Palestinians: Are you able to criticize your culture and religion?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.ย. 2024
- This project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
Please donate to the project at:
* www.paypal.me/...
* / askproject
.
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.
Those 3 Palestinian Girls were so well spoken.
Anon ymous I'm sure you mean in the English language.
Yeah...I mean they were speaking English
Yeah, I really wish we could hear answers from more people like that, who can really consider and answer clearly.
Yes, those three girls were obviously very liberal. You can deduce from what they said that they wish one could speak about these issues more openly.
To be honest, I think those girls are not religious. The only reason they're wearing a hijab is probably because they have no other choice. I don't know why but they give me the impression that they're non believers. :D
+Equinox Just 'cuz they can speak english very well doesn't mean they're non muslims, there are plenty of Muslims in West who discuss religion openly.
Respect to the women in this video, all much more reasonable than the men.
how?
When you become the most discriminated demographic in your society, you are indirectly being forced to become critical of your culture and religion. That’s why women seem more reasonable than men in this video.
Women have more heart than men generally.
@فؤاد العباس العسقلاني, do you know what is a slut? It's a woman that behaves like a man.
Women should be free to do whatever they want, as men are.
@فؤاد العباس العسقلاني, but you answered, didn't you? 😅 Explain me why your opinion has more value than mine. This time without insulting, because it's... Childish.
" Islam can't be criticized , any other religion can be " - height of hypocrisy & supremacist behaviour
thats why the world wouldnt be peace
That's The Real Meaning of word Peace
THIS VIDEO is crucial. Self-criticism of Islam is FORBIDDEN. Unfortunate but true. This is an unmovable obstacle to world peace.
Never mind. Putting aside what adherents can say, many of us non-believers think all religions are absurd though good manners preclude us from saying much to the face of those who believe unless it offends our morality.
The biggest obstacle for world peace is the west and its foreign policy.
Can you show me the evidence that self-criticism is forbidden?
Tasin Al-Hassan everyone who criticized Islam is now dead.
Tasin Al-Hassan is Jewish.
Those girls at the uni were pretty cool. Is it customary for people at university to speak English that well?
Antimony Cup in birzeit and al najah the 2 biggest universities in Palestine ofc yes :)
Thank you
until they get married thats when their life ends
who said ???
first of all they are in beirzeit which mostly ramallah and bira and women their are active
mayor of ramallah is a woman so !!!
a lot of them work and do what they want
for sure its not so white life but still not in a bad way in ramallah which more open minded as a city
yeah actually
Ask the same question to Israel Arabs!
hahahahaha thats ture
i dont blv that if abraham himself exist
but if he exist he is from iraq not levant
so let his sons go bach their
this land has civilization 7000 years before abraham
Random Guy Israel is built on secterism.
The Arabs actually expelled the Jews from their homes before 1947/8, when the war started, they brought this on themselves
@Mou Mou Lie in my ass,
If you have nothing to add to our knowledge just shut your fingers up and don't waste our time reading your idiotic comment.
the more interesting question would be: "can you criticize your government?"
I really appreciate the three young women who are very honest about what it’s really like for people to try to speak out the religion and culture .
This idea of conditional acceptance within Arab families or societies really bothers me. My parents are constantly pestering me about being religious, despite my hidden apostasy. They reject all information that contradicts the Quran and maintain some pretty backwards views. The fact that they are so adamant about it depresses me.
Very sad, especially if you are trapped in a country where Islam is dominant.
That sucks. I'm also an apostate but I've been luckier with my family situation. Pls join the exmuslim subreddit if you haven't already!
I believe there is a differene between having an islamic cultural upbringing and being religiously muslim....for example, i find that the reluctance to criticize Islam is a trait of a people who had an islamic cultural upbringing which forbids this type of thing. But converts will regularly engage in debate about Islam bc most (not all, but most) understand that in a country where freedom of speech is prevalent, that YOU NEED TO DEFEND YOUR IDEAS FROM CRITICISM.
I always feel sad to see another youngster leave Islam bc of the stranglehold their muslim family or friends or society has on their freedom to express themselves, it basically gives you little choice but to leave Islam...but i understand why you leave.
What is one backward view they have because of what Al Koran says?
Jaqua Shabazz
The problem isn't so much what the quran says, its how its enforced by those who follow it.
