Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite vs Renault Kiger | पंच या sub-4 SUV? | Space And Practicality Compared
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 พ.ย. 2021
- If you are looking for a compact SUV on a budget, the obvious choices are the Nissan Magnite and the Reanult Kiger. Not only are they practical for the family, but they also pack quite a punch for the price. Now, however, Tata has a new proposition. Yes, it is slightly smaller but has urban SUV potential, a decent feature list and is value for money as well. We decided to get all the three together to figure out if there is a hidden compromise in buying the Punch, or do the Magnite or Kiger still make more sense for an urban family.
- ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
![[Live] : ONE 167 วันนี้!! "ตะวันฉาย vs โจ"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/D9_dvfIa6Ao/mqdefault.jpg)
Magnite best base model ever 🙌❤️
No servicing centre
@@netke6177 humare city me toh hai ..
❤️❤️
Magnite 🔥🔥🔥
Honestly Kiger is best ❤️
Seems like the whole purpose of this video is to promote Punch against Magnite and Kiger no matter how much you have to compromise.
Because when the Punch prices were out many people started looking for other options and these two turned their heads around.
You can brag about the safety of Punch but how long!? You are not comparing here Punch with Alto!
These two hold good safety at very affordable prices.
correct
Yep We Should Promote Our Local Brand But It Questions There Neutral pont Like If They Will Promote Car Of Specific Brand Then it Clearly Means There Is No Need Of Watching Them
I think Kiger is better package of all..
With family we need comfortable back space and seats.
but magnite is bigger
Bro kiger is really value for money,
4 air bags, 4 star safety rating,
Aggressive look,
Yes, Kiger is a much better overall VFM product IMO.
Govt made mandatory now to have 4-6 airbags in base model too
CONCLUSION : KIGER is real TIGER...vth all included suv premium luks- specs /gud price/after sales service...
AC suxx bro.
Only 5% of the buyers go for top models,as far as lower variants are concerned Magnite and kiger offer much more value for money Variants.
No bro Punch is more value for money.. Base variants
@@dhonifanclub3358 magnite base has much more features, space
No punch is more value for money
Magnite is VFM and more features also engine has more power compared to punch.
@@svbaskar Lol that is only in top Variants
Kiger is a headturner 💯
Magnite is Beast ❤
Undoubtedly! Booked top end this weekend
Funny to see no mention of turbocharged-petrol of the Kiger and Magnite vs non-turbo Punch, especially given the variants that you are talking about!
biased video
Tata punch is beast 5⭐️⭐️🤩🤩⭐️⭐️
I bought Magnite XE white ( Base variant - Non turbo ,7.44lakhs ) ...
Look wise it feels like premium Suv and Road presence literally awesome 💥✨✨💫💫
Performance wise beast 💥in its price line .... easily it can achieve 140 without any vibration in cabin ✨💯💯
Build quality was peak
compared to others it's a Solid car
Milleage highway around 18 to 20 kmpl..
City - below 15kmpl ....
More spacious ...✨💯💯
Drawbacks :
1) without seat adjustment it looks lower when sitting..
2) compared to others it's big but you feels like you driving a weightless car ...
Conclusion :
It has more features in base variant compared to other cars... Definitely a headturner 💯✨✨
Everyone will think that this cars budget would be 15 to 20lakhs because of its look 🔥🔥
Definitely you can buy Magnite awesome car ✨💥💥💫💫❣️❣️
One question sir where you bought this and what is your height 😅
Sir I took trial of this car expectation was hundred and reality 40 maginite has much noise in cabin and while pickup we feel sound and vibration in cabin and gear vibrates very badly
Better go with Nexon base model. And if you have low budged go with kiger or magnite according to service in your area.
Punch feel low powered and also mileage is less.
cup punch best hai safety is priority not milage kiger and magnite has low built h=go for punchpure vfm variant and last to last ADVENTURE DONT GO FOR MILEAGE MARUTI WALO PLS CHUP HI RHO MILAGE LENE WALE BAS
I m using kiger...when I am driving like drive big SUV ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
How is steering response? Gear shifting?
Which model and price
@@anandsingh4071 nice 👍
@@pradipgharat707 I hv rxl
None talks about Driver's seat's comfort level... whether the driver can cover long distances without hurting his back or knees
Which one has better ride quality?
