That's an interesting theory. Maybe! Although if you recall chapter 5, the island's aristocrats seemed pretty eager to throw foreigners into prison or to put people on a chain gang.
Dutch new york has china town in real life in rdr2 saint denis is new york becouse if you get the robbery tip of the gunsmith and look at the details it says china town
@@izzybat666 Yes, but thats only about 1,000 in the time RDR2 takes place. An emerald in that time is about $7,000 - $15,000. So, it was a fake. Also, John/Arthur writes in their journal after selling it that it was a fake.
What the hell is this? I just wanted to make sure I didn't miss anything and I get something not even on the island, and nothing to do with the island, except a theory that I don't even see the connection with.
For those scrolling through the comments waiting to confirm their fears of being clickbaited, I figured I'd spice things up by adding some fun trivia from Fandom to at least give you a little something for your time. "While the player is confined only to a small area of the island and is discouraged from exploring it, players using mods/exploits to disable the invisible sniper have found the island is much larger than it seems. While the textures eventually turn into mush and vegetation disappears the further it is explored, the island is almost entirely solid, and unlike on the main map, animal AI still works outside the playable area. Dataminers have also found unused compendium entries for Guarma's wildlife and an unused text file that suggests the player was able to spend $100 to return to the island in the epilogue, implying that Guarma was intended to have a bigger role than in the final game."
Soon as I saw whose channel this was, I realized I was baited I guess this is what it looks like to have too much time and not enough creativity on your hands
What happens if you don't do this mission, but go see if the lion is at the stables? Or start the quest, but head straight for the lion, or the chick down the road? Wonder if it'll be there or what?
Yo whats up guys its mrVirginDieAlone here and today imma scam you out of 13min of your precious time to get my monetization working fine so i can claim my mclaren later
00:45 What's written: "...having given his betrothed an emerald engagement ring..." What's narrated: "...having given his beautiful bethrolled (sic) an emerald engagement ring..." facepalm
Is it possible that Ms. Margret was the one who found the emerald? But along the way, fell hard enough to not kill him but turned him into "Ms. Margret"? Forgetting his wife, kids, all them, and never writing or going back to them when he comes back from Guarma, and becoming an animal Wrangler...? It's plausible. Js
Maybe "Margaret" is in fact the lost husband who chose to chase his dreams instead of living in mediocrity (and a sham marriage). He found the emerald (and a lot more) and used his treasures to purchase a "managerie" and become a showman.
The whole video. Has little to nothing to do with guarma. Literally brought up once for the newspaper article. Then it goes to the side missions he's British. This whole video is obsolete
Dude should just get a job at Rockstar. Maybe then he wouldn't feel the need to pollute the tube with terrible videos that are always way too long winded.
Arthur writes in his journal about the emerald but next he writes "the emerald was a fake what did I expect man delt in fake tigers gave out real gems"
A iron ingot is 300 dollars and a emerald is 50 dollars I think a emerald is more rare then gold margeteven said it was worth more then all the gold in the Andes so marget lied lied
This is literally one of the worst channels in all gaming and it’s INSANE that it has 3.22m subs. Never once got anything worthwhile out of it, just 5-10 min of nonsense
I actually think that Miss Margaret is the son of the treasure hunter and the newspaper article was a ploy to throw off any trouble coming to the family from greedy thieves. So they made it seem like he died looking, but in reality he made it back home with the emerald. Miss Margaret is the son of the treasure hunter, apparent by his remark "what would daddy say". He had a second thought about giving his father's prized possession away, knowing what he went through to find it.
Boss, how is it that you graduated college but can’t manage to correctly read words larger than 2 syllables? Seriously man, you aren’t even reading at a 7th grade level!
I'm not sure that emerald is real though. Yes, you can argue that $50.00 is a lot of money, but at the same time a gold nugget is $25.00 and I feel that emerald half the size the gold bar would be at least $150.00 if it was real. Also, remember what Margaret said about giving people the illusion and how no one wants the truth. His/her whole thing is passing fake things as real: donkey as a zebra, cougar as a tiger, giant green stone as emerald. Still, I love the theory you presented.
"So for this video we're only going to concentrate on the relevant parts" *plays entire irrelevant cutscene* Maybe put "theory" in the title of your video, clickbaiter? 🙄
If you took a shot of liquor everytime he said "actually", you'd be sick before you ever finished one of his videos. This one isn't as bad as some of his though. Some of them he's saying every other sentence. Actually, actually, actually, actually, actually, actually....
