The following is what I borrowed from a Malaysian TH-camr’s comment: I’m from Malaysia. China has traded with Malaysia for 2000 years. In those years, they had been the world’s biggest powers many times. Never once they sent troops to take our land. Admiral Zhenghe came to Malacca five times, in gigantic fleets, and a flagship eight times the size of Christopher Columbus’ flagship, Santa Maria. He could have seized Malacca easily, but he did not. In 1511, the Portuguese came. In 1642, the Dutch came. In the 18th century the British came. We were colonised by each, one after another. When China wanted spices from India, they traded with the Indians. When they wanted gems, they traded with the Persian. They didn’t take lands. The only time China expanded beyond their current borders was in Yuan Dynasty, when Genghis and his descendants Ogedei Khan, Guyuk Khan & Kublai Khan concurred China, Mid Asia and Eastern Europe. But Yuan Dynasty, although being based in China, was a part of the Mongolian Empire. Then came the Century of Humiliation. Britain smuggled opium into China to dope the population, a strategy to turn the trade deficit around, after the British could not find enough silver to pay the Qing Dynasty in their tea and porcelain trades. After the opium warehouses were burned down and ports were closed by the Chinese in ordered to curb opium, the British started the Opium War I, which China lost. Hong Kong was forced to be surrendered to the British in a peace talk (Nanjing Treaty). The British owned 90% of the opium market in China, during that time, Queen Victoria was the world’s biggest drug baron. The remaining 10% was owned by American merchants from Boston. Many of Boston’s institutions were built with profit from opium. After 12 years of Nanjing Treaty, the West started getting really really greedy. The British wanted the Qing government: 1. To open the borders of China to allow goods coming in and out freely, and tax free. 2. Make opium legal in China. Insane requests, Qing government said no. The British and French (with supports from the US), started Opium War II with China, which again, China lost. The Anglo-French military raided the Summer Palace, and threatened to burn down the Imperial Palace, the Qing government was forced to pay with ports, free business zones, 300,000 kilograms of silver and Kowloon was taken. Since then, China’s resources flew out freely through these business zones and ports. In the subsequent amendment to the treaties, Chinese people were sold overseas to serve as labor. In 1900, China suffered attacks by the 8-National Alliance (Empire of Japan, Russian Empire, British Empire (including India), France, USA, Germany, Italy, Austria-Hungary). Innocent Chinese civilians in Peking (Beijing now) were murdered, buildings were destroyed & women were raped. The Imperial Palace was raided, and treasures ended up in museums like the British Museum in London and the Louvre in Paris. In late 1930s China was occupied by the Japanese in WWII. Millions of Chinese died during the occupancy. 300,000 Chinese died in Nanjing Massacre alone. Mao brought China together again from the shambles. There were peace and unity for some time. But Mao’s later reign saw sufferings and deaths from famine and power struggles. Then came Deng Xiao Ping and his infamous “black-cat and white-cat” story. His preference in pragmatism than ideologies has transformed China. This thinking allowed China to evolve all the time to adapt to the actual needs in the country, instead of rigidly bounded to ideologies. It also signified the death of Communism in actually practice in China. The current Socialism+Meritocracy+Market Economy model fits the Chinese like gloves, and it propels the uprise of China. Singapore has a similar model, and has been arguably more successful than Hong Kong, because Hong Kong being gateway to China, was riding on the economic boom in China, while Singapore had no one to gain from. In just 30 years, the CPC have moved 800 millions of people out from poverty. The rate of growth is unprecedented in human history. They have built the biggest mobile network, by far the biggest high speed rail network in the world, and they have become a behemoth in infrastructure. They made a fishing village called Shenzhen into the world’s second largest technological centre after the Silicon Valley. They are growing into a technological power house. It has the most elaborate e-commerce and cashless payment system in the world. They have launched exploration to Mars. The Chinese are living a good life and China has become one of the safest countries in the world. The level of patriotism in the country has reached an unprecedented height. For all of the achievements, the West has nothing good to say about it. China suffers from intense anti-China propagandas from the West. Western Media used the keyword “Communist” to instil fear and hatred towards China. Everything China does is negatively reported. They claimed China used slave labor in making iPhones. The truth was, Apple was the most profitable company in the world, it took most of the profit, leave some to Foxconn (a Taiwanese company) and little to the labor. They claimed China was inhuman with one-child policy. At the same time, they accused China of polluting the earth with its huge population. The fact is the Chinese consume just 30% of energy per capita compared to the US. Minorities in China Show me any currency in the world which also prints the language of its ethinc minorities. Chinese bank notes show 5 languages of 5 minorities living in China, including Tibetan and Uyghur. They claimed China underwent ethnic cleansing in Xinjiang. The fact is China has a policy which priorities ethnic minorities. For a long time, the ethnic minorities were allowed to have two children and the majority Han only allowed one. The minorities are allowed a lower score for university intakes. Muslims students get Halal food at the university cafeteria. There are 39,000 mosque in China, and 2100 in the US. China has about 3 times more mosque per muslim than the US. When terrorist attacks happened in Xinjiang, China had two choices: 1. Re-educate the Uighur extremists before they turned terrorists. 2. Let them be, after they launch attacks and killed innocent people, bomb their homes. China chose 1 to solve problem from the root and not to do killing. How the US solve terrorism? Fire missiles from battleships, drop bombs from the sky. During the pandemic, When China took extreme measures to lockdown the people, they were accused of being inhuman. When China recovered swiftly because of the extreme measures, they were accused of lying about the actual numbers. When China’s cases became so low that they could provide medical support to other countries, they were accused of politically motivated. Western Media always have reasons to bash China. Just like any country, there are irresponsible individuals from China which do bad and dirty things, but the China government overall has done very well. But I hear this comment over and over by people from the West: I like Chinese people, but the CPC is evil. What they really want is the Chinese to change the government, because the current one is too good. Fortunately China is not a multi-party democratic country, otherwise the opposition party in China will be supported by notorious NGOs (Non-Government Organization) of the USA, like the NED (National Endowment for Democracy), to topple the ruling party. The US and the British couldn’t crack Mainland China, so they work on Hong Kong. Of all the ex-British colonial countries, only the Hong Kongers were offered BNOs by the British. Because the UK would like the Hong Kongers to think they are British citizens, not Chinese. A divide-and-conquer strategy, which they often used in Color Revolutions around the world. They resort to low dirty tricks like detaining Huawei’s CFO & banning Huawei. They raised a silly trade war which benefits no one. Trade deficit always exist between a developing and a developed country. USA is like a luxury car seller who ask a farmer: why am I always buying your vegetables and you haven’t bought any of my cars? When the Chinese were making socks for the world 30 years ago, the world let it be. But when Chinese started to make high technology products, like Huawei and DJI, it caused red-alert. Because when Western and Japanese products are equal to Chinese in technologies, they could never match the Chinese in prices. First world countries want China to continue in making socks. Instead of stepping up themselves, they want to pull China down. The recent movement by the US against China has a very important background. When Libya, Iran, and China decided to ditch the US dollar in oil trades, Gaddafi’s was killed by the US, Iran was being sanctioned by the US, and now it’s China’s turn. The US has been printing money out of nothing. The only reason why the US Dollar is still widely accepted, is because it’s the only currency which oil is allowed to be traded with. The US has an agreement with Saudi that oil must be traded in US dollar ONLY. Without the petrol-dollar status, the US dollars will sink, and America will fall. Therefore anyone trying to disobey this order will be eliminated. China will soon use a gold-backed crypto-currency, the alarms in the White House go off like mad. China’s achievements and success have been by hard work. Not by looting and plundering the world. I have deep respect and love for China for all the suffering and the hardship they endured, but now I feel happy for them. China is not rising, they are going back to where they belong. Good luck China.
yeh, but that is no longer true, and wasn't quite true then (China's propaganda is more blatant and see-through that Soviet Russia's). True, it is LESSER KNOWN about China and interference/warfare for it's own interests, but, partly this is due to their EMPEROR GOD making sure their ''truth' was known, and partly due to what was gleaned from the Khan dynasties in relation to OTHER means of domination without the waste and expense of blatant war. Whatever side of the ridiculous argument you take, none the less, you CANNOT debate with China! CANNOT! Whatever their modern take upon Emperor-godship says is ''true'', then IT IS TRUE! Even when you perosnally know it all to be fake. You'll get crushed. MAKE NO MISTAKE! It is BRUTAL! You thyink America is bad? Russia? YOU AIN'T SEEN NOTHING YET! But the rich elites will LOVE China. Things ''get done'' due to one party leadership continuity (I remember listening to a Scottish construction owner who works there all the time due to one party politics suiting him only too well because ''things get done''.. Money, bottom line! same old, same old), and like IDIOTS we'll get sucked up along with the bullshit this encompasses. Compared to China, the West is an angel! Democracy may be as yet infantile, BUT, at least we can CONEST our leaders, and sometimes even make chanages. try THAT in china! Also, Malaysia shows no contest to China, no threat. So China has no need to flex it's muscles with them. DIFFERENT STORY ELSEWHERE where they dominate subtly, by stealth buying everything up, especially Africa. And I guess taking advantage of the hate generated by the ''West's'' initial neglactful propietorial use of Africa up till, and including modern times. BUT, we CANNOT say THE WEST IS LIKE THAT! For THAT is not true Why? because the West is built of many people with many views, and many differeing motivations,. and we are patiently, still learning which ones work best for everyone. And we still need to detect and isolate harmful individuals who try to dominate everyone else, as this keeps us stuck in our primitive past. In effect, China, Russia, and North Korea, where NEVER communist, but re-inventions of Ancient Emperor God systems like Egypt, and more recently ROME. Whatever CEASAR says YOU DO! NO AGRUMENT! How do we know pervasive emperor god primitivism yet is? iran and iraq and Arab cultures call high leaders ''Shah'', germans Kaiser, Russias Tsar, and so on. ALL OF THESE ARE FORMS OF CEASAR, the word and name. not that this proves China is, as they have different lingual roots. BUT the mechanisms of Ceasardom, Emperor Godship are all there in their consecutive leaders and dynasties and all had their origin myths too. At end of the day what ONE MAN SAYS? GOES! END OF. It is a primitve and BRUTAL way to run a world system. As everyone works for it via FEAR! or desperation. noit that the West is innocent here. BUT, we have been making stridfes, slowly, clumsily, and sometimes mistakenly, into getting rid of this nasty highly evolve means of schoolyard bullying. China will ONLY benefit the mega rich, even more so than the so called ''West''. A West which consists of so many differeing entities, that it is not at all a ''West'' in the slightest. And what of the Uighar Muslims of china? The concentyration camps? JKust like Hitler denied his camps, so too are China. And JUSt like hitler, experiments, mainly in control, and mind stuff, are being employed upon thesde poor Uighar people. WHO IS HELPING THEM? Are Malaysian Muslims even caring? Or like Western leaders, burying their heads in the sand while business is good? Or really, is it FEAR to call the new bully out?
Great write-up and good to educate people on. However, I think Chinese culture as well as Asian culture suffer from the same weakness. They are too apologetic and focus on explaining themselves too much as if to seek some form of validation in the world. I think the West believes showing strength and doing all these bad things to China is simply through the lens of competition and they are simply doing the best job possible to empower their country. The fact China only focusses internally and explain why they are not wrong means the west should continue to be on the offensive and explain why China is wrong. Because they are just doing their job the best way possible and their only interest is what is best for their country and that's it. This is why they were elected in the first place by their citizens. The west sees competition as the only way to decide who is more deserving in this world, because that is proof of who is better. So competition is a good thing and capitalism is also based on competition. Western culture prizes competition in business, athletic sports, politics, warfare, and like personalities that thrive in it. Competition validates who is the best and the best should get the most. That is it. I think from China's perspective they cannot grasp this culture from the west. They always feel trapped like the west truly think they are wrong and self reflect and try to explain. China needs to focus more directly at playing politics as oppose to blaming how politics is played. It is a sign of weakness when you explain too much because the west wants you to always keep your head down and maintain the debate about whether China is good or bad country. The only way to stay above judgement is to keep judging other countries, that is a western strategy.
Im suprised by how clear the responses to the questions were. I was expecting diplomatic answers but Kishore was absolutely crystal clear in his answers.
Kishore Mahbuhani has an excellent way of speaking without using flowery words, without speaking between lines, without mincing his words. Clarity, concise, precise and well-researched are his forte!
@@gcj7771 Lol, classic brainless western response when you have no counterargument. Funny how the west, the purported bastion of free and critical thinking, produces people like you who knee-jerk react with "zOmG CCP bot/stooge spotted!" whenever anyone says anything other than "ChY-Na is eVlL man". Absolute weak sauce.
Did you read this book online named: "How the specter of communism is ruling our world"? it is kind of so popular now, I also found its 10 Ep. series on TH-cam, it shows the answer of why the US is on the way to communism now, I was shocked by the truth mentioned in this book&video.
Lecture in 2015 by a very wise man and America, the West especially the UK has not listened to a word of it. Mr. Mahbubani must be shaking his head in despair.
Professor Kishore Mahbubani is very open and honest is his answer "..........I don't know how to solve the problem". I admire people who answer the question directly and honestly. Yes, man, you're great!
21:17 Brilliant observation by Mr. Mahbubani: "Be careful what you wish for .... because if the Chinese political system becomes more democratic it could very well become far more nationalist and far more aggressive as a power"
This makes a lot of sense, Just look at Taiwan and even USA. How the politicians rely on anti china sentiments to win votes. If China adopts western style democratic system, The Chinese people may become even more nationalistic then now.
@@alantan9863 Today there are more Chinese who are able to speak and write English when compared with the number of Western Countries combine who knows how to speak and write Chinese. Everyday there are 12,000 startups in China, 8 million graduate every year from Universities ... and the List goes on and on. This is due to exposure not seen in the 50's & 60's. Today Chinese and Asian Chinese are much smarter and able to decide what they want to do because of the Openness and Maturity of the Country and this is cannot be due to Dictatorship as we see in North Korea where movement (including access to Education, Connectivity; Internet ... etc) are Restricted. We have seen how Free Speech and Expression can cause Division, Racism in a Country like USA ... by 2047 Democracy would have failed due to Disintermediation (Dambisa Moyo). The Question remain: What freedom do you need? If there are successful People or Companies in China, why not you? How does dictatorship in China stop you from doing what you want but not able to stop others from succeeding?
@@esp4yu Thank you Phil. I myself could not have said it better, and I will incorporate your knowledge. Can't wait until serendipity brings us tet a tet (fr.) Attending Asian Solidarity in PHX this evening!
Deeply agree with the conclusion of first story as a Chinese...ppl here really don’t care what political system we have, either democracy or community. Our country has long history, we proud of the culture and we also feel upset of the humiliation had suffered. All we care and pursue is better life , peace and happy.
@@willd0g Uighurs are free in China. If you are talking about the obviously over-blown number of Islamist terrorists that is detained in China in the same way that Islamist terrorists are detained in Guantanamo Bay, then yes, those exist. People are in those camps for a reason. If you would like to know more about the reason, please ask the CIA on why there are people detained in GB.
@Jo Piscine That is just red scare propaganda. Baseless accusations because you are too afraid of reality. But keep on being afraid while the world moves on and leaves you behind to cry in your tinfoil hat.
@Jo Piscine There are no factual basis for your claims for a genocide. The Uighur population in China has been increasing, and the Chinese government has shown zero intent on killing a group of people. So you can keep on claiming "gEnOcide" all you want, but that is just propaganda. You are the one is who in fear of the facts. Sad.
so you think its reasonable to assume that 1000 "western" media entities with hundreds of different opinions all somehow conspire to distort the truth more than a single opinion, heavily censored state actor?
Most of the people & countries will always have their hatred to China, but me. I'm one of a few people that love and admire China as a country. A lot of lesson that we can learn from them. I don't know what it's all about with all those hatred towards them. British with their sins. Spanish with their sins (almost entire Indigenous people of South America were killed). French with their sins (read what they did to Haiti). Japan with all their sins (those killing & rape thing in Nanjing & all of Asia). US of A (do I have to write what they've done here?). But people never hate them. That's western propaganda for you. Keep growing & rising China. Warm greetings from Indonesia.
