Misunderstood: HOKA Cielo X1 Detailed Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.พ. 2024
- I have enjoyed running in this shoe. The reason is simple, good balance between cushion and return of energy.
I'll say it right now... This is a killer shoe and one of Hoka's best shoes to date. I have seen many reviews of this shoe so I thought I would speak out and share my own view because I'm a sucker for max cushion and max stack shoes and this is at the pinnacle of that.
It's not without fault and I certainly highlight a few but make no mistake, this shoe is revolutionary.
#Hoka #HokaOneOne #HokaCieloX1 #HokaRunningShoes #RaceDayShoe #SuperShoe - กีฬา
Totally agree with you on this one! Might not bother with a review myself you did such a good job- keep smashing it bro! I struggled for a good 5 minutes to get these undone last night, cold hands and these laces almost got the better of me x
These laces are on point! So many reviews are going against which is fair as that’s their opinion. I have to say though Ben, it’s always great getting this kind of feedback from you! And also… you’re lucky you put out the Seville vlog because I was about lodge a complaint about the infrequent videos with the government. You’re safe for now
But you persevered as usual Ben!
Like the honest and high energy review you bring! I’m a new + recreational + older runner with slightly wider feet here. Ordering these X-1s to experience the super shoe hype.
From the bottom of my heart, thank you so much!
Thank you for not just blindly following other reviews! Love the honest content! Also happy to see a Hoka with a bit of higher drop.
You’re more than welcome and always know you will get a true and honest opinion on we here. Thank you for checking the video out
Nice review, love your genuine enthusiasm. And the X1 is probably the kind of shoe I will like. Congrats on your 10K subscribers
Thank you so much, very kind of you m! I sincerely appreciate such feedback and don’t take it for granted
Hi Aubrey, I started running last September and I am loving it. I am glad to have come across your channel. Keep going and I hope your rehab is doing well.
Thank you so much, I hope you continue to enjoy the channel as I go and thank you for the kind wishes. I sincerely appreciate it
Aubrey I think your reviews are the most true to me! Couldn’t agree more! 💪🏻⚡️
I have come to embrace that these reviews are highly personal. I disagree with my favourite channels and at best take their reviews as mere guidance. Cheers for the feedback sir!!!
Great review Aubrey, detailed but also fun! wasn't considering this shoe at all but I may have to change my mind now, not straight away but definitely in the future.
Martin… listen. If you liked the Hoka rocket x2 you will love this, heck if you like cushioning or simply a good running shoe you will like this 😂😂. This will be in the top 3 running shoes of all time in my view
“ proper technical analysis “😆😆😆. Love it! You are the unofficial R n D guy for every shoe company on tongues and laces👍…..bro easy on the “ chill out” it’s why we love you 👊🏽….hope you’re well back from injury🙏🏻
Thorough R&D I tell ya! Hold the shoe up to the light… can you see the light through it? Yeah? Good! 1 point! 😂😂😂
Awesome review and style. Subbed 🙌🏾
Let’s go!!!! Thank you so much… !!!! Cheers for joining me
What a great review…very solid👌
Thank you so much!
nice review, keep going bro!!
Thank you very much. I sincerely appreciate the support
I love this take and fully agree with you about the weight. At least for runners like us, this weight is fine. It still weighs less than a lot of shoes people will gladly do 20 mile long runs in. It matters, sure, but maybe not as much as people make it out to be.
Also, epic colourway and nicely matched t-shirt, to boot!
I’m with you fully, yes the weight matters. It absolutely does… but maybe not as much as we make out. Aahhh yes… the T-shirt… I love the colour and the message… as always, great to see you in the comments section
Great review !!!!
Thank you so much… I appreciate that
Great review, I have one ordered but it's back ordered. Can't wait to try these out.
The feel and experience is highly personal but this is a great shoe. It’s as simple as that. It wouldn’t work for everyone but has to at least be given a chance
@@AubreyRunningim hype...I'll def let you know by the end of the month.
