I do wish Trinity would have won the AS4 makeover but let’s be serious for two seconds, she was never beating Naomi in this lip sync, Manila was doomed to go home.
Cheryl Hole was exactly who I had in mind when I saw this video. It was the biggest robbery during a makeover challenge, but production just wasn’t going to send her into the finale with one win.
Trinity the Tuck mentioned on Sibling Watchery that the AS4 makeover challenge included a Judy Garland lip sync with their partner. She says that’s the reason Monet was in the top, but I do wonder why they chose to remove that segment if it seemed to be important to the judging
they did show it, just partially. The same performance aspect was added to many other make overs, like season 5, 8, AS9, etc. They pick and choose when to count it or not.
06:15. That is not a butterfly effect. That's a domino effect. A butterfly effect is when the evets are completely not related with each other, but somehow end up affecting each other. In this case, Manilla winning the season would be in a direct corelation with her not being sent home that epiosde.
I agree with all of these - great video! Sidenote, I love your style of videos. They are not "in your face", dramatic, and overstimulating. I so so so appreciate that. Keep it up and thank you thank you thank you!
Last week I finished season 12 of drag race and I can't believe that Jaida won that challenge, the only thing she did was wear the same makeup and a similar dress, there was no concept. Crytal Methyd deserved that victory, even though they are not similar, it was very original and had the best concept. It seemed like something out of Sesame Street or the Muppets. Probably one of the biggest robberies in herstory. 😭😭😭
The judges explained this on the show. It’s not JUST because jaida beat jazz’s face down. She paired the partners perfectly and gave herself the hardest challenge. Essentially she was the reason s12 makeover challenge is one of the most beloved
Pandora would’ve won snatch game nowadays due to her runway being better, it’s just that Tatianna BECAME Britney AND she was funny. Probably the best snatch game of all time tbh
at the season 15 makeover challenge i think Loosey should've been safe or high(?) I guess because the makeup was on point and the dress was ok too and Luxx still being in the bottom because i did not see the resemblance at all with her and her partner's outfit and i think at the bottom replaced by Mistress or Sasha. edit: If the producers didn't want Loosey to advance to the Top 4 they should've eliminated her early or before the makeover challenge.
Is the easiest challenge to rig, that’s why the put it by the end, so they can send home someone they don’t want in the show anymore. In s15, they could create a case for every single one of them to put in the btm, even Anetra.
I’m thinking Mistress in the bottom since Sasha’s makeover feels very her. Like, the hawaiian vibe, the ponytail, the body shape, it very much feels like a Sasha Colby look. I love Mistress but her makeover was the definition of generic.
The judging on all stars 9 is so messy and just all over the place. Like they didnt give plastique a very deserved win, but then she gets several badges later on or challenges where someone else definitely couldve won. And then shannel- dont get me started on what they did to shannel. It really just seems like they're giving wins out and not thinking of the storylines that much. Like i cant tell if they want plastique to win or not.
Honestly who I was sad not seeing winning is Q. I think it was far the most unique but you could still see the resemblance. (Kinda like at Crystal's case) And I thaught they slayed the second part of the challenge too. Yeah...Plane've done a good job too but it was kinda giving me Sugar & Spice...
I just watched All Stars 1 cuz I've been getting into Drag, and let me tell you YOU ARE SO RIGHT. OBJECTIVELY RAVEN AND JUJU BEE SHOULD OF BEEN ELIMINATED THE WOMAN THEY "MADE OVER" WASN'T EVEN IN DRAG MAKEUP BECAUSE SHE WOULDN'T LET THEM DO IT TO HER. AWFUL HOW THEY TREATED YARLEXIS
I don't think other than exactly S8's Drag Makeover of the Little Women of LA have we actually had a Makeover Challenge where there wasn't production riggory.
I still can’t believe Cheryl hole sent blu home, especially considering that in UK vs the world s2 Cheryl home went home (2nd or 3rd I believe) after being in the bottom consistently, and blu went on to be in the top consistently and eventually win the season. Blu hydrangea earned her win so, SO rightfully. There are certainly winning queens who are much more iconic than her, yknow, but I think she doesn’t get enough appreciation, mainly because not nearly as many people watch the UK vs the world version. It’s just kind of random and doesn’t get much fan attention. But I think it should. It was really a great season and blu’s snatch game on that season was one of the funniest I’ve ever watched, along with Baga’s snatch game AND juju’s Cher. Juju’s Cher, admittedly, wasn’t the best, but I can not begin to express just how hard I laughed at “chercuterie”.
Season 11: VANJIE definitely should have won the makeover challenge. Season 12: CRYSTAL won the makeover, JACKIE won the standup comedy challenge (if she was still there) but if not then give it to CRYSTAL, and JAIDA won the Vegas Challenge.
I think Crystal said it herself that the prompt of the Standup Comedy Challenge is bringing themselves to the table. I think Crystal knew that Jackie was a serious contender for the win that episode and had the judges fully went that route, the latter would have won. ALTHOUGH I AM ALSO VISUALIZING that we lost Jackie anyway in the makeover episode then we lose Heidi at the Standup Challenge and Sherry at the Vegas Live.
