I think they should buff cam operators by ACTUALLY fixing the bug where their cams get disconnected as if they've been placed outside, despite being inside the building
this and bring the sensitivity down, there is no reason for valk, zero, & echo to have the ultra high sensitivity they have, especially zero, it should default to ur normal sensitivity or ads sens
@ what do you mean it’s not a bug I place it inside the building and it gets blocked like it’s outside??? Even in the patch notes a while ago they said they fix that but clearly they haven’t.
Some are bugs others are intentional there was a spot in Oregon basement where you could put a valk cam in the cage area and they made it so that counts as outside
For the IQ concept, remmber the targeted EMP gun she was seen using in one of the cinematics? What if she had that with her gadget being attached to it, allowing her to either shoot gadgets down or temporarily disable them with the emp gun.
@@yayman2538her whole thing is countering hidden gadgets, she is genuinely the only operator that can do it efficiently, and her being underpicked inadvertently buffs hidden gadget ops like valk & legion. she needs to be buffed.
Rooks armor should keep what he has now but added benefits. Such as applying the armor increases dbno crawl speed, his is also a flak jacket reduces explosion damage, the armor should always apply dbno no matter the cause of damage except for Headshot, his armor also has ammo inside of it, his armor bag can be a trap for attackers he makes a call like fenrir while looking at his armor bag and explosion damage occurs near his bag (Rook gains a visual que of his teammates that has his armor on)
Even better I feel like if you're moving right when you get downed it'd make him so much more viable, since when you get downed you just flop straight down for like two full seconds unable to move, meanwhile if you could like dive out the way with his armor it'd make being downed actually survivable past 10% of the time
I know you just wanted to provide a list of possibilities but I just imagine all of these buffs applied at once and mentally saw Rooks pick rate and win rate sky rocket.
Hot take but leave clash alone, she's such a unique operator and she doesn't need to be forced to conform. If anything I would want to see more operators that play totally different
I agree. She can be really strong with the right positioning and proper support from team mates. However, she can be countered very easily if she makes a mistake.
Yea i agree, its not just .1% of the player base that can play her, and at this point of where sheilds are at if you find her annoying to play against its really just a skill issue
for siege mailbox currently the laser sight is the only under barrel attachment and i believe there should be more such as spare mag that reduces reload speed and a flashlight that highlights enemies when in your field of view additionally they could add a bipod that narrows the hip fire spread (similar to the old laser sight)
Tachanka rework where his Shamika is mounted underbarrel to his old turret (with the face shield) so he cant get shield rushed. combined with a DS/azaami would make him crazy
so blackbeard crossed with smoke and Buck. Seems a bit OP. Just make his gadget less clunky to reload and maybe let the fire deal a bit more damage or something
I had posted this in the doc loses acog video but i'll repost it here because i actually have an idea to rework rook I always mained rook, and still do. I REALLY DO want to keep playing him, but the more you play him, the more you feel like you need to pick someone else to actually have an impact. Rook armor is fun and all, but it takes away precious seconds from prep phase, and not everyone even bothers picking it up, giving us just an useless sack of unused buffs right there. I think the armor should be a passive, just, everyone has it equipped by default as they spawn with rook, and give him something else as active gadget, that SHOULD still be related to his armor. I have an idea about this. The armors could be directly equipped with some adrenaline boosters for all teammates (would act like Finka, but probably without the health regen), and for all operators, it would activate automatically as soon as they take their first damage (only once). This would be different for Rook himself, since he is the main guy, so he could get the most benefits out of his own armor, so he could have perhaps 3 charges instead of 1, and could activate it himself as his gadget, instead of needing to damage for it (taking damage would still activate it automatically doe). This would encourage to have rook be the pick for being more aggressive pick over doc. As for his loadout, rook SHOULD have one of the best loadouts in defender sides, since in lore he's always kind of been "recruit's final form", as he's just a default dude, but really good at what he does, so logically he should have one of the better loadout. The fact that Doc has access to the Baillif and not Rook always seemed unfair to me, since doc already has a more influential role, and he get's to make easier rotates? This doesn't seem op in my opinion, he'll probably still be not the best defender, but at least he'll feel like he actually does something, i think.
For Rook, they should make him like a juggernaut from COD, which would be a massive speed debuff but would give him a powerful weapon and armor. To offset this, it could take him 10-15 seconds to fully suit up, leaving him very vulnerable. He could also have weak points or be susceptible to high-caliber rounds like Kali and Glaz's snipers.
For the Iana concept, when activating the Iana clone to move to a further location, the player should be able to move until those drones get into position (there should be a visual timer with how long left until the drones get into position). This will allow the player to run to a safer location outside or somewhere else and not be stuck in an open position
That Clash idea was something I’ve always thought about ever since she was introduced. A deployable shield that emits a shock pulse when attackers get too close can be a good way to counter rush strategies, even prevent defuser plants if placed in cheeky spots
The way you described Clash reminds me of the Guardian killstreak from Black ops 2 which is something ive been interested to see in siege for a few years now in my mind.
I 100% agree with this clash change. Gives her strengths in new ways. Imagine being zapped by her shield and she also has the ability to swing you at the same time with her smg, or a new ar, or a tcsg. Great crowd control
What if we flipped Rook's gadget on its head? Instead of armoring defenders, he can armor their gadgets? He could allow certain devices to take an extra hit or two, doubling down on his support capabilities.
KUDOS! 💪🏻 Heres my idea for maestro. Make his evil eye also explosive proof. Now his hard counters are: Sledge hammer to destroy it, Brava drone to take over, Ash launcher to destroy (drilling mechanic), Kali lance to destroy (drilling mechanic). Also emps dont open the window anymore. Glass can still be shattered by melee. EXPLOSIVES shatters the glass. Its a small buff that requires any of the 4 hard counters to completely take it of the board. Also i would REALLY like a second round for the gonne6. Please discuss this in an upcoming video. Maestro needs some love.
