Sad to hear the passing of Prof. Sunil Kumar. Such a great delight to me. Once in a lifetime you come across great TEACHER and he was one for me. I will miss him so much and our many conversation we had at his chamber. Rest in eternal peace ☮️
Educated Indians need to stand up and fight the facist forces The country is in grave danger....hope more journalists do these kind of programs...question who is indian
You are very right about the need to fight the fascist forces who seek to divide us. The question is how. We need to seriously think about it. Admire the way Americans stand up for justice and unity in this regard - they got some amazing civic sense.
Read the book by PN OAK. He proved Shah Jehan has not constructed Taj Mahal. He took it from Jagat Singh, the Grandson of Man Singh, in exchange for Shahabad. Look at the decoration on the walls of Taj Mahal. It is full of flowers and plants, not allowed in the Islamic Building. Look at the top, a lotus, on top of that a vessel , on top of that a trident. Red Fort was not constructed by Shah Jehan either. Look at the gates of Red Fort. There are two huge statues of elephants. How can it be constructed by a Muslim Sultan?
Flowers and plants are not allowed in Islamic builduings? Kaha se miltha hai oak ko ye sab. That's why I said said, PN Oak's reasoning is such that he can make white house, Eiffel tower, leaning rower of pisa or just about anything hindu. He even made statements to that effect. This is not trained history but pamphleteering.
I m afraid that Hindu zealots will dig up a tunnel in Agra, near & below theTaj Mahal, they will put a Shiva idol under it & declare that it was really a Shiva Temple. I m damn serious about it, the same drama happened in Ayodhya.
Bro the dept ur sunil headed in DU literally teaches that Ayodhya was in afghanistan tumhare dharam k lie inn hinduo ne itne jooth bole hai .. ab ek mandir bn gaya to bohot pet me dard ho rhi h.
The Anchors of Z TV perticulerly Rohit Sardana ,Rubica Liyaqat,and Amish Devgan of TV 18 and Anjana Om Kyshap of Aaj Tak ,Arnob Goswami,and others who are making the debate a Fish Market . Should learn the art of Anchoring the debates,particularly from Maya Mirchandani,Nidhi Razdan,Ravish Kumar ,Rajdeep Sardesai, Vikram Chandra ,Abhigyan Prakash ,Karan Thapper,
We all listen one story in the childhood that, the golden egg hen, A hen which gives golden egg every day, but one day the owner of that hen thought if he cut the hen so might he got more golden egg but after cutting the hen he finds nothing, That's the thing we are doing today, We thought that in below tajmahal, we might got something golden, But we forgot that the Shri Ram is every where.
Taj Mahal was a Hindu temple, converted into a mosque by Shah Jehan. Our historians, except a few, have closed mind, they repeat what the British and Muslims asked them to repeat. They do not want to know anything new. Read the book by PN OAK. He proved Shah Jehan has not constructed Taj Mahal. He took it from Jagat Singh, the Grandson of Man Singh, in exchange for Shahabad. Look at the decoration on the walls of Taj Mahal. It is full of flowers and plants, not allowed in the Islamic Building. Look at the top, a lotus, on top of that a vessel , on top of that a trident. Red Fort was not constructed by Shah Jehan either. Look at the gates of Red Fort. There are two huge statues of elephants. How can it be constructed by a Muslim Sultan?
Fight business community behind bjp which supports it... Amit shah is a baniya ... he gets his support from his community... these baniyas are making ppl fight and in the process Indians are not discussing laws made for the business community...
No, Amit shah is amit shah. He does not represent baniyas or hindus or anybody. He needn't be elevated to that status. He certainly don't represent any of us. Some people fell for their bluff last time. But one cannot fool all of the people all of the time.
Voila you are right in some sense but at the end he is a baniya ... and aim is to make money only... hence baniya making all the money... middle class continue to suffer.. ... ppl lol not thinking abt real issues
In round table conference London baba Saheb ambedkar are given speech non stop we are 85% population of India are not Hindu. And same in round table conference British Empire are accepted all non Muslim Indian are not Hindu, they are different tribe.
Wire is giving unnecessary importance to the ridiculous statement made by an irresponsible politician to gain political mileage, by doing stories on it on daily basis will only help him, ignoring such gimmickry automatically render it redundant and there is just no need to build up any defence for Taj Mahal, doing so is as ridiculous as the statement coming from the knowledgeable gentleman.