Proud to be a Singaporean. Thank you for your contributions and keep up the good work of trying to make the West understand, especially the US of the inevitable.
I am more interested in what Singapore can do next since it has done a great job. Leading edge technologies were supposed to lead to next phase, but it is not working, why?
Kishore is a class act in strategic thinking around the East Asia topic, which few others in Singapore able to match - and always articulated brilliantly and politely. Have a read of his books...................
@@TesterBoy yet that corny capatilist communist country has less people in poverty than US and they have 4 times the population of US and 4th hat too in a very short time.
@@TesterBoy Your post was pretty brain dead . Wierd as China is often used in business schools as the model of economic growth. Im guessing from your comment you didnt go to business school, or actually visited China. Sure China has corruption and has its problems. However the United States has it's own corruption and inefficiency. I suggest actually reading the book the talk based on before posting criticism of Kishore and perhaps you you might be able to contribute to te subject
Kishore was being very modest in stating that Chinese individual's productivity only needs to perform at 25% level to exceed America at the national level! But the truth is they are actually twice as productive and gets paid at 25% level of the Americans!
that's only small part of China's population. the majority, mostly in rural areas are still very inefficient. there is a huge potential there. With higher productivity, the work can be done by just a quarter of the people now. maybe 3 quarter of the rural area can be made redundant and be useful for higher productivity industrial work.
China because of 4.6 times of population need to produce only 23% engineers. To match America has to produce 100% engineers. Even if they exceed so what. They long exceeded Switzerland or Germany. Does it mean all Chinese have lifestyles equal to Swiss or Germans.
i never thought someone could have the knact of being so factual and well verse in the knowledge of history, economics and politics over the past century as the late LKY. His ability of linking all these events together and synthesising them to form the footprints for future scenarios is exemplary!
China hegemony: - 60 working hours per week. - 90% maths score or no citizenship. - the word 'lazy' is taken off the dictionary. - every parent must pay for their children's education, wedding and first-home downpayment. - obesity is illegal for networth
@Jordie actually this is what western youtube, politicians think about China. you need some intelligence to understand that debt is nothing in comparison to growth. Watch lessons by different economists in India, Japan,South Korea, Turkey and Indonesia to understand the big picture. Actually It needs lot of research to come out of western propaganda
Not so brilliant IMO. The USA has been scheming and running game trying to say China is committing genocide on Muslim populations which from my research is baseless neocon / neolib propaganda. The fact they're pushing those narratives is a sign for what the future holds between the 2 nations: conflict and war. Also don't forget sanctions are economic warfare. Then factor in western powers have proxies around China... This transition will not go smoothly. I don't particularly trust the Chinese government but I trust the USA government even less lol.
I don't think anybody in that hall had a millisecond of not being attentive to the lecture by Prof. Kishore Mahbubani; so soft spoken and at the same time very explosive in the content of the message.
I used to read Mabhubani and works that cited him during my international studies courses in early 2010s. Nice to come across this again and perfect timing I suppose.
Much much respect to prof.mahbubani, this might be the greatest Q&A session I have ever heard period. He’s shown so many inspiring perspectives which enlightened me that the biggest resistance towards politics has to be the limitation of thinking “angles”, so many politicians are constrained by he mentioned self referencing discourse or I would call it both egoist and arrogant thoughts. If we really keen to understand the world, we need to accept the world first
SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
Blame whom we wish, but what we are witnessing is the Abject Failure of the Indian Civilization, (such at it is and always will be), if truth be told. Blame whom we wish, but we are also witnessing the Abject Failure of India's body politic; India's Inability To Govern and To Benefit Their Indian People. www.economicsdiscussion.net/essays/main-causes-of-poverty-in-india/2277
@@lisashung9442 is it really 6 years ago? Then Americans are intentionally ignorant and resistant to change and embrace the world especially Asia Middle Eastern Africa
@@frankgenner782 I totally agree with you these china crimes are all America’s propaganda. I have watched Daniel Dumbrill’s interview Rushan Abbas, Uighur American activist. I was very disappointed as I thought her talk could be logic and evidence backed but full of speculations and imagination, even a lot of conflicts in itself, which was a deep insult to my intelligence.
42:38 American University 46:16 American News media 47:23 threat to American Supremacy 55:42 reserve currency and superpower 59:35 China in 1978 at the beginning 1:02:25 Singapore 1:03:27 London New York to Singapore of Asia 1:09:21 western education vs Asian mind
only idiots thinks of supremacy. honestly i have explored a lot about the universe. ideally, i can't and different between a simple bacteria and complex one. universe simply treat us as a mere event of nature. you can let your stupidity carry you away, but the truth is there is no different between a poor and rich person. we are just delusional and can't to read through lines/universe. some thinks the level of material possession make you superior to others. but the defining question is, do your material possessions make you live forever?.
@@siramike2654 The purpose of life is to experience, and if you’re more rich and powerful, you usually gets to experience more than a begged on the street
@@hiway19891 he is talking about the within world,,our morals, our values.. A psychopath can go ahead to acquire all..what will it do to them if they feel no value, morals or rules in this life? What to feel?
I think if you watch western medias and western politics for some time, you will realize that western politics exhausts politicians and people, for superficial issues. If the issue is small, exaggerate it to gain views. If the issue is sensitive, further provoke it to gain views. Politicians can never have a long term planning and vision with such atmosphere. Theid mind is always anxious...
They are already number one, they control the US through their proxy, Biden administration. Americans don't even realize they have been conquered. lol.
the pandemic that originated in the same city as a virus lab that was researching the exact virus. you are right, the "leadership" 'there' complete fuck up (or well planned considering who suffered the most).
communist kills, - dont let you free! BESIDE THAT ASK THEM IS THIS AREA (MONGOLIA SOUTH WAS IT YOURS?) IT WASNT THEIR WALL IS BEHIND MONGOLIA SOUTH and now they force them to speak their language and have taken the books with their own mongolian language!
u.s.a brought matters of Xin Jiang but did not bring up Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq..... why? cause u.s.a bombed Syria and Iraq, australia murdered innocent Afghanistan people (where all of them are Islam and Muslim countries)
The US is completely dysfunctional- their demented president a sign of a demented and declining country - it may not look like it but in the next 20 years US will just be a second rung power with lots of nuclear missiles
I’m amazed by this lecture. Hope more scholars like Kishore can give lecture to Harvard students and reduce western bias against China. In that way, the bilateral relationship will progress in a much better way. Can’t imagine anything unattainable if America and China work together.
It will not happen and it will never happen. The US will resort into all underhand tactics such as sanctions and warmongering. As witness from the latest development, the US government wanna ban sales of EV battery from China citing EV batteries can spy on US soil! 🤣
Americans have selective hearing. They do that to their own peril. It doesn't matter whether American are willing to listen, China has been moving along.
That applies to people in a society. Not adversarial nations, especially when one is eager to annex or deprave its neighbors and destroy the environment like no other nation.
@@deanw8206 What you said is just not true. After the People's Republic of China was established in 1949 and onwards, it had border issues with its neighboring nations, if i am not wrong should be around 16 nations, and within the last 60+ years, China has settled and reclaimed its territory in a peaceful and diplomatic manner which only leaves 2/1 nations that is India. There are much more land that historically would still be considered to be chinese territories, but with now modern legalized international border, china hasn't even mentioned that they want to take those over by force. I will not deny there are existing problems, but those problems shall and will be sorted out, but it's definitely not in the manner you speak of, which i quote "eager to annex and deprave its neighbors and destroy the enviroment".
@@christ7822 , Tibet was taken over and the Tibetans didn't want it. Now China intends to annex Taiwan within the decade. Taiwanians certainly don't want to be part of China, just like people in Hong Kong don't want to reunite with China. The fact that these places were once part of China means nothing, especially when marxists take over the government murder dozens of millions of people.
@@deanw8206 Regarding the marxist comment is bit outdated now days wouldn't you say? when now days the chinese governement is clearly doing much better than other countries in terms of servicing it's people. History doesn't dictate but it certainly affects the way it will play out. Hong kong doesn't want to reunite, but the fact is that it was returned to China from the long colonization and ocupation of then United kingdom, which the cease was deemed a peaceful return by then. It is China's goal to complete itself and return to before what was lost when it was invaded and splitted. I can't say for sure that the means or ways are good but i certainly admire the cause. Taiwan is an issue on its own, evantually I don't think mainland need to intervene in a hard way, it is already presenting failings in social, economic and political areas, as you say there are people who don't want to return, but then at the same time there are people who are willing to, just as a story always has two sides. But an exemplary example no one ever mentions is Macau, which was another teorritory returned to China. why it doesn't present any problems? why no one puts it in the forfront for this so called cause for the rights and justice. There is no denying china is prospering, and these areas being mentioned are benefitted from it, so as long facts present that the mayority of people's lives are improving, I generally think it's better.
Hope my videos can reach those who want to learn Chinese. I’ve spent about 100,000 hours studying English humor and Western culture. My native language is Chinese. I’m teaching Chinese language in jokes and pictures. Culture exchange and laughter can make the world better.
50:24 China invited KISHORE to Beijing to ask for his observations on 'What foreign policy mistakes China made?' ....the US never invited Kishore to Washington for his views lol ..... speaks to the arrogance of the US!
What a fcng ignorant shit head you are.i ssazds the ovod1 29 iwassan ameamsdcanmade vfruseticam cru 303⁰000pelr in no e 2112019. So llToshiba thrzwine fi
MR Mahbubani is a man of wisdom, he is one of the rare intellectual that understands Chinese history and China in the 21st century. I look forward to reading his great books.
@@暗香晚风 I too have read world current issues. But for me personally, every media have different outlet and story to be told so as to glorify one. Perhaps, reading the root cause is far more crucial is a must before pointing one's finger (just a suggestion)
This man is a shameless liar. He is being paid by the CCP to act as their mouthpiece and to pull wool over the eyes of the world. Only six years after he delivered his speech it has become clear that the CCP has global ambition, but the way of doing that is nefarious through bribe, extortion, predatory lending, honey trap and unrestricted warfare, such as unleashing deadly viruses to kill millions. To learn the truth about their plan listen to this CCP member th-cam.com/video/IYH_hUm1KG8/w-d-xo.html
Unfortunately, China is not in a position to be a world leader of Western Culture. As he says, China must and is on a path to restore its own culture but its own culture was hollowed out (and devoured) by the cultural revolution. The only remaining vestiges of Chinese culture that could be a basis upon which to provide world leadership is Taiwan, and was in Hong Kong. Basically China needs to re-create its soul. And, by the way, the speaker vastly overestimates the status of Chinese military power. Will 150 countries invite Chinese presence for bases on their borders? America is present in 150 countries for good or for bad (but it is true) and China's military is present in zero countries. Also, although the US has been generous in the past in giving the Chinese military technology (for good or for bad), the US weapons systems are vastly superior. The speaker's expertise seems to be in economics and he makes many good points but he seems unaware of the huge gap in military technology between the two countries.
@@danluzurriaga6035 What the CCP means by cultural rejuvination is the communist ideology with Chinese characteristic. As you said they destroyed every trace of their own culture. For example, the CCP now realizes that they can make a big profit by manufacturing and selling the Chinese traditional medicine, but they destroyed that knowledge in the cultural revolution. So they are trying to relearn it from the Japanese who preserved it. Talk about irony.
@SASA SASA Now here's the thing isn't it? The Nazis wouldn't have allowed any allied powers to see what was happening. Meanwhile the Chinese are begging people to see Xinjiang for themselves. Big difference no?
@SASA SASA you can say that to the uighers all day every day. Their population count, life expectancy, education level, and income level have all improved since CCP became the ruling party of China. At least get your facts straight before you make a comment, if you are unwilling to go there in person to investigate. After all, no one is banning you from visiting xinjiang lol.
Actually, the chinese gov't's position is he can go to china whenever he wants. He was always allowed to go back to contribute to what he can to make Tibet more prosperous. But he needs to understand that he needs to stop all separatist activities w/ supports from foreign gov'ts and other covert entities including so called "NGOs" (american, Europeans, Indians, etc) to undermine the Chinese govt and nation, of course. It is very generous deal that the US gov't would never give, if the roles were reversed. For example, if the former ruling heir of Hawaii wants to secede and have tried w/ foreign help (including covert military support). The US would have just killed him as a terrorist long time ago. And that person, like Bin Laden, won't even have a burial place.
It's true about American media in US being extremely insular. Living there for 4 years in the mid 1980s was like living in a well. No Internet then, so no news of the world outside of USA. We had to call our families in Singapore to get Asian news. But in Asia we can read news about the world in our papers and on TV. But even with the ease of Internet these days, many Americans are still so insular. They know so little about the rest of the world.
@@gutemberguefelix7108 Because they pretty much are. The US has never imported a recession from another country and relative to GDP is one of the least interconnected economies in the world and considering Canada and Mexico make up about 50% of their international trade portfolio they are extremely insulated. The only links hold the US interest in the world is importing oil, exporting agricultural good and access cheaper labor, but with the shale oil revolution in the US the oil link is disappearing. Literally the whole eastern hemisphere could disappear tomorrow and the US would get a decent sized recession and have to figure out where to source new commodities from but after that the standard of living would continue to improve.
@@gutemberguefelix7108 😂 insults based on ignorance are hilarious. Dude go read an Economics book, almost every economy experiences a corrective recession once a decade due to the short term debt cycle. The difference with the US economy is when other countries have recessions they don’t spread to the US making their economy the most stable economy in the history of the world.
Totally concur with you - my experience as late as 2007, the insularity of, print media, MSM and the man on the street was and still is ‘mind boggling’ !!
@@jamesjacobs3753 To some people, maybe ignorance is bliss. The US may have never imported a recession, but they definitely exported them. The major financial crisis which started in the US has cost other countries trillions too, does the US take blame for that? No... The cause of that? Wall Street greed. And when you look at the size of our country's debt against our GDP, you know what you see? Capitalism can continue to thrive ONLY if there are other countries to rip off, otherwise, there is no sustainable growth of standard of living. If the whole eastern hemisphere disappear tomorrow, would US have enough farms to produce food to self sustain? How about manufacturing? When was the last time US manufactured enough to not need import? The United State is just like how many of the families within it, a family that is living beyond its means, and debt ridden, with their family income, barely covering debt payment. Now the US has to print money daily just to service their debt, not to pay off any of that.
@@Anriko123 Speaking of ignorance, do you think really think the US has to print money to service its debt when interest payments on that debt is 1.6% of GDP? Or do you think the FED prints money because of it’s policy of quantitative easing during a economic downturn? As a fiscal conservative I don’t approve of our spending levels, but seeing how the yield on a treasury bond is lower than inflation I see why the do it. Speaking of ignorance, did you know that for every calorie consumed in the US, US farmers produce 1.33 calories? In fact the federal government will pay farmers to not grow food to decrease the supply of food. Seriously, look it up. Speaking of ignorance, did you know that 1/5 of the world’s manufactured goods are produced in the US? Seeing that the US makes up 4.25% of the world’s population they can produce enough to meet their population’s demand. The US does import products from countries that have low labor costs, but on a whole the US is the least globally exposed economy in the developed world and almost the entire world with only 5 countries, such as the economic behemoths like Sudan and Nigeria, being less exposed. The US could lose access to every economy in the world excluding Canada and Mexico and after an adjustment period would be fine. Speaking of ignorance, during the time that capitalism has been the dominant economic theory death by starvation, war and disease has decrease dramatically. The average life span has by increased by 10 years since the collapse of the USSR. In 1990 almost half of the world’s population lived in extreme poverty, now it’s less than 10%. Seeing that this is a worldwide phenomenon it’s hard to see which countries wouldn’t want to be “exploited.”
