Animator Ranks ALL 5-STAR BURSTS in Genshin Impact
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- See you on our streams where we review animations! / dillongoo
Professional 3D Anime Rig for Blender: dillongoostudios.com/rigs
Get Goo Engine here: gooengine.org
Twitter:
/ dillongoo
/ dillongoostudio
Main Animation channel: / dillongoo
Edited by @AbnormalSloth
Genshin has some amazing animations. Despite what I might say, keep in mind all of these animations are already incredible. It's hard to choose just one, so the nitpicking was a necessary evil. Huge props to the Genshin art and animation team for what they do!
Chapters
00:00 Intro
00:15 Jean
00:26 Diluc
00:42 Klee
00:54 Mona
1:18 Albedo
1:31 Eula
1:50 Venti
1:58 Keqing
2:09 Qiqi
2:20 Hutao
2:37 Ganyu
2:48 Shenhe
2:56 Baizhu
3:08 Xiao
3:29 Yelan
3:51 Childe
4:07 Zhongli
4:30 Kokomi
4:45 Yoimiya
5:05 Kazuha
5:24 Ayato
5:40 Ayaka
5:50 Yae Miko
6:29 Arataki Itto
6:40 Wanderer
6:52 Raiden Shogun
7:02 Tighnari
7:10 Cyno
7:24 Alhaitham
7:43 Nilou
7:57 Dehya
8:20 Nahida
8:29 Barbara
8:46 Lyney
9:05 Neuvillette
9:29 Wriosthesley
9:51 FINALIST ROUND
10:11 Keqing Finalist Review
10:25 Yelan Finalist Review
10:38 Raiden Shogun Finalist Review
10:52 Lyney Finalist Review
11:08 Neuvillette Finalist Review
11:17 Wriosthesley Finalist Review
11:27 WINNER
11:59 Raiden Shogun Explanation - เกม
Tbh all of the animations are incredible. The only way to differentiate them was to be PICKY. Also, keep in mind this is an animation ranking, so visuals only, not gameplay. Huge props to Genshin's art team! See you guys on stream next time 🧀twitch.tv/dillongoo
You know if you look closely on lyneys burst when its about to switch to the cat he spins and goes poof
Hey i gotta thank you
When i was pulling for yelan (single pull) i played your yelan animation in the background
And i won in soft pity 🎉😊❤
Yey
No wonder Yukong won
Tbh the animations in this game are supposed to be short and simple to flow with the gameplay
"I promise this is an unbias decision" That's what someone who did a bias decision would say.
pffffshhhhhhh whaaaaaa nahhhhhhhhhh no way :eyes:
@@professorGooS U S
Yeah I honestly feel like this is super biased. Yelan really doesn't stand out any differently than a lot of the other characters. I'm at least glad he didn't fall into the Raiden path but still, feels biased.
Isn’t the whole point of ranking animations supposed to be biased though?
@@truedarkknight0882 Saying professional animator made me think it would be more educational and less biased. The fact he said Ayaka's was way cooler than Ayato's despite them being practically the same is a bit disappointing. I was hoping to learn WHY the bursts were good or not in more detail. There's a very clear biased towards the females of the game, especially if you consider the fact that Raiden's animation really isn't that impressive compared to something like Cyno's which has more movement, more to animate, and a more dynamic angle. Also saying something like "Hu Tao's has more of a character driven thing" while not taking character personalities into consideration for others is also weird since it's supposed to be based on animation alone and not the knowledge of the character themselves.
I feel like the only reason why we don't get longer burst animations is purely due to the fact that Genshin combat is so time based
PGR added time stop to new character ults for this reason lmao
Not even a question lmao long sequences would get annoying as hell with how often a burst is used.
Same Zhongli's ult is cool but I feel every milisecond that I'm losing whenever I'm in the abyss or a domain
They're all short separately, but when I'm trying to set up supports for my main dps (for example, Cyno-Baizhu-Fischl-Nahida) I get extremely anxious over how fucking long some of the ults can take LOL.
Wait is that really why?@@ryanli5803
100% lyney should’ve won tbh, his burst animation is a whole mini movie
That’s exactly how I feel about neuvi
Yeah, and he has an additional "ta-daaaa" animation at the end of the burst if it deals damage
@@Kompoteek He doesn't have to deal damage for that.
@@drunknbard2807 really? I tried to show that to my gf and it didn't work, maybe it only works in-battle or something, then?
