What he just said is really a deep understanding. The truth is elegant when you find it. It maybe messy & half done when you first arrive at it, but once it is vetted, it has a subtle beauty inside it. We do need to be careful about which ideas we accept. If it is born ugly & does not resolve after working, you probably are chasing an empty idea. Regardless of why you think the universe is, it is a wonderful place. God Bless
Why does Weinberg think the universe is only 10 billion light years across when it is known that the visible universe is 92 billion light years across, 13.8 billion years after the Big Bang.
The extra dimensions of String Theory and the Many Worlds Interpretation could just be future possibilities and opportunities in our one three dimensional Universe of continuous energy exchange or continuous creation. This is possible because positive and negative charge is forming a two dimensional dynamic boundary condition of continuous change or continuous creation. Therefore this theory only needs three dimensions and one variable in the form of the continuum of time.
I know why other universes are not observed. It is because we are too far away from them. Their big bang would not reach us anymore than ours will to them. We are just suspended in time of a small explosion.
Edge or no edge it is all 1 Let's say I am a sloth and I can only move 1 cm a year and I live 2 years. So are all spaces outside my 2 cm diameter separate universe?
Thanks this is an interesting discussion and I’d like to hear more of your thoughts. My opinion is that whatever is outside the universe can’t also be the same universe otherwise it wouldn’t be beyond the edge. Also a Sloth is in the same universe as everything except what is outside the universe beyond the edge...if there is one. But if there is an edge then the universe can’t be infinite as many hypothesize.
Sloth was a bad example. In terms of analogy it gets too messy. My point was scientists are describing multiverses in terms of one universe not able to communicate any way by laws of physics. That still doesn't mean multiple universes in my book. Multiple universes are simply impossible by definition. One might say that's a semantic wordplay. But I think it's basic. There is no scope or any basis of thinking about more than 1 universe. All definitions are just arbitrary restrictions introduced by this or that theoretician
What about the creator of the universe? Do you think the creator does not care for beauty? The creator may be the most beautiful of all. This universe of ours may be a tiny fragment among billions and trillions and quadrillions of other universes!
In the same way that our solar system is one of a nearly countless number of other solar systems in the night sky, and our galaxy one of a countless number of other galaxies, perhaps our universe is just one universe in a night sky full of other universes. If so, then our universe would exist in relation to those other physically existing universes in a common time and space, with those universes effecting our own gravitationally and electromagnetically.
There could be a trillion or infinite number of universe considering that space is infinite in size therefore a trillion universe wll easily fit the unending space.
no, we're essentially babies when it comes to our understanding of said subjects. with time, and the betterment of technology things will start to slowly clear up.
All they want to do is keep the narrative going on and on and on and on and they won't admit or even answer their own Question !They already know hahaha
I propose we develop software to create a virtual being after we discover everything there is to know about nature ( if we make it) and play god with him. Enlighten him, play games with him, put obstacles in his way, and then finally reveal to him he was a simulation.
I smarter than both of them there's 12 dimensions and three Universes, One is just a vacuum , Bridge, and we're still in the BigBang We could still blow up any Moment .or Not ! they won't discover consciousness Because they are to Afraid to go past death or they won't tell.I did.Im Back
easy yes there m0re then 0ne do you think this only happen once ? space has no ending size so this been happening for ever how long is for ever ? think on that dont stroke are brains cant handle it all at once. lets just talk about each star in the milky way they have there own Galaxys that just in are own Universe. wow
when he says he is expecting a beautiful explanation what does he mean?? Doesn't he consider math beautiful?? For many people math is beautiful.. anyway i think his logic is very subjective..
mrkakotube not all maths is beautiful and to be even more specific not all physical theories are beautiful... just bc a physical theory has beautiful mathematics does not mean it will be correct.