Nobody wants to be forced to believe or do anything. Like if you love a particular food you'd probably hate it after a while if someone forced you to eat it when you didnt want to....that's kind of what's happening w islam.
The biggest issue is that they believe their souls are the perfect ones
Aaron Zhu as if the jews dont believe they are Gods chosen people.
Actually Muslims don’t believe they are perfect
Yeah but they are always butthurt if their religion gets criticized. "but muh religion", "but muh feelings". Bullshit.
Donde está Carter!! That’s because they believe the Quran is literally the word of god, and god is perfect so why wouldn’t the Quran be? Lmao
Who told you we think our sould perfect ?
Tbh, the younger Palestinian generation is more and more critical about those things...
I guess they are... 50 years ago there was much more honor killing and more marriages between close relatives. Young Palestinians doesn't take 3/4 wifes anymore, at least not so often. Off course, there are things Muslims will never accept in their society - LGBT will never be accepted.
Stella Smirella it will take time of course, but the Palestinians who are living in Israel are accepting it more and more, I am excepting the same in the West Bank but not so much for gaza ;)
Md mrq there is no palestinians living in israel. they are called israeli-arabs.
Yinon Dukhan there is no Israeli arabs sorry to disappoint you and your colonialist view :)
Md mrq an arab that have an israeli ID is an israeli arab, so you're wrong.
Great channel!. Thank you for building bridges between people!. Much love and respect :)
as a palestinian...im really ashamed of the males in this video they are completely.. closed minded but the women were very well spoken god bless them
Agree
The guys should be forced to wear skirts for their cowardice
you should have asked them the simplest question - can they criticize their own government? (their answer would be absolute silence)
@Someoneak17 Somewhere Netanyahu has nothing to do with arab/palestinian leadership, The one thing for sure is that palestinians can't criticize Abu mazen nor Haniya since they are so afraid of getting killed by only saying their own mind
As an Israeli I really feel sorry for the thoughtful Palestinians... It seems like that the secular/mild Muslim and peaceful side of the Palestinian people is just muted.
Nikola Tesla
brain washed ppl like you.
Nikola Tesla
oh I'm sorry. you rather I'll call you "one track mind" people?
Nikola Tesla ok shithead go fuck ur self cause even Tesla wouldn't prefer that over running around a Circle in the speed of light to fuck himself
Nikola Tesla something other than you obviously maybe your mom
@Someoneak17 Somewhere Good luck in life with that attitude.
If ever I see you making a video, I'm going to repeatedly back my car up in front of the camera just to keep the tradition going in all your videos. :D Loving your work, hope to see more Q&A interviews.
How is this video only 2000 views, Corey this should be over 1 million views.
anyone else smell the fear and discomfort?
Not as much fear and discomfort as the crusader 1.0s caused amirite
@@younes5043 😂
5:52 if its true why are they afraid to criticise it
“Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us.”
- Golda Meir 👩
Watch: 👉www.palwatch.org/main.aspx?fi=157&doc_id=15070
“We are not afraid of Martyrdom. Not long ago, you cried out loud: 'Death for Allah is our most exalted wish!' (Muslim Brotherhood slogan, -Ed.) You received the death you wanted." [Al-Aqsa TV (Hamas)]
there's no separation between the religion and the state in arab world . so if you say anything badly toward religion it will appear as form of opposition to those who's holding the power. and the religion is the perfect tool to keep people obeident and none would ask for change
true
the question also need to be if they can critisize their government (PA)
Yinon Dukhan palestine people come from saudi arabia-bosnia-ottoman-yemen.
Yinon Dukhan arabs palestine are racist to black palestine.
Palestinians don't have a government; they have a kleptocracy supported by Israel and the West.
king of somalia horn african. What about 40 million Iraqis and 90 million Egyptians are they also racist to black people?.
Mark Simons yeah because the PA is so pro-Israel, idiot.
I like those 3 girls, they seem very open in a society where suppression is everywhere.
The three women going to university were beautifully real.That is how it is
Here's my answer:
Culture: absolutely yes! it's ever-evolving, and there are some backward concepts that should be eradicated.
