She didn’t even ‘hear’ you play. Cloud is explaining all of this backstory verbally. His description of his own playing must have been so bad that Aerith spit in disgust at him.
Yes after he saw cloud go thick and thin for them in midgar, he started trusting him. Especially aeris saving Marlene bit. It's mostly after Cosmo canyon and Golden saucer past, Barrett chills out and let out why he acts the way he does. In the original he does approve of many actions if cloud chooses them. Later on when cloud is gone for a little bit the team really respects him as a leader, telling him how hard it is being leader, remembering all materials and who has what.
especially if you try to go through Tifa's stuff and say "actually no JK" he's like "come on cloud I know you're better than that", it's just like I'm sorry dad
@@crimsoncrusader4829 I don’t see it ironic. Even I don’t understand people’s fascination over Tifa. Aerith is obviously the fun and adventurous type. She has no problem getting Cloud wearing a dress and for many of us gamers, Wall Market will always be the funnest part of the game. People see Tifa as the waifu and I can accept that but again, her being the exciting one? Erm okay whatever.
@Noplayster13 Right? It's not like that actually saw how bad he was, and he could've just explained "ehh, it wasn't very good, I just hit a few notes and left"
I love that the rest of the party is actually reacting to Cloud telling them about his performance instead of actually listening to it. It means that when Cloud does badly he decides to be honest about it and that disgusts the rest of them.
I didn't even play the sheet the first time. I played the main theme and got the praise result. then I sat down again and played the sheet. XD so you can get them to praise you just playing the main theme. In the OG you got a little easter egg when playing the main theme ( cloud mentioning how he used to play this melody alot when he was younger) and if you play a lot , you found Tifa's savings; which I think was just 1 Gil or something.
@@Truelemonheadthat doesn't answer the question tho. The commenter didn't ask how they know he played the piano, he said how would they know HOW he played the piano, as in how would they know how well he did
Cloud: Then I played the piano and I was really good. Everyone: Wow!!! Cloud: Then I played the piano and I was really bad.. Everyone: Ughhh, pathetic....
Cloud's brutally honest. We can consider that if the player played well enough he'd answer something like 'i play a little piano, so i fooled around'. But if the player plays bad, id imagine he'd just be like 'i played piano, but all i made was a few horrendous noises'. After all, it's not his place. So with some context of how he might have answered, their reactions make sense. We gotta remember his actions are more less him 'explaining' how things went.
@@SnowHoof000 I think I got B rank first try then tried again and got A. Never left the piano between tries. Was honestly blown away with how detailed it was and spent 10 minutes just messing with it.
Cloud (excitedly): “And then I played the piano and was all like: do do do do di di di di, bumbdida bumbdida bumbdida bum, pikow! Zing! Zonk!” The rest of the cast: “I’m glad I wasn’t there…”
That's impressive. It's pretty tough due to the delay in getting the joystick to the side, as well as the analogue-ness of it all, but I haven't had any issues with wrong notes due to the direction not being correct
Watched this just after starting my first playthrough in Rebirth and playing the Piano in chapter 1. Through experimentation, I found and played the notes of the 'song' from the original game. I got the good piano reaction. 😊🎶
Took me about 10 tries to get A. Took me about 20 tries to get the star. You have to get perfect score for an star. It may help some people to turn the volume all the way down and just memorize the patterns instead
Didn't know you could get a bad score from the party in this scene, seeing as you don't even have any songs by this point in the game. Wonder how they rate this stuff, because all I did was spend a minute or two trying to figure out how to play Tifa's theme before moving on.
But this is Cloud just describing himself as really good or bad. Even if it really happened, it's him telling a story about how awesome or awful he was. The party just takes his word for it.
@@Ga-Bo-Ot Cloud: “And then I talked to the one lady and ate four whole sandwiches!” Barret: “Can we… focus on Sephiroth, or the incident, or ANYTHING relevant?”
Me: *Literally plays a bunch of random notes in the attempt to hash something together with minimal effort* Tifa and the gang: *Praises my efforts* Me: 1. I might’ve played the violin about 10 years ago, but I’m definitely no musician. 2. How the hell do you retell playing an instrument and get genuine feedback? It’s not like you were there to actually hear it.
Thought it was funny that this dialogue isnt in the full game, tifas song isnt there so your only choice is to mash on the keys and get told off by your squad 😂
I think it's more like.. "CLOUD WHY TF YOU IN MY ROOM. AND YOU PLAYED MY PIANO". but you are actually pretty good wow. As to "CLOUD WHY TF YOU IN MY ROOM. AND YOU PLAYED MY PIANO" and you even suck too... WHY! HOW DARE YOU. 😂
How would they know if you were any good at the piano though. As much as I hate aerith it's nice that they gave her an actual personality rather than what she had in ff7
Cloud (excitedly): “And then I played the piano and was all like: do do do do di di di di, bumbdida bumbdida bumbdida bum, pikow! Zing! Zonk!” The rest of the cast: “I’m glad I wasn’t there…”
“Very supportive guys, thanks.”