I honestly think that the Emerald that Margaret gave to Arthur is fake because 1.) Why would anyone in their right mind give away a real, precious, giant jewel away. With that Jewel, Margaret could have in the first place, bought himself a real performance menagerie, complete with crewmen. And 2.) Margaret's a showman. Did you watch the way he was selling the jewel to Arthur? Showcasing that it was dug from el durado and as dear from all the gold from the andes. And as soon as Arthur was gonna reach for it, he pulls back to second guess about his decision, so as to seal the deal with Arthur to take the jewel as payment. The jewel was less than a gold bar anyway.
The fact this guys whole stick is about illusion and the power of appearances Y’all still really think it’s a real emerald?!?! He’s a showman 😂😂😂 I don’t need a journal entry to confirm it
What gets me is you do get a trinket as well 👍and I do think the guy is in guarma, and I did ride the donkey it was so cool, the dudes on horseback was laughing making funny comments haha 😂😂
There Is A SECRET Treasure Hidden On Guarma & You Can Find It In Red Dead Redemption 2! (RDR2)
Stop with rdr2. Videos do something else it gets border line boring after a while
Get a life, mrbossFOR THE LOSE
That's an interesting theory. Maybe! Although if you recall chapter 5, the island's aristocrats seemed pretty eager to throw foreigners into prison or to put people on a chain gang.
Nice vid
@@deadgirldawn6013 then go watch something else?! Some of us still are enjoying the game!
Treasure hidden in guarama? Guys... I have a plan. One more score and we going to Tahiti or NewYork
Dutch new york has china town in real life in rdr2 saint denis is new york becouse if you get the robbery tip of the gunsmith and look at the details it says china town
Blanca Escobedo so according to that logic NewYork is right next to Mexico... nice
@@blancaescobedo5425 Saint Denis is actually based on New Orleans because of the geography and the animals
COME ON DUTCH
NO
13:03 thank me later
Thx
Thank u brother
Me copiaste >:(
You showed us the way. We are ever thankful
Thx
I feel actually stupid for giving this video a chance. I knew what was happening and there are just no excuses
Swear to god me too, that dude cant be helped
The emerald is a fake, if you sell it Arthur or John will write in their journal about how the emerald was fake. Your welcome
Wrong it was worth a lousy $50!
I did sell it, it was 50 lol
@@izzybat666 Yes, but thats only about 1,000 in the time RDR2 takes place. An emerald in that time is about $7,000 - $15,000. So, it was a fake. Also, John/Arthur writes in their journal after selling it that it was a fake.
If it was fake how comes you get money for it, if it was a fake you get nothing
@@izzybat666 If it WASNT fake, why would John/Arthur write in their journal stating it was fake???
This one might be the worst video so far lol
MrBossFTW "Hold my beer."
it has more dislikes than likes...thats sad
agreed
What the hell is this? I just wanted to make sure I didn't miss anything and I get something not even on the island, and nothing to do with the island, except a theory that I don't even see the connection with.
You got clickbaited
I haven’t seen the video yet but I looked in the description…I already feel clickbaited
"hidden treasure on guarma"
video itself: * on america *
I found the treasure, look at my profile
Anyone else find it interesting that the final mission with the lion is at EMERALD ranch
Its actually at valentine where a lion breached the auction yard
@@johannadeguzman4170 no it’s not
@@redeye8075 was wrong sry :)
@@johannadeguzman4170 it’s cool
Its only glas. If you hover over it on the fence, dont sell it and wait 24h ingame, Arthur will write in is book, that the emerald isnt real.
your title literally is a lie
For those scrolling through the comments waiting to confirm their fears of being clickbaited, I figured I'd spice things up by adding some fun trivia from Fandom to at least give you a little something for your time.
"While the player is confined only to a small area of the island and is discouraged from exploring it, players using mods/exploits to disable the invisible sniper have found the island is much larger than it seems. While the textures eventually turn into mush and vegetation disappears the further it is explored, the island is almost entirely solid, and unlike on the main map, animal AI still works outside the playable area.
Dataminers have also found unused compendium entries for Guarma's wildlife and an unused text file that suggests the player was able to spend $100 to return to the island in the epilogue, implying that Guarma was intended to have a bigger role than in the final game."
Merci ! 😅
Soon as I saw whose channel this was, I realized I was baited
I guess this is what it looks like to have too much time and not enough creativity on your hands
What happens if you don't do this mission, but go see if the lion is at the stables? Or start the quest, but head straight for the lion, or the chick down the road? Wonder if it'll be there or what?
it wouldnt be there it only spawns when u do the other ones
Yo whats up guys its mrVirginDieAlone here and today imma scam you out of 13min of your precious time to get my monetization working fine so i can claim my mclaren later
DuaLL you chose to watch it
So. There’s no secret treasure. And we can’t actually find it. Ok.