Video 20 of giving my concept for sledge Sledge as we all know is a decent operator breaching capability, good shotgun, and a low recoil rifle, but he can be better. What if he was able to unreinforce walls. What I’m talking about is that from the point of where the reinforcement was made, he’d have to go there, wedge the crowbar into the lever, and bring the reinforcement down without breaking it(taking him some time of course as to balance him). So let’s say they reinforce in site, he’d have to get into site and do that which encourages anchoring. The reinforcement being taken down allows him to make rotates with his hammer for him or his team. This means he can set up planting spots, get out of tricky corners, would need for defenders to start playing more aggressive towards him. The reinforcement not being broke lets defenders put it back up once he dies or it’s clear. Lmk what you guys think
rook could, besides giving armor, also be a weapons dealer, supplying the team with ammo boxes at the very least, perhaps even give teammates the ability to pick up his or other's weapons
I’ve had this idea for a clash rework since tachanka got his rework. she’d lose the shield and gain 2 primary weapons. but her new gadget is a kaid claw crossed with a bandit battery in which is attaches to a wall and electrifies the wall and any walls that are touching that wall. so theoretically if your on a map like villa or favela that has 4-6 reinforceable walls you can electrify all of them! you can also use razor wire to extend the electric current to other walls, in the idea of maybe making a set of 2 connect to a set of 3 or so on. I’d also like to say it’d be a pretty large gadget, around the size of a Banshee and is bulletproof. If it’s turned off by a emp it could be turned right back on by doing an animation to restart the generator. I think the name could be The Conductor or a more standard military name would be the C.E.G (pronounced like keg). it would simply mean conductive electrical generator. I really really like this idea and I’ve always loved telling people about the idea cause I think it’d make her an instant pick on any set up. Hopefully kudos sees this and maybe talks about it in a video
Just an idea, but giving rook a secondary ability. An arm shield that extends to cover the front of the body. It’s weightless and see through and can break like old school Blackbeard’s gun shield. When it isn’t broken yet, rook gains the ability to charge bash enemies but it breaks after one charge. If successful, Rook can pull up his gun while the enemy is trying to pick themselves up. This shield is countered by explosives and heavy fire. The shield can eat one explosion from a grenade for example. And leave you with zero damage, but cost you your shield. You only get one. When at a door he can set it as a two way mirror on the doorway.
Yes, the IQ remaster concept was one that I have always advocated for. I do believe that this remaster is definitely doable, kinda like how fenrir is able to activate/deactivate the fnatt of his choosing
Alibi does need a remaster for sure because it can be easy to spot the real alibi unless you have the elite. If she can just have clones that match her outfits there would be no problem. Twitch rework would be nice and to give her a drone that it more like bravas but shocks like clash but not over powered since they are both wolfguard.
Not much can be done with Alibi, but I think the Alibi Prisma doing all 3 stances would be most beneficial because a Prisma put on a head glitch would be most likely to be shot vs a Prisma that can look like any Op but stands still in a default outfit. I won't even shoot a default Prisma 2/3 times currently.
With clash you should be able to electrify wall like bandit for short amounts of time and have a mount on the shield for a bandit battery and you don’t need to recharge it when you use it all
I've said for a long time about how Rook needs a remaster so that he's more prevalent, I think the best way to make him just that bit better is to when operators are wearing the armor, not only will they be able to self revive, but they can also use their secondary while downed. I believe that this will make the self revive more accessible, especially for someone like Warden, who has the smg 12 as a secondary. Now with operators with such good secondaries, it could be a bit op, but maybe there could be a work around for that, like. You cant reload after you've been downed, or theres worse recoil (just throwing out ideas).
For the Iana rework, the alibi pinging would have to be one or two pings really quick like a lion scan. Other than shooting it, there's kinda no other way to counter it. 2nd part is amazing
Iana’s gadget should be similar to Zero’s and Fuze’s. Zero shoots a camera that can peek on either side of a reinforced/soft wall, and Fuze deploys items on the other side of walls. Imagine Iana shooting a device into a site from beneath that spawns her hologram. She can be a more effective counter-roam op instead of being a pseudo entry. As for Rook, I think he should get fully unbreakable reinforcements that cant be breached at all. The only catch is that they cant be put side by side so double walls can still be breached. Strategic placing of these reinforcements, which if you want can also only do halfwalls as well, would lead to unique team play. I would also automatically give his teammates armor. It wouldnt increase their HP but it would let them get the DBNO state if he’s still on the team. Rook should be a full fledged anchor and made to protect site. How the reinforcements would work: 1. Reinforce a wall normally either halfway for completely 2. Rook comes over and reinforces the hard wall. And, yes, he can do hatches as well. As for Clash, she should be a trap operator. One that puts traps in hallways that act as electric barbed wire. Think Kaid and electric barbed wire. She plants her trap on walls or ceilings near OBJ that have an AOE for damage and slowness similar to Melusi. Made to discourage attackers from entering in that location. She still should have a shield. Bonus points if she can activate the trap using the shield to slow down attackers or set it to a proximity. IQ…yeah proximity EMP or designated denial of electronics would work.
Yeah give ya boy Rook, Glazs sniper as secondary, emps, clay mores, And keep ability to get up which is rare anyway that someone isnt able to finished someone knocked due to another gunbattle, but increase the number of rounds by 4 rounds before knocked so allow armour to take an additional 4 more rounds.
An idea for IQ could be just making her gadget a visor like Ying or warden would be sufficient so you could use her primary and adding the ability to disable electronics like you said.
What if rook, gave every defender who takes his armour 2 'face plates' that defend that defender from being hs. It would help again dmr/kali sniper and would sometimes help defender who are in a pinch. The tradeoff might be to make the dfender slower/louder, which is something that you have mentioned before. What do you think, Kudos?
I had a pretty good idea for a Clash "Remaster", Originally posted this for Siege Mailbox, but now seems like a good time to post it again. - Clash starts the round with one charge for her CCE Shield, and will gradually gain more over time; she can infinitely gain charges but can only hold 3 at one time, similar to the sonic bursts on Echo's Yokai drones. When pressing the active ability button, the CCE Shield will release a burst of electricity akin to a single taser shot which can hit any Attackers within it's 5m cone radius, reducing the affected Attacker's movement speed by 30% for 3.5 seconds, as well as dealing 15 damage, before going into cooldown for 6.5 seconds.