Thanks to this channel! It gives us a remarkable lecture about the rising of political, educational, and economic systems for emerging countries, especially China, which has been progressively competing with the incumbent superpower country (The U.S.) for an extended period. Although there are some skirmishes along the way between those countries, but they're always learning and making something new in order to have a massive impact on their civilization and prosperity.
This lecture is so relevant today! He provided many predictions and some of them have already came true. It was great to see Prof. Ezra Vogel in the audience, who was a great scholar on Chinese affairs.
@@yapbt6579 pandemic has expedited his predictions to turn into reality. Before pandemic we knew US government is incompetent and inefficient, but we all underestimated how much incompetent and inefficient it can sink to.
His main prediction that China would become number 1 is completely wrong however. China has started their decline. They will not surpass the US. Not now, nor in the future.
The Chinese diplomats were decrying why the Americans would treat them with lectures and sanctions. Like Mr. KishoreMahbubani said, Chinese would want to show world the decency of our culture - we have a saying that "anyone comes through your door, is your guest and you should always treat him/her with courtesy and respect".
At 21:30 KM is conflicted. He states the ccp as keeping Chinese nationalism in check, implying it is the Chinese people themselves who drive nationalism. Five years later it's more clear nationalism was driven by the ccp. Probably he believed the ccp would be successful greatly increasing nationalism( and a hatred of freedom and democracy) in the Chinese people; he was merely being duplicitous. What he didn't say was more important- that it is freedoms of individuals and groups, not democracy, that is the greatest threat to the ccp. Especially freedom of speech and association. KM's unwavering avoidance of the freedom arguments against the ccp detracts greatly from the worth of his views.
SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
@@chankwaichoi1 they started fighting like kids ahahahaha Someone even leaked the footage The Uighur issue brought up but with americas track record with Muslims it was laughed off
What Kishor Mahbubani, who is lecturing here, is saying is most probably true. I've been aware that the USA's downward financial slide since Aug. 15, 1971 has been caused by USA's total disregard for basic financial stability practices within their country. The unilateral disconnection of the US Dollar from the gold standard by Nixon in 1971, despite international agreements, was only the beginning. Our (USA) inability to balance our budget, stay within our fiscal limitations and have a relatively harmonious relationship between our two political parties "scares" some of the foreign purchasers of our national debt. I believe we show signs of "circling the drain".
..despite China's long history., however in the last some 70 years of PRChina’s recently history, PRChina had become so extreme impoverished, where tens of Millions Chinese Citizens died from starvation & deprivation during the 1950-1960s Great Leap Forward Policy..and multi-Millions more Chinese Citizens perished during the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s-1970s. Only, after the 1972 Richard Nixon visit to Beijing to meet Chairman Mao and following Mao's death in 1976, the late-Paramount Leader Deng Xiaopeng then implemented "Capitalist economic reform” and “opening-up reform”, to permit China companies & its private citizens to accept foreign investments, set-up Citizens' privately owned businesses, as well as foreign JVs, that the economic development of China commenced and progressed forward rapidly, departing from the EXTREME Poverty Status, which were direct results of the disasters & failures of previous CCP policies implemented (1949 - mid 1970s). The USA-CHINA friendly relationship following visit of Richard Nixon, eventually led to the U.S.A. under then President Bill Clinton, in 2000, to convince the U.S. Congress to approve/grant permanent MFN trading status to PRChina, which provided the PRChina accession to full W.T.O. membership in 2001. Following, China's W.T.O. status, hundreds of billions$$ of FDIs inflowed annually into PRChina, along with massive unprecedented transfering of tech know-hows and manufacturing from Western /Japanese/S.Korean/Taiwanese etc. companies & factories, established into PRChina, making the country as the World's Manufacturing Center Hub and also the main Global Supply Chains Hub. It propelled PRChina's GDP then in 2001 at just only USD1.2 Trillion to reach USD 17.5 Trillion in 2021. Present times, PRChina has already clearly indicated that it does not anymore adhere nor to follow to the U.S. Led World Order, (as evidently conveyed publicly during, perhaps the most historic & openly frank (international broadcasted) exchanges between China - U.S.top officials, at the Anchorage Meetings, March 18-19, 2021. i.e. PRChina will actively desire to disengage from this U.S. Led Order and to seek to replace the U.S.Dollar’s World Premier Reserve Currency status with RMB. This is obviously an EXISTENTIAL THREAT signal to all American Politicians and to U.S. Citizens. Opine, moving forward, it will be interesting to observe how PRChina be able to once again manage those incredible high economic growth rate, without the previously un-restrained backing & support (financial and Techs IAs etc.) of U.S. and Western Countries & its allies, as PRChina moves away & disengages from the U.S. economic umbrella with PRChina forges its own Sphere of Influence to generate & create its own economic and geo-political development. Perhaps, a new Bi-Polar or even Multi-Polar World Orders is being created. One thing is certain, whatever, this new situation or different New World Orders be created, the once relatively stable World economic growth model status, since ending of WWII in 1945, led by U.S. Hegemony may not return. With de-globalization of manufacturing and de-globalization of raw material sourcing…..shortages of all essentials and cost of such essentials raw materials & as well as those commonly used household manufactured goods will be impacted. Worse, present time as at Dec. 27-2022, current Covid & medical & domestic economic Crises happening simultaneously/concurrently in PRChina, have now clearly exposed the incompetency of the CPC- Government's ability to prepare for contingency nor capability to manage in a difficult serious crises status. Reports coming -in, even when Citizens making emergency calls for police and ambulances emergency services , these are now left unanswered in most parts of PRChina, including the Capital Beijing. Opine, such is the state of affairs in present times PRChina, it will have likely serious ramificiations on future PRChina's Investment Profile and Country Risk Level Assessment, to attract the desperately required future & further FDIs and other Foreign Investments into China’s based Assets, equities, China Government Sovereign (SSA) Bonds etc.
As a Chinese, I think it’s more than good for western and eastern people to understand each other more. We still have a long way to go, and even so, we’ll always be a responsible country.
Majority of the people in the west do think like that, domination or 'obey' is one of the few words they like to use as a key path to success in this world.
There’s no point in that. Americans are bogged down with culture wars, gun violence, racism and hatred of people who don’t look like them. How does the country progress?
No, we are far less developed than the United States. We still have a lot to learn. We still have many internal problems to solve, such as corruption, the gap between the rich and the poor, sustainable development, environmental problems, etc. (although we have made great achievements, it is still not enough for us). But we have a stable government, a reasonable mechanism for selecting officials, and a hard-working and united people. It is the consensus of the whole society that the government and the army serve the people. These are exactly what the West does not have and what the west is afraid of. The more afraid things are, the more they have to resist and lie.
Lol China has Orwellian level Autocratic Dictatorship government ! Try fixing the mistakes of the CCP led Tinammen Square massacre first! Its very unfair for India to be compared with china because we are Democratric and our process is slow! Hopfully, China will soon be democratic like the rest of free world and move away from authoritative regimes...
China has succeeded in wiping out absolute proverty and is targeting simple proverty. I witnessed homelessness in a short block right across from the UN headquarter, more than 10 of them! Unfortunately, the situation didn't improve today. Average Americans are toiling along, going from paycheck to paycheck. The Chinese are very hard working which Kishore avoided to say. China was number one for millennia, not a couple of years. Chinese ships with sizes a hundred times Columbus's sailed as far as Africa seven times during the Ming Dynasty. How many countries are there back then? The South China Sea was part of China at least as far back as the Yuan Dynasty. Kishore was wrong about this.
Cry my beloved country, South Africa! I'd wish Nelson Mandela & the ANC were such excellent visionaries as your leaders! 1:02:30 Prof Kishore, your informed lecture changed my perspective regarding China.
To my utter surprise that there is such talk in America soil, utterly different from anything from Washington, WSJ, New York Times, CNN. Kudo to Harvard.
For students who felt confused by long speech, the conclusion of speech is that US should stop aggressive unilateral actions. And if US stay bound to multilateral institutions China gets to peacefully rise to the top. And then..
@@hoyle19771 why are you scared of this? 這句話是應該別人問你？否則怎麼叫做賤骨頭呢？ 洋人像靜靜的貓，但凡盯上你了，你沒跑了，出手穩準狠 國人像叫囂壯膽的貓：白哥黑漢秀一下肌肉，跪地穩准快 我擔憂全球的反華高潮，還在後面，早點回去吧，賤骨頭同學，這裡不適合您啊 晚安
@Deplorable_Brian Hi ,Brian,I am sorry ,Although I am not happy for ur words , but I know that China is the most shameless and deceitful nation in the world, I feel soooo sorry for my nation.....
America rose in prominence as a result of having helped win WW1 when being allied with Serbia, a country which sponsored terrorism (Black Hand) and their downfall was because of terrorism were they got baited into attrition just like the USSR.
@@Miodrag.Vukomanovic america rode on the coattails of the USSR in ww2. And what kind of nations attempt to take central Asia after a regional superpower fails? Not too bright
@@Miodrag.Vukomanovic America rose economically because of it's large land territories and huge natural resources. They had the largest steel production in history. And being away from conflict(World Wars) helped a lot as well.
I’m an American and this lecture opened my mind closer to understanding the Chinese perspective. And I wondered how the British felt when they were no longer the center of the universe, maybe a short period of resentment followed by acceptance? Please be kind to the world China, America by all means is transitioning the power quite peacefully…..thus far.
i agree, we’re always so harsh to china when it doesn’t something bad but when it does amazing things no one barely talks about it, it has gone to such an extent where people blame china for things that are barely connected
If you look the history you will know that when a rising power collides with the current one, it usually ends with one side dismember. British, Soviet union etc, America is transitioning the power peacefully but that is because they are unable to do it differently. If America invade China decades ago surely China will be domed, but you never know since both side have nukes. Also i'm pretty sure its America that starts wars all over the world in the name of so called democracy and human right, how many wars did China wage?
@@donaldduck1322How can you speak about China waging wars when they have barely entered the world stage? Let's see how they will do after 100 years of economic and military dominance. The U.S by all means has performed tremendously in keeping world peace, and I contribute this to their ability to welcome immigrants from all over the world and their generosity in sharing wealth and knowledge through their education system.
@@UnknownUnknown-hg7xg US started a lot of wars even before enter the world stage, only 20 years in US history that not involved in war, 4 years from Jimmy Carter, a great man and 4 years from Trump period. Dont mention US was build on Indian's skull. The US did something good during WW2, but the majority contribution are made by Soviet Union and China if you check the casualties. Don't mention the war crime that US committed from Afghan, Bikini island, Iraq, Yemen, Vietnam, Syria, Palestine etc etc. And you think America is fighting for world peace? Your entire country is run by the military- industrial complex, you think they get this rich by maintain world peace? As for welcome the immigrants, you are the immigrants and Indians took you in, now what happened to them and how many of them left?
@@kandam5517 sadly many posters are taking a defensive position about China nut are unwilling to take a middle ground. The perception of the CCP as being the same as in the days of Mao is ridiculous. If only they would visit cities like Shanghai, see their infrastructure it would blow their minds. Perhaps meet Chinese people and talk to them they would get over this malice your seeing in posts.
@@dagsmoko3889 How? Do you mind sharing your resources and evidence? I am quite curious and quite shocked by the what the media made up and what people I actually know see and experience. I genuinely want to know what is actually happening. (Also it is quite surprising if ordinary people who have never been to China attacking China, if they are not paid, why spending their time doing something like this? This intrigues me ) Thank you.
What an apt observation by Kishore when asked about the US media perspective of the world in general (47:06) - "There is an incestuous self referential discourse among the newspapers, journalists... they reinforce each others' perspectives and end up misunderstanding the world .. the era of western domination of world history ... is coming to an end.". Basically, with the rise of China and developing world, the access of social media, internet and widespread availability of the alternative news (not fake news) the Western narrative is increasingly being challenged and exposed.
@@victorkmlee Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't there a barrier of great censorship regarding the inflow and outflow of information penetrating the Chinese border due to its blanket ban on independent media and major social media networks? Again, I'm not well versed in this area so please feel free to rectify my assertion. I am also in full congruency with regards to what the incestuous self referential discourse is doing to the flow of information in western media.
@@richardpate-cranium5282 There is no blanket ban of foreign media in China. Facebook, TH-cam, etc. were not banned, they voluntarily withdrew when China asked them to comply according to their policies. This was the time when Terrorrists in Xinjiang were using Facebook and other platforms in coordinating their movements/actions. Before that, they were in China. New York Times and some other US news media I think were banned in the midst of the pandemic last year for repeatedly distorting the news about China. BBC was just banned early this year in retaliation for UK's banning their CGTN.
This man is a shameless liar. He is being paid by the CCP to act as their mouthpiece and to pool wool over the eyes of the world. Only six years after he delivered his speech it has become clear that the CCP has global ambition, but the way of doing that is nefarious through bribe, extortion, predatory lending, honey trap and unrestricted warfare, such as unleashing deadly viruses to kill millions. To learn the truth about their plan listen to this CCP member th-cam.com/video/IYH_hUm1KG8/w-d-xo.html
After a long search for a professional trader with consistency matched with good profit, Mr Elson has proven himself to be one of the best around the world with his amazing trading skills.
Did you read this book online named: "How the specter of communism is ruling our world"? it is kind of so popular now, I also found its 10 Ep. series on TH-cam, it shows the answer of why the US is on the way to communism now, I was shocked by the truth mentioned in this book&video.
At 21:30 KM is conflicted. He states the ccp as keeping Chinese nationalism in check, implying it is the Chinese people themselves who drive nationalism. Five years later it's more clear nationalism was driven by the ccp. Probably he believed the ccp would be successful greatly increasing nationalism( and a hatred of freedom and democracy) in the Chinese people; he was merely being duplicitous. What he didn't say was more important- that it is freedoms of individuals and groups, not democracy, that is the greatest threat to the ccp. Especially freedom of speech and association. KM's unwavering avoidance of the freedom arguments against the ccp detracts greatly from the worth of his views.
@@dagsmoko3889 No, KM understand that adversarial electoral democracy will bring out the worst in people, all the selfishness of people. This fact has already been well demonstrated in the US and many other Western nations with similar system in place.
This isn't anti China content. Since Harvard re-loaded this in came up in the feed. Whilst we are discussing this, in China there is O positive content about overseas. It's all rubbish from clickable Weibo articles, and brain washing from AI Weiwei
@@happyhappynuts Goods and bads are comparative. For example, Iran people democratically elected a strong government that believes Middle East belongs to those living in Middle East, instead of the US or Russia. Good for them but bad for the US. Meanwhile, you have to admit that it's quite difficult to find some positive content about the West. And as Putin says, "Don't blame the mirror when you're ugly."
Did you read this book online named: "How the specter of communism is ruling our world"? it is kind of so popular now, I also found its 10 Ep. series on TH-cam, it shows the answer of why the US is on the way to communism now, I was shocked by the truth mentioned in this book&video.
This mans perspective is still inspiring if you take his invitation to look at it from his point of view. I do hope he represents the rising middle class in the Asian world who have the power to built their economy, education and institutions. If not, then to which global ballance are we moving?
Glorify China? Kishore was sucking up the American audience so much with sweet words for the so called American political correctness here. I was gonna throw up😂
u.s.a brought matters of Xin Jiang but did not bring up Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq..... why? cause u.s.a bombed Syria and Iraq, australia murdered innocent Afghanistan people (where all of them are Islam and Muslim countries)
@@georgeinjapan6583 How many countries have you been to make this conclusion? From my perspective, I call the situation in the USA uncivilized. And this is the fact for a country with no history. A better education system for all US citizens is the most urgent need for the US.
@@kotobaG I heave been to 46 countries, how about you? I also have friends/former students that I kee in touch with from another 39 countries . I am not sure why discussions keep turning into bashing the USA (even though I agree with many of the criticisms).
@@kotobaG OK, yes Americans should learn more about other countries and languages besides English. There should be a 1 1/2-2 year national service like the Peace Corps for all.
