He's well spoken, but he's being purposefully misleading. The TTP is attacking Pakistan from Afghanistan, and the Afghan taliban is openly helping them, they're not even trying to keep it a secret. For him to say that Pakistan doesn't have the right to prevent attacks on its soil launched from Afghanistan is absolutely a lie.
Especially when you consider Afghanistan is a country led by a band of illiterate caveman that were used as cannon fodder against the Soviet invasion. 😂
This regions advocacy is not as simple as it appears. This area has been hot 🔥 since ancient times and Accent has nothing to do with what each region wants or needs. Shifting locative power both sectarian and political around this region, along with displaced emigrated population back to country of origin has made the situation more chaotic. Lot going on in this region.
If you call pointing finger at others,and not having the decency to remember ur own wrong doings, not remembering that ur own 4 fingers points back at you, than ok agree with,these talibans talks about following Islam,they made some promises, that they did not follow, Pakistan army made these talibans, if Pakistan army really wanted to harm the talibans, they would do it with out any issue, talibans are using ttp, bla as a bargaining chip,not forgetting Indian proxy terrorism against both countries and its citizens
Mirzasaad haram if pakistan is so nar then take his land sacchin gargill jammu kashmeer from india second pakistan i pashthon 90%wants to live with afghanistan not with punjabi pakistan so this dream of punjot never become true till day of judgement inshallah
@@bunchofcells We Indians have always extended a helping hand to Afghanistan in its journey of rebuilding and progress. Whenever there is a food shortage, we send them wheat to ensure no one goes hungry. We contribute to their infrastructure by building dams, schools, and hospitals, providing the foundation for sustainable development. Afghan students are welcomed in India to pursue higher education, gaining knowledge and skills that empower them to contribute to their nation’s growth. Additionally, India has consistently supported Afghanistan in times of crisis, offering humanitarian aid and technical expertise. Cultural exchanges and people-to-people connections further strengthen our bond, highlighting a relationship built on trust, mutual respect, and shared history. Our efforts reflect India’s commitment to being a reliable and compassionate partner in Afghanistan's progress. Pakistanis have been killing their civilians since 80s. What do you expect from Afghans ..chocolates?
I am ashamed of you who does not care about Pakistanis forces killings. Learn about gorilla war then draw your opinion for who is to blame for civilians casualties. 😡
@Freespch get lost we pashtuns are there target since independence of Pakistan! The army kills innocent and blame us for it and then kills more innocent people
Pakistani rulers and generals have always been fake and greedy except Liaqat Ali Khan, general Ayub Khan, general Zia ul Haq and maybe Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, and of course IMRAN KHAN. May Allah Subhanah Ta'alah grant Imran Khan long and healthy life and may Allah grant Imran's wish to make Pakistani citizens independent and proud.....Ameen❤❤❤ LAA'NAT on the fraudsters and liars and the corrupts and Zaalims who are ruling and corroborating with each other at present.❤
As a Pakistani, I believe that what the Taliban are doing to Pakistan today is the result of Pakistan's past actions. In 1979, when the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan, the United States, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan collectively brainwashed madrassa students and encouraged them to participate in the Afghan jihad. In this way, these three countries succeeded in driving the Soviet Union out of Afghanistan. However, they failed to decide what to do with the Taliban afterward. The same Taliban later inflicted a humiliating defeat on the United States after a 20-year war in Afghanistan. While the U.S. only suffered economic losses, Pakistan has endured countless economic, social, financial, and human losses, which are far from being resolved anytime soon.
US was only defeated once, in Korean war. Other than that, all their wars had objectives differant to what they publically stated. Afghanistan was about dope and giving cover for China to take control of 3 trillion dollars in mineral rescouces to take over the world once the deep state in US destroys America.. Iraq was about creating a land corridor so Irael and Iran could have war of Biblical End Times by eliminating Sadam.
The United States crushed the Taliban in every major military battle. Way more Tablian died then Americans. The American people did not want to be in Afghanistan. The war was not popular, and that is why the americans left. If the Americans wanted to stay they would still be in Afghanistan. Read a book once in a while.
@@Fun-facts143 Afghans were never loyal to Pakistan, they Invaded Pakistan with full force during 1961 , It has nothing to do with Soviet Invasion or Afghan Jihad. They hated Pakistan since beginning while eating and living in Pakistan as refuge
I am from Saudi Arabia and I support our innocent Afghan brothers............PKstan cannot be trusted, hence we have stopped issuing visas to their nationals
Thank you brother pakistan is a fake state plus pakistan was created by British empire on Afghan and Indian land fuckistani was made to create problems in the region and for Islam fuckistan army is puppet army and slave army of America and west.
As a Pakistani, I can not support the strikes they carried out. Firstly, they should've defended their posts and border. Secondly, bombing carelessly like that makes you as bad as the israelis.
