Bach - Toccata and Fugue in D minor BWV 565 - Van Doeselaar | Netherlands Bach Society
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ย. 2018
- From Disney’s Fantasia to The Phantom of the Opera, the opening of the Toccata and Fugue in D minor, performed by Leo van Doeselaar for All of Bach, has provided many memorable moments. The secret is in the striking first note, followed by that brief, tense moment of silence and the overpowering descending series of notes (or variations on it, like in Pirates of the Caribbean). Unfortunately, Bach’s own score has not survived, which has led to many speculations on the creation date of this wild and original composition that is actually not very ‘Bach-like’.
Recorded for the project All of Bach on October 8th 2013 at St Martin's Church, Groningen. If you want to help us complete All of Bach, please subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2vhCeFB or consider donating bit.ly/2uZuMj5.
For the interview with organist Leo van Doeselaar on organ registration go to • Van Doeselaar on organ...
For more information on BWV 565 and this production go to allofbach.com/en/bwv/bwv-565/
All of Bach is a project of the Netherlands Bach Society / Nederlandse Bachvereniging, offering high-quality film recordings of the works by Johann Sebastian Bach, performed by the Netherlands Bach Society and her guest musicians. Visit our free online treasury for more videos and background material allofbach.com/en/. For concert dates and further information go to www.bachvereniging.nl/nederla....
Leo van Doeselaar, organist
Organ: Arp Schnitger, 1692 - เพลง
![Bach Invention 13 in A minor BWV 784 [Harpsichord] Leonart](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ocb9IVLkrkI/mqdefault.jpg)
0:07 Toccata
2:43 Fuga
7:20 (Recitativo.)
La toccata non era perfetta .troppa confusione. I tempi e i ritmi li puoi inventare ma poi li devi mantenere. Verso la fine della fuga sembra una gara la sn.contro la destra chi arriva prima....non mipiace ho e ascolto di meglio. Questa opera la suonano tutti senza rispetto per l'autore. Fai pure il tuo ma fare senso ai suoni ritmi contrappunti fare chiarezza. Non è una fuga da ammazzare...
@@antoniobrivio8251 Per me, va bene quest’interpretazione :)
@@antoniobrivio8251 I totally agree.
You are amazing it's beautiful
Jus imagine being back in the day and hear this smashing out of the church.
I will be like : Ruuuuuuun Vampire's are coming.
”Quick! Get the pitchforks and fire!”
Here~!! take all my money!!!
And then you saw the organist and thought to yourself "Who is that 20-year-old dude and why was he trying to break the organ?"
Probably not, because the original manuscript was lost? I don't think it would have been played many times
When you look at him, you can say he is one with the music.
I totally agree with you
I had the privilege of taking his portrait, and photo's of several of his performances. I've never met a person that was so incredibly enthusiastic about every aspect of his job. Absolutely terrific gentleman.
Indeed he is. He has become one with the organ and the music he makes with it.
You have to be, if you want to be able to play as good as this guy. Unless you play piano yourself it's really hard to appreciate exactly how hard this is.
The more complex a piece is to play, the more emotion you have to bring into it in order to make it sound exactly how you imagine it should sound like. the slightest mistake and the song sounds "cut in half" to your ears. and it doesn't sound perfekt anymore.
He should win as Oscar for overacting. Lots of unnecessary upper body movement.
My mother was a professional organist and I remember listening to her practice this piece among many of Bach’s glorious works for the organ. Such happy memories! What a stirring performance! I’m sure that Bach would be pleased and honored to hear his music performed with such feeling and finesse.
Saludos Monica. !
You were a privilege daugther
wow,it must have been great experience listening to such great masterpieces
I would have love to listen!!🙏
A mí también. La musica de bach para órgano es impresionante y la Sra una privilegiada en saber tocar tan extraordinario instrumento
I thought I heard every possible interpretation of this piece within the realm of good Bach performance practice and good taste and believed there was nothing new to say. Well, Van Doeselaar proved that I was completely wrong! He breathes new life and new meaning into a piece that has been turned into a cliche thanks to cheesey advertisements and bad vampire movies, and finds so much hidden beauty and drama in the piece and makes it all new again. So grateful for this performance!
it is truly a shame how modern media has almost ruined this peice for many people
@Jondahl Davis HA! And it probably did!
