@@manikadas4929 Lol , speaking English eloquently does not mean much educated by mind n culture. Go n check her educational field. But I am ardent follower of sir Sashi Tharoor , I respect ,admire and appreciate him . Mahua maitra does stand by talent around Sashi Tharoor.
This is what a conversation ought to be - educated, factual and respectful. We have unfortunately forgotten the art of conversation, drowned as we are by daily dose of fake narratives, outright lies, divisive hate mongering.
From Deep State to Surveillance State via Afghanistan - how we landed here. And what could be the role of National Security Apparatus in all this. Kindly watch: th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
It was very healthy and a way forward discussion. Specially when Mohua said, let's not allow someone to capitalise our fears. That makes so much sense.
What a pleasant and matured discourse. Wish some like minded people could rule this country and make it a prosperous and inclusive India. Sadly wishes seldom come true.
Like minded people are ruling our country, that's the reason we have so called "Council of Ministers" who are "collectively" responsible to the parliament. As far as your second argument is concerned, i.e. India not being inclusive, you need to clarify what kind of inclusiveness are you talking about. Are you speaking from the perspective of a "Common Civil Code", then I am sure majority of Hindus wouldn't have any problems with that, instead the minorities would definitely rebel against the same. Or, if you are saying that things should be done such that nobody's sentiments are hurt, well then I am sure you can understand the magnitude of diversity that exists in our country. You can't make everyone happy. So, if you are butt-hurt then it's not because government is evil, it's because government's priorities are not aligned with yours. So, instead of expressing sorrow and discontent, make peace with the fact that you can't do anything about it atleast till 2024 General Elections. All the best for the same. :)
lol..hypocricy at its best..the guy who is talking about Democracy is the same guy who just accepted a person as his (and the party's leader) bcz of his surname fully knowing that there are at least 20 people with better credentials to head the party..the party has never seen a non-gandhi leader except for MMS era and that too was by force, not by choice the girl who is talking about how difficult it has become now to motivate ppl to join a movement bcz ppl's priorities have changed, that bcz now you can make someone not worry abt a danger to the nation if he is given internet for 5 rs is the same girl who abates killing of people just bcz they are from an opposition party and pose a threat to your rule, the party that is playing the dirty politics of "numbers" to consolidate their vote bank
James Henriques, India is one of the most inclusive societies.. If you delve into the Partition times, it was partitioned on the basis of religion, the ones who wanted a separate country got 2 countries.. Yet many of them stayed back in India. If not inclusive then what were we? We neither attempt to convert others nor are into proselytize. No other nation in the world has so much diversity as India..
Really excited to see and listen to their discussion. Happy to see highly qualified decent people are seen in the politics mainly in opposition.I fully support them.
Yes, both have great command of English language , but what does mean to you ? You are there for the substance of their discussion or to bask in the pleasure of their conversation in English language ? Would you care any less if the same topic was discussed in another language much more competently or with less command of the english lanuage ???
This is the problem of this country.. command over english is considered elite.. but the fact is countries like china japan russia focus on their native language not on a foreign soil language
Even I feel the same as Mahua Moitrs. Today I am 50 but I feel earlier India was more secular and democratic. My father was in the IAF and I stayed with Muslims, Sikhs and Christians in the same block. But today's generation has become so intolerant. 'Unity in diversity' is certainly in danger.
Earlier india has seen emergency, nasabandi of Hindus only , 3000 Sikhs death and attack on sikh temple, Bombay blast, 26/ 11 attack, 1200 major communal riots between Hindu and Muslim. Compare to that in last 8 yrs no terror attack inside India and very few communal violence.
WDecember 1992 and Feb-March 2002 riots against minorities (Muslims)- Why there is no mention of it? (You were merely mentioned as 1200 odd major communal violences)l@@sunandaroychoudhury9855
The population adds to a very particular style of competition that youth is doctrinised by many elders at home in the name of social, religious advantages the law gives to a few sect. But in reality, the size of the crowd has outgrown to a level where these reservations are just perks to survive. The poor continue to be poorer...Rich continue to be richer. And in between the sandwich the middle class continue to be foolish serving the rich.
In the background modi gets ups and goes to the kitchen , Modi is making tea in the kitchen for both of them as he finds no space among such intellect .
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right. th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
When it's a conversation between two individuals, one from Kerala which is the most developed state of India with the highest point in Human Development Index, highest rating in Sustainable Development Growth, highest literacy rate, highest sex ratio etc. and the other one from Bengal where the people are born intellect, a place which is the cradle of revolution and Indian national movement, then that conversation is definitely going to be a quality one🙏🙏🙏
Such a highest developed state of India - No one wants to go and settle and not even one IT Park in Kerala .. People of Kerala are settling in Bangalore and Hyderabad .. Perhaps it is too high and hence difficult to climb
Bengal is also the cradle of Muslim League, Khilafati movement, an Islamic state and Direct Action Day. Bengal is capable of unleashing great tragedies by white washing real danger. The cradle had 70% Muslims, yet go to Andaman and see how many Muslims you can find in freedom movement. Yet there are parks named after Khilafatis in Kolkata. So say Bengali HINDUS were the cradle of revolution and renaissance and Nobel winning work. Give credit where it's due.
As a malayali, I have to say that literacy is overrated by many in the academic field. Theoretically, literacy may look like a positive indicator (which it is), but without proper employment opportunities and liberalisation of markets, all that investment on literacy and human capital goes to waste since most of the talented workforce moves to other states (Karnataka, Maharashtra) or to other countries (Saudi, UAE,Oman, Muscat) since they offer much better employment opportunities. The alternative CPIM-congress govts haven't done much to boost the manufacturing sector which offers employment to a higher percentage of the labour force.