If u have a bad day which one would u choose to drive for relaxation?
Feature comparison with these mid size SUV's(rather micro SUV) should be in base price range as people opting for higher price can go for better or next gen cars. Coulsn't come to conclusion with this video though this is one of the latest videos in TH-cam doing comparison.
Magnite is clear winner ye sabse best hai bilkul
Engine technology, fuel efficiency, NVH level inside the cabin. Models offered, value for money option, automatic option availability missing in the review. Please make part 2 and cover all the points
Also need to understand the service network and it's cost....
Yes
@@sujitphatak7616 Tata has more network of services than nissan and renault
Guess what in places like Mumbai there is no service centre for nissan upon enquiring they promised it to be setup in next 2months and guess what it's been 9months none as of now.
So dropped the magnite. Kiger auto transmission is not at all good drive it before
For punc not at sure but service centre is down right pathetic and showroom people is just like government service
No mention of the yawn inducing, 18-second, 0-100 of Punch compared to 12-seconds for the Kiger and Magnite!
Magnite is beast..❤❤
Magnite comes with Bi projector headlights but in this review says normal headlights..pls check before do proper comparison
XV Primium me milege
Magnite is best. World class Japanese technology and safety.Only next to Toyota. Also looks spectacular on road.. I get confused to creta on road several times.
What you missed is:
Kiger and Magnite comes with 1.0 Turbocharged engine with CVT
And
Punch 1.2 NA with AMT.
Drive it once to feel the difference
No need to drive.... CVT is better any day against cheap AMT...but if nissan and renault need to improve service and open service centers in average cities then these sisters can touch 7 8k a month seperately otherwise punch will remain king of this price segment...
Woh kuch nahi hota
Magnite CVT or Kiger CVT 10-12L budget or anyone SUV, mostly long highway run & few bad roads for 5 people comfort, 1000km per month run. ; or S-cross?
Magnite best in look wise
The video felt like a Punch review rather than a comparison
Tata punch is best when compared on town r village roads. Kiger and Magnite are useful only for cities. On kaccha roads it is punch that gives us comfortable ride. This is my own experience.
Kiger anyday ❤
Magnite for sure.... Best for Middle class family... If you have little big budget between 8-9 Laksh then you can go for Kiger
The comparison i want
Please comment on Engine performance, mileage and overall ownership cost of these Cars...
Missed 2 important
1)Turbo engine options are available in Magnite and Kiger not in Punch
2) What about Mileage
Please address these also.
Yes
The intro is amazing. Loved it 😍👌. Ha bhai pasine to chut gaye hai 😂😆
One thing i observed he is underestimated kiger 🤣🤣🤣🤣 paise nhi diye kya kiger walo ne 😂😂😂
Kiger se magnite features ke vajah achhi lagi aur ek side punch ke sath compare ho rahi hai.
Kiger is not anything in front of punch and magnite..
Godi youtuber 😂
Tata ne sabse jayda paisa diya hai sab ko😂😂
I saw there is no rear wheel mudguard dome in Kiger and Mahgnite, it's too much of cost cutting
Imagine, Magnite with 4 airbags. It's a win win, 5star Ncap rating for sure.
Sir pls bataye muze tata ki punch Leni chahiye ya fir kiger... Muze base model hi Lena hai aur punch base model muze 700000 lakh aur kiger base model with 4 power windows music system with topend model touch screen and rear camera 695000 me ho rahi hai
I saw there is no rear wheel mudguard dome in Kiger and Magnite, it's too much of cost cutting
Kiger is real winner of compact SUV segment✨
Pls muze bataye konsi gadi Leni chahiye
Coincidentally I have driven all these 3 cars and Turbo version of Magnite/Kiger are so powerful and refined.... Magnite/Kiger competes with Nexon not a class lower Punch
yes, plus kiger when set to Sport mode, really gives fantastic feel to drive, it will be super fun on highways
yes true
Sahi pakde hai👍
You forgot kiger and maginte is based on Kwid platform, and it shares the same 999cc engine, Nexon has 1400cc engine with bigger underpinnings and stronger suspension, coupled with class leading built quality
@@MOTOFLIXGARAGE Kiger and Magnite are based Triber platform (CMFA+) not Kwid. And Nexon got 1.2 turbo chaged engine and Magnite/Kiger have 1000 cc NA and turbo charged engine, turbo one gives very good performance in beginning of RPM while in Nexon you need to build RPM to mid band.