What happen when US became super power. Recent events; Destroyed oldest civilization belonging country to rubble, all historical places Destroyed, oil, gold looted killed millions, Another country with same status Syria with no shame looting oil from that country, Libya, Afghanistan the list goes on.
@Sami Ilvonen I feel so much anger from you, are you okay? Are you living in a unhappy life? Are you spending all your life on hating China? God Bless you.
One of the finest talks I have ever heard. Take away. 1) best education / for mind 2) best infrastructure / home productivity/ institutions for India 3) learn Chinese language 4) Accept no more humiliation from other than immediate family members 5) Do every thing to rise lives of my indians first and the world.
@@Mr196710 we love you Israel. What I think is world is one home. Very one will realise that what they are looking for is being extatic in their body. Without external stimulus. ( Drugs/ alcohol/ comfort food) Only when one is rich enough he will realise this ( that money alone won't bring blissfulness). So first food on plates FOR all. Population needs to grow responsibly.( People should postpone reproduction ie marriage of women at 35 and 2 kids per couple) Humans will focus to rise their consciousness, then all come together as one 🙏. ' ADVAITHA'. Hope it make sense now.
@Qi Jia New Zealand has signed an upgrade to the China free trade agreement, offering some New Zealand goods faster access to Chinese markets and a reduction in tariffs. New Zealand was the first developed country to sign a free trade agreement with China, in 2008. This modernise the free trade agreement that was signed in 2008, brings it up to date. www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/124058012/new-zealand-signs-upgraded-free-trade-agreement-with-china.New Zealand will already have 98 per cent free trade with China, its largest trading partner, once the existing free trade agreement comes fully into force. The upgrade has primarily focused on reducing compliance costs for New Zealand exporters, and other measures which ease access to China’s markets.>The Kiwi Fruit was always a Chinese Gooseberry underneath..China/Japan/Korea & Straila are the biggest importer of the green/gold & now red fruit.!!! < The upgrade is only on par with the agreement that China already has with Australia. Straight from Scott Morrison’s mouth. Australia is still a far larger trading partner of China’s than NZ is. I really don’t know why the NZ - China overhype when Australia - China relationship is far larger except with a twisted political loyalty to the US.
The video is a lecture at the Harvard Kennedy School's Albert H. Gordon lecture series by Kishore Mahbubani, a Singaporean career diplomat and former dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy. He talks about China's rise as a superpower, its goals and aspirations, and the role of the relationship between the United States and China in influencing China's rise.
What a remarkable talk. I would like to know, under current toxic political environment, can Kennedy school still invite Mr. Mahbuhani to give a lecture about China?
@@miltonmueller7199 Except Chinese people use VPN, so it is available.. Yes VPN is officially forbidden, but China doesn't enforce this law.. Chinese people know all about the West, because we can see you and hear what you say on the internet... But do Americans know all about China? How could they? They never watch any Chinese media or social media, they don't speak Chinese... You have no idea what Chinese people say or think... But the Chinese know all about you... “If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle.” - Sun Tzu... The US belongs either to the 2nd or the 3rd group.. Also keep in mind, China never called the US our enemy, but the US has called China the enemy, many times... But you will lose, if you continue like this...
No, they will look at the people, shake their heads and laugh at how FOOLED you were by your politicians and media. Its 9 teasers later and the only thing that has bern accomplished is a reverse in race relations, because they have been sppin-fed by socialists and while they had your attention, they stole everything that was valuable.. Control... All the while stealing our freedoms, one by one.
@Joseph LOL. apparently I needed to go into more detail for people like you to understand. Why I found it astounding that Harvard repost this six year old lecture by a foreign diplomate who gave China a fair and objective analysis in the mist of all this anti-China propaganda, being they are part of the establishment. Setting up another one of those WMD lies to go into another war in order to protect our hegemony, aka bullying and our world currency reserve status, aka Fiat Money. In the end Harvard is suppose be elite higher learning university and if they looked the other way or peddle this propaganda then it stains their reputation in the future, and why some at that institution allowed for this repost of this lecture to happen. I have confidence that the business school side along with the Law school side wasn't thrilled about this reposting.
Harvard is instrumental in creating the woke culture in the US so you could argue that inadvertently they are accelerating the decline of the US as China ascends
melodious delivery of exceptional ideas in piercing precision! kudos! May I humbly devote one more Maxim= The way critics get treated in China tells everything! Could be applicable to any other cultures
@@amon5124 you married her because you love playing on the submissive asian stereotype. As for how china feels about muslims, there are five times more mosques per capita than the US. And didn't they murder a million iraqis? Please, if you really care about muslims so much, just stfu
@@amon5124 Yeah.. were the Chinese the ones who obliterated Syria, Iraq, Afganistan and Libya? Were the Chinese involved in creating IS? You need to help your brains to read facts and not watch rubbish on the television.
He is truly a gentleman. Really love his way which he delivered his remarks. Listening to his lecture just like taking a cold shower after a chaos day, then calm down
It is not only about the media report purely the news inside US. It’s also about how they report the rest of the world. If the media is not objective towards what they report, the audience are likely to be biased, though they are not aware of this. Unfortunately, the western media are rarely objective towards China which makes US people even harder to know China. Free press does not help if all the media you access are one-side biased. A great portion of Chinese can read English so they definitely know more about America. I can’t say many American can read Chinese.
While I acknowledge your claims of bias and potential bias and the harm this can and has done to relationships, what I've observed from the Chinese side, both through official statements, media portrayals (as well as other sources) reveals communication patterns also lacking in the objectively I believe we'd both prefer.
@@GB-ws8zx I agree with your opinion. What I’m trying to say is that as a Chinese living in UK for 4 years, I watch both BBC and CCTV so try to keep my understanding neutral. And I think most Chinese living abroad do so since they get access to both and care about both. What I’m concern is that, how many British or Americans will watch news from Chinese media to balance their view. Not to mention that there are fabricated news from BBC towards China sometimes which is just ridiculous to watch. How can the western people know real China if they only watch western media. I would say that the western media should be accountable for the misunderstanding of western people towards China. It is very harmful if you look at what happens to Asian in US now.
@@wendy9232 You've been in the UK for 4 years, I've been here over 50 years, just a heads up about the BBC and what they spout in the media regarging all Chinese related articles are all NEGATIVE , remember your history when chatting with people from European descent and be cautious with what they say.
Kishore is not only very intelligent but he understands China well. The Chinese culture does not have that “missionary” mentality and a Chinese is often surprised/shocked at the missionary zeal of western countries in both religion and colonization of other lands. Two dominant philosophical schools ingrained in the Chinese thinking is Confucianism, which values harmony of nations, and Buddhism, which values peace and interdependence; both schools looks down upon forcing others to believe in your ideology or way of doing things. Confucius said, “To rectify your mistakes is to do great good,” so it is not surprising that Kishore was invited to China to point out their policy mistakes. China has made huge mistakes, but it is on a constant learning path. On the other hand, the US is so proud of its achievements that it has blinded itself. Its reaction to China rising is to demonize China instead of objectively looking at what it has done right. Many Americans accuse China purely on the ground of being “communist”, when they don’t even know what that term means in current Chinese government. The CCP has reinvented and realigned itself so many times that the only thing that didn’t change was the term “Communist” in its party name. Kishore pointed out that (one of) the greatest contribution of the US is to educate the best minds from the world in its universities. This is where the US’s true influence on the world is, not bullying other countries using force or the dollar.
If the Chinese government is ‘communist’ in name only why do they still make speeches about Karl Marx calling him the most important thinker in human history? Why does XJP extol Marx above Confucius?
As a Chinese, I find this video very accurate. But sadly I’m witnessing more and more aggressive approach from the party and thus the population. But even that is the case, the Chinese people as I believe is peaceful, and I urge my fellow Chinese to not go the other way around. We are to bring back the glory of our civilisation, which builds upon the progress of ourselves, but not through the aggression towards others.
I don't know how and why this video of 2015 is only posted in 2021, but more importantly, is to attest how relevant even in today's context or not. I like Lee Kuan Yew's video as it has been proven time over and again, his words of wisdom do apply with the test of time. I suppose the same as with this one.
Posted on youtube in 2012, a lecture at University of Melbourne (AUS), entitled "When China Rules the World". Worth a look; many statements the speaker made we're seeing now. The West ruling elites and oligarchs enabled this, and were effectively Sun Tzu'd for decades. Welcome to the Chinese century. Enjoy the decline America, there's no going back, the golden age is behind us
The following is what I borrowed from a Malaysian TH-camr’s comment:
I’m from Malaysia. China has traded with Malaysia for 2000 years. In those years, they had been the world’s biggest powers many times. Never once they sent troops to take our land. Admiral Zhenghe came to Malacca five times, in gigantic fleets, and a flagship eight times the size of Christopher Columbus’ flagship, Santa Maria. He could have seized Malacca easily, but he did not. In 1511, the Portuguese came. In 1642, the Dutch came. In the 18th century the British came. We were colonised by each, one after another.
When China wanted spices from India, they traded with the Indians. When they wanted gems, they traded with the Persian. They didn’t take lands. The only time China expanded beyond their current borders was in Yuan Dynasty, when Genghis and his descendants Ogedei Khan, Guyuk Khan & Kublai Khan concurred China, Mid Asia and Eastern Europe. But Yuan Dynasty, although being based in China, was a part of the Mongolian Empire.
Then came the Century of Humiliation. Britain smuggled opium into China to dope the population, a strategy to turn the trade deficit around, after the British could not find enough silver to pay the Qing Dynasty in their tea and porcelain trades. After the opium warehouses were burned down and ports were closed by the Chinese in ordered to curb opium, the British started the Opium War I, which China lost. Hong Kong was forced to be surrendered to the British in a peace talk (Nanjing Treaty). The British owned 90% of the opium market in China, during that time, Queen Victoria was the world’s biggest drug baron. The remaining 10% was owned by American merchants from Boston. Many of Boston’s institutions were built with profit from opium.
After 12 years of Nanjing Treaty, the West started getting really really greedy. The British wanted the Qing government:
1. To open the borders of China to allow goods coming in and out freely, and tax free.
2. Make opium legal in China.
Insane requests, Qing government said no. The British and French (with supports from the US), started Opium War II with China, which again, China lost. The Anglo-French military raided the Summer Palace, and threatened to burn down the Imperial Palace, the Qing government was forced to pay with ports, free business zones, 300,000 kilograms of silver and Kowloon was taken. Since then, China’s resources flew out freely through these business zones and ports. In the subsequent amendment to the treaties, Chinese people were sold overseas to serve as labor.
In 1900, China suffered attacks by the 8-National Alliance (Empire of Japan, Russian Empire, British Empire (including India), France, USA, Germany, Italy, Austria-Hungary). Innocent Chinese civilians in Peking (Beijing now) were murdered, buildings were destroyed & women were raped. The Imperial Palace was raided, and treasures ended up in museums like the British Museum in London and the Louvre in Paris.
In late 1930s China was occupied by the Japanese in WWII. Millions of Chinese died during the occupancy. 300,000 Chinese died in Nanjing Massacre alone.
Mao brought China together again from the shambles. There were peace and unity for some time. But Mao’s later reign saw sufferings and deaths from famine and power struggles.
Then came Deng Xiao Ping and his infamous “black-cat and white-cat” story. His preference in pragmatism than ideologies has transformed China. This thinking allowed China to evolve all the time to adapt to the actual needs in the country, instead of rigidly bounded to ideologies. It also signified the death of Communism in actually practice in China. The current Socialism+Meritocracy+Market Economy model fits the Chinese like gloves, and it propels the uprise of China. Singapore has a similar model, and has been arguably more successful than Hong Kong, because Hong Kong being gateway to China, was riding on the economic boom in China, while Singapore had no one to gain from.
In just 30 years, the CPC have moved 800 millions of people out from poverty. The rate of growth is unprecedented in human history. They have built the biggest mobile network, by far the biggest high speed rail network in the world, and they have become a behemoth in infrastructure. They made a fishing village called Shenzhen into the world’s second largest technological centre after the Silicon Valley. They are growing into a technological power house. It has the most elaborate e-commerce and cashless payment system in the world. They have launched exploration to Mars. The Chinese are living a good life and China has become one of the safest countries in the world. The level of patriotism in the country has reached an unprecedented height.
For all of the achievements, the West has nothing good to say about it. China suffers from intense anti-China propagandas from the West. Western Media used the keyword “Communist” to instil fear and hatred towards China.
Everything China does is negatively reported.
They claimed China used slave labor in making iPhones. The truth was, Apple was the most profitable company in the world, it took most of the profit, leave some to Foxconn (a Taiwanese company) and little to the labor.
They claimed China was inhuman with one-child policy. At the same time, they accused China of polluting the earth with its huge population. The fact is the Chinese consume just 30% of energy per capita compared to the US.
Minorities in China
Show me any currency in the world which also prints the language of its ethinc minorities. Chinese bank notes show 5 languages of 5 minorities living in China, including Tibetan and Uyghur.
They claimed China underwent ethnic cleansing in Xinjiang. The fact is China has a policy which priorities ethnic minorities. For a long time, the ethnic minorities were allowed to have two children and the majority Han only allowed one. The minorities are allowed a lower score for university intakes. Muslims students get Halal food at the university cafeteria. There are 39,000 mosque in China, and 2100 in the US. China has about 3 times more mosque per muslim than the US.
When terrorist attacks happened in Xinjiang, China had two choices:
1. Re-educate the Uighur extremists before they turned terrorists.
2. Let them be, after they launch attacks and killed innocent people, bomb their homes.
China chose 1 to solve problem from the root and not to do killing. How the US solve terrorism? Fire missiles from battleships, drop bombs from the sky.
During the pandemic,
When China took extreme measures to lockdown the people, they were accused of being inhuman.
When China recovered swiftly because of the extreme measures, they were accused of lying about the actual numbers.
When China’s cases became so low that they could provide medical support to other countries, they were accused of politically motivated.
Western Media always have reasons to bash China.
Just like any country, there are irresponsible individuals from China which do bad and dirty things, but the China government overall has done very well. But I hear this comment over and over by people from the West: I like Chinese people, but the CPC is evil. What they really want is the Chinese to change the government, because the current one is too good.
Fortunately China is not a multi-party democratic country, otherwise the opposition party in China will be supported by notorious NGOs (Non-Government Organization) of the USA, like the NED (National Endowment for Democracy), to topple the ruling party. The US and the British couldn’t crack Mainland China, so they work on Hong Kong. Of all the ex-British colonial countries, only the Hong Kongers were offered BNOs by the British. Because the UK would like the Hong Kongers to think they are British citizens, not Chinese. A divide-and-conquer strategy, which they often used in Color Revolutions around the world.
They resort to low dirty tricks like detaining Huawei’s CFO & banning Huawei. They raised a silly trade war which benefits no one. Trade deficit always exist between a developing and a developed country. USA is like a luxury car seller who ask a farmer: why am I always buying your vegetables and you haven’t bought any of my cars?
When the Chinese were making socks for the world 30 years ago, the world let it be. But when Chinese started to make high technology products, like Huawei and DJI, it caused red-alert. Because when Western and Japanese products are equal to Chinese in technologies, they could never match the Chinese in prices. First world countries want China to continue in making socks. Instead of stepping up themselves, they want to pull China down.
The recent movement by the US against China has a very important background. When Libya, Iran, and China decided to ditch the US dollar in oil trades, Gaddafi’s was killed by the US, Iran was being sanctioned by the US, and now it’s China’s turn. The US has been printing money out of nothing. The only reason why the US Dollar is still widely accepted, is because it’s the only currency which oil is allowed to be traded with. The US has an agreement with Saudi that oil must be traded in US dollar ONLY. Without the petrol-dollar status, the US dollars will sink, and America will fall. Therefore anyone trying to disobey this order will be eliminated. China will soon use a gold-backed crypto-currency, the alarms in the White House go off like mad.
China’s achievements and success have been by hard work. Not by looting and plundering the world.
I have deep respect and love for China for all the suffering and the hardship they endured, but now I feel happy for them. China is not rising, they are going back to where they belong. Good luck China.