Wow what a quality discussion ,This was fantabulous , when two well educated, unbiased and rational people sit with each other this kind of conversations are bound to happen.
Enlightening Conversation. We must have more such conversations with Shashi Tharoor as a permanent figure because he is more experienced and knowledgeable .
Exactly. Sashi Tharoor the speaker is much more interesting than Sashi Tharoor the politician. His debates and speeches are a delight to watch and learn. The best part is he doesn't fet mad if you disagree with him. He would always try to give you a more logical answer.
@Braj H LOL you're literally saying this to a former secretary general of UNO did your father even get opportunity to serve tea there🤣🤣🤣 You're perhaps a modi follower or something else Doesn't have the courtesy to acknowledge such a sophisticated and intellectual personage. Ignominious person like you should be expelled from our country
Such discourses with genuine patriotic and broad minded people should be held more for the benefit of the common people and the welfare of the country as a whole .
Its appreciated , discussion went on without accusing the ruling party in any manner. Evaluation of the growth and development of the nation in all aspects looks very good. Both highly sweet statesmanship as well as firebrands. support the elected ruling party to take the nation forward. Please avoid mayhem in the parliament. You are elected by the electorate to debate , deliberate and discuss not to destroy or disrupt parliamentary proceedings.
@@geopazhoor Did u even listen to them? or just a fan boy of these English speakers. They were criticising the govt. as if the divisions in the society only happened due to BJP otherwise it was a peaceful society although there were riots before 2014 when UPA was in power. The crackdown of Opposition was first started in the early years of Independence by Nehru itself. Refer to book by Vikram Sampath on Veer Savarkar and his references.
Fantastic. The reality that you guys thought of sharing a discussion table is of immense importance. The content of that reality is expectedly and certainly one of the best that we have heard in recent times. Thank you guys.
Whenever I see Mahua Moitraji and Sasi Taroor together I become energised and inspired. I am confident that if they work together, our Indian democracy can get relief from the serious wound inflicted by the selfish negative minded leaders. Congratulations, thank you so much.
Its so reassuring and soothing to know that people like Shashi are in the Indian parliament, being from across the border my longing for peace and friendship in the Sub continent is not a lost cause.
Indeed a treat to listen to two extremely knowledgeable educated peoples’ representatives conversing on topics of public interests ……This is what people want to see in a democracy inside the parliament as well. I wish everybody would exchange their views with each other with such respect and tolerance. 👍
Wish a very flexible guy with a lovable 💓 heart doesn't protrude his heart & keeping the exchange of thought within the boundary of democracy. It is in lighter note 😄😄😄
@Kool Cj at least unlike bhakts we don’t claim fake patriotism and claim to be ‘saviours’ of Hindus 😂. Only illiterate bhakts are cajoled by BJP into delusion.
@@skylark304 divorcing is better than abandoning the wife by the PM. And you belong to that 2%, working as a IT coolie. You don't have to sell your conscience for the small payment you get.
The overall quality of people is reflected by the leaders they choose for their country. If the educated, far sighted, progressive leaders are not elected, then it is a matter of serious concern for any country. Watching from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
I envy him...he is high-profile Casanova and international lady killer besides being being a good speaker....Madam Mitra please...be cautious ... don't fall for his charm... remember what happened to Sunanda Puskar..🤫🥺😥😭
The two are clear examples of modern India's parliamentary representatives, who can garner more like minded people and thus foster the much needed change and thrawt the impending danger of communalism.
They r interested in Muslims Christians but not Indians. They don't have 1. Sab ka saath 2. Sab ka Vikas 3. Sab ka Vishwas 4. Sab ka prayas only appeasement of Muslims & Christians for votes & money
From Deep State to Surveillance State via Afghanistan - how we landed here. And what could be the role of National Security Apparatus in all this. If you watch this video till the very end you would be the most informed person. Kindly watch: th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
They have passion for their dynasty families with no passion for nation & patriotism. They love Muslims Christians Pakistan Bangladesh & not Indians. They r interested in Muslims Christians but not Indians. They don't have 1. Sab ka saath 2. Sab ka Vikas 3. Sab ka Vishwas 4. Sab ka prayas only appeasement of Muslims & Christians for votes & money
Bhai social media pe aise comments mat karo, kya pata BJP sponsored cops might end up charging you under sedition laws and name you as "desh drohi". Be careful, this ain't the india it used to be half a decade ago.
A much awaited rendezvous between the two great parliamentarians in the recent times.. Undoubtedly the politicians on whom the citizens of this country can rely on..
I am very much delighted to hear two most versatile and knowledge able parliamentarians are talking about the important issues that our country is facing these days.
I truly agree with her, we never were concerned about what is religion of friends we r playing with. But conversion is real, mahua always undermine the things happening in Bengal.my own sister was forced for this. Tina dabi remained silent after divorce.pwa e doesn't come one way.
Absolutely delighted to see these two discuss issues concerning our country to save democracy how nice. May God be with you both. Please do something about the present Government
They have passion for their dynasty families with no passion for nation & patriotism. They love Muslims Christians Pakistan Bangladesh & not Indians. They r interested in Muslims Christians but not Indians. They don't have 1. Sab ka saath 2. Sab ka Vikas 3. Sab ka Vishwas 4. Sab ka prayas
@@jotendrakumar2852 Obviously you have not listened or understood the thread of the discussion. Try to listen and understand the very relevant thoughts need and ideas on reaching out to the poor ....
Unity in diversity is the most beautiful thing happened in lndia. In the olden days we used to travel in a train the Sikh, the Muslim, the Hindu, the Christian, the Jain, the Buddhist and many animists group together with no animosity, may we be wise how to choose a leader in the coming election.....
That's how good people discuss and debate and talk , all media houses needs to learn something from here. And also many of the politicians can learn a great deal.
