Ranking All Demo Stages In Girls Planet 999
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ส.ค. 2021
- Hi guys so we all know that Girls Planet 999 has finally come! So I decided to rank the stages, these are all my personal opinions and which I enjoyed the most. Don’t take it personally.
Any Music In this Video isn’t mine and all credit goes to the original owners. - เพลง
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Playoffs DAY 5 // 100T vs PRX | FUT vs TH](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/q75pv359eP4/mqdefault.jpg)
For some reason this video is getting a lot of views after 2 months lmao…I’m very aware now that fu yaning was evil edited! Along with most of C group.
Also not u saying chaehyun was eViL eDitTeD lmaooo if anything they did her a favor by smoothing her actual voice crack
@@nmixx.changeupletsgo exactly, in fact the non edited one was definitely the voice crack, the voice crack version was literally in the live version and the smooth one was the one in youtube but shes gotten better so its okay
They never chose the songs
@@nmixx.changeupletsgo she literally was what
@@Ast-mo5qz ik
It's funny because a former participant said that Mnet chose the songs and maybe that explains why many were out of range or had disadvantageous songs.
Yes! it was one of the twins, I made this before she came out and said it. I’m not even surprised, it is mnet.
@@colourfulpinks1939
Xu ziyin I think said that as well not sure
And she also mentioned this is a direct 30 hours recording without being offered not even a single water, that’s why most of the vocals screwed up
@@lana_354 Liang Qiao said it
@@naushinraisa4740
Yup but xu ziyin as well
Love how Mnet chose the songs for everyone
but made it seems like it was all free will
What?
@@sluggfxxLuvydovex mnet chose these songs for them
they didn't choose them
@@sluggfxxLuvydovex mnet chose the song for them
I don't mean to defend Mnet, but if it is Mnet who chooses the song, it shows that they (the participant) are ready to be idols or not (I mean show how far they train)
@@callmerosee yeh but this was just the introduction tho, so almost no one was ready to be an idol and it also gave mnet a chance to give their favs songs that fit them better
When Yeseo said that "crazy" is not a kind of song that she's confident, I then wonder why would they perform it if they are not confident about it. Now it make sense why.
Mnet assigned songs
Bahiyih was not the most stable in MrChu 😅
@@nhat754 that has nothing to do with this comment
No 21: How can you forget Hyewon, she's literally the most stable there, no shaky breathing
She wasn't just k08(interim ranking) for no reason :))
She was K08 without much training tho she must work so hard 🥺 and I actually think she’s the most stable one
Still salty about lee hyewon 😭😭😭
Hyewon deserved better bit they gave her zero screentime
She did so good but that whole team didn’t do great they were a bit awkward and shy
5:33 the fact that it was scripted and Yujin and Yaning are besties its the most funny thing out of all the show
True, a former participant said that the line of Fu Yaning was arranged. Loving Yaning
In a recent interview, FYN has confirmed that she was indeed told to say the sentence "we go up, but you don't" by the masters/director of the show. And she has a tremendous amount of respect for CLC themselves. She even said most c group trainees went up to her to comfort her regarding this issue, they were afraid it'll affect her mental health but she claims that she's brave to gather enough courage to face negative comments about her.
She's indeed mnet's sacrificial lamb and deserves better.
FR
I never expected yujin and fyn to be besties lmao
Ikrr😭😭😭😭😭
The fact that mnet is the one who choose their songs yet jia and youngeun killed their kick it perf. 🤧
bet mnet was trying to set them up for failure but they ended up suprising everyone 💅
@@user-fk8hg9nc8f
They were literally Mnet's favourites (especially youngeun)
@@Faeriiexx favorite? when youngeun even got mnet evil editing ☠️
@@imonthenextlevel1724
When did she get evil edited. The judges ate her up. She could just breathe and they would cut to someone being in awe
@@Faeriiexx I wouldn't bring up when she got evil editing cause that was so tiring actually this is my first time seeing someone commented youngeun as mnet's favorite which is blind blowing lmfao. For now I'm just happy that she made it to the group and being happy while her haters are lying on their beds and being mad at her. ☠️
It's funny how the most of them you said that was just a bad song choice and then we discover that was actually Mnet's choice 😂 I wonder how it would be if they could choose the songs...