Can u send me this I tried to copy it won’t let me. Very good info
please provide link to the original Malaysia TH-cam comment.
yeh, but that is no longer true, and wasn't quite true then (China's propaganda is more blatant and see-through that Soviet Russia's). True, it is LESSER KNOWN about China and interference/warfare for it's own interests, but, partly this is due to their EMPEROR GOD making sure their ''truth' was known, and partly due to what was gleaned from the Khan dynasties in relation to OTHER means of domination without the waste and expense of blatant war.
Whatever side of the ridiculous argument you take, none the less, you CANNOT debate with China! CANNOT!
Whatever their modern take upon Emperor-godship says is ''true'', then IT IS TRUE! Even when you perosnally know it all to be fake. You'll get crushed. MAKE NO MISTAKE! It is BRUTAL!
You thyink America is bad? Russia? YOU AIN'T SEEN NOTHING YET! But the rich elites will LOVE China. Things ''get done'' due to one party leadership continuity (I remember listening to a Scottish construction owner who works there all the time due to one party politics suiting him only too well because ''things get done''.. Money, bottom line! same old, same old), and like IDIOTS we'll get sucked up along with the bullshit this encompasses.
Compared to China, the West is an angel!
Democracy may be as yet infantile, BUT, at least we can CONEST our leaders, and sometimes even make chanages. try THAT in china!
Also, Malaysia shows no contest to China, no threat. So China has no need to flex it's muscles with them.
DIFFERENT STORY ELSEWHERE where they dominate subtly, by stealth buying everything up, especially Africa. And I guess taking advantage of the hate generated by the ''West's'' initial neglactful propietorial use of Africa up till, and including modern times.
BUT, we CANNOT say THE WEST IS LIKE THAT! For THAT is not true
Why?
because the West is built of many people with many views, and many differeing motivations,. and we are patiently, still learning which ones work best for everyone. And we still need to detect and isolate harmful individuals who try to dominate everyone else, as this keeps us stuck in our primitive past.
In effect, China, Russia, and North Korea, where NEVER communist, but re-inventions of Ancient Emperor God systems like Egypt, and more recently ROME. Whatever CEASAR says YOU DO! NO AGRUMENT!
How do we know pervasive emperor god primitivism yet is?
iran and iraq and Arab cultures call high leaders ''Shah'', germans Kaiser, Russias Tsar, and so on. ALL OF THESE ARE FORMS OF CEASAR, the word and name.
not that this proves China is, as they have different lingual roots. BUT the mechanisms of Ceasardom, Emperor Godship are all there in their consecutive leaders and dynasties and all had their origin myths too.
At end of the day what ONE MAN SAYS? GOES! END OF.
It is a primitve and BRUTAL way to run a world system. As everyone works for it via FEAR! or desperation.
noit that the West is innocent here. BUT, we have been making stridfes, slowly, clumsily, and sometimes mistakenly, into getting rid of this nasty highly evolve means of schoolyard bullying.
China will ONLY benefit the mega rich, even more so than the so called ''West''. A West which consists of so many differeing entities, that it is not at all a ''West'' in the slightest.
And what of the Uighar Muslims of china? The concentyration camps? JKust like Hitler denied his camps, so too are China. And JUSt like hitler, experiments, mainly in control, and mind stuff, are being employed upon thesde poor Uighar people.
WHO IS HELPING THEM? Are Malaysian Muslims even caring?
Or like Western leaders, burying their heads in the sand while business is good? Or really, is it FEAR to call the new bully out?
Superb write up and on point. The west and their hypocrisy can learn something from Asia.
Great write-up and good to educate people on. However, I think Chinese culture as well as Asian culture suffer from the same weakness. They are too apologetic and focus on explaining themselves too much as if to seek some form of validation in the world.
I think the West believes showing strength and doing all these bad things to China is simply through the lens of competition and they are simply doing the best job possible to empower their country. The fact China only focusses internally and explain why they are not wrong means the west should continue to be on the offensive and explain why China is wrong. Because they are just doing their job the best way possible and their only interest is what is best for their country and that's it. This is why they were elected in the first place by their citizens. The west sees competition as the only way to decide who is more deserving in this world, because that is proof of who is better. So competition is a good thing and capitalism is also based on competition. Western culture prizes competition in business, athletic sports, politics, warfare, and like personalities that thrive in it. Competition validates who is the best and the best should get the most. That is it. I think from China's perspective they cannot grasp this culture from the west. They always feel trapped like the west truly think they are wrong and self reflect and try to explain.
China needs to focus more directly at playing politics as oppose to blaming how politics is played. It is a sign of weakness when you explain too much because the west wants you to always keep your head down and maintain the debate about whether China is good or bad country. The only way to stay above judgement is to keep judging other countries, that is a western strategy.
Im suprised by how clear the responses to the questions were. I was expecting diplomatic answers but Kishore was absolutely crystal clear in his answers.
馬凱碩太讚了，感謝李光耀與新加坡的識人善用，中國人要謙虛繼續加倍努力，不負世界所有人的期望
“ No country is perfect, every country has something to learn and to improve”. Jesus, what a point to make!
Now let's talk about the marriage merry-go-round!
Stupid mind ruin Jesus name into politic
Kishore Mahbuhani has an excellent way of speaking without using flowery words, without speaking between lines, without mincing his words. Clarity, concise, precise and well-researched are his forte!
@Joseph exactly
He is a chinese stooge paid to paint china as a beautiful garden of roses. Plain bull-shit. xi jinping bull-shit
He is a wonderful speaker, sound intellectual and a good diplomat. I could listen to him all day
@@gcj7771 Lol, classic brainless western response when you have no counterargument. Funny how the west, the purported bastion of free and critical thinking, produces people like you who knee-jerk react with "zOmG CCP bot/stooge spotted!" whenever anyone says anything other than "ChY-Na is eVlL man". Absolute weak sauce.
Did you read this book online named: "How the specter of communism is ruling our world"? it is kind of so popular now, I also found its 10 Ep. series on TH-cam, it shows the answer of why the US is on the way to communism now, I was shocked by the truth mentioned in this book&video.
Lecture in 2015 by a very wise man and America, the West especially the UK has not listened to a word of it. Mr. Mahbubani must be shaking his head in despair.
Professor Kishore Mahbubani is very open and honest is his answer "..........I don't know how to solve the problem". I admire people who answer the question directly and honestly. Yes, man, you're great!
Lies again? Jurong Institute
What a profound speech, what a wise man he is ! I have learnt so much from you ! Respect and thank you!
21:17 Brilliant observation by Mr. Mahbubani: "Be careful what you wish for .... because if the Chinese political system becomes more democratic it could very well become far more nationalist and far more aggressive as a power"
Indeed
Ironically, the same collective dictatorship is the only force that can moderate Chinese public.
This makes a lot of sense, Just look at Taiwan and even USA. How the politicians rely on anti china sentiments to win votes. If China adopts western style democratic system, The Chinese people may become even more nationalistic then now.
@@alantan9863 Today there are more Chinese who are able to speak and write English when compared with the number of Western Countries combine who knows how to speak and write Chinese. Everyday there are 12,000 startups in China, 8 million graduate every year from Universities ... and the List goes on and on. This is due to exposure not seen in the 50's & 60's. Today Chinese and Asian Chinese are much smarter and able to decide what they want to do because of the Openness and Maturity of the Country and this is cannot be due to Dictatorship as we see in North Korea where movement (including access to Education, Connectivity; Internet ... etc) are Restricted. We have seen how Free Speech and Expression can cause Division, Racism in a Country like USA ... by 2047 Democracy would have failed due to Disintermediation (Dambisa Moyo). The Question remain: What freedom do you need? If there are successful People or Companies in China, why not you? How does dictatorship in China stop you from doing what you want but not able to stop others from succeeding?
@@esp4yu Thank you Phil. I myself could not have said it better, and I will incorporate your knowledge. Can't wait until serendipity brings us tet a tet (fr.) Attending Asian Solidarity in PHX this evening!
Mr Mahbubani you have earned my profound respect. You are truly a genius and full of insight
Deeply agree with the conclusion of first story as a Chinese...ppl here really don’t care what political system we have, either democracy or community. Our country has long history, we proud of the culture and we also feel upset of the humiliation had suffered. All we care and pursue is better life , peace and happy.
Free the Uyghurs
@@willd0g Uighurs are free in China. If you are talking about the obviously over-blown number of Islamist terrorists that is detained in China in the same way that Islamist terrorists are detained in Guantanamo Bay, then yes, those exist. People are in those camps for a reason. If you would like to know more about the reason, please ask the CIA on why there are people detained in GB.
@Jo Piscine That is just red scare propaganda. Baseless accusations because you are too afraid of reality. But keep on being afraid while the world moves on and leaves you behind to cry in your tinfoil hat.
@Jo Piscine There are no factual basis for your claims for a genocide. The Uighur population in China has been increasing, and the Chinese government has shown zero intent on killing a group of people. So you can keep on claiming "gEnOcide" all you want, but that is just propaganda. You are the one is who in fear of the facts. Sad.
so you think its reasonable to assume that 1000 "western" media entities with hundreds of different opinions all somehow conspire to distort the truth more than a single opinion, heavily censored state actor?
Most of the people & countries will always have their hatred to China, but me.
I'm one of a few people that love and admire China as a country.
A lot of lesson that we can learn from them.
I don't know what it's all about with all those hatred towards them.
British with their sins. Spanish with their sins (almost entire Indigenous people of South America were killed). French with their sins (read what they did to Haiti). Japan with all their sins (those killing & rape thing in Nanjing & all of Asia). US of A (do I have to write what they've done here?).
But people never hate them.
That's western propaganda for you.
Keep growing & rising China. Warm greetings from Indonesia.
Don’t waste your time trying to convert muppet Trumpers.
感謝，雖然中國也有許多不足，但是希望我們都進步發展，提高人民生活😊
Proud to be a Singaporean. Thank you for your contributions and keep up the good work of trying to make the West understand, especially the US of the inevitable.
Kishore was removed from Dean LKY School of Public Policy to an obscure post.. what do you think?
I am more interested in what Singapore can do next since it has done a great job. Leading edge technologies were supposed to lead to next phase, but it is not working, why?
Inevitable what? China being a global bully?
Inevitable what?
@Boonhwee Sim He sounds like a salesman for PRC.
Kishore is a class act in strategic thinking around the East Asia topic, which few others in Singapore able to match - and always articulated brilliantly and politely. Have a read of his books...................
He is brain dead. He knows jack shit how inefficient and corrupt a crony capitalist-communist system is in Communist China.
@@TesterBoy yet that corny capatilist communist country has less people in poverty than US and they have 4 times the population of US and 4th hat too in a very short time.
@@TesterBoy Your post was pretty brain dead . Wierd as China is often used in business schools as the model of economic growth. Im guessing from your comment you didnt go to business school, or actually visited China. Sure China has corruption and has its problems. However the United States has it's own corruption and inefficiency.
I suggest actually reading the book the talk based on before posting criticism of Kishore and perhaps you you might be able to contribute to te subject
@@patrickchilds2987 What was "Reality Check"'s comment *about*? The post was so brain dead it got deleted..
@@ragnarokofborg That guy Reality check is just a troller funded by the US congress to spread false information about china..
Kishore was being very modest in stating that Chinese individual's productivity only needs to perform at 25% level to exceed America at the national level! But the truth is they are actually twice as productive and gets paid at 25% level of the Americans!
Can not hear clearly
cannot agree more, China's national GDP will undoubtedly surpass US' in next decade or so, but the GDP per capita will be a long way to be caught up.
that's only small part of China's population. the majority, mostly in rural areas are still very inefficient. there is a huge potential there. With higher productivity, the work can be done by just a quarter of the people now. maybe 3 quarter of the rural area can be made redundant and be useful for higher productivity industrial work.
China because of 4.6 times of population need to produce only 23% engineers. To match America has to produce 100% engineers. Even if they exceed so what. They long exceeded Switzerland or Germany. Does it mean all Chinese have lifestyles equal to Swiss or Germans.
Very true
i never thought someone could have the knact of being so factual and well verse in the knowledge of history, economics and politics over the past century as the late LKY. His ability of linking all these events together and synthesising them to form the footprints for future scenarios is exemplary!
China hegemony:
- 60 working hours per week.
- 90% maths score or no citizenship.
- the word 'lazy' is taken off the dictionary.
- every parent must pay for their children's education, wedding and first-home downpayment.
- obesity is illegal for networth
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
%%
@@fookmohow2473 咕咕咕咕咕咕咕咕咕咕%%%%嘎嘎嘎嘎嘎嘎嘎嘎嘎嘎%g%
%
Brilliant lecture by Mr. Kishore. It’s the first time I have listened to him but, brilliant. Eye opening in some respects
If India can become 25 of US GDP...the Salut my Brotha!
@Jordie Don't you think that China has been making its economy grow more slowly to a sustainable level, after leaning from Japanese burst in 1990s?
@Jordie actually this is what western youtube, politicians think about China.
you need some intelligence to understand that debt is nothing in comparison to growth.
Watch lessons by different economists in India, Japan,South Korea, Turkey and Indonesia to understand the big picture.
Actually It needs lot of research to come out of western propaganda
We
.
Not so brilliant IMO. The USA has been scheming and running game trying to say China is committing genocide on Muslim populations which from my research is baseless neocon / neolib propaganda. The fact they're pushing those narratives is a sign for what the future holds between the 2 nations: conflict and war. Also don't forget sanctions are economic warfare. Then factor in western powers have proxies around China... This transition will not go smoothly. I don't particularly trust the Chinese government but I trust the USA government even less lol.
I don't think anybody in that hall had a millisecond of not being attentive to the lecture by Prof. Kishore Mahbubani; so soft spoken and at the same time very explosive in the content of the message.
I am so deeply grateful that lectures like this are available free of charge to anyone with internet access.
American are too naive about Chinese communist。
Every time I watch, I learn more and respect Kishore Mahbubani more.
Love his Sutras.
I used to read Mabhubani and works that cited him during my international studies courses in early 2010s. Nice to come across this again and perfect timing I suppose.
Much much respect to prof.mahbubani, this might be the greatest Q&A session I have ever heard period. He’s shown so many inspiring perspectives which enlightened me that the biggest resistance towards politics has to be the limitation of thinking “angles”, so many politicians are constrained by he mentioned self referencing discourse or I would call it both egoist and arrogant thoughts. If we really keen to understand the world, we need to accept the world first
SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
@@indiasuperclean6969 q
Kishore demonstrates linguistic genius by delivering punches wrapped in humor.
Blame whom we wish, but what we are witnessing is the Abject Failure of the Indian Civilization, (such at it is and always will be), if truth be told.
Blame whom we wish, but we are also witnessing the Abject Failure of India's body politic; India's Inability To Govern and To Benefit Their Indian People.
www.economicsdiscussion.net/essays/main-causes-of-poverty-in-india/2277
@@leochen887 Try not to be dumb .....
The most important part: this is a lecture 6 years ago.
People, especially American people, have to be reminded of his lecture given 6 years ago because the people are deaf........
@@lisashung9442 is it really 6 years ago? Then Americans are intentionally ignorant and resistant to change and embrace the world especially Asia Middle Eastern Africa
@@lisashung9442 China committing genocide, forced labor and military aggression around the world . This was nothing but propaganda.
@@frankgenner782 I totally agree with you these china crimes are all America’s propaganda. I have watched Daniel Dumbrill’s interview Rushan Abbas, Uighur American activist. I was very disappointed as I thought her talk could be logic and evidence backed but full of speculations and imagination, even a lot of conflicts in itself, which was a deep insult to my intelligence.
@@lisashung9442 Imagine it's after midnight in China and you replied to my comment in less than 5 mins on a Sunday night.
Amazing speakers Kishore Mahbubani!
All the questions asked were so good and important. Love his boldness,I wish they were more people as bold as him.
Not sure how it's bold to speak favorably of China. In China if you don't your given a martyr's death.
