2020 Porsche 911 (992) Carrera 4S Review | Why the C4S is not the 911 to go for!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- In this review Mark discusses why the latest Porsche 911 Carrera 4S is a good car but is not the 992 you should consider buying.
Redline Magazine is a print and digital motoring magazine that reviews some of the world's most exciting performance cars and luxury vehicles. You can purchase one of our high-quality print magazines or sign up to our free digital subscription using the links below.
Print Magazines: www.redlinemag...
Digital Magazine: www.redlinemag...
You can also find us on Instagram (@redlinemagazine) and Facebook (@redlinemagazineofficial)
Thanks to John from JB CTR for help with our rolling shots. Here's the link to his channel / @jbctr
Music from Audio Library -
Opening theme - Mariposa by Quincas Moreira
Second song - A Stranger Thing by Bruno E.
Third song - ARP Ascent by DivKid
Fourth song - Timelapsed Tides by Asher Fulero
Final song - Warm Water by Underbelly
Want to read Redline Magazine? Check out the link where you'll be able to subscribe to our zero-cost digital copy: www.redlinemagazine.co.uk/digital-subscription
Like a few other comments posted here, you're a tad contradictory in your review.
Firsty, you say you're not that keen on German cars. Not a good starting point. The rain is hammering down and the roads are very wet. Yet you're driving it like you stole it. You said that it's refined and comfortable. You say it's a good car to travel for miles and miles. You've praised this 992 for everything it's done.
And then you say at the end it's "too safe"...??? And this your sole critique?
Safe is good. Safe is better than stuffing it into a tree going backwards on soaking wet tarmac which is what would happen if you ever you did the same speeds (Or even if you ever managed to get anywhere near to the Porsches speed!) in a Ferrari or McLaren.
So, can I suggest you stick to driving English or the Italian cars and leave Porsches for people who appreciate that they are fantastic drivers cars.
Over 1 million worldwide sales for the 911 is proof that Porsche are getting it right. And I think that this new, 992 version of the 911 is quite stunning. It's fast, comfortable, reliable, has a fantastic engine/gearbox pairing and it will keep you driving whilst other sports car drivers would be sat at home, waiting for the roads to dry out.
Oh! And name me another sports car manufacturer where you can do multiple "launch controls" time and time again, without the car shutting down and wanting to be taken home on the back of a recovery lorry?
Lets clear up some facts. We never said we don't like German cars. When it comes to sports cars the preference has been for British and Italian marques, and that "the stuff from Stuttgart", obviously referencing the Porsche 911, has never been our pick. It's an opinion, which we're all entitled to.
We have praised the latest 992 because there are things it does very well and it would be wrong not to mention those points, as it makes for a balanced review. In our opinion however, the Carrera 4S (not all 911s) feels too grown up and lacks the edge that we'd like from a sports car. As for the wet weather driving, it only proves our point that the car is too easy to extract the performance from. It's also worth noting that McLaren and Ferrari aside, Porsche also make other 911s that you wouldn't think of messing with in the wrong conditions, but this review is of a C4S and we feel that this particular 911 is not the driver's choice in the range for the reasons explained. Not that it's not a good car, just not the driver's model.
In terms of safety, we never said it's too safe and wouldn't suggest that a car that is less safe is better than one that isn't. Most performance cars are safe owing to modern traction control systems, tyres that do a good job of displacing water, and in other cases, sports cars from the likes of McLaren and Ferrari that offer enough feedback to inform where their limits are in certain conditions.
To conclude, we think the Carrera 4S is a good car and if you're the type of driver who wants an approachable sports car that you can use 365 days a year, then by all means buy one. In our opinion however, it sacrifices a little too much edge in favour of a usable driving experience which is not what we want from a 911. We'll keep on testing them until we find one that ticks all our boxes, and report back with the good news when we find it.
^ in that case, keep a keen eye on either the upcoming GTS or a no-nonsense T (not the Turbo) until the 9000-rev GT3 breaks cover and unleashes pure driving emotions to warm your heart.
@@iceberg4736 Now we're talking! Bring 'em on!
well said.
Come on Mark. That 911 addresses all of most people’s needs. It is a sports car (despite what you say), it’s low cost maintenance compared to the more fussy super cars, it performs on bends not just in straight lines, it works well in the snow and can be a daily driver (unlike the more fussy cars out there that you seem to prefer. I think it’s time for you to convert. From John at the gym....btw I love the film. More 911 films please (ASAP)
Nice review, didn't like the end. The no doesn't make sense at all. The 911 never had the intent to be edgy. It had and has the intent into what you explained in the beginning. If you want a more "edgy" one you should go for the GTS. And if that is not edgy enough you go for The GT3 and so on. Comparing manual to dual clutch.. Yeah that's taste. Anyway, keep it up.
You’re absolutely confused. The 992 is the best of the 6 911s I’ve had. Why the fuck would they have a non 911 enthusiast rate it?? GTFO
So you are basically complaining that it is too perfect. OK. I wonder if you are wearing a raincoat with holes or if you are only using open beta versions of SW. If so, you are consistent and you should buy another car. Maybe a british car, or american.
jealousy of british
It's soo funny when you need to get through these...fake car journalists...every bracelet/watch that is put for the show or flex...hits soo hard...just like all these pretencious beard styling...it's hard to make it ALL ABOUT CARS...when your're simply not ALL ABOUT CARS...so if you prefer british and italian sportscar...it makes sense...
