thanks a lot - was in search of this answere for years and years, you removed all the confusions, May Allah subhan watallaha give you long life with health and eymaan.
is say behtar tareeqa koi ho hi nahi sakta May hayran hota ho itna asan topic baki scholer itna Mushkil kar kay batatay hay ghamdi sir nay aik minute may clear kar dia sab Thanks Mashallah
Sahih kaha ghamidi sahab aap nay. Molvie hamaray moasheray ko jhannum me badal rahay hen. Allah T’ala aap ka saya hum per ber qarar rakhay aur apko sehat aur lambi umar ata fermae.
After listening to Ghamdi saheb, you can see the difference between maulviat and ilmiyat. He opens the window of your mind and empowers you with knowledge .
Just ask his sister and mother if they will be willing to have sex with the person who killed their brothers and son and become wives of the people who killled their family? They would rather prefer to die . As a courageous woman, she will love to die rather than marrying the killers of his family members and becoming a whore. Islam is a cult religion written by Muhammad and his lustful friends. Why would allah allow to have sex with the war slaves ? And sex slaves were sold. Everything is right whatever he says but how can allah allow to have sex with the female whose brother and father is killed by you? Just make them do the work as sa slave or a servant but having sex with them is alllowed in islam..
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves even two men can have sex with a slave girl a slave girl child dont get inheritance ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
Ghamidi is wrong According to Non muslim ko hi gulam,londi banaya ja sakta hai. Muslim muslim Jung me Muslim ko gulam nhi bnaya ja sakta. Gulam Sirf Jung se nhi Raid krke, Non muslim dwara agreement todne, Jaziya na dene par bnaya ja sakta hai. Londi ko Beparda ka hukm h.
Assalamualikum Up till now this was the most detailed and organised explanation i got on the topic of slaves in Islam i disagree with Javid Sir on many of his opinions but i find this explanation to be on the right and bright side of our religion. May Allah (S.W.T) reward you for this good act.
Critical questions.....having ramifications in today's world too....answered so beautifully...as if negatives of hundreds years of civilization...corrected in a few minutes.,.....only superbrillants can..so let's pray that may Allah swt grant this scholar long hayat and correct him his mistakes if any and benefit the ummah from his discourses in this difficult times
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves even two men can have sex with a slave girl a slave girl child dont get inheritance ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
Aap ko sunnaye bina zindagi kuch adhoori si lagti hai....Allah aap ko sehat aur lambi umar day...I am thankful to Almighty that i met you through you tube...
JazakaAllah ❤❤ th-cam.com/users/clipUgkxZHmxaskSeQRw-uU_Nmyjohmw7H5kfTex Al-Qur'an. 23:5-6 Surât Al-Mu'minûn Jo apni sharmgahon ki hifazat kartay hein mugger apni biviyon say aur apni kaneezon say jo unnki milk hoti hein keh unnsay ta aluq kayim karnay mein koi malamet nahin. جو اپنی شرمگاہوں کی حفاظت کرتے ہیں مگر اپنی بیویوں سے اور کنیزوں سے جو انکی ملک ہوتی ہیں کہ ان سے تعلق قائم کرنے میں انہیں کوئی ملامت نہیں ۔ Al-Qur'an. 23:5-6 Surât Al-Mu'minûn 5. And those who guard their private parts, from illegal sexual acts 6. Except from their wives or THE CAPTIVES and SLAVES that their right HANDS POSSESS, for then, they are free from blame. Captives and slaves are NOT wives as I'm sure you're well aware. And wives are NOT captives or slaves ❤❤❤
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves even two men can have sex with a slave girl a slave girl child dont get inheritance ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves even two men can have sex with a slave girl a slave girl child dont get inheritance ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
This was something new and positive to hear. But I guess the answer did not cover the particular verse often quoted about female slaves ' what your right hand possesses'.
today "modernists" (quoting this because some are really progressive but some of them are what Jordan Peterson calls "Pusedo moralistic" individuals) call on slavery not being prohibited by islam as a major reason to reject Islam and our mullahs try to justify everything without taking reason into consideration. But personnel like Ghamidi is someone God has given us to see Islam though the eyes of modern western individual and we can see how progressive Islam was in cases of eliminating riba (modern interest based captilistic society) so poor can get some relief, asking people to be kind to slave, to free them, to implement the system of zakaat etc..
I would say Ghamdi Sahab uses the method of critical thinking and analysis when forming opinions or reaching conclusions. Islam has always been like this.
Ghamdi sb is wrong here because it is against Quran and Sunnah Slavery is allowed if a group of people commit a severe treason, betray Muslims like how banu Quraiza did (which would have had ended up massive casualties of Muslims) Or you can make war of prisoners slave ( only those that are present in battlefield and are directly involved in battle because they are their to kill Muslims not those that are at their house or not involved directly ) But it is when you cant free the POW for free or cant take amount for that or can't exchange POW This slavery is for punishment because many Muslims become martyrs due to war and betrayal and you will only know the pain if one from your household would have been the one , only then we can ask you how to treat these criminals Rest of the things which Ghamdi sb said are mostly true like how to treat them, freeing slaves is a great deed etc.
