ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ย. 2022
- You've spoken in the last System Of A Down song, and based on your recommendations, here we are with "Question!" Questioning one's faith and wondering about death and heaven and hell is the premise of this track, and once again SOAD delves deep into the theoretical inquiries of worldly problems and how we perceive them. I'm once again in awe at their songwriting. . .
Join professional opera singer Elizabeth Zharoff, as she listens to System Of A Down performing "Question!" for the first time.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Performed by System Of A Down - Words and Music by Serj Tankian
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I definitely recommend watching the original video without interruptions. Here's the link: • System Of A Down - Que...
Show System Of A Down some love: / @systemofadown
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WE HAVE MERCH! Check-out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎧 Elizabeth’s favorite headphones 🎧 : imp.i114863.net/zayoEM
Music Gear Questions? 🎤 See my list of recommendations: imp.i114863.net/yRyGoV
WANT MY CHAIR? I don’t blame you…and here’s a link to make it even sweeter:
secretlab.co/?rfsn=4692958.b2...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎙️Podcast: thecharismaticvoice.com/podcast/
🌐Website: thecharismaticvoice.com
📸Instagram: / thecharismaticvoice
🧑🤝🧑Patreon: / thecharismaticvoice
📺Twitch: / thecharismaticvoice
📰Our FREE Newsletter: eepurl.com/gz7Z_z
-------------------------------------COURSES------------------------------------------
🎵MUSIC APPRECIATION COURSE🎵
Want to understand how to listen to and appreciate music more? My Music Appreciation course is now live. Take a look at thecharismaticvoice.com
🎶DEMYSTIFYING SINGING🎶
My intensive 7-week course on vocal foundations includes weekly group sessions and private lessons. Learn more at thecharismaticvoice.com.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Elizabeth Zharoff is an international opera singer and voice coach, with 3 degrees in voice, opera, and music production. She's performed in 18 languages throughout major venues in Europe, America, and Asia. Currently based somewhere between Los Angeles and Tucson, Arizona, Elizabeth spends her days researching voice, singing, teaching, writing music, and recording TONS. She also plays Diablo and Dungeons & Dragons.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We have a sister channel: THE SINGING HOLE. Join us there to examine how ordinary creatures create extraordinary sounds. / @thesinginghole
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#systemofadown #Reaction #TheCharismaticVoice
-------------
The next SOAD song HAS to be B.Y.O.B. crazy screams. Great Melodie’s. Incredibly catchy
Up up up!!!
So much yes!! Chaotic energy, great tunes, amazing harmonies, overall just the perfect song to analyze next
Is this all people want? The same bands over-and-over again, because it gets kinda boring. For example, I love Kind Diamond. She did one. Great. There are many other bands to discover. Why are people so interested in rehash?
Kirk's been saying this for months now, but I gotta listen to the comments! He said to couple it that week with "War Pigs".
@@JasonSmith-lp6wg I’ve been thinking the same, I definitely want more variety, but with all the SOAD reactions I just think at least this song as well is completely necessary
The fact that we're not pushing radio/video is just wild to me. Vocally that song is beyond amazing
100%
La-la-la lalalalaaa lalalalaaaa lalalalaaaa
La-la-la lalalalaaa lalalalaaa lalalalaaaa
Agreed. Hope she sees this and reacts to it.
Just thinking the same
I think because most people on here are just casual fans.
Not to mention how culturally diverse radio/video is!
How are we all not recommending Radio/Video???????
I highly recommend reacting to Lonely Day for a very Daron-centric performance. His voice is amazing in its own right and he takes center stage in that track with Serj on backup.
Personally I prefer lost in Hollywood for Daron-centric songs but I love that one too.
Second Lonely Day!!
Would rather she chooses something from Scars on Broadway! Daron is so good on those albums.
@@endercrafter5104 lost in hollywood is one of the most beautiful soad songs out there
I love Lonely Day.
I love their harmonies in "Radio video", they sound both great and a bit silly, like they used to do in their early days. As much as I appreciate Ariels, Chop Suey and Questions, sometimes I just have to sing BANANA BANANA TERRACOTTA PIE!
"Is there a perfect way of holding your baby? RRRREEEEEAAAAAH"
Eat all the the grass that you want, accidents happen in the dark.