Treat to watch a decent and enlightening conversation between two most right thinking educated people. Proud of politicians like you with whom the future of our nation has a glimpse of hope!! We need such voices and all the best to both of you!!
It's a great pleasure to listen to you . I highly appreciate your conversation . Real love and concern for our Country's welfare .May God bless you Sir Taroor and Madam Moitra
They are never getting enough time to speak in the parliament. Even Ruling party is afraid of them do not give enough time to speak. My two favourite parliamentarians 👍🙏🙏🙏👍
It makes basic sense when any two 'true Indians' talk. Shashi and Mahua radiate the nobility and the glory of our Indian Constitution. HAMARA INDIA AMAR RAHO
yes..inke raaj mein hi toh amar tha India..jab na toilets the, na transparency thi (India's market has one of the biggest share of unorganized sector in it, in the whole world), na terrorism se fight karne ka jigar tha
Wow, this is what i have been waiting for! Both of you are very talented and modernised way of approaching to the reality. I am very much jealous towards their English command fluently.👍👌👍
There was never a la la land scenario in India. We have been the victims of unending communal violence right from the 1947. Ignoring things won't take you anywhere for good but addressing it certainly can.
As the two Expert Parlamentarians participated in a conversation on the occasion of 75 years of completion of our Indian Independence . Very very attractive discussion was held regarding post-independence era . How much India moved & how much should have moved forward in respect of development after gaining Independence . A lot of grateful thanks goes to Dr. Sashi Tharoor & Mrs. Mahua Maitra .,
From Deep State to Surveillance State via Afghanistan - how we landed here. And what could be the role of National Security Apparatus in all this. If you watch this video till the very end you would be the most informed person. Kindly watch: th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
Two brilliant individuals in their own way. They are both my favorites as I gain a lot of knowledge and insight from their conversations. Only the really educated can understand their brilliance and give them due respect for their leadership qualities in their own way.
While the current Governance is a Quagmire with the Meglomaniac attitude of ‘Nation Destroyer’ NDModi passed bills in parliament - it was indeed a delight to see my favorite parliamentarians discuss their minds & treat us. Love you both.
From Deep State to Surveillance State via Afghanistan - how we landed here. And what could be the role of National Security Apparatus in all this. If you watch this video till the very end you would be the most informed person. Kindly watch: th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
I,from this side of the border,am surprised when i hear this gentleman speak.Such a soft spoken,well informed and a balanced personality as compared to the loud mouthed,full of hatred speakers of your country.
When I went through the some of many comments, all are enthusiastic and overwhelmed to see the most intellectual and my most favorite politicians' conversations, which is indeed fruitful and heartening.
Gandhiji was a very intelligent person, he knew that public will not get every thing, so to connect with public he took the attire of public, so does Mamata Banerjee and gets votes of people.
@@subhadeepmandal7089 connecting with masses is not at all an easy task. Gandhi ji left materialistic pleasures to do that. Here they are concerned about identity politics, if they really are, then they need to leave the "intellectual attitude". So certainly even if that was not the gist, I felt it was an important part of the discussion.😊🤝
@@camelliamandal8853 Wow! A reply not ending in hatred and/or abuse. Well that's a new one... Thanks for that. Also I won't present my argument but agree to disagree. 😔
Shashi Tharoor and Mahua Mohitra discussions are very wisely perceived. Intellectually delivered. People at large do not have disposable income. Similarly, people have so much religiously proselytized that nationalism has become intangible. My granddaughter 7 years old asked me, that wrong she did to be named Anti-national or immigrate to Pakistan.
Congratulations to the most suitable and promising person to become the future PM of our country Irrespective of how many ever false allegations are there against someone, only the absolute truth will win in the court of the Supreme Lord Satyameva Jayathe✊️🇮🇳 Shashi Tharoor 🧡🤍💚
It is a matter of great pleasure to watch the discussion of these two noble lauriates on different topics specially on economy related to our country. Both have very good command on language.
Bro..yes it is .it's their choice..I completely agree on it..but when Shashi makes a comment on the post independence generations and about commitments..this the question arises? What are we doing to our citizens of current generation? What have we done? Lots are settling in foreign nations just like his sons did..
@@optimusprime2456 exactly..so what does that mean ..there is some problem with system isnt it ...its not just about any single political party or individual
How can you justify individuals don't matter.. Individuals matter..if all individuals start thinking in a good way society ll change.. And second thing is he made a general statement regarding the post independence generations and those nonsense he should think about his own children,, you can't just say it's their choice blah blah.. otherwise he wouldn't have said that.. my opinion is personal one nothing to do with his political affiliation or anything or with his childrens choice..he must have also thought about it..it's about how he brought up his own sons..he's a hypocrite in those measures I would say..
She could never have been able to beat Shashi in terms of the pace of accost,it's just that the legend is aging now. One of my favourite speakers yet I would say Mohua still would uphold to be in my favourite list.
Neither Indira nor Rajiv had college degree. Nor did Manmohan Singh live up to his potential. You are confusing education with fluent english. Thats the tragedy
They discussed many things that affect us as individuals and as a nation…. The quality and spirit of the discussion kept rising till the end where I wished it never ends. It made me thirstier and thirstier because they were fountains of knowledge and understanding…… I believe they are genuine and wish the country is placed in their hands in 2024.
The moment where Mr Moitra says that growing up we did not think about whether the person next to us was a Hindu or a Muslim.... whether we celebrated Diwali or Eid. I beg to differ on that. We were always conscious of these differences. Maybe there wasn't a party in power which was trying to capitalise on these differences and make the separations wider.
Indian National Congress has been giving this positive outlook for last 100 years and they still giving us hope for next 100 years while living in super luxury.
