ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- Perpetual Motion of Water - Robert Boyle's Perpetual Flask - One of the most curious inventions of Robert Boyle, is known as the Perpetual Flowing Vessel, or Self-Flowing Vessel.
The principle is quite simple: the weight of the liquid in the vessel is significantly higher than the weight of the liquid contained in the neck of the vessel, this causes a pressure difference which causes the water to rise up the neck of the vessel. Thus, the liquid is forced to flow in order to compensate for the difference in weights (hydrostatic pressures). If this compensation is sufficient to raise the liquid from the neck to the upper zone where the tube ends, the system acquires a continuous behavior to compensate for pressure differences.
Unfortunately the theoretical foundation is wrong because it confuses weight with pressure, and therefore this would never work.
I'm very glad that you are showing people how the scam are done. I think it's sad that anyone is trying to scam others like this. Thumbs up for this!
This is not scam you id...he uses special liquid 😅
Id... Right back at you 😉
He uses regular water mixed with blue color so we can see it better.
Now what I meant was NOT that this video is scam in fact the opposite... I think this is a great video showing HOW the scammers are cheating People.
For the doubters:
My wife has a perpertual motion mouth that never stops nagging. She must have inherited that mitocondrial gene from her mother (which would be my mother in law).
Poor man. And you even try and joke about it.
Jajajajaja. I think the same as you.
Tell her to put her motor mouth to good use. But tell her through the locked garage door so if things go left you can make a speedy getaway 😂😂😂😂
Man when i read My wife has a perpetual motion mouth. I thought it was going to have a good ending.
Too funny
I see a lot of people saying it’s impossible and to those people I said no duh if you watched the video beyond one minute you would know 1:24
Think!
took about 5 seconds to realize this was not possible water seeps it's own level, I just built a water level to set the piers for a gazebo
nice idea, was thinking the same thing. but what if you make the hole more smaller and make the water holder more bigger, will it make a difference. like make the straw thing very very small.
we can t get free energy....unless by fission ;)
Haha, your video is almost 4 min long, but over 90% watched only the first min to conclude. Great video!
Unfortunately haha
Thanks for watching
How did you determine that over 90% only watched the 1st minute?
oh it's a trick. I thought the flow looked a bit low for the bore of tube shown. makes sense when you reveal the bore of the actual donor tube.
Though Perpetual Motion Devices don’t exist, shouldn’t the potential energy introduced into the system when dumping in water from a higher point allow it to run for a while? How long can this realistically be? I imagine the frictions (such as creation of drops at the output) to be extremely small!
Until the water evaporates
There is not such a thing as potential energy, there is only actual movement. How could there be an energy which does not move «physically speaking»? Impossible.
@@sigurfeanaro3356 wrong potential energy is energy being held back by resistance waiting to be released. if you wind a rubber band around a stick and tie it off it is full of potential energy waiting to be released and when you do it will snap around that stick using the potential energy it had stored. this is the basis of a torque battery like ones you find in a wind up music box. you can wind it up to store potential energy and pin it to release at a later time.
If it is an elastic tension = it is movement, if it is pressure = it is movement, if it is weight over something = pressure = it is movement, if it is oscillation = it is movement, if it is »temperature« = it is movement, if it »electricity« = it is movement, magnetism, and so on...
Also, by the principle of conservation of energy, there is not such a thing as a 'still' or 'at rest' molecule or atom or particle. There is always transfer of energy and no system is hermetic. So there is always movement.
If it was beer we might find it interesting.
Back in the 90s as a teen thought of the concept of the Toyota Prius. A vehicle that uses a battery that regenerates it's energy. Also, the concept of the drone... Except thought of the smaller version and big enough to carry at least 2 people.
But one concept of which I have not yet drawn or written on paper is a perpetual machine with water. But I'm not going to divulge my secret on the internet. Ever.
You can go ahead and divulge it, it won't actually work. Water isn't magic.
