Anette is awesome. She doesn't do the Tarja tunes well, due to the difference in vocal styles, but she's great at the songs written for her. It's kinda like Deep Purple with David Coverdale replacing Ian Gillan. Does anyone really expect Cov to do "Child in Time"?
I agree. Each of these 3 ladies are phenomenal, amazing vocalist each with their own skill sets and styles. Each of them have amazing songs which were written specifically for them. Let's appreciate the legacy and contribution each of them have made for this amazing band. I do have a favorite of the 3 but I enjoy listening to all of them.
Well there's just something about the way she sings this song. She can hit the "one" without sliding, bang on - riveted in place. That adds a lot to the chorus. Powerful piece !! \m/
I’m with you on this one. She was an absolutely amazing front woman. Beautiful and talented artist. And in my opinion at their very best. Miss those days.
This is a great performance! The issue is her vocals aren't mixed right. The strength of Annette's voice is her purity of tone and focused sound. I think she'd sound a lot better if the vocals were mixed louder, there was a bit of reverb, and her midtones were boosted (since the higher tones are what cut through and can be heard, which makes it sound thin).
I first heard Floor’s version and loved it. I read comments that Annette and Tarja did it better. So I listened to all three. I would rank them in this order. Floor Annette Tarja
@@noisyboy5529 that irritating "run" or "vocalization" thingy she does at the end of almost every verse. "DAY-AY-AY" "TI-YI-YIME" It's almost as bad as the people who end their sentences in a higher tone, making it always sound like they're asking a question. 😏
I have to point, this is not the audio from Lowlands 2008, check any other source and you will see. I'm sad because the edition made this sound worse. This audio probably is from Rock Werchter 2008.
She sounded better than floors version...on the album. And I'm not sure that's just not because she was tired? Where in the set was it in 2013. Anyway live she just cannot seem to focus, vocal ADD BRO
I love these two albums with this singer "AMAZING AWSOME SONGS" , but just do not care for much before this and especially can't stand the two i checked out with floor singing.
I like her solo music. I hated her when she was with nightwish. She was more of a radio friendly pop singer. She was boring to watch live. Tarjia would put you in a trance watching her & just sucked you in & mesmerized you. Floor was this power house that came in & demanded your attention & was a force to be reckoned with.
@@hasinduwelarathne7113 she never does well in live singing. Her songs with the Dark Elements are in the same way because they all sound amazing on the album; however, when she does live, they sound awkward
Tellement mauvaise qu'elle rate même ces propres chansons 😂 elle pouvait avoir l'excuse de dire que les autres titres avaient étés écrits pour la voix de Tarja mais là elle n'a aucune excuse si ce n'est celle d'être mauvaise.
Le plus cruel est le montage de Nemo en concert avec Tarja (et son band), Anette et Floor. Anette pousse tellement sa voix dans la coda qu'on se croirait à un télécrochet avec une chanteuse qui aurait vu plus grand que sa voix.
Absolutely love what she did in the last phrase, that kind of growl, i guess... I regret ever speaking anything mean of her. Anette is a great singer and is a game changer for all metal singers
She is so off-key through this whole song. She sounds better in the recording but she is the absolute worst fit for Nightwish and the weakest out of the 3 lead singers Nightwish has had.
Idk why people hate her. Of course her voice isnt as strong as floor or tarja but SHE IS INCREDIBLE and has her own style just like the other two.
No real people hate her. Only zombies.
Anette is awesome. She doesn't do the Tarja tunes well, due to the difference in vocal styles, but she's great at the songs written for her.
It's kinda like Deep Purple with David Coverdale replacing Ian Gillan. Does anyone really expect Cov to do "Child in Time"?
@@YngtchieMusic yess.
I agree. Each of these 3 ladies are phenomenal, amazing vocalist each with their own skill sets and styles. Each of them have amazing songs which were written specifically for them. Let's appreciate the legacy and contribution each of them have made for this amazing band. I do have a favorite of the 3 but I enjoy listening to all of them.
I agree. I don't understand hate for the voice someone was born with. This is a different voice people! Idiots everywhere,
Anette is so in her element with this song! She nailed every performance of it.
Russia forever.
@@siriusforever Russia forever stop murdering neighbors.
You first.
@@siriusforever Russia first. I don't murder my neighbors.
