ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- Hungary is a member of both the EU and NATO but the foreign policy approach of the country's prime minister, Viktor Orban, often rejects the sensibilities of these alliances. Not one serving EU leader came to Hungary in August 2023, when Prime Minister Viktor Orban celebrated Hungary's birthday. Instead, his guest list included for example: the heads of Turkey, Serbia, Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, and Qatar. What's going on in Hungary? And why does Orban have the friends that he does?
Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#Hungary #Orban
The crime stats don't lie. Poland, Hungary and other Eastern European nations made the right decision when it came to rejecting mass immigration, putting their own cultures and peoples well being first.
😅 or people go to where money is and that is not the east
@@walex5462 a gyarmatosítóikhoz vágynak amolyan Stockholm szindróma..de a kóta törvény szerint részt kéne vennünk az elszálásolásukban...erről volt szó nem arról, hogy ők hová vágynak.
@@adavada5394 their colonisers stole all their resources & put unelected dictators in charge, so what do you expect people to do? You can’t ruin other nations & then complain about migration.
@@walex5462exactly 😅
@@adamllana1443 Yes Dear they should go tó their colonisers but not to aur county . We hadn''t colonies ín the world.
I like the expression "They rejected non-traditional forms of family, along with many other progressive social ideas" 😂😂😂
Old men screaming at clouds.
Of approximately 4,000 Hungarian immigrants who were in the United States at the time of the Civil War, 800 served in the Union Army, or twenty percent. “This degree of participation exceeds that of any other ethnic group in America.” There were an estimated 130 officers of the 800 Hungarians in the Union Army.
@@ZltZltt Cool but what do you want to say with this?
@@csokis1 he somehow wants to say that these possible 800 of 2,2 million made a difference in US Civil War. lol
@@Nubbe999 thank you. I really meant the question. No offense here
Whatever you said. Orban put Hungary first
Not. Orban put his clan first. They are the apex predators here, and Hungary is their own territory. Foreigner predators have to ask their permission to hunt here.
Hungary is de jure democracy, de facto kingdom.
Is that the reason he's more popular than his Western collegues?@@SandorFule
Like Putin put Russia first?
at lest money aren't flying out of Hungary like in Romania@@SandorFule
Leave the EU. Then you can be the first where you want.
I don’t Like Mr. Orban but I agree with some of his ideas. Another thing the Eu always talk about ,Hungary getting oil from Russia. Hungary is a landlocked country, Hungary have a pipeline ,what they expect,not to use it ?
Every other country buying oil and gas from Russian via third countries.
Eu always talk about ,Hungary getting oil from Russia and US is buying uranium from Russia...still.
Hungary's birthday, and Orban throws a party? Really? What a discusting way to put it. I understand that DW News hates Orbán, but please, for God's sake, don't make such discusting statements. It's a national holiday, not some party that was made by a politician for other politicians.
Cry more
@@fluidice1656 Sorry for asking DW News to give us some respect. I know you don't know this word, try to search for it on Google, you may find it helpful.
Orban leads the national government, and the national government paid for the event. It's not too far fetched to say that Orban threw a party.
Yes, it is a really low level manipulation attempt. They bend their knee for a coin..
People who does not know this 'party' can this way have an impression that Orbán has bigger power and control than he really has... But how dumb I am.. that is the goal.. (Non hungarians will never understand how much they are misslead and taken for a fool with that one sentence and the pictures of the fireworks..producers know it well)
Who made the guestlist, sent out the invitations, and made all the arrangements? Did Hungary do this without any humans?
I don't agree with Orban's policy, but this is the first time I agree with Orban regarding immigration.Countries that allowed immigration to bear the consequences.
Nem is kell neked egyet érteni! Elég ha mi Magyarok egyet értünk!😂
@@GaborFarago-fp1ns🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 🤣🤣😂🤣😂It is wonderful. The chosen road is towards your original destination. Good road.🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
Countries signed the UN asylum treaty (including Hungary) No country is "allowing immigration" most countries work according to the treaty and their independent rule of law.
Immigration is not bad per se for a country, Europe would have been bankrupt long ago as too little people are born to sustain the economies in European countries, governments walk a fine line between the population that want less immigration and companies that are screaming for more (cheap) labour.
Hungary does the US-way of cheap labour, just make 1% extremely rich, and the rest of the country gets poor and is willing to work for close to nothing just to stay alive. And Orban gets his votes because the 99% of people are afraid their life will be even worse with immigrants coming to their country that will steal their jobs.
ps. Would you clean toilets for a living? do you know any people who would?
One could not just stay inside eu and veto everything, do whatever he wants veto everything and ask the others to pay without questioning his violation. There are rules. You don't like it, you go.
5 years ago DW was respectful. Now you have taken sides like most modern journalism. You either pay your journalist very very good wages, or your editors only allow their agenda.
Forza Hungary! God bless you all.
Köszönjük
❤
It is very interesting that you create such a report without even trying to show a balanced view. Normally you would voice opponents as well as people in favour of a leadership. The way you structure videos like this shows you have a clear agenda and you are not even technically try to show any truth.
Biased "trust news outlet" at its finest
But it's true, isn't it? Orban is looking east and despices the west, except for the money. He takes the EU hostage in decision making in alliance with Poland and maybe now with Slovakia. A friend of Putin and Erdogan. We can't trust him. This can't be good for Hungary. Don't complain about a missing balanced view when Orban is just simple and clear with his statements.
Absolutely agree!
There is no truth other than Orban receives 5 times the amount that he puts on the table, and he uses his position as a member to get more and more in a sistematic way,
Try to ask something from the "fidesz" leadership :D they don't give answers, just running away.😂
One thing is for sure ☝🏼
In Hungary is NOT a single terror attack, there are not Palestinian invader vandalism.
On the other hand he should cooperate with western allies a bit more .
But for him, Hungary FIRTS , which is normal .
Hungary is a Russian asset successfully copying its autocracy.
