Love this video. Ciara shook me a bit lol. I will admit I slept on her. Rihanna's C3 did something to me spiritually. Overrall I gotta go with Cici. Preference: Riri
I love both but I pick rihanna has better overall vocalist she may not be the best but she's so damn lazy when rihanna wants to she can deliver excellent vocals
C3- Ciara D3- Rihanna Eb3-E3- Ciara F3- Ciara C5- Rihanna D5- Rihanna (more emotion) Eb5- Ciara F5- Ciara G5's- TIE Eb5- Rihanna E5- Rihanna F5- Ciara G5- Rihanna G#5- Ciara A5- Ciara B5- Rihanna C6- Rihanna E6- TIE I think Ciara is better far as cleaner vocals, Rihanna has more technique I would say and her head voice is just a lil better. All around I'll say Ciara, because Rihanna's voice is damaged. Amazing video btw!!! A1 editing!!!
th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html no she does not win. Ciara never sings better than Rihanna, especially live. Show me a vocal performance of Ciara’s that can compete with this.
Lows was a Tie for me Belts C5 and G#5 was tie for me but the rest goes to Ciara High goes to Rihanna cause she sound stronger then Ciara to me but that C6 goes to Ciara this is my Opinion dont @ me overall Vocal goes to Ciara My preference rihanna
Ciara does not singer better than Rihanna at all, this video is very bias towards her. th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html Ciara doesn’t have a vocal performance that can even come close to this.
Head Voice: Love both Eb5s but love Rih's more. E5 Ciara, especially on You Can Get It. F5 G5, G#5 Ciara. Rih B5, couldn't really hear Ciara's B5. Rih C6. I mean you can hear it, but a foreground note vs a harmonized note is about always better. Didn't hear the E6 from Ci. So Rih by default and I did really like the E6. Ciara wins overall. Rih seems to have a better head voice tho.
Sir. Dave I had to listen to Ride twice to actually notice the C6, I remember a Ci pointing it out to me. it's actually really good note, I don't get why she lowered the vocal production. Ci E6 is there too and better than Rihanna's
You are lying to yourself. Ciara is never a better singer than Rihanna & she can’t even hit half of the notes that Rihanna can. th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html show me a vocal performance LIVE of Ciara that can compete with this.
Bad examples partly... in several moments music play louder then ciara's voice cause her songs made the way it is. So, C3 - CIARA D3 - CIARA Eb3 - CIARA E3 - RIHANNA F3 - RIHANNA C5 - RIHANNA D5 - CIARA (Rihanna always just yelling on that note in all her songs) Eb5 - CIARA (music/oranging covers) F5 - both G5 - both E5 - CIARA G#5 - CIARA A5 - CIARA B5 - CIARA E6 - RIHANNA CIARA!
Rihanna will always win. She is an amazing vocalist. This battle was clearly won by rihanna. You didn't show any of her breaks that she does where she sings with all her heart and that's when she's at her best. I have seen many comments calling riri lazy and I'm honestly offended. People that judge need to look at all of Rihanna's music. I bet that most of you have heard one song and gone . No I don't like rihanna. I'm sorry but look at the full picture. Rihanna is a born singer and doesn't need anything to make her better she's just so talented. Her voice is so different and you here a song and just instantly go, that's rihanna. Sorry but for me rihanna is the winner. Always
Rihanna's BiggestFan so if you're such a big fan. point out her best vocal breaks. because I listed her best ones here for this battle. and I did not include 4th octave belts which is where she shows the best vocal strengths. this is simply Rihanna and Ciara's best and most resonant notes from Lower to higher.
@@Prettiboimico th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html Ciara can’t compete with Rihanna in vocals, no shade but she’s not as talented when it comes to singing.
I love ciar as voice more. it's soft and sultry but I love Rihanna as well. two completely different artists, both mega talented. Rihanna is just more in your face. and I'd have to say Rihanna production is precise, but Ciara has that dirty south vibe whether is pop R&B or trap pop. so honestly I'm done comparing them.
Tbh the only thing rihanna has over Ciara vocally is head voice everything else goes to Ciara. Ciara lows are better and kinda stronger while rihanna can sound airy (Eb3) but I like it. Both could work on their belts but Ciara's belts are better. Great video as usual!