@@Kompoteek at the end of his burst don't move as it will cancel the ending animation so he won't suffer an unnecessary hit. Its pretty sensitive too so you really cannot do anything when he pops out the hat
Barbara 5 star confirmed
she gets the honorary 5 star
She was primarily a 5 star before but hoyo made her a 4star instead before release.
Thats why she has a burst animation and her C6 revives one dead character.
barbara gets a spot but no aloy u_u
Always wondered why Barbara had an animation, thanks!
I was waiting for this comment.
Ayato's burst animation is lackluster but, the burst itself of ripples and petals, is so pleasing to look at!
I feel like if you judge Keqings burst based on the effect that happens after her cinematic shot, you have to give the same treatment to everyone and in that regard Ayato should rank much higher. The visuals are so good to look at and fit his character so well. If you don't take that into account then Keqing's burst is mid as well as it's literally just her looking over her sword
let's be real
aside petals and ripples, even though I like a lot of characters animations, ayato skill alone is definitely top 3, which is funnily, basically is what his whole kit relies on.
our dude here goes through yelan whole kit and makes her top one, ayato skill singlehandedly outwits yelan whole kit animations lol
it's so fun, so smooth and so neat and pleasant to just watch.
xiao too... just do some attacks
Can be said for hutao too, when burst hit enemies their soul leaves their body and it can be seen as animation
What I love about his burst is the image of some place that shows up before the flowers show up and stuff.
Tbh Xiao’s ult is basically his normal, charged and plunge attacks. His animation on cast has no reason to be super hard. He is simply unleashing a power up
Yeah, the whole point of his short burst animation is because the casting of the ult itself at the start of the fight is crucial to his kit, which means it would be more annoying than satisfying to watch an animation of his mask appearing on his face, than to just watch him pop it on and go back into combat
But he is just judging casting animations not attack animation
@@rohamebrahimi7844 The point is that a lot of these have no reason to be so flashy to his likeness because *It’s not the actual burst*. Cyno and Xiao are just simple animation of transformations because *Their actual burst is the fucking rest*. Yet, he jugged all the same as if they had the exact same function like if they were all the same.
@@rohamebrahimi7844 then why did he show raidens animations after?
@@rohamebrahimi7844He judges things like Mona's effect, Diluc's phoenix or Keqing's rays very unfairly but not Itto's charged ones, Tartaglia's effects or Cyno's claws.
ain't no way he put nahida on A when the burst blew his mind
Nahida burst is just cute. it doesn't have the same impact as the Shogun or Zhongli.
@@lilfreak1491 Shogun I get but Zhongli burst I've seen way too many things similar to that in manhuas and even from Tatsumaki in One Punch Man
@@lilfreak1491 She's literally a child, and a catalyst user to be exact, how well do you expect her character to do so much animation? Good heavens.
@@lilfreak1491not a Jujutsu Kaisen watcher I see.
Because she is doing a Domain Expansion, THE most powerful move in that anime. That's cool AF.
Coz he is yelans kid😂
I think you need to take into consideration the animation effects a Burst might have on the caster's Normal Attacks or Elemental Skill, and vice versa. I noticed you did consider them for Miko and Raiden, but not for others, like Itto, Kokomi, and Cyno. The changes are very noticable.
Xiao, as another example yes
Plus Childe meelee burst has special effects hitting Riptide enemies and one of the most satisfying if against group
Theres also the fact the bigger is the animation, the worst it becomes because it does not stop enemies or time.
@@KadaEklund yeah, but that's from practical perspective. We're judging aesthetics here
@@alexprus7953 I understand, but when you make art theres a demand behind it, if you ignore these demands you cant think properly about the art, it would be the same as judging pixel art, but thinking into AAA 3D games.
Cyno being ranked so low is CRIMINAL
fr
Honestly!
That eye shine effect was BEAUTIFUL, its crazy good
ikrrr
especially with Raiden being so much higher, I definitely agree. Cyno has a very cool burst animation and while Raiden looks intimidating and powerful, so does Cyno. He deserved better
I have to disagree, Yelan's burst feels rather simple to me. I do like those more high energy bursts like how we see from Wriothesley Lyney and Raiden.
dimple
And she shows her armpit. Cringe.
yeah tbhh its just really dimple ☝️
For real.
Listen...
