Whether it is Scripted or Not that Mission was straight DANGEROUS because it can very muck Kill the Trainee's both Physically and Mentally plus IT DOESN'T MATTER if some of them are EXPERIENCE OR NOT that mission is very much a DEATH RACE to everyone each one of them have LIMITS this shows very much showed the WORST REALITY OF THE MISTREATMENT OF KPOP IDOLS
I feel so bad for these trainees, they are trying so much to achieve their dreams but even people who were supposed to be their mentors are forcing them to literally break their bodies. The guy who spoke is brave, as I saw in other comments he has a good fanbase and some experience, I think that is why he was able to speak out. You can see that his eyes are wet while he is observing the trainees. All survival shows strive for the attention of the public, even if it's negative, so probably the organisers wanted us to pity these boys and acknowledge their effort. Well, I'm not a fan of such entertainment, I want to see these boys singing and dancing with enjoyment.
seventeen didnt come off of a survival show :3 17TV and Project 17 were just to gain popularity and debut funds since the company was bankrupt at the time. members kept joining while only 4 left but they all left for different reasons. their old leader left bc he didnt think they would make it, one wanted to be an actor more, one (i think) got kicked bc he was dating a fan, and samuel was pulled out by his mom bc he would have been only 13 at the time of debut while all the others were 16+. nobody was eliminated.
I hate when channels like these clearly make these videos for clout and just namedrop random groups without doing their research. Luckily someone in the comments was quick enough to correct them before it went under the rug.
I don't think it's scripted, I mean of course the flow of the show is but the abuse and the mistreatment isn't. It's clear none of the boys are prepared for the challenge (it doesn't even make sense in the first place), and it takes a very good actors to act with that kind of mental breakdown and the judges themself must be a very great actors if they can act that 'spooked' when one of the trainees chose to speak up. And if judges simply agrees with proceeding with such conditions, they are inhumane too. Cuz like "okay, mention how this trainee have no charms, and give one of the trainees 1 point for his looks alone, take out the black kid, and force them to continue dancing even if it's gonna send them to the hospital, Lee Seunggi", and he goes "Ay ay sir"...? He can't actually AGREE to do those things, can he? He have a law named after him to prevent mistreatments towards artists, so he CAN'T actually agree with that. And for one trainee to agree risking his debut and popularity by being the 'bad guy' for stopping the show in the middle of the challenge, that's impossible too. He trained for years just to get recognized. And for the other trainees to cry like that for the other trainees who were not picked and were forced to dance 20 times with little break, it's gonna take a reallllyy great actors to cry and also have a breakdown like that. Yall can't really excuse all these as scripted, it's ridiculous
I want to see lee seung gi perform non-stop for an hour and let's see if he survive! His wife's parents were criminals and stole millions of dollars from people. Why is he still on TV?!?!?!
Neither Stray Kids or Seventeen were created through survival shows. There were already chosen members and the show was just to watch them practice and try and debut
completely scripted or they wouldnt have shown any of the "drama" - its not shown live so producers clearly planned it out . remember most of the boys have been around years - Hang yul has beena dancer and trainee and debuted - hes 10 years experience. Most of the boys are great actors as well .
its so weird because Iqiyi's CPOP show (Youth With You) was so chill in China lol. It was so fun and there was barely any drama throughout the show 😭 they gave this to a korean team and they decided on this. the budget on the chinese set was so much higher too
Thats such a bullshit.. Whoever that actor is lets see him dance nonstop for hour..,. What is wrong with these people.. They are literal children.. Have some care???????????
The fact that the judges gave a contestant ZERO points because he couldn’t dance but “looked like he should have been able to” (because the contestant is part black) makes me happy to NOT live in a homogeneous culture.
If anyone wants to watch survival shows that are less rigged/cruel, I'd recommend World Klass (2019) and Loud (2021)! Neither show had drama, evil editing, rigging or cruelty. Loud had a bit of skewed screentime favouring popular trainees, but I enjoyed it more than World Klass :)
I love survival shows but they are full on unnecessary drama. My favorite ones are not the k-pop shows but the chinese ones like Idol Producer and Youth with you - i don't remember if there was drama in them or at least not that much
Taiwanese actor Godfrey Gao died of sudden cardiac arrest in November during the shooting of Chinese reality show Chase Me - a spin-off from South Korea’s most popular variety show Running Man. Cast members of both shows are seen competing in races and missions every week that involve physical activities such as running, hiding and chasing each other.