mnet would probably never let them choose them
@@colourfulpinks1939 u are right! they just wanted the girls they wanted to shine. but... i wonder what songs would they pick. even the girls who did greaaat like youngeun and jia. i just wonder... if the worst ones could stand out and have more fans... i think mnet would cut them out like they did with seungeun
(Sorry if my English is not good)
They won't let them choose them songs so it won't ruin mnets plan, the line up is already planned from the start of the show based on popularity. (Yujin and Bayiyh - sorry if her name was wrong, was most likely already chosen before because they know that people will be choosing then and they're the most popular in the show). They could easily show their abilities if they chose their own songs, which is something again mnet doesn't want. They could easily receive discrimination if they Debuted members that aren't based off of voting. In previous shows from mnet, they messed up the voting system so they could Debut the group that they want, not what the people want.
@@z.6480 Yes, I know it and I agree with you. That's why since the beginning Xiaoting was the only one chinese that they were trying hard to the koreans liked. They already hated that there is a chinese in the group but "at least" its Xiaoting and she's pretty. But what I meant was that I really wanted to see they doing what they're good with, it would be so nice to see that. I'm sure that Ziyin would be a BLAST. She also said that she spends all the record (?) without drinking water, I bet that if she was hidrated and with a song she knew, she would have done better.
The possibility that MNET only gave water to the girls they wanted to do well, is super scary to me.
I don’t like how most c group were evil edited
Fr mnet is so xenophobic
@@colourfulpinks1939 yet you fell for yaning's scripted speech :/
@@winon2404 Maybe they have already changed their mind, just like most of the viewers :/ This video was posted 2 months ago, this comment was posted 1 week ago so...
@@winon2404 Yaning's evil edit is the first one, so not surprised everyone hated her (exluding me I really dont care abt that issue despite having Yujin as my pick)
@@winon2404 her evil editing wasnt why a lot of people disliked her tho? many didnt like her because she said the n word, Su ruiqi also lost a lot of fans because she did blackface
Siren trainee didn’t sleep for 48 hours before she stepped on the stage. Her vocal range is definitely amazing if you take a look at her other stages.
girl can sing opera if she had more than 2 sips of water and full energy she would have done so much better
hurts how much mnet made these girls go through then make them look like the villains
@@sunnygirl7669 This is just what Mnet does, makes a big show to attract everyone’s attention, and then does things really bad to the contestants.
@@user-xb1ol9bc9n the worst part is, in the end, even if you do make it it’ll only be for 2 years which considering you were formed through a mnet survival show you’ll most likely be surrounded by scandals throughout your 2,5 year carrer 🙁
@@sunnygirl7669 Yes!!! That’s the worst part!!! People will always say the debut is not fair.
For the Siren, XuZiyin (the trainee) said that she was one of the last (3rd before the last) for performing. She also said that she doesn’t sleep since 30 hours and eat for 12 hours sorry my bad english
Indeed, im very sad for ruada, but mnet is very cruel, i think that is the way korean industry works, and gain a lot of popularity
that performance wasn't so good but she got one of the best voices in the show honestly and it's sad that she got sick and left or maybe she would be among the top9
@@lorena5619 she's Chinese so I doubt.
i made the 1k like
I was waiting criticism in helicopter stage, not criticism on Fu yaning for something outside the stage :/
sorry this was 2 months ago when she was evil edited lmao
all this kind of videos do the same :// don't expect them to do something else since they ate the evil edit!
as a Yaning stan i'm a little bit triggered :/
@@yoooreeeeee006 me too, ppl always end up criticizing yaning's "attitude" instead of the presentation. yaning still did amazing despite the evil edit
@@PerigeePRG this was two months ago…..