Sayed Kay - if we don't strictly condemn these comments they will become a new normal. People will eventually start believing in RSS version of history. It will legitimize Talibanization of India.
@jeetkaformula people already believe the rubbish. That's why RSS doesn't target university syllabus as much as the schools. They are good at disseminating their myths and lies through simple pamphlets targeting children, rural households etc. When the lie has sufficiently undermined the truth, it then rears its head into the open.
“ A BJP "lootera" sees his own face in the mirror and in madness he calls others " lootera"!! In three years these BJP leaders are exposed that their "model" from Gujarat ( MODI) is a national disaster, so they have gone rabid they don't know how to prop up this National Disaster-Narendra Modi !!!!!!!!!!!!! “ - Onkar Singh
" भारत में गृह युद्ध होगा !! ३ प्रतिशत ब्राम्हणो ने जो भी षड्यंत्र किये है उसका जनता बदला जरूर लेगी !! अब तो समझ में आया राष्ट्रव्यापी जनांदोलन के अलावा कोई विकल्प है ? मूलनिवासी जागेगा विदेशी ब्राम्हण भागेगा ! सबसे बड़े आतंकवादी ब्राम्हणवादी ब्राम्हणवादी !! यह कैसी लाचारी है ८५ पर १५ भारी है ? " -Prof. Vilas Kharat Director, Dr Ambedkar research centre, new delhi. जय Bhim, जय मूलनिवासी
These so called wise people...say...Indians are labourers and Indians doesn’t include Mughals....at the mean time they say why Mughals are not Indians....siyapa.....
Ask wildlife about the sufferings of their past and present generations due to destruction made in their habitats to raise lavish monuments as artificial heritages. How can monuments a symbol of safety to biodiversity & humanity? Shameful on the part of so called civilized modern human educated class. Monuments a shortcut to make public forget their real grievances.
Taj mahel is may be shiva temple but there is something built by hindu rajput kings and subramanian swamy is going to prove.And 2018 hindu mahasabha win ayodhya case
Sad to hear the passing of Prof. Sunil Kumar. Such a great delight to me. Once in a lifetime you come across great TEACHER and he was one for me. I will miss him so much and our many conversation we had at his chamber. Rest in eternal peace ☮️
Miss you professor Sunil Kumar sir
Educated Indians need to stand up and fight the facist forces
The country is in grave danger....hope more journalists do these kind of programs...question who is indian
You are very right about the need to fight the fascist forces who seek to divide us. The question is how. We need to seriously think about it. Admire the way Americans stand up for justice and unity in this regard - they got some amazing civic sense.
Shamita Dasgupta pak is much better ,
Educated doesn't they have logical brain They are Digry Holder
Read the book by PN OAK. He proved Shah Jehan has not constructed Taj Mahal. He took it from Jagat Singh, the Grandson of Man Singh, in exchange for Shahabad. Look at the decoration on the walls of Taj Mahal. It is full of flowers and plants, not allowed in the Islamic Building. Look at the top, a lotus, on top of that a vessel , on top of that a trident.
Red Fort was not constructed by Shah Jehan either. Look at the gates of Red Fort. There are two huge statues of elephants. How can it be constructed by a Muslim Sultan?
Flowers and plants are not allowed in Islamic builduings? Kaha se miltha hai oak ko ye sab. That's why I said said, PN Oak's reasoning is such that he can make white house, Eiffel tower, leaning rower of pisa or just about anything hindu. He even made statements to that effect. This is not trained history but pamphleteering.
Nice to see educated individuals discuss history! A good watch!
Today i met ,he is so kind and good human being . My professor (Sunil kumar)
swati singh I’m a big fan of him tbh 😍
Rip sunil kumar sir (17.01.2021)
Sunil Sir, you will be missed by all of us. You were such a great teacher to us. May your soul rest in peace, Sir
You can't change history. It is better to accept bitter truths of history rather than closing eyes.
correct that is why read meenakshi jain.
Good discussion and very informative Maya ji, thanks to Hashmi Sab, prof. Kumar for delivering the truth.
Sohail Hashmi is very brilliant . He has looked into the narrative rather well !
Discussed wisely.thanks the wire and team.