@@Solo.Gr8 brother if u wanna know u should keep it in mind before prophet the civilization was totally crumbled and murder,rape,the weight measuring up and down was normal but when He came he destroys these things with stages as u know for example if somebody says u about a job which is very strict leass people will apply but if u say that u will given comfort and A little bit facilities u will join otherwise u will be in your free routine so don't consider that Islam established slavery
@@SheikhAlAhmadMuhammad did all these things. He was a war lord, r@pist, sax slave owner. Had multiple sax slaves. He took new women as slaves such as jawahriyia and saffiya. He invaded and genocided khaiyber and Banu qurayza and hunain. Infact he ordered jihad all over the world. He was worse that any previous society in Arabia. A truly evil man.
The Prophet himself had slaves, and they were often taken after wars. I’m not sure why Ghamidi Sahab is suggesting it was banned just during the Battle of Badr. Our fiqh includes detailed guidance on this, stating it’s up to the ruler whether to take concubines or not. He didn’t even mention the term "right hand possession." While everyone agrees that freeing slaves was encouraged and would have led to a progressive and systematic end to slavery (by freeing existing slaves), it’s important to note that during wars, slaves could still be taken as prisoners of war. The issues related to sex with them are addressed separately in fiqh.
Wonderful explanation.. how a social evil should be eradicated, I think this is the best method which Islam has provided... Today We have problems like dowry, corruption, untouchability, indecency etc but instead of having strong laws, regulations and even international conventions we are not able to stop it... rather it is increasing day by day..
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves even two men can have sex with a slave girl a slave girl child dont get inheritance ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
Sir if slavery was forbidden during the battle of badr then how come in surah ahzab verse 26 it is told that the Muslims made captives of the banu qurayza? If Allah had specifically banned the capture of new slaves beforehand then how can the prophet ignore that command under any circumstance?
@@harrisonking8972 let's not go into semantics here. The fate of the women and children left after all the men of the tribe were killed was inevitably to be used as slaves.
@@behzadmirza1131 Banu quraiza committed treason And if help of Allah didn't come, Muslim would have faced huge casualties because from front Quraish and its allies attacked and at the back there were forts of banu quraiza which committed treason and betrayed Muslims Also there was an access to the place where Muslim Women and Children were present through forts of Quraiza And we all know what and Quraish and its allies plus Quraiza would have done to those women and children if Muslims got killed So banu Quraiza ( both their Men and Women ) were punished for their act And even in today’s world their is capital punishment for committing treason in many countries Also Ghamdi sb is wrong here because slavery is allowed if a group of people commit a severe treason Or you can make war of prisoners slave ( only those that are present in battlefield and are directly involved in battle because they are their to kill Muslims not those that are at their house or not involved directly ) But it is when you cant free the POW for free or cant take amount for that or can't exchange POWs Rest of the things which Ghamdi sb said are mostly true like how to treat them, freeing slaves is a great deed etc.
@@apurpose8614 I respect Ghamidi sb and most of his points are quite logical but I think he made a massive mistake here. My point is that slavery was never banned and even if you lay down the code of how to treat your slaves fairly and if every single Muslim were to follow that exactly (which we both know is impossible), it still would not make up for the fact that you took away their basic human right to freedom and that in my mind is irreconcilable with a fair God.
@@behzadmirza1131 when you commit treachery and war crime, it seems enough "humanity" that you are treated with life, food, shelter and also not being confined in a jail, and on the other hand justice also says that you should be punished too. In my country Bangladesh a "secular" state war criminals were hanged even after 40 years, . Just think logically the women were weak and the children of quraiza were also weak, if GoD was unjust he could have ordered to kill them as well. As far regards banu quraiza, banu quraiza's entire tribe comitted serious war crimes. And when the were bought to judgement, they were given choice to choose between muslim judgement and jewish judgement, they chosed their jewish judgement according to jewish law, which was passed by wounded saad bin muaz who was a jewish then and saad bin muaz was also choosen as judge by quraiza people, not by Allah or the prophet. Even banu quraiza accepted that judgement. Now you can ask, why the women weren't freed with their children, do you know when president Abraham lincon freed the slaves they willingly returned to their masters just because they had no shelter at all and poverty. If the women were left without there male gurdians where would they go because at that time women were totally depended on their males? The children would have died out of poverty and hunger and the women would get involved in prostitution, or being captured by other arabians and sold as slaves which was quite frequent in that time of non muslim arabs. Was that better? Saying things seems sometimes easy, but we have to think in context of circumstances of that time. If you read world history of quite modern than seventh century many asian soldiers at the time of world wars used to hold enemy women mostly wives of army officers in captivity in concentration camps, every night different soldiers would rape each of the women, even when they were given food like dogs, tortured physically, beaten and with heavy work load was these better than the treatment of banu qurayza? I cant change your opinion nor you can mine inShaAllah, but i think taking pows as slave seems quite logical because if you leave them unpunished freely they would again and again conspire against you, for example the war criminals of my country even got into power and politics with proper conspiracy and killing the (weak: women and children (without in return of killing)) among enemies is a sort of cowardness to me as well as feeding them in captivity in jail without any benefit is a foolishness nothing else. Dont read western orientalism, they are too much biased in their opinions and they only praise the west to hide its flaws
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves even two men can have sex with a slave girl a slave girl child dont get inheritance ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
Well explained but Hazrat forgot to mention the biggest step that was taken for freedom and equality of slaves was the example set by Nabi AS himself in case of his slave Zaid bin Haritha. He was not only freed and adopted as his son but the Prophet pbh arranged his marriage with her cousin Zainab RA which was duly sanctioned by. Allah SWT. Zaid's son Usama was appointed as head of a continent which was to go for battle against infidels and very famous Sahaba RA were placed under his command. Is there any such example set by any one in the history?. Probably no. This was the final.nail in the coffin of centuries old traditions of slavery. Please do add this most important aspect in your subsequent talks which are so educative and illuminating for not only the Muslims but for mankind as a whole.. Jazak Allah khaira.