This is really true...
@@FUNATtiCGamer But the price fot it? Feudalism.
@@Pekka.Pekka.1296 Feudalism is middle age history....capitalism with a nice portion of social assistance what is really going on in Hungary, system is same in general as in any country in EU....
You get pays it’s due to israel so
Happy Birthday my dear Madjar cousins!!!!!
Magyar ! ))
if they understand me - i dont care :)
@@LEK-we2hh
Thanks!!
@@timursadi6981
I don't either 🤭 My name is Chuck ........ I don't give a........😆
@@LEK-we2hh Chuck Norris :) all the best man
I know the German Chancellor Olaf and with all due respect, there is not much to talk with him about, that's also the reason he is in that position. 🤣
Of approximately 4,000 Hungarian immigrants who were in the United States at the time of the Civil War, 800 served in the Union Army, or twenty percent. “This degree of participation exceeds that of any other ethnic group in America.” There were an estimated 130 officers of the 800 Hungarians in the Union Army.
Do you see at the demonstartions people being arrested or biten up?
Every one can share his opinion in Hungary! No one silenced!
There is corruption, But even amongs the leader of the EU. Corruption is Europien norm.
Yes people were being arrested :) :)
@@mesqueunclubful Who?
@@TheVektast Students who were protesting. They were released but the cops 'started investigations'. Obviously they won't be imprisoned, These are just psychological weapons. They want people to fear them.
Also teachers who were going on strikes and protested were fired (in a lot of cases)
@@mesqueunclubfulnobody where arested dó not lying please
techers were fired who protested
For me, the Dutch elections show that people want to get rid of left-wing ideology, and maybe Orbán is on the right track to making the right choice for all countries.
The right is called right for a reason
Geert Wilders only got 21,85% of the total votes and right now, it's very unlikely, that he can form a government - which is not suprising at all.
Netherlands is not Hungary, where Orban can win 2/3 majority with only 3 million votes out of 7,8 million.
@@alfoldmapping5504dicsőség a fidesznek
Dutch case is completely different, Orban is just corrupt autocrat, anti immigration and nationalist rhetorics is only a tool in his agenda to brainwash population and to stay in power. In Netherlands mass immigration has became a real problem to some extent, so it's reflected in the outcome of elections
The Dutch election showed that 75% of the Dutch people didn't want Geert Wilders
The amount of manipulation in this video is unreal.
Explain.
This arranged video is another attempt to manipulate and mislead a nation towards transnation power as if modarate mind..
@@nedeljkovarcakovic3655 you wont get that from bots. they gonna tell you its all a lie and manipulation and thats it.
@@nedeljkovarcakovic3655They didn't like it - ergo it must be some kind of political manipulation conspiracy
Happy birthday Hungary.
Brave man ORBAN
Very happy with our evil dictator, sorry EU 😢
Of approximately 4,000 Hungarian immigrants who were in the United States at the time of the Civil War, 800 served in the Union Army, or twenty percent. “This degree of participation exceeds that of any other ethnic group in America.” There were an estimated 130 officers of the 800 Hungarians in the Union Army.
That's on August 20th
Thank You ❤️
3:29 - Yeah, and there were no "how to prepare for freezing to death" types of demonstration films here. So it is interesting that while the criticism is sharp in terms of how low the salaries are (I would note that there are more German / English / French / American and so on owned employers in the country than Hungarian ones), they expect us to give up the cheap and reliable energy source for an unpayable (at least x 5) cost and uncertain origin. So we should to practically replace the Russian gas and oil, which reliably arrives via pipeline with an American source, which arrives from the other side of the world to ports that Hungary does not have, and pipes, which ends at the national border, because our dear western neighbors didn't really care about building the right european infrastructure for the untermensch of central Europe. And just because Putin so and so, and for the holy Ukraine, where, by the way, one year after the outbreak of the war, in the former Hungarian territories (National minority areas in Ukraine inhabited by Hungarians), statues of Hungarian origin are torn down by Ukrainians and Hungarian schools are forbidden to speak in Hungarian. It was probably the most important thing they had to do besides the war... How interesting, how interesting. Of course, the list could go on and on... and if I feel like it and have time, I'll share a few thoughts, because it is more than likely that in the west, which is full of freedom of speech, such stories are not heard by the dear audience, because such excellent channels like this somehow don't like to share...
Thank you! More people should know about this!
You are proposing to continue sponsoring Russian aggression against Ukraine
Europe has failed time and time again to understand that money is not everything. Ideologies, fanaticism, are very powerful realities and they cannot bring themselves to deal with those effectively.
So you turn tu russia? the same russia allied with iran (where teens are killed for not covering hair) and north korea? Man, Orban is just a thief, there is nothing more to that. I hope Hungary greate people gets rid of him.
🤔 Then perhaps it's time for EU West to stop bailing out Hungary and Turkiye's failing economies with billions/yearly. Let them get help from Russia and China. As for friendship, let's see how kindly any of those lily white countries will stoop down to actually mixed breed with Chinese or African countries.
You do realize that Putin, Xi Jinping and any other dictator does it out of pure greed right? They don't believe what they spout, the only thing that matters to them is that they are in the power. They will say and do anything to keep themselves there. Orban is doing, what is he doing, because he knows that under a democracy, he would be replaced sooner or later...
You have zero understanding of Hungary if you unironically assume that the average voter for Orbán's party is anyhow politically aligned. A small portion of them really is, but the majority is just cleverly manipulated apolitical masses.
orban chases money
1 of the few countries that still genuinely strives for peace.🙋♂️🇫🇮👍🕊🕊🕊
God bless Hungary.
So from who should Hungary buy their gas from DW? Please tell me.
You should eat beans and you will have plenty of gases. Almost for free.
Everyone how's not dancing to the rhythm of the progressive left is alt-right.