Religion: no, our religion is perfect and faultless. HOWEVER, the people practicing the religion are not perfect nor faultless, so THEY can be criticized, the way they use aspects of religion to harm others or impose incorrect notions.
what if for example there is a non muslim be it a christian or jew or whatever who thinks that muhammad was a false prophet and islam is a fraud? is that sort of idea okay?
@@user-vh7sl4kn9f thats not criticizing but thats insulting or claiming so provide your evidences
a sexist and homophobic religion can and should never be considered perfect and faultless, your religion is extremely imperfect and full of flaws and scientific errors
What a nauseating culture where you feel suffocated 24/7.
As a palestinian i will criticize Islamic extremism and ISIS.
That is somewhat different.
that's not the question
50% of palestinians support isis.
Osama Hamdallah We dont support ISIS they are killing people
Random Guy we dont support ISIS and the people we see on video they are afraid to talk about them
HAMAS is not terror organization like ISIS and they want palestinian freedom but sometimes they attack innocent people under their rule so. i see them against the law.
Thanks a lot for posting this! Definitely eye opening, especially the three Palestinian girls & the other in her store, what they shared was refreshing to hear.
wow those 3 palestinian girls spoke way better english than the average israeli....I wonder if the girl in the middle was actually american and just visiting
Billy Batts No, she's a Palestinian, she's majored in English literature and translation at the uni, she's as well known for her high intelligence, very smart girl with bright thoughts, special student. All respect to her.
and she will be married to her stupid cousin.
The issue with regards to criticizing religion in Islam is that most Muslims don't have a very in depth understanding of the religion, that's why people are scared that if they criticize anything in religion that it means that they're criticising the whole religion, when in reality they might not be, maybe they are infact just criticizing a radical concept or ideology within religious academics.
For example, when I was a teenager I thought as a Muslim I would become sinful if I were to criticize al Qaeda, Osama bin Laden, or extremist ideologies because I thought it meant that I was criticising the religion. When I went to Africa (best places are Mauritania with Sh. Abdullah bin Bayyah and Murabitul Hajj and in Darul Uloom Azaadville (South Africa) with Sh. Abdullah Dabhelia, Sh. Ahmed Chotia, and his twin brother Sh. Muhammad Chotia. When I studied by these scholars, sat in their seminars, and read their books) they taught me straight from the Quran and the Sunnah about how killing Jews and non Muslims are not allowed in Islam, and they openly condemned 9/11 and taught me that as a Muslim I'm allowed to criticize extremist and militant ideologies, and that by helping eradicate extremist ideologies I'm actually getting rewarded each time an innocent Jew, Christian, or non-practicing Muslim is safe from harm and evil, and that all these extremist and militant ideologies have nothing to do with Islam.
I implore that everyone listens to individuals like Hamza Yusuf, Habib Ali Jafri [great grandson of the Prophet Muhammad (ص)], Zaid Shakir, Murrabitul Hajj, Dr. Timothy Winter, and Sh. Abdullah bin Bayyah if they want to know how other Muslims can help fight against religious extremism.
Yusha Umeri can you criticize Mohammed's words tho? i'm pretty sure you can't. (not to mention, there are some REALLY questionable things Mohammed said in the Ahadith)
some young Muslims want to question & be critical , but they have been indocrinated as shit
معظم العرب لا يميزون المعنى بين النقد والنقض بل وكثيرا ما يخلط بينهما.
النقض يعني الهدم
النقد ان تزن الامور وتناقش وتسمع لكل الاطراف وتميز الغث من السمين، الذي بدوره سيصل لنتائج اكيد افضل.
و ما ان ترى شيئا حرموا ومنعوا "النقد" عنه فاعلم ان هذا الشئ هش وضعيف الحجة ويحتاج من يحميه
Great video man, very interesting
The first minute speaks volumes.
The girl in the red/pink hijab really speaks her mind! Love it!
Question what u think about the taboo of people having sex with animals and cars and there relatives?
sad for the girls in the beginning of the video. they're seems advance minded. these taboos backup by religion is why I feel ethically impossible to support such a state to be establish.
יגאל גורביץ i am Palestinians and like I said before the younger is generation is very critical about those things, but you have to know that if the country is not rich enough to educate the population, the poor and uneducated people will be very easy to manipulate , that's what's happening here in Palestine, and it's not by the occupation that this problem will cease my Israeli friend ;)
יגאל גורביץ If there is an establishment of a Palestinian State I can assure it will crumble just like all other Islamic countries, All minorities will suffer because of the barbaric Death cult called Islam.
yes the teachings of Islam are the main reason why the Arab world will never progress it is the same here as well in north africa.
