Shattered: Inside Hillary Clinton’s Doomed Campaign
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ส.ค. 2024
- Amie Parnes and Jonathan Allen, The New York Times bestselling authors of Shattered: Inside Hillary Clinton's Doomed Campaign, give a gripping postmortem of Hillary Clinton’s fraught 2016 presidential run.
Jonathan Allen, head of content for Sidewire, and Amie Parnes, Senior White House Correspondent, The Hill, detail never-before-heard stories of how the lack of a clear campaign message, the internal conflict among Clinton operatives and Clinton’s inability to understand the 2016 electorate led to a loss that shocked the nation. Jonathan Alter, award-winning author and reporter, moderates.
Recorded at 92Y on September 10, 2017.
Subscribe for more videos like this: bit.ly/1GpwawV
Your support helps us keep our content free for all. Donate now: www.92y.org/don...
Facebook: / 92ndstreety
Instagram: / 92ndstreety
Twitter: / 92y
Tumblr: / 92y
On Demand: www.92yondemand...
Pretty easy to win a debate when CNN gives her the questions ahead of time.
*266 days till the 2020 election!!! TRUMP 2020*
Did CNN feed these questions to the interviewer?
It's was brilliant seen her lose ha ha she just couldn't take it and after the way she kept saying if trump didn't win he wouldn't accept the great democratic system she's just an evil witch
@@josedcarrillo24 Hillary lost!
Well lets help a gem of a quest iontv @alyssahaddish
#questionary
#penmanship
#politicartunesafter😭
#stedmanclinton
#jodyarius
#romandatingcampus
#chelseafifahearts
#billforassylumask
#iheartbill
#he was president why 1st lady get secret service in divorce proceedings
1 & 2 & 3 mockarena.
Question democracy is🤷 under your skin fun.
3:11: "Did she not know why she was running for president?
"That's not our conclusion, that's the conclusion of the people who worked for her"
This is one of most, if not the most telling reason why she lost. If you don't know why you're running for president, you have no business running for president, and will most certainly lose.
Her secondary reason for running; I sit when I pee!
After she lost to Obama in 2008, she was so angry that she threatened to destroy the Democratic Party. That's why the party plowed the field for her in 2016: nobody was allowed to run against her, and very good potential Democrat candidates like Harry Reid retired from politics instead because they knew they weren't allowed to join the primary. So basically, she was running because she lost in 2008 and the party was making it up to her. That was her only reason.
@@Hastur876 A reason; not the only reason.
These ppl are clueless.
100%
“She beat bernie in the debate and bam bernie comes out of nowhere.”
Sounds to me like she lost that debate m8.
💯
It is a common feature of organised charities that 80% is spent on wages, travel, hotels, advertising, rent, etc. Only 20% goes to the needy, the objects of peoples giving. The Clinton Foundation was a tax free way to privide a great lifestyle. Never donate to organised charities. Give direct to the needy.
Wages are actually part of the charity itself. You're paying for those workers to deliver the goods to these people.
Russian
It amazing how these people just don't get that 'making your message resonate' does not mitigate being a crook, a liar and a felon.
C. A. G.
And they never will sometimes you just can't FIX STUPID‼️‼️🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
They are talking about politicians, is that not a given? Don’t think she’s been to jail though.
Not the first person to say that “they got their asses chewed out by Bill Clinton” 😂
777
Secret service everybody knows a woman takes half your money and all your 🐱(pussy) when she leaves. #secretservice
you are packaged somewhere else in privates.
Lucky you got away with free willy & the boys after menapause & woman man bashing.
#hilarywivematterbookclub
None of them could see it. They didn't want to see it. They still don't want to see it.
She thought the news media was unfair to her? Exactly what kind of treatment did she expect? Obama's?
That's hilarious the horrible treatment of not only Trump but his supporters were treated so badly. Call terrible names racist, stupid, uneducated and blah blah blah. Even that night after after she lost we were called horrible names.
it is different. Trumps power to fire his FBI director is absolute. He doesn't need a reason. The Clinton/Lynch meeting is way worse
Mr. Allen hasn't missed a meal and Ms. Parnes has nice boots. But I love the interviewers comment about the press "badly exaggerated" stories about Bill Clinton's character flaws and Hillary "had been beaten up so badly by the press". Holy Christ! They never laid a glove on her. It was the press that anointed her. The press was the problem because they never tested her. She never gave interviews or press conferences. She was a paranoid lunatic. The email server which was arguably her undoing was a self inflicted wound. She knew it was wrong when she did it and she did it for the very reason that she wanted to shake down people and didn't want anyone to know about it. Basically the Richard Nixon of the left. If the press had gone after her from the git go she would never have been elected dog catcher. People forget how vicious she was to Obama back in 2008.