3:16 actually I think Lee Hyewon did the best out of them, her vocals were really stable and her dance was good. But as with the other 3, the downside was just a lack of facial expressions.
Hyewon actually had some really cute expressions
Her smile is just so precious 🥺💗
They were just all very shy so the performance was weakened
Hyewon was so good, her vocals were insanely clean onstage. But yeah Bahiyihh for one is pretty stable but lacks any sort of stage presence besides the association w her brother tbh. She needs to work on her facials a lot
@@Zarzar22 i think that's just how her face looks like I don't think she can do much with it
@@crackbae7610 they were Talking about her facial expressions and stage presence not her visuals
So nice to see someone else appreciate the Dumdi Dumdi performance!!
They rlly seemed like idols to me!
Ikr I freaking loved their performance
Agreed
I love it but mashiro is just so chill during it, her facials improved so much 😂
you might want to correct the Helicopter part, it was said to be scripted by some trainees. to add on, she was heavily evil edited. you'll find out in the end that yujin and yaning are actually really close
I know I made this 2 months ago
do you want to put a highlighted/pinned comment on this video speaking about this matter? because i still see people in this comment section bashing her for it
@@kazchiong123 I’m pretty sure they know.. and people are allowed to dislike fu yaning because she’s been racist
@@colourfulpinks1939 wait no, i'm not asking people to like her, but more like inform others about this misunderstanding. also about the racist thing, i know she speaks fluent english but she learn that in China. i will just assume that she isn't aware of american slangs because majority of Chinese weren't taught about those stuff and also she did apologise about it. Chinese people aren't usually too update about slangs in the world because of the social media exposure they get, it's different from the rest of the world.
@@kazchiong123 I know but black fans are still allowed to feel how they feel by their actions.. and it’s pretty obvious that people know that mnet set her up now.. considering how in the show it was brought up again.
When SU RUI QI is THIS talented. And she didn’t debut.
kim bora too
in mr chuu, hyewon voice is stable too, imo she's more stable than bahiyyih
Ive never watched girls planet but I did watch the demo and I thought the girl they were talking about was hyewon lol
Why you so pressed about it
@@kalinakirifah7641 wdym 🤨 no one is pressed here
to say the truth I liked hiyyih voice more but yeah she was pretty stable as well those two carried the performance
My favorite demo stage is definitely the wow things stage, these girls had FANTASTIC chemistry and as you mentioned look like an already debuted group, hyerim was also my favorite vocal out of the whole show, can anyone actually believe no one of these girls made it to the debut line up, not even after the 2nd elimination, I'm madddd
Honestly I was devastated at how mnet made ya ning sound. It was all scripted and fu ya ning is actually a very sweet and lovely person.
Didn't Yujin and Ya Ning become really good friends during the show aswell?
fu yaning mentioned later in an interview that she respects clc and at that stage it was all edited to make the atmosphere look tense but it was all normal and she even became really close to yujin during the show she also mentioned that after she saw how the edited version made her get alot of hate she started to cry shes such a sweetheart i blame mnet
plus she's really talented, I personally liked her better in ywy2 bc of no evil edit.
Personally, Su Rui Qi reminds me of Moonbyul and Solar combined. Solar, Moonbyul, and Su Rui Qi all have amazing vocals. I'm devastated she didn't make it into Kep1er; she was one of my favs.
Su Ruiqi 🥺💗
fu yaning got evil edited, actually when she said that first line We go up helicopter, she was laughing. but mnet cut it
I know I made this 2 months ago
as a bvnditbul i want to say thank you for the way u appreciate seungeun, bcs yes she’s underrated..
yw
Agreed
Like noone paid attention to her 😭😭😭
I was expecting my girl to be blown up and praised for her dance and stable vocals while performing it but ack-
Nada no one🥲💕
@@kclarke421 right! and also i was expecting her for the 2nd mission for dance, so that everyone knows how talented she is. but the fact that she’s eliminated from the 1st elimination hurt me
yesss so sad to see her get eliminated in the first elimination 😭😭
@@abeerihsan2661 bvndit :)
hikaru already made her debut the first time ppl glanced at her. shes truly a performer
The popstars performance was so perfect and cool. Definetly my first pick!!