Kyle Peterson you do not understand vocal fach at all Ciara has no head voice, her tessitura is her chest voice (speaking voice) she cannot do vocal runs it's why she sing flat rhythmically and whispers and is inaudible when she suppose to sing high check when she had to sing the national anthem with backing singers I might add she tilted her back and did not the land of the free high note because she cannot do it , in her duets with Chris Brown, Enrique Igesias and Usher the male singers are hitting higher and more powerful notes than her, when she sang The Rolling Stones 'Paint It Black' the ugly toes chick sang it totally flat in chest register Ciara cannot sing even the Mama I wanna Sing movie producers knew that, it was autotune and dubbing all the way.
This video is bias toward Rihanna, she exceeds Ciara in every style of vocals. th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html Ciara has no vocal performance that can compete with this.
There's no such thing as a light lyric mezzo soprano. Light lyric is only used as a prefix for some soprano or male tenor voices. Mezzo sopranos or baritones "the male" equivalent of a mezzo don't have so-called light weight voices. They have a darkness or weight to them which doesn't fit a "light" effect
Mico, The DON oh okay . I guess a human voice is so unique and as so varied as eye colour they have made many different classifications to group people into
This is a 4 year late response but I disagree, Fach's be adjusted to include "Light Lyric" for all types. For example a sopranos like Whitney Houston or Jhud consistently have more darkness & weight than Mezzo's like Brandy who has a voice brighter and smaller than even most sopranos. My second point is that "Light Baritone" is an existing fach that you can google. All in all, the fach system is somewhat flawed because it assumes that people's timbre is related to their tessitura & range.
@@Sloppyjoey1omg … AGREED , even though your comment is 8 months old I agree with your opinion on how the system can be flawed and it can trick ppl into thinking your voice type is determined by color or timbre than the actual tessitura itself . Brandy is a mezzo soprano but has been called a soprano so many times even though her timbre itself isn’t that light.
That first song you played for Rihanna D5 Rihanna sounds a fucking mess. And that was the studio version , Imagine how bad it would sound live. Sound like someone was killing a damn cat.
Love this video. Ciara shook me a bit lol. I will admit I slept on her. Rihanna's C3 did something to me spiritually. Overrall I gotta go with Cici.
Preference: Riri
I love both but I pick rihanna has better overall vocalist she may not be the best but she's so damn lazy when rihanna wants to she can deliver excellent vocals
seyven dreon she needs to train her voice. I like how on Anti she was expressive vocally, she might sound strained but I like it.
@@Prettiboimico yes, she sounded strained but it was in a good way. She needs to train but somehow her voice is still great.
C3- Ciara
D3- Rihanna
Eb3-E3- Ciara
F3- Ciara
C5- Rihanna
D5- Rihanna (more emotion)
Eb5- Ciara
F5- Ciara
G5's- TIE
Eb5- Rihanna
E5- Rihanna
F5- Ciara
G5- Rihanna
G#5- Ciara
A5- Ciara
B5- Rihanna
C6- Rihanna
E6- TIE
I think Ciara is better far as cleaner vocals, Rihanna has more technique I would say and her head voice is just a lil better. All around I'll say Ciara, because Rihanna's voice is damaged. Amazing video btw!!! A1 editing!!!
Ciara wins overall Rihanna just has a better chest voice where as Ciara's sounds too whiny at times but Ciara's head voice>>>>>>> CSquad 💃🏽💃🏽💃🏽💃🏽
th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html no she does not win. Ciara never sings better than Rihanna, especially live. Show me a vocal performance of Ciara’s that can compete with this.
I love them. Ciara's voice is very smooth and pleasant. Rihanna's tone, her accent, her personality and delivery make her music so unique.
Lows was a Tie for me
Belts C5 and G#5 was tie for me but the rest goes to Ciara
High goes to Rihanna cause she sound stronger then Ciara to me but that C6 goes to Ciara this is my Opinion dont @ me
overall
Vocal goes to Ciara
My preference rihanna
Ciara does not singer better than Rihanna at all, this video is very bias towards her. th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html Ciara doesn’t have a vocal performance that can even come close to this.
Rih
Head Voice: Love both Eb5s but love Rih's more. E5 Ciara, especially on You Can Get It. F5 G5, G#5 Ciara. Rih B5, couldn't really hear Ciara's B5. Rih C6. I mean you can hear it, but a foreground note vs a harmonized note is about always better. Didn't hear the E6 from Ci. So Rih by default and I did really like the E6.