Beauty is just a subjective human creation. These physicist just keep repeating ad nauseum this naive philosophical theory of beautiful bla bla borrowed from the Greeks
What a ridiculous topic. What the hell would these multi-universes have as their boundaries definable borders? how can it's boundaries be measured/ calculated?e
Universe is defined as all matter and space. There can’t be multiple universes, they are just calling the universe a multiverse now, but there is still only one universe. What are all the universes inside of? Surely all the universes must be inside a universe. My question now is what is outside the universe that all these universes are supposedly in?
There's seven universe only excit and they are like bon top of each other and the gap distance between them are 500 years journey so and all the seven have earth and they are identical and we are one of these seven...
So what's the Real Question,that never ends On this show , Hahaha Is this the new Miracles of God? No ,but ho about the Miracle of God. Let's See! One one hand the possibility of something. And on the Other hand,A Possibly of Another ? On the other side. Where's the Magic? YOU ,We need each other We're the same on Both sides,Or Can we? This is where you come in hahaha! The question is not were 19 million miles from the Sun .but if not us ho.hahah Remember Two places at Once !
There will be one universe. Why 2, why 5000, why 100000000000000000. 1 universe = everything, so we have nonsense about 2 everything, 5000 everything and 10000000000000000 everything.
@@Drew15000 to a lost soul like you, it's easier to believe in a non-sense religion like yours, namely atheism, than in a very Powerful, Intelligent, Loving and Just Being - sounds like GOD, isn't it, that created everything. Next time, when you even think to start defending atheism - which claims that nothing created everything, do the following experiment: EAT NOTHING for the next 4 ( four ) months and see where that takes you. It takes much more faith to believe in a non-sense religion like yours, atheism, than to believe in God.
@@Drew15000 oofffff, you poor ignorant man! You make me laugh when I realize that you are delusional even without starving! You're such an ignorant that you're not even realisng the fact that you're not talking about the God of the Bible when you-re assuming that these are "his priests". God doesn't have and doesn't need priests anymore. But if you don't read the Bible you have no way of knowing. These are satan's priest. And because you dare to judge the Judge of the Universe, satan is also your father. You are most likely one of these hypocrites that judjes God but is a pro-abortionist, a killer of children, a much worse creature than a rapist. You hypocrit and viper! When are YOU going to do something about it, as we, real Christians do, when we speak against catholics, orthodox, budists, jehovah's witnesses, etc, etc.? You hypocrit and viper! You don't know anything about God's Word, you never read the Bible to understand what he wants from us and yet, you dare to call Him evil. God doesn't allow the rape of children, it's people like you that does it by not taking a stand against it, out of cowardness! You hypocrit and viper!
People who believe in your imaginary little friend yhwh have killed more kids than any abortionist you sick freak! Psalm 137:9 Blessed is whoever smashes your babies skulls against the rocks
@@Drew15000 so you're not a true Christian after all. You're serving Satan as well, like all catholics which at the counsel of nicea modified the Bible and introduced idolatry as well. There was a faction of them at the time that opposed these changes but they were 2 days late for the counsel. And they were late not b/c they were late for the established date of the counsel but b/c your abominable friends, the pro-falsification of the true Gospel group, deceived them by coming 2 days earlier and voting for the changes. All of the above is proven by official documents. All you have to do is to read "The History of Religions" by Mircea Eliade which by the way is translated in over 150 languages and has references to these documents. God did and does not kill anybody. NEVER, EVER! HE IS THE ONLY GOD AND SUPREME JUDGE OF ALL HIS CREATION AND HAS ALL THE RIGHTS TO TAKE ANYBODY HE WANTS AND WHEN HE WANTS, FROM THIS LIFE AND PUT THEM INTO THE ONE THAT THEY DESERVE: HEAVEN OR HELL! SO FAR, YOU'RE GOING TO HELL, YOU HYPOCRIT AND VIPER! YOUR SATANIC catholic church, KILLED IN FACT MANY MORE PEOPLE THAN EVEN hitler DID, YOU HYPOCRIT AND VIPER! Psalm 137: 8 O daughter of Babylon, you devastated one, How blessed will be the one who repays you With the recompense with which you have repaid us. 9 How blessed will be the one who seizes and dashes your little ones Against the rock. ( NASB ) The whole psalm is a lamentation of the Jews after they were taken slaves by the Babylonians. Killing babies, so to cut off bloodlines, was common practice at the time. If you read the whole psalm you should also notice that it came out of the mouth of Jewish people, not from the mouth of GOD. But you, in order to serve your father, satan, and your satanic catholic church, you put these words in the mouth of the HOLLY GOD! AS SUCH, YOU ARE AN ABOMINATION IN HIS EYES! REPENT, REPENT, REPENT AND TRUST IN JESUS CHRIST, YOU WICKED MAN!