System has some legendary lyrics lol
Are The Kombucha mushroom people still sitting around all day? :-/
Chic 'N' Stu like the whole song
I really want Vicinity of Obscenity too 😆😌👌
Next SOAD song should be Holy Mountains!!!!!!!!!!!! Deeply symbolic and meaningful for this band
this is unironically a “correct” answer. if this is a vocal reaction channel the idea she would do BYOB over that is unimaginable but I just know the horde has convinced her of it. lmaooo saying that in the nice way! more people know the song so it’s getting recommended, it’s just a shame. this song has been in the top 3 for good choices for vocal reactions, but nothing yet. maybe we’ll hear her do holy mountains in 2024 lol because as things are now she’s done A LOT of SOAD and needs to please some other people
She should do the live version from Yerevan 2015. The emotions on the faces of the crowd are stunning.
Underrated song
@@jeffreycherep8264 agree!!!
Yes yes yes a million times yes ❤
I absolutely love Serjs voice but personally, I don’t think Daron gets enough credit for his vocal contribution; he can scream like a demon yet sing like an angel. I absolutely love his voice and hearing him take lead in System’s “Lonely Day” is just a great example. I also love how Hypnotize & Mesmerize his vocals seem to be more noticeable but definitely can’t forget about his harmony in Chop Suey, I had to listen to just his vocals by themselves and it was angelic. 😇 Lol. Great reaction, you seem to be shaping into a System fan, I hope you get to experience them live like I have! Such an amazing time.
Scars on Broadway all Daron
@@LuisDiaz-pr5zx Of course! I enjoyed their first album but when Serj and Daron work together, it’s just magic. 🎶 🔥
For sure. The fact that Daron can smash out guitar and sing so powerfully is crazy! He often seems to take the highest of highs and the intense screams 🤯
spot on. SOAD wouldn't be anywhere near as vocally unique without his contributions.
Yeah his vocals are brilliant and nothing worse than weak backing vocals and harmonies. And definitely doesn't get enough credit.
As far as harmonies go, i’m surprised nobody is requesting “Lost in Hollywood”.. I think it’s a pretty emotional song.
Though it was on the first part of their two-part album, I always kind of felt like they knew they were at the end of their road as a group and was like their final Goodbye.
I agree with you man, it's one of their best songs
Facts dude. I've been suggesting this one for a while but everyone keeps screaming BYOB 🤡
Theres no way she can do it with some of its lyrics
@@The_Absolute_Dog what about the lyrics? Are you referring to "fag"? It's talking about cigarettes.
@@The_Absolute_Dog why you say that?
SOAD has been my favorite band since 2000 and I never knew about the dream Shavo had. Amazing insight
Buckethead has some songs with the vocalist of Sistem of a Down, I highly recommend them to everyone who likes, they are on the album Buckethead and friends
They were my favourite band through most of the 2000's and are still Top 5 today.
Just brilliant musicians all around.
It’s cool seeing you here Michael, been around since the trailwood days! System of a Down is a great band and I’ve even known that it is you’re favorite band lol. I think my favorite from them is Holy Mountains. Also, looking forward to the new AGP vid❤️
Sound engineering and vocal processing synths are at play. The belting it's either humanly impossible or just plain otherworldly
Same here, props to my big bro introduced me so many good bands.
SOAD, Lamb of God, Tool, Limp Bizkit, SlipKnot, Linkin Park, Alter Bridge & Creed, Breaking Benjamin, Killswitch Engage, Nirvana (he's a huge fan of it), Oasis, Avenged Sevenfold, Blink 182, Muse, Paramore, and other many amazing bands from my country the list will be endless if I didn't stop here LOL.
Even my dad, he also loves musics that are more on the harsh side (Or at least it. was considered that way in his era. I think these bands' genre are called either Classic Rock and/or Glam Metal now), such as Led Zeppelin, Mr. Big, Deep Purple, Scorpions (he's a huge fan of it), Gun & Roses, KISS, Metallica, Megadeth, Alice In Chains, Dream Teather, Rush, etc
This is 100% System of a Down's most underrated song. Granted litteraly every song of theirs is on my favorites list, but this one takes the cake for me, it is just phenomenal through and through from the first guitar note to the last ladadadada. It pulls you in in a moment takes you onto an emotional roller coaster throws you around and then spits you out.
What about Forest, no one ever talks about that song but I love how it is constructed as well as the subject of it
Dude, I love this tune but it was a single with a video. In no way is it their most underrated song.
Easily top 3 for me as far as their songs are concerned. It has everything I want from them. Soft nuanced sections, fun riffs, heavy transitions, the list goes on.