That's why you called reality show for a reason. I think this trainees now days are had a special treatment compare to the past gen like 1st and 2nd even 3rd gen I thinks so, are more than worst compare now. If you are a kpop fan for so long you know what I'm saying. Being kpop idol is not easy they know the consequence and they need to work hard to debut cause in the end of the day their work hard will be payoff and granted.
you're just like them toxic, brainwashed and has not human decency whatsoever. If this happened to 1st, 2nd, and 3rd gen we can't do anything because it's in the past. But now things NEED to change. NO one should get tortured, barely fed, lose sleep, dance and practice for hours only for a specific few that were LIKED better to debut and the others to rot. For god sakes, the judge wasn't even an idol before, just an actor. He only cares about profit and his own twisted VALUES. And although it maybe considered culture, it really is more like PROFIT. These are all ways to profit the country, survival shows, companies and nothing helpful towards idols, artists, trainees or even the audience. I genuinely hope something changes and people like you and the judges should be blamed and criticized. And although there isn't much we can do to stop this, i hope that one of them will organize a group and take a stand AGAINST all of this. Because if not, they're going to be tortured, used, and manipulated by the judges, companies, toxic fans, and people like YOU!
dont audition if you are not ready for any kind of brutal kpop standards. thats why its called kpop survival show for a reason. crybabies are not welcomed.
If you can't handle a survival show don't audition. Kpop idols in the past would run 10km before dance practice. It's a fitness issue. If you can't handle the mental and physical discipline needed you're free to leave.
kpop iDOLS ARE WEAK THEY ARE ONLY FOCUSED IN DANCING NOT IN SINGING BECAUSE SINGING CAN BE CHEATED ACCORDINGLY BUT DANCING IS NOT HA HA HA. YOU CAN BE SUPERFICAIL IN SINGING , BUT NOT IN DANCING. THATS IS WHY KPOP IS WEAK. ONLY DANCING. KPOP IDOL DANCERS.
THE ROSE - Underrated K-Pop Group: th-cam.com/video/HV5OsrWBohA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=oK4_2KCMU7VbHvAr
Whether it is Scripted or Not that Mission was straight DANGEROUS because it can very muck Kill the Trainee's both Physically and Mentally plus IT DOESN'T MATTER if some of them are EXPERIENCE OR NOT that mission is very much a DEATH RACE to everyone each one of them have LIMITS this shows very much showed the WORST REALITY OF THE MISTREATMENT OF KPOP IDOLS
I feel so bad for these trainees, they are trying so much to achieve their dreams but even people who were supposed to be their mentors are forcing them to literally break their bodies. The guy who spoke is brave, as I saw in other comments he has a good fanbase and some experience, I think that is why he was able to speak out. You can see that his eyes are wet while he is observing the trainees. All survival shows strive for the attention of the public, even if it's negative, so probably the organisers wanted us to pity these boys and acknowledge their effort. Well, I'm not a fan of such entertainment, I want to see these boys singing and dancing with enjoyment.
No way survival shows are rigged. They must be clean and real just like WWE pro wrestling 😂
Lol
seventeen didnt come off of a survival show :3 17TV and Project 17 were just to gain popularity and debut funds since the company was bankrupt at the time. members kept joining while only 4 left but they all left for different reasons. their old leader left bc he didnt think they would make it, one wanted to be an actor more, one (i think) got kicked bc he was dating a fan, and samuel was pulled out by his mom bc he would have been only 13 at the time of debut while all the others were 16+. nobody was eliminated.
I hate when channels like these clearly make these videos for clout and just namedrop random groups without doing their research. Luckily someone in the comments was quick enough to correct them before it went under the rug.
it's painful to watch that's why my last idol show i've done was I-Land at that time i was praying for all their health and it was so heavy
I don't think it's scripted, I mean of course the flow of the show is but the abuse and the mistreatment isn't. It's clear none of the boys are prepared for the challenge (it doesn't even make sense in the first place), and it takes a very good actors to act with that kind of mental breakdown and the judges themself must be a very great actors if they can act that 'spooked' when one of the trainees chose to speak up. And if judges simply agrees with proceeding with such conditions, they are inhumane too. Cuz like "okay, mention how this trainee have no charms, and give one of the trainees 1 point for his looks alone, take out the black kid, and force them to continue dancing even if it's gonna send them to the hospital, Lee Seunggi", and he goes "Ay ay sir"...? He can't actually AGREE to do those things, can he? He have a law named after him to prevent mistreatments towards artists, so he CAN'T actually agree with that. And for one trainee to agree risking his debut and popularity by being the 'bad guy' for stopping the show in the middle of the challenge, that's impossible too. He trained for years just to get recognized. And for the other trainees to cry like that for the other trainees who were not picked and were forced to dance 20 times with little break, it's gonna take a reallllyy great actors to cry and also have a breakdown like that. Yall can't really excuse all these as scripted, it's ridiculous
I want to see lee seung gi perform non-stop for an hour and let's see if he survive! His wife's parents were criminals and stole millions of dollars from people. Why is he still on TV?!?!?!
He's already washed up. He's just using this drama to be relevant again
It might be scripted tbh, somi was told to argue with other trainees on pd101 to create drama
Neither Stray Kids or Seventeen were created through survival shows. There were already chosen members and the show was just to watch them practice and try and debut
The Stray Kids show said it was a survival show. Unless you work for JYP or know something everyone else doesn't know please enlighten us.
I don’t know that every aspect of the shows are rigged but I do think winners are for sure pre-determined by the networks.
This is not entertainment, it's torture!