That is why it is called a theory. It may or may not be true, but science keeps questioning and had no problem rejecting theories in light of new evidence.
How would nonexistence explode? Why? That sentence told me nothing & implied much. You cannot have nothing spontaneous form matter into being. If that was true, it should constantly happen. There is something that is timeless, spaceless, immaterial, powerful, & without a cause (causality requires time to exist). Thus, it could not be a causeless law that started existence, because the conditions exist & thus it should happen over & over. That is Not our observation. This requires a mind directing the creation of the universe (one with the above traits). There was a choice to act that started the Universe. I would call that God (that is a philosophical statement though). Your claim, does not have anything but blind faith at this time, with a hope we may some day know. You should have said, 'We do not know how the universe was made.'. That is accurate strictly scientifically speaking.
There is no more proof in more than one Universe than there is for the existence of a Creator (God). On the other hand, since I have "Faith" that there is a God, I must believe in Multiple Universes. Otherwise, there wouldn't be separate places for Heaven or Hell. Thus, multiple universes must physically exist.
RIP Dr Weinberg. 🙏🏻❤
Could be he has now discovered the spiritual universe.
What he just said is really a deep understanding. The truth is elegant when you find it. It maybe messy & half done when you first arrive at it, but once it is vetted, it has a subtle beauty inside it. We do need to be careful about which ideas we accept. If it is born ugly & does not resolve after working, you probably are chasing an empty idea. Regardless of why you think the universe is, it is a wonderful place.
God Bless
mackdmara which God do you believe in?
Wildman Samurai
The only God. The God of Christianity. Did you want to talk about that?
Beauty has nothing to do with reality. It's a sad philosophical baivete of physicists who keep.repewting this nonsense borrowed from the Greeks
“Love knows no reason, no boundaries, no distance. It has a sole intention of bringing people together to a time called forever" - Unknown.
Please improve the sound. Great content.
In this Universe, PBS needs to buy a better microphone.
they need a fund drive for mics lol
Down to Earth factual observation... beautiful!
And it seems the statistical theory would not need time in order to be true. I like it.
Why does Weinberg think the universe is only 10 billion light years across when it is known that the visible universe is 92 billion light years across, 13.8 billion years after the Big Bang.
He is lld and senile probably thats why
He said there could be Universes ten billion light years across.
I think if we knew the answers to the universe it wud blow our minds
The mind is the answer to the universe. Not the mind that we know. The mind that we don't.
We couldn’t understand it, it would be like teaching a Rottweiler Chinese.
The extra dimensions of String Theory and the Many Worlds Interpretation could just be future possibilities and opportunities in our one three dimensional Universe of continuous energy exchange or continuous creation. This is possible because positive and negative charge is forming a two dimensional dynamic boundary condition of continuous change or continuous creation. Therefore this theory only needs three dimensions and one variable in the form of the continuum of time.
"how many universes exist?"
Weinberg: "Eleven"
He said how much in this video
th-cam.com/video/oO0QRUX4HGE/w-d-xo.html
Could the quantum field be infinite, even if universe were to be finite?
Can only be finite in appearance. They can't co-exist.
No nothing outside universe
what's the name of these interview series , can anybody tell me that?
Closer to truth.
Universe by definition is 1
I know why other universes are not observed. It is because we are too far away from them. Their big bang would not reach us anymore than ours will to them. We are just suspended in time of a small explosion.
But what is between the edge of one universe and another? What does this edge consist of and if there is no edge then isn’t it all one universe?
