Blame Snyder or Netflix? | Rebel Moon Part 2 - The Scargiver (2024)『Rebel Rewrite』
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 พ.ค. 2024
- Rebel Moon Part 2 is Netflix's and Zack Snyder's second part of their own Star Wars franchise. But the sad reality is that the movie fails its daunting task, and is instead a forgettable and bland concoction. The second part picks up where the first part left off and continues to fail.
If you like this video, give it a like. If you enjoy the content, consider subscribing to the channel, sincerely, Pat.
#rebelrewrite #rebelmoon #zacksnyder #rebelmoonrewrite #rebelmoonpart2 #rebelmoonreview #rebelmoonscargiver #netflix
Chapters:
00:00 - Intro
00:21 - Positives
01:38 - Negatives
03:42 - Bad Scenes
03:58 - Strange Start
08:40 - Silver Lining
09:58 - Re:Write
10:18 - Final Thoughts
______________________
Music Credits:
Space Journey Hartzmann
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/hartzmann/space-...
License code: 6MM5YYIL9QG8XNOG
Rumble - Mojo
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/mojo/rumble
License code: VRRCUSUMBSYRRSY3
AVBE - Night in Kyoto
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/avbe/night-in-kyoto
License code: J9Y3NNQRLKDXCNXS
Call of Fate - Alex Besss
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/alex-besss/call-...
License code: XB3RB7XFEDAYKORY
Digital Dreams - Infraction
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/infraction/digit...
License code: ULKVTKGISEQGWAQM
Insomnia - Mountaineer
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/mountaineer/inso...
License code: 1CJHBW5BY1GZSEZ2
Campfire - Mountaineer
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/mountaineer/camp...
License code: WJYPJNONDH5KPBCE
Cozy Time - Icosphere
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/icosphere/cozy-time
License code: FYPTQ9ASTEOX0RWS
Aspire - Pryces
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/pryces/aspire
License code: RMPHXZVQLUNHLJUS
Awakening - Roo Walker
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/roo-walker/awake...
License code: OCWZGHKHTAFJYWTG
Stellar Escape - Prigida
Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/prigida/stellar-...
License code: CNMPJIP1ZNDSCLNC
_______________________________
YT Credits:
Credit - John Deere
• Every Piece of Land ha...
Credit - IGN
• Zack Snyder on Breakin...
Credit - One Media Coverage
• BATTLE STAR WARS Trail... - บันเทิง
Blame Netflix, For hiring Zack Snyder
I do like Snyder's movies for the most part, and Rebel Moon is his idea. He just isn't a good enough writer. What it really boils down to is hiring someone who understands how to write compelling characters and knows actual worldbuilding. Snyder relies almost too exclusively on visual storytelling. Thanks for watching and commenting.
Blame Snyder or netflix?
answer: yes.
Good video.
I pretty much agree with everything you said.
Some better writing and editing decisions alone, while by no means make it a good movie, I think would have helped a lot and at least kept the audience engaged. I think I am fairly forgiving of movies if I can find something to keep me interested, but I struggled with the first half of part 2 due to its slow pace and how little invested I felt in the story and characters.
The movie had some beautiful scenes - ones signature of Snyder's style. It also had some interesting ideas and potentially interesting stories and characters, but the terrible writing and editing made most of the movie and characters forgettable.
Holding back on the exposition and trusting the audience more, plus adding more b-plots to flush out the characters I think would have helped.
A lot of reviews go over how much Rebel Moon took from other movies. I don't personally think that's the main issue with the movies. A New Hope did a lot of the same thing taking from existing movies, but A New Hope worked because it felt like everything fit together and worked towards making an original vision. Rebel Moon didn't feel like it had that consistency and forethought.
Thank you for sharing your insightful views.
Regarding the point about borrowing from other movies, you’re absolutely right. Rebel Moon isn’t the first film to draw inspiration from existing works, and it won’t be the last.
As you mentioned, A New Hope borrowed elements from earlier sources. George Lucas was inspired by classic space operas like “Flash Gordon” and the French comic series “Valérian and Laureline.” Additionally, the concept of a sprawling, interconnected universe with thousands of cities and planets has been a recurring theme in science fiction.
In the case of Rebel Moon the execution fell short. Somehting that I can appreciate about Star Wars are the many creative designs that make it futuristic, and memorable. Whereas Rebel Moon borrowed ideas and styles from existing, past cultures; "German WW 2" uniforms and Roman togas. Rebel Moon's creativity felt stifled.
Thanks again for watching and commenting.
Amazing objective analysis. I really appreciated your detailed explanation of why exactly some things in the movie didn't work. Subscribed to your channel
Thank you for commenting and the supporting. I appreciate it.
I actually liked the assassination scene. After her initial inner struggle she finally gave in to Belissarius commands, despite her will. Then he right away betrays her to serve his own purposes and this was the last small small push she actually needed to switch camps. But... the other scene of revealing that the princess is alive, seems too stupid and effortless to me. A scene that contradicted with the previous one (I am guessing that there will be some magical and hi-tech kind of ressurection again) and was made only so that there can be a sequel. As if taking down Belissarius for good couldn't have been enough of a motive.
I think the assassination scene could've worked for me if we had more insight into Belisarius and Kora's relationship. Throughout both movies, they never really engage with each other. They have no dialog except for when she's a child on her home planet. The audience doesn't know if Kora has expressed doubts before and if she shot the princess to prove her loyalty to Belisarius, or if she's always been loyal.
We have no clear image of how good or bad their relationship is. Due to that, the betrayal lost a significant amount of impact - for me. I couldn't tell how sudden or telegraphed Belisarius' betrayal was. Given what we know, it was very illogical. He could've used the assassination to get rid of a political rival, perhaps rather than a loyal companion.
Another reason I didn't mention why I disliked the scene is how Kora was robbed of her decision to rebel. After Belisarius' betrayal, realistically, she had no choice but to take up arms and rebel. She wasn't pushed over the edge (internal conflict), Belisarius' betrayal forced her to switch sides in order to survive (external influence).
The princess surviving isn't an issue, if the reveal of her survival was better implemented into the story. Perhaps if the information led to a subplot, where Korra faces a dilemma: abduct a person aboard the main ship who knows the princess's location, or prevent the cannon from destroying the village and villagers.
I hope that helps clarify my view on this. Thanks for watching and I appreciate your comment.
@@Rebel_Rewrite snyder never really has his characters speak.