As a Sound Design student, I think Wriosthelsey is severely lacking when it comes to the sound. It is very impactful visually, but the sound is VERY lackluster. It doesn't have that setup, anticipation and pay off that you see in the animation. I feel like if they put more emphasis on that jet and impact, it would be SS for me.
Animation wise, I think when he swings, they should've made the camera swing a little more harshly to match the energy of the punch. In game, it kind of just looks like a powerpoint transition LULUL
TRUTH. Sound is a very important part of why Neuvillettes hits harder imo
OOH you’re right! They could have made Wrio’s sound effect crispier. There is a sound but it’s not very noticeable or maybe bec it happens too fast? Because with Neuvillette, the bell toll sound is quite loud and you can’t miss it. Lyney has his own fun little carnival bgm during his burst (in animation and during his cat form)… Though I have been playing Wrio, and his burst is satisfying in combat haha. It feels like it hurts, from a visual standpoint. Sound, it’s kind of the usual ice swish blizzard sound they us. but i dont really know how they could have improve it.. 😅
@@lazynull transformers sound? like the metal clings prob
I was wondering what was lacking. It didn't have that oomph, ya know? That boom shakalaka. That pow pow. That shababangba- Okay I'll stop. But yes, it needs some more. Just some more.
Yae has one of the best bursts for this reason imo, i never get bored of how powerful those thunderbolts sound right after her intimidating cheeky glare
Fontaine is animation powercreep.
they went all out in Fontaine in all possible ways, I’m so excited for what is yet to come, especially Sneznaya 🎉
It'll just go better and better, they're improving their animation with each new patches, just look at how stiff Jean's movements were back in Mondstadt and look at Sumeru and Fontaine characters 😭✨
Especially now that Furina is out and Navia's leak is also out
@@nyes4596Furina is mid wdym? Even Albedo looks way cooler than her literally just a clown fiesta.
Bro he NEEDS to do another one now with more fontaine characters released
yelan winning over lyney is so weird?? definitely biased sorry
Everyone is biased as they see it based on their own taste.
@@dilucragnvindr130 i think literally anyone can see lyney would've objectively won there but thanks for being in character!!
@@ghostingspirit In reality, there's no objectivity when it comes to preferences on characters and their animation that people like.
@@dilucragnvindr130 there is!! sorry if you're not okay with that
@@ghostingspirit sorry, there isn't that's the truth. No one can objectively verify what is the best since everyone is just making an opinion based on their preferences. It's the same as what is your favorite color or character.
I like how you emphasized power, movements and authority but diminished all the standards when it comes to yelan when she is just simply posing 🥴
fr
Bc Yelans op 🤷🏾♀️
now do this for Star rail. considering it's a turn based game so the animations get more time to be expressive and unique.
Silver Wolf would win Star Rail because she is the only character who breaks the fourth wall in her dialog, depending on whether you're running the game at double speed or not.
@@Lynemn Bro we're rating animation here, not their dialogue.
@@Lynemnnah Kafka and Jingyuan are better
Clara cuz Mr. Svarog
Spoiler: Win Yukong
So you wanna tell me Yelan has a better ult than Neuvillette, I’m sorry I felt I wasted my 12 mins
Tbh this is from an 'how well was the animation' standpoint not 'how good the ultimate' looked and Yelan just ranked higher due to the reasons he listed in the end.
@@NevaRthelesser Nah from some comments of his you can see clearly that he himself admits indirectly that he was bias, besides that his reasons showed that he was bias as well.
thats why i dont like yelan, she makes plp become dumb
Same it was interesting to see the ranking but then he said shes the best and it just feels bad
Honestly Yelan's burst animation is one of my favourites. It's simple, dynamic, looks interesting with and without camera angles.
Keep in mind Dillon is a fight animation choreographer. Neuvillette's animations look good from a cinematographic and SFX PoV, but it's super lackluster when you look at the posing and transition frames. It's the complete opposite of Yelan where her entire aesthetic is stylish movements, while Neuvillette's aesthetic is stern and god-like elegance. Two different strengths that really can't be compared.
Never let bro cook again
Fr
Bro angry that genshin animations are mid af💀💀
@@ihaveacrushonmypillow5500 When did in the video he said that genshin's animations were bad ? Rage bait used to be believable
bro rlly put Ganyu in A 💀
bros mad LMAO
Yelan's burst is as dry as Sumeru's dessert, Lyney or Neuvillette won for me.