Ciara wins overall. Rih seems to have a better head voice tho.
Sir. Dave I had to listen to Ride twice to actually notice the C6, I remember a Ci pointing it out to me. it's actually really good note, I don't get why she lowered the vocal production. Ci E6 is there too and better than Rihanna's
Sir. Dave the C6 was sustained by Ciara, which is pretty good demonstration.
You are lying to yourself. Ciara is never a better singer than Rihanna & she can’t even hit half of the notes that Rihanna can. th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html show me a vocal performance LIVE of Ciara that can compete with this.
Ciara hands down her voice is so smooth and relaxing ..If you think rih sounds bad here then hear her live .
Ciara hgfgdbx
Ciara A Ciara Stan coming for live vocals? Hm ... when can count many a questionable performance from her as well.
Um…we all know Rihanna sings way better than Ciara.
@@Badgalriri2.0 lmaooooo plz go lie somewhere else . Ciara voice is pure no auto tone n nothin is needed
@@Ciarawilson th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html link me to a performance of Ciara that can compete with this, until then, hush 🤭
I'm #Rowlandstones 💎 but...
Ciara wins.
Rihanna's C5 was cute tho
Michael well you're a Ci now 😉
no
I SAID WHAT I SAID
Mico, The DON whatever 😒
No. Compare them live.
Bad examples partly... in several moments music play louder then ciara's voice cause her songs made the way it is.
So,
C3 - CIARA
D3 - CIARA
Eb3 - CIARA
E3 - RIHANNA
F3 - RIHANNA
C5 - RIHANNA
D5 - CIARA (Rihanna always just yelling on that note in all her songs)
Eb5 - CIARA (music/oranging covers)
F5 - both
G5 - both
E5 - CIARA
G#5 - CIARA
A5 - CIARA
B5 - CIARA
E6 - RIHANNA
CIARA!
Rihanna will always win. She is an amazing vocalist. This battle was clearly won by rihanna. You didn't show any of her breaks that she does where she sings with all her heart and that's when she's at her best. I have seen many comments calling riri lazy and I'm honestly offended. People that judge need to look at all of Rihanna's music. I bet that most of you have heard one song and gone . No I don't like rihanna. I'm sorry but look at the full picture. Rihanna is a born singer and doesn't need anything to make her better she's just so talented. Her voice is so different and you here a song and just instantly go, that's rihanna. Sorry but for me rihanna is the winner. Always
Rihanna's BiggestFan so if you're such a big fan. point out her best vocal breaks. because I listed her best ones here for this battle. and I did not include 4th octave belts which is where she shows the best vocal strengths. this is simply Rihanna and Ciara's best and most resonant notes from Lower to higher.
@@Prettiboimico I bet you won’t compare their live vocals 🤭
@@Prettiboimico th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html Ciara can’t compete with Rihanna in vocals, no shade but she’s not as talented when it comes to singing.
I love ciar as voice more. it's soft and sultry but I love Rihanna as well. two completely different artists, both mega talented. Rihanna is just more in your face. and I'd have to say Rihanna production is precise, but Ciara has that dirty south vibe whether is pop R&B or trap pop. so honestly I'm done comparing them.
this shouldn't even be a question & y'all have to stop downplaying Rihanna's vocals. she clearly has a stronger & more distinct voice than Ciara...
fentyaiko everyone can have their opinion.
fentyaiko not even 🤣.....like she sounds decent on track but have you heard her live? Plz
Ciara is terrible live wyd? Her vocals are usually shaky and weak.
Luhh on I'm not even going to go back and forth . Rihanna can't even handle her own songs live plz.
Luhh on ciara doesn't need music in the background to cover up
Woah! Ciara makes her Eb3 sound like what... A3's? Nice lows
by the way, your videos are visually so nice like keep it up man
vocal vids thank u
Ciara
Both are legends.
Ciara better singer dancer performer...Rihanna better songs and more hits
Ciara is never a better singer than Rihanna…
I deffly pick cici
Ciara obviously C-squad
Tbh the only thing rihanna has over Ciara vocally is head voice everything else goes to Ciara. Ciara lows are better and kinda stronger while rihanna can sound airy (Eb3) but I like it. Both could work on their belts but Ciara's belts are better. Great video as usual!