Great debate but how such debates will be able to change opinions in today’s scenario
Vinay Chand... Sir i think logical thinking is the only option.
Beautiful and enlightening discussion.
Meaningful insight. Sorry to say, please stop dancing to the tune orchestrated by the uneducated thugs, brought to power by few rich businessmen.
Manoj Dash... Very correct, but still some of our fellow citizens need this insight.
I m afraid that Hindu zealots will dig up a tunnel in Agra, near & below theTaj Mahal, they will put a Shiva idol under it & declare that it was really a Shiva Temple. I m damn serious about it, the same drama happened in Ayodhya.
Bro the dept ur sunil headed in DU literally teaches that Ayodhya was in afghanistan tumhare dharam k lie inn hinduo ne itne jooth bole hai .. ab ek mandir bn gaya to bohot pet me dard ho rhi h.
R. I. P. Sir
Insightful discussion. But the time constraint made the discussion incomplete. Could have been extended to another quarter of an hour.
very fruitful talk very very best talk
Very nice programme very well said
The Anchors of Z TV perticulerly Rohit Sardana ,Rubica Liyaqat,and Amish Devgan of TV 18 and Anjana Om Kyshap of Aaj Tak ,Arnob Goswami,and others who are making the debate a Fish Market .
Should learn the art of Anchoring the debates,particularly from Maya Mirchandani,Nidhi Razdan,Ravish Kumar ,Rajdeep Sardesai,
Vikram Chandra ,Abhigyan Prakash ,Karan Thapper,
basically u mean anyone who makes ghazwa e hind faster and easier is better.
Bjp has succeeded in diverting attention from core issue of governance and the promises made.
Very thoughtful, this reminds me what I learned in 8th class
Nice video
There is a saying " Half knowledge is more dangerous than no knowledge " That's what happens in India now.
Good attempt the wire...
We all listen one story in the childhood that, the golden egg hen,
A hen which gives golden egg every day, but one day the owner of that hen thought if he cut the hen so might he got more golden egg but after cutting the hen he finds nothing,
That's the thing we are doing today,
We thought that in below tajmahal, we might got something golden,
But we forgot that the Shri Ram is every where.
Why PM visit grave of Bahadur Zafar in Rangoon.
Please seriously correction is needed in subtitles.Please have a look at it.
History is history which cannot eraise..
Taj Mahal was a Hindu temple, converted into a mosque by Shah Jehan. Our historians, except a few, have closed mind, they repeat what the British and Muslims asked them to repeat. They do not want to know anything new.
Read the book by PN OAK. He proved Shah Jehan has not constructed Taj Mahal. He took it from Jagat Singh, the Grandson of Man Singh, in exchange for Shahabad. Look at the decoration on the walls of Taj Mahal. It is full of flowers and plants, not allowed in the Islamic Building. Look at the top, a lotus, on top of that a vessel , on top of that a trident.
Red Fort was not constructed by Shah Jehan either. Look at the gates of Red Fort. There are two huge statues of elephants. How can it be constructed by a Muslim Sultan?
We will miss u sir (Sunil Kumar)
Inshallah inshallah..bolte the class me bohot shayad ab inhe jannat me 72 hoore mili ho.. asli musalman to yahi the
Fight business community behind bjp which supports it... Amit shah is a baniya ... he gets his support from his community... these baniyas are making ppl fight and in the process Indians are not discussing laws made for the business community...
No, Amit shah is amit shah. He does not represent baniyas or hindus or anybody. He needn't be elevated to that status. He certainly don't represent any of us. Some people fell for their bluff last time. But one cannot fool all of the people all of the time.
Voila you are right in some sense but at the end he is a baniya ... and aim is to make money only... hence baniya making all the money... middle class continue to suffer.. ... ppl lol not thinking abt real issues
Cannot agree with maligning an entire group of people just for actions of a few. Chahe wo 'baniya' 'hindu' 'muslim' ya kuchh bhi category ho.
Ideot Sangeeth Som should produce, direct, screenplay and action a C grade Bollywood film on Taj Mahah where in he can rewrite history.
I like wire news
the baap of chutiya sangit som.
aapke baap ko bhi Hinduon ne invent kiya thaa. RSS walon se pooch lijiye
P Banerjee good bro
P Banerjee good
harami secularo ka baap hai wo.