Yeah it’s literally just like
*heh armpit pose*
Deyha should have won
"I promise this is an unbias decision" proceeds to put his favorite character Yelan at the top
I don't think four stars have worst animations, they just don't have the angle to support them. But if you look at the five stars animations without the angle, most of them looks weird af
Yeah, because they are made to be seen from one specific angle
@@skanweers5318 it's just funny that they forgot that co-op actuslly exists so those weird ass animations can't be considered glitches
@@SayaNorwichwell tbf you can't really interrupt other players with burst canera
@@wibs0n68 but still in the other players perspective they always look goofy
So far, I’d say Lyney’s burst is the best animation wise, Neuvillette has the best burst cool-wise and Yelan’s might be the most unique one.
i'd argue keqing is the most unique she does an entire routine
@@anakinsmith4770 no she was unique but now Keqing shares her animation with Alhaitham
@@Juice-chan and your point it must be incredibly good if it got used again
@@Juice-chan also calling someone the same when keqing moves and alhaitham stands still is quite dumb by your logic yoimiya and ganyu are the exact same and anybody with a similar stance is to
Some of these i don't quite agree with. I'm not an animator but i do think some of these rankings don't make sense to me. Like Eula being so high but then Kazuha who's slash and build up is almost identical, and then the field too added.
Then we have wanderer where a lot is put in and you even said it tells you a lot, but that's A tier, but then Yelan's where the isn't really a lot going on, is ranked S.
Same with Nadida. So much detail has gone into it and i'd consider it an S too
@@tartagliax804 I wouldn't say all his ranking is bias to waifus, but most of them definetely are. One of the thing I also don't like is how he lets Al-Haitham be in A tier bc the excuse of lack of movement in the burst make sense to his character, but then drop Baizhu down to C tier for the exact same reason (lack of movement, being only him swinging his arm like Albedo) but forgot to take into consideration that it made sense and in-character for Baizhu to only do that bc dude is literally sick/had weak physical condition and it would make less sense had Baizhu moved around alot in his burst. Also Keqing burst being S tier despite the lacking animation in her burst (discounting the after one) but then kick Ayato down to C tier even when he shares the same amount of movement in his. He loves Keqing after-burst animation but then immediately ignored Ayato after-burst animation with the water droping down and the pretty detailed water petals around him.
He complains about a certain aspect of a character burst, throw them in a lower rank but then 5 seconds later he forgot about it and praise another character that share the same problem as the previous one for some odd reason and put in high tier (Also he just rank based on how flashy they are in some of the burst). Dude calls himself "professional animator" but then judge animations with pure bias and forgetting several aspect that he took consideration in other character but not the rest.
(I came from the HSR ultimate animation ranking and my opinion on this dude ranking is still the same. Several character getting butchered to lower tier (B or C) just because it's not flashy (or as he like to calls it, "anticipating") enough for him. Although there's some that I do agree with, still doesn't change that I feel like half of the character there get thrown down the lower tier for some odd, illogical reason)
"Like Eula being so high but then Kazuha who's slash and build up is almost identical, and then the field too added. "
He literally said that Kazuha's slash went by too quick while Eula's has better anticipation, he's judging it by the QUALITY of the animation not just what is BEING DONE, and yea there are some inconsistencies and sure he is biased but consider 2 things: he's streaming(trying to be entertaining) and he's fucking human, meaning ofc hes gonna make mistakes. Y'all are just being super picky
@@levi0394 cry about it
Y’all, it is literally just a tier list. No need to get so worked up about. If you have qualms still, make your own. At the end of the day, he ranks it from his own artistic perspective-and art is always subjective.
@@SpikoDreams tbh I wouldn't mind the tier list that much (dude can put all his fav all in S tier for all I care) but the fact that he starts the video with "as a professional animator" I would have expected a bit deep analysis on the character burst animation unlike some of the other because he maybe could have known more better on this kind of thing but ig I expected too much.
(and to the other person in this reply, I genuinely don't know what does streaming had to do with making inconsistencies comment every 5 minutes but that will still not stop me from disliking this tier list. Dude presents his tier list for the world to see and there's nothing stopping me or the other to judge his own tier list (be it super critical or just a simple "i dont agree with it"))
I feel like this is missing so much when you don’t take into account every characters enhancements like you did for miko. Specifically xiao and itto for me but there’s much more
Nah nah. Neuvilet's animation better than Ye Lan. I'm not a fan of both but if we are chosing, personality over quality because it's a gacha game. And i can FEEL Neuvilet's status, presence and pressure. While Ye Lan... pretty and dicey - just ok, no goosebumps.
