamidi saab ki video dekh kar Allah ne mujhe tofik di or ab me apne aap ko sirf musalman kehta hoon.par is masle pe ho sakta hai ki aap dalail me gamidi saab se zyada mazboot houn par is jagah aap galat Hain gamidi saab bhi aapki kai baton se ikhtlaf karte hain par kabhi unki zaban par aapke liye ya kisi or ke liye koi galat alfaz nahi aaya.aap ek achche Alim hai par achha insaan banne ke liye apko gamidi saab se sikhe ki zarurat hai.allah Hafiz
Kahan qalandar badshah kahan dallu faqeer,
kahan Ghamidi sb aur kahan engineer sb.
Ghamidi sb never behave like Ali bhai. That is difference between Aalim and Jaahil
Bht afsos hua ustaz engineer muhammad ali mirza sb k rawaiye p. Allah pak ap pr karam kry. Qk ap tohmat ke jurm ke murtakib ho rhy hyn. Ghamidi sb ny na hazrat abu bakar o umar ko degrade kiya na hi wo hazrat ali as k bary mn bughz rkhty hyn. Please sir, like traditional ulama don't become biased and listen his point of view without being biased to ameer muawiya.
Jazak Allah
Allah hidayat de ap ko engineer sab
There is no need for a sharayi masala to apologize to people. People do it out of morality :) Engineer Sb seems to have a bit of ego
Engineer shb is best among all molvies, but he is nothing infrnt of ghamidi shb
Inna lilah e wainna elahe rajeon....engineer sahab ne sabit kiya hai woh khud jahil aur ujjad honay kay saath saath ganwar bhi hain bahut shouq se inko suna kartay tha aainda na kabhi sunonga na kisiko kisko sun-nay ka kahon ga.
Ghamdi sahab ke alawa sabhi aalim tang dil, intolerent aur daroga malum hote hn, jo kisi ko bhi daante, bura kahne, fatwa lagane ka haq rakhte hn. Pata nahi ye tang dili aati kahan se ha.
I listen to Ali and like his aqida. However he is unrefined as a person.
Ayee Musalman kr ly es py goor....🧐
Baboon ka khuda oor.....😨😡
Kitabon ka khuda oor.....📚🌹❣
Mirza sahib ko ghamdi sahib se Mafi mangni chaheay ll
جس شخص کے پاس اپنے استاد کے لئے عزت نہیں وہ کسی اور کے لئے کیا عزت کرے گا
AIK DOUSREY PER FATWA BAAZI..NAHI HOONI CHAHEAY😢😂
Engineer Saheb instead of condemning Ghamidi Saheb and his opinion, refute his daleel on which his opinion is based with your daleel. That is how true scholars behave.
dalael na hoon tu phir sab aisay hi behave kartay hain jahalat aur jhoot k sath le k. Allah inhain hidayat de
Ali bhai have tiny mind and very little wisdom. He can not understand and will not even come out of his little well
True
Ager ye Mafi nahain mangey ga iss ko dubara kabi nahain sunain gain
Allah Bless Ghamidi For All Da Time In Life.❤❤❤❤
EMAM is 100 percent right
انجینئر صاحب نے نے بات تو ٹھیک کیں ہیں کافی پر نیا کٹا کھولا ہے. دوسرا اپنی غلط اور جارحانہ رویے اور بیان کی معذرت کرنے کے بجائے اس پر ڈٹ گئے.
FATWA WOH LUGHAEIN..JO AAP PER BHI LUGHEY...😂😢..YA OUS KAY ULTT LUGH JAEY...😢😢..
Javed Ahmad Ghamdi is the prominent Islamic scholar, let's not disrespect him
Ghamidi is absolutely different from others
Good
Engineer looks a street vendor before Ghamdi sab. He is taking Ghamdi sab name to improve his TRP.
Ali bhai moje ap ki smaj ni ati ap on Se ilmi manazra kio ni kar lete yahan lan tan karne ki Kia zrorat ap dono hamre liye qable Ahtram hen
eng sb ki bat theek hai.
Which one??? If I say Ghamidi Sahab is right then, I have to pin point about what on what grounds…
For Gaamdi followers ..he is not a prophet he is just scholar.. so we have to understand that follow him only in the boundary of qurano sunna..not his personal openion..simply
True...
ali bhai ghamdi sahi say maafi mange q k wo ap k ustad hai,
Is ka shyeri hukam ye hai ? Jo apny se kye gunna qabil admi ko jahil ur ojad kahy wo khud jahil ur ojad Hota hai 👎
khuda ki qasm ye shaks ghamdi sb sy 10 min bhi behs nhi kr skta..... intehai jahil aadmi ha jo apnay siwa sb ko ghalat kehta ha
Haaq baat boht khub samjahi....Allhamdulillah....💚🌟🌹❣
So disappointed to listen your comments about Ghamdi Sb, Hi Engr Sb, you are kid in front of Ghamdi Sahib knowledge of Quran & Hadith.