High quality video as always.
A good friend who has the Cielo X (and he has also almost every single marathon supershoe of the market...) told me the same exactly about the laces and the weight.
He agrees totally with what you mention .I am saving money for this beauty..very impressive running shoes!
Thank you!
Thanks for sharing and I promise you it’s an amazing shoe
Great Review Aubrey. Often enough these 'Sho-engineers' often overlook the practical parts of the shoe which clearly hold the most critical part in maintaining performance. The shoe and the laces. So glad you ALWAYS point that out when it comes to every shoe review that you've done.
Yes! Your ending phrase crushes it! "Head to The Clouds .. Feet to the Ground" Mate that hit home. The perfect mantra for us Average Runners.
Let’s go!!! Thanks for always engaging with this content. It’s always great seeing your comments. Yeah I feel like some things are worth spending time on but I really wanted to defend this shoe in line with my opinion.
Thannkkk you!! I can’t tell you how many folks keep telling me “but the laces are horrible” and they haven’t even run in the shoe! I try to tell them the weight and laces were a non issue on the run, but because folks on line said they were bad, then it MUST be bad. They won’t even try for themselves.
Yeah sometimes we are influenced by other people’s views that we make them our own. I just thought I’d share my actual felt experience
So, I couldn't resist and got the Cielo X1 in this Cerise colorway and it really is awesome. It's like the Prime X Strung (both v1 and v2 meshed up together) and Alphafly 3 had a baby together. Haha. It definitely has its own thing going but it's in that category of hyper-propulsive mega-stack supershoes that catapult you forward while being very comfortable and protective. I received it yesterday and immediately took it out on a 10-mile run and I was very impressed although it took a few miles before I was able to pick up the pace after the warmup and also find the sweet spot for the foot strikes.
It really started coming alive when I took it up to 7:00/mile (4:20/km) pace and was singing at 6:30/mile (4:03/km) and faster paces. I took it on a 15-miler today and did around 8 miles in the middle at average of around 6:30/mile with some short segments at 5:30/mile (3:25/km) and the ride was exhilarating. This is the first shoe I've felt that matches up to the Prime X Strung in terms of bounce, propulsion, comfort, ease (keeping the HR down), and the all-important fun-and-excitement factor. The Alphafly 3 is definitely up there but, to me, it's a no-frills all-out serious race shoe and isn't as fun. The AF3 is all about the PB on race day and scattered serious training sessions.
The Cielo X1 is super fun at almost all paces and I wouldn't have any qualms about running a full marathon with it. It has the fun factor of the PXS but is much more stable, so I can run carefree and enjoy the scenery more instead of always being mindful about potholes, cambered surfaces, going fast downhill, and turning corners. For the last 3~4 miles today, I ran at an easy pace of around 9:00/mile (around 5:35/km) and the Cielo X1 still felt really good and kept my legs churning although I was fatigued by then after the long threshold effort.
I can't say that the Cielo X1 has dethroned the PXS v1 from the top of my list, but it has definitely nudged up to #2 ahead of the Alphafly 3 and Prime X 2 Strung. I'll probably still pick the AF3 for a HM or FM race due to its lighter weight (it's 1.3 ounces or 37 grams lighter than the Cielo X1 and that's significant), but I'm not so sure now. I'll just have to go back and forth between the two over the next several months before the fall marathon season.
The Cerise colorway looks really good although I'm generally a white colorway guy with some black versions of my favorites for the occasional rainy days. I really like how it looks although I hope that Hoka will come out with a "boring" white version eventually. Haha. For those who liked the feel and ride of the PXS v1 but couldn't deal with the stability issue, I highly recommend the Cielo X1. The weight is approximately the same as the PXS v1 but is lower to the ground, more stable, and more nimble when turning corners. I also think it's a little more "explosive" on the toe-offs. The Cielo X1 is a revelation - a shoe I did not see coming from Hoka. Hoka really hit it out of the park with this shoe. Yes, it really is a BEAST!