Imho liney is ahead of everyone else by so much. I dislike his personality and outfit and playstile, but that burst alone nearly made me pull for him. It's soo well made and convey so much of the character.
I don't know why he glossed other it so hard
fr i really love neuvillettes its my fav burst in the game 😭
yelan tbh doesn't beat any of s,a or b
Xiao's burst animation is simple because the real effects are on his plunges and normal/charged attacks. The animation doesn't do any damage so it's short for gameplay's sake. Also, as Fontaine characters are the newest and their animations have greatly improved over time, it's likely their ultimates will all be S or high A tier. I'm interested to see how this list will look once all of them are released.
Never let this guy cook again
Yelan being that high is criminal
Well that's 12 minutes of my life that I'm never getting back.
Bro pulled this entire tier list out of his cheeks
Lyney’s my favorite. His burst is a whole performance! ✨🔥
Yelan's burst couldn't be more basic...
Agreed as a Yelan fan. Also he's biased.
Honestly, it's basic. I love Yelan. But Her Burst is literally just Basic, not that Cool.
Literally. I mean it's the same as the basic hand movement but with more angle to of course... show her figure.
Idk. It look so coop. The pose and string
@@arjunthakur6477 Of course it is good but not enough to be in top 5 and in no way it is number 1
A big factor of why animations in the game can feel “too short” is the fact that the animations have to be quick because time plays such a big part in the combat. Due to this, it can be hard to extend parts. An example would be some people criticizing Zhongli’s burst feeling too long or slow. You’re constantly on a time limit in the game with so much off the content, especially spiral abyss where the time you take to complete it is what matters. This is why the animations can’t really be that long.
I honestly want genshin to redo the 1.0 5 character bursts cuz if fontaine 5 stars are these good just imagine shneznaya characters 💀
Yelan has one of the best character trailers but her burst animation is basically just a pose, i wouldn't even put it in S tier if i'm being honest
Definitely biased Yelans ult is no where near good as any of the Fontaine characters, imo I would say I really liked lyneys
Cool idea, would love to see a similar video for Star Rail ults, or the cinematics for Honkai Impact 3rd.
OOO yeah I haven't seen those yet actually, that's a good idea
@@professorGoo A blind/first time reaction from an animator's perspective would be all the better then~
Jingliu, Kafka, Fu xuan and Jung win easy
I cant name myself a professional animator, but I did animate my own models a bit as a hobby, and so I understand the process behind. And so, hearing at the start of the video "a professional animator reaction" I was expecting a strictly technical analisys of the animation. But, honestly, that was very biased toward certain characters. Placing Hu Tao in A for "character" and then B for Yoimiya when they are equaly good, if we speaking about "character" aspect of the burst and fitting it is. Ayato does not deserve C if we, again, considering "character" as one of the aspects of the final grade. Also, very strong bias towards Yelan. A lot of characters in A grade have better bursts than Yelan.
So, as a personal tier list I wont say anything, cause thats a personal opinion I wont argue with, but that wasnt really a professional opinion.
But 8:29 Barbara 0:04 is not a 5 star character?
@ Umm, Im not sure what it has to do with my comment, but Barbara has a 5* burst animation (with dynamic camera movement) because in beta she was gonna be a 5*, but then close to release she was demoted to 4*, but developers didnt have time or simply didnt care to rework her burst animation to fit it into 4* grade.
Or at least thats a tale that was told since release, I dont know if its actually true or not.
@@YiorKha I know all that, but he said in the video that he will only look at the animation of the five star characters and therefore Barbara will be excluded regardless of whether she has an animation of a five star character or not. He was referring to the fact that he wants to judge animations of the five stars five star and therefore he should only consider the five star characters.
Sorry, I'm from Germany and I take such statements very seriously, if you say five star then you should only take five star characters.
Especially as his rating is unfortunately full of bias anyway. I'm sorry but I take such statements very seriously.
I love Yelan’s ult so much but neuvillette just hits diff, and Lyney’s is just so cool. I’d personally to neuvillette, Lyney, then yelan.