@@SilentBob731 did you ever once hear it on the radio though? Did you ever once see the video on MTV? Just because it has a video, and was a "single" which as far as I know it wasn't. Does not mean that it was rated high enough. This is 110% their most underrated song. Also just looked, you were correct it was prerelease for mesmerize as a single.
They may have other songs that you you and me are just as good if not better, but in terms of critical success this song is unmatched in how underrated it is. If we're talking most underrated by system fans it's a whole different ball game
@@wolfinthesno Yup, heard it on Edge102 out of Toronto and saw the video many times on MuchMusic.
Listened to this song a million times and just now realized how awesome Shavo's bass line is when the lyrics start.
those slides do magic
One of the most unique bassists and basslines iver ever heard perfect encapsulates the mystical, but mysterious aspect. Beautiful
im almost positive he took the lead on all but the vocals on this tune. Shavo's a MONSTER, and one of the reasons i picked up bass in the first place
You would be correct. This is one of his shining achievments in the band. I think he initially wrote a large chunk of it and showed it to the band for further dialing
@@itsalways44420
Serj does the screams in this one. Daron occasionally will do this section live but, his tonality is different. You can tell when the scream resolves at the end into a clean falsetto at the end. Serj has a very distinct nasal quality to his voice.
🧐
Crazy, I honestly thought Daron begins the scream, Serj then harmonised with his own briefly in the middle before Daron drops out of the scream to the clean vocal. Finally finishing with Serj hitting a final harmonised cleaner vocalisation to close.
Ultimately creating a cohesive & inversed internalised and externalised expression of sorrow to painful cry.
Where both internal & external meet in the middle before inverting and at the end where they become one with both the sorrow & painful cry. Which in turn becomes a whimpered combination of both in a a brief sob of unknowing frustration.
At least, that was my interpretation of the first scream anyway.
Haunting, beautiful and deeply human in execution of the whole arrangment. As in the instrimental music, lyrics and vocals all combined.
All of SOAD have honed their skill and talant to deliver what can only be described by myself as the musical equivalent of Lived Human Experience.
@@soulsurvivor8293 I agree with this, to me it always sounded like Daron started the scream and then dropped off and serj continued , with the end and growl trail at the end is def serj
I'd love to see Lonely Day get covered soon to give Daron's voice a spotlight. It's one of their few ones where he sings lead all throughout.
Also, it's crazy to think that in the mid 2000's these guys were like, mainstream popular. Such a strange unique band that probably wouldn't see much mainstream airtime today but whose albums consistently hit number 1 upon release. I love SoaD.
A very much needed reaction.
OH god yeah SOAD was like THEE band in the early 2000. They where the reason i went to my first concert lol
Could also be good to see a reaction to something like "They Say" or "Kill Each Other/Live Forever" both by Scars on Broadway.
If she wants to hear daron's vocals she should go directly to scars on broadway ! So many great songs !
I want to see analysis on Daron’s vocals so badly. :(
The time signatures on this one are wild, they're dealing with conventional ones like 4/4 and 3/4, but also 5/4, 6/4 and 9/8, kinda hard to play but it pays off, truly amazing
Just 5/8,6/8 and4/4
@@gunesbulak I think what grabs Elizabeth (self admittedly not having really exposed her attention to heavier music while growing up) isn't just doing her noticeable counting, but when there is a subtle transition that reboots her internal metronome.
@@gunesbulak 9/16 too
@@gunesbulak the verse is in some form of 9. 9/8 or 9/16. I guess you could write in 5 alternating with 4 but at that point why not just write it in 9
@@chikuthoth don't think about subdivisions, and bpm is not solid in the music. That's why we have too much different opinions to talk about
"Question!" is written in the key of E minor - a somewhat unusual key for System of a Down, which normally relies heavily on Cm, C#m, and F#m. The song uses five different time signatures (5/4, 9/8, 6/4, 3/4, and 4/4). The acoustic guitar intro and part of the verse is in 9/8, expressed as 3+2+2+2 (This phrasing suggests a hemiola, and is essentially 4/4 with an extra eighth note on beat 1). The verse briefly switches to 3/4 (when Serj sings "Are you dreaming?"). The guitar motif after the acoustic intro is in 5/4. This same section appears throughout the song as well. The chorus is in 6/4. The heavy tremolo-picked section towards the end underneath the vocals is in 4/4. Serj Tankian plays acoustic guitar in the intro and deeper in the background behind lead guitarist Daron Malakian.