This is the most detailed comment I have EVER received on my channel… I might need to bring you into the review team 😂😂😂
Keep keeping it real Aubrey. Mad respect for coming on here and saying you like the laces.
Just thought I would share my views. It’s imperative that we share our own actual experienced opinions. I think the people who dislike the laces are also being truthful and that’s THEIR truth.
@@AubreyRunning we need more of this in our world 😞
I'm with you! I kept trying to figure out why everyone hates the laces but I ended up loving them. I'm a 205 pound old guy and I absolutely love these shoes. I run a barely sub 2 hour half marathon and these are perfect for my training. I also have the same complaint about the tongue--It takes me a minute or so when I lace them up to get the tongue just right so it doesn't make any hot spots when I run.
This is definitely an all time favourite for me. A game changer
Been waiting for this one!! Totally agree with your points. The weight? Don't feel it. PR'd my 5K first run with these pups, not even going full gas. The laces? Double knot them and they're the most secure in the world due to the texture. The weird blue/green colorway? When you're going fast no one can even see your shoes bro so who cares, fast is hot. As of now, these will be the shoes I wear for my 10K race goal this year. I am interested in the Asics Metaspeed Sky Paris coming soon - but really, no complaints about these Cielo X1s. Love your honesty Aubrey. Looking forward to comparing our 100K results with the X1. So far the durability of this outsole looks money but yeah...the exposed parts do take some damage.
Also, that tongue is most definitely annoying. I have to carefully flatten it out like I"m making my bed 😂 else I get hotspots above my metatarsals.
You are genuinely my twin! 😂😂😂. I am with you 100%
Totally agree with you on the laces, I have a pair of Cielo myself and I totally can’t understand why people hate it. It is not flimsy, it is nothing like gift wrapping ribbon. It is sturdy and won’t come undone at all.
Yeah same here but I guess that’s their view as well. I just thought to share my own felt experience about the entire shoe. I still respect their views but for me personally I didn’t experience any of what I’m hearing
Looking forward to that 100K review !!! 🙂…..honestly,I think “ max stack” is relative to body weight and foot strike,it takes away the temptation to try every great shoe that’s performance based.I am seriously curious about the 2024 Adios 9 ,which might replace my go to shoe ,the Takumi sen🤔🤔
I had the Takumi Sen 8 and loved it for shorter workouts. I also love it for making LOOK like a runner 😂😂😂😂
Woth that said… I have just grown to love high stack shoes over the more minimalistic midsoles. It might be my build or pace or both.
You're right about that price point for sure-- but the hype for this show is undeniable for the Hoka fiends. Another fantastic video as usual Aubrey!
It’s really sad because aise these shoes aren’t made for your average runner. The average runner will not experience the feeling of this shoe because we have bills like mortgages, rent, gas, phone bills and life in general. I would love it Hoka gave people a chance to experience this shoe at a lower price point
I really appreciate hearing how a shoe might perform for us heavier runners. And I think the shoe weight question will also vary based on the weight of the runner. If you have a lot of muscle on strong, heavy legs then the weight of the shoe relative to the weight of your leg might be less noticeable.
Absolutely. Additionally the paces and distances that the runner does!
Good review 👏. I’ve recently sourced this shoe (£212 with discount). It doesn’t feel heavy in hand and feels incredible to run in - given the amount of foam and outsole coverage it isn’t a heavy shoe. A whopping 30 grams heavier than my Hoka Rx2! Mine measures 50mm of stack mid foot area 😮😂
Hoka is really outdoing themselves each time! Well done them! Glad you love the shoes
I love the fact that he love the laces...every single Shoe-tuber is saying how much they hate them or how the shoe's weight is a problem. It's refreshing to hear someone with their own opinion, it makes their review so much more believable!