42:38 American University
46:16 American News media
47:23 threat to American Supremacy
55:42 reserve currency and superpower
59:35 China in 1978 at the beginning
1:02:25 Singapore
1:03:27 London New York to Singapore of Asia
1:09:21 western education vs Asian mind
Ty my man
Thank you
only idiots thinks of supremacy. honestly i have explored a lot about the universe. ideally, i can't and different between a simple bacteria and complex one. universe simply treat us as a mere event of nature. you can let your stupidity carry you away, but the truth is there is no different between a poor and rich person. we are just delusional and can't to read through lines/universe. some thinks the level of material possession make you superior to others. but the defining question is, do your material possessions make you live forever?.
@@siramike2654 The purpose of life is to experience, and if you’re more rich and powerful, you usually gets to experience more than a begged on the street
@@hiway19891 he is talking about the within world,,our morals, our values.. A psychopath can go ahead to acquire all..what will it do to them if they feel no value, morals or rules in this life? What to feel?
If this lecture is 6 years old, clearly Americans elites had not learn a thing. 🤣😂🤣
I think if you watch western medias and western politics for some time, you will realize that western politics exhausts politicians and people, for superficial issues. If the issue is small, exaggerate it to gain views. If the issue is sensitive, further provoke it to gain views. Politicians can never have a long term planning and vision with such atmosphere. Theid mind is always anxious...
Mainstream media audience are too dense for this level of political analysis
Yup, they’re either in denial or slow learners.
Americans politicians are controlled by big corporations, ie $100 million funding just for a senate seat, what that telling you.
They are already number one, they control the US through their proxy, Biden administration. Americans don't even realize they have been conquered. lol.
说实话 作为一个中国人 看到title就已经很为过去几十年前辈们的努力感到骄傲了
See what the Chinese government did to its people in Tiananmen Square... Your legs will be stumble
See what the Chinese government did to its people in Tiananmen Square... Your legs will be stumble
See what the Chinese government did to its people in Tiananmen Square... Your legs will be stumble
The false narrative of a superior white race is slowly fading away thanks to China.
不能忽视西方在愚民和躺赢的全球化治理体系的贡献😖
He even predicts the lack of global leadership in global pandemic. 39:43
This was from 2015!
Eye opening comments
the pandemic that originated in the same city as a virus lab that was researching the exact virus. you are right, the "leadership" 'there' complete fuck up (or well planned considering who suffered the most).
@@TheSejuice proof? opinion≠truth
It's not a prediction when it's part of a plan.
If the US government listens to Kishore, the world would be better off.
communist kills, - dont let you free! BESIDE THAT ASK THEM IS THIS AREA (MONGOLIA SOUTH WAS IT YOURS?) IT WASNT THEIR WALL IS BEHIND MONGOLIA SOUTH and now they force them to speak their language and have taken the books with their own mongolian language!
u.s.a brought matters of Xin Jiang but did not bring up Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq..... why? cause u.s.a bombed Syria and Iraq, australia murdered innocent Afghanistan people (where all of them are Islam and Muslim countries)
@@Fallingup690 Have you been smoking pot again?
@@Fallingup690 nonsense, hysterical propaganda
The US is completely dysfunctional- their demented president a sign of a demented and declining country - it may not look like it but in the next 20 years US will just be a second rung power with lots of nuclear missiles
I’m amazed by this lecture. Hope more scholars like Kishore can give lecture to Harvard students and reduce western bias against China. In that way, the bilateral relationship will progress in a much better way. Can’t imagine anything unattainable if America and China work together.
it is attaunable with the recent visit of President Xi Jing Ping extending Peace &
Cooperation to work objectively with the US. 😍
@@enriquepanganiban2103😮😊
It will not happen and it will never happen. The US will resort into all underhand tactics such as sanctions and warmongering.
As witness from the latest development, the US government wanna ban sales of EV battery from China citing EV batteries can spy on US soil! 🤣
An excellent talk by the excellent professor Mr. Kishore Mabubani
Here is something Mr Mahbubani spoke 6 years ago however Americans are still struggling to understand today.
Americans have selective hearing. They do that to their own peril. It doesn't matter whether American are willing to listen, China has been moving along.
Not only Americans. Look at the European.....
Some of us were listening and paying attention back then and sounding the alarm.
Americans are reluctant to understand and not ready to accept the truth
@@margritwujing not all Europeans, EU yes but not whole Europe.
"Those who can't stand to see the success of others will never experience their own"
That applies to people in a society. Not adversarial nations, especially when one is eager to annex or deprave its neighbors and destroy the environment like no other nation.
@@deanw8206 What you said is just not true.
After the People's Republic of China was established in 1949 and onwards, it had border issues with its neighboring nations, if i am not wrong should be around 16 nations, and within the last 60+ years, China has settled and reclaimed its territory in a peaceful and diplomatic manner which only leaves 2/1 nations that is India.
There are much more land that historically would still be considered to be chinese territories, but with now modern legalized international border, china hasn't even mentioned that they want to take those over by force.
I will not deny there are existing problems, but those problems shall and will be sorted out, but it's definitely not in the manner you speak of, which i quote "eager to annex and deprave its neighbors and destroy the enviroment".
@@christ7822 , Tibet was taken over and the Tibetans didn't want it. Now China intends to annex Taiwan within the decade. Taiwanians certainly don't want to be part of China, just like people in Hong Kong don't want to reunite with China. The fact that these places were once part of China means nothing, especially when marxists take over the government murder dozens of millions of people.
@@deanw8206 Regarding the marxist comment is bit outdated now days wouldn't you say? when now days the chinese governement is clearly doing much better than other countries in terms of servicing it's people.
History doesn't dictate but it certainly affects the way it will play out. Hong kong doesn't want to reunite, but the fact is that it was returned to China from the long colonization and ocupation of then United kingdom, which the cease was deemed a peaceful return by then.
It is China's goal to complete itself and return to before what was lost when it was invaded and splitted. I can't say for sure that the means or ways are good but i certainly admire the cause.
Taiwan is an issue on its own, evantually I don't think mainland need to intervene in a hard way, it is already presenting failings in social, economic and political areas, as you say there are people who don't want to return, but then at the same time there are people who are willing to, just as a story always has two sides.
But an exemplary example no one ever mentions is Macau, which was another teorritory returned to China. why it doesn't present any problems? why no one puts it in the forfront for this so called cause for the rights and justice.
There is no denying china is prospering, and these areas being mentioned are benefitted from it, so as long facts present that the mayority of people's lives are improving, I generally think it's better.
@@christ7822 Didn't read cause you indicated you believe CCP propaganda. You're cleary out to polish bolshevik knob
Hats off to a knowledgeable gentleman who speaks the truth. Thank Harvard Kennedy School so much for sharing this great video.
Very thoughtful, articulate and knowledgeable. Great lecture.
Hope my videos can reach those who want to learn Chinese.
I’ve spent about 100,000 hours studying English humor and Western culture. My native language is Chinese. I’m teaching Chinese language in jokes and pictures.
Culture exchange and laughter can make the world better.
50:24 China invited KISHORE to Beijing to ask for his observations on 'What foreign policy mistakes China made?' ....the US never invited Kishore to Washington for his views lol ..... speaks to the arrogance of the US!
Coz America government is a arrogant regime
Coz Washington never made a mistake
Washington did invite Lee Kuan Yew to speak to their Congress
Kishore probably would have recommended tackling corruption -- the entire business of Washington.
What a fcng ignorant shit head you are.i ssazds the ovod1 29 iwassan ameamsdcanmade vfruseticam cru 303⁰000pelr in no e 2112019.
So llToshiba thrzwine fi
MR Mahbubani is a man of wisdom, he is one of the rare intellectual that understands Chinese history and China in the 21st century. I look forward to reading his great books.
I think you Need to understand the current world situation. This is what a wise man should do.
@@暗香晚风 I too have read world current issues. But for me personally, every media have different outlet and story to be told so as to glorify one. Perhaps, reading the root cause is far more crucial is a must before pointing one's finger (just a suggestion)
This man is a shameless liar. He is being paid by the CCP to act as their mouthpiece and to pull wool over the eyes of the world. Only six years after he delivered his speech it has become clear that the CCP has global ambition, but the way of doing that is nefarious through bribe, extortion, predatory lending, honey trap and unrestricted warfare, such as unleashing deadly viruses to kill millions. To learn the truth about their plan listen to this CCP member th-cam.com/video/IYH_hUm1KG8/w-d-xo.html
Unfortunately, China is not in a position to be a world leader of Western Culture. As he says, China must and is on a path to restore its own culture but its own culture was hollowed out (and devoured) by the cultural revolution. The only remaining vestiges of Chinese culture that could be a basis upon which to provide world leadership is Taiwan, and was in Hong Kong. Basically China needs to re-create its soul. And, by the way, the speaker vastly overestimates the status of Chinese military power. Will 150 countries invite Chinese presence for bases on their borders? America is present in 150 countries for good or for bad (but it is true) and China's military is present in zero countries. Also, although the US has been generous in the past in giving the Chinese military technology (for good or for bad), the US weapons systems are vastly superior. The speaker's expertise seems to be in economics and he makes many good points but he seems unaware of the huge gap in military technology between the two countries.
@@danluzurriaga6035 What the CCP means by cultural rejuvination is the communist ideology with Chinese characteristic. As you said they destroyed every trace of their own culture. For example, the CCP now realizes that they can make a big profit by manufacturing and selling the Chinese traditional medicine, but they destroyed that knowledge in the cultural revolution. So they are trying to relearn it from the Japanese who preserved it. Talk about irony.
The speaker sounds so peaceful. Thank you! We just want our lives to be improved. We should not incite wars any more. All people deserve peace.
@SASA SASA go to Xinjiang and look it by yourself before commenting
@SASA SASA Now here's the thing isn't it? The Nazis wouldn't have allowed any allied powers to see what was happening. Meanwhile the Chinese are begging people to see Xinjiang for themselves. Big difference no?
Say that to India idiot. Brutal violent country
Give the damn SCS back.
@SASA SASA you can say that to the uighers all day every day. Their population count, life expectancy, education level, and income level have all improved since CCP became the ruling party of China. At least get your facts straight before you make a comment, if you are unwilling to go there in person to investigate. After all, no one is banning you from visiting xinjiang lol.
Love this professor very much.Excellent and remarkable speech.👍👍
👍👍👍👍👍
"When will the Dali Lama come back to Tibet?" - when will Snowdon be allowed back to the USA!
When will Julian Assange be released?
Tmrow. Why Mr Singh?
Actually, the chinese gov't's position is he can go to china whenever he wants. He was always allowed to go back to contribute to what he can to make Tibet more prosperous. But he needs to understand that he needs to stop all separatist activities w/ supports from foreign gov'ts and other covert entities including so called "NGOs" (american, Europeans, Indians, etc) to undermine the Chinese govt and nation, of course. It is very generous deal that the US gov't would never give, if the roles were reversed. For example, if the former ruling heir of Hawaii wants to secede and have tried w/ foreign help (including covert military support). The US would have just killed him as a terrorist long time ago. And that person, like Bin Laden, won't even have a burial place.
How tibet is taken over by china is quite interesting
Good if both can happen.
The most aggravating part of any Harvard lecture is their 10 minutes of circlejerking pre-lecture.. 🤢
Feel free to skip to 9:30 and not miss anything.
Cheers!
Thanks 😊
agree
Thanks!
You're a mensch. Thank you for the tip.
It's true about American media in US being extremely insular. Living there for 4 years in the mid 1980s was like living in a well. No Internet then, so no news of the world outside of USA. We had to call our families in Singapore to get Asian news. But in Asia we can read news about the world in our papers and on TV. But even with the ease of Internet these days, many Americans are still so insular. They know so little about the rest of the world.
@@gutemberguefelix7108 Because they pretty much are. The US has never imported a recession from another country and relative to GDP is one of the least interconnected economies in the world and considering Canada and Mexico make up about 50% of their international trade portfolio they are extremely insulated. The only links hold the US interest in the world is importing oil, exporting agricultural good and access cheaper labor, but with the shale oil revolution in the US the oil link is disappearing.
Literally the whole eastern hemisphere could disappear tomorrow and the US would get a decent sized recession and have to figure out where to source new commodities from but after that the standard of living would continue to improve.
@@gutemberguefelix7108 😂 insults based on ignorance are hilarious. Dude go read an Economics book, almost every economy experiences a corrective recession once a decade due to the short term debt cycle. The difference with the US economy is when other countries have recessions they don’t spread to the US making their economy the most stable economy in the history of the world.
Totally concur with you - my experience as late as 2007, the insularity of, print media, MSM and the man on the street was and still is ‘mind boggling’ !!
@@jamesjacobs3753 To some people, maybe ignorance is bliss. The US may have never imported a recession, but they definitely exported them. The major financial crisis which started in the US has cost other countries trillions too, does the US take blame for that? No... The cause of that? Wall Street greed. And when you look at the size of our country's debt against our GDP, you know what you see? Capitalism can continue to thrive ONLY if there are other countries to rip off, otherwise, there is no sustainable growth of standard of living. If the whole eastern hemisphere disappear tomorrow, would US have enough farms to produce food to self sustain? How about manufacturing? When was the last time US manufactured enough to not need import? The United State is just like how many of the families within it, a family that is living beyond its means, and debt ridden, with their family income, barely covering debt payment. Now the US has to print money daily just to service their debt, not to pay off any of that.
@@Anriko123 Speaking of ignorance, do you think really think the US has to print money to service its debt when interest payments on that debt is 1.6% of GDP? Or do you think the FED prints money because of it’s policy of quantitative easing during a economic downturn? As a fiscal conservative I don’t approve of our spending levels, but seeing how the yield on a treasury bond is lower than inflation I see why the do it.
Speaking of ignorance, did you know that for every calorie consumed in the US, US farmers produce 1.33 calories? In fact the federal government will pay farmers to not grow food to decrease the supply of food. Seriously, look it up.
Speaking of ignorance, did you know that 1/5 of the world’s manufactured goods are produced in the US? Seeing that the US makes up 4.25% of the world’s population they can produce enough to meet their population’s demand. The US does import products from countries that have low labor costs, but on a whole the US is the least globally exposed economy in the developed world and almost the entire world with only 5 countries, such as the economic behemoths like Sudan and Nigeria, being less exposed. The US could lose access to every economy in the world excluding Canada and Mexico and after an adjustment period would be fine.
Speaking of ignorance, during the time that capitalism has been the dominant economic theory death by starvation, war and disease has decrease dramatically. The average life span has by increased by 10 years since the collapse of the USSR. In 1990 almost half of the world’s population lived in extreme poverty, now it’s less than 10%. Seeing that this is a worldwide phenomenon it’s hard to see which countries wouldn’t want to be “exploited.”
Thanks to this channel! It gives us a remarkable lecture about the rising of political, educational, and economic systems for emerging countries, especially China, which has been progressively competing with the incumbent superpower country (The U.S.) for an extended period. Although there are some skirmishes along the way between those countries, but they're always learning and making something new in order to have a massive impact on their civilization and prosperity.
Brilliant! Absolutely accurate understanding of China and the role Chinese communist party plays in China and on international arena! 👏
This lecture is so relevant today! He provided many predictions and some of them have already came true. It was great to see Prof. Ezra Vogel in the audience, who was a great scholar on Chinese affairs.
Any prediction on the ongoing pandemic?
@@yapbt6579 pandemic has expedited his predictions to turn into reality. Before pandemic we knew US government is incompetent and inefficient, but we all underestimated how much incompetent and inefficient it can sink to.
Betcha your a schill for the murders in Peking!
His main prediction that China would become number 1 is completely wrong however.
China has started their decline. They will not surpass the US. Not now, nor in the future.
Jan 2022 .. China now #1 in debt and imploding economy and financial system. Way to go! Way to predict!
It is interesting to find that this is a refresh upload of the lecture at a time right after the recent US-China high-level talk.