No 6/8? I'm pretty sure there's a section with a clear 6/8 Waltz feel
@@soullessSiIence Well, there's 3/4 and 6/4... so, there's 6/8 if you choose to write it down that way, I guess. Kind of a moot point, her analysis is technically correct.
Edit: Corrected a typo.
this is so fascinating to read. wish i could understand a thing! :D
Are you kidding? A lot of SOAD songs are in e minor. There’s nothing unusual for them in that key. Maybe you should try to sharpen your listening skills a bit more bruh.
@@joejackson9986 name one other song please…
You don’t know shit clearly
I love that you unknowingly pretty much nailed the "lalalalalalalalala" from BYOB before hearing it haha
Holy Mountains is, in my opinion, one of their greatest works. Its a very meaningful song, and Serj does an INCREDIBLE job singing it. (I recommend the studio version)
One of the more powerful for sure.
So glad I'm not the only one who thinks this is a major stand-out. That and "full" version of Soldier Side bring me to tears.
Absolutely.
Couldn't agree more. Holy Mountains is one of their best.
That song is POWERFUL.
Sad Statue is such a slept on song when I hear people talk about System of a Down. Some stellar harmonies and Daron’s super high singing in the back towards the end still gives me goosebumps
If she did Sad Statue I would pass out fron excitement. My fave song by SOAD and phophetic in many ways. Prison Song would be awesome as well. In the end SOAD could be a year long dive but any we get are all treasures.
Love that song
radio video would also be fun.. or old soad. like PLUCK or soil
also Cigaro 😅
Deer Dance and Sad Statue are my two favourites
When I was 14 I always felt left out and misunderstood because no one in my class or friend's circles liked SOAD [I was obssessed with this song in particular], it makes me so happy that it's now so highly appreciated by other people, brings a tear to my eye :')
Don't mind them, probably reggaeton/trap listeners by now 🤭
You're so sweet :)
The only person that I know personally that likes SOAD as much as me is my best friend, every other friend of mine that knows them likes only a few of the most mainstream songs (Aerials, Toxicity..) and I feel that they don't get the true vibe of SOAD...
For the time signatures, the main riff is in 5/4, the intro riff is in 9/8, the first two choruses are in 3/4, the last chorus is in 4/4, and the verses switch between 9/8 and 6/8.
I'm proud to say I counted 9 correctly 🤣 working with my drummer is paying off 🤘🏼
There were times when Daron relegated Serj to backing vocal status on Mesmerize and Hypnotize, but overall him taking on a bigger role in the vocals worked well. The two harmonize well together, and as long as Serj has the main role and Daron the complimentary role magic happens. Although Lonely Day is magic too.
Also, kudos for Shavo and John for being the unsung heroes that give the other two a solid foundation to strut upon.
He did a Billy Corgan and receive all the revenue for writing credits. IMO that's selfish and a bit scammy but I'm not going to tell anyone how to do their finances
@@franciscoborjaescobarsuare5802 who are you referring to?
@@franciscoborjaescobarsuare5802 I don't know what you are talking about, Malakian and Tankian both have shared credits on most albums with Malakian and Tankian having equal writing credits on their first album, with Tankian having more on Toxicity (14 to 13), and the same on Steal this Album (16 to 15). On Mezmerize and Hypnotize Malakian takes a lead on writing with 11 to 6 on the former and 12 to 8 on the latter; even Odadijian has 10 writing credits over the 5 albums mentioned.
So which of the two primary writers is the one that is supposedly taking all the writing credit?
Daron doesn't get enough love.
Very well said.
"Ego Brain" or "Mr. Jack" are a couple of hidden gems in SOADs astounding catalog. Be safe everyone and much love!
Mr. Jack is one of my favorites from Steal This Album! The guitar sound is so insanely heavy and the contrast between the whispering and screaming make it extremely powerful
Mr. Jack is my go to SOAD song.
I think that this is the most 'beautiful' song that SOAD has produced - between the raw, extended phrasing in the chorus, or the haunting harmony/melody combinations, or the way that runs in the vocal and melodies move together seamlessly, not to mention the lyrics.... just a phenomenal song. Maybe my favorite song ever from SOAD.
Totally agree, this one just itch’s my brain in the right way.
Listen to ego brain if you think this is something you'll love that one
Such a great song. I did want to mention that Daron is super responsible for a lot of the vocal portion of SOAD and deserves almost as much attention and analysis during these videos as Serj, especially with the highs and harmonization. Love these regardless, thank you!