So because he's not a sheep and says his own opinion and thoughts he's now a bad guy? What the heck is wrong with everyone who says that here? Ever heard of democracy? Everyone has a right to have his own opinion about issues, and that goes for EU members.
Látod, ilyen egyszerű.
You can both use your rights to freedom of speech AND be a bad guy doing it...
Its like when Trump says he will be ''dic.t.ator but just for one day!''. That's also freedom of speech... but see the problem with certain opinions and thoughts??
9:18 labeling Jordan Peterson as alt-right is all I need to know when assessing the credibility of this channel.
Denying he is alt right tells us all we need to know about you too
Jorden Peterson is the darling of the far right, its amusing that literally every far right true believer refuses to admit that.
With all due disrespect to Orban, I wouldn't invite Scholtz either.
With all due respect. Germany should keep their money to themselves and no money to beggars.
Lol is there a state named Germany anymore? I thought it is officially US minor.@@petitben5240
@@petitben5240 Germany still needs to pay reparations. After that, it can become a part of Israel, if I care.
In program noone said about Hungarian history.hungarians root witj relate Turks.Vctor Orbar prefer good relations with Turk nations countries.Azerbaijan Turkiye Kazakistan Kirgizstan .Ther are turk nations❤We love Hungary.
Hungary has a lot of roots with Ukrainian people too. Anyways Orban is against the EU help to Ukraine
@@user-tn1pf5fp2b2 millió ukránt etetünk és szállásolunk Magyarországon .Munkával és iskolával , lakással is segítjük ezeket az embereket a háború kirobbanása óta...nem tudom te mit értesz segítség alatt adjunk fegyvert a gyerekek kezébe és küldjük biztos halálba öket? Neked az a segítség?
@@adavada5394 nincs itt 2 millió ukrán. Átjött annyi a határon , aztán mentek is tovább.
@@doradiary3391 ha elmentek miért van teli velük a munkásotthon, óvodák, iskolák Pesten vidéken egyaránt? Amúgy meg folyamatosan jönnek a határon napi tizenkét tizenötezren...lehet hogy ennek nagyrésze megy tovább, de addig is itt eszik alszik ruházkodik a szeretet szolgálatok civilek és állami intézmények megállás nélkül segítenek .
@@user-tn1pf5fp2b azért kíváncsi vagyok, ha a fajtádat küldenék a frontra golyófogónak, akkor te hogyan reagálnál..küldenéd S fegyvert, hadd hulljonna férgese?
Wrong question. Should be put the other way around: What's up with European leaders? And go figure that.
Cheapest energy in Europe I think people hate him for that
EU: Hungary is doing what US not allowed to do, crazy !!
Wut.
Hungary is flirting with Putin and the other criminal countries like BRICS….
Let Orban go ASAP from EU and NATO….
It’s funny how this media classified JP. Among all other factual things about him.
JP is clearly pushing a North American conservative viewpoint along with his philosophy. Why else would he be invited to CPAC, and accept it? It's a good thing that he encourages young men to take responsibility for their lives, but it's bad that he pushes a political narrative to the same people, without presenting different viewpoints.
This shows how desperate they really are.
Does liberal democracy means when Washington and Brussel say "jump !", all you can say is "how high ?"
No. But dont beg for money in Brussels if you dont want conditions attached.
@@quintvanblitterswijk6162 so liberal democracy use money to control each other, not to promote real liberal democracy where people have different ideas?
@@quintvanblitterswijk6162 Sounds like quid-pro-quo, isn't it?
Conditions like accepting illegal immigrants ?
@@boxingsense3459 If you join a club, abide by its rules. It's like any partnership - If you keep on looking elsewhere and are being obstructive while getting the benefits, then go.
I am Polish and I am so proud we chose new government and left Orban behind. Poland deserves better. I have never felt any special bond with Hungary.
I am Polish expat and feel exactly the same ✌🏻
The Visegrad4 was a healthy opposition to Brussels. And you do know what they say about the lack of opposition, don't you?
@marthacichon5950 you are just too good and too sophisticated 🥲
I never understood the friendship between Poland and Hungary, a neutrality makes more sense. While Poland is full of great and good people, Hungary is full of trolls and good people.
why would there be a special bond? the two countries are historically and culturally very separate. hungary used to form an imperial state with austria, and they once or twice occupied poland or parts of it for a little while, but who hasn't?
in the 20th century, poland went into WW2 as territory divided between germany, austria-hungary and russia, and got I think its second go of independence afterwards. in WW2, hungary was allied with germany. both poland and hungary were eastern bloc members, but hungary functioned more independently and more open to the west in trade and travel than most eastern bloc countries, whereas poland was almost as much of a puppet state as east germany.
hungary has more historic ties to austria and to the balkans than to poland.
in language, hungary is extremely distinct, as hungarian together with finnish and estonian form the finno-ugric languages, which originate in the ural mountain region of today's russia and are not part of and are highly distinct from the indo-european languages spoken by basically everyone else in europe. not only is polish more similar to other slavic languages like czech or russian than it is to hungarian, but it's also more similar to german, portuguese, swedish, farsi, or hindi.
Wow, if there ever was biased nasty reporting...stinning 1st prize DW
don't care much for orban, but this dw report makes me agree with some of his points, odd really. sees like that no country has a right to follow their own way. you must obey the eu way, which doesn't work.
There are basic principles on the separation of power, meant to safeguard democracy as well as some basic principles of human rights that the EU demands of it’s members. Hungary has been dancing on the gray line and increasingly stepping out of line. The EU is a club of liberal democratic countries, set up to try and prevent the kind of horrors that happened during the first and second world wars. When a member starts flirting with authoritarianism then the EU has full rights to pressure their member to comply. If the country doesn’t like it, it can leave the club. Brexit has demonstrated that no one is forced to be a member of this club if they don’t want to. It would be a shame if Hungary decides that they would prefer to be outside, but at the same time, if they keep moving further in this authoritarian direction and don’t leave the EU, I think they should be kicked out.