Bob Wilson C'mon , I think you can drop the "Arab World", don't you think ? :). North Africa, Tunisia, Morocco, Algeria and Libya is Amazigh :)
Ibn Yahudi yes I agree we are not Arabs.
but culturally we are.
9:20 ,, women get half of it because they aren't required to pay for their families AT ALL , being a Shia this is what we believe , while being a man requires you to pay for your wife and your kids , so you need the money more than women , because you are responsible for your families spendings , nowadays both wife and husband pay for their family , but it wasn't the same at that time
Are you Serious ? What if you can't have children? What if you have children but you physically can't work (because of some illness for example)? Let's face it: the truth is this law doesn't make any sense.
Asma Atamna they dont get it. Brainwashing works too well. Its clear their is NO equality in religion, weither muslim jew or Christian. They are misogynistic mumbo jumbo that punishes women because of the short comings of men, I.e. hijab. IF it was really about the support of the family, then the man and woman would have gotten a smaller, equal share and the rest would have went specifically towards the maintainence of the children. If no children, equal shares. But when you have 4 wives to support, you need that extra share. Another example of punishing women because of the short comings of men........
The last woman - in red - seems very intelligent and smart. Is she a teacher?
kiril1 she's a student
Women also get dowry and men don't. Islam is balanced in different ways.
The West is counting on our societies to break through women, spread secularism, and destroy local culture and religion
عقلية العرب و المسلمين متحجرة هههه
Zero tolerance..
it amazes me how almost all Names are "Muhammad" & from Ramallah !
it's called diversity
The girls are very intellectual 👍🏽
Poor girl at 8:43 was caught off-guard. You could see she couldn't speak her mind.
Good practice for life as a responsible adult.
Random Citizen23 you will get different answers in Cairo or Baghdad, now I am sure you can criticize religion by way or another in Baghdad.
I can't imagine living in a society where you can't question the validity of a religion. If you're not allowed to criticize and question Islam it only proves its fallacy when violence and threats are used to refrain people from speaking boldly about needed reformation and change. A fact Muhammad new very well.
Uka ex Christian islam is perfect we don't need it to be changed yea arab culture might need reformation but not religion i wish u ignorant people stfu u are allowed to question Islam but not criticize Islam is a superior religion to Christianity in every other eay
When they say how they have to tip-toe around every discussion topic for fear of incurring the wrath of an overly-religiously-sensitive person, the next question should be," Do you want this to change, should it go on like this forever?" As long as there are fanatics, there can never be peace, and I honestly feel bad for these people, they have to turn around to make sure no one is listening to them talk about culture for fear they might actually be viciously attacked. that's a crazy way to live
so true
Why does it take so long for people who don't think for themselves to think about it?
This is what hate and fear lead to, talking LOUD but saying NOTHING.
Funny how the most articulate and intelligent people in this clip were 14 year old girls.
Wonders of social media.
WTF women in this video are SOOOO WELL SPOKEN AND WICKED AND SMART !
There is no hope.
you claim to be asking them if they are able to criticize, when in reality you ask them if they think people should criticize.
It is clearly that Muslim men are mostly ok with the things the way they are because Islam is clearly written by men for men. It is also obvious that many women would like to challenge that but they are afraid to openly speak about it.
As always the women are the one to speak english, more open to listen to criticism and to permit criticism even toward their religion. These men like their religion because it gives them control, but women are treated as second class, they know in their hearts it is unjust therefore they seek equality and are open to criticism.
The West relies on women to burn society, spread secularism, and destroy culture, identity and religion
Do you know that countries on the top of the list of having violence against women are not muslim they belong to the world that call itself" advanced".
@@AlmohadeSoldier Your culture deserves to be burned, because is misogynistic and fascist.
@@0688miro Bullshit. The most brutal societies against women are islamic. Violence, discrimination and oppression against women are all fair in your society
Mashallah! May Allah Almighty strengthen all the Muslim Men and Women to protect their religion and dignity with the Power of their IMAAN!