@@lordzedd3297, I think what is meant is each universe has its own origin. The edges may or may not overlap.
Edge or no edge it is all 1
Let's say I am a sloth and I can only move 1 cm a year and I live 2 years. So are all spaces outside my 2 cm diameter separate universe?
Thanks this is an interesting discussion and I’d like to hear more of your thoughts. My opinion is that whatever is outside the universe can’t also be the same universe otherwise it wouldn’t be beyond the edge. Also a Sloth is in the same universe as everything except what is outside the universe beyond the edge...if there is one. But if there is an edge then the universe can’t be infinite as many hypothesize.
Sloth was a bad example. In terms of analogy it gets too messy. My point was scientists are describing multiverses in terms of one universe not able to communicate any way by laws of physics. That still doesn't mean multiple universes in my book.
Multiple universes are simply impossible by definition. One might say that's a semantic wordplay. But I think it's basic. There is no scope or any basis of thinking about more than 1 universe. All definitions are just arbitrary restrictions introduced by this or that theoretician
There should be 8 of them.
Try billions
th-cam.com/video/oO0QRUX4HGE/w-d-xo.html
I would say a trillion.
The universe does not recognize beauty nor does it care. Beauty is a human construct.
What about the creator of the universe? Do you think the creator does not care for beauty? The creator may be the most beautiful of all. This universe of ours may be a tiny fragment among billions and trillions and quadrillions of other universes!
There is no creator to care for the concept of beauty
Even so, there is a lot of beauty in the cosmos. Though beauty is a human construct, humans are a part of nature.
In science it just means a theory without random constants that we can not explain.
@@Crazytesseract th-cam.com/video/d-ZtBc0RUHk/w-d-xo.html
Is nothing and a purely empty space one and the same?
Is nothing, mathematically, the same as 0?
Very good questions my friend
Yes. Otherwise it is not truly empty. Of course you can include something ny changing your definition of nothing. But then it means 'nothing'
So.... are we listening to all the universes at one time?
In the same way that our solar system is one of a nearly countless number of other solar systems in the night sky, and our galaxy one of a countless number of other galaxies, perhaps our universe is just one universe in a night sky full of other universes. If so, then our universe would exist in relation to those other physically existing universes in a common time and space, with those universes effecting our own gravitationally and electromagnetically.
There could be a trillion or infinite number of universe considering that space is infinite in size therefore a trillion universe wll easily fit the unending space.
The human mind is just not hard wired to understand and get a grasp of such questions.
no, we're essentially babies when it comes to our understanding of said subjects. with time, and the betterment of technology things will start to slowly clear up.
Don't assume everyone else is as dumb as you.
mattsmiddy40 i dont have to assume shit, when you already make it apparent.
And it’s because of that mind set you never will.
I both agree and do not agree at the same time
If it’s not beautiful it’s not worth the thought❤️
All they want to do is keep the narrative going on and on and on and on and they won't admit or even answer their own Question !They already know hahaha
I propose we develop software to create a virtual being after we discover everything there is to know about nature ( if we make it) and play god with him. Enlighten him, play games with him, put obstacles in his way, and then finally reveal to him he was a simulation.
Or we treat you for symptoms of psychopathic and keep a close monitor on you
@@firstal3799 u ARE in fact a simulation
Mr Weinberg is the most credible scientist that has been interviewed on this channel. Most are crackpots.
I smarter than both of them
there's 12 dimensions and three Universes, One is just a vacuum , Bridge, and we're still in the BigBang We could still blow up any Moment .or Not ! they won't discover consciousness Because they are to Afraid to go past death
or they won't tell.I did.Im Back
55. it was on my physics 101 final exam
9.7 bn. Minimum
easy yes there m0re then 0ne do you think this only happen once ? space has no ending size so this been happening for ever how long is for ever ? think on that dont stroke are brains cant handle it all at once. lets just talk about each star in the milky way they have there own Galaxys that just in are own Universe. wow
The arrogance of individuals who don't even know if they themselves exist will attain to such nonsensical questions as how many universes exist!!
when he says he is expecting a beautiful explanation what does he mean?? Doesn't he consider math beautiful?? For many people math is beautiful.. anyway i think his logic is very subjective..
mrkakotube not all maths is beautiful and to be even more specific not all physical theories are beautiful... just bc a physical theory has beautiful mathematics does not mean it will be correct.