@@sgjonibest comment, thanks for that!
It’s not about migration. Orban selling citizenship to anyone. Nobody wants to stay in Hungary even Hungarians. Orban built a softish little Russia within the EU this is the most terrifying thing.
@@sgjoni Somehow Orban is attached to Putin, as this would be the case...in fact Hungary nad Orban did huge effort to safeguard democracy, the communist era inherited constitution was trashed, and new baselines considered.
What one can see now, is clearly a political game between left and right wing in the EU. As you said, EU has left wing, Hungary elected right winged government, and since 2010, Orban is the pm again and again. But it can change, as free will election is provided really. Left wing is not so favorable to the majority in Hungary because of Gyurcsány Ferenc, who has failed as he admitted (in a closed party) they were cheating at everytimes, and in every possible ways during their reign, just to keep the power, and get more money from the system to their hands, meanwhile driving Hungary to bankruptcy....
Left wing can say, "ohh there is still the leaders are stiling money", but yet the country at least doing well, and ppl know, all on high level would still money, so whatever....
Basically no human rights or whatsoever is in danger in Hungary, this are left wing bullshits....as this "report" also false...Hungary did all the structural changes what EU wanted, still no money from EU. This is the game, aiming to have leftists in rule of Hungary, nothing else....
Ohh Orban and Putin....clear economic relation, as Hungary depending on Russian energy historically, but Hungary already started to working on the separation from Russian energy....But still, you would not find it in left winged media emphasized...
@@zoltanvass9492 Gyurcsany and Orban co-operate, that's for sure. Either side had the chance to imprison the other at some point...
Unbalanced bad "journalism" as usual.
lol "risking trust with our allies" 😂😂😂....which allies is that dear, do you mean our allies that sabotaged another ally's infrastructure ...aaaahh, with allies like these. Ya'll very blue pill here 🇧🇬🇭🇺. Can you blame Hungary, as for Serbia - joining the EU at this point is like rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic
This video is excellent material for a public opinion manipulation course in media.
Yes, Orban making out with a pack of dictators is excellent for a public opinion manipulation.
So is your post
He stands up for his own people, that's why the eu hate him
If by standing up for his people you mean creating a corrupt oligarchy and threating the future of his people by keeping hungary a poorhouse and trying to align it with other corrupt poorhouses.
Yeah, he definitely does.
@@artonio5887 im ok if they get few cash in return of saving the country look ,west europe... Look zelensky days ago bought 95 million worth yatch his wife in newyork buying all kinds of things with the money given by EU and america instead of helping poor ukranians.
Get out EU !
Which is why he is disempowering "his own people" more and more? Corruption, as a real indication of "standing up for one's own people" has been increasing for years, ranking 77th in the corruption index in 2022. The opposite is the case, isn't it?
good joke, sir. congrats.
Let the Huns have a referendum on Hunxit.
France and Germany: Shitting on Hungary every time they do something
France and Germany when they dont get invited to Hungary's birthday party: 😲😲😲😮😮😮
🤣😂👍
In your dreams.
Hungary is sick.
Like ín kindergarten 😂
@@akosh99😂like yout brain?😅
What’s up with fair and balanced reporting Fanny Facsar?
Facsar ín hungaryan means misstatement...nomen est omen
@@adavada5394 No it doesn’t,but anyhow…
Hungary is huns. They are from Kazakhstan. Central Asia. And CA will supply Hungary oil and resources for sure.
That’s what iktor orban believes too. Hungarians? Not so much…
@@mrm3800I am an outsider who studies this topic. I’m curious what are some general Hungarian views on their origins? From my genetic research the Hungarians migrated from the Urals and the Szekely are Huns as well
@@EzraBenKhazar what you've wrote is generally accepted, but there is no definite clear answer. It's still open research and there are several debated theories.
The Hungarian tribes were living at one time in the Khazar Khaganate, until they were pushed westwards. Some of the Khazar tribes joined them, so indeed, Hungarians are partly Kazakh too.
@@EzraBenKhazarHere is a hungarian view for you. The origins of the hungarian nation pretty much far from the present population composition of Hungary. The hungarian language is Finno-Ugric - so relating with Finn, Estonian and north-east European smaller folks. (Manshi, Khanti, Mordvin etc.). This is the core of the hungarian language - our basic words coming from the Finno-Ugric root. Hungarian or "Magyar " tribes moved to South of Ural and migrated to West through 500 years. During this period Hungarians met with turkish folks, and few of them melted into the hungarian tribe. The Hungarians who arrived to their present place in the 9th century weared turkic clothes, used turkic war strategy and tribunal system, turkic names. After Hungary decided to baptize to christianity, the western impact became determinative. During the 1000 years long history so many invasions, resettlements, war happened in the territory of the country, the uralic population melted into the big central european genetic pool. This mean the genetical map of present Hungary very similar to the Austrian genetical map. Present Hungarians keeping their unique culture, holding Eastern and uralic impacts (for example the pentatonic folk music), and holding a unique Hungarian spirit. Meantime the present Hungarians a descendants from slavic and german people - this visible in their outlook and characteristic. According to the DNA map, the Hungarians mostly Celtic R1b (27%), Slavic R1a (25%) and Germanic I1 (21%) and South Slavic I2a (14%). As you see 87% of the present hungarian population holding this very european genetic admixture. Orbán's himself has austrian ancestry. So you can see that in Hungary the cultural heritage and the very strong spirit survived the times, meanwhile the genes are not! This is based on the Hungarian language, as we saying "The nation living in it's language!"....
This is outrageous, Hungarians do not want to be replaced by arabs and africans in their Hungary! Why not take example from Germany, having already 3,000,000 Turks and inviting 4,000,000 more.