Maybe Rook should have different armour packs he can choose from and bring 1 per round. Like maybe instead of plates, he could bring helmets that negate 1 headshot and instead drop you into down but not out. Maybe he could give flak padding that minimises the damage from explosives Etc
With clash i would like that change, but only making the shield take a certain amount of damage before it breaks when set down the slowness effect only happens at the 7-10 meter range, the longer they are in this effectthey will build a bar that will do damage like a lesion mine. It will no longer do damage every like half second that it does it would just charge. It could be hacked my brava, anything in front of the shield gets slowed, give her two maybe.
IQ in my opinion should have goggles, kind of like jackal, allowing her to see the electronics while still having her AUG up. Also she should be able to see defenders on cams.
I think Clash should have like a barbed wire but electrified, liga barbed wire with the bandit battery, without actually wasting a battery on a normal barbed wire, and if a defender hits it, they get 5 damage back, and maybe 5 or 10 damage like normal barbed wire when they step inside
For IQ, I think the scanner needs to be on the primary weapon and I think it would be cool if she could hack or disable a gadget for a certain amount of time, hacking the gadget would take around 30 seconds due to it being through a wall, that way brava isn’t useless, and then if you wanna disable it it will start flashing for the defenders and they can either pick the gadget up or it will be destroyed
I love clash as is, and you are correct that she is only as good as her teammates. I do however like yours idea for her, might be my favorite of the video. How would the deployed shields zap though? Are we talking a echo/maestro syle were she needs to cam to them to turn on? Or do they just auto zap in a range like a melusi? Each has benefits for sure. Also how may deploys does she have? 2? 3?
My idea for a IQ rework would be similar to jackal with her current scanner built into the helmet and a close range emp where she has to be on the other side of the wall to emp it
Hey Kudos, as for the IQ thing, they could just give her a flipper zero, making her amazing basically seeing as it can read, copy, and replicate electronic signals from wireless devices.
Rook- make his armor not only have withstand but you also have like a pre rework Blackbeard shield on his chest so it takes damage if your shot in the chest making enemies have to hit your head or limbs
It would be cool if you placed clash’s shield on the ground, it would act like a guardian but only activate when an enemy is nearby and still retains the battery function so it can run out and needs to recharge, also I think if she got a new primary weapon she would be too good, the mp9 is already good secondary smg. That’s just my opinion tho.
Amaru should have a second ability to have silent repelling. Also allow her to move faster than regular repel. Doubles down on her map control role by being the best repeller for window play. Makes it very difficult to zero in on her location with no sound cues to work with as a defender.
Maybe for iana it becomes a throwable thing, and there is a second or so that defenders can shoot the little drones without getting pinged to encourage using it more cautiously.
For the concept of my favorite op Flores, he need to breach and have anti gadget EMPs. His gadget needed to upgrade it into Twitch and Brava abilities. 😊
nah iq just needs the ability to ping everything she sees at once, she is more than fine. Imagine she will disable a vigil or a pulse... that's just insanely op
Rook i was hoping instead of putting you in the DBNO state, a bodily killing blow puts you to half your starting hp, so headahot still kills but now effectively youre a 150 operator if youre a 3 speed. So kali instant kills wont happen, you can tank an upclose frag, or not lose to that claymore on the window. Heres the trade off. You can have only one on at a time, you cant destroy the vest case its in, and theres now a maximum of 10
IMO I think IQ is in a great spot. Her ability may be slightly underwhelming but I think it is perfect for her. My only thought on how we could help her, is if she had some kind of “smart glasses” like warden that would perform the same thing that her ability does now with marking gadgets, but it wouldn’t require her to use a pistol while having it active. To me, that is the only downside to using her gadget, which is being forced to use her secondary. But other than that, I think she’s fine. The whole “EMP” thing seems a bit strong for an operator like her.
I kinda want iq scammer to be mounted to her primary and it can be flipped on and off sorta like how nomad flips on her laser. Although i honestly think you cooked with all of these. Especially the alibi and Iana ones
I have a better idea for Clash, I like the idea of it becoming a deployable but hear me out. During prep phase or later in the Round it can be placed but not picked back up once placed. It would have 3 bar charges that are connected to a button remote you push on your phone and once hit it will be constant until the bar is over, so it won't end until shock bar runs out which would show on your hud. This would be situational because the Shield needs to be strong in order to be useful to the team, it should take 3 utility explosives to destroy.
Make the Clash shield a literal Gadget, so it's not the Primary Weapon slot, and give her a Tachanka-like sidearm that can shoot up to 2 Smoke Smokes, like CS gas in real life since she is Riot Police-like. And of course her new Primary should be the old Secondary.
Since it’s highly unlikely attack will ever receiving another healer finka think of health should be permanent. The first boost increases health by 25 points. She’s the only healer and the only healer probably will ever see on attack until something comes along.
Rook should have swappable plates. He gives you a pack of 3 and if you take >30hp damage you can independently swap a plate a la COD to recover it in 30hp increments. Could also do fewer plates for more hp. Its unique, no healer gives player the ability to "pocket" a heal to use when needed. Still gives DBNO and can burn a plate to gain 30 hp back on a self revive.
I think Alibi clones could be improved to match the gun loadout (charms skins attachments) and vanity items (head gears and outfits) to match the Alibi, bcs now all the headgear and outfits are useless bcs they don't match the actual Alibi
I’ve been playing since year 2, on and off as of recent. If they made that Alibi change, I’d shoot them all the time since I’ve been so trained to avoid shooting Alibi standing still(as well as recognizing the difference between the real Alibi and fake.)
Clash needs a buff idc what people say. She is okay right now, but needs a bit of protection when she gets punched. I would add an shock to the attacker like the shield does. I was in a 1v2 and won with Clash, she isnt unbalanced, very overlooked operator.