@Hashmi....Mughals were outsiders to Delhi Sultans....To Lodhi and Tughlaq....please read history
In round table conference London baba Saheb ambedkar are given speech non stop we are 85% population of India are not Hindu.
And same in round table conference British Empire are accepted all non Muslim Indian are not Hindu, they are different tribe.
সঙ্গীত সোম একজন পাগল ছাড়া কিছু নয়
Wire is giving unnecessary importance to the ridiculous statement made by an irresponsible politician to gain political mileage, by doing stories on it on daily basis will only help him, ignoring such gimmickry automatically render it redundant and there is just no need to build up any defence for Taj Mahal, doing so is as ridiculous as the statement coming from the knowledgeable gentleman.
Sayed Kay - if we don't strictly condemn these comments they will become a new normal. People will eventually start believing in RSS version of history. It will legitimize Talibanization of India.
@jeetkaformula people already believe the rubbish. That's why RSS doesn't target university syllabus as much as the schools. They are good at disseminating their myths and lies through simple pamphlets targeting children, rural households etc. When the lie has sufficiently undermined the truth, it then rears its head into the open.
Sayed Kay wdum
Good. PM your adress. Will mail you a ventilated khakhi chaddi FREE 😊
I don't agree to what Hashmi spoke
*ye Indians ke pass aur koi mudda nahi desh me , ye bus din bhar Hindu Muslim karte rahte Hai*
“ A BJP "lootera" sees his own face in the mirror and in madness he calls others " lootera"!! In three years these BJP leaders are exposed that their "model" from Gujarat ( MODI) is a national disaster, so they have gone rabid they don't know how to prop up this National Disaster-Narendra Modi !!!!!!!!!!!!! “ - Onkar Singh
" भारत में गृह युद्ध होगा !! ३ प्रतिशत ब्राम्हणो ने जो भी षड्यंत्र किये है उसका जनता बदला जरूर लेगी !!
अब तो समझ में आया राष्ट्रव्यापी जनांदोलन के अलावा कोई विकल्प है ?
मूलनिवासी जागेगा विदेशी ब्राम्हण भागेगा !
सबसे बड़े आतंकवादी ब्राम्हणवादी ब्राम्हणवादी !!
यह कैसी लाचारी है ८५ पर १५ भारी है ? "
-Prof. Vilas Kharat Director, Dr Ambedkar research centre, new delhi.
जय Bhim, जय मूलनिवासी
These so called wise people...say...Indians are labourers and Indians doesn’t include Mughals....at the mean time they say why Mughals are not Indians....siyapa.....
Treat to watch..
karsewa on taj mahal is planned to win 2019 election
Taj and other monuments ka revenues wakf board ko de dena chahiye
एक सवाल।
शांतिधूर्तों के किसी भी देश में कोरोना वैक्सीन का निर्माण हो भी रहा है या फिर ताजमहल ही इनका आखिरी अविष्कार था।
😀😀
There was plenty of empty land to build worship places and destroyed temples and new worship places.
So I don't agree with you.
Ask wildlife about the sufferings of their past and present generations due to destruction made in their habitats to raise lavish monuments as artificial heritages. How can monuments a symbol of safety to biodiversity & humanity? Shameful on the part of so called civilized modern human educated class. Monuments a shortcut to make public forget their real grievances.
GREAT INSIGHT. BUT BJP MANIACS ARE NOT AS ARTICULATE AS THIS PANEL TO GRASP THIS. THE PERSON MENTIONED IT TOO AT THE END. ILLITRATE.
Hindi me bhi bnao is topic pr video
Harbans Mukhiya, Sheeren Moonsvi or Najaf Haidar were far better than this Sunil Kumar.
I agree that India juld hi hindpakistan ban jayega
Please sir hindi me
Ek Sajish k Anusaar sabko Hindu banaya gaya,,, q k Ek samaaj k log bharat par apni Satta banaye rakhey,,, but Yeh jhoot bahot din Nahi chalegaaaa
Ye sale tajmahal ko bhi hindi Muslim me batne lage jab ki taj mahal saath ajubo me mana jata he
.
Taj mahel is may be shiva temple but there is something built by hindu rajput kings and subramanian swamy is going to prove.And 2018 hindu mahasabha win ayodhya case