@@abeninan4017 exactly... they will only say "garibi hatao" garibi never listens to them... so bad... they have been fooling this country for ages now...
My two most favorite politicians together in discussion is so mesmerizing to watch. 👍
They are not politician ,they are just educated individual who hold government office.
@@gauravpandey6850 Also hope you are aware of their current posts as MPs.
She is most dangerous woman.
@@manikadas4929 Lol , speaking English eloquently does not mean much educated by mind n culture. Go n check her educational field. But I am ardent follower of sir Sashi Tharoor , I respect ,admire and appreciate him . Mahua maitra does stand by talent around Sashi Tharoor.
Absolutely “a treat”..!
This is what a conversation ought to be - educated, factual and respectful. We have unfortunately forgotten the art of conversation, drowned as we are by daily dose of fake narratives, outright lies, divisive hate mongering.
Well said, that's i wanted to write.
From Deep State to Surveillance State via Afghanistan - how we landed here. And what could be the role of National Security Apparatus in all this. Kindly watch:
th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
MODI JI JINDABAD
@@tarakvaakil8553 you are the hopless one.
Yes Arijit you have articulated right ✅ and hit the nail on the hesd
Both of them are my favourites 🔥🔥These are the people who need to be in our cabinet rather than illiterates dividing india on the basis of religion .
True well minded well meaning politician s, who really care for India, and its people
Mahua, we love you
How much do u like both of them now specially mahua 😂😂😂😂
@@Baris793 wth 😂 who replies to a 2year old comment (don't know not keeping up with the politics much these days)
Mine too
This interview is enough to Prepare for IELTS exam!
Damn mate
👏👏👏😃😃
😀😀
🙏
Only for English...Come to Telangana and see KTR, you will see a mixture of English, Vision, Knowledge and good governance
It was very healthy and a way forward discussion. Specially when Mohua said, let's not allow someone to capitalise our fears. That makes so much sense.
What a pleasant and matured discourse. Wish some like minded people could rule this country and make it a prosperous and inclusive India. Sadly wishes seldom come true.
Wow..!
True
Like minded people are ruling our country, that's the reason we have so called "Council of Ministers" who are "collectively" responsible to the parliament.
As far as your second argument is concerned, i.e. India not being inclusive, you need to clarify what kind of inclusiveness are you talking about. Are you speaking from the perspective of a "Common Civil Code", then I am sure majority of Hindus wouldn't have any problems with that, instead the minorities would definitely rebel against the same.
Or, if you are saying that things should be done such that nobody's sentiments are hurt, well then I am sure you can understand the magnitude of diversity that exists in our country. You can't make everyone happy. So, if you are butt-hurt then it's not because government is evil, it's because government's priorities are not aligned with yours. So, instead of expressing sorrow and discontent, make peace with the fact that you can't do anything about it atleast till 2024 General Elections. All the best for the same. :)
lol..hypocricy at its best..the guy who is talking about Democracy is the same guy who just accepted a person as his (and the party's leader) bcz of his surname fully knowing that there are at least 20 people with better credentials to head the party..the party has never seen a non-gandhi leader except for MMS era and that too was by force, not by choice
the girl who is talking about how difficult it has become now to motivate ppl to join a movement bcz ppl's priorities have changed, that bcz now you can make someone not worry abt a danger to the nation if he is given internet for 5 rs is the same girl who abates killing of people just bcz they are from an opposition party and pose a threat to your rule, the party that is playing the dirty politics of "numbers" to consolidate their vote bank
James Henriques, India is one of the most inclusive societies.. If you delve into the Partition times, it was partitioned on the basis of religion, the ones who wanted a separate country got 2 countries.. Yet many of them stayed back in India. If not inclusive then what were we? We neither attempt to convert others nor are into proselytize. No other nation in the world has so much diversity as India..
Really excited to see and listen to their discussion. Happy to see highly qualified decent people are seen in the politics mainly in opposition.I fully support them.
Two persons with a great command over the English language having a conversation with each other! Such a pleasure watching them speak!!
Yes, both have great command of English language , but what does mean to you ? You are there for the substance of their discussion or to bask in the pleasure of their conversation in English language ? Would you care any less if the same topic was discussed in another language much more competently or with less command of the english lanuage ???
This is the problem of this country.. command over english is considered elite.. but the fact is countries like china japan russia focus on their native language not on a foreign soil language
@@Lunaticlegend5804 my language is telugu and kannada. Can you understand these languages ? What's your language ?
@@premprasad3511 i know telegu.. not kannda.. but do you know hindi and marathi??
Yes, oxford and cambridge dictionary talking to each other.
I always dreamt and had a feeling that these 2 would end up having a conversation together and it would end up in a dynamic one ❤️❤️
Marriage very shortly
Even I feel the same as Mahua Moitrs. Today I am 50 but I feel earlier India was more secular and democratic. My father was in the IAF and I stayed with Muslims, Sikhs and Christians in the same block. But today's generation has become so intolerant. 'Unity in diversity' is certainly in danger.
Earlier india has seen emergency, nasabandi of Hindus only , 3000 Sikhs death and attack on sikh temple, Bombay blast, 26/ 11 attack, 1200 major communal riots between Hindu and Muslim. Compare to that in last 8 yrs no terror attack inside India and very few communal violence.
😊
Last 10 years were the darkest 10 years in India's history, both figuratively and in every practical sense. @@sunandaroychoudhury9855
WDecember 1992 and Feb-March 2002 riots against minorities (Muslims)- Why there is no mention of it? (You were merely mentioned as 1200 odd major communal violences)l@@sunandaroychoudhury9855
The population adds to a very particular style of competition that youth is doctrinised by many elders at home in the name of social, religious advantages the law gives to a few sect. But in reality, the size of the crowd has outgrown to a level where these reservations are just perks to survive. The poor continue to be poorer...Rich continue to be richer. And in between the sandwich the middle class continue to be foolish serving the rich.