@@emanazmat13037 because that sahabi gave divorce to his and prophet married her to give an example of marrying a divorced women..if he didn't do it then all the muslim girls who are divorced would have been remained divorced rest of there life and muslims wouldn't marry them
@@emanazmat13037 bcz Hazrat Zaid bin Harith RA was NOT His actual son..So when He divorced his wife , she was In no way illegal/ illegitimate/ Unsuitable for being marrying to the prophet.. She was completely willing for this marriage Just like any women of today is free to marry anyone she wants !!!
Extremely surprising even a great scholar like Gamidi Sir is couching this subject in intelligent words. Sir, First of all how can a slave woman be happy with people who killed her father, Husband and brothers ?? She can only be coerced because of her situation.Does this not amount to rape ?? Why make somebody a?slave and then earn merit by freeing them ?? What is the meaning of you have complete control over whatever your right hand posesses ? A person that too a female is included and considered as Maal e Ghanimat ie Maal or property itself is an insult to womanhood. How come this practice continued among Muslim nations till 20 th century ?? Please take a list of Islamic countries which banned slavery.I t all ranges from 1960 to 1980 Mauritania being the last country and still clandestinely practiced over there. Finally Will Ghamidi sir with all his intellectual honesty admit if non muslims after winning a war mete out same treatment following exactly same laws to Muslim men & Women; Will that be acceptable to you Sir ?? I would consider any form of slavery anywhere in the world,by anybody is a shame on humanity. True Muslim is one who does not defend his religion but one who is not afraid to speak the truth. Truth is slavery is a shame for entire humanity.
It's not just a best explanation only for muslim, but it could make non muslims speechless. Highly convincing and satisfactory answer by Ghamidi Sahab.
Filthy logic is used in this video to hide the shit written in islamic cult. If there was true God he would had tell the Muslims to release the slaves and told the muslims to give them work/money This way the slaves will become free and slavery would had been stopped.
Since the reign of Banu Ummayyah, Islamic rule ended. All the subsequent reigns, including the aforementioned, twisted Islamic laws to their own liking. Hoarding of wealth, alcohol, and similarly slavery, became the norms of their society. Their method of ruling itself demonstrates that they weren't Islamic. A Khalifa is not permitted to live a lavish life. But these monarchs lived in nothing but endless splendor. Hence, their doing is of no value to our Islamic laws and neither can be used as an authority.
@@rabbiyafarrukh1866 what about mehmed 2 who conquered Constantinople and Salahuddin Ayyubi who conquered jerusalem, both made slaves and were given good news of Jannah by Prophet Muhammad(PBUH)
No one will buy it This is what the Quran says “And [also prohibited to you are all] married women except those your right hands possess. [This is] the decree of Allah upon you.” Quran 4:24 اور (حرام کی گئیں) شوہر والی عورتیں مگر وه جو تمہاری ملکیت میں آجائیں
@@PakistaniMulhidLegacy oh harris .. Pls read verse 23 to 25 ... Not only 24 . Isme kaha gaya h ki kis kis women se shadi karna prohibited h .. Shadi shuda aurat se marry karna haram h .. Verse 23 Except wo aurat jo pehle se tumhari slave ho ..kyonki agar slave aurat shadi shuda v h to wo wapas ja nahi sakti h ...so unse v shadi ker sakte ho .. Verse 24 Isme ye to kaha hi nahi gaya h ki slave banawo ... Balki ulta slave girl se shadi karne ko kaha gaya h .. Slavery ek pre islamic institution tha .. Pehle dil saaf karke quran padho ...sab clear ho jayega ..
Iss topic par bahut confused tha. Research ke liye mashoor aalim or daayi ke bayan suna lekin satisfaction kiseese nahi Mila. Lekin tab is lecture sunne ke baad aur yakeen hogaya ki Islam insanoki asli sukoon aur justice life Dena chahta hai....