Clash could just have health on her shield (with enough dmg it would break) Also osas talon could be destroyed while she has it in hand bcs it doesnt make sense that the same impact that can destroy it while its placed smwhere cant do anything while she has it in hand
ROOK REWORK IDEA: Playing on his name ROOK, the idea is to convert his gadget into a walking chariot/defense tower. His armor is now a default buff to all defenders while his gadget is 2 foldable Kevlar shields. He can basically use one as an attacker shield (can't use weapons with it) or drop it on the ground like a normal shield. The shield can take a few hits before collapsing. The shield can be thrown at a certain distance to be deployed (so you can help protect your teammates and maybe they also can interact with it and choose to carry the shield). To distinguish it from Azami, an extra ability to the shields can be added such that if thrown near a DBNO op, the shield can engulf them/cover them like a cocoon until they revive themself.
I like your Clash/Osa combo, but keep it full-sized, and she only has one. If she's not holding it, it can't zap, and it can be destroyed with explosives. This can basically give her post-plant potential without just turning her into another Osa. My Mute rework would be that he has the option to plant his Jammers on vertical surfaces. Castle's barricades would act like trap doors; he has the option to place them in a window/doorframe in an open or closed position (and an Aurni-esque button can toggle them.) They can even be placed over wood barricades in the Open position. When a defender walks or vaults through an open one, his barricade shutters down, locking the door behind them, which can disrupt a push. They can still be destroyed by explosives and Maverick, and Twitch can hit the button to close them. They're also detectable by IQ.
honestly clash is fine. i think the thing that makes her frustrating is her zapper has crazy range so its hard to close the distance unless u have EMP nades
I partially agree with the castle rework. We don't need more electronic gadgets on defence, but I do like the trap door idea. It could be trip-wire based, and visible at the top so attackers can still destroy it if they see it but without emps.
i think CLASH should be able to use her shield like she can use it right now, but also be able to deploy it like OSA. She would be a hybrid of MONTAGNE and OSA.
I don’t have an exact idea for rook but since he’s the protector and shielder of his team I thought of something that extends from his arm and shields him. Nothing overpowered like a actual shield idk Js a thought
I agree with most of this, except for the Clash change. It may end up that she'd just be brought for spare shields (like past Goyo) and that it would make her significantly less fun and more annoying. Again tho, love the rest.
What if amaru just attached a tether point at the top of a hatch, and attackers could use it as a mini rappel and go up into the hatch, exact same way a rappel works outside
about clash i dont think she needs that kind of rework imo if clash is getting reworked the only thing i would do is give her both a primary and a secondary (the shield would have a seperate slot) and make the shield work like montagne's so you can unextend it but the downside would so if its unextended the zapping lasts half the time, geez i should work in the dev team of ubisoft
iq gets 2 little zero cam like objects she can link them to a devise to disable it for indelicate amount of time the range is like 10 20m if a gadget is picked up iq needs to relink the devise by picking it up and placing it again or by scanning the gadget the devises she has could have an under gun launcher
i dont think clash should be changed, but if i had to i would give her a little camera on her shield, so dead tm8s could use it to help clash ping enemies (im just a dumb silver dont listen to me lol)
Clash and Cavi are the 2 most skill based ops in the game. Usually they are run by idiots who fold. But I have gotten ranks were Clash or Cavi destroy us.
I don't think Rook needs anything. I really like the simplicity of his gadget. I'd be totally fine with giving him an LMG or a deployable shield but that's not enough to call it a remaster imo. Clash doesn't need any changes either if you ask me. Just make the slow-down effect disappear as soon as she isn't zapping anymore, that's so annoying because you're still getting punished while she gets to have a break. And I think the slow-down from her zapping should decrease it's damage and slowing the further the attacker is away. This way you can still run-away while running at Clash isn't made easier. Going from 0 slow to 100 slow isn't ideal. But, again, these changes aren't enough to call it a remaster or rework in my eyes. They are just balance patches and quality of life changes.
Not much can be done for Rook, but I would highly suggest them giving him a C4. Also please for the love of Lord Tachanka, Ubisoft please remove Doc ACOG and give it to Thunderbird! Doc is too good and the bar graph shows that on PC and Consoles!
Hear me out, what if iana could do not only what you mentioned but also be able to toggle her hologram to become invisible and slow or visible and fast
How about solis ? I think she would better got a rework than nerfs or buffs because after many nerfs idk what to buff if after it’s going to get many nerfs
Iannas rework you though of would go well with Amaru since if you broke a barricade you want to fly in have ianna send her hologram through it and drone it for you
One idea for alibi I thought could be her hologram doing different stances by doing a stance while deploying it.
Thought of the same thing.
@@nahCyzar0520shows you how original your idea was lol
think same thing, alibi crouch throwing holo, holo will crouch, when lean at door, holo will lean but gonna be op if right player use it
And we’ve been saying for years, MATCH THE OUTFITS
@@buddyboy21875 they are matched no?
I think they should buff cam operators by ACTUALLY fixing the bug where their cams get disconnected as if they've been placed outside, despite being inside the building
this and bring the sensitivity down, there is no reason for valk, zero, & echo to have the ultra high sensitivity they have, especially zero, it should default to ur normal sensitivity or ads sens
Not a bug its a balance, maestro should have option tho
@ what do you mean it’s not a bug I place it inside the building and it gets blocked like it’s outside??? Even in the patch notes a while ago they said they fix that but clearly they haven’t.
Some are bugs others are intentional there was a spot in Oregon basement where you could put a valk cam in the cage area and they made it so that counts as outside
@ oh i see what u mean, dude i have that glitch as maestro so much and its so annoying
For the IQ concept, remmber the targeted EMP gun she was seen using in one of the cinematics? What if she had that with her gadget being attached to it, allowing her to either shoot gadgets down or temporarily disable them with the emp gun.
Would finally make my shorty playable in ranked
hidden gadgets would be useless, should be one or the other
@@yayman2538 If it's one or the other, she's either useless, or Thatcher is better.
@@yayman2538her whole thing is countering hidden gadgets, she is genuinely the only operator that can do it efficiently, and her being underpicked inadvertently buffs hidden gadget ops like valk & legion. she needs to be buffed.