Engineer Shab theek hain
معزرت کے ساتھ، یہ کوئی طریقہ نہیں ہے اختلاف کرنے کا، آپ نے فرد کے اوپر تبصرھ کیا ہے نہ کہ فکر یا نظریے پر، اگر آپ نے تنقید ہی کرنی تھی تو بتاتے کہ انکی اس بات میں یہاں یا اس جگہ خرابی ہے اور یہ میری صحیح بات ہے اور اسکی بنیاد یہ ہے بس اتنا ہی کرنا تھا۔ لیکن اپنے اخلاقی حدود سے تجاوز کیا ہے جو کہ گناہ ہے۔ اور آپ نے جاھل بول کے اس کے تمام استدلال کو زیرو سے ضرب دیا ہے۔
اور یہ کہنا کہ فلاح تو یہ کرتا ہے اور میں نے اس سے ہلکی بات کی ہے تو یقین جانیں قیامت کے دن اللہ تعالیٰ آپ سے یہ نہیں پوچھیں گے کہ فلاح نے کیا کہا، بلکہ آپ سے آپکے بارے میں جو رویہ آپ نے اختیار کیا اس کے بارے میں پوچھا جائے گا۔ آپ کسی کے مکلف نہیں ٹھہرائے جائیں گے۔
Jumaa jumaa 8 din hua hai beta ko paida huye aur ghamidi sahib ko jaahil bolta hai, pura clip ka zayeja lene chahiye isko ki ghamidi sahib ne pura pasmanzar bayan karke jo baat boli hai usme Zara bhi khulta e rashideen ki tauhin hai aur na hazrat muaviya ki inper ko barotari.
You should be ashamed of yourslf engineer sb, mend your ways and look in the mirror before you call an esteem scholar a jahil. Shame on you
Ager Mirza engineer ne ghamdi ko ujad kaha ha iss ko bi tamam ullama chutta Mirza kehtey hain wo sarey sahi kehtey hain
Engineer bhai ni ye alfaz bilkul galat use kie hi, sir Javed ni apni ek rai di thi koie galt bat nhi ki thi esi jis si sahaba ki tohen huie ho, par dosri molviyon ki tarh Ali Bhai bhi apni galti tasleem nahi kar rahi, or khud ko hi sahi samj rahi hi. Allah hum sub ko hidayadt ata kari.
Apni ego ko satisfy krny k liye below the belt guftgu ki ghamidy shb k bary me ..!! Ye hai ilmi kitaabi guftgu
Mere hisab se to Nasbi, Rafzi hi bahter tha Ali bhai ne kha-mkha jahil jaise halke alfaaz bole . Aise soch rakhne wale ko Rafzi ,Nasbi hi bolna chahiye👍😂
Jehlum ma short honay wali cheezon ma plug aj bh dsry nmber pr ha
Khulfa rashideen hakoomat nahi chala sake. is me koi ghalat bat nahi he.
#arrestnupursharma#
Ghamidi Sahib ne jo baat ki us video me comparison of two systems tha. Wo kon sa nizaam he jo written form me chora gaya - Ager chora gaya to wo kider he? Is question me to koi bi be-adabi wali baat nahi he ? Ye baat he ke Ghamidi Sahib Ameer Muawia ka dafah really kerte hain aor shaed boht ziada
پہلے تو اختلاف کرنا سیکھیں، بات مذہب پہ کر رہے ہیں اور اتنا معیوب انداز کہ کبھی سکول بھی نہ گئے ہوں۔ ایک پڑھا لکھا بندہ جب ایسے بات کرے تو بھر توجہ تربیت یا دماغی صحت کی طرف چلی جاتی ہے، جو نہیں ہونا چاہیے۔۔۔
ہمیں بھی اس موضوع پہ غامدی صاحب سے اختلاف ہے لیکن اس کو لیکر، ان کی باقی علمی خدمات کو بھول کر، توں تڑاک پہ آ جانا خود جہالت کہی جاسکتی ہے۔۔۔
جب کوئی بندہ اپنی اوقات سے باہر نکل جاتا ہے تو پھر اس طرح کے غلطیاں سرزد اس سے ہوتی ہیں
اور دوسری مجلس میں غامدی صاحب کو نمبر ون عالم بھی اپنے منہ سے ہی بولا جاتا ہے
اب چاہے مرزا جہلمی رجوع کرے یا نہ کرے عوام کو اس کی علمی قابلیت کا پتہ چل گیا ہے