Without being biased to Yelan, Keqing has the best burst animation and the fact that it's made in beta
Well you did say you were biased about it so I'm not surprised, but my guy... Neuvillette's is better bro. I don't have either of those characters, and I can see that. Even Lyney's shows at least as much character as Ye lan's.
Who lets this man cook😭😭 he doesn’t know what hes doing he only favors the female characters LMAO
Literally like I somewhat get keqing but bro was not cooking with the rest of
This feels more like a ranking of poses than the skills behind editing and the effects tbh...
Yes posing is what animation is.....
Barbara in 10x slowmo does the heart thingy with wink.
It's the most frame heavy animation in the game, they really put a lot of effort into this, you can even check frame by frame.
Please bring back team commentary of your own animations projects again! I know it's probably a hassle getting the team together but they are amazing and your recent productions since have been getting better and better! 😮
We're planning to do one soon for Progenitor 1 and 2 combined! :D stay tuned!
Fantastic! Looking forward to it ☺@@professorGoo
good to hear, behind the scenes stuff is fascinating
If you make this tier list maybe a month later, Furina's burst would definitely be the champion
Oh yeah easily
I like this, but honestly I feel like your final answer is super biased. On a technical level her burst is impressive, but it has no oomph to it
The issue with Genshin ult animations is that they need to be short or they become a detriment, they don’t have Time-Freeze like in Honkai or a turn-based game like Honkai.
Ngl I feel like having to fit the burst animations into a 1-2 second time window so it doesn't slow down gameplay too much is what really restricts some of the other characters' burst animations.
Also if you ever plan on doing this again can you maybe do it with Star Rail? I wanna hear some of your thoughts on the ult animations there as well
Keqing burst goes for like 3~4 seconds tho (if you don't animation cancel), it's no reason tbf
@@STARZZgenshin the animations itself is around 4 seconds total, but you can start attacking again around 2 seconds after casting it, so gameplay wise, it’s still only 1-2 seconds
@@SF3L Nah, gameplay wise most Keqing Mains who minmax her build (and use no healers) Abuse the 4 seconds of I-frames for dodging and conserving stamina.
It's super underrated bc the 4 seconds of I-Frames is MASSIVE.
@@STARZZgenshin I am not referring to s, I was referring to how quickly you can continue attacking after casting your burst. I said in my comment "doesn't slow down gameplay too much" as in how quickly it takes for you to start attacking again.
@@SF3L ah, makes sense
did bro expect a whole ass cutscene
i would love to hear your thoughts on the normal attack animations
I'd love to talk about the normal attack animations tbh, the ranking would look pretty different
@@professorGoo a fun extra factor there too is all the different animations for blending back to idle for stopping at different parts of the combo
Neuvillette should’ve won this. There’s just no other way.
Goodfy ahh animations
Nobody could beat Yelan's armpits!
There’s something about Wriothesley’s burst that tickles the unga bunga in my brain. I love him and Heizou for being catalyst users who eschew the “mage” archetype for being elemental brawlers, especially Wriothesley’s more aggressive boxing attacks and skill.
The fidelity is not great on mobile, which is the video you were watching for the animations, not sure if that would affect your decisions but just putting that out there
If you look closely in Ayato’s burst, there is the Sakura tree of the Grand Narukami Shrine.
I could not find it for the life of me
I love animation, but only doing this whit the "cutscene" doesn't help whit the ranking + for some characters have an élémental normal attacks (Kokomi fishes are little bigger and water effects are more notable, Raiden Ei has "her" Katana, Itto normal ult attacks change effects and has a spécial charged utl attack and I hope I didnt let other characters behind) But I understand why you did just the "cutscenes" elemental burst
I'm obssesed with the bell sound in Neuvillete's burst
I am currently working on an animation that has a moment similar to an Elemental burst. After trying to make one myself, i realise how many VFX go into one of these. I've added a few effects and the frame still looks empty.
Also, besides bursts, I do love that his charge attack is the same as Ayaka's normal attack ender, and his normal ender is the same as her charged attack. Lol Nice bit of sibling asymmetry.
I wish you would've chosen footage that was not recorded on low graphics settings. On high settings on PC or PS5 the models, animations and particle effects have extra oomph and flair. You mentioned the close up of Mona's face model not holding up. Well, that was because these bursts seem to be recorded at potato settings. ;)
Dillon, you should check out the bursts as a whole by effect (from a distance) and do a different tier list. Some of the bursts effects are fantastic, like swirling maples and so on
"I'll only do the 5 stars cuz they're better"
*barbara appears* 😅
Some people are forgetting and judging based off effects, while he is mainly ranking the animations of the models.
