I feel like the phrasing was wrong. I think he wanted to remove half of all sentient life. He thought resources were too scarce, and most resources come from life
I think so too. We don't see trees and the like disappearing. Also plants and animals, while they are life, can be considered resources for intelligent life which is probably what Thanos meant.
Well, first, Thanos snapped off only a half of sentient life. Second, the snap didn't turn bodies into dust, it made them completely disappear from existence (if you watch the process carefully you can notice, that dust become smaller and smaller and afterwards nothing remains)
Yah the dust just disappears completely into nothingness. And when the people are shown coming back the dust just forms out of the air and rebuilds them.
This is a really interesting take on Thanos's Snap that caused the blip.. the thing is in the movie... I don't know if it was a view of New York City or but the weather actually looks like pretty bleak and dark... I know I'm reading into it lol but you're theory makes sense... My biggest question for the blip was how many accidents it caused....planes..cars... were enough people left in the government to keep it going? What about people that work at a nuclear power plant? growing and shipping food? So lol another Ice Age plus thousands of deaths caused by accidents...limited utilities...famine... This was a really great discussion sir...I kinda feel like I would be lucky if I got blipped lol... Props to your channel..
One thing that is interesting, is that Thanos specifically said to Tony "Once I'm done, I'll make sure Half of Humanity is still alive." Meaning, he snapped a few civilations COMPLETELY. So some sentient species just dissappeared. Also I heard from the comic nerds that the snap was actually better for the unviserse due to snapping also half of the World Eaters, meaning that the Avengers cast undoing the snap possibly doomed more people than Thanos did. Though No idea about the nitty gritty of the comic stuff and how the MCU actually introduces it, considering they have changed a lot too.
To people saying that Thanos plan was useless, that is the point. He is the MAD titan, He is doing what He believes that will save everyone, not what actually will
Then there's the fact that at least 25% of the planes in the sky would simply fall to the ground, that half of the cars on the road would immediately crash and that there would be quite a lot of trains derailed, further increasing casualties, as well as the amount of soot in the atmosphere.
Volcanic eruptions and meteor impacts can alter the climate because they loft particles high into the atmosphere, not because they simply create new particles.
Firstly it probably wouldn’t cause a nuclear winter or post super eruption like scenario because the dust wouldn’t be thrown high enough into atmosphere and most would just coat surfaces and then get mixed into water and soil. Secondly it really seems like the snap only applied to sentient life as we didn’t even see a single plant or bird get dusted so it would be more reasonable to take half of all of humanity’s biomass which would still be a lot but it would be way less than what you used here. Good video though.
The snap is related to all life. Kevin Fiege said so in an interview. They just only showed main characters getting dusted because doing the same for every blade of grass in a scene would be insane.
If you really think about it: He got rid of ALL life Anything that manufacturers new cells is effected So he did nothing to save resources He should've just put 50% of a population on a spaceship and moved em to a new planet that was made to have the same ecosystem as their home planet
Ok but, how much of the ash *would* end up in the atmosphere? Volcanoes and asteroid impacts have a lot of energy going on that blasts it into the air. None of that is present here. Of course, it's dust. So a wind could pick it up. But would that get it to the upper atmosphere? I think more research is required.
the dust would all be on the ground not in the air, besides it would have been cool to go I tj wagyu this would mean for ecosystems and microorganisms. the title felt like a lead on
Everyone misunderstood the snap. He could have erased all life in the universe with just the reality and power stones. By using the whole gauntlet everything just works itself out. The math is literally pointless. Heck... Why do you even assume that's just dust?
thanos unintentionally causing a absurd pseudo nuclear winter on a universal scale is probably something the writers didnt think about
tbh they don't really think much about anything
@@neljx they stopped thinking after age of ultron and all that multiverse snap crap
Thanos also solving global warming is crazy.
Modern problems requires modern solutions
I feel like the phrasing was wrong. I think he wanted to remove half of all sentient life. He thought resources were too scarce, and most resources come from life
I think so too. We don't see trees and the like disappearing. Also plants and animals, while they are life, can be considered resources for intelligent life which is probably what Thanos meant.
All resources come from life.