"Did I mention it comes wrist mounted?" ~Osa, in the same cinematic
Rooks armor should keep what he has now but added benefits. Such as applying the armor increases dbno crawl speed, his is also a flak jacket reduces explosion damage, the armor should always apply dbno no matter the cause of damage except for Headshot, his armor also has ammo inside of it, his armor bag can be a trap for attackers he makes a call like fenrir while looking at his armor bag and explosion damage occurs near his bag (Rook gains a visual que of his teammates that has his armor on)
Even better I feel like if you're moving right when you get downed it'd make him so much more viable, since when you get downed you just flop straight down for like two full seconds unable to move, meanwhile if you could like dive out the way with his armor it'd make being downed actually survivable past 10% of the time
I know you just wanted to provide a list of possibilities but I just imagine all of these buffs applied at once and mentally saw Rooks pick rate and win rate sky rocket.
Hot take but leave clash alone, she's such a unique operator and she doesn't need to be forced to conform. If anything I would want to see more operators that play totally different
I agree. She can be really strong with the right positioning and proper support from team mates. However, she can be countered very easily if she makes a mistake.
I agree with you guys I think she promotes also some very good team play compared to some other operators (Doc mains)
Yea i agree, its not just .1% of the player base that can play her, and at this point of where sheilds are at if you find her annoying to play against its really just a skill issue
yeah his idea as another op would be better even tho its kinds underwhelming
for siege mailbox
currently the laser sight is the only under barrel attachment and i believe there should be more such as spare mag that reduces reload speed and a flashlight that highlights enemies when in your field of view additionally they could add a bipod that narrows the hip fire spread (similar to the old laser sight)
Tachanka rework where his Shamika is mounted underbarrel to his old turret (with the face shield) so he cant get shield rushed. combined with a DS/azaami would make him crazy
so blackbeard crossed with smoke and Buck. Seems a bit OP. Just make his gadget less clunky to reload and maybe let the fire deal a bit more damage or something
I had posted this in the doc loses acog video but i'll repost it here because i actually have an idea to rework rook
I always mained rook, and still do. I REALLY DO want to keep playing him, but the more you play him, the more you feel like you need to pick someone else to actually have an impact.
Rook armor is fun and all, but it takes away precious seconds from prep phase, and not everyone even bothers picking it up, giving us just an useless sack of unused buffs right there.
I think the armor should be a passive, just, everyone has it equipped by default as they spawn with rook, and give him something else as active gadget, that SHOULD still be related to his armor.
I have an idea about this. The armors could be directly equipped with some adrenaline boosters for all teammates (would act like Finka, but probably without the health regen), and for all operators, it would activate automatically as soon as they take their first damage (only once). This would be different for Rook himself, since he is the main guy, so he could get the most benefits out of his own armor, so he could have perhaps 3 charges instead of 1, and could activate it himself as his gadget, instead of needing to damage for it (taking damage would still activate it automatically doe). This would encourage to have rook be the pick for being more aggressive pick over doc.
As for his loadout, rook SHOULD have one of the best loadouts in defender sides, since in lore he's always kind of been "recruit's final form", as he's just a default dude, but really good at what he does, so logically he should have one of the better loadout. The fact that Doc has access to the Baillif and not Rook always seemed unfair to me, since doc already has a more influential role, and he get's to make easier rotates?
This doesn't seem op in my opinion, he'll probably still be not the best defender, but at least he'll feel like he actually does something, i think.
I LOVE the concept videos, please do more. I’ve only ever seen Anifex do them!
when you said Amaru can bring a teammate I immediately imagine her hugging an operator while flying thru a window xD
Much better option than putting up a ladder imo both for genuine gameplay purposes as well as for trolling.
For Rook, they should make him like a juggernaut from COD, which would be a massive speed debuff but would give him a powerful weapon and armor. To offset this, it could take him 10-15 seconds to fully suit up, leaving him very vulnerable. He could also have weak points or be susceptible to high-caliber rounds like Kali and Glaz's snipers.
A Concept for alibi I had was to have an option to make the clone to be in a leaning position.
For the Iana concept, when activating the Iana clone to move to a further location, the player should be able to move until those drones get into position (there should be a visual timer with how long left until the drones get into position). This will allow the player to run to a safer location outside or somewhere else and not be stuck in an open position
That Clash idea was something I’ve always thought about ever since she was introduced. A deployable shield that emits a shock pulse when attackers get too close can be a good way to counter rush strategies, even prevent defuser plants if placed in cheeky spots
Big kudos to you Kudos for the concepts! Plz keep doin them
The way you described Clash reminds me of the Guardian killstreak from Black ops 2 which is something ive been interested to see in siege for a few years now in my mind.
I 100% agree with this clash change. Gives her strengths in new ways. Imagine being zapped by her shield and she also has the ability to swing you at the same time with her smg, or a new ar, or a tcsg. Great crowd control
What if we flipped Rook's gadget on its head? Instead of armoring defenders, he can armor their gadgets? He could allow certain devices to take an extra hit or two, doubling down on his support capabilities.
Amaru using her grapples inside is such an easy, simple but also super effective improvement. It borders on being a must have.
KUDOS! 💪🏻
Heres my idea for maestro.
Make his evil eye also explosive proof. Now his hard counters are: Sledge hammer to destroy it, Brava drone to take over, Ash launcher to destroy (drilling mechanic), Kali lance to destroy (drilling mechanic). Also emps dont open the window anymore. Glass can still be shattered by melee. EXPLOSIVES shatters the glass. Its a small buff that requires any of the 4 hard counters to completely take it of the board.
Also i would REALLY like a second round for the gonne6.
Please discuss this in an upcoming video. Maestro needs some love.
Video 20 of giving my concept for sledge
Sledge as we all know is a decent operator breaching capability, good shotgun, and a low recoil rifle, but he can be better. What if he was able to unreinforce walls. What I’m talking about is that from the point of where the reinforcement was made, he’d have to go there, wedge the crowbar into the lever, and bring the reinforcement down without breaking it(taking him some time of course as to balance him). So let’s say they reinforce in site, he’d have to get into site and do that which encourages anchoring. The reinforcement being taken down allows him to make rotates with his hammer for him or his team. This means he can set up planting spots, get out of tricky corners, would need for defenders to start playing more aggressive towards him. The reinforcement not being broke lets defenders put it back up once he dies or it’s clear.
