As a pianist, one thing that is visible to see in almost every youtube video about the 3rd movement is the lack of attention to expressions. Paul has the best of them by far compared to the others. Well done!
Mad respect to him. He isn't just putting someone else's recordings and adding sheet music, he is recording the music himself and also providing us with sheet music!
Paul you represent everything that is good in this world. Your music, your work with the elephants radiates the light this world badly needs . God Bless you and your beautiful family .🐘☀️🎹❤
Bravo! I grew up with Mum playing all three movements and I always miss hearing the second and third movements on most productions. This was a happy jaunt down memory lane. Thank you, Paul. And thanks for the love you give the elephants especially through your music. I can only imagine what it means to them.
I have to comment again - my 7th viewing since 01/27/20. Your hands never seems to fatigue no matter what you play. Mr. Barton, you amaze me. Have filled my heart with wonderful memories of my Mother teaching me piano on custody weekends.
This method may finally get me to start learning the piano I bought a few months ago. I've been printing a lot of sheet music from a service I signed up for, but you're showing me how the sheet translates to the keyboard. Should make it much easier for me. It's been taking me forever to translate the sheet music myself, hopefully I'll be able to just copy your movements and that'll help teach by example how to translate. Presently, I have a ton of songs printed out (printing this one now), but haven't played even one.
Maestro, de Maestros! Gracias por tu enseñanza y tu gran talento! Dios te guarde por muchos años, y que cada dia nos regales más de ti! Desde México Antonio!
well that took my breath away so many times....you're a wonderful pianist! I also just realized that you're the man who plays for the elephants and other critters! I really enjoyed those videos as well. Also thanks for making these masterpieces look possible...such stamina in your playing.
Excellent interpretation Paul .. I saw also previously your separated videos of each movement ! Well played and welcome back to the serious Piano videos after a while ;)
Bars 32-36 to me seem like the soul trying to climb out then falling into a dark abyss. The moonlight title is misleading. Stokowski made an arrangement for symphony orchestra that captures to a great extent the nature of the immortal first movement. Regards and thank you for the video.
Великолепная школа владения инструментом вы виртуозно играете на рояле, при вашем исполнение музыка открывается по новому, погружая слушателя в волшебные и магические звуки. Для себя в вашем исполнение я вижу настоящего учителя, скачав видео, я потом учусь на вашем исполнение, желая приблизится к вершине вашего мастерства! Спасибо за ваши видео.
@@andrewdronsson9028 мы поняли, что вы великолепный. Где вас можно послушать? А для того, кто это написал, по любому, лучше чем он сам играет. Для него это в любом случае прогресс. Зачем жестко критиковать?
@@ЮрийЧико Если бы я выложил то, что сам сыграл, ютьюб лопнул бы от злости. Поэтому я и не выкладываю. Но вы правы, не стоило критиковать. Давно дело было, сейчас я не стал бы.
Beethoven suggested to play 1 part with the right pedal constantly depressed so that the sound resembled a Pantalon piano without mufflers. In those days, the piano sound was short, the pedal pressed down constantly did not cause dissonance. Currently, the sound of the piano is much longer, so it is impossible to play with the right pedal constantly depressed, because it causes a sound jumble. The harmonic pedal is good here. Its use makes the sound of a modern piano closer to what Beethoven wanted.
Well, it sort of goes from: "I can play this" to: "Oh mon Dieu! is that Rachmaninoff?" My eyes can read the music right along, but I know my own skills drop after the first movement. So,, yeah.. this is quite difficult. He plays it effortlessly and without fatigue.
Wow!!!Is this the original moonlight sonata ?Curious to find out . I bought the complete movements for my mother who was a piano teacher by profession,, I have no idea how to read the classical pieces but wanted to surprise her by purchasing it from Amazon.
As a pianist, one thing that is visible to see in almost every youtube video about the 3rd movement is the lack of attention to expressions. Paul has the best of them by far compared to the others. Well done!