I think the danger of TH-cam reviews is that we are heavily influenced by a few loud voices and we forget that these (including me) are just another set of opinions.
@@AubreyRunning Yes sir.. I agree with you 100%!
when hoka’s running ambassador Hellah said he didn’t like the laces.., I was surprised..he is usually more positive than negative
@@matthiassventoest6800 yeah I love Hellah… cool guy. But still… that’s only his opinion and we should all form and express our own
The Cielo seems very interesting.. Although I am a sucker for ASICS, so I am also excited about the Asics Metaspeed XX Paris
I hope that they will soon open their eyes and send you shoes like this 😁
I truly believe that one day Asics will see the light 😂😂😂
Bladdered😂😂. Such a funny analogy comment. Great video👌
It’s true though right? 😂😂😂😂
@@AubreyRunning 😂😂
Love the x1 it enhance my performance
Great shoe… love it!
I haven't tried these, but comparing them to the PX2S makes it sound more like a fun daily trainer / long run shoe for bigger dudes. That's how I use the PX2S. I don't think of it like a race shoe, though it can certainly do that.
That’s the beauty of running, it’s very personal. It’s highly subtractive. For me, this is for sure a race day shoe. I raced the Oxford Half I. The PX2 and plan to do similar distances in this one as well
Does Cielo X1 have a removable sock liner? I use a custom insole and some super shoes have permanent liners. Great review ! Thanks.
I’m so sorry for the late reply but yes it does! Apologies again
Great Video!
Between Cielo and new balance supercomp elite v4 which one will be better for a average heavy runner (170lbs) heel striker ?
I will do a video this week on this, thanks for the prompt. I will answer that in this video.
I'm not a Hoka fan but I'm intrigued by this shoe and am willing to give it a try. I'm a huge Adidas Adizero fan and have multiple pairs of the PXS and PX2S and a pair each of the AP3, TS8, TS9, Boston 12, and Adios 8. Love them all and, to me, it comes down to the feel and ride of the Lightstrike Pro midsole. I also love NB FuelCell shoes like the new SC Elite v4, the SC Elite v3, SC Trainer v1 and v2, and the Rebel v3 (have v4 on the way) for a squishier feel and ride. For me, the Hoka shoes I've tried have tended to be too narrow in the toe box and the feel and ride of them just haven't felt as good as the Adizero and NB FuelCell shoes. Ditto for ASICS and Saucony shoes although I do like the feel and ride of some of the Puma shoes very much although they also tend to run a bit narrow.
I've been reading and seeing reviews comparing the Cielo X1 to the Prime X Strung, which is my all-time favorite running shoe with the v2 not far behind, so that got my attention. I also love the Alphafly 3, which the Cielo X1 is also being compared to favorably. Do I need another expensive running shoe that is like the PXS (v1 and v2), the AF3, and SC Elite v4? No, I definitely don't, but I do want. Haha. I love shoes that propel me forward, protect the legs and feet, and keep the long runs (10~20 miles) fun and exciting. Cielo X1 seems like it is more accommodating in fit and has the feel and ride I'm looking for in long runs.
It seems I'll give the Cielo X1 a try eventually, but I'll wait to see what other colorways Hoka comes out with. Personally, I'm just not a fan of flashy, colorful, and busy-looking shoes. Still, very intrigued and I look forward to running in the Cielo X1. It seems like it's right up my alley for the types of runs I do on a regular basis. My mpw average is 90 and on weeks I feel good, I'll hit 110.
You are my long lost twin!
@@AubreyRunning Love your channel, bro. We love running and great shoes make the experience of running that much more enjoyable and sweeter. It's like we go out to run to savor the feel and ride of these amazing shoes!
I chose violence! lol. Love it and love this show for training!