Not to mention he writes the overwhelming majority of the lyrics and a good deal of the musical arrangement
Would love for a "Lonely Day" reaction. To be able to hear and analyze Daron's voice in a very emotional song. One of my favorites and a different more personal song for the band.
If you want to do an analysis of SOAD's Daron Malakian do Lonely Day, he heads that one with Serj on backing vocals.
Lost in Hollywood is also great.
Totally agree. When I need to recenter myself, Lonely Day does it for me!
@@andchi2000 Lost in Hollywood is an absolutely beautiful song indeed
If anyone here knows, “Dreaming” is a vocal masterpiece and is a must review, it’s probably harmony-wise their most complicated piece and I’m really curious how you’d react, there’s nothing else like it!
This ^^^^
Agreed
Dreaming is definitely one of my top 10 SOAD songs, it’s legendary
Soil, P.L.U.C.K, Lost In Holywood, Sad Statue, Dreaming, Holy Mountains, ATWA, Forest, I-E-A-I-A-I-O and Mr.Jack are their best work
For another short, wild ride, try Suggestions on their first album. Serj doing Serj things for 2.5 minutes. Singing, screaming, goofy falsetto, a quick ululation. It's intense and fun, and then it's over. Thanks for all the great content!
couldn't agree more. such a cool track. do it! :D
I don't know how this community got so lucky to have such an enthusiastic curiosity such as yourself to analyze so many different types of songs. Providing so much insight and just general fun! Can't wait to see what's next!
"ego brain" and "b.y.o.b" are also great SOAD songs.. These guys deserve to have every single song they let out analyzed by someone as talented and well versed as you are.. Feels good to live long enough to witness this.
Ego Brain is one of the most underrated songs. Fun fact, they have never played it live.
Ego brain is one of my all time favorite songs.
I used to love ego brain...forgot about that one! Thanks for the reminder....going to listen to it now!
Mr Jack is another amazing track really show both Serj and Daron vocal range and harmony
I would buy a box-set of you doing literally the entire SOAD song library for a large amount of money.
I am SO STOKED for you to do this one!!
This is honestly my favorite SOAD song that isn't super popular- everything about this song makes my spirit soar.
I basically know nothing about music theory or song writing, but I firmly believe that there are certain notes that perfectly hit our individual ears...Serj hits notes that are perfect for my ears. It's hard to explain, but this song moves me too.
@@angelaaltman864 I feel ya!
I always thought so too, but I'm pretty sure I saw this on MTV when I was a kid. First time hearing them and instantly fell in love :)
Mezmerize/Hypnotize weren't well received when they came out in 2005, but both same year releases contain a lot of gems. Never understood why some bands are knocked for experimenting with an evolution of their material. Sure "War?" and "Sugar" and "Suite-Pee" are killer tracks that set expectations differently for some folks. I just love the joy that we see when Elizabeth or anyone else who sits and listens to a song such as "Question!" for the first time. Isn't that what music should do?
@@angelaaltman864 Same brother, same.
One of the best vocal performances by them is done on an underrated song called Streamline. Unfortunately it doesn't have a music video to react to, but the song and vocals are amazing.
th-cam.com/video/AiChzM1JEkY/w-d-xo.html
This right here
Confirmed
Streamline is my favourite song by them. Coincidentally that song is also in 5/4 xD
Unfortunately multiple great songs are overlooked just because they are from Steal This Album. Such a shame. But I agree, Streamline is the best of them...
If you haven't heard Serj singing the Rains of Castamere, it's definitely worth a watch. Dripping with emotion and really shows off his incredible range.
The next song you should totally listen to, must be "Holy Mountains"
Totally deep emotions and great singing from Serj
Back to the SOAD ocean... Take a deep breath, Elizabeth, and then we'll begin this deep dive 🎶🤿🎶
Prison Song, Sugar, Forest, BYOB, I-E-A-I-A-I-O, and Jet Pilot are all great songs that are definitely worth the listen. Such wild rides. Really SOAD does not miss with any of their songs.
Agree, "Psycho" too.
Lets say all of the songs from steal this album!
@@arcaneTR People don't talk enough about Steal this Album!
Or Violent Pornography.... One of the best.
With SOAD, it's always been easier for me to list the songs I don't particularly like than the ones I love 😂
If you haven’t already I would humbly and highly recommend Streamline!!Another great example of Serj’s deeply unique sound spread amongst interjected and distinct sections of “throat fire” and that sweeping, entrancing, float on the wind and sand vocals.