Right Popstars and Wow Thing are the best
I'm the one who didn't like Yujin performace that much? She was good, but like, it was not such wow performace
I’m just addicted to it for some reason.. I love the song and she was so stable while jumping !
Same, i think it was just okay
was just ok
I didn’t feel anything special from hers but it was definitely a good performance!
Agreed, was good but that's about it
When u find out they weren’t allowed to pick songs themselves 😪
the wow thing group should just debut on their own
apparently many of the trainees hadn’t slept in a really long time and they were exhausted (xu ziyin said on her live) so they couldn’t perform their best
yaning was evil edited by mnet thats why :( it was scripted
yeh Ik lmao this was two months ago
@@colourfulpinks1939 eso no es excusa
Además, se supone que estas calificando las actuaciones
No sus personalidades
Seungeun was so underrated and talented I agree!
No 20: Ziyin actually begged the staff to change her demo song but she was ignored
And yes Seungeun is severely underrated! Like I don’t get? Do people not see or hear her?!
Moana and Rayeon was so underrated :(
For mr chu I found Hyewon most stable
and thought wow thing should be way higher
also Bubble pop feels it should be a bit lower (Yujin is my bias though)
And hug u Sakurai is her last name her first is miu
AGREE
Best audition
1 paradise lost
2 snapping /bombaya
3 Kda /bounce
4 gogobabe
5 dumdi dumdi
7 crazy/helicopter
8 Wow things
9 bubble pop
10 black
Omg, we have the same taste. I put paradise lost 1st too
Popstars?
xu ziyin said that they didn't let her drink water for idk how much time, couln't choose their song and that all c-group were treated very badly. If you saw youth with you 2 you know that she is one of the best, she can literally do opera. She didn't sleep for 30hours, didn't eat and drink for so many hours she didn't even know it was possible to
Mnet had the audacity to put two ex-sm trainees in the same group and give them an aespa song
Ruiqi is really like Chungha. They both super great to dance and singing at all.
ziyin's performance i also didn't like
but after she explained everythign i was like wow
then it's actually really good
and that song is in her range WITHOUT A DOUBT
but under those circumstances it's acceptable
fu yaning was actually a victim of mnet editing. She came on live and explained the situation. Apparently, she had no choice in what she said, and yujin's reaction was actually good-natured
It's so sad tbh that none of the girls could choose the songs they wanted to perform and mnet just wanted to make individual trainees shine
Seungeun was the best solo for me and wow thing girls were just another level. They were flawless.
Bubble pop is actually not THAT good. She sounds soo breatheless and the song choice is too 'safe'
But yujin didnt really gave any impression to me in the whole show idk y maybe i expected more from her since she ia experienced
Same!
20. I know her from Youth with you 2, if anyone wants to debate, I will get aggressive. Her vocal range, sustainability and breath control are amazing. She couldn't sing here, because she hadn't slept for 30+ hours and only had 2 sips of water before going on stage (she said so, you can look it up). Her dance is on point as well and I can tell you from experience that singing loud headvoice/falsetto with a dry throat is beyond difficult, almost impossible. Ugh I just wanted her to debut so badly, she's amazing
Thank you for acknowledging the bounce back group they were so underrated idk how that video had so little views 😭 also i also cant stop watching the crazy 4minute demo, they absolutely slayed oml
Hymph is by far the most entertaining demo in all of produce
I agree they were so cute
hey remember that girl in the first season of produce who cracked on IU's Good Day? that was pretty funny too
right!! i loved the twins so much, i can't wait to see what they do in the future. they were so cute together and the way they had never been apart ahh >_< it was so sad when one of them was voted off and one stayed on, they both cried so hard. i miss them!