Every mrboss video can be started on the last third to get to the point.
This video is completely irrelevant.... again, just like the others. I'm gonna stop watching anything by MrBossFTW.
Honestly, props to this guy for having thick skin OR the will power to not read his comments. Everyone thinks you’re a fraud and a scammer.
Lmao u said it, friend
I knew it was you. You take forever to actually get to what the title promises
there is no need for two adverts at the start of each vid
in Arthur's journal, it says that the emerald was fake.
Maybe the treasure hunter is that guy that is hanging in Guarma when you get kidnapped.
Thats a really good theory
@@dr.drill2303 Thank you, Arthur Morgan 🙏
this is the best way to ignore a channel on youtube
Bruhhhhhh.....
This topic has already been discussed before smh
Nayops 18 lousy TH-camr right?
Nayops 19 and the topic of him being late on topics has been talked before so what’s your point hypocrite
Nayops 19 Lol Exactly!!!
So basically this Video aint telling me shit?! I need money boah
00:45
What's written:
"...having given his betrothed an emerald engagement ring..."
What's narrated:
"...having given his beautiful bethrolled (sic) an emerald engagement ring..."
facepalm
Is it possible that Ms. Margret was the one who found the emerald? But along the way, fell hard enough to not kill him but turned him into "Ms. Margret"? Forgetting his wife, kids, all them, and never writing or going back to them when he comes back from Guarma, and becoming an animal Wrangler...?
It's plausible. Js
I literally just wanted to see if I could get to the house, that’s north of cinco torres
Holy shit how can anyone be okay with wasting so many people’s time with making these videos
A little fact, if you sell the emerald author will write I his journal about how it was a fake, so that debunks this entire theory
Whouldint the tresure hunter be looking for s rouf emerald and this is a "finely cut emerald"
Maybe "Margaret" is in fact the lost husband who chose to chase his dreams instead of living in mediocrity (and a sham marriage). He found the emerald (and a lot more) and used his treasures to purchase a "managerie" and become a showman.
This is a very good theory
me watching this video 3:08
Lmfao 🤣 I was thinking the same thing
I'm surprised you have so many views and subs. Your videos are just like Dutch's plan: empty and go nowhere.
I found MrBoss's channel a couple days ago; I am leaving MrBoss's channel already. This is possibly the worst channel I have ever come across
The whole video. Has little to nothing to do with guarma. Literally brought up once for the newspaper article. Then it goes to the side missions he's British. This whole video is obsolete
hidden treasure ON GUARMA... I wonder why I don't get vibes about being on guarma during this video...
Those guards have no chance against Arthur. I felt like I was back in van horn stacking them like chord wood
This guy takes photoshop on another level
its like the photoshop is the treasure to him
Dude should just get a job at Rockstar. Maybe then he wouldn't feel the need to pollute the tube with terrible videos that are always way too long winded.
Even though 50$ was a lot that was not the price it should have been a basic emerald was worth 600$ so it should have been worth around a thousand
He exaggerates his titles way to much
Arthur writes in his journal about the emerald but next he writes "the emerald was a fake what did I expect man delt in fake tigers gave out real gems"
A iron ingot is 300 dollars and a emerald is 50 dollars I think a emerald is more rare then gold margeteven said it was worth more then all the gold in the Andes so marget lied lied
They will write in the journal that the emerald was fake if you sell it
@@turtlevison1496 oh
Nobody:
MrBossFTW: Lies
That lion mission was one of my favorite mission
It's actually all just a reference to Romancing the Stone
There is a cabin in Guarma but no treasure
“Beautiful bethrolled” 😂😂😂
This is literally one of the worst channels in all gaming and it’s INSANE that it has 3.22m subs. Never once got anything worthwhile out of it, just 5-10 min of nonsense
I think Miss Margaret is the treasure hunter son because he says what would daddy think.
There's a reason some of your videos have more dislikes than like bro
So basically ur whole video was about the emerald you get in chapter 3 not a damn treasure like ur video states!?!?! GIANT WASTE OF TIME DUDE!!
It said in the cutscene it was from the mines of El Dorado not Guarma
Margaret's emerald was fake
I actually think that Miss Margaret is the son of the treasure hunter and the newspaper article was a ploy to throw off any trouble coming to the family from greedy thieves. So they made it seem like he died looking, but in reality he made it back home with the emerald. Miss Margaret is the son of the treasure hunter, apparent by his remark "what would daddy say". He had a second thought about giving his father's prized possession away, knowing what he went through to find it.