Their pro-Hilary bias is clearly apparent
Pretty good economy?..? Where was this guy living? Just because they kept telling us the economy was improving, it was only improving for 1percent. Almost destroyed the middle class.
He explained himself.
She had the questions in advance of the debate. Gee, why did she do well?
trump crushed her in the 2nd debate. even Frank Luntz focus group showed that.
Talk about delusional.
that's it, keep re-litigating a done deal... oy vey, i hope people didn't pay to hear these same excuses.
media failed to press issues that a special prosecutor now has to sort out, that's what happened.
"Improving and reasonably good economy not good for everybody I understand" a comment by Mr. Allen that crystalizes why Trump was elected. Let them eat cake.
i notice something interesting here, the reporters don't really like Hillary.
Noticed that liberal-leaning media types will ask, "What could Democrats do..." or "Who should Democrats nominate to run in 2020?" They make it seem like Democrats have no clue... and its probably true.
The level of disconnected these people are from the public is ASTOUNDING!
These two insiders - with connections into the tentacles of the Hillary campaign are what - disconnected? Hell no. I am so impressed at how well researched and fact checked these assessments are.
@@lynnemiller3633 Soooooo, Hillary Clinton is “…the public…”? 🤣🤣 Come on, now. Stop it.
@@ItsTimeToFITE I think the host is disconnected from the public.
Yes hilary is padma@ public & free willy was private email stroking his ego. A pattern here @peter sellersberg traveling & selling pipe fitting & plumbing while beavis & buthead do america mormon mission brought them to sell propane & propane accessories i n ARLEN TX THERES REAGANOMICS FOOL SPECTRUM.
#RODHAMWINSLOW
And the Democrats still don't get it!!!
WHAT ECONOMIC MESSAGE?? Raising taxes, open borders, putting coal miners out of work is NOT a positive economic message!
RIP Seth Rich.
How did Seth Rich die? When are we getting the full scoop?
The host demonstrates clearly why they didn't get it then, don't get it now and will lose again in 2020. Calling Trump supporters stupid, pardon me, implying that they're stupid. Repeating once again that she should have tried to gain sympathy. All the the gross irony of that aside, they still don't get it; we don't want a President who needs sympathy, we want a leader.
The grave stupidity of this host is astounding. The two authors are interesting though.
Those pant suits didn’t help her as well as she had zero vision
Is this a interview or a intervention.
Hillary needs a intervention, i am sure GITMO can help with that...
Jonathan Alter thinks pushing his reading glasses down to the tip of his nose fools us into believing he is intelligent. It doesn't.
Ken Hiett
No STUPID IS STILL STUPID‼️🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Poster child for the term pseudointellectual
I found Allen's trivialization of the Lynch-Bill Clinton meeting on the tarmac and his premise that HRC clearly won all three debates extremely questionable.
This interviwer has such a smug face he reminds me of those people who smell their own farts from that south park episode
I guess the large man forgot Hillary’s Goldman Sachs speech where she said it was necessary to have a public and private view on issues.
He mentioned it in other interviews. Relax.
They can't give up their lefty views come through.
OK, never mind, around 41:00, they all become idiots.
But the host definitely wins the award for being the sycophantic of all.
This was hard to watch.
OMG... JON ALTER says, while FOREVER & ALWAYS DEFENDING HILLARY, "When you look at what Trump does every day, the PRIVATE EMAIL SERVER DOESN'T KNOCK MY SOCKS OFF." Are you KIDDING? Classified data & correspondence don't need to be protected? What a CLOWN...!!!!
Tubby said Hillary won all three debates, I guess tubby forgot the debate where trump brought the house down w the “cuz you’d be in jail” comment!!
Omg,one line that some drunk would say in a bar, wins a debate? Deplorable
Soon, very soon, we're all going to see just how narrowly we avoided utter disaster.
We did not.
She is a horrible excuse for a human being -- she would send me to a political reform prison.
moderator made this about himself
These two are playing to the audience...sad they can't just be neutral
Liberals making excuses for liberals.
I didn't know this book was written in 2014-15.
Journalism is still ALIVE.
America LOVES TRUMP.
It's fascinating that they still don't understand why.
Bad chair for Allen.
When Hitlery commits a crime it's OKAY!!!! But, when Trump coughs it a terrible CRIME!!!!!!!!!!
Trump goes to jail the prison never eat so well his grampa built it.
They be trying to keep him prisoners would best cojugals models.