Cloud, probably.
That actually sounds like something he'd say
😂😂
“Nailed it, I know, thanks, moving on.”
you know you are doing it bad when even the incarnation of the phrase "see the glass half full" goes "Ugh" after hearing you play.
She didn’t even ‘hear’ you play. Cloud is explaining all of this backstory verbally. His description of his own playing must have been so bad that Aerith spit in disgust at him.
how did they even hear, he was telling a flash back lmao
At this point Barret has softened down on Cloud a lot. Wow what an improvement!
I'm surprised he's the most polite
Nanaki is probably the kindest of the group.
Yes after he saw cloud go thick and thin for them in midgar, he started trusting him. Especially aeris saving Marlene bit.
It's mostly after Cosmo canyon and Golden saucer past, Barrett chills out and let out why he acts the way he does.
In the original he does approve of many actions if cloud chooses them.
Later on when cloud is gone for a little bit the team really respects him as a leader, telling him how hard it is being leader, remembering all materials and who has what.
@@TehReasoning not really agreeing with last part he literally says why are we even doing this for this guy he brings a lot of trouble and shit
especially if you try to go through Tifa's stuff and say "actually no JK" he's like "come on cloud I know you're better than that", it's just like I'm sorry dad
i feel like the good one seems more canon, Cloud is not someone who would play piano in front of people if he wasn't actually good at it
That "Ugh" from Aerith is pure disgust and disappointment.
Don't worry, she'll stop whinning... Eventually.
@@ghostknight2011 If only we didn’t have to suffer through more boring ass scenes with Tifa.
@@ghostknight2011I have a lot to worry. If there is no more Aerith then we are stuck with scenes with Tifa. Boring as heck.
@ReikoTheGamer pretty ironic now aerith is considered the exciting one and tifa the boring one
@@crimsoncrusader4829 I don’t see it ironic. Even I don’t understand people’s fascination over Tifa. Aerith is obviously the fun and adventurous type. She has no problem getting Cloud wearing a dress and for many of us gamers, Wall Market will always be the funnest part of the game. People see Tifa as the waifu and I can accept that but again, her being the exciting one? Erm okay whatever.
barret at least tried to soften the blow, while the girls just grilled him.. specially aerith, she almost sounded disgusted 🤣
They were probably still upset with cloud after he admitted going through Tifa’s bras and panties. 😹
So, was Cloud just going "Dooo do do do doo do do do" while describing how he played the piano to his friends during this segment?
that's a good question😂 gotta love videogames😂❤
Was that Saria's Song?
It would be funny if while in Midgard Cloud actually took lessons because he knew Tifa played and that is how he is actually good at Piano
Video game logic.
Maybe he just using piano in kalm inn and reenact it during his story
I suddenly don't feel so bad about snooping through Tifa's stuff
I was expecting something like "don't worry, you'lle get better" not they literally going "wtf where you even thinking!?", "KYS" 😂😂😂
LOL! The girls are pure savage! 😂
I like that Cloud is just verbally explaining that he played poorly and the girls still pile onto him for touching the piano.
@Noplayster13 Right? It's not like that actually saw how bad he was, and he could've just explained "ehh, it wasn't very good, I just hit a few notes and left"
Agreed! Surprisingly, Barret's comment was actually the nicest lol.
At least they didn't call him an asshole again
people sure do throw words around till they no longer have any meaning of effect
I love that the rest of the party is actually reacting to Cloud telling them about his performance instead of actually listening to it. It means that when Cloud does badly he decides to be honest about it and that disgusts the rest of them.
Ha, yeah, I was thinking the same thing, he must have been *really* eloquent about how much he sucked :P
John Bentley said the exact same thing at the Anime Expo lmao. "Don't quit your day job"
"Ugh... What were you even thinking?"
_proceeds to play One-Winged Angel to absolute perfection without without breaking eye contact with her_
We'll just pretend that the bad piano play was Sephiroth messing with him.
That's weird. I don't think I even managed to get to the lowest rating and got the good reaction. This minigame is pretty tough to play.
I could not wrap my head around it at all... got 5000 points and STILL the good ending
*bad piano playing*
cloud: hey, these hands are made to swing swords alright
I didn't even play the sheet the first time. I played the main theme and got the praise result. then I sat down again and played the sheet. XD so you can get them to praise you just playing the main theme. In the OG you got a little easter egg when playing the main theme ( cloud mentioning how he used to play this melody alot when he was younger) and if you play a lot , you found Tifa's savings; which I think was just 1 Gil or something.