No he just means without random elements that can not be accounted for.
Beauty is just a subjective human creation. These physicist just keep repeating ad nauseum this naive philosophical theory of beautiful bla bla borrowed from the Greeks
What a ridiculous topic.
What the hell would these multi-universes have as their boundaries definable borders? how can it's boundaries be measured/ calculated?e
Yea but where did it all come from. Not supposed to ask that
No beginning no end ...
It didn't come from anywhere. YOU came from somewhere.
No, you can ask it, but we can only suggest answers that relate to what we currently understand from science, otherwise the answer is "I don't know".
How about an almighty God. Oops!
17 maybe 18 there I,ve solved it all.
Seven universes.
Universe is defined as all matter and space. There can’t be multiple universes, they are just calling the universe a multiverse now, but there is still only one universe. What are all the universes inside of? Surely all the universes must be inside a universe. My question now is what is outside the universe that all these universes are supposedly in?
Right. By definition we have 1 universe. They are just philosophical idiots.
Listen to these men discuss multiple universes and recognize this: intelligent people are not always rational.
There's seven universe only excit and they are like bon top of each other and the gap distance between them are 500 years journey so and all the seven have earth and they are identical and we are one of these seven...
WTF r u talking about lmao
So what's the Real Question,that never ends
On this show , Hahaha Is this the new Miracles of God? No ,but ho about the
Miracle of God. Let's See!
One one hand the possibility of something.
And on the Other hand,A Possibly of Another ? On the other side. Where's the Magic? YOU ,We need each other
We're the same on Both sides,Or Can we? This is where you come in hahaha! The question is not were 19 million miles from the Sun .but if not us
ho.hahah Remember Two places at Once !
Bit of a waffle, but multiverses of all possibly imagined types ive believed in for 35 years:)
There will be one universe. Why 2, why 5000, why 100000000000000000.
1 universe = everything, so we have nonsense about 2 everything, 5000 everything and 10000000000000000 everything.
✋🏻🇸🇦
However we define multiverse, a single wave function governs the whole universe.
None. It all in our imagination.
Multi universes=multi gods. Why not?
Mathematical masturbation does not the truth make.
This is pink unicorns 🦄 on rainbows 🌈 ... R.I.P. science.
No you are just a dumbass who can't understand science.
Go read some fairytales about rainbows and unicorns in your little bible
@@Drew15000 to a lost soul like you, it's easier to believe in a non-sense religion like yours, namely atheism, than in a very Powerful, Intelligent, Loving and Just Being - sounds like GOD, isn't it, that created everything. Next time, when you even think to start defending atheism - which claims that nothing created everything, do the following experiment: EAT NOTHING for the next 4 ( four ) months and see where that takes you. It takes much more faith to believe in a non-sense religion like yours, atheism, than to believe in God.
@@Drew15000 oofffff, you poor ignorant man! You make me laugh when I realize that you are delusional even without starving! You're such an ignorant that you're not even realisng the fact that you're not talking about the God of the Bible when you-re assuming that these are "his priests". God doesn't have and doesn't need priests anymore. But if you don't read the Bible you have no way of knowing. These are satan's priest. And because you dare to judge the Judge of the Universe, satan is also your father. You are most likely one of these hypocrites that judjes God but is a pro-abortionist, a killer of children, a much worse creature than a rapist. You hypocrit and viper! When are YOU going to do something about it, as we, real Christians do, when we speak against catholics, orthodox, budists, jehovah's witnesses, etc, etc.? You hypocrit and viper! You don't know anything about God's Word, you never read the Bible to understand what he wants from us and yet, you dare to call Him evil. God doesn't allow the rape of children, it's people like you that does it by not taking a stand against it, out of cowardness! You hypocrit and viper!