Inka bayan hmesha sahi or logical hota h. Baki to ektarfa non satifying bayan dete h. Just like hai to hai aap kon hote h eteraj karne wale. Eteraj ni hota bss tasali baks dimag ko jawab chahiye hota h. Chijo ko smjhne se smjh aata h sirf fact se ni. logic aur dour ka situation bhi jaroori hota h. 👍
اللہ غامدی صاحب کی عمر دراز کریں ۔ایسے عظیم شخصیات کسی بھی قوم کے قیمتی اثاثے ہوتے ہیں ۔
G bilkuk ameen
thanks a lot - was in search of this answere for years and years, you removed all the confusions, May Allah subhan watallaha give you long life with health and eymaan.
@MrA what is your problem with marriage???
Orya maqbool also says we can still make slaves in war
Ameen
If taking interest on money is bad, and God removed it, why can't it ban slavery too ?
@@sourabhverma597 These evils were present before the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) and Allaah removed them through revelation
غامدی صاحب کا مرکھوں اور دشمنںان اسلام کو منہ توڑ جواب !!
is say behtar tareeqa koi ho hi nahi sakta
May hayran hota ho itna asan topic baki scholer itna Mushkil kar kay batatay hay ghamdi sir nay aik minute may clear kar dia sab Thanks Mashallah
isse behtreen jawaab ho hi nahi sakta is sawaal ka.. Allaha appko bohot bohot himmat sehat lambi umr de..
Amen ❤
Very eloquent manner of speaking. May Allah bless his soul.
Sahih kaha ghamidi sahab aap nay. Molvie hamaray moasheray ko jhannum me badal rahay hen. Allah T’ala aap ka saya hum per ber qarar rakhay aur apko sehat aur lambi umar ata fermae.
Thank you Ghamdi Sahib, very well explained, all confusion removed.
لاجواب لاجواب غامدی صاحب لاجواب ،،ایک منفرد اور خوبصورت approach ھے،
Excellent!!And it could answer very criticism of Islam imposed by Non Muslims .👍👍👍
After listening to Ghamdi saheb, you can see the difference between maulviat and ilmiyat. He opens the window of your mind and empowers you with knowledge
.
Just ask his sister and mother if they will be willing to have sex with the person who killed their brothers and son and become wives of the people who killled their family? They would rather prefer to die . As a courageous woman, she will love to die rather than marrying the killers of his family members and becoming a whore.
Islam is a cult religion written by Muhammad and his lustful friends.
Why would allah allow to have sex with the war slaves ? And sex slaves were sold. Everything is right whatever he says but how can allah allow to have sex with the female whose brother and father is killed by you? Just make them do the work as sa slave or a servant but having sex with them is alllowed in islam..
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls
there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves
even two men can have sex with a slave girl
a slave girl child dont get inheritance
ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
What knowledge ?????
he didn’t answer the question
properly his answer was just
gool mool.
@@yasminschirtzer4395he gave a perfect reply and covered every point beautifully. Samajhnay kay liay akal chahiay.
@yasminschirtzer4395 what a idiot.
Prophet Muhammad SAWW peace be upon is the World best personality ❤️
Aye Allah ! Ham sab ko Islam se gumra hojaye na fouran Jald se jald hamare galatfehmi door karde...
aameen summa aameen
Ghamidi sb gave very relevant answer of this question.
Most rational scholar i have ever seen.
Molana Islahi would be proud of you sir.
Ghamidi is wrong
According to Non muslim ko hi gulam,londi banaya ja sakta hai. Muslim muslim Jung me Muslim ko gulam nhi bnaya ja sakta. Gulam Sirf Jung se nhi Raid krke, Non muslim dwara agreement todne, Jaziya na dene par bnaya ja sakta hai.
Londi ko Beparda ka hukm h.
@@humanbeing361 sare insaan musalman hote hen dearr islam doesn’t teach exclusivism
@@UsmanAli-ok6gp *All are Muslim. But all don't have Imaan. Those people who don't have imaan can be made slave according to sharia*
Read shariat bro
@@humanbeing361 Abhi nahi janab, naa, londio ka system alhumdulilah khatam hochuka hay, ab londio se woh nahi kar sakte sir jee, janab
Assalamualikum
Up till now this was the most detailed and organised explanation i got on the topic of slaves in Islam i disagree with Javid Sir on many of his opinions but i find this explanation to be on the right and bright side of our religion. May Allah (S.W.T) reward you for this good act.
Your disagreeing with Ghamidi sb on what issues and what is the counter argument for what Argument Ghamidi sb is giving??
@@khansherani alright we can talk about it personally via any SN i dont want to create an annoying thread on this comment
Edit : wtsap 8309422331
@@zubairno6420 ok
@@khansherani I've got no msg on my wtsap? eager to get clarified...
Please watch the following video in order to know the actual reality regarding this issue from Quran :
th-cam.com/video/vmRVenQuQy0/w-d-xo.html
Asa jawab Ghamidi sahib kay ilawa shaid hi koi dey sakta ho. Superb.....
mind blowing explanation...
thats how we can answer the criticisms raised by enemies of islam...