@@siriusforever ruso traica aguante Argentinaaaa papa los garchamos de parados a los dos juntos
Annette is just a hell of a frontwoman with an incredible voice, hitting some mighty notes without live... A legend in her own right
Well there's just something about the way she sings this song. She can hit the "one" without sliding, bang on - riveted in place. That adds a lot to the chorus. Powerful piece !! \m/
Well put
Maybe she can hit the "one", but she sure as hell misses 80% of the other notes. It is not often that I hear a voice this bad. Sorry.
Anette un lindo cambio en nightwish. Hermoza
I really love the Amaranth sung by Anette.
Anette was brilliant in nightwish. I don't care what all the haters say
She is so cute also.
I agree. Dark Passion Play is still my favorite album to this day
Haters will hate. She is so enjoyable.
I’m with you on this one. She was an absolutely amazing front woman. Beautiful and talented artist. And in my opinion at their very best. Miss those days.
i discovered nightwish with floor, just recognized how nice anette was
I put this on every morning to get me going. Love this line up. They felt raw and full a energy. Love it.
Still she sings THIS song much better than Floor. Sorry. She had problems with the old Tarja stuff but this is perfect.
Insanamente Dulce. Esta canción es para ella.
Muy verdad.
De acuerdo
muy cierto
i love her, best front of the band , marco shines more with her as well. best album of the band ever
What a beautiful voice
The only version that is relevant
Annete is a pop star singing metal, rock, sinfonic metal etc. And that twist is beautiful
I am a big Tarja fan but this song is Anette's.
This is a great performance! The issue is her vocals aren't mixed right. The strength of Annette's voice is her purity of tone and focused sound. I think she'd sound a lot better if the vocals were mixed louder, there was a bit of reverb, and her midtones were boosted (since the higher tones are what cut through and can be heard, which makes it sound thin).
I miss Anette!
Same but she was always out of breath
@@atcera8714 She's doing way better now in The dark element, check it out.
@@agustinpugliese1715 Thanks I will
I think Floor is the better fit BUT the stuff written during Anette's time fits her voice and doesn't fit Floor's in my opinion.
Me either.
To grow up means to recognize that this lady always was awesome
Annette,,, Hermosa,,
¡Hermoso!
And not to forget she was the original singer from that album this single came from.
Annette tiene una voz muy bonita y con está canción mejor.
I missed her...
Me encanta
Tuomas wrote the best when An was in the band.
Yeah, especially Poet and the Pendulum, that was so epic musically!
Annette is great as a pop metal frontwoman.
I miss her so much
I miss her too.
I was pretty bummed when they fired Tarja but I liked Annette. Then they got rid of Annette too :(
Anette's haircut screams 2008, miss those times.
Kkkk queria fazer esse corte
00:29 yeah
HEP HEP HEP HEP
LMAO! love Anette.
Te amo Anette
she got me into nightwish while i was a heavil addicted to slipknow then
Yes, that Nightwish lineup. Simply the best. Amo-te Anette ❤
0:29 look that BOSS shit
0:54 Tuomas was so fine here tho 🫦🫦🫦😂
Thanks for posting
I first heard Floor’s version and loved it. I read comments that Annette and Tarja did it better. So I listened to all three. I would rank them in this order.
Floor
Annette
Tarja
who sings the original? Anette?
0:53
His face says it all: "omg she's doing it again, make it stop!"
Stop what?
@@noisyboy5529 that irritating "run" or "vocalization" thingy she does at the end of almost every verse. "DAY-AY-AY" "TI-YI-YIME"
It's almost as bad as the people who end their sentences in a higher tone, making it always sound like they're asking a question. 😏
@@derekg7853 OMG SO TRUEEEE
LMFAO
@@derekg7853 That's quite stupid! Some Tarja fanboys are unbearable!
I have to point, this is not the audio from Lowlands 2008, check any other source and you will see. I'm sad because the edition made this sound worse. This audio probably is from Rock Werchter 2008.
TE AMO MÃEZINHA 🖤
You gotta wear black as the singer of NW. But I feel her voice fits the two albums she did, I like her a ton
But Tarja didn't always wear black.
C'mon, Tarja wore with, red and even yellow on stage.
Floor has worn some green, red, white and blue on stage.
@@geelicon but that didn't matter as their hair was/is always black.
@@luxetveritas9196 that's nitpicking
@@meurer13daniel Hard disagree. The black hair is a strong 'gothic' feature.
Darn, A., you've grown.
Best album, but always felt disappoint live.
But,much better than using playback.
This is her song (as is Sleeping Sun Tarja's)
Nightwish and Megadeth are the best!