Так вроде у Бойля стеклянный сосуд был ( если не путаю) , и конусность плавно поднималась в вверх , в чем и был секрет .( Я в курсе о сообщающихся сосудах ) .фокус был в раствореном в жидкости газе который и был топливом ( вариант примитивного эрлифа ) ,цвет и вязкость жидкости подбирались с целью скрыть пузырьки поднимающихся газов .( По газу , варианты азот , водород ) .
Могу ошибаться.
This only work with liquids of high surface tension. They don't create much energy. the surface tension creates a rise in the liquid on a small diameter.
It might work also with soap water if you add airpipe into the other pipe so soap can make bubbles. You have to try.
Water having greater density you wouldn't be able to do this... now since this liquid is less denser the force of gravity plus water pressure from falling and slightly builds that pressure for it to be possible to cycle mechanically free with using a hand pump or an electrical pump.
But really cool and not fish friendly...
We can use them in wash basins, just put a filter in between and then put the setup
It will save much water
It’s Impossible because where is the force to push the water all the way up the tub coming from and it is no being pushed up by other water unless it’s able to bend the laws of Physics and gravity look at Einsteins relativity theory.
Vues xxxx dollars youtube !!!!
I spent 3 minutes and 50 seconds watching the video and then spent 30 minutes reading the comments 🤣
I would point out that even if this worked, eventually the water would evaporate so it wouldn't be truly perpetual motion.
Отличный фокус.И главное , что физика и её законы торжествуют.
Man is some how breaking one of the laws of physics. The fricken law of thermodynamics
как мы любим быть обманутыми....
ага
Fact: Using the word “machine” with perpetual motion or energy, will give it a beginning
and an end, making it finite. With this new and better understanding of perpetual devices, its meaning will need
updating in defining it as finite. This way, these devices or machines will not violate the laws of thermodynamics,
laws of nature, laws of physics, makes them patentable. ~Guadalupe Guerra
If this is a trick, i will demolish the Robert Boyle statue .
Realmente no aprecian el truco ? .. Realmente creen en el ? El mismo video muestra cual es el truco !!! ...
A drawing please.
I’m too old now , but I would love for my grandkids to make this as a science project.
Is it a trick? I don’t know.
Whatever it is, it’s very interesting.
Thanks.
Красавчик, что показал как работает лохотрон!
Very well explained. You are Great. Many people will think that the device actually work but you say that there is a trick to deceive them.
nice bro.. not that easy😉👌
I don't really get it. Can't you just suck the water at the end, so it starts pouring, while you still pour water in at the other side. If the device, inclusive the way the water needs from the "end" to the "beginning", is completely filled why would it stop pouring?
A siphon hose fails the second that the exit stream is higher than the supply end of the hose. You can't siphon uphill. A liquid in a U-shaped hose will always be the same height as long as it is open to the air on both ends. You can actually make a very accurate level called a "water level" out of a long, clear hose containing a liquid. That's how you can check if a 100' wide building is level on each end if you don't have a laser level.
Como podría calcular la entropía de entrada y salida del flujo,de esto
Как дела
Thanks
The water will never go above the lever of the canister if you use regular water. This can be done only with a special luqiud.
At 0:21 we see the liquid start on right just 0.5 second before falling at left !!!!
this might be possible since it is using the force of gravity, maybe you could make a machine that "steals" from gravity which still obeys conservation of energy law. laws can be broken too right?
Theories yes, Laws no.
Colonel Bastian Thanks for watching and for your comment.
It's absolutely impossible that water in the hose gets higher than in the bottle. This would mean that atmospheric pressure would be lower in the hose than 15cm on the left. Nonsense.
If you watched all the video you would clearly see where he brought the hose through the the 5th dimension where atmospheric pressure is actually lower than Earth's, thus lowering the atmospheric pressure in the hose thus the higher atmospheric pressure of Earth is able to push the water through the lower atmospheric pressure of the hose 🤷🏻♂️ so I'm sorry but you're completely wrong
Поправка.В жидкости давление не передается во всех направлениях-в верх не передается.
It could work without a trick. The weight of the water would push the water ahead of it up the tube. It would need to be enclosed to prevent evaporation, but there might be a problem with fog, which wouldn't prevent it from working, but it would ruin the spectatorship, but could be used for hydroelectricity.