Lmk what you guys think
rook could, besides giving armor, also be a weapons dealer, supplying the team with ammo boxes at the very least, perhaps even give teammates the ability to pick up his or other's weapons
I’ve had this idea for a clash rework since tachanka got his rework. she’d lose the shield and gain 2 primary weapons. but her new gadget is a kaid claw crossed with a bandit battery in which is attaches to a wall and electrifies the wall and any walls that are touching that wall. so theoretically if your on a map like villa or favela that has 4-6 reinforceable walls you can electrify all of them! you can also use razor wire to extend the electric current to other walls, in the idea of maybe making a set of 2 connect to a set of 3 or so on. I’d also like to say it’d be a pretty large gadget, around the size of a Banshee and is bulletproof. If it’s turned off by a emp it could be turned right back on by doing an animation to restart the generator. I think the name could be The Conductor or a more standard military name would be the C.E.G (pronounced like keg). it would simply mean conductive electrical generator. I really really like this idea and I’ve always loved telling people about the idea cause I think it’d make her an instant pick on any set up. Hopefully kudos sees this and maybe talks about it in a video
Just an idea, but giving rook a secondary ability. An arm shield that extends to cover the front of the body. It’s weightless and see through and can break like old school Blackbeard’s gun shield. When it isn’t broken yet, rook gains the ability to charge bash enemies but it breaks after one charge. If successful, Rook can pull up his gun while the enemy is trying to pick themselves up. This shield is countered by explosives and heavy fire. The shield can eat one explosion from a grenade for example. And leave you with zero damage, but cost you your shield. You only get one. When at a door he can set it as a two way mirror on the doorway.
Some really great ideas and improvements for sure, hope ubi listens to this
Yes, the IQ remaster concept was one that I have always advocated for. I do believe that this remaster is definitely doable, kinda like how fenrir is able to activate/deactivate the fnatt of his choosing
Alibi does need a remaster for sure because it can be easy to spot the real alibi unless you have the elite. If she can just have clones that match her outfits there would be no problem. Twitch rework would be nice and to give her a drone that it more like bravas but shocks like clash but not over powered since they are both wolfguard.
Not much can be done with Alibi, but I think the Alibi Prisma doing all 3 stances would be most beneficial because a Prisma put on a head glitch would be most likely to be shot vs a Prisma that can look like any Op but stands still in a default outfit. I won't even shoot a default Prisma 2/3 times currently.
With clash you should be able to electrify wall like bandit for short amounts of time and have a mount on the shield for a bandit battery and you don’t need to recharge it when you use it all
I've said for a long time about how Rook needs a remaster so that he's more prevalent, I think the best way to make him just that bit better is to when operators are wearing the armor, not only will they be able to self revive, but they can also use their secondary while downed. I believe that this will make the self revive more accessible, especially for someone like Warden, who has the smg 12 as a secondary. Now with operators with such good secondaries, it could be a bit op, but maybe there could be a work around for that, like. You cant reload after you've been downed, or theres worse recoil (just throwing out ideas).
For the Iana rework, the alibi pinging would have to be one or two pings really quick like a lion scan. Other than shooting it, there's kinda no other way to counter it. 2nd part is amazing
The IQ gadget can be equipped with the ocp that sam fisher had on his pistol in chaos theory which temporarily disabled gadgets
Iana’s gadget should be similar to Zero’s and Fuze’s.
Zero shoots a camera that can peek on either side of a reinforced/soft wall, and Fuze deploys items on the other side of walls.
Imagine Iana shooting a device into a site from beneath that spawns her hologram. She can be a more effective counter-roam op instead of being a pseudo entry.
As for Rook, I think he should get fully unbreakable reinforcements that cant be breached at all. The only catch is that they cant be put side by side so double walls can still be breached. Strategic placing of these reinforcements, which if you want can also only do halfwalls as well, would lead to unique team play. I would also automatically give his teammates armor. It wouldnt increase their HP but it would let them get the DBNO state if he’s still on the team. Rook should be a full fledged anchor and made to protect site.
How the reinforcements would work:
1. Reinforce a wall normally either halfway for completely
2. Rook comes over and reinforces the hard wall.
And, yes, he can do hatches as well.
As for Clash, she should be a trap operator. One that puts traps in hallways that act as electric barbed wire. Think Kaid and electric barbed wire. She plants her trap on walls or ceilings near OBJ that have an AOE for damage and slowness similar to Melusi. Made to discourage attackers from entering in that location. She still should have a shield. Bonus points if she can activate the trap using the shield to slow down attackers or set it to a proximity.
IQ…yeah proximity EMP or designated denial of electronics would work.
Yeah give ya boy Rook, Glazs sniper as secondary, emps, clay mores, And keep ability to get up which is rare anyway that someone isnt able to finished someone knocked due to another gunbattle, but increase the number of rounds by 4 rounds before knocked so allow armour to take an additional 4 more rounds.
An idea for IQ could be just making her gadget a visor like Ying or warden would be sufficient so you could use her primary and adding the ability to disable electronics like you said.
What if rook, gave every defender who takes his armour 2 'face plates' that defend that defender from being hs. It would help again dmr/kali sniper and would sometimes help defender who are in a pinch. The tradeoff might be to make the dfender slower/louder, which is something that you have mentioned before. What do you think, Kudos?
I had a pretty good idea for a Clash "Remaster", Originally posted this for Siege Mailbox, but now seems like a good time to post it again.
- Clash starts the round with one charge for her CCE Shield, and will gradually gain more over time; she can infinitely gain charges but can only hold 3 at one time, similar to the sonic bursts on Echo's Yokai drones. When pressing the active ability button, the CCE Shield will release a burst of electricity akin to a single taser shot which can hit any Attackers within it's 5m cone radius, reducing the affected Attacker's movement speed by 30% for 3.5 seconds, as well as dealing 15 damage, before going into cooldown for 6.5 seconds.
Maybe Rook should have different armour packs he can choose from and bring 1 per round.
Like maybe instead of plates, he could bring helmets that negate 1 headshot and instead drop you into down but not out.