Kyle Peterson you do not understand vocal fach at all Ciara has no head voice, her tessitura is her chest voice (speaking voice) she cannot do vocal runs it's why she sing flat rhythmically and whispers and is inaudible when she suppose to sing high check when she had to sing the national anthem with backing singers I might add she tilted her back and did not the land of the free high note because she cannot do it , in her duets with Chris Brown, Enrique Igesias and Usher the male singers are hitting higher and more powerful notes than her, when she sang The Rolling Stones 'Paint It Black' the ugly toes chick sang it totally flat in chest register Ciara cannot sing even the Mama I wanna Sing movie producers knew that, it was autotune and dubbing all the way.
This video is bias toward Rihanna, she exceeds Ciara in every style of vocals. th-cam.com/video/kJAQv-S3AcA/w-d-xo.html Ciara has no vocal performance that can compete with this.
Rihanna is so underrated ciara cant sing for shit
CIARA, THE BEST
I love C3-Eb3 by both of them for different reasons. Different texture, but I love both
Y'all joking huh, Ciara sound under sung. Rihanna voice have more presence , in all categories. Ciara sound like you have to up the volume.
On I side not I know rihanna voice is damaging but do you guys think she'll every explore her upper belts like she did when she was younger
Ciara.
#RihannaNavy😍⚓
For the D5 you could've used Rihanna's vocals from Sledgehammer
Juliën Bernard don't care for it
@@Prettiboimico You really wanted her to win so bad, Ciara is not better
#Navy4Life
Rihanna
Aren't those high notes in The Monster Bebe Rexha?
chantoya17 I really don’t like that bitch, trying to play Rih like a B5 is too high for her to sing. Move lab rat.
MICO rih sung them live.
There's no such thing as a light lyric mezzo soprano.
Light lyric is only used as a prefix for some soprano or male tenor voices.
Mezzo sopranos or baritones "the male" equivalent of a mezzo don't have so-called light weight voices. They have a darkness or weight to them which doesn't fit a "light" effect
michael woolcock actually there is just like there Is a vocal type called Mezzo-Contralto, there are MANY vocal types.
Mico, The DON oh okay . I guess a human voice is so unique and as so varied as eye colour they have made many different classifications to group people into
michael woolcock yess!
This is a 4 year late response but I disagree, Fach's be adjusted to include "Light Lyric" for all types. For example a sopranos like Whitney Houston or Jhud consistently have more darkness & weight than Mezzo's like Brandy who has a voice brighter and smaller than even most sopranos.
My second point is that "Light Baritone" is an existing fach that you can google.
All in all, the fach system is somewhat flawed because it assumes that people's timbre is related to their tessitura & range.
@@Sloppyjoey1omg … AGREED , even though your comment is 8 months old I agree with your opinion on how the system can be flawed and it can trick ppl into thinking your voice type is determined by color or timbre than the actual tessitura itself . Brandy is a mezzo soprano but has been called a soprano so many times even though her timbre itself isn’t that light.
But live though ... wherrrre does ciara's vocals go???
That first song you played for Rihanna D5 Rihanna sounds a fucking mess. And that was the studio version , Imagine how bad it would sound live. Sound like someone was killing a damn cat.
D D Williams that was her most recent and best D5. the one from Diamonds is terrible.
Mico, The DON You did a good job with this video. Her voice just sounded horrible on that song.
D D Williams fuck you
@@Prettiboimico the one from diamonds is not terrible at all…you’re a Rihanna hater.
That d5 was not horrible at all, you just don’t know music.
3:29
7:05
6:29
Rihanna’s songs??? Please
Jesus Renteria Complicated. Redemption Song. Fool In Love
Thanks ❤️
Do one of Mariah please but great video:)
Trap Soul Mariah Carey?
+MICO yes
wait what's that Ciara song at 5:59
London Smith 5:59 is Rihanna, if u mean before that song it's "Slow Down"
Comparing a Mezzo vs a Soprano basically
SimplyMJ Mezzo vs Mezzo
Ciara paying her Stans to make these inaccurate Vocal Range videos to convince us she is a Lyric Soprano, Lawd Gawd C-squad damn near delusional.
none of them are mezzos
does Rihanna call her fans Navy?
Filipo Ma'aelopa haha yea she does
The Monster Bebe Rexha
Ćiara 4 octaves? U sure
island boy higgs yes sir
MICO oh no she actually has three and a semi tone
island boy higgs she has more range than 3 octaves
island boy higgs no ma’am