*Great to see Shashi Tharoor and Mahua Moitra together in one frame, having a discussion is like an icing on the cake*
What a delight to watch two bold erudite educated parliamentarians having a conversation
Erudite ? Shashi Tharoor ? Just bcos he speaks good English ?
@@vargheseabraham2154
You should listen to him more
@@vargheseabraham2154 You should go through the books which he's written.
In the background modi gets ups and goes to the kitchen , Modi is making tea in the kitchen for both of them as he finds no space among such intellect .
What's the point of the education and the degrees when u turn a blind eye to to all the attrocities, outright corruption in your own backyard!!
I always wanted both of u to have a discussion together...we need more ppl like u in the Parliament...
So true but sadly we got more of good for nothing educated and illiterate morons alike in parliament.
Very true
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right.
th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
Onlh discussin
True we got idiots in parliament.
When it's a conversation between two individuals, one from Kerala which is the most developed state of India with the highest point in Human Development Index, highest rating in Sustainable Development Growth, highest literacy rate, highest sex ratio etc. and the other one from Bengal where the people are born intellect, a place which is the cradle of revolution and Indian national movement, then that conversation is definitely going to be a quality one🙏🙏🙏
Such a highest developed state of India - No one wants to go and settle and not even one IT Park in Kerala .. People of Kerala are settling in Bangalore and Hyderabad .. Perhaps it is too high and hence difficult to climb
Bengal is also the cradle of Muslim League, Khilafati movement, an Islamic state and Direct Action Day. Bengal is capable of unleashing great tragedies by white washing real danger. The cradle had 70% Muslims, yet go to Andaman and see how many Muslims you can find in freedom movement. Yet there are parks named after Khilafatis in Kolkata. So say Bengali HINDUS were the cradle of revolution and renaissance and Nobel winning work. Give credit where it's due.
@@sureshpolali4616 Friend, you have no idea about Kerala. Please come to Kerala and see what we have..
@@velayudhanputhiyoth337 I want to Visit Kerala .. Do we need Visa there?
As a malayali, I have to say that literacy is overrated by many in the academic field. Theoretically, literacy may look like a positive indicator (which it is), but without proper employment opportunities and liberalisation of markets, all that investment on literacy and human capital goes to waste since most of the talented workforce moves to other states (Karnataka, Maharashtra) or to other countries (Saudi, UAE,Oman, Muscat) since they offer much better employment opportunities. The alternative CPIM-congress govts haven't done much to boost the manufacturing sector which offers employment to a higher percentage of the labour force.
Wow what a quality discussion ,This was fantabulous , when two well educated, unbiased and rational people sit with each other this kind of conversations are bound to happen.
Enlightening Conversation. We must have more such conversations with Shashi Tharoor as a permanent figure because he is more experienced and knowledgeable .
Exactly. Sashi Tharoor the speaker is much more interesting than Sashi Tharoor the politician. His debates and speeches are a delight to watch and learn.
The best part is he doesn't fet mad if you disagree with him. He would always try to give you a more logical answer.
and bcz he is no different than other "spineless boot-lickers"
@Braj H LOL you're literally saying this to a former secretary general of UNO did your father even get opportunity to serve tea there🤣🤣🤣 You're perhaps a modi follower or something else
Doesn't have the courtesy to acknowledge such a sophisticated and intellectual personage. Ignominious person like you should be expelled from our country
@@RahulSharma-wq5go Spineless? Your comment makes you spineless and definitely visionless.
@@Unknownwarrior2377 Hhhm.
Such discourses with genuine patriotic and broad minded people should be held more for the benefit of the common people and the welfare of the country as a whole .
Very true Naseem.
ABSOLUTELY A MAJOR NEED.
Its appreciated , discussion went on without accusing the ruling party in any manner. Evaluation of the growth and development of the nation in all aspects looks very good. Both highly sweet statesmanship as well as firebrands. support the elected ruling party to take the nation forward. Please avoid mayhem in the parliament. You are elected by the electorate to debate , deliberate and discuss not to destroy or disrupt parliamentary proceedings.
Boring, diversionary references to pegasus. Not important or pressing at all.
@@geopazhoor Did u even listen to them? or just a fan boy of these English speakers. They were criticising the govt. as if the divisions in the society only happened due to BJP otherwise it was a peaceful society although there were riots before 2014 when UPA was in power. The crackdown of Opposition was first started in the early years of Independence by Nehru itself. Refer to book by Vikram Sampath on Veer Savarkar and his references.
This is so soothing to listen to such two erudite persons who have been endowed with stupendous and deep knowledge.
Two colonial stooges!!
True👍
@@yatnavalkyan U and I know why these people admire them.
Kiya likhe ho bhai samajh me nahi aaya
Two great intellectuals. Such a pleasure to listen. A very rare pleasure indeed!
Fantastic. The reality that you guys thought of sharing a discussion table is of immense importance. The content of that reality is expectedly and certainly one of the best that we have heard in recent times. Thank you guys.
An absolute treat to watch two of the best orators and erudite people engaging in a conversation. I was eagerly waiting for this.
Whenever I see Mahua Moitraji and Sasi Taroor together I become energised and inspired. I am confident that if they work together, our Indian democracy can get relief from the serious wound inflicted by the selfish negative minded leaders. Congratulations, thank you so much.
The two most knowledgeable and respectful parliamentarians India has in the present government
Both are corrupt 😂
@@vishalgupta7522 feku is most currupt pm in indian history😂😂😂😂
Its so reassuring and soothing to know that people like Shashi are in the Indian parliament, being from across the border my longing for peace and friendship in the Sub continent is not a lost cause.