Also, m’lady, just as so many others have said - you have absolutely rekindled my LOVE for Serj and SOAD after so many dormant years 🙏🏻💛
Streamline is fucking dope! Everyone always quotes the same sheep song song title but most haven't really listened to their music in full.
This
MUH LADY 🎩🤏
This song is an absolute masterpiece. The time signatures, contrasts, tension, beauty, power…all packed into 4 minutes. That last chorus leading up to the big scream, the way they veer into common 4/4 time with the same melody that was sung over 6/8 in the previous choruses - ferocious and sublime. Just absolutely brilliant, unique music.
Something that should be noted is that Serj harmonizes with himself in the verses ("are you dreaming?" section)
He then harmonizes with Daron for the prechorus ("dreaming the night/dreaming alright" section) and chorus.
They both scream/growl in their songs interchangeably, but Serj does all the screams in this particular song.
Serj wrote and played the acoustic guitar parts, Daron the electric parts in this song
Even the scream at 15:40 ? I can hear them both screaming, but I still can't decide who goes "louder"
@@pedroivomartins9905 Serj is screaming (overdubbed, but still him), Daron is sustaining his line ("till we die..."), and seems to distort for about half a second to end with an "eeee-ohhhh" sound
Both Daron and Serj were born to sing, separately and together. Their natural raw voices are amazing 🖤🖤🖤
While I agree, I do think Daron has a voice that's better in moderation. Too much of him gets borderline annoying. It's why I don't like their newer stuff compared to their older stuff. They seem to increase Daron's vocals by a certain percentage every album and it just makes things sound awkward to me. Serj is, and always should be, the voice of System of a Down in their songs, not Daron.
knowing that this song was inspired by a dream, the transitions between the choppy staccato verses and the more fluid chorus almost makes you feel like you're having a dream where the scene keeps changing.
I saw them in 2006 and they opened with this song.. Followed with BYOB. It was incredible. Serj did a lot of the intense screaming
I've replayed this song countless times throughout my life and you've allowed me to hear this song in an entirely new capacity, and I appreciate it even more now. The Charismatic Voice is definitely one of my favorite TH-cam channels.
Literally the only band that i can think of that literally EVERY song is an absolute masterpiece. I put their whole discography on shuffle and never skip a song. Cant say that for really any other band, you know pretty typical to prefer maybe a couple albums over others.
The only other band like this imo are Tool.
Sure we only got five albums, but damn were they freaking fantastic ones.
@@vitaemecha yeah even masters of a genre like Metallica have "eh" material.
TooL and SOAD never bore.
100%
Absolutely right
I skip few song only when not in the right mood
I rarely comment on YT but i need to say. The main thing i love about your videos with SOAD is that i feel this is the closest i could get to experiencing these songs for the first time again. I listen to these songs all the time but seeing your reactions takes me back and reignites emotions for this music that i felt as a young teenager. I can't recommend any other songs, i just hope you make your way through as much System as possible❤️
Goosebumps with this song every time.
Absolutely awesome vid! The next thing is to get Serj for an interview 🤘🏻
YES!!! I’ve been waiting so long for this one. But let’s not forget about Daron Malakain. Most of the higher vocals and harmonies in this song are him. Serj and Darons voices compliment each other so much, with Serj’s sharp and forward sound and Daron’s clear cut and smooth voice (well, when he’s not taking care of the growls and screams)
I'm a big fan of Daron's voice. His screams and singing. BYOB and Lonely Day are musts
I love this song, and the harmony in the chorus is gorgeously haunting. Each voice tells me two different approaches to the question at hand (Where do we go when we die?): As with Serj I get that perhaps more curious, a bit afraid inquiry, Daron is saying "I´m desperate to know, I NEED to know this or I can´t go on".
SOAD vocals are one of the few bands that can communicate through the voices themselves, besides the words. At least to me.
Over-thinking: I feel at some point (Mid-way through the song, during the instrumental break) "Serj" finds an answer, but keeps it to himself for some reason.
so happy you listened to some of the comments! B.Y.O.B. is another one that i wholeheartedly recommend.
So many songs. So many harmonies. So many screams. So many time signatures. The whole discography is a treasure. If you ever get back around to Slipknot, Vermillion Parts 1 & 2 are worth a deep dive.
Oh yeah... that would be a good one. And I completely agree with your analysis of SOAD.
YES! Two Vermilions in a row!