#primokeistering
STREET CREDS AS COOL BIDEN TOO!
Watching in 2020 and the US job figures and economy are the best ever - so much for "Trump far worse for the country than she would be" - go Donald!
How did that turn out for you?
@@tomjones5650 it would have been fine if Trump had closed the border to China when he wanted to but others were calling him racist.
These people really drank the Hillary Kool Aid. Wow.
God, when are people going to get over that she had so many flaws and would have made the worse president in my lifetime next to Obama.
Bill Roda
Just another continuation
Of Obama and a THIRD WORLD COUNTRY ‼️‼️‼️🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Obama was worse than Jimmy Carter? Worse than Gerald Ford?
Omg, red shoes, on purpose?
Wow, cant be anymore biased as a moderator.. so happy she is not the P
Leo Chang
Leo we and millions of others are just as glad ‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
There but for the grace of God....
the reason for a failed campaign is always rhetorical incompetence... never that maybe people just disagreed on the message..
Inputance as a lame duck try that a while.2nd place
What is wrong with these people?
MAGA MAGA MAGA
Hillary says she lost because of sexism...what a joke.
She did; her campaign was built on it and this turned people off.
I sit when I pee, so vote for me! HRC
Exactly. She had nothing. I kept waiting for her to say how she was going to help Americans, but then she just partied with Beyonce.
Trump is polarizing but Hillary is hard to like, listen to, and believe.
Hokey Wolf
Because she is a NARCISSIST
AND AN UNMITIGATED ASS‼️‼️‼️🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Her and that gravely by design voice!
Ugh, I know! So many young women speak like that, and it's so damaging to their vocal folds!
That’s Normie from Cheers on the left and next to him is Jennifer Aniston‘s older smarter sister.
The authors are liberal sympathizers. The tone of the book (as well as their interviews) is very sympathetic towards Hillary. They seem to be always explaining and/or apologizing for Hillary's duplicity and lack of candor. Also, and I think this is key: Hillary could never articulate a reason or a theme for her candidacy. There is a part in the book where Bill and Hillary are verbally chastising the staff because they have not come up with a slogan for her campaign. I'm sorry but, isn't that the candidate's job? More to the point: Isn't that her job? Weather you agreed with Donald Trump or not he at least had a reason for running: Make America great again.
Um, the authors said the very thing you just said.
This interviewer shows so much arrogance what does he mean when he says why didn’t Bernie supporters vote for Hillary and the DCCC because they couldn’t stomach her and them shaming voters instead of the candidate and the group that enabled her. God
thank god this criminal lost & I would never vote for Trump
Correct, and Alter doesn’t mention that more disgruntled Bernie folks voted for Clinton in 2016, than disgruntled Clinton supporters voted for Obama in ‘08.
No we didn't think "unfit" meant being fat. As a deplorable, I thought Clinton was unfit to be President. I always thought I would vote for a woman if she ran for President, but I would of voted for Judge Judy before Clinton. Her stance on open borders and illegal immigrants FORCED me, without question to vote for Trump. And...since when does a popular vote win an Presidential election??? Trump won 30 out of 48 states. So why even bring it up? A little unbiased aren't we?
sableblonde
I would have voted for LASIE and OLIVE OIL before I'd vote for CLINTON‼️‼️🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
So you felt that you were one of the half of Trump's supporters who were in the basket of deplorables? Because you're aware she did say "half", right?
Thankyou Trump....thankyou
Talk about out of touch.......just look at the rallys! The enthusiasm! The USA loves Trump because he loves the USA! And he loves Jesus!
Won the debate against Bernie Sanders?!?! PWHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! What debate?!! GTFOH Lol. She got her behind handed to her REPEATEDLY in the debates. These two are SO disconnected from the public Lol.
The condescension from Jonathan alter is really great. Montclair nj represent
Drain the swamp
This tired little.. I guess that is a pseudo "man," from bsNBC looks like he's melting.
Host: Hillary was not entitled to anyone's vote. Bernie was the leader but they didn't have to follow his lead.
We Sanders supporters are tired of the neoliberalism and at the end of the day, that's what lost. Neoliberalism and the corporatism that she represented to the fullest, the establishment
Bernie is a buffoon
I’m late reading this book, but I started recently.The authors got it right; Clinton felt entitled to be president. He campaign slogan, “I’m with her“, always struck me as the most tone deaf, beltway stupid idea imaginable.