It's simply trying to converting our mind to punch..for example - all the time he firstly taken punch name and magnite kiger isn't mentioning properly
I am of your reviewing style.
Turbo variants in magnite?
Tata punch is best.
Non Turbo AMT ( RXT) or Tata Punch Adventure AMT+Rythem , which one i should buy?
If say go for punch adventure AMT rhythm......
Kiger
Kiger
How safe is door lock unlock mechanism for kids??
I loved the looks of tata punch
I will go for Magnite..Though it is seen very less in Kolkata..very value budget car!!!
In looks it’s magnite anytime
In features as well
XL variant
Black magnite......osm h bro. ......best to nissan magnite h ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️😘😘😘
Magnite is ❤️
Kiger for ever❤️
Magnite
Kiger♥
Nexon
Punch driving ergonomics are not sorted. I am 5'10" and I still feel that if the seat is not height adjustable, as in Lower variants, the seating is very low and the visibility is not so great; the dashboard itself obstructs vision. Surprised how nonone is pointing it out
Bro I'm 6'1 and the seating posture is very comfortable as a driver. Driving Visibility is great compared to the other offerings, plus point you won't get the Tata punch kind of steering maneuverability on any other Brand. I have ridden all three and finally bought Punch for all the above reasons.
@@utsavsarkar4926 punch is useless only show off, less space.
I booked Tata Punch top model automatic. For me what matter was overall comfort, features, safety and service.
I drove nissan also, equally good but i was bit worried on service part and hence thought to go with Punch only.
I am no fanboy.
I need daily drive of 100kms and punch is comfortable enough for me.
It is in my budget.
Rahi bat vo power and beast and monster ki to people who love all that should definitely think of Turbo Engines and all those features.
I don't agree with you. I personally driven Tata punch and the visibility is great. The dash board doesn't obstruct at all.
मैं दो महीने सब गाड़ी का test drive लेने के बाद finally Renault Kiger Turbo engine CVT पसंद किया,
I am extremely very happy. It is the best SUV in India, It gives a lot of features and comfortable drive experience. It is worth for money spend. It is Bold and Beautiful SUV.
Kwid took steroid and become kiger.
Thanx Cardekho team... I was looking for such video for long time.. 😊
We're glad it was helpful.
Magnite best ♥️🔥
I try to list
Safety
1. Xuv 300
2.brezza, urban cruiser
3.magnite,kiger
4. Venue,sonet
Look:
1.magnite
2.sonet
3.xuv 300,kiger
4.venue
5.brezza,urban
Features
1.sonet,venue (sun roof)
2.magnite
3.xuv 300
4.kiger
5.brezza,urban
Nexon is no 1 in all above these and where is engine,after sales support, brand value????😑
@@Amoghgamer69 Ghanta where is reliability, services huh. And engine mein xuv300 is better and even in safety. Only thing where it lacks is old design layout and bootspace. Magnite hits the right boxes in most aspects, and gives the cvt varient in 9.5 to 10 onroad, which is far better deal. 😌😌. U can gets nexon xm varient whicj is not at all value for money as it lacks touchscreen
@@Amoghgamer69 Nexon has shitty exterior looks, xuv300 has better exterior looks, and yes everone knows after sales services and brand value of tata. 🤭🤭
@@Amoghgamer69 nexon not sub compact suv
I will choose Tata Punch all day long,
5 Star Safety Rating
Cruise Control
Auto Engine Off/On
Cooled Glove Box
Automatic Climate Control
Traction Control
Height Adjustable Driver Seat
HARMAN Speakers
Projector Headlamps
Brake Sway Control
Puncture Repair Kit
90 degree opening doors
3 charging ports
Homework toh thik se krlo bhai!!
I will not buy Magnite because the lock mechanism is from 90's.
And I will not buy Kiger because uska safety rating hi nai aya ab tak. (Dal me kuch kaala hai).