The way she explained the "V" "K" shape development 💯. I would love to see this kind of discussion between mahua, tharoor and KTR.
This V and K shape is discussed daily on CNBC TV .. Ignorance is bliss
Excellent. Gems of our great Expectations. Jai Hind.
Indeed a treat to listen to two extremely knowledgeable educated peoples’ representatives conversing on topics of public interests ……This is what people want to see in a democracy inside the parliament as well. I wish everybody would exchange their views with each other with such respect and tolerance. 👍
Everyone excepts Bhakts. I wonder why didn't those Bhakts go to Laddakh & Depsang. All are anti nationals in their eyes except them.
@@blueheaven4838 Absolutely 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼 better bhakts not Hypocrites
@@YESHWANTHGunthapally Yes Bhakts who can only talk but do rat shit. Bravery is in their genes. We see it daily in the news.
Wish a very flexible guy with a lovable 💓 heart doesn't protrude his heart & keeping the exchange of thought within the boundary of democracy. It is in lighter note 😄😄😄
@Kool Cj at least unlike bhakts we don’t claim fake patriotism and claim to be ‘saviours’ of Hindus 😂. Only illiterate bhakts are cajoled by BJP into delusion.
Both portrayed the true story of India and its Spirit.
Really zero knowledge fellow orissa is far better than west bengal in gst collection in 2021 despite have 3 times less population than west bengal.
@@ramaraju7754 you have displayed your knowledge and showed how you missed the entire point. Watch again and see what is more important.
@@titus.sj.pune. 2% OF INDIA SPEAK AND UNDERSTAND ENGLISH BUT ASK THEM HOW SUCH ENLIGHTENED PEOPLE GOT 3 TIMES DIVORCE ?
@@skylark304 divorcing is better than abandoning the wife by the PM. And you belong to that 2%, working as a IT coolie. You don't have to sell your conscience for the small payment you get.
agreed
I am a great fan of these two learned persons. Anxiously waiting to watch them in one frame. It seems my dream come true.
I wish people like them highly educated are appointed as PM
We have murderers and sycophants in politics ? Education or command over English does not stop them from being corrupted .and mud slinging.
The overall quality of people is reflected by the leaders they choose for their country. If the educated, far sighted, progressive leaders are not elected, then it is a matter of serious concern for any country. Watching from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
This is Indian representation i want to listen to on news. This podcast should become more regular, loved it.
Iam 16 and last year I found about shashi sir and I think I am in right age to follow and take him as inspiration. He is truly a genius mind
No he isn't. He is lying to you.
I envy him...he is high-profile Casanova and international lady killer besides being being a good speaker....Madam Mitra please...be cautious ... don't fall for his charm... remember what happened to Sunanda Puskar..🤫🥺😥😭
@@paldendorjeebhutia9903 judicial decision still pending or rumers ???
Court aquitted him in the case.
Pls he is not somebody to be inspired about wrong choice
I'm only here to hear him speak in English ❤
He's just a marvelous English speaker that India has!
Love and prayers from Europe.
The two are clear examples of modern India's parliamentary representatives, who can garner more like minded people and thus foster the much needed change and thrawt the impending danger of communalism.
Agree
They r interested in Muslims Christians but not Indians. They don't have
1. Sab ka saath
2. Sab ka Vikas
3. Sab ka Vishwas
4. Sab ka prayas
only appeasement of Muslims & Christians for votes & money
From Deep State to Surveillance State via Afghanistan - how we landed here. And what could be the role of National Security Apparatus in all this. If you watch this video till the very end you would be the most informed person. Kindly watch:
th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
@@jotendrakumar2852 something wrong just think over again.
I never knew this is the collaboration I needed at this time 😊🙏. Much love.
Good to see both in one frame. Fight on behalf of voiceless, underprevilleige, minority n reach out to them🙏
You are our hope for our great India .👍👍🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
From Pak. Wonderful, insightful & civil talk b/w two genuine and concerned politicians.
A debate of the highest order! A great salute to both of the participants👃
This is a great conversation by educated and civilized parliamentarians. Please care to happen whenever possible.
The best we got in the name of HOPE. GOD BLESS YOU BOTH AND OUR MOTHERLAND.
Thanks for this ! Reminder that India is an educated country.
Two of my favourite politicians, pleasure to watch them together and learn so many new things 👍👍👍👍👍👍
What a wonderful way to spend my evening on this 75th Independence Day, listening to some the brightest minds in the land.!
They have passion for their dynasty families with no passion for nation & patriotism. They love Muslims Christians Pakistan Bangladesh & not Indians.
They r interested in Muslims Christians but not Indians. They don't have
1. Sab ka saath
2. Sab ka Vikas
3. Sab ka Vishwas
4. Sab ka prayas
only appeasement of Muslims & Christians for votes & money
One thing I can proudly say that I never bothered with cast or religion or colour of my friend back in my childhood and I still Don't...
@Kool Cj I am not influenced by any political ideology It is my belief and it should be for all of us.
Bhai social media pe aise comments mat karo, kya pata BJP sponsored cops might end up charging you under sedition laws and name you as "desh drohi". Be careful, this ain't the india it used to be half a decade ago.
@@Blessheed Absolutely Bhai...Our identity is linked with inclusive, compassion, progress and tolerance India.
Actually almost no one care about that but these things come in mind when you get betrayed by those friends.
@@Blessheed yea, ha bhai
A much awaited rendezvous between the two great parliamentarians in the recent times.. Undoubtedly the politicians on whom the citizens of this country can rely on..
I am very much delighted to hear two most versatile and knowledge able parliamentarians are talking about the important issues that our country is facing these days.