Agreed. I was looking for an interpretation of this piece to send to my partner (who doesn't listen to classical music much.. he needs to be prepped for when we move in together..) and was completely taken in by the integrity and sincerety with which this organist performs it. So well done.
It is a shame indeed, the sad part is that most people have never heard the fugue!
I love the little ornamentations in this performance, it sounds like they're improvised on the spot (even though every one is practiced 1000s of times before). I think we've ve found the interpretation closest to what Bach intended.
The one that know this piece...knows that van doselaar makes it imortal. Absolute fatastic!💖
The player is a master playing a master's masterwork.
The tocatta and fugue is probably the weakest organ piece from Bach. Far from his masterwork.
I can never get tired of this piece of Bach. I don't know how many hundreds of times I've listened to it ! Thanks Mr van Doeselaar for a new rendition !
This is probably one of the best renditions of this Fugue I've ever heard.
Wdym
@@sappclobyt1331they meant this is the version they liked the most
The way he plays and puts his passion into it is admirable
Every time I look for a piece by J.S. Bach on YT I find the renditions of the Netherlands Bach Society to be the best. Fantastic!
I wish that everybody could love their job as much as this guy.
For real
This is especially satisfying if you have heard many interpretations of this before. He plays it in a very special and refreshing way, and there’s a big suprise around every corner. Still it‘s extremely convincing! This is great art!
I love how out of all the organist they choose Van Doeselaar. No one else could be a better choice.
There are musicians, and there are composers.... and there is Johann Sebastian Bach!
There are musicians, there are organ players.... and there is Leo van Doeselaar!
❤
You are right!!
And then there's Ludwig Van Beethoven! Lol
Plot twist: the piece is not from from bach
Thank you, Mr van Doeselaar. I cannot say anything else. It is the most powerful and meaningful rendition of this piece of music I have ever listened to. I am moved to tears.
Absolument d'accord avec vous!
Ma version préférée de cette œuvre de Bach tellement massacrée par beaucoup de musiciens, et la comme par miracle une autre vision apparaît, c'est magnifique!
Tout à fait ! Un phrasé délié, loin de la bouillie de nombreux organeux en souffrance!
This is how it's supposed to be played! That ending brought me to my feet!
Undoubtedly the best recording of this piece I have ever heard.
Here on an authentic Baroque organ which was built when Bach was alive: th-cam.com/video/Nnuq9PXbywA/w-d-xo.html
Leo van Doeselaar playing Bach’s „Toccata and Fugue in D minor“ on this amazing Schnitger organ ! Wow, you can’t top that - A FANTASTIC PERFORMANCE 🥰
Why people hate the ending in major chord? It's great.
I'm a bit shocked at first. But then I realised, renaissance music always end in major chord, whatever key being played. It's not totally wrong to continue musica ficta practice in baroque piece. It's part of interpretation.
I'm glad he did that. Especially because the organ's temperament allows that.
One more, this is the best performance of BWV 565 I've ever heard.
@@angelicamartacahyaningtyas9083 Glad I found this
I'm don't hate the ending in the D chord, that ending is novelty but, now rises two opinions about this, I love both D chord ending and the dm ending
This is called a Tierce de Picardie (meaning Picardy third). It is magnificent!
It is a major third in the final tonic chord of a minor-key passage, a device mostly used in Baroque, although occasionally in Classical music, and then adopted much later on in neoclassicism.
@Angelica Marta Cahyaningtyas The shock you mentioned is not so strange. Since many questions are asked about this ending in major, here is a response from Leo van Doeselaar:
"During a concert I once spontaneously played a Picardy third (i.e. in major) at the end of this piece. For some listeners this came as a shock, but I thought it worked better and more naturally than ending in a minor key, especially on a baroque organ in older tuning. For me the following considerations play a role:
1. Almost always in the Baroque period a movement or work in minor key was ended in a Picardy third. As far as I know, Bach only wrote the final chord in a minor key in the A minor Fugue BWV 543.
2. In the case of BWV 565, only one copy of this work (by Johann Ringk from Berlin) has survived and that is a fairly late copy for an - very likely - early work by Bach. It could very well be that Ringk accidentally forgot to write down that one cross.
3. And if not, the listeners in the Baroque period must have had the same shock with the minor ending as some listeners now with the Picardy third. This consideration was the decisive factor for me to end in Picardy as much as possible, in particular on baroque organs: either the shock is ultimately just as great as it was then or Ringk accidentally forgot to note a cross. An omission that in that case has been imitated millions of times..."