I would like to do an honorable mention to Gala Varo in Drag Race Mexico S1 imo she should have won the make over because not only she made two cohesive looks with her previous outfits , she was the best of them all!!
I would add DeLa on season 6. Her critic was a lame eyeline or something like that while Bianca won using the same silhouette and relying on her personality.
I’m probably going to get hate but I don’t care, I don’t think that Naomi shouldn’t have been in the top 2 for the makeover in All Stars 4, because although it was an amazing transformation, it didn’t read as Naomi’s aesthetic as the only thing that read as Naomi was the long wigs, never did she show that she was inspired by Cher and Sonny Bono.
I do wish Trinity would have won the AS4 makeover but let’s be serious for two seconds, she was never beating Naomi in this lip sync, Manila was doomed to go home.
I honestly producers could rig it in favor of trinity
that part, both Trinity & Naomi would've been both double winners of a makeover challenge
It should have been Monique and trinity on the top 2
Unfortunately Manila made a HUGE miscalculation trying to save Latrice.
@@lulumallowGirl no Naomi had a good concept and fun looks Monique had some hockey pokey campy club drag
Cheryl Hole was exactly who I had in mind when I saw this video. It was the biggest robbery during a makeover challenge, but production just wasn’t going to send her into the finale with one win.
Trinity the Tuck mentioned on Sibling Watchery that the AS4 makeover challenge included a Judy Garland lip sync with their partner. She says that’s the reason Monet was in the top, but I do wonder why they chose to remove that segment if it seemed to be important to the judging
they did show it, just partially. The same performance aspect was added to many other make overs, like season 5, 8, AS9, etc. They pick and choose when to count it or not.
06:15. That is not a butterfly effect. That's a domino effect.
A butterfly effect is when the evets are completely not related with each other, but somehow end up affecting each other. In this case, Manilla winning the season would be in a direct corelation with her not being sent home that epiosde.
thank you i was SO shocked by the AS9 one!!!
SAMEEE
I agree with all of these - great video! Sidenote, I love your style of videos. They are not "in your face", dramatic, and overstimulating. I so so so appreciate that. Keep it up and thank you thank you thank you!
Last week I finished season 12 of drag race and I can't believe that Jaida won that challenge, the only thing she did was wear the same makeup and a similar dress, there was no concept. Crytal Methyd deserved that victory, even though they are not similar, it was very original and had the best concept. It seemed like something out of Sesame Street or the Muppets. Probably one of the biggest robberies in herstory. 😭😭😭
It blows my mind to this day. Same with Vanjie but Brooke and Plastique do look too gorgeous to be real
To be fair Jaida should've won the ball but they really wanted to push Gigi and the other one and their storyline that never saw the light of day
@@joaogouveia2224that part!
The judges explained this on the show. It’s not JUST because jaida beat jazz’s face down. She paired the partners perfectly and gave herself the hardest challenge. Essentially she was the reason s12 makeover challenge is one of the most beloved
@@joaogouveia2224 fr
Pandora would’ve won snatch game nowadays due to her runway being better, it’s just that Tatianna BECAME Britney AND she was funny. Probably the best snatch game of all time tbh
at the season 15 makeover challenge i think Loosey should've been safe or high(?) I guess because the makeup was on point and the dress was ok too and Luxx still being in the bottom because i did not see the resemblance at all with her and her partner's outfit and i think at the bottom replaced by Mistress or Sasha.
edit: If the producers didn't want Loosey to advance to the Top 4 they should've eliminated her early or before the makeover challenge.
Is the easiest challenge to rig, that’s why the put it by the end, so they can send home someone they don’t want in the show anymore. In s15, they could create a case for every single one of them to put in the btm, even Anetra.
I’m thinking Mistress in the bottom since Sasha’s makeover feels very her. Like, the hawaiian vibe, the ponytail, the body shape, it very much feels like a Sasha Colby look. I love Mistress but her makeover was the definition of generic.
@@maximeminassian6002I definitely think s15's makeover follow this order:
1. Loosey
2. Anetra
3. Mistress
4. Sasha
5. Luxx
@@calipeixoto930 agree to disagree I guess 🤷 I think Mistress and Luxx were the clear bottom 2
i’m sorry but loosey’s makeover was so ugly to me 💀
The fact that loosey laduca wasn’t mentioned is criminal
The judging on all stars 9 is so messy and just all over the place. Like they didnt give plastique a very deserved win, but then she gets several badges later on or challenges where someone else definitely couldve won. And then shannel- dont get me started on what they did to shannel. It really just seems like they're giving wins out and not thinking of the storylines that much. Like i cant tell if they want plastique to win or not.
Honestly who I was sad not seeing winning is Q. I think it was far the most unique but you could still see the resemblance. (Kinda like at Crystal's case) And I thaught they slayed the second part of the challenge too. Yeah...Plane've done a good job too but it was kinda giving me Sugar & Spice...