The Chinese diplomats were decrying why the Americans would treat them with lectures and sanctions. Like Mr. KishoreMahbubani said, Chinese would want to show world the decency of our culture - we have a saying that "anyone comes through your door, is your guest and you should always treat him/her with courtesy and respect".
Harvard university want Biden administration to know what is the right way to deal with China.
At 21:30 KM is conflicted. He states the ccp as keeping Chinese nationalism in check, implying it is the Chinese people themselves who drive nationalism. Five years later it's more clear nationalism was driven by the ccp. Probably he believed the ccp would be successful greatly increasing nationalism( and a hatred of freedom and democracy) in the Chinese people; he was merely being duplicitous. What he didn't say was more important- that it is freedoms of individuals and groups, not democracy, that is the greatest threat to the ccp. Especially freedom of speech and association. KM's unwavering avoidance of the freedom arguments against the ccp detracts greatly from the worth of his views.
@@dagsmoko3889 I think it is better to break up China into different countries. We should sue China at the UN for anti-trust.
£pplppopppppppppppppppppppppppp
A very interesting presentation from Prof Kishore...Open Minded, Factual based..I think, Singapore has a great asset and a lot to learn from him.
Indeed.
SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER 🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
Only after watching this entire event, what aspired in Anchorage Alaska 3 weeks prior makes perfect sense. Great world view
what did happen, i wonder
@@chankwaichoi1 they started fighting like kids ahahahaha
Someone even leaked the footage
The Uighur issue brought up but with americas track record with Muslims it was laughed off
What Kishor Mahbubani, who is lecturing here, is saying is most probably true. I've been aware that the USA's downward financial slide since Aug. 15, 1971 has been caused by USA's total disregard for basic financial stability practices within their country. The unilateral disconnection of the US Dollar from the gold standard by Nixon in 1971, despite international agreements, was only the beginning.
Our (USA) inability to balance our budget, stay within our fiscal limitations and have a relatively harmonious relationship between our two political parties "scares" some of the foreign purchasers of our national debt.
I believe we show signs of "circling the drain".
@Moonland Almond gģgr
..despite China's long history., however in the last some 70 years of PRChina’s recently history, PRChina had become so extreme impoverished, where tens of Millions Chinese Citizens died from starvation & deprivation during the 1950-1960s Great Leap Forward Policy..and multi-Millions more Chinese Citizens perished during the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s-1970s. Only, after the 1972 Richard Nixon visit to Beijing to meet Chairman Mao and following Mao's death in 1976, the late-Paramount Leader Deng Xiaopeng then implemented "Capitalist economic reform” and “opening-up reform”, to permit China companies & its private citizens to accept foreign investments, set-up Citizens' privately owned businesses, as well as foreign JVs, that the economic development of China commenced and progressed forward rapidly, departing from the EXTREME Poverty Status, which were direct results of the disasters & failures of previous CCP policies implemented (1949 - mid 1970s).
The USA-CHINA friendly relationship following visit of Richard Nixon, eventually led to the U.S.A. under then President Bill Clinton, in 2000, to convince the U.S. Congress to approve/grant permanent MFN trading status to PRChina, which provided the PRChina accession to full W.T.O. membership in 2001. Following, China's W.T.O. status, hundreds of billions$$ of FDIs inflowed annually into PRChina, along with massive unprecedented transfering of tech know-hows and manufacturing from Western /Japanese/S.Korean/Taiwanese etc. companies & factories, established into PRChina, making the country as the World's Manufacturing Center Hub and also the main Global Supply Chains Hub. It propelled PRChina's GDP then in 2001 at just only USD1.2 Trillion to reach USD 17.5 Trillion in 2021.
Present times, PRChina has already clearly indicated that it does not anymore adhere nor to follow to the U.S. Led World Order, (as evidently conveyed publicly during, perhaps the most historic & openly frank (international broadcasted) exchanges between China - U.S.top officials, at the Anchorage Meetings, March 18-19, 2021.
i.e. PRChina will actively desire to disengage from this U.S. Led Order and to seek to replace the U.S.Dollar’s World Premier Reserve Currency status with RMB. This is obviously an EXISTENTIAL THREAT signal to all American Politicians and to U.S. Citizens.
Opine, moving forward, it will be interesting to observe how PRChina be able to once again manage those incredible high economic growth rate, without the previously un-restrained backing & support (financial and Techs IAs etc.) of U.S. and Western Countries & its allies, as PRChina moves away & disengages from the U.S. economic umbrella with PRChina forges its own Sphere of Influence to generate & create its own economic and geo-political development. Perhaps, a new Bi-Polar or even Multi-Polar World Orders is being created.
One thing is certain, whatever, this new situation or different New World Orders be created, the once relatively stable World economic growth model status, since ending of WWII in 1945, led by U.S. Hegemony may not return. With de-globalization of manufacturing and de-globalization of raw material sourcing…..shortages of all essentials and cost of such essentials raw materials & as well as those commonly used household manufactured goods will be impacted.
Worse, present time as at Dec. 27-2022, current Covid & medical & domestic economic Crises happening simultaneously/concurrently in PRChina, have now clearly exposed the incompetency of the CPC- Government's ability to prepare for contingency nor capability to manage in a difficult serious crises status. Reports coming -in, even when Citizens making emergency calls for police and ambulances emergency services , these are now left unanswered in most parts of PRChina, including the Capital Beijing. Opine, such is the state of affairs in present times PRChina, it will have likely serious ramificiations on future PRChina's Investment Profile and Country Risk Level Assessment, to attract the desperately required future & further FDIs and other Foreign Investments into China’s based Assets, equities, China Government Sovereign (SSA) Bonds etc.
Tiananmen incident caused by far more misery than the great leaps forward and the cultural revolution combined. You should not forget this part.
As a Chinese, I think it’s more than good for western and eastern people to understand each other more. We still have a long way to go, and even so, we’ll always be a responsible country.
Majority of the people in the west do think like that, domination or 'obey' is one of the few words they like to use as a key path to success in this world.
不要哈七搭八。 侬自家都不了解侬自家
Wish more American audiences be exposed to lectures like this. Very enlightening
There’s no point in that. Americans are bogged down with culture wars, gun violence, racism and hatred of people who don’t look like them. How does the country progress?
Kishore got kick out of Singapore civil service , know more before blindly follow him , now a China lackey
You have to be insane to think you could tell an American you'll be number two. The reactions would be so horrible.☠️
@@TacticalMayo "You have to be insane to thi..." Our cousins like a good laugh.
No, we are far less developed than the United States. We still have a lot to learn. We still have many internal problems to solve, such as corruption, the gap between the rich and the poor, sustainable development, environmental problems, etc. (although we have made great achievements, it is still not enough for us). But we have a stable government, a reasonable mechanism for selecting officials, and a hard-working and united people. It is the consensus of the whole society that the government and the army serve the people. These are exactly what the West does not have and what the west is afraid of. The more afraid things are, the more they have to resist and lie.
Good point, I agree
So true👍
Damn he just does not miss lmaoo
truly the consensus of the whole society that the government and the army serve the people
Lol China has Orwellian level Autocratic Dictatorship government ! Try fixing the mistakes of the CCP led Tinammen Square massacre first! Its very unfair for India to be compared with china because we are Democratric and our process is slow! Hopfully, China will soon be democratic like the rest of free world and move away from authoritative regimes...
China has succeeded in wiping out absolute proverty and is targeting simple proverty.
I witnessed homelessness in a short block right across from the UN headquarter, more than 10 of them! Unfortunately, the situation didn't improve today. Average Americans are toiling along, going from paycheck to paycheck.
The Chinese are very hard working which Kishore avoided to say. China was number one for millennia, not a couple of years.
Chinese ships with sizes a hundred times Columbus's sailed as far as Africa seven times during the Ming Dynasty. How many countries are there back then? The South China Sea was part of China at least as far back as the Yuan Dynasty. Kishore was wrong about this.
Cry my beloved country, South Africa! I'd wish Nelson Mandela & the ANC were such excellent visionaries as your leaders! 1:02:30 Prof Kishore, your informed lecture changed my perspective regarding China.
@crazywarlord777 Excellent question. I bet he won't tell us...
To my utter surprise that there is such talk in America soil, utterly different from anything from Washington, WSJ, New York Times, CNN. Kudo to Harvard.
@Blue Radio Our politicians love to arm and train our future enemies to fight our current ones. Gotta keep the wheel rolling!
Try to build friends, not enemies.
Watched the video once again after I year and still finds Kishor Madubhani a Brillant and Phenominal Speaker. 👍👏👏👏👏
For students who felt confused by long speech, the conclusion of speech is that US should stop aggressive unilateral actions.
And if US stay bound to multilateral institutions China gets to peacefully rise to the top. And then..
So, why are you scared of this?
That's a childish comment.
"And then".... What? Please, tell us... Rgr
@@hoyle19771 why are you scared of this? 這句話是應該別人問你？否則怎麼叫做賤骨頭呢？
洋人像靜靜的貓，但凡盯上你了，你沒跑了，出手穩準狠
國人像叫囂壯膽的貓：白哥黑漢秀一下肌肉，跪地穩准快
我擔憂全球的反華高潮，還在後面，早點回去吧，賤骨頭同學，這裡不適合您啊
晚安
@Deplorable_Brian Hi ,Brian,I am sorry ,Although I am not happy for ur words , but I know that China is the most shameless and deceitful nation in the world, I feel soooo sorry for my nation.....
This is the result of having a superiority complex and looking down on everybody.
America rose in prominence as a result of having helped win WW1 when being allied with Serbia, a country which sponsored terrorism (Black Hand) and their downfall was because of terrorism were they got baited into attrition just like the USSR.
@@Miodrag.Vukomanovic america rode on the coattails of the USSR in ww2. And what kind of nations attempt to take central Asia after a regional superpower fails? Not too bright
@@panama2468 are you bright?
@@snoopdogg7407 I mean, does somebody need to be bright to post historical facts?
@@Miodrag.Vukomanovic America rose economically because of it's large land territories and huge natural resources. They had the largest steel production in history. And being away from conflict(World Wars) helped a lot as well.
What a great great talk and sharing from Mr Kishore! I've learned a lot from the sharing and I'm looking forward to his other sharing as well.
I’m an American and this lecture opened my mind closer to understanding the Chinese perspective. And I wondered how the British felt when they were no longer the center of the universe, maybe a short period of resentment followed by acceptance? Please be kind to the world China, America by all means is transitioning the power quite peacefully…..thus far.
i agree, we’re always so harsh to china when it doesn’t something bad but when it does amazing things no one barely talks about it, it has gone to such an extent where people blame china for things that are barely connected
If you look the history you will know that when a rising power collides with the current one, it usually ends with one side dismember. British, Soviet union etc, America is transitioning the power peacefully but that is because they are unable to do it differently. If America invade China decades ago surely China will be domed, but you never know since both side have nukes. Also i'm pretty sure its America that starts wars all over the world in the name of so called democracy and human right, how many wars did China wage?
@@donaldduck1322How can you speak about China waging wars when they have barely entered the world stage? Let's see how they will do after 100 years of economic and military dominance. The U.S by all means has performed tremendously in keeping world peace, and I contribute this to their ability to welcome immigrants from all over the world and their generosity in sharing wealth and knowledge through their education system.
@@UnknownUnknown-hg7xg US started a lot of wars even before enter the world stage, only 20 years in US history that not involved in war, 4 years from Jimmy Carter, a great man and 4 years from Trump period. Dont mention US was build on Indian's skull. The US did something good during WW2, but the majority contribution are made by Soviet Union and China if you check the casualties. Don't mention the war crime that US committed from Afghan, Bikini island, Iraq, Yemen, Vietnam, Syria, Palestine etc etc. And you think America is fighting for world peace? Your entire country is run by the military- industrial complex, you think they get this rich by maintain world peace? As for welcome the immigrants, you are the immigrants and Indians took you in, now what happened to them and how many of them left?
@@kandam5517 sadly many posters are taking a defensive position about China nut are unwilling to take a middle ground. The perception of the CCP as being the same as in the days of Mao is ridiculous. If only they would visit cities like Shanghai, see their infrastructure it would blow their minds. Perhaps meet Chinese people and talk to them they would get over this malice your seeing in posts.
Damn, this speech was packed with amazing truth.
@Plain Truth I hope so too
Truth? Bought by China
@@Idrissi_Mas so overwhelming, you're blind
The speech is over 5 years old. We now know how China was poohing the bed.
@@dagsmoko3889 How? Do you mind sharing your resources and evidence? I am quite curious and quite shocked by the what the media made up and what people I actually know see and experience. I genuinely want to know what is actually happening. (Also it is quite surprising if ordinary people who have never been to China attacking China, if they are not paid, why spending their time doing something like this? This intrigues me ) Thank you.
What an apt observation by Kishore when asked about the US media perspective of the world in general (47:06) - "There is an incestuous self referential discourse among the newspapers, journalists... they reinforce each others' perspectives and end up misunderstanding the world .. the era of western domination of world history ... is coming to an end.". Basically, with the rise of China and developing world, the access of social media, internet and widespread availability of the alternative news (not fake news) the Western narrative is increasingly being challenged and exposed.
Couldn’t disagree more. China is caving, and the West will dominate another century.
@@STELLASCUTENESS I think you live in an alternate world, reality and universe. Your answer just reinforced the point made by the speaker Kishore.
@@victorkmlee Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't there a barrier of great censorship regarding the inflow and outflow of information penetrating the Chinese border due to its blanket ban on independent media and major social media networks? Again, I'm not well versed in this area so please feel free to rectify my assertion. I am also in full congruency with regards to what the incestuous self referential discourse is doing to the flow of information in western media.
@@richardpate-cranium5282 There is no blanket ban of foreign media in China. Facebook, TH-cam, etc. were not banned, they voluntarily withdrew when China asked them to comply according to their policies. This was the time when Terrorrists in Xinjiang were using Facebook and other platforms in coordinating their movements/actions. Before that, they were in China.
New York Times and some other US news media I think were banned in the midst of the pandemic last year for repeatedly distorting the news about China. BBC was just banned early this year in retaliation for UK's banning their CGTN.
This man is a shameless liar. He is being paid by the CCP to act as their mouthpiece and to pool wool over the eyes of the world. Only six years after he delivered his speech it has become clear that the CCP has global ambition, but the way of doing that is nefarious through bribe, extortion, predatory lending, honey trap and unrestricted warfare, such as unleashing deadly viruses to kill millions. To learn the truth about their plan listen to this CCP member th-cam.com/video/IYH_hUm1KG8/w-d-xo.html
So much insight from Kishore......every single answer was so sharp and on point!
Unfortunately, it reaches not enough people, and changes even fewer minds. But admirably, he labors on.
@@yjk5430 q0q00qq0q0àqqà
@@yjk5430 àqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq⁰0⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰00⁰000⁰⁰⁰àà0àààààààqà
@Boonhwee Sim Don't freak out.
sorry,u r no mind, that's why
Prof Kishore mahbubani knows China and Chinese so well, appreciated.
Please add closed caption. I like watching Elson Sebastian video with accurate cc. I know he's are a great teacher. Keep up your work.
After a long search for a professional trader with consistency matched with good profit, Mr Elson has proven himself to be one of the best around the world with his amazing trading skills.
The CC generated by AI is mostly accurate - at least to me it's better than no CC at all.
Do you guys want to kiss his foot?
Did you read this book online named: "How the specter of communism is ruling our world"? it is kind of so popular now, I also found its 10 Ep. series on TH-cam, it shows the answer of why the US is on the way to communism now, I was shocked by the truth mentioned in this book&video.
I am just shocked and stunned that this is a speech presented to Harvard 6 years ago.....what a vision he had!
At 21:30 KM is conflicted. He states the ccp as keeping Chinese nationalism in check, implying it is the Chinese people themselves who drive nationalism. Five years later it's more clear nationalism was driven by the ccp. Probably he believed the ccp would be successful greatly increasing nationalism( and a hatred of freedom and democracy) in the Chinese people; he was merely being duplicitous. What he didn't say was more important- that it is freedoms of individuals and groups, not democracy, that is the greatest threat to the ccp. Especially freedom of speech and association. KM's unwavering avoidance of the freedom arguments against the ccp detracts greatly from the worth of his views.