Greatest Islamic Scholar and Philosopher of the century. Respect✋
th-cam.com/video/mklZ0x-02Gc/w-d-xo.html
روضہ رسول ﷺ کے اندرونی مناظر کیا انٹر نیٹ پر موجود قبر مبارک کی تصویر اصلی ہے
most satisfying answer ,may you live long javed sehb.
th-cam.com/video/K4Zcm_kMhH0/w-d-xo.html
ISLAM is NAZISM sanctioned by Allah
Critical questions.....having ramifications in today's world too....answered so beautifully...as if negatives of hundreds years of civilization...corrected in a few minutes.,.....only superbrillants can..so let's pray that may Allah swt grant this scholar long hayat and correct him his mistakes if any and benefit the ummah from his discourses in this difficult times
Please watch the following video in order to know the actual reality regarding this issue from Quran :
th-cam.com/video/vmRVenQuQy0/w-d-xo.html
God is always right but sometimes we can't understand the Hikmah behind any order
Thanks Ghamidi for helping in understanding ❤️❤️
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls
there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves
even two men can have sex with a slave girl
a slave girl child dont get inheritance
ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
so u'll be okay if ur sister/daughter becomes a londi if all the conditions/criteria are met
Aap ko sunnaye bina zindagi kuch adhoori si lagti hai....Allah aap ko sehat aur lambi umar day...I am thankful to Almighty that i met you through you tube...
Best explanation sir thanks for clearing the doubts.
Beautiful answer ❤
JazakaAllah ❤❤
th-cam.com/users/clipUgkxZHmxaskSeQRw-uU_Nmyjohmw7H5kfTex
Al-Qur'an. 23:5-6 Surât Al-Mu'minûn
Jo apni sharmgahon ki hifazat kartay hein mugger apni biviyon say aur apni kaneezon say jo unnki milk hoti hein keh unnsay ta aluq kayim karnay mein koi malamet nahin.
جو اپنی شرمگاہوں کی حفاظت کرتے ہیں مگر اپنی بیویوں سے اور کنیزوں سے جو انکی ملک ہوتی ہیں کہ ان سے تعلق قائم کرنے میں انہیں کوئی ملامت نہیں ۔
Al-Qur'an. 23:5-6 Surât Al-Mu'minûn
5. And those who guard their private parts, from illegal sexual acts
6. Except from their wives or THE CAPTIVES and SLAVES that their right HANDS POSSESS, for then, they are free from blame.
Captives and slaves are NOT wives as I'm sure you're well aware. And wives are NOT captives or slaves
❤❤❤
His explaination is so simple and clear direct to the point, No unnecessory discussion and jokes. Allah bless you, History will be kinder to you
What a beautiful analysis of ghulami era and present economy depend on interest.
th-cam.com/video/K4Zcm_kMhH0/w-d-xo.html
ISLAM is NAZISM sanctioned by Allah
Best explanation sir ❤️lots of love from kashmir
ماشاءاللہ ۔بہت زبردست کلیریفیکیشن ہے ۔ میں تو مولویوں کی باتیں سن سن کر مائوف ہو گیا تھا۔ اللّٰہ جزا دے ۔ غامدی صاحب کو ۔
What an intellect! Amazing!
Best Explanation ever, lots of love and respect Ghamidi sahab.
Sex slave no answer
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls
there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves
even two men can have sex with a slave girl
a slave girl child dont get inheritance
ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
great explanation 👍👌
may Allah bless Ghamidi Sahab
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls
there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves
even two men can have sex with a slave girl
a slave girl child dont get inheritance
ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
This was something new and positive to hear. But I guess the answer did not cover the particular verse often quoted about female slaves ' what your right hand possesses'.
Read verse 23-25 ... Surah 4
The verse does prove anything against bond women . @@jahangirhussain3677
It was really a best explanation...
He is such a intellectual person.
Allah bless u sir..
Jazakallah khair, May Allah Taala bless you in both the worlds.aamin
Ghaamdi sahab Ek behtareen scholer hyy. ilmo Hikmath ka khazana . ALLAH Talaa Aapko Qubool farmaye Aapki Khidmaath ko . JazaakAllah My Apka Fan hun
Thanku, more scholars like you
Allah blessed you. I was very puzzled and on the basis of this topic atheist criticize Islam but you explained very well.
SubhanAllah... Very well explained.
May Allah SWT bless Ghamidi sab
Completely understand and Satisfaction
today "modernists" (quoting this because some are really progressive but some of them are what Jordan Peterson calls "Pusedo moralistic" individuals) call on slavery not being prohibited by islam as a major reason to reject Islam and our mullahs try to justify everything without taking reason into consideration. But personnel like Ghamidi is someone God has given us to see Islam though the eyes of modern western individual and we can see how progressive Islam was in cases of eliminating riba (modern interest based captilistic society) so poor can get some relief, asking people to be kind to slave, to free them, to implement the system of zakaat etc..
I would say Ghamdi Sahab uses the method of critical thinking and analysis when forming opinions or reaching conclusions. Islam has always been like this.