Healthy discussion..India needs such brave and educated leaders
Not me me and myself and I politicians and and leader. Bring educated politicians .look at their education status and more before voting.
33:00 is the greatest issue of all. Without countrymen, there is no country
I truly agree with her, we never were concerned about what is religion of friends we r playing with. But conversion is real, mahua always undermine the things happening in Bengal.my own sister was forced for this. Tina dabi remained silent after divorce.pwa e doesn't come one way.
Absolutely delighted to see these two discuss issues concerning our country to save democracy how nice. May God be with you both. Please do something about the present Government
They have passion for their dynasty families with no passion for nation & patriotism. They love Muslims Christians Pakistan Bangladesh & not Indians.
They r interested in Muslims Christians but not Indians. They don't have
1. Sab ka saath
2. Sab ka Vikas
3. Sab ka Vishwas
4. Sab ka prayas
@@jotendrakumar2852 🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@jotendrakumar2852
Obviously you have not listened or understood the thread of the discussion.
Try to listen and understand the very relevant thoughts need and ideas on reaching out to the poor ....
@@subrahmanianbalakrishnan4035 congress has been talking about poor for 70+ yrs and will talk about it for 70000+ yrs being in power.
Two of the most eloquent and educated members of the Parliament. Something which is rare to see these days. 👍
Unity in diversity is the most beautiful thing happened in lndia. In the olden days we used to travel in a train the Sikh, the Muslim, the Hindu, the Christian, the Jain, the Buddhist and many animists group together with no animosity, may we be wise how to choose a leader in the coming election.....
That's how good people discuss and debate and talk , all media houses needs to learn something from here. And also many of the politicians can learn a great deal.
She is from my area.. happy to see her with Shashi sir..
You are lucky to have her as an mp I live in rajasthan my representatives are useless
Future of India
Treat to watch a decent and enlightening conversation between two most right thinking educated people. Proud of politicians like you with whom the future of our nation has a glimpse of hope!! We need such voices and all the best to both of you!!
One is killer of wife and pakistan sympathiser other do politics on deaths in Bengal during every election
It's a great pleasure to listen to you . I highly appreciate your conversation . Real love and concern for our Country's welfare .May God bless you Sir Taroor and Madam Moitra
Madam Moitra can be a reincarnation of CM Mamatha Banarjee . I think She has the enthusiasm to lead West Bengal as well as India. Jai hind.
Both are brilliant and hope for the best from them for our country 👍🏻❤
We cannot watch decent debates in parliament it is a pleasure to hear two intellectuals discuss the prevailing problems in our country
They are never getting enough time to speak in the parliament. Even Ruling party is afraid of them do not give enough time to speak. My two favourite parliamentarians 👍🙏🙏🙏👍
It makes basic sense when any two 'true Indians' talk.
Shashi and Mahua radiate the nobility and the glory of our Indian Constitution.
HAMARA INDIA AMAR RAHO
yes..inke raaj mein hi toh amar tha India..jab na toilets the, na transparency thi (India's market has one of the biggest share of unorganized sector in it, in the whole world), na terrorism se fight karne ka jigar tha
Wow, this is what i have been waiting for! Both of you are very talented and modernised way of approaching to the reality. I am very much jealous towards their English command fluently.👍👌👍
Shashi has finally found his successor
Two of our most intellectual politicians.....a treat to watch and listen....
Great people discuss great things
Real India is this
Not d things like go to pak , go to afghan...
Love from Kashmir
There was never a la la land scenario in India.
We have been the victims of unending communal violence right from the 1947.
Ignoring things won't take you anywhere for good but addressing it certainly can.
A very informative and analytical discussion between two of my most favourite political personalities. Thank you.
As the two Expert Parlamentarians participated in a conversation on the occasion of 75 years of completion of our Indian Independence . Very very attractive discussion was held regarding post-independence era . How much India moved & how much should have moved forward in respect of development after gaining Independence . A lot of grateful thanks goes to Dr. Sashi Tharoor & Mrs. Mahua Maitra .,
This is going to be interesting. Just started watching
Excellent !! Discussions . Much needed to boosting the fire of progress of our Young fantastic youth of Our Country .🙏🏻🇮🇳
One day, sooner than later we can expect these intellectuals at helm of power.
Never!!
Can we?
Far fetched dream...All they have is concocted stories..
The rendezvous between Titans is relishable and enlightening.wish to hear more such discourses.
The only crossover this democracy needs but does not deserve.
😂. Stop with the dark knight it's getting cringy.
We Indians came with biased mindset, prejudice & fanaticisms is the reality
Hey sir...kindly bring some ruling government members on your channel. We would love to hear contrasting but constructive discussion.
Loads of love ❤
Ruling party dunno English they know only Hindi
Absolutely wonderful to hear both of them speak. Pls keep these discussions coming regularly.
Yes i am expecting
Wish people in sri lanka would listen and learn..from these two people. Marie alles fernando. Artist
How Educated "parliamentarian talks" both are Great orator
Their dogs are shitting in parliament though.
From Deep State to Surveillance State via Afghanistan - how we landed here. And what could be the role of National Security Apparatus in all this. If you watch this video till the very end you would be the most informed person. Kindly watch:
th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
Glad to see two of you discussing. I wish at least one of you head the country some time in future.
Great discussion !!
Hearing Shashi is always a soulful experience and Mahua is cherry on the cake 👍👍👍
I Salute sir mam Aise Aducate say Country devlopment hota thank you sir
Inspite of SC saying Adhaar card is not mandatory still banks are insisting for adhaar card for opening an account.
Two brilliant individuals in their own way. They are both my favorites as I gain a lot of knowledge and insight from their conversations. Only the really educated can understand their brilliance and give them due respect for their leadership qualities in their own way.