Allahumma Ameen
Why would anyone criticize their own culture or religion? Asking stupid questions.
Because if people didn't criticize the way they live and how they do things we'd still be a bunch of naked guys sitting in caves. Culture is everchanging. Culture from today is different from a 100 years ago, culture from 100 years ago is different from culture 200 years ago and so on.
lol, they are saying it is ok to criticize culture but not religion. well, it is the culture that creates religion.
A Muslim able to criticise their religion? Those three young ladies laid out what would happen. Just goes to show the ridiculousness of religion and how it stunts free thinking and progress.
We are the generation that will return to Palestine.The time has come to end the suffering and the plight of millions of Palestine refugees in the homeland and the Diaspora, to end their displacement and to realize their rights, some of them forced to take refuge more than once in different places of the world.
Nothing in Islam to criticize. But there is a lot things to critisize from its followers/muslims
Islam is Perfect so I don't see any reason to criticise it.
I think it is comical and ironic that the guy who disagrees with criticizing culture [7:36] is wearing a "see no evil, hear no evil, and speak no evil" t-shirt.
THIS IS WHY ISLAM AND DEMOCRACY....FREE SPEECH WILL NEVER GO HAND TO HAND....AS ISLAM IS RELIGION THAT VERY SENSITIVE.....
We have been brainwashed not to criticize the religion
These people live in a prison and don’t even know it
Does the westbank autonomous govt have the death penalty and for which crimes?
The people are not well educated about islam . It's pretty clear from the video. Had there been good scholar like people, they would have responded to all of these answers fairly as they would have the wisdom of islam. For example, that equality thing he asked. She could have replied that it's a western ideology of a different kind of equality. We already have equality in Islam in its true sense. We are equal a humans and in respect . Only the roles are divided to make it simpler . A man is made the protector and provider because of their capability to earn but that doesn't mean that women can't earn . Just that there are more jobs for men based on certain capabilities and women aren't burdened with earning . It's her choice if she wants to work but can't be forced . Like this, she can focus on family needs coz someone needs to take care of that too . Women are good at multitasking and nurturing . They take care of home well. Now I am not saying that men can't do that . It's only the division of roles for the simplicity without genders fighting each other like what's happening now. I really wish they talked to educated people regarding this ( educated both in worldly affairs and religion)
The guys at 8:35 shirt fits him so well. He doesn't want to hear, see or say anything. His culture and religion is perfect. Nothing should change! Lmao
Khalida Jarrar MP is a political prisoner of Israel.. again.
Israeli authorities re-arrested the prominent Palestinian lawmaker in an overnight military raid across the occupied West Bank, officials said on Sunday.
¶
Haaretz Editorial, Dec 2015:
"What does jailing a Palestinian politician say about Israeli democracy?"
Khalida Jarrar is a political prisoner. The Ofer Military Court, which on Monday sentenced the Palestinian parliamentarian to 15 months in prison for membership in an illegal organization and incitement, is a political court that punished her for her political activity, and for that alone. Thus Israel, which pretends to be a democracy, has political prisoners, political arrests and political prison sentences, at least in the occupied territories.
Jarrar’s trial once again proved the intolerable contradiction between the rule of law and the principles of justice, on one hand, and the military justice system on the other. The latter has no relationship to the former.
Jarrar was arrested at her home in Al-Bireh in April. The defense establishment claimed at the time that the reason for the arrest was her violation of a military order that allowed her to live only in the Jericho area, far from her home. No other crime was mentioned. Later, she was indicted on 12 different counts, some of them ridiculous and even outrageous, like attending a book fair and paying condolence visits. In the end, she was convicted on two counts in a plea bargain.
One military court judge ordered her freed long ago; another ordered her kept in prison until the end of her trial; and the military prosecutor threatened her - and essentially the court as well - by saying that if she were released, she’d be thrown in jail without trial, in other words placed in administrative detention. This is not how the legal system of a properly run state conducts itself.
Even the fact that Jarrar is a legislator, a member of parliament, an elected representative of her people - a post that ought to grant her immunity from political charges - didn’t give her a moment’s protection. Israel treated her brutally, just as it treats every Palestinian it deems suspect.
