Nobility: What We've Lost

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ก.ค. 2024
  • In this video I contrast the ancient conception of nobility with the modern view we hold of "the Elite." Throughout, I present contrasting views of traditional nobility, and make the case that many of its features were better for the average person than the elite today. I explain both why the Elite today are so reviled and why nobility of the past are not deserving of this ridicule, and end with a few ways principles of nobility can apply even to our democratic system.
    00:00 Introduction
    00:32 Elaboration
    02:28 The Elite Remain
    04:16 Unaccountability and its Consequences
    05:59 What to do? Rethinking Nobility
    07:00 Knight: Defender or Exploiter?
    08:32 Which Vision is True?
    09:11 Premises to Question
    10:10 Addressing the Premises
    11:34 Questions about Equality
    14:33 What about Democracy?
    15:56 Mythological Meritocracy
    16:52 High-Trust Environments
    18:43 What We've Lost
    19:39 Accountability
    21:27 The Arts
    23:48 The Elite and Uplift
    25:13 The Knight and Responsibility
    27:36 Generational Wealth (and the Boomer Problem)
    29:04 Nobility and Our Intellectuals
    32:59 Wholeness
    34:18 Justifying Nobility
    36:00 Benefits of Explicit Nobility
    36:58 Wrapping Up and Considering Nobility
    39:42 Conclusion
    40:50 Outroduction
    #videoessay #history #monarchy #tradition

ความคิดเห็น • 3

  • @mathieuleroux9912
    @mathieuleroux9912 16 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    I have often wondered why we have such nostalgia and reverence for the old elite, the nobility, compared to today's who seem inspired only by contempt and disdain. I would have expected them all to be hated equally because of their exploitation of those below them in the social pyramid, or seeking to prevent by any means possible from allowing the same people to rise to their level.Your video gives me the best answer to this question. An answer that I could only assume until now.👍
    Thank you for opening my eyes, I would do my best so that as many people as possible know this response that your video offers by seeing it.😉

    • @PennedLionsPen
      @PennedLionsPen  16 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      That means a lot - I know this video is a bit denser than some of my recent content (and less movement/no background music). But I am really proud of the writing - glad you appreciate it! Hope you've seen my recent superhero video already - if not, it's a bit more accessible, communicating things in a more direct way for most people.
      I do wonder how many things go wrong because we don't understand what the word "elite" means - or why our current elites suck. Hopefully we come to a better understanding as time goes on. Again, glad you found my video insightful. As a fairly small channel, nice comments mean a lot!

  • @waltonsmith7210
    @waltonsmith7210 10 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Social security is sustainable with a few adjustments. And its not like we'll ever have to pay the national debt off in one big collection. National debt is not like personal debt.