Yelan? Really? It’s too biased. I’m sorry but yelan doesn’t come close to Fontaine burst animation level of improvement. I bet if yelan was a guy he would rank shogun as best burst animation lol.
Cyno and Xiao's bursts have more effects during the combat portion of their bursts. So I'm not sure that's 100% fair assessment of them since you also took into consideration some of Raiden's active combat visuals as well as Dehya's full burst duration which includes her gameplay portion (while she's punching.) Of course, you don't have to consider the entire burst duration, but I'm just saying... I'd put Cyno in high A tier and Xiao in mid B tier when considering instead
11:57 Ah yes the spinning dice.
I just started this but I can't take you seriously after you put Venti's burst you called basic above Diluc's burst which you said has a cool phoenix , where both bursts is almost identical in idea and execution. You're literally contradicting your own words, brother.
"How are the Fontaine characters dominating so much?"
Well, I guess you can say...
*They're built different*
Albedo got done dirty
Umm... clearly not biased 😂
I see why he likes Yelan over Lyney's. While both are, functionally doing the same thing which is posing,, the execute it very differently.
Yelan's still has the sense of conservation of movement, which is something that this youtuber REALLY likes. That and impact frames. The camera and framing transfers her body's turning momentum into the string and the die to get those great string arcs and that spinning die arcing across the screen. Then when you get that pause for the pose, the die is still spinning so it turns into an anticipation moment rather than a pause. Then the animation gives you that payoff by exploding the die in the foreground and zooming the camera out for the final pose where she's framed by the strings on the field. She's standing still, the strings are similarly still and the black screen is working with the camera to draw your eyes completely towards her. It makes her the focus coming out of the ulti and the pose itself is dynamic and uses her character model to get those nice, clean, long lines to compliment the strings around her. Yelan, her strings and her die all work together to form a cohesive concept with her at the center.
By contrast, Lyney is not the focus of his ult, his hat is. You get a brief look at him and his winking expression before the camera zooms out and he throws his hat in the air. He disappears into, what we assume is the hat, but the ulti doesn't communicate that very well. The hat has great momentum as it moves up into center then arcs out and it has taken over as the focal point. But the background and the FX don't escort it along to give the camera a sense of movement to compensate for a lack of limbs or that nice long shape language that communicates a transition. So, when you're moving to control the hat and it's a little jarring because the camera doesn't move with it and it feels more like a "We're here now" rather than a natural progression. And then the black cat with the black hat against a bright flash of a background that then turns black and relies on the spotlights just doesn't help, in my opinion.
On the flip side, we have the final pose of him jumping up, but it feels very static and weightless. We have his upward movement and expanding body, but again, nothing is moving with him so the upward movement feels floaty rather than as actual movement. So with that, we're now relying on the foreground action lines, but those are going away from him which just robs him of even more momentum. So...now we're really relying on the cat FX, which feels like it detracts from his posing, in my opinion, because it's so much larger than he is. I kind of feel like the cat's engulfing him so Lyney can get lost in it. Aside from that, the communication is not very good, in my opinion. If you'd have told me that Lyney was a Geo character, I'd have believed you. I know he has the fire effects going, but I would not have directly connected them to him. They're kind of out of the way and seem like they're a part of the confetti rather than an indicator of Lyney's element.
This is juxtaposed to Vill-V's ult, in HI3rd, which I feel like communicates the whole magician character to hat to gameplay transitions much better. We see her with the hat, we see her throw the hat down, we see her in the hat and we see the hat turn into a tank which is now player controlled and we get great camera movement to transition the player from character to ulti cutscene to that tank gameplay.
Lyney's Burst is flashy and bright and it has an interesting concept, but I think the execution of it could've been better. And Yelan is just objectively better from an animation standpoint as his mirror. Everything works together to compliment the character in these frames for her, whereas poor Lyney is in competition with his own FX and hat.
Just my opinion, of course.