Ghamdi sb is wrong here because it is against Quran and Sunnah
Slavery is allowed if a group of people commit a severe treason, betray Muslims like how banu Quraiza did (which would have had ended up massive casualties of Muslims)
Or you can make war of prisoners slave ( only those that are present in battlefield and are directly involved in battle because they are their to kill Muslims not those that are at their house or not involved directly )
But it is when you cant free the POW for free or cant take amount for that or can't exchange POW
This slavery is for punishment because many Muslims become martyrs due to war and betrayal and you will only know the pain if one from your household would have been the one , only then we can ask you how to treat these criminals
Rest of the things which Ghamdi sb said are mostly true like how to treat them, freeing slaves is a great deed etc.
Best explanation I ever heard
If you want to hear what you LIKE to hear then then its ok but in reality islam allowed sex slavery for fun just read hadiths of battle of hunayn
@@Solo.Gr8 brother if u wanna know u should keep it in mind before prophet the civilization was totally crumbled and murder,rape,the weight measuring up and down was normal but when He came he destroys these things with stages as u know for example if somebody says u about a job which is very strict leass people will apply but if u say that u will given comfort and A little bit facilities u will join otherwise u will be in your free routine so don't consider that Islam established slavery
@@Solo.Gr8 if u wanna a little bit debate and proves I can tell me your Instagram
@@SheikhAlAhmadMuhammad did all these things. He was a war lord, r@pist, sax slave owner. Had multiple sax slaves. He took new women as slaves such as jawahriyia and saffiya. He invaded and genocided khaiyber and Banu qurayza and hunain. Infact he ordered jihad all over the world. He was worse that any previous society in Arabia. A truly evil man.
Thanks to gamidi Sahab... who clear this mind boggling question!!
The Prophet himself had slaves, and they were often taken after wars. I’m not sure why Ghamidi Sahab is suggesting it was banned just during the Battle of Badr. Our fiqh includes detailed guidance on this, stating it’s up to the ruler whether to take concubines or not. He didn’t even mention the term "right hand possession."
While everyone agrees that freeing slaves was encouraged and would have led to a progressive and systematic end to slavery (by freeing existing slaves), it’s important to note that during wars, slaves could still be taken as prisoners of war. The issues related to sex with them are addressed separately in fiqh.
I always say ghamdi is best scholar in Pakistan 🇵🇰
Best in world
Beautifully and intelligently answered.
Nicely explained
May Allah bless you more
ALLHA pak hume aur javed ahmad.aur dr zakar naik jaise mufakar atta kare ameen
Wonderful explanation.. how a social evil should be eradicated, I think this is the best method which Islam has provided...
Today We have problems like dowry, corruption, untouchability, indecency etc but instead of having strong laws, regulations and even international conventions we are not able to stop it... rather it is increasing day by day..
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls
there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves
even two men can have sex with a slave girl
a slave girl child dont get inheritance
ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
Kya baat he subhan allah
Sir if slavery was forbidden during the battle of badr then how come in surah ahzab verse 26 it is told that the Muslims made captives of the banu qurayza? If Allah had specifically banned the capture of new slaves beforehand then how can the prophet ignore that command under any circumstance?
The answer lies within the question itself
There is a difference between "slavery" and "captivity"
@@harrisonking8972 let's not go into semantics here. The fate of the women and children left after all the men of the tribe were killed was inevitably to be used as slaves.
@@behzadmirza1131
Banu quraiza committed treason
And if help of Allah didn't come, Muslim would have faced huge casualties because from front Quraish and its allies attacked and at the back there were forts of banu quraiza which committed treason and betrayed Muslims
Also there was an access to the place where Muslim Women and Children were present through forts of Quraiza
And we all know what and Quraish and its allies plus Quraiza would have done to those women and children if Muslims got killed
So banu Quraiza ( both their Men and Women ) were punished for their act
And even in today’s world their is capital punishment for committing treason in many countries
Also Ghamdi sb is wrong here because slavery is allowed if a group of people commit a severe treason
Or you can make war of prisoners slave ( only those that are present in battlefield and are directly involved in battle because they are their to kill Muslims not those that are at their house or not involved directly )
But it is when you cant free the POW for free or cant take amount for that or can't exchange POWs
Rest of the things which Ghamdi sb said are mostly true like how to treat them, freeing slaves is a great deed etc.
@@apurpose8614 I respect Ghamidi sb and most of his points are quite logical but I think he made a massive mistake here. My point is that slavery was never banned and even if you lay down the code of how to treat your slaves fairly and if every single Muslim were to follow that exactly (which we both know is impossible), it still would not make up for the fact that you took away their basic human right to freedom and that in my mind is irreconcilable with a fair God.