8:07 They've lost these three aces🙃
9:32 also ji-a ace it so well , i love their frndshp sm😭
10:34 bora is a cherry bullet member , she debuted that's why she's all arounder❤️
It’s okay Shoen is in BILLLIE now
Also, Kim Dayeon is in Kep1er, so they didn’t lose her
Hope I can find out when Yeyoung debuts (if she does)
The uploader must be really ashamed now that the mnet evil editing of Fu Yaning has been confirmed. Mnet's been expoded to have told Fu Yaning beforehand that they would peform Helicopter and she had to say that line making herself really unconfortable. Smh at all those disgusting people patronizing and bad-talking Fu Yaning. Pathetic
I mean it’s been cleared up in the show anyway
@@colourfulpinks1939 the way you answered looks like you're not even apologetic on hating her..... that's kinda messed up....
@@emmie9102 i literally am but it’s cleared up already
hikaru is the boombayah performance will forever be iconic idc
5:32
long after this video was posted I want to clarify that the staff forced Yaning to say that to Yujin. She did not intend, and because of that evil edit Yenny could not debut, since her image was badly damaged (just like Cai bing)
Remember that all trainees actually met each other beforehand because they had to be assigned songs and divide parts and practice together for these intro performances. Everything was planned
6:49 Their voices are so stable and strong and their dance is so good like WHHAAAt I would have thought that they were a K-pop group already...
2 of them had already been in kpop groups before the show
Im kinda obsessed with the Maria performance for no reason at all
"Bahiyyih was the most stable and has the most idol potential"
Hyewon:
They need some likes and pressed moas would support anyone who says bahiyyih is good so it’s clout
I didn't get the point where you know the evil editing of Mnet and still fall for Helicopter stage drama...
Because people can still have bad attitudes in general 🤷♀️also I wasn’t aware that mnet was specifically evil editing Chinese trainees at the time
Seungeun part 😭😭 everyone become gay after watching her performance
The one's who dance maria by hwasa was so good 😩 ngl
I’m not surprised that it turned out Mnet chose their audition songs
Pop Stars was the best performance for me. Dayeon killed it and I'm so dissapoited Suyeon didn't debut
The way this video was done before the reality show ended, and yet you especially praised the girls who in the future would make their debut😭😭😭 And you even praised the girls who finished gp999 in the top 18--- I would be proud honestly
I didn’t even realise that lmao 😭
everyone stood out in "crazy", just a few trainings in each individual but theyre basically perfect and idol-like already
Twinkle girls are top tier vocalists of the show tho
this is funny bc one of the twins said that the whole yujin and yaning scene was planned by mnet (not defending fyn, as far as i know shes problematic)
Fu yaning said in a live that she was told to say that line which is why she did so, and the girl that sang Siren also stated in a live that she was told to sing that song and when she asked to change it (again) she was told she couldn't
wow thing literally marked me as a person when i first watched it like they were soooo good like they even added some ad-libs that the og song didnt have and they fit so well
Dumdi Dumdi duo was one of the best and Pop stars was extremely good and one of the best
Moana is dope... if we including that fact that Mnet throw Boa's song for her solo, barely get water to drink, and she even manage to choreograph by herself...
omg thank you for talking about moana!!! she did so well despite her disadvantages i love her sm
Bubble pop is way too high for third, and paradise lost was a top 10 perf...
not rlly..yujin slayed
@@colourfulpinks1939 she's good but not really a standout. I think its at least in the top 7 but not top 3.