Gravity is the fuel. If we switch it to a magnetic fluid , and add some coils to generate additional forces. The output might me bigger.
very nice
Is that actually free energy
Like can we use this energy to light light bulb?
bro, you need to pin a comment with the time stamp, just browsing through this vids comment section is a bit annoying since people dont watch the entire thing
Wow free energy! That's awesome
Законы физики ни кто не отменял о сообщающихся сосудах вода всегда будет находиться на одном уровне есть в продаже водяной строительный уровень, а так фокус прикольный не сразу догадаешся что в соединении трубки и крышки бутылки замаскирована электро-микропомпа😊☝
What ive never seen been tried before is the same thing but the tube is connected higher up and its way shorter, with this liquid that should work? Idk someone should try it
it is plus able and needs a little bit more to work. think about your toilet flush mechanism , the plastic ball creates pressure generating force. . it will work with a bit more ingenuity.
L'eau dans le tuyau ne peut pas dépasser le niveau de la bouteille ( Principe des vases communicants ! )
C'est expliqué
Voilà Comment se faire des vues et des dollars par youtube !
I love this idea 😍😍 soo much 😍
Закон физики ещё никто не отменял, а остальное попытка его нае...ть
вообще то колбОчка ударение на второй слог а не колбАчка колбаска
Ну начнём с того, что вода испаряется и нет вечного движения, одной и той же воды!
what if instead of using an open container, you use an air tight one? does the water still flow?
Just tried this with no luck unfortunately it creates suction but not enough to not enough to bring the water back into the bottle
Its impossible because its eastier for gravity to create vacuum than push water up
So how much more weight would be needed, to add the pressure needed?
if you want to improve this modal with continues function then use clothes cotton fabric, foam, any capillarity action giving materials so we have endless supply of energy but when water goes evaporated then we put more water, it works better near a hydroelectricity dam
All waste of time sharmaji, pokhat mei tho ek pattha bhee nahi hilega !! Energy can not be created whatever the efforts we put. Energy can be transformed from a potential source to a more useful format. This is the universal truth valid eternally.. ..
@@ravikumarvitthala2950 if you are with me then it's become possible how you can put your efforts in this technology, are you doing something scientific
Ferro Fluid instead of water... Copper cable wrapped around plastic tube... :)
nice
Interesting that the GOG would decide for you what can and can't work. Censorship is suspiciously interesting.
Ловкость рук и никакого мошенничества
Не насосик, а ещё одна бутылка выше этой конструкции, шланг скрыл рукой. В конце видео секрет раскрылся
Nice super fluid
You are transferring energy sources here. Gravitational to kinetic. Perpetual is impossible. Utilizing gravity is not the same thing since it is an energy force that is constant. This wouldn't work in a vacuum tube I'm sure.
Not possible, the
principle of communicating vessels is not evaded and any Perpetual Motion is possible by phisics..
Now put a water wheel with generator.
Guided Hand still not perpetual motion cause the water will evaporate
Add a solid lid to where the water come down.
It would be perpetual if the liquid element was a light oil with low evaporating properties, maybe in a a sealed environment to reduce dust and foreign inpurities. Then add a mechanism WTH the capacity to generate electricity. This ancient technology is part of the solution to our energy problem in the future. Many have doubt do to it's simplicity. Many of our today's problem remain unsolved or approached due to our simple kindness and laziness. We should have paid more attention in elementary school.
@@monta247 it violates law of thermodynamics you cannot get more output of energy than what the input of energy so no perpetual machine is just useful to study but it has no practical uses for generating power because it uses as much as energy is supplied in moving the machine
Kendrick historian poet
There are many laws of physics, the basis in which all theories are hypothesized ,but one must consider and be mindful of that we do not know everything and all that we have tried and attempted has not be approached by the best strategy or methods. The laws of gravity states that water flows in a downward motion/pattern. Yet in this world there are at least two known rivers that flow in the opposite direction, wouldn't this be consider backwards, is this a anomaly that goes against the the laws of physics or what's. Remember it is not man made or reconfigured.out side of interest and value ,why would men kill,steal and lie. Would the laws of also apply, whereby the energy employed would result in a wasted response.