GOD thank you, finally somoene in this comment section who understands what this guy was going for in this video. Have a like and a nice day
FRRR like everyone also saying Neuvillette like yeah the effects are cool and all, but it’s the full burst in general and his is just lacking in character. Lyney’s burst is cool and all, but those few seconds of being a cat really draws out the feeling. Yes, I do have a Yelan pfp, but Yelan’s is pretty great. Her effects go hard and the simple posing and stature of her body and the small detail of personality on her face makes her burst satisfying (for me at least) everytime I use it. Everyone also not trusting Goo when he said it isn’t bias, but based on his expertise in animation, like he’s an animator and knows what to look for in quality animations, so why can’t they acknowledge that? 💀
Very happy about Nilou's ranking! I say it's so much better when her burst line is "All eyes on me!" because her commanding voice clashes yet matches her elegant burst animation.
I believe MC has the best burst animations.
Epic cutscenes are bursts.
Voiced lines are elemental skills.
Funny facial expressions are normal attacks.
Cool downs are locked behind quests though.
never let bro cook again💀💀💀
I don't see what makes yelan better than keqing or raiden shogun or neuvillette.
Imo,her burst animation is in same tier as itto.
Theres a place in old mondstald ruins with a series of ring wind field that connect the centre area to a ramp at the outskirt, when you go from the centre and the moment you hit the ground, you will still slide forward abit, casting the burst at that moment will make it look even more cool for some character.
A lot of the bursts have something like an elemental skill that makes it better so...
And many characters were created in the way that they had to be quick in combat as well
I have ZERO knowledge about the process of creating animations but I can tell that bro was really strict on grading them LOL. I think some of them could've also included judgement on their normal/charged/plunging attacks (Raiden, Itto, Xiao, Cyno, Hu Tao, etc.) since for Raiden they're technically a part of her burst but I also get that we're just grading it based on the animation. Great video and I also think Yelan has a top tier burst animation (my bias is Hu Tao btw). There's actually already a video of Furina's burst animation and it looked pretty nice. We're just gonna wait for a follow up video once there are more characters added to the game.
Bro was strict on males but way too lenient on waifus lol
the only thing I can agree with you about in this chaotic, definitely not biased, tier list is that if zhongli had a better angle at first and last moment, he would be definitely top 3. cause the feeling of meteor impact is always pleasant to watch after all these years of release.
Man, Ayato getting the shaft is just dirty, his burst is gorgeous.
For me , both siblings has very similar burst animations. They both should be in same tier
Yeah they certainly have plenty of similarities, and they both looks great.@@Kixzuki
@@byrntoast8385 yeah..& we all know Zhongli's burst animation is one of the best in the game rn. It looks great even from 3rd party view. Then this professional dude puts him that low😅
Please never cook again
Hey does anyone know how professor goo do animate this character face. This looks soo good. I got that it's not the motion capture or lip sync ai tool because they don't look like that much good.
Raiden under keqing? Yelan overall even to neuvillette? So biases😂
I clicked onto this video and am hit with THE JORT STORM MUSIC :O now the only thing i can think about are JORTS
Aloy: "Am I a joke to you?"
never let bro cook again
my favorite part of lyey's is that it puts the focus on his hat while he disappears, to emphasize the "misdirection" of the magician theme.
honestly, this makes me wanna recreate these animations making some changes
U did Ayato dirty
Bro forgot to add blender in the video title. Actually maybe you should’ve titled it “Blender TH-cam Animator with horrific bias and taste criticizes a team of experienced animators to the point he could do better!”
i dont know about ayatos burst being ranked last man
damn checking hi3 hsr and then genshin ults in that order, it's pretty insane how subdued they are here, although it makes sense for a more dynamic and "friendlier" interaction
Bro did certain characters so dirty ☠️
Yoimiya is at least above yelan, she got done dirty with the pose with the most movement and she literally has FIREWORKS!!
I'd love to see you react to the combat animations they are similar but they all have their unique style !
Having watched your HSR and HI3 animation reviews prior to this video, I think the short burst animations in Genshin contribute a lot to how enjoyable the combat is in Genshin. They are fun but don't take a lot of time or distract from the combat, instead you have this nice short animation and then often you get some really good combat effect. I appreciate how the animations are so concise in Genshin compared to the other 2.
yelan winning from bias pick is criminal
Bro, Neuvillette losing to Yelan made me die inside.
I love my girl yelan but the fontaine chars bursts are just too good
This is too biased for me😅
Some characters were placed *lower* on the list *because* they had *minimal movement.* Yet somehow other characters were placed higher on the list *despite* having *very minimal movement.*
So...... doesn't feel quite unbiased to me hahaha ;)