I hope she goes through a lot more of both. Slipknot has some surprising range.
Here we go, with the slipknot sh-t... I wonder why people like that garbage.
@@EagleBreasts If you don't like them, you don't have to listen to them. Moving on.
These deep dives are incredible - I saw someone else say that it feels like listening to the song for the first time again, and that's so true. Crazy having it feel so fresh, being a fan for almost 20 years! The energy, interest and insight here is so inspiring!
SOAD has been my favorite band for a long time. I think you should do Radio/Video next! Amazing song!!
Love these walks back through SOAD songs, reminds me just how unique they are and how awesome some of their hits are
Definitely nothing like them. They are so clean and tight. Everything in unison. Beautiful rests.
I enjoy your SOAD breakdowns intensely; I have a few that I consistently listen to, that are really good to sing along to and harmonize with:
ATWA, BYOB, and then Lonely Day and Soldier Side are more sad and singing-driven. Lonely Day is my go-to to sing with after a hard day, it's extremely heart-wrenching and emotional. It's a lot different than most SOAD songs. ATWA is also very good, it is extremely emotional and has a TON of Serj's heart put into it. So looking at what you've been enjoying out of them, I'd recommend:
-ATWA
-Lonely Day
-BYOB
And adding in 'Old School Hollywood' because it's a bop and ridiculous, I learned the guitar for it.
Lonely day is a freaking fantastic song, definitely should be next on the SOAD list. An ABSOLUTE harmony of vocal and instrumental. Brilliance.
And Old School Hollywood is just pure, unadulterated fun. Love them both.
BYOB would be a fun one because of how much it switches things up within the song
I second this, also with lonely day and soldier side you hear the backup vocalist (sorry I don’t know his name) take a more prominent role.
I seriously reccomned Hypnotize, Lonely Day, Needles, I-E-A-I-A-I-O, and Forest, they're all beautifully made and their lyrics are just so emotional
I’m a huge life-long fan of SOAD and I love every single one of their songs, but as far as the vocals go I would recommend Holy Mountains or Lost in Hollywood
Yes Holy Mountains.
@@Meccarox Holy Mountain for sure...
Lost in Hollywood mannnnnnn, so good.
I almost cried listening to it live.
5/4, 9/8, 6/4, 3/4 and 4/4 for time signatures. Absolutely insane and awesome how they blended it all to sound so beautiful!
Would love to recommend "Bother" by Stone Sour. That song made me absolutely love Corey Taylor's clean vocals. It has so much depth and meaning to the lyrics, too!
That shook me at 13:50. I've never heard someone embrace the break in their scream that much. Usually vocalists want a pure scream (if that's a thing) and the voice crack would be a retake but he owned it
DREAMING is one you HAVE to do. You will love it. The crossover vocals and independent waves over harmonics is beautiful!
Hi Elizabeth, another great reaction! I never expected my recommendation to blow-up like that, so I'm really glad you liked it :) One thing I love about the visuals on this video is how the 'stage show' parts juxtaposed with the cinematic sections mirrors the Questions around Life/Death/Dream/Reality. (The bit with the horse riders is a perfect example of this)
I love how giggly you get whenever you listen to SOAD! It's so much fun seeing how much you enjoy Serj's singing. You definitely need to listen to more of his solo work. "Lie Lie Lie" and "Honking Antelope" are great, there is also one called "Feed Us" which has a studio recorded acoustic version, it was a bonus track, which I absolutely love.
Great picks, also "The Charade"!
2nd for the “Honking Antelope” suggestion
I know I'm super late, but far as SoaD goes, this is my all-time favorite....there's something about it that I can't place. Some kind of fantasy/mystery about it. Anyway, so glad to see you finally got to it!
I'm surprised no one has mentioned the fact that Serj is actually a trained opera singer! That's why he has such masterful and tight control of his vocals and you can bet every single vocalisation is deliberate ❤
Passenger by Deftones is mostly sung by Maynard James Keenan and his performance is so beautiful and mysterious
It's probably the best song about giving road head
My top suggestion for Serj's vocal brilliance and just everything that is SOAD as a whole is "Suggestions" from their first full length album. Way too good.
based
I just realized why suggestions and question have been in my top 3 fav songs of theirs for so long. Spiritually they just feel similar, like they have this dream like element and they both feel very dramatic but also whimsical in a way. Watching Elizabeth analyze their insane talent is so awesome.