Now consider charity/love. Once invested/applied the interest is greater than than the invested sum . LaMonte Kendrick
0:42 There is no trick and there is no deception.
So easy to fool laypeople. This is not possible and any xray would show the components underneath. Please learn basic physics, then go to 1:27
систему сообщающихся сосудов никто не учил в школе?
по ходу это для них темный лес...
Попробуйте воспроизвести.
😂😂😂🤝
Народ хочет быть обманутым. Или, перефразируя "героя 90х", -ПИПЛ СХАВАЕТ.
bonito, pero no hay explicación del proyecto.
Véalo hasta el final para comentar.
You forgot to consider another element in this system... Where the hell is your AIR PRESSURE!!!
🤣😜😆🤪😂
No wonder your device did not work that you need to resort to a trick.
I'm wondering if you thought of using a progressive rise in the tubing ,as in just over level tubing, until the top where you want gravity to be strongest. Spring riser tubing , precharged with liquid then ....
No different
По этому принципу я так понял основана работа водонапорных башен Рожновского.
Это фокус, проще говоря обман
il n'existe pas de machine à mouvement perpétuel (principe de conservation de l'énergie )
Exato (1:27)
Vues xxxx et dollars sur TH-cam !
This music is aweome
Free energy exists!
it works with carbonated stuff too.. till the carbonation is gone.. but technically it could in a pressurised enviroment :0o
Very cleverly explained illusion.
Well done dude
До последнего был уверен что в пробке насос.
Love this trick (and thanks for showing people it cant work, thumbs up!). Now do it without all the wood hiding pumps and batteries or extra tubes ansd I wills ned you a billion dollars lol. Just hold the tubes and bottle while its working and then hand it to someone else. lol
Thanks for watching
Now a attach water mill for power to it. Minus the meter
por efecto capilar podría funcionar.
Lo mismo pensé
Nice edit
Its real
КолбАчка!!! Кто ж тебя учил? Пришел бы и поклонился в пояс учителю русского и литературы. Ведь она (он) открыла новое направление в родном языке, в том числе такой самородок как ТЫ!😆👍
Это на белорусском.
Que líquido está sendo usado. Com certeza não é água.
..вероятно, что когда произойдёт полное смешение, это остановится:)
Ага,когда вода в бутылке не стене закончится. Ролик внимательно просмотри!
te doy tu meresido like gracias ya lo conosia pero te lo dejo por demostrar a la gente lo que es y como funciona
pero si te estan mostrando que es falso !!!!
Thanks. (Teşekkürler).
Hello! this project can use in aquarium for oxygenated the water to the fishes ??? Have some possibility do this to work in the oxygenation of an aquarium with electric energy.
Why doesn’t the device actually work?
Because energie can't be
produced
so even with enough water pressure this would never work?
It would lose the momentum
Unless you had a perpetual motion machine to power the perpetual motion pump
yo estoy asiendo un generador con agua estoy muy serca de lograrlo el agua la pude controlar para que ande sola pero tengo problemas con el systema de electricidad no soy muy ingenioso en eso
да повторив это в крупном масштабе можно и тубинку для электричества дешевого крутить
Спасибо за просмотр и комментарий
На одном уровне должно быть
good one !!
My mother-in-law keeps annoying me! This is a perpetual movement.
So what is the whole point?
Well if it worked for real than the human race would probably be able to survive for infinity. We would never go extinct, except we probably would because in an infinite amount of time everything an anything that could break the machine would probably happen
nice background music.
How to hide a pump part 6.
why used hand to help gravity
not possible as water evaporates
What if we put the pipe from which the water is existing into the funnel ? Can it work then?
No
@@simonkoeman3310 explain
@@kiwuuspurr1927 Entropy
Pipe kaha se laye
Add in a Turbine and you discovered endless renewable energy
quel dommage de ne pas avoir une vue d'ensemble du système ,mais bon ça se comprend la pompe qui apporte l'eau n'as rien de perpétuel ;-) ...
finally the energy probs of germany can be solved