The Toccata and Fugue in D minor, BWV 565, is a work for organ written between 1703 and 1707 according to musicologists. The imslp attributes it in 1708. In his early days, Bach was a great admirer of Dietrich Buxtehude, to the point of absenting himself for several weeks, while working for the city of Arnstadt, in order to go and listen to him in Lübeck. North German organ works from this period are characterized by the presence of the Stylus phantasticus, derived from improvisation. This one includes heroic passages, with sought-after harmonies and sudden changes of rhythm. The toccata is a musical piece for keyboard instruments in an improvised and virtuoso style involving arpeggios, traits, and pedal. Klaus Eidam puts forward the hypothesis that the work was written in order to severely test the mechanics of the organ as well as the sound and playability of the instrument. Indeed, Bach was shooting all the stops of the organ in order to evaluate the power and the sufficient wind produced by the bellows. This piece would have been originally created for the harpsichord and then transposed to the organ to increase the spectacular effect. Due to the age of the work, there remain many unknowns about the conditions of its composition. Recent musicological works attribute the work to Johann Peter Kellner. However, there is a very broad consensus that the BWV 565 is indeed an original work by J. S. Bach. Certainly a youthful work, it is particularly imprint with the influences the composer loved to imbibe. The resemblance with other works are clear BWV 564 or BWV 566, and the initial formula of three notes more generally called a pinched is found the BWV 538, BWV 540. Generally speaking, the solidity and length of the fugue, particularly the small contrapuntal labyrinth that Bach used, was practically inimitable at the time. *Lucien*
Utter concentration and marvellous dancing of his hands from 4:09 onwards. Wonderful playing.
8:55 I just love how this verion ends on a major chord. Its like the end of a good movie, and judging by youtube's "most replayed" feature, this version has the most liked ending of any version I can find.
Brilliant rendition. Was blown away by the surprise ending on the D major chord!
Glorious Tierce de picardy !
I did that once in an organ lesson, the look on my teacher's face was priceless.
Same here. Still don't know if he is a genius move or an impostor one. Cameron Carpenter would play that, the internet would break in seconds under the hoots and the cries...
Picardy thirds are just awesome.
I did not like the major ending, to be frank...
I saw Toccata & Fuge BWV 565 and thought, yeah yeah, here we go again... boring; but then was utterly transfixed. Wow, I can't stop listening to this. Wonderful to hear such a fresh interpretation of this piece, brings it totally alive again.
I just got used to those trills at the start and then a MAJOR resolve? Wow! So different 😊
I love this piece, this organ, and its organist! I view this video over and over. Wonderful. Thank you!
I can play guitar and sing at the same time quite well. But this boggles my mind.
This is weep-worthy Mr. van Doeselaar. Bravo!!!
The church reverberation hides most small but my ear heard none. He's a true organist, he played to the maximum. Really, WOW. Year's of practice. He's definitely a Master. Beautiful. In a great hall for music. TOO bad, we can't have people in the church, but the sound would change, because the reverberation would wreck the pure sound. But, he'd still bring down the house, his bass be thumpin , and his finger work was smooth as silk. Great job, sir. Wonderful performance.
Outstanding performance by one of the best baroque organ players in the Netherlands.
JS Bach and Van Doeselaar, two forces of Nature converging for this performance!
0:33 I keep saying this but this harmony is just the best sound I've ever heard and ever will hear in my life
i dearly love the extreme harmony from 8:31 to the end too 😭😭
What a fantastically sounding and beautiful instrument that organ is considering its age, I have never heard a modern organ have such a rich tone as that Schnitger.
That was a beautiful performance. I loved your ornamentation you added throughout the piece. Bravo!
I was totally surprised by his ending, but have on many occasions wanted to do exactly that! Lol! Well played Leo, Bach is smiling too, lol!
An astonishing performance, indeed! Wonderfully performed by Leo van Doeselaar!
This music is so tragic and exciting at the same time . So beautiful. Such marvelous playing skill.
The music is so overwhelming! Just so amazing
THE best piece of Bach...THE best organist...THE most beautiful organ of all...all in ONE video!!!!!!🥲🥲🥰🥰 Faaaantastic!!!!
I really admire anyone who can perform music like this.