How would they even know how Cloud played the piano?
@@Truelemonheadthat doesn't answer the question tho. The commenter didn't ask how they know he played the piano, he said how would they know HOW he played the piano, as in how would they know how well he did
@@Neptune_171he could describe the melody. Knocking on the walls around him
Cloud: Then I played the piano and I was really good.
Everyone: Wow!!!
Cloud: Then I played the piano and I was really bad..
Everyone: Ughhh, pathetic....
Cloud's brutally honest. We can consider that if the player played well enough he'd answer something like 'i play a little piano, so i fooled around'. But if the player plays bad, id imagine he'd just be like 'i played piano, but all i made was a few horrendous noises'. After all, it's not his place. So with some context of how he might have answered, their reactions make sense. We gotta remember his actions are more less him 'explaining' how things went.
@@cipangorenglol
I didn’t even know there was a “bad” option 😂 That’s fantastic.
you nailed it first try?
@@SnowHoof000 I think I got B rank first try then tried again and got A. Never left the piano between tries. Was honestly blown away with how detailed it was and spent 10 minutes just messing with it.
I Wonder how clouds story telling conveyed his piano skills
Cloud (excitedly): “And then I played the piano and was all like: do do do do di di di di, bumbdida bumbdida bumbdida bum, pikow! Zing! Zonk!”
The rest of the cast: “I’m glad I wasn’t there…”
The, "Ugh," was personal.
Video's Title: Aerith and Tifa's reaction.
Barret: Am I a joke to you?
“Don’t quit your day job.” I died 😂
"I just jammed on it."
I suddenly don’t regret searching Tifas cupboard for that Orthapedic Underwear
Cloud treats the piano with such respect. I salute him. o7 Also the music playing immediately afterwards in piano is perfect.
Wow, the girls were harsh. Good thing I'm decent at rhythm games, I got a perfect score on my 4th try.
I got a perfect score on my first try, so there!!!
I am what they called Tonedeaf. So I'm not as skill as you are. 😂
That's impressive. It's pretty tough due to the delay in getting the joystick to the side, as well as the analogue-ness of it all, but I haven't had any issues with wrong notes due to the direction not being correct
@@christaggart5687 Hey same! Although I do play instruments so I am used to keeping time.
Do you play any Project Sekai? Looking for a friend here
I feel like the piano is going to make me cry because I must have that good score.
I was horrible and they give me positive reaction.
Must've been better than you thought
The girls went in on him if he sucks. 😂
how do they even know what he sounds like from the flashback
This seems like a throwback to ffv with the piano playing
Tifa also called me an asshole for looking for her orthopaedic underwear
I got the "good" reaction from just banging on random notes for a couple of minutes
The worst thing she could say is no:
Aerith: Ugh.
Brother ugh...what's that
I can just imagine cloud in kalm trying to mimic the notes to them
Did Cloud really need that in the story?
"Yeah, I tried playing the piano and I was complete chocobo-shit at it. Anyway..."
I feel bad for Cloud in the bad reactions.
How is same music so wholesome and so depressing at the same time?
Watched this just after starting my first playthrough in Rebirth and playing the Piano in chapter 1. Through experimentation, I found and played the notes of the 'song' from the original game. I got the good piano reaction. 😊🎶
Sharps at the lowest tone: C,D,E,B,A,C,D,E,G,F,C,D,C.
You're welcome!
Their disappointment is just like when they discovered you have a small wee wee
How bad do you have to be to get the bad response? Because I made one attempt, and didn't do well at all. But they were all impressed.
Wait how? All I did was twinkle twinkle little star and messed around and they were like wooaaa O:
leaving my guy barret out of the title is wild
How did i know Barret was gonna say "Don't quit your day job."? 🤣
"Don't quit your day job."
Terrorism?
Damn, even Aerith is roasting Cloud! It must have been REALLY bad if even the pure-hearted flower girl is giving you flak.
yeah she’s the most supportive of cloud even when he’s even bad dancer damm must that bad if she’s Angry at cloud
@@badreedinebedroAerith is the most cruel and evil character in FF7😢Roasted Cloud Like that so Horrible
Took me about 10 tries to get A. Took me about 20 tries to get the star. You have to get perfect score for an star.
It may help some people to turn the volume all the way down and just memorize the patterns instead
Man I feel like playing a rhythm game with no sound would be harder.
Nah for me having the song memorized and going based off the music makes it way easier
I had to do the same thing with the pullup/squats in Remake. Had to eliminate all sounds except a sound it made during the minigame to stay in rhythm.
How did they even hear it? 😂
I didn't know they could react negatively
Tbh, no idea what triggers the good piano playing vs the bad. I just got the good piano playing dialogue for some reason.