Her pollsters were awful too, they told her she was “competitive“ in Texas and she did a campaign rally in the last week, but they also told her Wisconsin was in the bag, so she didn’t campaign there, even when the Wisconsin Democratic committee were begging to come. The Clinton campaign was run by the worst out-of-touch Beltway thinkers you could conceive of. An A-team of our-of-touch incompetents.
she failed to define her goals for the country clearly and precisely. she was too superficial and not confidence.
Did you forget when she was calling the voters horrible terrible names? The people that could vote for her she called them irredeemable and deplorable. I don't believe those people are going to vote for you after you do that.
I always thought that comment was taken out of context. She was talking about a specific group that hates everybody. On the other hand, Trump called everyone he didn’t like even worse names, grabbed women by the p#€€¥, referred to Dems as disgusting and got elected. Go figure.
"Fresh Blood". Like the Red Shoes?
it is a very good book. This interview is not good because of th interviewer.
I find it telling that the authors talk about they and them as leaders, instead of she and her. If she cannot organize and lead a team during the campaign, it's likely she would not have done well as president either.
“If you’re a woman you can’t win” Tell that to Elizabeth Warren & all the other female senators.
ipadsforautism That's not true a woman could win Hillary Clinton just not a good candidate She was a flawed politician who is out of touch with the American public In a time people were hungry for change in populism But keep in mind Trump is easily defeatable hes not popular and hes not gonna deliver on all his promises Any only thing hes doing is dividing the country
Steven Born your response is ignorant, reread my post you missed it
I know this is old and off subject, but I notice Amy wearing RED SHOES those in the know, know what I'm referring too.
47:05 she's the presidential candidate now!
Amie is interesting but that vocal fry has got to go.
It was a 'bait and switch' campaign anyways. She said she was appointing Bill to fix the economy. What was your vp going to do?! It was too screwy.
"The Clinton Foundation does alot of great things" lol
Watch these guys at Princeton and Syracuse. Those videos are much better.
Watch the Clinton Chonicles, you could never think Hilary and Bill were so evil, Thank you God for not letting her win, there both crooks and murderers, and Chelsea is not even his daughter, she's Webb Hubbels, she looks just like Webb, she couldn't even do that right
Amie and Jonathan, great book, good job! Host is a poster-child for pseudo-intellectual lightweight. Love the red boots Amie, rock on and trust your reporting instincts.
The moderator is unbearable 😒
Hahahaha
Ppl love to ask SJP ( a lovely ppl even tho she's a demo), "why the long face"- what do u call that red-shoe-ed monstrosity, Dems?
I love seeing them sti Triggered over Bernie's power, we love to see it💁🏻♂️
At this point, what difference does it make..........😃
The "journalist" references the polls showed HRC won the debates? Yeah, go ahead and keep referencing those spot on partisan polls. lol
It’s because she is paranoid.
Well they were wrong about Harris, heh.
Hindsight is wonderful but this armchair bourgeois advice is what lost it for her.
No, people like Senator Warren, hell, all sorts of people like her. No, we’re going with this woman who’s plain disliked by everyone! That’s right, her! That’s who we’ve decided to run!
Use the guy that Voters LOVED as Vice? Team them up? No way! We found a Republican-Lite named Tim Kaine to run with her, and we’re ignoring everyone and everything that those shittty “ultra-liberal” kids want (which of course we all enjoyed, whew! Thank God for free college!)...no, no. Not at all. Message? No! We don’t need one!
#StaySmarmy
#I’mWithSnide!
#PrivatePositionsVsPublicPositions
44:53 - Amie Parnes is forced to choose who to criticize: Clintons or Obama. Observe how long she pauses before prevaricating.
Wow Still don’t stand the Truth
So this was a way to make $$$$$$ about their failure to win......lol
These two authors are good people..jonathan is trying to get them to.make excuses for Hilliary..this a public forum
.not fair
The guy in the banana suit is a big liar. Doesn't know basic facts. Undermines his whole credibility.
We are forgetting that Hilary won popular vote by about 3 Million votes and lost by 74,000 votes in three states - Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. She did not even go to visit Wisconsin. We are also forgetting about Wiener crotch photos that were reason for re-opening email investigation 11 days ahead of the election. Hilary got "screwed up" by Bill and his alliances with the other women and by Wiener and his crotch photos.
No, you are forgetting that there are 49 other states besides California. Clinton lost 30 of them.
"BTFO" would have been a better title.
"Metaphorically!" Lol *266 days till the 2020 election!!! TRUMP 2020*
At 50:401, "She could have killed him (President Donald Trump), ha, ha, ha, ha, gut laughs, haw, haw, haw!!!". She will probably still, literally, try to! She is capable of anything.
JC Smith
Oh my GOD such a TRUE
STATEMENT ‼️‼️🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