I so totally agree with Kryztian. What a fabulous spine chilling performance! Such beauty, drama and musicianship. It reminded me of the first time hearing played in a cathedral by a brilliant concert organist. So wonderful to hear it brought to life. As an organist I often declared that its one work I would never include on a program. This interpretation is totally inspiring! Thank you Van Doeselaar. I have always wondered if finishing on the major tonic would work and or be good taste. With Van Doeselaar its almost shear assertive brilliance. So love the performance with the inspired decoration. OK ... I should stop!
Thank you from the bottom of my heart❤ this Bach by your way to play is wonderful, I can hear joy and passion and love!
I listen and cry every time.
Happy Christmas to all❤️🌟❤️🌟♥️🌟 ( today is 24.12.22)
I watch and listen to this piece again, and again, and again. I never tire of it. Wonderful work and passion, sir!
If it’s not by Bach, I can definitely see his pupil Krebs writing this. Their styles are so similar for many they’re difficult to tell apart (mainly due to the fact that Krebs learned like most of what he knew from Bach). I find Krebs’ work to be a bit more “brash” or perhaps a tiny bit more showy... this certainly fits the bill.
This has to be the greatest playing of toccata and fugue I've ever heard.
Esto es increíble! El órgano y la iglesia evangélica tan distinta a las catedrales latinas que hay desde Italia hasta Vienna. Que afortunados los organistas de tocar un instrumento con tantas posibilidades en cuanto a notas, colores, potencia y versatilidad. Y por supuesto, Bach el primer gran genio de la historia. Bravissimo!
This is pure perfection... hats off! Back then when Bach was playing this people were passing and telling to others that he must be possessed by the devil... I think this organist perfectly demonstrated how virtuosity and dedication look like.. just like Bach himself
Baroque rethoric theory applied to the toppest level. Thank you very much for this unforgettable rendition.
I am 18 years old and playing the organ, I don’t know how to read notes, but by ear I listen. And with determination I will learn this piece, even if it takes me 60 years! Bach is truly a legend.
How is it goin :) ?
@@guhuuuugj pretty well, I am making progress
@@cromwell.is.awesome thats amazin, good luck with it
Such an inspiring mindset! Bon courage.
Ik hoor deze uitvoering vor de zoveelste maal en ik kan er niet genoeg van krijgen !
Een magistrale uitvoering op een van de mooiste orgels die ik ken, muzikaal zowel als visueel.
De emotionaliteit die van Van Doeselaar in zijn interpretatie legt is beyond praise.
Wow, incredible sound on that organ! Very clear played and resonates beautifully in the recording. I would love to come to a organ concert there every morning
Come to Groningen in Holland and you can hear the organ!
Be my guest. The Netherlands has it; www.orgelagenda.nl
Con ésta serie de vídeos y de otros intérpretes de éstos monumentales y magníficos instrumentos ,no me queda más que seguir maravillándome y hectaceándome de la magnificencia arquitectónica de éstos preciosos aparatos , son realmente joyas a las que no se les puede asignar un valor en dinero , y los señores que interpretan las partituras y que ya saben el manejo total de cualquiera de éstos modelos por muy simples que parezcan, es sencillamente maravilloso , me da pena que tanta maravilla ni siquiera sea vista por el número suficiente de personas para que aprendan a apreciar algo tan bello y fantástico, gracias.
Leo, wonderful organ work and registration! What an incredible instrument and church, perfectly matched for both clarity and warmth!
"no son los angeles que vuelan Es el Señor Juan Sebastian Bach." María Elena Walsh. Gracias Maravilloso!!!
Wat een heerlijke registratie van dit mooie stuk muziek!
This is one of the best organs in the world. A Schnitger, of course.
Not even close to one of the biggest 😁
@@hannesholmborg4769 she said best
@@SR009s sorry i read beast
@@hannesholmborg4769 no worries
Prachtige! Welke Nederlandse kerk is dat? Wie weet het?
The plenum sound is amazing thanks to the great Arp Schnitger!
only 7 stops o AS survive here; only the Mixtuur of the Hoofdwerk is AS.
@@adriandegroot2264 The Mixture is the most important Stop for plenum sound. It's easier to rebuilt a normal diapason than a mixture.
@@orgelfan1675 The Hoofdwerk Mixtuur isn't actually that strong; you really need to add the Scherp to get somewhere.