Hungarians are also outsiders who stole the land they live on. Grow up
@@moif_velocitawrong we conquered* and fought against = Kingdom of Italy
East Francia
Middle Francia
Great Moravia
Byzantine Empire
Catalan Counties
Upper March of Al-Andalus
First Bulgarian Empire
Khazaria
West Francia
Lower Pannonia
Principality of Littoral Croatia
Kingdom of Croatia
Principality of Serbia
Duchy of Carinthia
Unlike slovakia serbia austria Romania ukraine and so we didnt got the lands gifted by the treaty of trianon 🤢
replaced? how? what happens with the natives?
They don’t wanna go to Hungary anyway
Lmao there are already so many Gypsies there i dont think anyone will notice lol
2:39 Using pressure is suddenly unusual in 'western political culture' when Hungary makes demands? Why was that pressure not unusual when you were forcing LGBTQIA down Hungary's throat?
You forgot to mention the results of the national consultations in all the major issues that concern the Hungarian people. I wish other countries would follow this practice. For example, Switzerland has tradition for centuries to ask its people. Well, that's democracy. Rule of majority...
Why spoil the holiday with the presence of leaders of Western fascism... Happy birthday, Hungary!
Huexit in the making. Is this the end of European Union and nato
Nope.
Please, let it be so.
Shame on you DW News !!! Leave the Hungary alone. They don't want to follow you guys' agendas....and you start talking bad things about him. Shame on you DW News !!! 😢😢😢😢😢
They want to be Russia’s puppet state instead?
The EU does not speak with one voice in foreign policy since there is no common mandate. There are 27 sets of member state ambassies in all countries around the world. So the EU should not expect Hungary to behave as if foreign policy is a common EU mandate.
They should never have enlarged EU to poor European countries. They should have kept the old common market. Now they have taken former eastern block countries with all their problems.
Why? Do they lack gray cells or common sense? Perhaps they are determined to blackmail UE.
@@petitben5240 ehh you think western block doesn't have problems? Islamization of France Belgium, Netherlands and Sweden, Desertization of Spain, Balkanization of Portugal, deindustrialization of Germany... every country in the EU has a major problem to solve. It's where EU must commit to aid and help to resolve those problems, and not isolate itself from the country.
Of approximately 4,000 Hungarian immigrants who were in the United States at the time of the Civil War, 800 served in the Union Army, or twenty percent. “This degree of participation exceeds that of any other ethnic group in America.” There were an estimated 130 officers of the 800 Hungarians in the Union Army.
@ZltZltt that means absolutely nothing today. It's Haitian french army trained officers who help the United States continental army defeat the British red coat. So, your history of Hungarian fighting for the union is wonderful, but do you know how many Eastern European fought with the confederacy to keep the barbaric legacy of slavery. History is sometimes extremely complicated.
It's kinda funny when you accuse Hungarian government of "interfering with public education".
If there is a few sectors state absolutely needs to interfere then it's a public schooling
Lol as someone who went to state school in Orbanistan I can tell you that they absolutely need more interference.. just not in the education material, but financial aid. Most schools in Hungary (esp. rural) are collapsing, rundown and sometimes dangerous. In my elementary school once the walls were soaked after a heavy rainstorm and it was dangerous to turn on the lights :)
Hungary the money collector，there is chaos there is chance to make money😂😂，nothing more，Mr orban was born for money，nothing more😅😅😅
Status on Hungarian public schools: in our middle school our kids had to bring their own toilet papers. We had to photocopy the history textbook for the entire class. There was no art class. But the kids were happy, because what is sold to the public and the EU as education was actually a good time for them. The teachers let them play on their phones the entire day.
Kuss te rohadt f@sz
Hungry is probably the only country in Europe which can pursue its own independent policy . They are not like Germany or France which are satellite states
No no. We do not hate those two countries, Germany and France. Or not all of us. But we don't like it when someone else decides the fate of our country in our affairs, not us. The fate of our country was already decided at Trianon, and Hungarians living abroad have been suffering ever since because of the evils of oppressive nations. We DON'T WANT another bad thing like this or worse!
they want to be satelite of russia
Yes, but it is unfair to say. We had the occupying forces leaving the country in 1990. Germany wasn't this lucky.. they still have them.
Also we knew for the whole time, that the occupies are lying to us...thought to the children that what is in history books, TV, radio, what activist grouped are saying..are coming from someone with different interests than ours..so they are in most cases likely to be lies or half lies.
The germans did not really have this filter.
Well, let them be true individualists and stand on their own financial feet. Who keeps them in the EU?
@@conaccento Really? Then please answer when we joined the EU, was this what they are doing now? No, right??? Are you sure then that the problem lies with Hungary and not with the bureaucrats in Brussels who built the empire? Where are the equal treatment politicians in the eu?? Everyone waits for years to join, for example, but Ukraine would be admitted immediately on political grounds.. Where is the equality here? And why aren't wages equal in the EU, for example??? Where is the investigation into the vaccine procurement scandal??? Nowhere, right? Well, just in light of this, threaten here in a veiled, hidden style! Thanks!
As a westerner I respect this man’s integrity. I struggle to find something like him in Western Europe.
I wish we had this kind of excellent news coverage in Canada.
It is bias.
You can see similar in China or North Korea, have you noticed how many were interviewed on the accused part?
So everyone can stay up to date on otter mating habits?
@@nyali2 I think it is a sad change in politics in all around the world. Politicians refuse to accept interview request from non-friendly media. Fidesz is in the forefront on this as they stopped to accept invitation from independent media for more than a decade ago.
How and like what. Le Québec ne veut pas de cette propagande européenne.
2:42 Western countries have never linked conditions in one relationship (for e.g. NATO) with concessions elsewhere (e.g. EU, IMF, arms deals, etc)?
He is the only sane person in club
How dear you, Mr. Orban, you didn't invite French President Emanuel Macron and German chancellor Mr. Scholz to your party. Didn't you think that you were going to hurt their feelings?
A nyugat eltemetett minket tianonnnal, csak azt felejtette el, hogy a mag mindig kikel 😂
Most logical leader in Europe whose support national benefits more than EU and US benefits.