Maybe he could give flak padding that minimises the damage from explosives
Etc
With clash i would like that change, but only making the shield take a certain amount of damage before it breaks when set down the slowness effect only happens at the 7-10 meter range, the longer they are in this effectthey will build a bar that will do damage like a lesion mine. It will no longer do damage every like half second that it does it would just charge. It could be hacked my brava, anything in front of the shield gets slowed, give her two maybe.
IQ in my opinion should have goggles, kind of like jackal, allowing her to see the electronics while still having her AUG up. Also she should be able to see defenders on cams.
I think Clash should have like a barbed wire but electrified, liga barbed wire with the bandit battery, without actually wasting a battery on a normal barbed wire, and if a defender hits it, they get 5 damage back, and maybe 5 or 10 damage like normal barbed wire when they step inside
For IQ, I think the scanner needs to be on the primary weapon and I think it would be cool if she could hack or disable a gadget for a certain amount of time, hacking the gadget would take around 30 seconds due to it being through a wall, that way brava isn’t useless, and then if you wanna disable it it will start flashing for the defenders and they can either pick the gadget up or it will be destroyed
I love clash as is, and you are correct that she is only as good as her teammates. I do however like yours idea for her, might be my favorite of the video.
How would the deployed shields zap though? Are we talking a echo/maestro syle were she needs to cam to them to turn on? Or do they just auto zap in a range like a melusi? Each has benefits for sure. Also how may deploys does she have? 2? 3?
My idea for a IQ rework would be similar to jackal with her current scanner built into the helmet and a close range emp where she has to be on the other side of the wall to emp it
Hey Kudos, as for the IQ thing, they could just give her a flipper zero, making her amazing basically seeing as it can read, copy, and replicate electronic signals from wireless devices.
Rook- make his armor not only have withstand but you also have like a pre rework Blackbeard shield on his chest so it takes damage if your shot in the chest making enemies have to hit your head or limbs
It would be cool if you placed clash’s shield on the ground, it would act like a guardian but only activate when an enemy is nearby and still retains the battery function so it can run out and needs to recharge, also I think if she got a new primary weapon she would be too good, the mp9 is already good secondary smg. That’s just my opinion tho.
As long as clash still gets to scream at the attackers im down lmao
Amaru should have a second ability to have silent repelling. Also allow her to move faster than regular repel. Doubles down on her map control role by being the best repeller for window play. Makes it very difficult to zero in on her location with no sound cues to work with as a defender.
Think about being that defender though, she would probably become one of the most annoying ops to play against
Maybe for iana it becomes a throwable thing, and there is a second or so that defenders can shoot the little drones without getting pinged to encourage using it more cautiously.
For the concept of my favorite op Flores, he need to breach and have anti gadget EMPs. His gadget needed to upgrade it into Twitch and Brava abilities. 😊
nah iq just needs the ability to ping everything she sees at once, she is more than fine.
Imagine she will disable a vigil or a pulse... that's just insanely op
Rook i was hoping instead of putting you in the DBNO state, a bodily killing blow puts you to half your starting hp, so headahot still kills but now effectively youre a 150 operator if youre a 3 speed. So kali instant kills wont happen, you can tank an upclose frag, or not lose to that claymore on the window. Heres the trade off. You can have only one on at a time, you cant destroy the vest case its in, and theres now a maximum of 10
IMO I think IQ is in a great spot. Her ability may be slightly underwhelming but I think it is perfect for her. My only thought on how we could help her, is if she had some kind of “smart glasses” like warden that would perform the same thing that her ability does now with marking gadgets, but it wouldn’t require her to use a pistol while having it active. To me, that is the only downside to using her gadget, which is being forced to use her secondary. But other than that, I think she’s fine. The whole “EMP” thing seems a bit strong for an operator like her.
I kinda want iq scammer to be mounted to her primary and it can be flipped on and off sorta like how nomad flips on her laser. Although i honestly think you cooked with all of these. Especially the alibi and Iana ones
I have a better idea for Clash, I like the idea of it becoming a deployable but hear me out. During prep phase or later in the Round it can be placed but not picked back up once placed. It would have 3 bar charges that are connected to a button remote you push on your phone and once hit it will be constant until the bar is over, so it won't end until shock bar runs out which would show on your hud. This would be situational because the Shield needs to be strong in order to be useful to the team, it should take 3 utility explosives to destroy.
Make the Clash shield a literal Gadget, so it's not the Primary Weapon slot, and give her a Tachanka-like sidearm that can shoot up to 2 Smoke Smokes, like CS gas in real life since she is Riot Police-like. And of course her new Primary should be the old Secondary.
Since it’s highly unlikely attack will ever receiving another healer finka think of health should be permanent. The first boost increases health by 25 points. She’s the only healer and the only healer probably will ever see on attack until something comes along.
You are invited to the Family Cookout 🗣️🗣️
I think having rook armor allowing you to use either ur secondary or primary could be cool and making the self revive faster
You shouldn’t be getting your primary as a gun while your down 😂
Rook should have swappable plates. He gives you a pack of 3 and if you take >30hp damage you can independently swap a plate a la COD to recover it in 30hp increments. Could also do fewer plates for more hp. Its unique, no healer gives player the ability to "pocket" a heal to use when needed. Still gives DBNO and can burn a plate to gain 30 hp back on a self revive.
I think Alibi clones could be improved to match the gun loadout (charms skins attachments) and vanity items (head gears and outfits) to match the Alibi, bcs now all the headgear and outfits are useless bcs they don't match the actual Alibi
Imagine if Amaru’s grapple was an underbarrel attachment like Buck and she could go in and immediately start shooting.
I’ve been playing since year 2, on and off as of recent. If they made that Alibi change, I’d shoot them all the time since I’ve been so trained to avoid shooting Alibi standing still(as well as recognizing the difference between the real Alibi and fake.)
Clash needs a buff idc what people say. She is okay right now, but needs a bit of protection when she gets punched. I would add an shock to the attacker like the shield does. I was in a 1v2 and won with Clash, she isnt unbalanced, very overlooked operator.
For me, Cav is one that i personally believe that absolutely needs atleast a small rework.
iania’s drone should bear able to shoot something like a lesion into the enemy. this would ping would lion ping the attacker until they removed it.