First it tried to keep her away from her hometown with a draconian military order. Then it tried to put her in administration detention, which is no less arbitrary. Finally, and only after public and international pressure for her release had intensified, members of the military justice system were forced to fabricate an indictment against her - most of which, as noted, collapsed. Essentially, this was a Band-Aid, based at least in part on dubious evidence, including vague hearsay evidence and testimony obtained under pressure.
The fact that Jarrar was thrown into prison because of her political activity on behalf of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine is first and foremost an indictment of the State of Israel, which puts politicians on trial because of their legitimate opposition to the occupation and even sentences them to jail. Jarrar and her attorneys decided to accept the plea bargain in order to shorten her trial, and thereby the length of her detention until the end of proceedings. But the black flag that flies over the shameful imprisonment of a Palestinian member of parliament will continue to fly over the State of Israel, tarnishing her jailers and, above all, those who are responsible for them.
The 3 young student girls gave me hope of the Palestinian people in the future. Education, people, is what changes a nation. And this applies to Iraq, Afghanistan, etc. If the West believe you can defeat extremism and terrorism with jets and bombs, good luck with all the money you spend on your wars.
Yasser Arafat was the worst thing to happen to the Palestinian people, but instead of acknowledging that they desperately need good leadership that does not promote terrorism, and will accept Israel and the fact that Jews live in the Middle East, they just blame Israel for all of their problems. If Israel never declared Statehood, what would have happened? Jews would have been blocked from the Western Wall, more of the Jewish Quarter in the Old City would have been destroyed, it would have been more of the same. just because Palestinian leadership wants to continue the violence and suffering doesn't mean Israel shouldn't be allowed to prosper, and all these anti-Zionists put emphasis on Palestinian lives but literally de-value all Israeli lives
So basically they can't criticize Sharia law......no wonder.
Culture of fear no freedom to speak
Saying it's fair or not fair about Islam is like saying God is not fair. You have two choices: believe or don't believe. Nothing in between
10:36-12:31 it seems like Mahmoud (Ramallah) was carefully wording his answers.
They're literally pleading Israel's case. I get it, some Muslims and Jews may have gotten along, although it's usually along the lines of ,"Jews were "tolerated" at best, and were lucky to at least not have been killed." It's like a slave-owner saying how he owns slaves but doesn't whip or beat them so they should be grateful. I've seen the contemptuous way Muslims look at Jews just for praying or wearing a tallit. They don't understand modern societal behavior, like, if a Jewish person were to pray within ear-shot of them, they would literally take that as an "act of insult and aggression" that must be met with violence. we talk about people in the U.S. provoking police-officers and getting shot. Jews couldn't accidentally brush shoulders with a Muslims on the street without being hit or taken to court
they are not able to criticize their religion and society, oh man. maybe thats the reason why most of them like to blame Israel for all the bad stuff happens there
4:28-4:31 "Look at upon you"? "yes, upon you"
??? Is that what they say, I can't hear properly.
This video is so sad…hopefully things have improved over the last 4 years since this video was published. This is totally a “crabs in a bucket” mentality - as soon as you try to think differently or challenge the status quo, the other crabs pull you right back down.
Good question
3:00 why you put subtitle for her she speaks perfect English
You can discuss everything with them, but at the end, they will scream in arabic and you will become ''racist''.
Those 3 Palestinians girls were right to say that the Arab society was judgemental, yet the example brought forward was critical. Especially they as Muslim girls, because LGBT rights aren't accepted in Islam, they go against what Allah has decreed, I would say that western culture and Islam are two separate constructs Islam is seen as an old, traditional religion that is no longer needed, yet the principles that are laid within Islam, are the very principles required for a sane and respectable society. Thus culture is criticized because as said, the Honor Killings are out of pride, which is an idea that Allah dislikes very much, showing religion - Islam specifically, can never be judged.
Being religious is the sign of lack of intellectual development.
they take the religion too seriously pff I'm sick of that
SuperBooboohaha
actually, today, in the west, i would say materialist atheism has replaced religion as the ontology of the blindly-accepting man
Babylonian Hebrew "Materialistic Atheism". LOL that was funmy
SuperBooboohaha Tell that to Israel. All its rights are defined by the Jewish religion.
Did you know non-Jews can't get married in Israel? They have to marry abroad to get married. Non-Jews aren't even allowed to marry.