People who believe in your imaginary little friend yhwh have killed more kids than any abortionist you sick freak!
Psalm 137:9
Blessed is whoever smashes your babies skulls against the rocks
@@Drew15000 so you're not a true Christian after all. You're serving Satan as well, like all catholics which at the counsel of nicea modified the Bible and introduced idolatry as well. There was a faction of them at the time that opposed these changes but they were 2 days late for the counsel. And they were late not b/c they were late for the established date of the counsel but b/c your abominable friends, the pro-falsification of the true Gospel group, deceived them by coming 2 days earlier and voting for the changes. All of the above is proven by official documents. All you have to do is to read "The History of Religions" by Mircea Eliade which by the way is translated in over 150 languages and has references to these documents.
God did and does not kill anybody. NEVER, EVER! HE IS THE ONLY GOD AND SUPREME JUDGE OF ALL HIS CREATION AND HAS ALL THE RIGHTS TO TAKE ANYBODY HE WANTS AND WHEN HE WANTS, FROM THIS LIFE AND PUT THEM INTO THE ONE THAT THEY DESERVE: HEAVEN OR HELL!
SO FAR, YOU'RE GOING TO HELL, YOU HYPOCRIT AND VIPER!
YOUR SATANIC catholic church, KILLED IN FACT MANY MORE PEOPLE THAN EVEN hitler DID, YOU HYPOCRIT AND VIPER!
Psalm 137:
8 O daughter of Babylon, you devastated one,
How blessed will be the one who repays you
With the recompense with which you have repaid us.
9 How blessed will be the one who seizes and dashes your little ones
Against the rock. ( NASB )
The whole psalm is a lamentation of the Jews after they were taken slaves by the Babylonians. Killing babies, so to cut off bloodlines, was common practice at the time. If you read the whole psalm you should also notice that it came out of the mouth of Jewish people, not from the mouth of GOD. But you, in order to serve your father, satan, and your satanic catholic church, you put these words in the mouth of the HOLLY GOD! AS SUCH, YOU ARE AN ABOMINATION IN HIS EYES!
REPENT, REPENT, REPENT AND TRUST IN JESUS CHRIST, YOU WICKED MAN!
Nothing exploded and became everything....
Tango Delta 2 ????
That is why it is called a theory. It may or may not be true, but science keeps questioning and had no problem rejecting theories in light of new evidence.
How would nonexistence explode? Why? That sentence told me nothing & implied much. You cannot have nothing spontaneous form matter into being. If that was true, it should constantly happen.
There is something that is timeless, spaceless, immaterial, powerful, & without a cause (causality requires time to exist). Thus, it could not be a causeless law that started existence, because the conditions exist & thus it should happen over & over. That is Not our observation. This requires a mind directing the creation of the universe (one with the above traits). There was a choice to act that started the Universe. I would call that God (that is a philosophical statement though).
Your claim, does not have anything but blind faith at this time, with a hope we may some day know. You should have said, 'We do not know how the universe was made.'. That is accurate strictly scientifically speaking.
mackdmara Maybe there are multiple Universe's, but a magical sky god doesn't explain anything.
mackdmara also out of curiosity, which god is it that you believe in?
man...the way that he touched his eyes when he heards multiverse...shows that he thinks thats is the ultimate bullshit ever
There is no more proof in more than one Universe than there is for the existence of a Creator (God). On the other hand, since I have "Faith" that there is a God, I must believe in Multiple Universes. Otherwise, there wouldn't be separate places for Heaven or Hell. Thus, multiple universes must physically exist.
Atheists accept unseen unproven infinite multiple universes... But not an infinite God... Hilarious!!
@@5tonyvvvv you could paste that into every thread on youtube, but hopefully you grew up since a year ago.
Not a greatest public speaker.
Better than most guys!
David Mahoney .....and it pleased you to say so......not enough important stuff to put your time on?
You sound vindictive.
A Noble Prize winner doesn't have to be.
✋🏻🇸🇦
🐰