😂😂😂😂 it’s needed sometimes
Stretchy tongues are the worst. Great detail and POV here. 🤙🏻
I would absolutely love to watch a Sagasu review on these (albeit you’re not a massive max stack fan). This is literally one of my favourite shoes right now. The ride is second to none
@@AubreyRunning It’s a shoe I know is not my thing… but alot of the tech and ideas in it I find fascinating. I’m on the fence right now. I’m be in the Mach 6 this week so depending on how that goes I’ll decide. It is such an intriguing shoe in so many ways.
…great review.., all aspects covered. I have to pass on these due to the $275, I can’t take these on as my plated race day shoe. there are other decent options at a lower price.
thanks for mentioning those who wear brooks, I don’t .., but my father in law does.., and he is faster than me.., he is wearing glycerins to race.. and still handles a half marathon faster than me.
Yeah I think the price is going to be a limiting factor for many runners. Which is a shame because this shoe is amazing. A shoe I’d love to see as many people as possible try it!
I’m a heavier guy 190-200, I powerlift year round but I’m in the military so I have to run and I like to have carbon plated shoes for my training and my annual physical performance tests, everyone keeps telling me to go with a Saucony pro 4 as im in the market for a new shoe, last year I ran in the superblast for training and tested in the Vaporfly 2.
With that said would you recommend the Strung x2 or the Cielo X1? Or would you recommend the Pro 4 since its a better all around by public opinion.
Hey hey.. check out my comparison video on the Cielo X1 vs Strung X2 and that will help your decision I guarantee it
Hi Aubrey, do you prefer this or Adidas Prime X2 Strung and why?
I actually have a comparison video, check that out
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Let’s go!!! Cheers
For those that have slight overpronation concerns and have run in it, how does this the Cielo X1 go considering the cutout on the insole is on the lateral side, would i be correct in thinking it pushes you more lateral than medial, thus in turn being a bit of a savior for those who overpronate?
Thanks
Probably not the best person to answer but the high stack will always present a stability issue but the winged plate addresses that
Thankyou Aubrey
Dang Aubrey...lol is that color way only available in the UK or did they send you an exclusive pair? Because here in the U.S. a rainbow's color way is only available.
I also know there are on back order in some places
They are sold out in the UK but I got it from Running Bear. I prefer the lettuce 🥬 colour 😂.
They were sold out the first day they were launched in the UK and the only store to have them was Hoka Covent Garden.
The one from the video just came out last week so plenty of them.
well said bruh
Thank you my man!
Considering it for a hard pack gravel 100 miler, been training in the Tecton x2 and love it but lots of runners wear road shoes at this race and I would love the extra stack. Thoughts?
Depends on the terrain sir, what’s that like?
@@AubreyRunning it’s technically gravel but it’s so packed down it’s hard like roads. Only a few hundred meters here and there of actual gravel.
@@AubreyRunning it’s the Umstead 100 if you search on YT you can see the terrain. I appreciate it very much. I
Hi. Do you think this shoes are roomy and stable enough for people with wide feet and overpronating?
It’s tough to say because I think that’s a very personal thing. I personally have an average width foot and have no problems at all with it overpronation so I wear a neutral shoe
Agree👌
💪🏾💪🏾💪🏾
Do these shoes recommend for people with flatfeet/overpronation?
I wouldn’t recommend it. You would need a support shoe
You gotta remember that the majority of runners who review shoes might weigh as much as a 12 year old child. They are extremely thin with very little muscle mass. Therefore , any shoe over 8oz feels like bricks to them. Weight is really not of any importance as long as it's distributed properly. Example the asics kinsei max. It comes in over 11.5oz but feels and rides like a shoe that is significantly lighter.
Additionally the speed that someone runs at is also a driving factor… with me and my paces, weight is not as much a factor for faster runners
Wow this colorway
I’m all about it!