+Ant B
What about Israeli citizens who are not affiliated to a recognised religion? How do they marry if there is no civil marriage?
While the orthodox Jewish religious establishment in Israel controls marriage between Jews, and does not consent to interfaith marriages, I've been intrigued by whether Jews can marry a Christian or Muslim under the auspices of the Church/Mosque which do allow such weddings in other countries. Is that forbidden?
Islamism. Plus the reluctance to accept Christianity and Judaism
If you critisize my religion[christianity] i dont even care much. God is a big boy,he can take care of you,why should i bother?
People don’t get that humans are the same no matter where you go, people criticising their own culture is them having a discussion and changing their society. A foreigner criticising your culture the first reaction is offence, their criticism is not for the same reason it’s often to take a superior position by pointing out only NEGATIVE in others culture & religion while only pointing the POSITIVE in their own culture.
and here children , this is why muslim world didnt evolve since middle ages : critisize islam is forbiden.
Your questions to Arabs and Muslims are absurd. Do you ask same questions to Israeli Jews even though they are deviated from their original belief. ..??
The question is not "do you ask questions to understand" the question is "do you question if this part of your belief correct" They don't do that since that would make them leave Islam if they don't believe in a single thing God has sent. It is a different thing to ask to understand. In Islam we believe that God is The Wise, so everything has wisdom behind it.
Those Palestinian women spoke very sensibly, unlike the men.
I don't know the situation there and I don't really care about Islam or Judaism or any other religion. But just from the videos, it seems that there is a much largerer number of religiously radical and fundamentalist people in Palestine than in Israel. I might be wrong but that is the impression I get from the videos. .
7:35 It is "funny" and appropriate the "I disagree" guy has a Monkey-No-See, Monkey-No-Hear, Monkey-No-Say shirt on.
This video is a good example for people who do not respect religion because of how it oppresses the victims hooked by the religion. (so many hooks!) Often the religious do not understand that those that oppose religion do not oppose the humans forced to practice it, but support them as fellow humans.
Two things You can't criticise two things in Arabic culture: Religion or family this include even christian Arabs. Arabs are deathly afraid of blasphemy. Our colloquial language and idioms and expressions are saturated with religion, so religion is deep rooted within psyche of any arab of any religion.
religion demands you obey and do not question just like a dictatorship
Why would someone criticize their own religion? Such a stupid question. If you were to ask a Jew the same question you'd get the same answers.
Vexilator yes sometimes people do criticize and bring reforms . It is seen in every religion . Christianity , Buddhism , Hinduism had several reforms over the past years . But muslims don't ever reform their religion . At present , islam allows polygammy . Previously , every other major religions like christianity , hinduism , judaism advocated that . They had done away with it . But islam is stuck in a loop hole of 700 AD . That's the criticism . You don't mordernize your society .
That guy's "see no evil" shirt is Ironic as fuck lmao!
Just israel from Iran❤️
arjan kiani Lol, Israel wants to destroy your country and you support it.
How thick-minded. :)
israel doesn't want to destroy iran. iran is already destroyed by its regime.
Undead Pumpkins What a Liar you are. If you feel the only way to weaken your enemy is by making lies about him it shows you have already lost the battle. Israel has no intention in hurting Iranian people, The Israeli Gov't is NOT a Terrorist gov't, The Iranian gov't is
KURD MEANS STRONG! يا اخي من حقك ان تكون مفتخرا بقوميتك ولكن لماذا كل هذه العنصرية، لدي أصدقاء أكراد كثيرون وهم يختلفون عنك، عِش حياتك مع العرب والاتراك والفرس و كل القوميات فهم بالنهاية بشر وهم اخوانك.
CrazyBob i actually live in the netherlands born and raised :
If your religion is the literal word of God, how come all religions were written down and edited by humans?
muslims never criticize their religion but criticized their cultures,there is not any thing you can criticize in islam relegion practicle aspects purely exclude muslim communities..
When the man refers to the splitting of inheritance, it said that the man gets the most as he has the responsibility over all the heads of the household, differently the woman has the right to keep the money from the Inheritance all to her self, therefore, it is not that the man gets more money, but the way the west has highlighted there to be inequality because at the end of the day if the man was to spend the inheritance correctly the woman would end having more money, logically.
Simple answer. Probably not.