@@dagsmoko3889 copy and paste everywhere?
@@dagsmoko3889 says you who are obviously brilliant at reading subtext that isnt there... congrats on being fake news dude.
@@dagsmoko3889 Pure lies
@@dagsmoko3889 No, KM understand that adversarial electoral democracy will bring out the worst in people, all the selfishness of people. This fact has already been well demonstrated in the US and many other Western nations with similar system in place.
why is youtube finally start promoting unbiased china-related contents?
Good Point. You know the saying: even a broken clock is correct twice a day.
Because I think at this point the US actually is worried now and kinda gave green light for anti-China content.
This isn't anti China content. Since Harvard re-loaded this in came up in the feed.
Whilst we are discussing this, in China there is O positive content about overseas.
It's all rubbish from clickable Weibo articles, and brain washing from AI Weiwei
@@happyhappynuts Goods and bads are comparative. For example, Iran people democratically elected a strong government that believes Middle East belongs to those living in Middle East, instead of the US or Russia. Good for them but bad for the US. Meanwhile, you have to admit that it's quite difficult to find some positive content about the West. And as Putin says, "Don't blame the mirror when you're ugly."
While anti-China, neutral channels are also recommended.
The algorithm is not perfect yet😝
What an excellent talk, thank you Kishore!
Thank you for uploading the great lecture from 2015 .
from 2015? not 1 math ago?
@@lllsofia6210 Yes
@@randomVlog555 👏 wow！ then he is really a supper smart Indian. he can even foresee better than many Chinese leaders.
@@lllsofia6210 Isn't it a good thing ! I am glad that he could lend a fresh perspective to the opposites
Did you read this book online named: "How the specter of communism is ruling our world"? it is kind of so popular now, I also found its 10 Ep. series on TH-cam, it shows the answer of why the US is on the way to communism now, I was shocked by the truth mentioned in this book&video.
Simply explained on how the world is functioning. Love listening to widely read people and vision
This mans perspective is still inspiring if you take his invitation to look at it from his point of view. I do hope he represents the rising middle class in the Asian world who have the power to built their economy, education and institutions.
If not, then to which global ballance are we moving?
I can say as a Chinese that he truly understands China.
Ok pinky
just waitting 10 or 20 years,you guys will laugh louder and louder😀
Glorify China? Kishore was sucking up the American audience so much with sweet words for the so called American political correctness here. I was gonna throw up😂
@@petervillalba3925 好的白皮虫豸
@@MissAwa515 😅so funny
US should be ashamed for doesnt have some people like Kishore Mahbubani.
u.s.a brought matters of Xin Jiang but did not bring up Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq..... why? cause u.s.a bombed Syria and Iraq, australia murdered innocent Afghanistan people (where all of them are Islam and Muslim countries)
Actually you get a very large variety of views (like them or not) in the USA. Many countries only tout a single narrative.
@@georgeinjapan6583 How many countries have you been to make this conclusion? From my perspective, I call the situation in the USA uncivilized. And this is the fact for a country with no history. A better education system for all US citizens is the most urgent need for the US.
@@kotobaG I heave been to 46 countries, how about you? I also have friends/former students that I kee in touch with from another 39 countries . I am not sure why discussions keep turning into bashing the USA (even though I agree with many of the criticisms).
@@kotobaG OK, yes Americans should learn more about other countries and languages besides English. There should be a 1 1/2-2 year national service like the Peace Corps for all.
when china becomes #1 - Harvard will upload videos with the Sound really really low.
lol
@Carlos R Why?
@Khoa Nguyen they improve what they steal.
@Khoa Nguyen Paid $10 and expect $1000 quality. Lmao you broken ass...
@Khoa Nguyen salty viet spotted
Highest respect to this gentleman. He s really smart and well conversed
Professor Kishore is the most respectful expert in educating people around the World 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
What happen when US became super power. Recent events; Destroyed oldest civilization belonging country to rubble, all historical places Destroyed, oil, gold looted killed millions, Another country with same status Syria with no shame looting oil from that country, Libya, Afghanistan the list goes on.
Add on Seniors Genocide through a pandemic to this list please.
@Sami Ilvonen You mean US coronavirus right?
@Sami Ilvonen You'll feel a lot more comfortable staying in the universe created by Fox and Sky News. Why bother coming out?
@Sami Ilvonen I feel sad about you. But it's ok, you well see. Hope you enjoyed this lecture.
@Sami Ilvonen I feel so much anger from you, are you okay? Are you living in a unhappy life? Are you spending all your life on hating China? God Bless you.
Great talk by K,Mahbuhani about China! Hopefully China can emerge to be a better global player in science and technology in 10 years time!
@Jo Piscine With all the free information about China's dictatorship, it's willful ignorance most likely.
China will saw video that China will have 35% of the worlds scientist, India 25%, US 4%.
One of the finest talks I have ever heard.
Take away.
1) best education / for mind
2) best infrastructure / home productivity/ institutions for India
3) learn Chinese language
4) Accept no more humiliation from other than immediate family members
5) Do every thing to rise lives of my indians first and the world.
Israel will use China as a labor force as the transition of power technologically speaking is primarily in Israel.
@@Mr196710 we love you Israel.
What I think is world is one home.
Very one will realise that what they are looking for is being extatic in their body. Without external stimulus. ( Drugs/ alcohol/ comfort food) Only when one is rich enough he will realise this ( that money alone won't bring blissfulness). So first food on plates FOR all. Population needs to grow responsibly.( People should postpone reproduction ie marriage of women at 35 and 2 kids per couple)
Humans will focus to rise their consciousness, then all come together as one 🙏. ' ADVAITHA'.
Hope it make sense now.
@@alexabraham9035 None of that made any sense.
@@Mr196710 yup lots of typos. Thanks a ton. Let me know if it's good now.
Thaaannnk Yooouuu ❤️ 💚 💜
“It is far better for people to admire them for their deeds than to pay attention to their words”
Abd their deeds are horrific.
@@walkertongdee 😅
@Qi Jia New Zealand has signed an upgrade to the China free trade agreement, offering some New Zealand goods faster access to Chinese markets and a reduction in tariffs. New Zealand was the first developed country to sign a free trade agreement with China, in 2008.
This modernise the free trade agreement that was signed in 2008, brings it up to date.
www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/124058012/new-zealand-signs-upgraded-free-trade-agreement-with-china.New Zealand will already have 98 per cent free trade with China, its largest trading partner, once the existing free trade agreement comes fully into force. The upgrade has primarily focused on reducing compliance costs for New Zealand exporters, and other measures which ease access to China’s markets.>The Kiwi Fruit was always a Chinese Gooseberry underneath..China/Japan/Korea & Straila are the biggest importer of the green/gold & now red fruit.!!!
< The upgrade is only on par with the agreement that China already has with Australia. Straight from Scott Morrison’s mouth. Australia is still a far larger trading partner of China’s than NZ is. I really don’t know why the NZ - China overhype when Australia - China relationship is far larger except with a twisted political loyalty to the US.
Usually when people put something in quotes they attribute a source. Only liars don't do that.
@Qi Jia Admiring them for slaughtering your people?
WOW this is 2015!!! This is shocking why Harvard uploaded this now.
timely upload...
Quote: “Truth is like poetry.
And most people fucking hate poetry.”
― Adam McKay
Most people don't hate poetry. They don't like poetry. They don't care about poetry. They might hate Obama who has destroyed America.
The video is a lecture at the Harvard Kennedy School's Albert H. Gordon lecture series by Kishore Mahbubani, a Singaporean career diplomat and former dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy. He talks about China's rise as a superpower, its goals and aspirations, and the role of the relationship between the United States and China in influencing China's rise.
What a remarkable talk. I would like to know, under current toxic political environment, can Kennedy school still invite Mr. Mahbuhani to give a lecture about China?
They would never 🙈
Kennedy's school will be branded as Communists
of course they can, and they did. A better question would be: why is this lecture blocked in China (it is on TH-cam which is not available in China)
@@miltonmueller7199 Not only is the lecture not blocked in China, Prof. Mahbuhani is a frequent guest on China's CGTV and Guan Video lol.
@@miltonmueller7199 Except Chinese people use VPN, so it is available..
Yes VPN is officially forbidden, but China doesn't enforce this law..
Chinese people know all about the West, because we can see you and hear what you say on the internet... But do Americans know all about China? How could they? They never watch any Chinese media or social media, they don't speak Chinese... You have no idea what Chinese people say or think... But the Chinese know all about you...
“If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle.”
- Sun Tzu...
The US belongs either to the 2nd or the 3rd group..
Also keep in mind, China never called the US our enemy, but the US has called China the enemy, many times... But you will lose, if you continue like this...
I have to give it to Harvard, being part of the establishment they know history will judge this period in American history. And it won't be kind.
No, they will look at the people, shake their heads and laugh at how FOOLED you were by your politicians and media.
Its 9 teasers later and the only thing that has bern accomplished is a reverse in race relations, because they have been sppin-fed by socialists and while they had your attention, they stole everything that was valuable.. Control... All the while stealing our freedoms, one by one.
@Joseph LOL. apparently I needed to go into more detail for people like you to understand. Why I found it astounding that Harvard repost this six year old lecture by a foreign diplomate who gave China a fair and objective analysis in the mist of all this anti-China propaganda, being they are part of the establishment. Setting up another one of those WMD lies to go into another war in order to protect our hegemony, aka bullying and our world currency reserve status, aka Fiat Money. In the end Harvard is suppose be elite higher learning university and if they looked the other way or peddle this propaganda then it stains their reputation in the future, and why some at that institution allowed for this repost of this lecture to happen. I have confidence that the business school side along with the Law school side wasn't thrilled about this reposting.
@@shellibuhratgmail freedom to control?!😁.
Only racist whites, there is no other racists, say that shit.
Harvard is instrumental in creating the woke culture in the US so you could argue that inadvertently they are accelerating the decline of the US as China ascends
@@shellibuhratgmail Thats the sad Truth and I'm so dissapointed in Americans I really thought they were smarter than that to fall for such Hogwash!
Very well spoken and highly qualified, enjoyed this, thanks!
melodious delivery of exceptional ideas in piercing precision! kudos!
May I humbly devote one more Maxim=
The way critics get treated in China tells everything!
Could be applicable to any other cultures
The comment he made on the us news is so much how I feel!
Read paper only ...than sleep.
So the statement is not “If China becomes number one”, it’s “When China becomes number one”. Good to know
@@amon5124 yes and trump is GOd agent
@@amon5124 yes, all the ccp bots and pro-china. then you can stfu
@@amon5124 You Americans hate Muslims and hate China, but you love Muslims in China the most, what hypocrisy!
@@amon5124 you married her because you love playing on the submissive asian stereotype. As for how china feels about muslims, there are five times more mosques per capita than the US. And didn't they murder a million iraqis? Please, if you really care about muslims so much, just stfu
@@amon5124 Yeah.. were the Chinese the ones who obliterated Syria, Iraq, Afganistan and Libya? Were the Chinese involved in creating IS? You need to help your brains to read facts and not watch rubbish on the television.
His prediction is becoming reality after short 5 years
He is truly a gentleman. Really love his way which he delivered his remarks. Listening to his lecture just like taking a cold shower after a chaos day, then calm down
0090
Thanks Mr. Kishore Mahbubani, you are saying the truth about China!
It is not only about the media report purely the news inside US. It’s also about how they report the rest of the world. If the media is not objective towards what they report, the audience are likely to be biased, though they are not aware of this. Unfortunately, the western media are rarely objective towards China which makes US people even harder to know China. Free press does not help if all the media you access are one-side biased. A great portion of Chinese can read English so they definitely know more about America. I can’t say many American can read Chinese.
Sure the Americans can read Chinese. I saw many of you got Chinese characters tattoos.
While I acknowledge your claims of bias and potential bias and the harm this can and has done to relationships, what I've observed from the Chinese side, both through official statements, media portrayals (as well as other sources) reveals communication patterns also lacking in the objectively I believe we'd both prefer.
@@GB-ws8zx I agree with your opinion. What I’m trying to say is that as a Chinese living in UK for 4 years, I watch both BBC and CCTV so try to keep my understanding neutral. And I think most Chinese living abroad do so since they get access to both and care about both. What I’m concern is that, how many British or Americans will watch news from Chinese media to balance their view. Not to mention that there are fabricated news from BBC towards China sometimes which is just ridiculous to watch. How can the western people know real China if they only watch western media. I would say that the western media should be accountable for the misunderstanding of western people towards China. It is very harmful if you look at what happens to Asian in US now.
@@wendy9232 说得真棒！
@@wendy9232 You've been in the UK for 4 years, I've been here over 50 years, just a heads up about the BBC and what they spout in the media regarging all Chinese related articles are all NEGATIVE , remember your history when chatting with people from European descent and be cautious with what they say.
Kishore is not only very intelligent but he understands China well. The Chinese culture does not have that “missionary” mentality and a Chinese is often surprised/shocked at the missionary zeal of western countries in both religion and colonization of other lands. Two dominant philosophical schools ingrained in the Chinese thinking is Confucianism, which values harmony of nations, and Buddhism, which values peace and interdependence; both schools looks down upon forcing others to believe in your ideology or way of doing things. Confucius said, “To rectify your mistakes is to do great good,” so it is not surprising that Kishore was invited to China to point out their policy mistakes. China has made huge mistakes, but it is on a constant learning path. On the other hand, the US is so proud of its achievements that it has blinded itself. Its reaction to China rising is to demonize China instead of objectively looking at what it has done right. Many Americans accuse China purely on the ground of being “communist”, when they don’t even know what that term means in current Chinese government. The CCP has reinvented and realigned itself so many times that the only thing that didn’t change was the term “Communist” in its party name. Kishore pointed out that (one of) the greatest contribution of the US is to educate the best minds from the world in its universities. This is where the US’s true influence on the world is, not bullying other countries using force or the dollar.
If the Chinese government is ‘communist’ in name only why do they still make speeches about Karl Marx calling him the most important thinker in human history? Why does XJP extol Marx above Confucius?
As a Chinese, I find this video very accurate. But sadly I’m witnessing more and more aggressive approach from the party and thus the population. But even that is the case, the Chinese people as I believe is peaceful, and I urge my fellow Chinese to not go the other way around. We are to bring back the glory of our civilisation, which builds upon the progress of ourselves, but not through the aggression towards others.
I don't think that there is any other legitimate way to earn money nowadays rather than investing
As a beginner trader u like to take the opportunity to earn a lot of money... Get a professional broker and start a career in bitcoin trading
Bitcoin trading right now will be at every wise individuals list. In few minutes you'll be ecstatic with the decision you made today
Bitcoin trading nowadays is a big change to make money
BITCOIN: IS THE ONLY TRUE DEMOCRACY EVER EXISTS IN THE WORLD
Buy and invest in bitcoin and other cryptocurrency today!!!!
Smart, eloquent man. I will be looking for more talks/lectures. PS.. our town loves our Chinese group, funny , happy and just plain beautiful.
In fact, Chinese people are funny, happy and peaceful people. It was the western media portrayed them as evils.
I don't know how and why this video of 2015 is only posted in 2021, but more importantly, is to attest how relevant even in today's context or not. I like Lee Kuan Yew's video as it has been proven time over and again, his words of wisdom do apply with the test of time. I suppose the same as with this one.
Posted on youtube in 2012, a lecture at University of Melbourne (AUS), entitled "When China Rules the World". Worth a look; many statements the speaker made we're seeing now.
The West ruling elites and oligarchs enabled this, and were effectively Sun Tzu'd for decades.
Welcome to the Chinese century. Enjoy the decline America, there's no going back, the golden age is behind us
Thank you for giving us access to this great lecture. I find it inspiring for humankind
And never trust Western Media because they tend to lie spew BS 😃👍🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺!!!