Sorry if we invited our cultural cusins to our nations birthday instead of someone who always intrigue against us.
Seeing what migration caused in Germany, France, Italy. Hungary is 18th safest country in 2023. Conservativeism and nationalism is not a crime It doesn't matter how liberals want to paint it.
And it looks like people has enough of liberals. Look at the elections in Finland, Netherlands, Italy, Slovakia ect...
... they form death squads there and kill minorities?
The march of the frustrated also passes.
Seeing the migrations ín West ..everybody eats its selfmade soup.
The problem with Hungary there is no alternative on the left side which could replace Orbán. If there would be a party with left values but not supporting the migration. Hungarians want to be Hungarians in Hungary. And it seems the left side doesn’t want to understand that. I myself live in a very mixed country in England and I see this mixed cultures just doesn’t work.
You see? damn mabye you can take orbans place? you need to share that insider info to everyone and explain how you ended up like this
I live in the UK atm. The population density, immigration and economical power are just a few factors where the UK and Hungary differences multiply.
Yet the UK is more capable than Hungary in managing these factors.
If you take aside you are not exactly welcomed with open arms ( you won't be anywhere as a man anyway ), and different cuisine The UK is a great place to live in.
I bet there are plenty of people who feel happy that the only thing they can brag about is 1) having to prove their worth and skills 2) eat some undercooked food with no spices.
out of everything that could go wrong. I am happy it's only these two and I don't really have a problem with 1st point because as a man, you got to do that anyway anywhere you live in. Nobody likes lazy slackers
edit: I am from Czech Republic, not Hungary
The opposition is so corrupt, power hungry and they can't offer anything to the people. The majority of Hungarians very satisfied with their PM Viktor Orbán, they don't want to replace him, only the opposition would love that but they have no program and no vision.
Hungary is a European state, Orban a EU leader…what is the narrator talking about?
Germany has long been trying to enforce that nobody is "out of step" of its marching. Should be enough of the "One EU, One Thinking, One von Leyen" attitude! Germany will never learn?
Ja wohl haha
You do know germany lost the war right. Charlotte knobloch said in the budestag. You lost the war you will continue to fight for your germany and we will keep fighting for our germany. So now you know the trouble germany has. She is israelis
Deuschland wird nicht Sanionirt, aber Ungarn schon. 😮
God bless Europe
The woke left are panicking 😂
Oh the left?
Like the literal communists building universities in hungary, from China?
ukraine in the EU, great joke😂
Hungary in the eu,great joke😅
Jordan is not alt-right. Plus his characterization in this video is completely partisan.
DWs characterization of Jordan Petersen is shameful.
Orban is a freedom fighter. He fights freedom at every turn.
He does not seem to accept 1956 and 68 in Czechia.
We Don't accept 1848 and 1920
The usual "balanced" view of the german state-funded media. And it wasn´t "Orbán throwing a party", that´s the way Hungary as a state and as a nation celebrates it´s jubileum, it was that way even under communist regime!
Hungary should be thrown out of the EU.
When the left is on my boot
yes, EU should be the little brother of US and follows big US's instruction!
Living in Hungary I also wish we would leave this leftist experiment destined to fail.
@@jeffxu6871 Russians are not allowed on TH-cam.
Nver gnna happen 😊
Isn't it very sad that EU come to the point that Hungarians can talk more with Turkey and Azerbaijan then with European leaders.
Yes, but I need to ask the question: Is it that all EU leaders are making a mistake and Hungary is right alone? EU politics is worse than Azerbaijan or Turkey?
@@sebipayne Wake up buddy! Welcome to reality!
@@jakabgipsz4910 I don’t know about you but I would rather live in Germany than Azerbaijan. But I respect your opinion.
@@sebipayne That's the problem with you, you want to live here and there, always where it's better... and we like to live where our roots tie us! Where our parents, grandparents and great-grandparents lived and sacrificed their blood and work so that we could have something! I know this is hard for your kind to understand! But that's your problem!
Unfortunately, it seems we don't have a leaders anymore in Europe.
They look more like choir singers with Choir master.
Hungary Economy would/is collapsing without EU funds
The EU funds Hungary is entitled to has been withheld for years, and miraculously, Hungary has survived. Go, figure.
Keep crying
@peterbalogh8138 it survived because its exports it unemployed to Germany&Swiss record high inflation is pushing people in to poverty.
@@peterbalogh8138 At what cost though? Hungary's was on brink of collapse during the gas crisis.
just because europe inflicted themselves with sanctions doesn't mean hungary has to. hungery has to suffer poverty to prove their loyalty? what idioicy. @@TheBlackIdentety
Why he didn’t invited Scholz?
Because chances are that he will not be around for very long.
As opposed to most EU leaders, Victor Orban cares more about Hungary than about what the US master’s directives.
He cares about Hungary but not about Hungarians - they're leaving in droves
@@moif_velocita they might,it’s a free world supposedly,french people are coming to Canada in droves even though Macron is the total opposite of Orban,German industry is leaving in droves re-locating to places where they can afford to operate even though Scholtz is what EU dreams about.
From what I know,people from neighbouring countries go to Hungary to fill their gas tanks.
Orbán cares only about his own power and wealth. Education is failing, healthcare as well, the inflation is the highest in the EU and the list goes on...
@@moif_velocita
Hungarians leave the country in one of the smallest numbers proportionatly considering the eastern European countries. About as many hungarians live in other EU countries as Austrians in other EU countries. And the number does not really grow, because it is not a one way road...about as many moves back home as many leaves. Also we have a significant ammount of German and Dutch people coming in. Mainly people who got to the point where they are financially free in Hungary, but would not be in Germany etc., some for political reasons, some because want to live a richer life on his/her pension, some just want to be able to live from the pention., some for sense of safety.. very diverse bunch of people..