The emerald is fake tho, it's just glass. If Arthur keeps it for a few days, I instead of selling it, he'll write in his journal that it's fake
Boss, how is it that you graduated college but can’t manage to correctly read words larger than 2 syllables? Seriously man, you aren’t even reading at a 7th grade level!
The thumbnail is from the mission where the lady dude ask him to get the “circus animals” and in the end he gives him that emerald
How does this guy have a channel?
I thought he was going to find treasure in Guarma but still a little interesting I guess.
Have mercy!!!! You don’t want to be rude. But dude just get to it.
in a new update of the RDO emerald was found.
Guido Marteli gives you a mission to steal it
I'm not sure that emerald is real though. Yes, you can argue that $50.00 is a lot of money, but at the same time a gold nugget is $25.00 and I feel that emerald half the size the gold bar would be at least $150.00 if it was real. Also, remember what Margaret said about giving people the illusion and how no one wants the truth. His/her whole thing is passing fake things as real: donkey as a zebra, cougar as a tiger, giant green stone as emerald. Still, I love the theory you presented.
I love you're videos
Bruh this emrald isnt even in gaurma
After you sell it you get a not in you’re journal it says it was fake
No you don't smh
Yeah... you kinda do... go be stupid somewhere else
@@izzybat666 yes you do, if you sell the emerald, they'll write in the journal that it's fake
Feels lile I seen this video before...
Feels so familiar.. Seems like I'm slipping into a dream within a dream
Hey guys, MrRapedAKid for the win here
Mr.Gay always cappin on his videos
Bethrolled
I see it's a Mrboss video and I immediately back off and look for an actual honest content creator
so if $50 is $1500 in 1899 a $900 arabian is $27,000...
"So for this video we're only going to concentrate on the relevant parts"
*plays entire irrelevant cutscene*
Maybe put "theory" in the title of your video, clickbaiter? 🙄
The real emerald is in Saint Denis, you can steal it in online by doing the heist with the italian person.
Why you always lying ?!
Luv ur vids
Seriously have to fast forward after -2minutes until the end because you show the ENTIRE game. Scene which at this point everyone has seen.
50$ ok thank me later
Make a video about where dutch walks off to in the last mission American Venom
Bob Sam he walks to Red Dead Redemption 1
Bob Sam and where he walks off to at the end of ‘rdr’
“Margaret” the “animal tamer”
First time he gave me the emerald i thought for sure it was going to be fake.
Well you do kill the lion at emerald ranch 😂
Finally now Dutch can sell it to go to Tahiti!
The treasure hunter went missing but the guy that hanges from the tree in Guarma in the stranger mission is that the treasure hunter
wtf. wasted my damn time.
If you took a shot of liquor everytime he said "actually", you'd be sick before you ever finished one of his videos. This one isn't as bad as some of his though. Some of them he's saying every other sentence. Actually, actually, actually, actually, actually, actually....
How in the hell can I get Arthur to stop wanting to draw his gun when I am not even touching anything and at the most inopertune moments?
that's emerald isn't on guarma, get over it
What if the guy that author sees before he gets knocked out in guarna WAS the treasure hunter
OMG yeah wait the guy who got hanged ?!
When you follow. Them after The mission. Thay get really pissed off.
You need to keep in mind cigarettes are 5 dollars in this world 50 ain't shit
I honestly think that the Emerald that Margaret gave to Arthur is fake because 1.) Why would anyone in their right mind give away a real, precious, giant jewel away. With that Jewel, Margaret could have in the first place, bought himself a real performance menagerie, complete with crewmen. And 2.) Margaret's a showman. Did you watch the way he was selling the jewel to Arthur? Showcasing that it was dug from el durado and as dear from all the gold from the andes. And as soon as Arthur was gonna reach for it, he pulls back to second guess about his decision, so as to seal the deal with Arthur to take the jewel as payment. The jewel was less than a gold bar anyway.
After Arthur sells it, he rights in his journal that it was a scam and a fake jewel
So you wasted my time just to tell me I already have the emarld
10:38 lol
For anyone wondering what’s actually there: it’s just a worn down house with cases of dynamite
yep i found it
The fact this guys whole stick is about illusion and the power of appearances
Y’all still really think it’s a real emerald?!?! He’s a showman 😂😂😂
I don’t need a journal entry to confirm it
What gets me is you do get a trinket as well 👍and I do think the guy is in guarma, and I did ride the donkey it was so cool, the dudes on horseback was laughing making funny comments haha 😂😂
People are so easy to offend these days. They are always “I’m TrAnSgEnDeR!!!YoU hAvE tO uSe PrOpEr LaBeLs!!!” It fucking sucks!!!
WHY THE DISLIKES