Did you notice things like vocals two octaves apart in 1:37, a detuned guitar in 2:36 or double kick dropping in 2:59 ? Also, duets of Daron and Serj are surely underrated, as well as Daron himself. Not to mention an excellent music video. Truly a masterpiece!
Darin's ability to get those high notes is so clutch in this song.
Whoa I'm kind of surprised by the amount of soad/serj videos in such a short time but not complaining ofc! 😅😊
I'll back off for a little bit soon, I just needed to get a fix in. Much like I did the first time I heard Dio!
@@TheCharismaticVoice Speaking of Dio, aren't we overdue?🤔
Your face is exactly what I'd expect from someone listening to the SOAD best songs like this one! Goosebumps, amazement and complete eargasm all together.
This is my all time favorite System of a Down song, and I'm so happy you covered it!
This is probably my favorite SOAD song, I'm surprised I don't see more people mention it
“Streamline” has some great harmonies between Serj & Daron, and showcases Serj’s vocals well.
“A.T.W.A.” is another solid tune where they pack a lot into less than 3 minutes.
“Vicinity of Obscenity” is just insane.
This was so fun to watch. I love this song, all the crazy time signatures, emotional depth, and watching somebody discover it with your knowledge base was delightful!!
So excited for this one!! I love watching you discover different aspects of SOAD's music, especially Serj's insane vocals. Thank you for reading the comments and delivering! :)
Would love to see you react to "Innervision" by SOAD. Serj harmonizes with himself on multiple layers through a bunch of the song
This being one of my favorite songs of soad, I'm happy to see you finally get to experience the craziness yet satisfying mix of melodies and screams . I would recommend "lonely day" and "byob" from soad . War pigs by black sabbath is another one I would like to see
Watching people get startled from the last 3 seconds of this song never gets old.
System always finds ways to totally catch the brain off guard in super funny and refreshing ways! The la la's always feel super cool and funny at the same time XD
Can I recommend ‘Almost Easy’ by Avenged Sevenfold? I’d highly recommend the live version that they did in Long Beach. Great and intense instrumental and vocal performance from the whole band. You can find it by searching A7X Almost Easy Live at the LBC.
I love the way you analize the SOAD songs. I suscribe for more music (not only SOAD, of course). Greetings from Spain
One of my favorite SOAD songs is "Tentative" - the emotion and desperation in his voice is off the charts. It switches back and fourth between the extremes of desperation - violence to an almost hopeless surrender, and in the end...well...where do you expect us to go when the bombs fall?
I saw the time signatures kicking your butt at the beginning and was like "good luck" I had to look it up even after listening to it many many times being that it's my favorite of their songs. There's so much going on and it blinds together and flows so well that it's easy to miss which is insane.
I need "Hypnotize" bad now!
Your reactions to music and music videos are a blessing to us all, such in depth commentary and break downs of everything going on. Great stuff. 🌸
Listening to you enthralled with SOAD is just a delight. These reactions are amazing, and your technical insights are great too!
Long time fan and Patreon supporter here! I appreciate you and this channel so much, and I'm loving this new SOAD phase--I'm sure it's already on your list, but "I-E-A-I-A-I-O" is packed with tongue-twisters, great harmonies, and the chorus is one of your favorite things--an epic diphthong! "Sugar" is also a really playful one I think you'd like. Keep doing you!!
Absolutely agree
It is incredible watching someone get the same feelings I have been having about this song for over 15 years. I think this song is an utter masterpeice that is so underappreciated. Thankyou for showing it so much care.
Love that you did this song very cool !
I hope you'll be analysing SOAD for a while. They have a lot of good tracks. We only run out of good tracks because we run out of tracks. But then you can move onto Serj and Daron's respective solo work - most of which is very good too. It's quite interesting listening to their separate works and getting to isolate their different influences which you hear in combined form in SOAD.
If you enjoyed this song I wnat you to experience their other song, Streamline. Like this one it has some fun time signatures and Serjs vocal performance is great as always, so I highly recommend you check it out.
Soldier Side and Holy Mountains are so great at showcasing the incredible vocal symbiosis Serj and Daron have on track. You should definitely check them out.
Girl, just love your videos
Oh my God yes I've been waiting for you to do this one!!!!!!
This is the song I recommend everyone to get to know what soad is capable of.
*Count Dooku* : "I've been looking forward to this!"
Thanks for breaking this one down. *Almost no one analyzes or reacts to this song, and even then they don't really do anything except rock out to it.
Question (heh), Is Leprous going to make a return to the channel someday?