He doesn't care about Hungary. He's stealing his own taxpayers' money like there's no tomorrow and every decision his making serves this goal. He made his exschoolmate the richest one in Hungary. The guy can't even speak Hungarian fluently 😂
Not to mention orban is Putin's lapdog. That's not the interst of Hungarians.
8:07 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️ Jesus! NO ONE IS FORCING THEM TO STAY IN THE EU!!!!
Top on the list of EU perceived corruption, but I note all the actual proven corruption has sat with other countries in the EU. I find this both ironic and ridiculous.
Most people don't know that Hungary has one soviet build nuclear power plat that produces ~45% of electrical power. Hungary needs Russian expertise to run this nuclear power plant.
Actually once some other country was asked to repair partially our nuclear power plant in Hungary and it leaded nearly to a catastrophe. Rosatom from Russia came to save the situation.
Its only money 😆
Everything about money. Just look the prices of Brent , WTI and Ural.@@LEK-we2hh
I like DW channel for various reasons, but i also think it's a propoganda machine.
1. Definition of Conservative. Its someone that is change averse, someone who is not prone to challange its beliefs. If you are born in a family in US, where changing sex with surgery is absolutely normal, thinking that meat industry is the reason of climate change, or Putin is a dictator that just wants to stay in power and you are not even willing to challenge those beliefs, then you are still a CONSERVATIVE, definitely not progressive. As semantic it may sound, that exactly what media does on these subjects. So this wording in political media is absolutely misleading.
2. If anyone watching this video is not familiar with Jordan Peterson, instantly would be shocked and condemn the organisers to invite such person. Would raise a lot of questions. But we know very well who Jordan Peterson is.
3. I'm from Azerbaijan. DW news calls Aliev an autocratic leader, dictator and so on. Sure, i was born in 1995, his faster was in power and now him. But guess what? That is exactly what is needed. We are only 30 years independent country rich in Oil and Gas and many other resources. When you are an ally with Turkey and Russia, this is the form of goverment you get, its simple how it works. But
But we know the cost of leaning towards West and going againsy Russia. We have seen it with Georgia , Armenia and now with Ukraine. The cost to become an ally of West is thousands of dead bodies, lost territories, and decades of delayed burocracy and in the end you are not even sure if they will contunie to support you. E.g. Ukraine case.
Do we want that? No thanks man.
Im happy with Aliev and his policies. People are getting wealthier year by year, life standards are significantly increasing month by month, corruption is gone from vast majority of areas in the country, it's very safe, i can go to city center at midnight with family and not even worry a bit. Try that in Paris.
Azerbaijan keeps good relationships with countries like Russia, Turkey, Israel, China, and have economic growing economic and cultural ties with Western world.
Your very selective choice of Hungarian political commentators is clear as to the intentions you set out to present and to say about Orban Viktor.
What is said has more to do with attacking Orban on personality traits and "European Norms", which are never defined. The sour grapes taste comes through in your commentators' declarations.
The DW is as balanced that all the Hungarian commentators in the video are with left-liberal opposition, no one from the right-wing to make the video balanced by opinions.
But we know the liberals are tolerant until you share their opinion.
Well done Mr Orban from South Africa 🇿🇦✌
I like how you depict Hungary as an "extreme outlier" in terms of energy dependence while multiple EU countries are renewing their resources purchaises from the russians. Such a shield tactic.
Really? Then why are China, India, Hungary are buying up Russia excess oil at such low prices?
@@pohanahawaiibecause their leaders are clever.😅
Lol.. he is leader of his country and answerable to his people, he can choose to be friends with anybody for the benefit of his people.
It is interference from other countries that is the cause of conflicts, prime example is Ukraine.
Despite Zelensky voted on a peace ticket to reconcile essentially a civil war, he signed on instead to NATO funded proxy war.
ever heard of sphere of influence? you can't do business with a hostile country that played the major role in forming the military alliance you're in. isn't that a bit weird? he can make business with so many other countries, why the invader Putin? Hungary is a small country, a VERY small country yet they bark so loud, weird, right?
Oh, so it was Zelensky who attacked Russia? Can you tell us in detail what happened in 2022 on the 24th? Who attacked whom? NATO attacked Russia at the hands of Zelensky? What world do you live in, what reality? I want you and your Asian children to experience everything that Ukrainians experience. And I would sit on the couch looking smart and writing messages on TH-cam.
Answerable to his oligarchs, his people dont get a say.
We, Ukrainians, have been defending our freedom, territory, the right to rule on our own land, the right to exist and other sovereign rights from Russia since 2014, when Russia treacherously attacked, violating our agreements (Treaty on the State Border, Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation , Budapest Memorandum and others). Ukraine has never attacked anyone and has never been an empire in history. Zelensky, the composition of parliament, all previous presidents and parliaments came to power democratically, that is, they were elected. Yes, we still have a strong oligarchic influence, there are problems with corruption, but if you look at the trend, you will see progress (largely thanks to the European vector). For 300 years in the Russian Empire (and then the USSR, remember Holodomor), the Ukrainian language and Ukrainian identity were infringed on at the state level, but now we have strong support in the world and we will not give up the right to our own national state, for which we fought for so long.
There's not one more illiberal structure or project West of Russia than the EU.
Do you ever heard of Victor Orban? great guy, leader of Turkey 😂
🤣🤣🤣 Yeah, and a friend of Trump, too!
@@PetrCaracas this literally tells everything how he works lmao when his sentences contradicts with yesterdays 11/10 best great leader wish we didnt had
😂😂😂😂
Orbán Hungari,Erdogán Török!2🤴💪💓
Why are you comparing and crying, EU tastes their own medicine.
What about Zimbabwe's Orban or Montenegro's Orban ?