Yeah
While the current Governance is a Quagmire with the Meglomaniac attitude of ‘Nation Destroyer’ NDModi passed bills in parliament - it was indeed a delight to see my favorite parliamentarians discuss their minds & treat us. Love you both.
‼️seeing these hypocrites impressing themselves ignoring the damage their supporting parties have done to this Nation!! ‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️
The nation has come ahead in many respects. Broaden your outlook. One always moves forward.
From Deep State to Surveillance State via Afghanistan - how we landed here. And what could be the role of National Security Apparatus in all this. If you watch this video till the very end you would be the most informed person. Kindly watch:
th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
I,from this side of the border,am surprised when i hear this gentleman speak.Such a soft spoken,well informed and a balanced personality as compared to the loud mouthed,full of hatred speakers of your country.
When I went through the some of many comments, all are enthusiastic and overwhelmed to see the most intellectual and my most favorite politicians' conversations, which is indeed fruitful and heartening.
I wish such an incredible /highly respected and educated human being are to be chosen to be our leaders like PM /Finance and FM etc…🤝
Gandhiji was a very intelligent person, he knew that public will not get every thing, so to connect with public he took the attire of public, so does Mamata Banerjee and gets votes of people.
What do you mean
And that's the gist of what you learnt from this conversation?
Great!
@@subhadeepmandal7089 connecting with masses is not at all an easy task. Gandhi ji left materialistic pleasures to do that.
Here they are concerned about identity politics, if they really are, then they need to leave the "intellectual attitude".
So certainly even if that was not the gist, I felt it was an important part of the discussion.😊🤝
@@camelliamandal8853 Wow! A reply not ending in hatred and/or abuse. Well that's a new one... Thanks for that.
Also I won't present my argument but agree to disagree. 😔
Gandhiji did not live at a room having AC.!!
Shashi Tharoor and Mahua Mohitra discussions are very wisely perceived. Intellectually delivered. People at large do not have disposable income. Similarly, people have so much religiously proselytized that nationalism has become intangible. My granddaughter 7 years old asked me, that wrong she did to be named Anti-national or immigrate to Pakistan.
Two of my favorite politicians across the border.more power to both of you, crush the fanatics!
Congratulations to the most suitable and promising person to become the future PM of our country
Irrespective of how many ever false allegations are there against someone, only the absolute truth will win in the court of the Supreme Lord
Satyameva Jayathe✊️🇮🇳
Shashi Tharoor 🧡🤍💚
If English speaking is the measure to become PM then by 12th std English teacher can also become PM
It is a matter of great pleasure to watch the discussion of these two noble lauriates on different topics specially on economy related to our country. Both have very good command on language.
❤Tharoor and Mohua ❤ Tharoor sahab ek aur ho jaye❤
Rays of hope from you Shashi and Mahua… all the best for the future ✌🏻
Irony is Shashi's two sons are foreign citizens 🤣🤣
Thats their choice isn't it ..and their life buddy ...
Tharoor even after living in US for decades did not apply for green card. Does that count?
Bro..yes it is .it's their choice..I completely agree on it..but when Shashi makes a comment on the post independence generations and about commitments..this the question arises? What are we doing to our citizens of current generation? What have we done? Lots are settling in foreign nations just like his sons did..
@@optimusprime2456 exactly..so what does that mean ..there is some problem with system isnt it ...its not just about any single political party or individual
How can you justify individuals don't matter.. Individuals matter..if all individuals start thinking in a good way society ll change..
And second thing is he made a general statement regarding the post independence generations and those nonsense he should think about his own children,, you can't just say it's their choice blah blah.. otherwise he wouldn't have said that.. my opinion is personal one nothing to do with his political affiliation or anything or with his childrens choice..he must have also thought about it..it's about how he brought up his own sons..he's a hypocrite in those measures I would say..
Very scholarly discussion about the prevailing situation of our country,both the learned parliamentarians satisfactorily enlightened us
She could never have been able to beat Shashi in terms of the pace of accost,it's just that the legend is aging now.
One of my favourite speakers yet I would say Mohua still would uphold to be in my favourite list.
Never Never Ever degrade education as entitlement and illetracy as political virtue or selling product . Pm should be educated not chaiwala.🙏
Was he ever a chai wala? Has any customer ever turned up to say yes I bought chai from him? It's a genuine question.
@@sulaganabiswas rightly said there are fake news popularity now a days
How prejudiced can you get
Neither Indira nor Rajiv had college degree. Nor did Manmohan Singh live up to his potential. You are confusing education with fluent english. Thats the tragedy
Yes, MPs. You as Opposition Party ( rulers) have all the responsibility to fight for the rights of a Constitutional Democracy.
The constitution was dismantled long before BJP came to power. Thanks to Indian National Congress.
They discussed many things that affect us as individuals and as a nation…. The quality and spirit of the discussion kept rising till the end where I wished it never ends. It made me thirstier and thirstier because they were fountains of knowledge and understanding…… I believe they are genuine and wish the country is placed in their hands in 2024.
We need more and more personalities who equates these two❤❤❤
The moment where Mr Moitra says that growing up we did not think about whether the person next to us was a Hindu or a Muslim.... whether we celebrated Diwali or Eid. I beg to differ on that. We were always conscious of these differences. Maybe there wasn't a party in power which was trying to capitalise on these differences and make the separations wider.
I had never thought that we would have the chance to see these two dignified orators sharing the same screen together.
The narrative was very interesting and all of that point towards positive impact.
Indian National Congress has been giving this positive outlook for last 100 years and they still giving us hope for next 100 years while living in super luxury.
@@abeninan4017 exactly... they will only say "garibi hatao" garibi never listens to them... so bad... they have been fooling this country for ages now...