@@behzadmirza1131 when you commit treachery and war crime, it seems enough "humanity" that you are treated with life, food, shelter and also not being confined in a jail, and on the other hand justice also says that you should be punished too. In my country Bangladesh a "secular" state war criminals were hanged even after 40 years, . Just think logically the women were weak and the children of quraiza were also weak, if GoD was unjust he could have ordered to kill them as well. As far regards banu quraiza, banu quraiza's entire tribe comitted serious war crimes. And when the were bought to judgement, they were given choice to choose between muslim judgement and jewish judgement, they chosed their jewish judgement according to jewish law, which was passed by wounded saad bin muaz who was a jewish then and saad bin muaz was also choosen as judge by quraiza people, not by Allah or the prophet. Even banu quraiza accepted that judgement. Now you can ask, why the women weren't freed with their children, do you know when president Abraham lincon freed the slaves they willingly returned to their masters just because they had no shelter at all and poverty. If the women were left without there male gurdians where would they go because at that time women were totally depended on their males? The children would have died out of poverty and hunger and the women would get involved in prostitution, or being captured by other arabians and sold as slaves which was quite frequent in that time of non muslim arabs. Was that better? Saying things seems sometimes easy, but we have to think in context of circumstances of that time. If you read world history of quite modern than seventh century many asian soldiers at the time of world wars used to hold enemy women mostly wives of army officers in captivity in concentration camps, every night different soldiers would rape each of the women, even when they were given food like dogs, tortured physically, beaten and with heavy work load was these better than the treatment of banu qurayza? I cant change your opinion nor you can mine inShaAllah, but i think taking pows as slave seems quite logical because if you leave them unpunished freely they would again and again conspire against you, for example the war criminals of my country even got into power and politics with proper conspiracy and killing the (weak: women and children (without in return of killing)) among enemies is a sort of cowardness to me as well as feeding them in captivity in jail without any benefit is a foolishness nothing else. Dont read western orientalism, they are too much biased in their opinions and they only praise the west to hide its flaws
what a great scholar
Indeed the best explanation I ever heard of the concept of concubines and slaves in Islam.
What an answer impressive maine bht scholers ko suna is topic pe lakin is se bahthareer answer nhe mila
Bahut khoob Ghamdi Sahab bahut khoob. Allah Apko salamat rakhe.
Much needed answer for the matter.
SUBHAN ALLAH sir ALLAH bless u, so satisfying answer MASHA ALLAH
G bilkul allah inki hifazat kare
Subhanallah Alhamdulillah allahuakber
Khubsoorttt....behtreen...... salute of u sirrr
i wish i had father like ghamdi his kids are lucky to have father like him
Subhanallah the best explanation there is ♥️
Ghamdi sahib is sugar coating . If you read quran 4:3 4:24 23:6 all of them clearly allow men to have sex with slave girls
there are many hadith that talk about selling and buying of slaves
even two men can have sex with a slave girl
a slave girl child dont get inheritance
ghamdi sahib is lying clearly
Jazakallah Dr ghamidi
Bohot ala ghamdi sahab
Mashallah Great explanation 👍
Right❤
this man has class
Well explained but Hazrat forgot to mention the biggest step that was taken for freedom and equality of slaves was the example set by Nabi AS himself in case of his slave Zaid bin Haritha. He was not only freed and adopted as his son but the Prophet pbh arranged his marriage with her cousin Zainab RA which was duly sanctioned by. Allah SWT. Zaid's son Usama was appointed as head of a continent which was to go for battle against infidels and very famous Sahaba RA were placed under his command. Is there any such example set by any one in the history?. Probably no. This was the final.nail in the coffin of centuries old traditions of slavery. Please do add this most important aspect in your subsequent talks which are so educative and illuminating for not only the Muslims but for mankind as a whole.. Jazak Allah khaira.
Indeed!
Jazakallah 🥰
And then hazrat married to his wife?? Why?? How??
Uui
@@emanazmat13037 because that sahabi gave divorce to his and prophet married her to give an example of marrying a divorced women..if he didn't do it then all the muslim girls who are divorced would have been remained divorced rest of there life and muslims wouldn't marry them
@@emanazmat13037 bcz Hazrat Zaid bin Harith RA was NOT His actual son..So when He divorced his wife , she was In no way illegal/ illegitimate/ Unsuitable for being marrying to the prophet.. She was completely willing for this marriage Just like any women of today is free to marry anyone she wants !!!
Ghamdi sb is unique rationale humane with prudent scholar...
Extremely surprising even a great scholar like Gamidi Sir is couching this subject in intelligent words.
Sir,
First of all how can a slave woman be happy with people who killed her father, Husband and brothers ??
She can only be coerced because of her situation.Does this not amount to rape ??
Why make somebody a?slave and then earn merit by freeing them ??
What is the meaning of you have complete control over whatever your right hand posesses ?
A person that too a female is included and considered as Maal e Ghanimat ie Maal or property itself is an insult to womanhood.
How come this practice continued among Muslim nations till 20 th century ??
Please take a list of Islamic countries which banned slavery.I t all ranges from 1960 to 1980 Mauritania being the last country and still clandestinely practiced over there.
Finally Will Ghamidi sir with all his intellectual honesty admit if non muslims after winning a war mete out same treatment following exactly same laws to Muslim men & Women; Will that be acceptable to you Sir ??
I would consider any form of slavery anywhere in the world,by anybody is a shame on humanity.
True Muslim is one who does not defend his religion but one who is not afraid to speak the truth.