I heard they visited Hong Kong's Orban to discuss important matter over the oil crisis in Europe and Africa
Orban has a right to protect his country's interests like everyone does, EU try to help to all whereas his own population is just struggling. Shame on you eu
Interesting report from liberal mainstream, looks they heard the voices of the critics, that not only bias neoliberal experts they asked, but first time ever I saw in a liberal mainstream channel a conservative thinker, to answer to defend Hungary's position. Meantime of course the whole tone of the report was bias, few times false and not very fair, but still we can celebrate the breakthrough, that they gave a small few seconds to a different perspective than their own!
Important thing to mention. We would never leave an established alliance! We wait until it destroys itself, then turn off the lights and close the door! :D
Liars. There are no new gas deal with Russia. Those are deals before the Ukranian war. And they are not talking about where are the energies originating form at the other states. Buying second third hand energy from Russia is the same. Again do not make economic decisions based on non economic factors.
Germany, France are on the way to become new kalifats and going down economi... Orban is looking for good partnerships
Orban may not be a nice guy, but he's definitely a good leader. Something the EU, the US and the UK simply don't have!
His job is to take care of his country and his people and that means making sound economic deals and diplomatic engagement with strategic partners. The EU and the West as a whole have become a pathetic Middle school garage band rather than a group of countries actually engaged in conducting pragmatic International Relations.
How true😂😂😂😂😂😂
Wut.
A good leader doesn't steal the money of his own taxpayers, makes his superdumb ex-schoolfriend and his relatives the richest ones of the country while making fool of and manipulating the uneducated millions through the state-owned media.
If Putin is a good leader than orban is as well..
He does not really take care when the national minimum wage is less than EUR 600... (in HUF of course)
No he’s not a good leader
Fun... very soon EU elections. But we cant vote for smart people we trust in other countries list. the gamble is clear.
One thing his government does that others should do to counter the lack of babies being born in western countries is cutting income tax from new moms. Meanwhile in places like Canada those without kids (who want them but can't afford them) work to pay a high tax and barely get any help for their children when they have them. If a couple even gathers the means to be able to do it (an ever so rare thing these days) the tax benefits and returns are a joke, barely scratch the surface of how much it costs for a family so survive.
No country is perfect but Orban’s Hungary is as bad as RuZZia!
in most countries there are tax cuts based on having children
In Hungary if a woman has 3 children, gets a massive tax cut. If she has 4, than zero income tax for life.
With 3 children also the gov grants about half a flat worth of money and gives a super cheap gov protected loan that covers about the other half of a flat and the repayment is about the same ammount as the monthly tax cut. So after all if you have 3 children, you get granted about 15 years of salary of an average Joe.
I don't know any other country that gets anywhere near this.
This Earth experiment is going well, we are chocking ourselves to death. Just in my lifetime, we went from 2.8 to 8 billion. All systems are built for more voters, devotees, consumers, workers, producers listeners, clicks. it is a perfect way to self destruct. maybe some other apes will develop in a few million years upon our ashes.
Just FYI: because the gvt supports having babies only on paper they have a massive decline in birth rates.
Hungary is an authoritarian hybrid regime in which orban steals the taxpayers' money (via help of his oligarchs), the educational system is in ruins, childbirth centers are closing because of lack of personel - this shows how he cares about demography: nothing counts just the power.
Why is Hungary in the EU? Free cash? What an insignificant country being a thorn in the flesh of both EU and NATO.
Orban is focused on developing his country and economy while other EU countries are slaves of USA and their economies are being destroyed by all theses sanctions. For example Germany sanctioned Russia and buying Russian oil through India at the higher was price how dumb.
Why are you in EU? Free cash??? Heard they giving 500 euro for lazy immigrs
Because in Europe people do not vote for parties that give the EU the power to kick Hungary out.
Hungary is not an anti-EU, pro-Russian country, as it was said in the whole video. Yes, Orban has insane and corrupt policies and I hate him as a Hungarian. But don't equalize the whole Hungary with Orban. Most of the Hungarian population supports the EU and Ukraine.
@@alfoldmapping5504 quit the nonsense, Orbán and fidesz is what will save Hungary.
16:06, “He will become more dangerous…” I didn’t expect from DW to listen to palm readers but yes when they are no facts to present one has to use other means.
The captions are wrong here 1:40
I am a British Pakistani who loves the old family values of Pakistan and the UK. Victor Orban wants to keep family values. What the heck is wrong with that!!!!
Who is he to decide what family values are? 😂😂😂😂😂. That’s the problem!
No, he only wants to protect his power and uses every populist weapon to reach this goal.
@@davedon260 'he not decide it !! the Citizens does !!! it was a public opinion vote in Hungari and the public decide that they don t need what the west wan t to offer !!
@@szamitogep215
They don't have this kind of things..like regularly voting on issues in betwean two elections. (Ok once the UK did it, but turned out that the public did not agree with the elit.) So it is not a thing in western Europe. Imagine the people could decide😮
You couldn´t be a hungarian pakistani because Orban.
2:34 Well she should mention that the funds are Hungary's withheld funds...why did the EU withheld those funds in the first place
Probably because the EU is allowed to and because Hungary didn’t care about the rule of law
Aaah. Because of graft and corruption in Hungary and failure on human rights reform. If Hungary wants the benefits the EU, then obey the rules. Otherwise, rejoin the Soviet bloc.
Hany tehervonat erkezik naponta Kinabol Nemetorszagba,tomve elektronikai cikkekkel?
Bulls.t, US keeps on trading with Russia, too.
The list is getting longer:
Hungry, Slovakia, Italy and Netherland. Pretty soon, you'll find you are the minority.
As a Hungarian, I hope, that Orban and Fico will be removed soon. Also, Wilders can't even form a government at the moment.
4 against 23 - and yeah, we're trembling in our boots over Geert Wilders and his crazy alt-right hair cut
@moif_velocita1624
What really matters is that Trump will be the next US president very soon in this country. MAGA, our tax payers should not pay the security for Europe.
@@waynegore5291 Hegemony doesn't come cheap. Pay up, yank
@Memovox
Just wait several more months. You'll see. LOL