Excellent... Paul's always been great over the years... Best TH-cam pianist
No kidding! Simply amazing and so inspiring to practice more for perfection. He's also a fantastic artist which blew me away also!!
Yes he is underrated. Rousseau is overrated
@@practicalkids5355 fr
… and painter.
Mad respect to him. He isn't just putting someone else's recordings and adding sheet music, he is recording the music himself and also providing us with sheet music!
In the third movement, you can hear every note so clearly, beautiful ♥️
Because it is sped up
@@florisdejong1512 i don't think so
@@florisdejong1512 no. lol in the beginning it was mostly around 158bpm and later it got even less which is not at all fast.
Very beautiful Master Piece. One of My favorites.
Thank You Mr. Paul for sharing with us. 🙋🇲🇽
Paul you represent everything that is good in this world. Your music, your work with the elephants radiates the light this world badly needs . God Bless you and your beautiful family .🐘☀️🎹❤
*BRAVO!* That 3rd Movement! Whoo! 🤯
Bravo! I grew up with Mum playing all three movements and I always miss hearing the second and third movements on most productions. This was a happy jaunt down memory lane.
Thank you, Paul. And thanks for the love you give the elephants especially through your music. I can only imagine what it means to them.
Paul, you are such a renaissance man! You give me hope as a young musician.
I respect your piano performance. ☺️
Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata is a beautiful piano performance. I want to be like him and I respect him.
The end is for a few players.... bravo👏
I can play the end
Good! I can,t now and I will never
Sweet proverbial honk. I've never heard the third movement all the way through. That's intense.
After the waltz in A minor of Chopin the best classical music 😍😍
Это восхитительно, просто божественно! БРАВО!
Damn! Very good. The end of the third movement is spectacular 😎
I played the first movement for my school concert many years ago.
Makes my heart sing
I really enjoy your playing Paul.
I have to comment again - my 7th viewing since 01/27/20. Your hands never seems to fatigue no matter what you play. Mr. Barton, you amaze me. Have filled my heart with wonderful memories of my Mother teaching me piano on custody weekends.
This deserves more views.. cmon man . Amazing job
Just wow😢, this is incredible
Wow! That third movement, spectacular.
Beethoven estaria aplaudindo essa interpretação. Excelente.!!!!!!
Stunning! Thank You for sharing your talents with us Paul.
Full sound! Perfect !
BEAU-TI-FUL!!! Bravo!
This method may finally get me to start learning the piano I bought a few months ago. I've been printing a lot of sheet music from a service I signed up for, but you're showing me how the sheet translates to the keyboard. Should make it much easier for me. It's been taking me forever to translate the sheet music myself, hopefully I'll be able to just copy your movements and that'll help teach by example how to translate. Presently, I have a ton of songs printed out (printing this one now), but haven't played even one.
You should learn forst how to read fast that should make your process just so much eadier and its the right way to do it
Outstanding. Truly masterful.
No dislikes. Beethoven one dope ass dude
Maestro, de Maestros! Gracias por tu enseñanza y tu gran talento! Dios te guarde por muchos años, y que cada dia nos regales más de ti! Desde México Antonio!
Gorgeous!!
This is magical
You played that so beautifully.. wow
well that took my breath away so many times....you're a wonderful pianist! I also just realized that you're the man who plays for the elephants and other critters! I really enjoyed those videos as well. Also thanks for making these masterpieces look possible...such stamina in your playing.
Just beautiful!
Thank you so much 🥰
Thank you sir
Excellent interpretation Paul .. I saw also previously your separated videos of each movement ! Well played and welcome back to the serious Piano videos after a while ;)
amazing perfomance!!
Wonderful performance! Bravo!
¡ Bravo !
Wow Amazing, you’ve helped me so much with my playing.
congratulations Paul !!!
Inspires me to practice!
Bars 32-36 to me seem like the soul trying to climb out then falling into a dark abyss. The moonlight title is misleading. Stokowski made an arrangement for symphony orchestra that captures to a great extent the nature of the immortal first movement. Regards and thank you for the video.