I'm really confused with this offering from Hoka? I just don't understand why people would use it over the Alphafly 3 or Adidas Adizero Pro 3 for example? I appreciate the Alphafly is a marmite shoe, but there seem to be better offerings for marathon distance from other brands that are lighter and probably faster, even looking at the Rocket X2 for example. Like you I love a fat max shoe so maybe I need to get my ass into my local running store to try it on and see how it feels. Cheers for the review though champ 👌
Very simple answer. We all have different feet shapes. The alpha3 may be too tight for folks with wider feet. The cielo x1 is wide enough to accommodate these folks.
I own the adios pro 3 and recently bought cielo x1. The cielo x1 has a more aggressive rocker and feels even more bouncy and propulsive. The adios pro 3 is lighter. Still undecided which is better.
Yeah I appreciate we are all different hence why I said about the Alphafly not working for everyone. My main issue with this shoe is its size and weight compared to others on offer. I also own the Adizero Pro 3 and think it's an amazing shoe! I'd like to try the Hoka on to see what it feels like though 👍🏻
@@woshihuo which one is softer?
The compression and rebound of these are so much better than the Adios pro 3, can't see myself ever putting them back on. They are 30g heavier but I literally don't notice as the ride is so much better than the pro 3 and they end up feeling more responsive and give back more than the pro 3 anyway.
The upper is horribly warm. You can see through a trash bag too, but that sure doesn't mean that it's breathable. 🙄
Hi Duane, please be assured that my assessment of the breathability is actually done through running in the shoes and sharing my experience in them.
What's really amazing about you is how in wearing that shoe your 10K London Winter run performance declined by 16% from the previous year, yet you're not expressing the slightest hint of disappoint whatsoever. I could not do that, in fact I would be cursing the shoe and then either burning it or donating it to the circus (where it might belong). Look that shoe in the eye and say, "It's not you, it's me"...and go your separate ways. Breaking up is hard to do but you and that shoe are not meant to be... 6:35 min/K? oh hell no.
I think that would be a fair comparison only of if I was running the race as an actual race. Then yes I would be saying that sir. Except the run was my first one back after my spinal injury. It was a fun run with Fordy Run and I was literally stopping to film each street act.
I get your point though but let me assure, the next time I bite down and actually race… this shoe won’t be a drawback at all. It feels like I have found my soul mate 😂😂😂
@@AubreyRunning yeah I know, just yanking your chain a bit since you're now running royalty on these internet streets, have you ever considered how plated bounce / rocker super shoe use may have contributed to your spinal injury? There is no shortage of podiatrists, physical therapists, and runners reporting lower back and spinal issues, potentially correlated with using carbon-plated shoes.
The upper isn’t breathable as it’s almost like a corduroy fabric and feels thick. Feet will be on fire over a marathon once spring arrives
Again… very subjective. It absolutely is. You can literally see through the shoe. Catch me o. My Instagram as I aim to prove this to people. I assure you, this thing is breathable. I have done 3 runs in it and that’s one thing the shoes can’t be faulted for
@@AubreyRunning what distance have you ran upto in them? 10k distance won’t generate as much heat as say a half or full marathon and let’s not forget it’s pretty cold here in the uk. Maybe an updated review when the warmer months arrive to see how the breathability is. Either way your video content is on point and your enthusiasm is infectious👌
I am super interested but all reviews says it's narrow with little space in toe box.
Like I always say… it’s narrow for THEM. Thats the danger with reviews. Take what WE as guidance and not rule. Try them for yourself
@@AubreyRunning Most reviewers have much narrower feet than me, so if most say narrow, it won't work for me.
Dang Aubrey...lol is that color way only available in the UK or did they send you an exclusive pair? Because here in the U.S. a rainbow's color way is only available.
It launched yesterday. I have seen Helah Good (American guy) in this colour so it’s global for sure. I am unfortunately not quite big enough to be getting exclusive drop hahahaha 😂😂😂)
@@AubreyRunning Ok...Maybe it's just available in my area then...and you should be getting exclusives!!! lol keep up the good work!