So do you mean, Kiger is good if Global rating comes 4
@@AjayKumar-nw2fh Yes. If it is a strong vehicle then Renault shouldn't delay the GNCAP. It will only contribute to customers gaining confidence in the brand
Theres no arguing that magnite is the ultimate value for money machine of all the three 🔝
Not in safty
@@KULDEEPSINGH-ui5bn why? Cos global ncap said so? 😂😂
@@midonjose2375 yes bro
@@midonjose2375 u mean ncap takes bribe from Tata nd Mahindra? 🙄😂
@@KULDEEPSINGH-ui5bn euro ncap is the only goverment backed organisation that provide genuine crash test results with a 360° perspective of the car. Everything else including global ncap are third party private car testing organisations. You can believe the test result provided by a private firm that popped out of nowhere last year. I don't have to. I'm not claiming global ncap takes bribe from Tata or Mahindra. Then again, I'm not saying that they don't. Do your research before you sound funny infront of random strangers on the internet buddy. Cheers.
Good my all doughts are cleared by this comparison
Doubt**
Thank you!! We're glad the video was of help. Stay tuned for more latest updates.
Kiger is value for money,
4 air bags, 4 star safety rating.
Aggressive look.
One of the excellent review 👌 thank you brother ,💯support
Thank you for watching the video.
Ghante ka excellent review he was totally biased.. He himself knew Magnite is real winner still preferred to talk only about Punch.. May be TATA paid him much 😂
Well, i would say i am not impressed with the comparison. I predicted in first couple of minutes that Punch is going to win in this comparison, which infact is not one. Reason being they way it was being presented you were more focused on Punch. The tone tone volume for good things/pros of punch was high and lightning and for cons it was low and less focused on subject. Seems like you were desperate for Punch to win. Honestly the comparison was felt partial and not fair. In my opinion Nissan Magnite is the real winner. Looks, 4 star rating, presence on road, more spacious and so on....
**By no means I am saying Punch and Kiger are bad ones. Just being fair between these three.
Yes me too Magnite is best of two worlds - safety and features .. rest the resale as well as Service may shove a point or two.
Yes I agreed.. punch is micro suv and should be compare with ignish..
Very fast review. It should be more detailed. V3 cars reviews are very good
No need to complain about the rear ac vents.....punch has something called express cool which cools up the cabin real fast.
Most waiting video ❤️
Hope you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching. :)
please help me bro kya nissan magnite buy karna sahi rahega future me iske service center me kami to nahi ayegi?? ya iski jagah tata punch ko buy karna sahi raega ?
jaydatar log punch ko prefer kar rahe hai ...nissan magnite ka future nhi hai india me ? please suggest me
Both the cars are good in their own forte. However, as per the user's experiences, Tata Punch is a winner for you if you are seriously looking for comfort and safety in your car. But Nissan Magnite is better on the grounds of mileage, performance, maintenance and features. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive before making the final decision to know about the performance and comfort better. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealership details: bit.ly/3BMNGLc
Magnite 💕
Taigun aur magnate ka b comparison kariye sir.
Magnite value for money
Does Tata punch AMT rollback on slopes ? I mean does it have hill hold or hill assist feature ?
I think the higher end variant has.. Not the two base variants
No hill hold on any variant of punch
6:50 there is control for the light , you can also program the duration of the light to remain on from 30sec to 90sec when the door is opened and also switching off the engine.
Plz research a lil more before posting -ve remarks.
I Have a punch and I have been using since a month.
Overa all review
And how can one do it.. please elaborate
Sir please explain a video about connected car and its subscription charges after some year
Thank you for the suggestion. We'll surely try to make a dedicated video.
@@cardekho please briefly explain not like my recommend transmission video
My favorite is kiger
Nissan Magnite 💯
Punch has 366 ltr boot space. Why you showing 319 ltr.??
Magnite top model 😍😍
Mileage comparison should be there
The Comparison King C 🤣 Cardekho team is back .
Nice Comparison video 👍🏻
Thanks for watching the video. Keep supporting!! :)
Wagonr cng ka video bnao
Enjoyed thoroughly ...