@@crudojoshuaricofort8795 she rlly stood out to me.. she was jumping while singing and she was stable and charming
when u know real reason behind yanings "we go up but u dont"🙂
Thank you for ranking Su Ruiqi in the top 10! 🥺 She deserves the world, mnet evil edited her but that will not hinder her dream, she released a song "PHOENIX" after GP999 and she debuted Phoenix in Japan!! She worked really hard, please try to listen to her new somg Phoenix (about her hardships) and her old songs especially "See The Light" she's such a gem 🥹🫶🏻💍
I'm tired tht everyone keeps saying tht hiyyih did the best in Mr CHU... I know tht she is good but hyewons voice is the most stable and dancing is on point too...
no. 21 im a kep1er stan but how can you forget about hyewon..? she's the most stable and literally carried the whole performance.. did you even watch the whole video..? um
I loved hyewon aswell but she didn’t stand out to me as much as bahiyyih
@@colourfulpinks1939 oh but anyway i respect your opinion
The name for Kawaguchi Yurina is not Furina
3:33 Imagine being given a song thats 1.) Hard to sing live w choreography 2.) Infront of the artist who did it originally 3.) and without any choice since mnet chose the songs for each contestant
Wow Thing perf should be top 5 at most
fu yaning was forced to say hateful things as she explained in an interview and i dont believe anyone would be arrogant during competitions-
I really hate creators when they insist that BAHYYIH brought and was the most stable in the demo stage... LEE HYEWON was the best there not hyyih
Black Mamba voicecrack its true though, i would put that perfomances like top 16 just because on Jeongmin and Yunji being queens, because if just Chaehyun perfomed this and failed the highnote, this would be 26 probably
Mr Chu Team actually all are stable except for one girl(and Hyewon is the most stable of that time and who have the most star quality)
blackpink songs are really hard to cover, because you have to know whenever you need to give it all and when to chill. when the best drops you have give out pure power into it then comeback soft. I'm really impressed with the boombayah team.
Fu yaning revealed that her “diss” to Yujin was actually scripted
How seuogyeon didn’t debut is beyond me like her voice is pure gold and the reason I looked into bandit in the first place
Yeseo shocked me so much. She’s so small and cute but her dancing is extremely good. Her control is everything
8:01 Popstar top 8??? WHAT??? That is top 1 obviously
And Wow thing at 11
1. Pop Stars
2. Wow Thing
Its so funny to me how shows make the contestants do this and later when they become idols companies make them sing with pre-recorded lives
0:29 love the Momoko praise
Reina,Her dancing is so charismatic and her vocal so good❤
actually in most talent shows like this, auditionees cannot chose and perform the song they want. the program/producers chose for them. it was mentioned on one of get real podcast episode with heejun.
+ the girls themselves explained that they just received the songs and tried to suck it with all their best
OMG HER VOICE IS SO CUTE!!!! The whole group snapped!!! 7:53
Info!! Yeyoung has debut this year with Geenius
U call out evil editing but u believe that fu yaning was arrogant. Like why be hypocritical but call out msnake
This was 2 months ago…
Bahiyyih and Hyewon carried their whole performance.
Fu Yaning didn't done nothing wrong at all it's just Mnet 1 said to her to say something like that 2 The edit did everything Fu Yaning and Yujin got pretty close through the show and Yujin didn't take it wrong and the insult isn't even that harsh since she said "I go up but you don't" Yujin already got up and Yaning was just beginning so nothing wrong (:
0:53 mnet choose all the songs conveniently
Fun fact that The contestants can’t choose their own song,Mnet have a choice to give a easier song to The more favorable contestant
5:35 everything was planned by mnet, Yaning is not arrogant
Jia and youngeun KILLED IT ✨
I don't blame you for writing it in the video, as many people don't know (and how will we ever learn if nobody gives us the heads up?) so it's a common misconception about the song. But just a heads up-- "Whatta Man" is actually NOT originally by Salt and Pepa + En Vogue! They were actually covering Linda Lyndell's song "What a Man" from the 1960's!! So, we've had many artists now, across various generations + from many backgrounds reimagine the song and it's very cool
7:23 actually the ver aired on gp999 is the correct one and they actually auto tuned her voice in this version so it doesn’t sound as bad. She’s super talented but mistakes happen!
Si estaba editado la versión del episodio, es obvio como tomar ese mili segundo ene l que su voz casi se rompe y alargan ese flacmento haciendo que us voz suene desafinada