Merci💕
Amazing
Gracias
Великолепная школа владения инструментом вы виртуозно играете на рояле, при вашем исполнение музыка открывается по новому, погружая слушателя в волшебные и магические звуки. Для себя в вашем исполнение я вижу настоящего учителя, скачав видео, я потом учусь на вашем исполнение, желая приблизится к вершине вашего мастерства! Спасибо за ваши видео.
Правда, на 9:10 чёрт знает что. Аж резануло. Ага, на 10:49 - то же самое. Значит, система, ноты мы не читаем. А на 15:35 - зачем педаль?
@@andrewdronsson9028 мы поняли, что вы великолепный. Где вас можно послушать?
А для того, кто это написал, по любому, лучше чем он сам играет. Для него это в любом случае прогресс. Зачем жестко критиковать?
@@ЮрийЧико Если бы я выложил то, что сам сыграл, ютьюб лопнул бы от злости. Поэтому я и не выкладываю. Но вы правы, не стоило критиковать. Давно дело было, сейчас я не стал бы.
Beethoven suggested to play 1 part with the right pedal constantly depressed so that the sound resembled a Pantalon piano without mufflers. In those days, the piano sound was short, the pedal pressed down constantly did not cause dissonance. Currently, the sound of the piano is much longer, so it is impossible to play with the right pedal constantly depressed, because it causes a sound jumble. The harmonic pedal is good here. Its use makes the sound of a modern piano closer to what Beethoven wanted.
Beautiful ! I had to remind myself to take a breath :)
멋져요~ 잘 감상하고갑니다
The piece that contains the easiest and the hardest section ever written for piano. Lol. Not really but you know it's a huge difference
Well, it sort of goes from: "I can play this" to: "Oh mon Dieu! is that Rachmaninoff?"
My eyes can read the music right along, but I know my own skills drop after the first movement. So,, yeah.. this is quite difficult. He plays it effortlessly and without fatigue.
To me. The hardest of this sonata is the first movement.It takes years to master to near perfection.
Lar M 🤨
Compared to the third movement? Surely you jest.
Dude,I love the first movement than the rest of the two
Banger
Maravilhoso
Really good. Thank you for that piece Paul.
Do you plan to record the Waldstein sonata ?
You rule so hard, you inspire my ass to practice. You're bad ass dude.
Wow!!!Is this the original moonlight sonata ?Curious to find out . I bought the complete movements for my mother who was a piano teacher by profession,, I have no idea how to read the classical pieces but wanted to surprise her by purchasing it from Amazon.
Love, love this..... thank you Paul. Question who is Uncle Paul?
Paul how about you record tutorials on the 51 Brahms exercises and then record a video running the entire album?
Respect🙏👏👏👏👏🎼🎹🎶🎹
9:59
I wonder what the next challenge will be? 🤔
Show🎼...!!!
I can't read so I can only play it by hearing haha, I'm still trying, never giving up for 5 years!
Can you please make recordings at half the MMs? Thanks!
I'm not crying, you're crying.
👏👏👏👏👏
🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
8:46 I had to make sure I wasn’t on 2x speed lol 😂
👏👏👏👏👏👍🏻😯
Btw Beethoven gives a break in the 2nd movement because he knew what he was going to do to the pianist in the third movement.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏😄👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
I always extemporise around bar 51 etc, I find it to dull, simply as the sheet notes alone.
🎹 👌🏻
Ah hello ! , its the guy who can't answer a simple question ! . . . .
I can handle the first two… the third not so much…
Your pace in the 3rd movement was the normal one or a quickened one?
Dimitra P normal
Im not available you are..what r u doing here?
9:10, 10:49 What the f...
como arruinar la cancion
Oh, jeezus, the second movement is ALSO too slow, and by about 20 percent too long.
Nope. Incorrect. Please learn the correct tempos, sir, like Glenn Gould.
@socratic...whatever , please just go away
The tempo marking is "adagio" not "whatever speed Glen Gould likes"