@@Mechjeb661 not uranium it doesn't
@@katethegoat7507 you havent met my uncles pitbull Jimmy
@@katethegoat7507if life didn't exist nothing would
Well, first, Thanos snapped off only a half of sentient life.
Second, the snap didn't turn bodies into dust, it made them completely disappear from existence (if you watch the process carefully you can notice, that dust become smaller and smaller and afterwards nothing remains)
I’m allergic to dust I’m screwed
Also cool
I don't think there's gonna be dustmytes in the people dust
I don't think they turn into dust. I think they just cease to exist and the matter that made up their bodies is simply gone.
Yah the dust just disappears completely into nothingness. And when the people are shown coming back the dust just forms out of the air and rebuilds them.
This Anthropocene mass extinction is about to make the Great Dying look like a paradise.
why are we assuming high sulfur volcanic dust? surely the dust would have the same proportions of elements as made up the biomass?
so you're telling us that to prevent the global warming we need to turn half of living things into dust! Geniuns!
almost as powerful as my dad
This is a really interesting take on Thanos's Snap that caused the blip.. the thing is in the movie... I don't know if it was a view of New York City or but the weather actually looks like pretty bleak and dark... I know I'm reading into it lol but you're theory makes sense...
My biggest question for the blip was how many accidents it caused....planes..cars... were enough people left in the government to keep it going? What about people that work at a nuclear power plant? growing and shipping food?
So lol another Ice Age plus thousands of deaths caused by accidents...limited utilities...famine...
This was a really great discussion sir...I kinda feel like I would be lucky if I got blipped lol...
Props to your channel..
One thing that is interesting, is that Thanos specifically said to Tony "Once I'm done, I'll make sure Half of Humanity is still alive."
Meaning, he snapped a few civilations COMPLETELY.
So some sentient species just dissappeared.
Also I heard from the comic nerds that the snap was actually better for the unviserse due to snapping also half of the World Eaters, meaning that the Avengers cast undoing the snap possibly doomed more people than Thanos did.
Though No idea about the nitty gritty of the comic stuff and how the MCU actually introduces it, considering they have changed a lot too.
To people saying that Thanos plan was useless, that is the point. He is the MAD titan, He is doing what He believes that will save everyone, not what actually will
Then there's the fact that at least 25% of the planes in the sky would simply fall to the ground, that half of the cars on the road would immediately crash and that there would be quite a lot of trains derailed, further increasing casualties, as well as the amount of soot in the atmosphere.
Volcanic eruptions and meteor impacts can alter the climate because they loft particles high into the atmosphere, not because they simply create new particles.
Firstly it probably wouldn’t cause a nuclear winter or post super eruption like scenario because the dust wouldn’t be thrown high enough into atmosphere and most would just coat surfaces and then get mixed into water and soil.
Secondly it really seems like the snap only applied to sentient life as we didn’t even see a single plant or bird get dusted so it would be more reasonable to take half of all of humanity’s biomass which would still be a lot but it would be way less than what you used here.
Good video though.
The snap is related to all life. Kevin Fiege said so in an interview. They just only showed main characters getting dusted because doing the same for every blade of grass in a scene would be insane.
If you really think about it:
He got rid of ALL life
Anything that manufacturers new cells is effected
So he did nothing to save resources
He should've just put 50% of a population on a spaceship and moved em to a new planet that was made to have the same ecosystem as their home planet
marvel didnt take this into account when making movie 0/10 sue
Ok but, how much of the ash *would* end up in the atmosphere? Volcanoes and asteroid impacts have a lot of energy going on that blasts it into the air. None of that is present here. Of course, it's dust. So a wind could pick it up. But would that get it to the upper atmosphere?
I think more research is required.
the dust would all be on the ground not in the air, besides it would have been cool to go I tj wagyu this would mean for ecosystems and microorganisms. the title felt like a lead on
Even the survivors are fucked
Everyone misunderstood the snap.
He could have erased all life in the universe with just the reality and power stones.
By using the whole gauntlet everything just works itself out.
The math is literally pointless.
Heck... Why do you even assume that's just dust?
Just leaving a comment to help with the algorithm