Truth is slavery is a shame for entire humanity.
Excellent information 👌
Jaza kallah
Subhan Allah very informative
dill thanda ho gya detailed information ♥️
Good explanation on this topic ghamidi sahab 😍😍
It's not just a best explanation only for muslim, but it could make non muslims speechless. Highly convincing and satisfactory answer by Ghamidi Sahab.
Can you please translate some of what he is saying ? I really need to understand
@@teutalimani6631 you can this with english subtitles.
th-cam.com/video/6pEb3MAm1IA/w-d-xo.html
Speechless? Non Muslims are not uneducated like you to buy this shit.
Filthy logic is used in this video to hide the shit written in islamic cult. If there was true God he would had tell the Muslims to release the slaves and told the muslims to give them work/money This way the slaves will become free and slavery would had been stopped.
But Idiots like you have biased nature towards anything that's written in Qur'an.
Beautiful Explaination ❤
still ghamdi sahab did not tell sex with concubines is legal or not؟ Kindly provide me cimplete link of this video
Then why Muslims did not abandoned slavery later? It was a norm that continued as we could see in ottoman empires.
th-cam.com/video/K4Zcm_kMhH0/w-d-xo.html
Hi
Since the reign of Banu Ummayyah, Islamic rule ended. All the subsequent reigns, including the aforementioned, twisted Islamic laws to their own liking. Hoarding of wealth, alcohol, and similarly slavery, became the norms of their society. Their method of ruling itself demonstrates that they weren't Islamic. A Khalifa is not permitted to live a lavish life. But these monarchs lived in nothing but endless splendor. Hence, their doing is of no value to our Islamic laws and neither can be used as an authority.
@@rabbiyafarrukh1866 what about mehmed 2 who conquered Constantinople and Salahuddin Ayyubi who conquered jerusalem, both made slaves and were given good news of Jannah by Prophet Muhammad(PBUH)
@@Anonymous-uo2bt tum banna chahoge kise ke gulam? Jo itna favor kar rahe ho
@@play-pl6uj offcourse not.
Best scholar, great lecture
allah blessed ghamdi sahab
Sir jazakAllah.
What a wonderful explanation! !!!!!!
Please arrange to dabbing in English language.
th-cam.com/video/K4Zcm_kMhH0/w-d-xo.html guy
Subhan Allah.
Please someone add subtitles to it please i need to show it to one of my frnds
No one will buy it
This is what the Quran says
“And [also prohibited to you are all] married women except those your right hands possess. [This is] the decree of Allah upon you.” Quran 4:24
اور (حرام کی گئیں) شوہر والی عورتیں مگر وه جو تمہاری ملکیت میں آجائیں
Pakistani Mulhid Also no one will buy your book 😂
@@noraiz5105 but i bought his book and many of my friends too..
JD Bhai Me and my friends also listen to Ghamidi daily.
@@PakistaniMulhidLegacy oh harris .. Pls read verse 23 to 25 ... Not only 24 .
Isme kaha gaya h ki kis kis women se shadi karna prohibited h ..
Shadi shuda aurat se marry karna haram h .. Verse 23
Except wo aurat jo pehle se tumhari slave ho ..kyonki agar slave aurat shadi shuda v h to wo wapas ja nahi sakti h ...so unse v shadi ker sakte ho .. Verse 24
Isme ye to kaha hi nahi gaya h ki slave banawo ... Balki ulta slave girl se shadi karne ko kaha gaya h ..
Slavery ek pre islamic institution tha ..
Pehle dil saaf karke quran padho ...sab clear ho jayega ..
Greatly explained
th-cam.com/video/mklZ0x-02Gc/w-d-xo.html
روضہ رسول ﷺ کے اندرونی مناظر کیا انٹر نیٹ پر موجود قبر مبارک کی تصویر اصلی ہے
SubhanAllah ❤
❤ ap agree hain ustad sahab se
Ghamdi Sahab you are great !!!
Surah noor ki kaunsi ayat hai???
Thanks you sir ap ne mira confusion khatam kya
Jazak allah
Allah apko ajr ata furmae ameen
Great Islamic scholar...God bless u
Great Ghamidi sahib
Ma Sha ALLAH ❤️ Sir
What a grea man❤️❤️
Can anyone provide the reference of surah Muhammad that ghamidi saab is talking about
Iss topic par bahut confused tha. Research ke liye mashoor aalim or daayi ke bayan suna lekin satisfaction kiseese nahi Mila. Lekin tab is lecture sunne ke baad aur yakeen hogaya ki Islam insanoki asli sukoon aur justice life Dena chahta hai....
May Allah bless you!
Ghamdi saab forgot "وما ملكت ايمانكم" right hand possess...
Inka bayan hmesha sahi or logical hota h. Baki to ektarfa non satifying bayan dete h. Just like hai to hai aap kon hote h eteraj karne wale. Eteraj ni hota bss tasali baks dimag ko jawab chahiye hota h. Chijo ko smjhne se smjh aata h sirf fact se ni. logic aur dour ka situation bhi jaroori hota h. 👍