Clash could just have health on her shield (with enough dmg it would break)
Also osas talon could be destroyed while she has it in hand bcs it doesnt make sense that the same impact that can destroy it while its placed smwhere cant do anything while she has it in hand
ROOK REWORK IDEA: Playing on his name ROOK, the idea is to convert his gadget into a walking chariot/defense tower. His armor is now a default buff to all defenders while his gadget is 2 foldable Kevlar shields. He can basically use one as an attacker shield (can't use weapons with it) or drop it on the ground like a normal shield. The shield can take a few hits before collapsing.
The shield can be thrown at a certain distance to be deployed (so you can help protect your teammates and maybe they also can interact with it and choose to carry the shield). To distinguish it from Azami, an extra ability to the shields can be added such that if thrown near a DBNO op, the shield can engulf them/cover them like a cocoon until they revive themself.
They should give clash a option that she could either shock or shot out fire that we’ll do more damage but wouldn’t slow down the enemy
But only has a little bit of fuel
I like your Clash/Osa combo, but keep it full-sized, and she only has one. If she's not holding it, it can't zap, and it can be destroyed with explosives.
This can basically give her post-plant potential without just turning her into another Osa.
My Mute rework would be that he has the option to plant his Jammers on vertical surfaces.
Castle's barricades would act like trap doors; he has the option to place them in a window/doorframe in an open or closed position (and an Aurni-esque button can toggle them.) They can even be placed over wood barricades in the Open position.
When a defender walks or vaults through an open one, his barricade shutters down, locking the door behind them, which can disrupt a push.
They can still be destroyed by explosives and Maverick, and Twitch can hit the button to close them. They're also detectable by IQ.
honestly clash is fine. i think the thing that makes her frustrating is her zapper has crazy range so its hard to close the distance unless u have EMP nades
I partially agree with the castle rework. We don't need more electronic gadgets on defence, but I do like the trap door idea. It could be trip-wire based, and visible at the top so attackers can still destroy it if they see it but without emps.
About Clash remaster, what if her shield just like remastered BB but keep the same gadget?
I think if clash was kind of like a melusi so if you place down the shield if attackers were in certain area they would start getting zapped
Make it so sledge can still use his pistol when having the hammer out. If they ain't gonna give him his smg11 may aswell give his pistol some use.
i think CLASH should be able to use her shield like she can use it right now, but also be able to deploy it like OSA.
She would be a hybrid of MONTAGNE and OSA.
I don’t have an exact idea for rook but since he’s the protector and shielder of his team I thought of something that extends from his arm and shields him. Nothing overpowered like a actual shield idk Js a thought
I agree with most of this, except for the Clash change. It may end up that she'd just be brought for spare shields (like past Goyo) and that it would make her significantly less fun and more annoying. Again tho, love the rest.
What if amaru just attached a tether point at the top of a hatch, and attackers could use it as a mini rappel and go up into the hatch, exact same way a rappel works outside
about clash i dont think she needs that kind of rework imo if clash is getting reworked the only thing i would do is give her both a primary and a secondary (the shield would have a seperate slot) and make the shield work like montagne's so you can unextend it but the downside would so if its unextended the zapping lasts half the time, geez i should work in the dev team of ubisoft
I always thought if alibi could make holigrams of gadgets (shields and barricades) including her teammates
i guess iana shouldbeable to get out of her hologram, but the hologram could still be running for a bit, so she could enter after her own clone
No Nøkk? What a miss…
They just need to bring back his silent step
I think clash's shield should be able to be shattered by gonne 6, ash, flores etc. simple fix, shes borderline broken on some sites.
For alibi what if instead of throwing the clones you can drop it at your feet and it will copy the position that you were in
honestly if they were to have a remaster, I hope they will do two per remaster
iq gets 2 little zero cam like objects she can link them to a devise to disable it for indelicate amount of time the range is like 10 20m if a gadget is picked up iq needs to relink the devise by picking it up and placing it again or by scanning the gadget the devises she has could have an under gun launcher
i dont think clash should be changed, but if i had to i would give her a little camera on her shield, so dead tm8s could use it to help clash ping enemies (im just a dumb silver dont listen to me lol)
My Top 10 for operators who need remasters:
Tachanka
Glaz
IQ
Ela
Clash
Kali
Oryx
Thunderbird
Thorn
Sens
Yo I been playing alibi with her elite skin but that concept is the coolest idea I ever hear for her
Clash and Cavi are the 2 most skill based ops in the game. Usually they are run by idiots who fold. But I have gotten ranks were Clash or Cavi destroy us.
nice video , not sure about clash but I think Sledge should be number 1 for being iconic with hammer and not being that useful ,
Alibi used to be able to do that before, idk why they removed it
What if they made rook armor absorb more damage the further away the attackers are shooting them from. I think that would be kinda cool
I don't think Rook needs anything. I really like the simplicity of his gadget.
I'd be totally fine with giving him an LMG or a deployable shield but that's not enough to call it a remaster imo.
Clash doesn't need any changes either if you ask me.
Just make the slow-down effect disappear as soon as she isn't zapping anymore, that's so annoying because you're still getting punished while she gets to have a break.
And I think the slow-down from her zapping should decrease it's damage and slowing the further the attacker is away. This way you can still run-away while running at Clash isn't made easier. Going from 0 slow to 100 slow isn't ideal.
But, again, these changes aren't enough to call it a remaster or rework in my eyes. They are just balance patches and quality of life changes.
iq could have her gadget on her main gun kinda like glaz but for electronic
Not much can be done for Rook, but I would highly suggest them giving him a C4. Also please for the love of Lord Tachanka, Ubisoft please remove Doc ACOG and give it to Thunderbird! Doc is too good and the bar graph shows that on PC and Consoles!
Hear me out, what if iana could do not only what you mentioned but also be able to toggle her hologram to become invisible and slow or visible and fast
How about solis ? I think she would better got a rework than nerfs or buffs because after many nerfs idk what to buff if after it’s going to get many nerfs
Iannas rework you though of would go well with Amaru since if you broke a barricade you want to fly in have ianna send her hologram through it and drone it for you
Make clashes shield deployable and 2 charges to break and give her mp7 acog