Megadeth are shit
@@DEERHUNTER1309 Nope
@@hollowmade they are just as shite as Metallica
These days Megadeth are still better than most of the metal around today
@@dean1618 you must be tone deaf
3:22 Marko telling Anette what key to sing in
and more.time HEP HEP
We got a touring keyboardist here!
😊gonna miss this song with anette. Really love the last part
3:43 dedicated for all haters
👍❤👏🌹🥂🍾
She sounded better than floors version...on the album. And I'm not sure that's just not because she was tired? Where in the set was it in 2013. Anyway live she just cannot seem to focus, vocal ADD BRO
Amaranth is only for Anette
Sahara Anette better than floor
Seeing Annette Olson is similar to what Blaze Bailey did in Iron Maiden. All the loves and hate of the fans filled their days with the band.
She's better than Blaze, her albums with Nightwish were very popular, unlike Blaze's albums with Maiden.
I like this band, but they seem to ignore each other with all three singers I will add.
Tarja era - Damnnn this is solid AF!
Anette era - Oh hey nice frontman there, cute too.. are they changing direction?
Floor era - THIS IS NIGHTWISH!
But,they are all good.
Neemuz Ano, that pretty much sums it up. Well said.
Floor era - Covers de Anette y Tarja 👎👎👎
Wszystkie wokalistki fajne a najlepsza Tarja😉
diana Leon metalera
Lmao this is the worst recorded concert I've ever seen, she was so amazing live
I love these two albums with this singer "AMAZING AWSOME SONGS" , but just do not care for much before this and especially can't stand the two i checked out with floor singing.
This song fit for annete ton
then why is she so off key?
When you know, that it's possible to sound worse th-cam.com/video/p56-h1ImdYc/w-d-xo.html, Anette's live singing is like honey...
Anette may not be the best singer Nightwish had, but the most beautiful one for sure
You've clearly never seen Floor Jansen, then.
@@TotsNater Floor she is hideous, she looks like a man
@@TotsNater Floor is more what I'd describe as a handsome woman
@@TotsNater I’d agree if I was attracted to NFL linebackers
3:44. Gorgeous babe alert ! Also, Anette is stunning. In my opinion , better than Tarja.
I like her solo music. I hated her when she was with nightwish. She was more of a radio friendly pop singer. She was boring to watch live. Tarjia would put you in a trance watching her & just sucked you in & mesmerized you. Floor was this power house that came in & demanded your attention & was a force to be reckoned with.
She never could sing live very well.
but this song is perfectly suited for Anette's voice.
@@hasinduwelarathne7113 on recordings yes. But on the live versions absolutley not.
@@hasinduwelarathne7113 If it's perfectly suited for her voice, why did she always struggle with "her" songs live?
@@hasinduwelarathne7113 she never does well in live singing. Her songs with the Dark Elements are in the same way because they all sound amazing on the album; however, when she does live, they sound awkward
Tellement mauvaise qu'elle rate même ces propres chansons 😂 elle pouvait avoir l'excuse de dire que les autres titres avaient étés écrits pour la voix de Tarja mais là elle n'a aucune excuse si ce n'est celle d'être mauvaise.
Le plus cruel est le montage de Nemo en concert avec Tarja (et son band), Anette et Floor. Anette pousse tellement sa voix dans la coda qu'on se croirait à un télécrochet avec une chanteuse qui aurait vu plus grand que sa voix.
She's not made for goth or Symphonic metal 😢😢😢
Absolutely love what she did in the last phrase, that kind of growl, i guess... I regret ever speaking anything mean of her. Anette is a great singer and is a game changer for all metal singers
She is so off-key through this whole song. She sounds better in the recording but she is the absolute worst fit for Nightwish and the weakest out of the 3 lead singers Nightwish has had.
If she was the worst for Nightwish that's totally an opinion, but I can't hear any off-key singing on this version and this is a fact, hehe.
Ok, at 3:28 and some other seconds during the last chorus (she's a mezzo, give her a break) but definetely not the whole song.
I agree but she does this song better than Floor live.
@@simoo7755 lmfaooooo
Your tone deaf
Annette is horrible sorry 😞
Yes, but I like her anyways, she's a very nice person. With her new band The Dark Element she is much better btw, also live.
Let's hear you then smart arse
I feel like she's better on this than Floor is. And I love Floor.
Come smart arse we are still waiting to hear you
@@itsmelissa5788 Unfortunately, being a nice person is not enough when fronting a band like Nightwish.
"She sounds fine to me"
That's because you're not musically trained.
Sweet Anette is Amaranth
Prefiro ela do que a flor