And they are not sure they Will debut or not!! Can you imagine all of the worst training but you are not debut😢
I never liked those survival shows . They are barbaric. I watched one and already regretted it
Only survival show I liked was peak time
@@ofentseisntavailable6764 Peak Time was actually good and I hope that there is a second season
Everything is scripted in these shows; even winners are already decided. Seungi making such comments is part of the script
My Jongwoo's problem was mentioned
Can be scripted to get all the attention it is getting
completely scripted or they wouldnt have shown any of the "drama" - its not shown live so producers clearly planned it out . remember most of the boys have been around years - Hang yul has beena dancer and trainee and debuted - hes 10 years experience. Most of the boys are great actors as well .
its so weird because Iqiyi's CPOP show (Youth With You) was so chill in China lol. It was so fun and there was barely any drama throughout the show 😭 they gave this to a korean team and they decided on this. the budget on the chinese set was so much higher too
@@Lalalalala98872 no drama and a ton of BL ships
Thats such a bullshit.. Whoever that actor is lets see him dance nonstop for hour..,. What is wrong with these people.. They are literal children.. Have some care???????????
Starlight Boys is pretty disturbing and I don't think I even want to continue watching it.
Idol and trainee mistreatment is very real. Everyone should be aware of that by now.... I'm sorry this happened to them. 😢
A SURVIVAL SHOWS IN KOREA ARE BAD , LOW SURVIVAL SHOWS. LOOK AT ROAD TO KINGDOM 2 SHOW WAS BAD TOO. FULL OF CRUELTY.
The fact that the judges gave a contestant ZERO points because he couldn’t dance but “looked like he should have been able to” (because the contestant is part black) makes me happy to NOT live in a homogeneous culture.
Dont watch everything is scripted
If anyone wants to watch survival shows that are less rigged/cruel, I'd recommend World Klass (2019) and Loud (2021)! Neither show had drama, evil editing, rigging or cruelty. Loud had a bit of skewed screentime favouring popular trainees, but I enjoyed it more than World Klass :)
LOOK AT THAT BODIES ... THIN AND UNDERWIEGHT, MALNOURISHED DOING TIRING CHALLENGES, THEY WERE TAXED MORE THAN THEY CAN GIVE WITH THAT BODIES.
I love survival shows but they are full on unnecessary drama. My favorite ones are not the k-pop shows but the chinese ones like Idol Producer and Youth with you - i don't remember if there was drama in them or at least not that much
Those are trash the producers. and the judges.. they are killing them..
why bringing seowoo again and again in the video. Compare to other survivor shows, Universe Ticket is better.
Better watch Chinese survival show
lol clown
Taiwanese actor Godfrey Gao died of sudden cardiac arrest in November during the shooting of Chinese reality show Chase Me - a spin-off from South Korea’s most popular variety show Running Man. Cast members of both shows are seen competing in races and missions every week that involve physical activities such as running, hiding and chasing each other.
BUT Look at 2nd GEN idols
That's why you called reality show for a reason. I think this trainees now days are had a special treatment compare to the past gen like 1st and 2nd even 3rd gen I thinks so, are more than worst compare now. If you are a kpop fan for so long you know what I'm saying. Being kpop idol is not easy they know the consequence and they need to work hard to debut cause in the end of the day their work hard will be payoff and granted.
you're just like them toxic, brainwashed and has not human decency whatsoever. If this happened to 1st, 2nd, and 3rd gen we can't do anything because it's in the past. But now things NEED to change. NO one should get tortured, barely fed, lose sleep, dance and practice for hours only for a specific few that were LIKED better to debut and the others to rot. For god sakes, the judge wasn't even an idol before, just an actor. He only cares about profit and his own twisted VALUES. And although it maybe considered culture, it really is more like PROFIT. These are all ways to profit the country, survival shows, companies and nothing helpful towards idols, artists, trainees or even the audience. I genuinely hope something changes and people like you and the judges should be blamed and criticized. And although there isn't much we can do to stop this, i hope that one of them will organize a group and take a stand AGAINST all of this. Because if not, they're going to be tortured, used, and manipulated by the judges, companies, toxic fans, and people like YOU!
Oh well, kpop. Wondering why ppl still supporting this.
Anyways, dont forget to watch the next episode of starlight boys .
dont audition if you are not ready for any kind of brutal kpop standards. thats why its called kpop survival show for a reason. crybabies are not welcomed.
Im still watching the show
If you can't handle a survival show don't audition. Kpop idols in the past would run 10km before dance practice. It's a fitness issue. If you can't handle the mental and physical discipline needed you're free to leave.
kpop iDOLS ARE WEAK THEY ARE ONLY FOCUSED IN DANCING NOT IN SINGING BECAUSE SINGING CAN BE CHEATED ACCORDINGLY BUT DANCING IS NOT HA HA HA.
YOU CAN BE SUPERFICAIL IN SINGING , BUT NOT IN DANCING. THATS IS WHY KPOP IS WEAK. ONLY DANCING. KPOP IDOL DANCERS.