Didn’t know Cloud was playing for ghosts
Didn't know you could get a bad score from the party in this scene, seeing as you don't even have any songs by this point in the game. Wonder how they rate this stuff, because all I did was spend a minute or two trying to figure out how to play Tifa's theme before moving on.
But this is Cloud just describing himself as really good or bad. Even if it really happened, it's him telling a story about how awesome or awful he was. The party just takes his word for it.
lol I just smashed the keys randomly and they acted like it was great. I wonder what the trigger for the 2 different reactions is
I played badly yet they still complimented me lol
damn. they went right for the jugular there didn't they.
wait what i tried to do bad playing but they were just amazed how good i was with my 0 points and tons of missing while only couple hit :D
Beret's good job is funny
Where is the rest of them? They aren't even in the same room together?
Why the girls ara so harsh, lol, and why they know, how he played?😂
This like cloud tell he good or bad to them. And cloud will tell everythink we did in this flash back.
@@Ga-Bo-Ot Cloud: “And then I talked to the one lady and ate four whole sandwiches!”
Barret: “Can we… focus on Sephiroth, or the incident, or ANYTHING relevant?”
Good question. Where DID Cloud learn to play like that? Maybe his mom sent him to music class or something...
Glowing praise to blunt insult (is insult the right word?)
Was there any yellow paint conspicuously pointing towards the piano? Or did you have to painstakingly figure out how to get there on your own?
It's just in tifas room in her house. And what's your problem?
@@yendothegamer9880 What…?
Where’s the secret item from playing a secret song?
wait. I got the GOOD ending!? I thought I was terrible at the Piano minigame! How BAD do you have to PLAY!?
Took me at least thirty tries to perfect that! Not looking forward to the other ones! Hope there’s no trophy for perfecting all of them.
Oh there's going too, also in the OG if you do the piano and hit a requirement you will get Tifas final weapon in the game later
@@yendothegamer9880 yea I know, just hope they all aren’t so difficult
Unknown what happens when ex soldiers from crisis core and advent children reacts this.
i was basically just slamming keys and the game deemed it as good piano playing lmao
Me: *Literally plays a bunch of random notes in the attempt to hash something together with minimal effort*
Tifa and the gang: *Praises my efforts*
Me: 1. I might’ve played the violin about 10 years ago, but I’m definitely no musician. 2. How the hell do you retell playing an instrument and get genuine feedback? It’s not like you were there to actually hear it.
I Litrally just did random buttons and they liked it
Thought it was funny that this dialogue isnt in the full game, tifas song isnt there so your only choice is to mash on the keys and get told off by your squad 😂
what rank do you need to get a bad reaction?
I got the good response, but I'm a musician.
Where are these voices coming from
I wonder how long it'll be until Never Gonna Give You Up gets played on this piano 😂😂😂?
If my love interest said that to me they would no longer be my love interest lmaoo 💀💀
Okay, how bad do you have to be for getting the bad reaction?^^
I played very, VERY bad and still got the good one.
the bad part.... emotional damage
Aerith, Tifa & BARRET
Don't forget Barret 😐
Wait I played Mary had a little lamb and got the good reaction
Is this in Tifa's room?
I was wondering if you could get a bad reaction from them lol
Aerith's reaction just makes me wanna do better at life, she was so utterly dissapointed.
I think it's more like.. "CLOUD WHY TF YOU IN MY ROOM. AND YOU PLAYED MY PIANO". but you are actually pretty good wow. As to "CLOUD WHY TF YOU IN MY ROOM. AND YOU PLAYED MY PIANO" and you even suck too... WHY! HOW DARE YOU. 😂
I played the opening of Bring Me to Life by Evanescence. And I got the good reaction.
Good thing you only need a C to be considered a good pianist.
XD
Well dang
How would they know if you were any good at the piano though. As much as I hate aerith it's nice that they gave her an actual personality rather than what she had in ff7
What is there to hate abt Aerith??
Why is Barret not mention on the video's name?
Barret is considered a 2nd tier waifu… which is a disgrace. Man’s a big teddy bear.
Barrets the reaction thag natters the most
Thanks sony, your highly advanced controller from the year 2077 of which i have 4 of all have stick drift. Cant play this because of that.
Aerith Disapproves
Dunno how but I got the good when I played
Aerith got the ick
Why was barret the nicest one? 😂
Cloud (excitedly): “And then I played the piano and was all like: do do do do di di di di, bumbdida bumbdida bumbdida bum, pikow! Zing! Zonk!”
The rest of the cast: “I’m glad I wasn’t there…”
So fucking mean lol
and Barret
Not enough people recognize Barret as the 1st class waifu that he is. Bestgirl.
Barrett erasure