The most divine beauty! Such a stunning performance!!!
Meravigliosa esecuzione. Organo magnifico. Non ci sono parole per descrivere tutto..🤩
I keep expecting him to burst into flames by the sheer power of awesomeness.
I feel lucky to have heard this. I really have no words to express my feelings. I bow down before the great player and also before the great composer. 🙏♥️
Now that have the Passacaglia and Fugue in C Minor, I feel why it is debated among scholars if Bach wrote this piece. Purely from feeling, the Passacaglia feels so much more musically dense than BWV 565, it's bound to make anyone feel as if BWV 565 is not by Bach.
Correct !
Thats absolutely incredible, it touches and enriches the spirit. An an excellent best ever musician, higher than angels. Thank you xxx
Without words for this music. It's beautiful.
Maybe one of the best pieces ever written in music history
I never tire of seeing and hearing this wonderful piece beautifully played by a great artist. Thank you!
Какой шикарный инструмент! Бах великолепен!!! Браво 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 исполнителю!
Después de decenas de versiones escuchadas de esta pieza, esta es mi versión preferida, por su ataque, dramatismo, fuerza.
Such intensity on this masterwork.
shoot, i cant walk and chew bubble gum at the same time, yet this wonderful genius is playing with two hands AND two feet!! Awesome!!
outstanding, just perfect ... can´t stop watching this masterpiece.
A Bach Masterpiece played by an Organ Master!! Bravo!!
You guys are constantly so good in your productions! I am almost tempted to relocating to Amsterdam! :)
We have many protestants churches it is a different way then the Catholic church
This is in Groningen
Bravo, a masterful performance by Van Doeselaar. Bach played to perfection...
Back in high school my buddies and I were sitting around listening to Bach fugues, and decided he was just a smidge crazy. Had to be. I'm 65 now, but still buy into this notion.
8:04 that thing is causing earthquakes in south America
I would not like to go close to that organ
I saw a pipe organ before.....................
Great passion in the music. Love it!
4:10 stunning musicality
the final echo lasts literaly for 5 seconds and it is very satisfying to listen to after you have heard it in its intirity 9:05
Prachtige uitvoering, schitterend om te zien hoe Van Doeselaar de muziek zo intens beleeft!
When old men lose their inhibitions the result can be magnificent.
“I’m listening” _Rudy G-spot_
Magnifica interpretación de esta célebre composición barroca. BRAVO !!!
No me había dado cuenta que el ejecutante deja que la acústica haga el resto del trabajo ya que encontraba los tiempos muy acotados ,pero ahora veo el detalle de la acústica y es muy inteligente es un todo muy bello,gracias.
The best version. Just the best. Bravo
This piece by Bach is a huge tour de force. When you get the final chords you are completely tired and sweated such an effort and passion you have to instilate into the organ.
Essa Toccata é a benção do universo
Again, WONDERFUL! This is fresh to me every time I play it!
Words can not say how good this is stunning this music is the real world
He plays it so effortlessly, bravo!
Greetings from Sweden!❤️🎼
He's not playing that organ he#s making love with it. Awesome
"Was ich zu Bachs Lebenswerk zu sagen habe: hören, spielen, lieben, verehren - und das Maul halten."
- Albert Einstein
"What I have to say about Bach's life's work: listen, play, love, revere - and keep your effing mouth shut."
- Albert Einstein
Genau so ist es.
Einstein was also a socialist
@@guibernardes3 And a genius. A revolutionary genius. Relativity's theory has been a revolution in physics
How can this only have 2000 views!!!
Should be 2 mill!!
Hans have more, hans is the reference....
more than 32,000 now!
Almost 200k views!!!
343k now.
This piece isn't only done justice on these large church organs. Well played.
A masterpiece!!! What a performance!!!
One of the top prrformances, if not the very best. The harmony of technique and sound, the magnificence of the music gives an insight of protestant faith and spirit.
Outstanding rendition!
Absolutely FABULOUS- thank you too much!!!!
Once again I hear Doeselaar play and I hear with new ears.
Perfect en met veel passie gespeeld. Geweldig!
Simply magnificient and passionate interpretation of this immortal masterpiece of JSB. So emotional and breathtaking...MARVELLOUS!!
This should have millions upon millions of views.
. . . . . . één groot feest om naar te luisteren, maar ook om naar te kijken . . . . . . .