I would like to know which British or Italian sports car, available for same money, ie under £100k, you actually prefer to this car?
yeah, what a pollock
Totally wrong
- watches 911 C4S review for 90 seconds
- sees chav with floppy gold bracelet, tiny cartier watch and over-processed beard driving in leather-soled pointy brogues telling me he has a bias against german cars
- nopes outta here. goes looking for Chris Harris.
bla bla bla... try driving like you did on an Aston or a McLaren on such wet roads.......
McLarens don't like it at all! Rained a few times when we had the 720S and couldn't get anywhere near the throttle in it!
Comments like "the brakes are good too" makes me wonder what you expect in a German sports car. Did you think it would be lame as the review?
Not sure what value someone adds by reviewing a car they've borrowed for a few hours.
No idea who you are and why your personal preferences matter
How can a “Regetón-Guy Reporter” could understand Porsche heritage?
You say the 4S ain’t the one to buy yet I see you getting your man and driving it pretty aggressively on wet roads. LOL
What a contradiction this is😂😂😂😂
Kind of proves our point actually. It rained the entire two days we had the car and we still managed to extract the performance except for one time. It shouldn't be that easy.
Takamusasu
- Just what I thought too. A great car that the presenter doesn't like. He's praised it for everything it did, but the only criticism was, it's "too safe".
So, a return to the Widowmaker will suffice, then.
@@iceberg4736 Depends how brave we're feeling!
he compre with Ferari???
Seems they've always got to say something is wrong with it if only to show how clever they are ...... Well, it will do me pal. 😎
you should have drove the S... not 4S.. that would have been less forgiving..
Did you have to adjust the pedals? Or are you wearing platforms
Wtf was the point of this 'review'?
You've told us nothing new at all. A lighter version with a manual box might give more fun was your conclusion? Why not just tell us the sky is blue or something else as equally obvious.
Go get a proper job.
We reviewed a car, told you what it does well and where it needs improving while forming an opinion in the process. Job done.
Uh…”not turbocharged”??? The 992.1 C4S has TWO of them, in fact! 🥴
5:06
Vague, unsatisfying answer as to why the 4S isn't the 911 variant to aspire to.
Ideal car to rediscover your youth. The car you should have had when you were 18 back in the 60s .... 👍
Your review shows very well that you have absolutely no clue what you’re talking about. And that you did not understand the concept or rather the idea behind a 911. Go, drive your McLaren. Best of luck.
italian and british cars?? huh? Im from an italian family and italians dont touch german engineering.
If ever someone didn't suit a car, and vice versa.
Nice review,and that’s why Porsche built other cars like GT3 and GT4 for real track enthusiasts 😀
Hahaha its good but not great?? Ive driven just about every sports car out there and the AWD 911 is serious goods. Especially in the states you wont get anything better other that a turbo s.
Why your beard and eyebrows look drawn on mate?😢
The perfect sports car. PERFECT. Fast. Understated, but still eye catching. Sorry...no need to drive to the office in a Ferrari or a McLaren...unless you have a small penis. The 911 is all about class.
It's a great Car , what world are you coming from
hey man very cool watch what is it?? cartier and breguet?
I was thinking of a 911 but just came across your video. Would you opt for this 992 4s or a 991.2 4s?
Looking at that jacket and the way you speak it’s zero surprise you don’t like “stuff from Stuttgart” 😆😆. Utter nonsense
C2S, you drove the wrong one!
We'll get our hands on a rear wheel drive car with a manual gearbox soon ;)
I'm with you bro, manual all the way!
Which watch are you wearing?
Cartier Ballon Bleu
The very things that you find lacking, is what I like.
m8, you loved that car. Looks, performance and you won't wrap it around a tree.
dolomite silver?
Correct, yes!
What’s the best colour to get it in
@@74aamer Down to personal preference, but they look great in Racing Yellow!
Best Color is either red or yellow
Pretty good review brother. I truly enjoyed it. I drop my review around next week with same car 🙏🏻👍🏻
its put on weight yet still accomplished.......
The only thing I dislike about my 992 4S is the door handles. I prefer both the style and functionality of the 991.
Fair comment, heard this a few times from other owners!
This guy has no clue 😂. Poor
Fella.
Good video 👍👍👍👍
Thank you!
03:50 becomes a fan of Porsche
Enjoyed your review 🙂
Nice, loving the 992 Carrera
What is the interior spec?
Gregg Pebbles It has the heritage package
That interior is gorgeous, masculine, sophisticated, classy. The owner of this car wears At Least Rolex, Omega, Breitling, hand made Italian shoes and finest designer shirts. He's also probably older than 45. No offense to any who wear athletic or casual and so would choose a black or red and black interior. Just sayin... that's who loves this color scheme.
We liked the colour choice as well! Looks great!
Great review
Great review as always, keep it up! You need to get in to the new GT3 when it's launched.
Thank you! We'll do our utmost to get our hands on it!
@@redlinemagazine one out of 1000 reviewers calls a porsche avg. opinions are great and no offense but they dominate the industry and have for years.
My ferrari is what i call beautiful and fine but my porsche is a twisting corner track demon that grips never slips and runs the tracks faster than anything. c4s is just below the turbo s especially in 2022...either way good honesty on your opinion, but thats like enjoying kenny g on saxaphone. He needs some weed before he can find the right notes!
Great video again buddy! Will get this on in the waiting room ;)
Thanks! Keep the Porsche owners happy when they come in for their remaps ;)