Q got overlooked more than once.
it wasnt even her style
This video is so on point it’s crazy agree with everything. Kudos for yarlexis that’s digging
I just watched All Stars 1 cuz I've been getting into Drag, and let me tell you YOU ARE SO RIGHT. OBJECTIVELY RAVEN AND JUJU BEE SHOULD OF BEEN ELIMINATED THE WOMAN THEY "MADE OVER" WASN'T EVEN IN DRAG MAKEUP BECAUSE SHE WOULDN'T LET THEM DO IT TO HER. AWFUL HOW THEY TREATED YARLEXIS
I don't think other than exactly S8's Drag Makeover of the Little Women of LA have we actually had a Makeover Challenge where there wasn't production riggory.
Vanjie totally should've have won on s11, both looks are so gorgeous!
Mama thanks for re-uploading that. For fixing. 💛
I still can’t believe Cheryl hole sent blu home, especially considering that in UK vs the world s2 Cheryl home went home (2nd or 3rd I believe) after being in the bottom consistently, and blu went on to be in the top consistently and eventually win the season. Blu hydrangea earned her win so, SO rightfully. There are certainly winning queens who are much more iconic than her, yknow, but I think she doesn’t get enough appreciation, mainly because not nearly as many people watch the UK vs the world version. It’s just kind of random and doesn’t get much fan attention. But I think it should. It was really a great season and blu’s snatch game on that season was one of the funniest I’ve ever watched, along with Baga’s snatch game AND juju’s Cher. Juju’s Cher, admittedly, wasn’t the best, but I can not begin to express just how hard I laughed at “chercuterie”.
I've been wanting to watch for a while because I really love Blu's aesthetic! With all those infos, I'm even more excited to see her journey.
Season 11: VANJIE definitely should have won the makeover challenge.
Season 12: CRYSTAL won the makeover, JACKIE won the standup comedy challenge (if she was still there) but if not then give it to CRYSTAL, and JAIDA won the Vegas Challenge.
meh, crystal 100% had the best standup. Jackie was really smart and did amazing, but nothing can top crystal. but who would wanna top crystal?
I think Crystal said it herself that the prompt of the Standup Comedy Challenge is bringing themselves to the table. I think Crystal knew that Jackie was a serious contender for the win that episode and had the judges fully went that route, the latter would have won.
ALTHOUGH I AM ALSO VISUALIZING that we lost Jackie anyway in the makeover episode then we lose Heidi at the Standup Challenge and Sherry at the Vegas Live.
I would like to do an honorable mention to Gala Varo in Drag Race Mexico S1 imo she should have won the make over because not only she made two cohesive looks with her previous outfits , she was the best of them all!!
I would add DeLa on season 6. Her critic was a lame eyeline or something like that while Bianca won using the same silhouette and relying on her personality.
I'm surprised Jimbo's CDR makeover wasn't brought up...
Litter boxx is the only makeover name i remember ahaha
I actually think Dakota’s is on par with Cheddar’s. It perfectly portrays her drag both on her and her partner, the makeup was spot on.
I love Pandora too, but you have to admit, her runway looks were not hitting, and that's why she didn't go further.
The makeup challange often seems to be off with the winner. I kind of want to see a list of the most deserved makeover wins
6:10 “hey, it could happen”
pffft sure, jan.
Great list. I think you nailed it.
this is the riggory challenge 🥰
You make a good argument.
I kinda think the Judges are too old. They do not have the youth of INTEREST and not minding new things
12:06 I´m sorry but not even on the top of best makeover challenge, it was EXCELLENT but camp can´t beat glamour
The rigged over challenge
The fact that Cheryl Hole had gotten eliminated when she was the best and everyone elses looks were busted.... Hmmmm
So in my opinion roxxxy will be given the all star seasons win so whoever is her partner this season is also going to be in the top/win the episode.
The way Plastique was robbed in the makeover and the rusical is so sad. She could've had 6 wins if the judging was fair 😕
Great video! Couldn’t agree more! Keep spilling the T, babes!
Ok but saying Roxxxy and Vanjie had the worst makeover is insane, they were clearly the second best
I’m probably going to get hate but I don’t care, I don’t think that Naomi shouldn’t have been in the top 2 for the makeover in All Stars 4, because although it was an amazing transformation, it didn’t read as Naomi’s aesthetic as the only thing that read as Naomi was the long wigs, never did she show that she was inspired by Cher and Sonny Bono.
What is the most rigged drag race season
Divina was the worst of the four, really.
Angelique for season 17
I hate this challenge. but I do agree with this list.
I love the make over challenge, but why is the judging so whack?
I thought crystal method DID win. Yeesh
Omg, Vanjie's was super boring.
Sorry but Jaida won that challenge fair and square.
I agree. That lady looked totally different from herself before Jaida got a her hold to her
Calling Roxxxys and Vanjies worst looks of the episode? someone had too much poopers and meth i see
Yeah it was a lovely third place, but last? No way
"too much poopers and meth" trying to not be a basic gay and a local makes y'all say sm weird ass shit 😂😂😂