I love my magnite ❤️ 10k KMS Driven . HeadTurner on Road 🔥, good milage, comfort, Big, bold and beautiful.🦁
Im planning to buy magnite, please let me know the over performance, any road noises in cabin, milage ur getting
I m from banglore it's good in city and long drive as well..go for turbo u will love it
What's the mileage it's giving in city rides
@@mazharuddinmohammed8115 15 to 16
Magnite turbo is very good fun to drive
Magnite ❤️
Tata punch ek ragarde urban small suv hai jo k ek raaf n taaf wali feel aati hai
Punch is just a raised hatchback along with front of harrier 🙂
Yes bro
Kiger is raised Kwid with inflated ass
magnite 🥰
Yaar base modal ka kia kro
Comparison we all were waiting for🔥
Pride and Gem of India-TATA sir donates 66% of the profit for the charity so from now from Salt to Cars we must buy only TATA brand.
Be Indian buy Indian
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Love you TATA sir
♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏♥️🙏
😸❤️❤️
I agree with you. As per my knowledge and experience Tata punch gives best driving experience even for beginners in town roads as well as high ways. We won't feel tired after long drive also.
Comparison is detailed but engine and transmission comparison is missing. Not every one care for top model so Model wise comparison should have been taken care of.
Guys you can go through the sales figures for customer reliability, choices & performance etc over the the year.
Car engine se lete hain nissan aur renault me turbo option hain to abhi to best hai wo hi apart from 5 star safety that punch provides
Magnite 🖤
The one thing is common in all the cars is safety
Punch scored 5 star ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Magnite scored 4 star ⭐⭐⭐⭐
@@ishanprakashsingh9036 you mean 4 star is waste only 1 star difference and see the overall comparison then you know what is 1 star = overpriced 🤣🤣🤣
Punch tested on gncap while magnite on ASEAN ncap
Kiger in looks hand's down
Kiger or magnite ? Magnite is great but it's showroom is too far away from our city and we don't trust Nissan because if in case suddenly Nissan's car sales become lower then it had to say bye bye like Ford because the magnite is the only one car of Nissan which is selling well because kicks is on its end and will discontinue soon because nobody is buying it much and even Nissan has less service centres that is the major con of it ! But we are thinking to buy kiger because renualt cars are selling well like kwid and triber but the problem is that the kiger is not selling as well as it should be so we are so confused please help
The Kiger’s strength clearly lies in its tempting price tag. But you can’t help but see how Renault is pushing you towards the top two variants, for that’s where the real value is. You should give in to the Kiger’s charm if you want a stylish, spacious and comfortable SUV on a budget. However, it could do better with quality interior and some latest wow features such as the all-important sunroof and cruise control. For a better understanding of performance, compatibility and driving comfort, we would suggest you to take a test drive.
@@cardekho but why kiger's units are selling less than magnite ? I mean should we buy kiger if it sell less than other cars?
In case you are not aware, Renault and Nissan are tied up in India since 2010 and called Renault Nissan Automotive India Pvt Ltd. So all cars of both companies will have to sell very poorly for them to leave India. Both cars share the same engine and manufactured in same plant.
You forgot to mention about traction pro in punch
Only in AMT, Magnite has esp, proper traction control etc
Please compare always in their base variant
Bhai kaun si kharidoon itna confuse ho gaya vid dekh kar😔. I stay in jaipur please someone suggest me.
Selecting the right car would depend on several factors such as your budget preference on the segment, features required, cabin space, engine options, brand preference, etc. The Nissan Magnite has a lot of potential as a family car. It’s spacious, practical, well loaded and considering its aggressive pricing, will be a strong alternative to the low-mid range variants of its popular competitors. If we talk about Renault Kiger, a practical and balanced family car with just the right amount of frills. An affordable, yet, sensible way to enter the world of mini SUVs. If you are looking for a properly spacious, family-friendly, rough road-loving, and peppy sub-4 meter SUV at an affordable price tag, then the Renault Kiger will feel like quite a complete SUV to you. On the other hand, the Punch pulls off muscular SUV-like looks, high ground clearance along an easy to drive hatchback -like experience. Impressive cabin quality, clever customization options make it even more appealing. It is a sensible package that focuses on useful equipment like auto headlamps and wipers, electric folding wing mirrors, cruise control and connected car tech highlight a sensible features list. 5-star Global NCAP safety rating. The Punch could be the ideal alternative for city-friendly hatchback users looking for something more rugged and versatile. For a better understanding of compatibility and driving comfort, we would suggest you to take a test drive. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealership: bit.ly/3ffbbSm
Konsi best rahegi