Jonny! Do you know who your father is? let me guess, are you from one of those countries who ran like a mad dog from Afghanistan? If yes than do you know your soliders used to wear nappies while posted in the areas in question. So shut up
what are you talking about? they have to focus after those people attack on civilian and military establishment almost every week.....it is one of the nuclear powers not a puppet states like india
The Taliban did not say they attacked Pakistan, but that they carried out attacks in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and that they do not consider this region to be part of Pakistan!
Because they want money from USA so that they can give there imf loans the military of Pakistan is in control of everything and they killed a lot of pashtons and baloch people so most of the people want freedom from this military regime
Pak army selects the country’s so called Prime minister with the single most important aim of raising funds by begging around the world just for supporting the army’s lavish lifestyle
and who elected Afghanistans leaders? Who elected Khamenai in Iran? Who elected Xi in China? who keeps electing mass murderer Modi? We are proud of Pakistan army, it removes criminals for us, we love our military.
Wonder why Al-Jazeera lacks the guts to mention "China Administered Tibet" like they do for Kashmir? Hypocrisy such as this takes away your credibility.
TTP "tehreek-e-taliban-pakistan", pakistan army itself created TTP, trained them, deployed them, now they are blaming afghanistan and others for all the mess. They can never admit the truth.😂🤣
The term “Afghan” is/was used to represent the diverse ethnicities living in Afghanistan (Pashtuns, Tajiks, Baloch, and Uzbeks) However, when discussing the Durand Line, the argument is often framed exclusively from a Pashtun perspective, equating “Afghan” with “Pashtun,” as Pashtuns inhabit both sides of the border By this logic, Uzbekistan could claim all Uzbek-majority territories in Afghanistan, and Tajikistan could do the same for Tajik-majority regions etc. This selective reasoning highlights clear hypocrisy from Afghans
@@saadali5689 thats not true at all. The term “Afghan” was used to describe the Pathans or Pasthuns that inhabited that area. Taiks, Uzbeks, and others immigrated to Afghanistan from their own lands creating what is modern day Afghanistan. It’s been a melting pot of cultures that fused and transformed into whats Afghanistan today. But the original Afghan was the ancient Pathan or whats known today as Pashtuns. Many Tajiks fled to Afghanistan in the early 1800s and early 1900s when the Russians invaded.
Uzbeks and Tajiks have nothing to do with people north of the border, thats why no one fought to join them in 43 years of war. Pakistan on the other hand lost 60% of the country after its forces to surrendered in Dacca in 1971. This is because Pakistan is a British construct like Levantine countries Israel and Syria and can actually be partitioned, logically so between India and Afghanistan for Punjabi unity with their indian brethren.
The difference is, that Tajik and Uzbek came to Afghanistan as immigration from those regions that are called today Uzbekistan, Tajikistan. Just talk to some elderly people in badakhshan province they will tell the whole story how some of their forefathers were drowned in in the Amu river while crossing it into Afghanistan.
Its not new for Pakistan to play a double game like they send diplomat for talks n then attack , remember Kargil war , then PM Nawaz Sharif were in India that time 🤨
You're wrong. Nawaz Sharif was in Pakistan. But that was a conspiracy against Pakistan as you saw coup right after kargil venture of Pakistan Army on the orders of a few traitor generals. Pakistan being an atomic power RAW AND MOSSAD conspired against Pakistan 😢
The main issue driving the tense relations between Pakistan and Afghanistan is the Durand Line. Pakistan has consistently used religious terrorism as a tool to destabilize Afghanistan, including areas across the Durand Line where Pashtun Afghans reside. Pakistan seeks to eliminate Afghan nationalism by utilizing proxy terrorist groups, possibly believing that this tactic will help maintain weak, anti-nationalist governments in Afghanistan and disrupt the unity of Afghans across the imaginary Durand line. While we may be weak, we will never give up on the dream of reuniting our land and people as one.
afg is already broken. blaming pakistan for the racism in your state is silly. pakistan also has tactical nukes your dream is a wishwash. improve the country you have, the land you have. but you wont.
@@npb1748your country gave bases to Americans to bomb Afghanistan you npc clown you guys also created and funded Isis and Al qaeda we aren’t dumb 😂 you don’t have no nukes everyone knows that you just have the title from your daddy cia to keep India in check 😂
16 Taliban killed 26 injured and 3 Pakistani soldier injured Latest report Pakistan army has given threat to Taliban that if TTP once again from Afghanistan soil than Pakistan will capture Wakhan Corridor
I am Pakhtuns from Pakhtunkwa which is under Pakistani occupation. Pakhtun in Pakhtunkwa don’t recognize this artificial line draw. Across the chest of two Pakhtun Muslim brothers. Pakistan’s mercenary army is dominated by those of Punjabi ethnicity who are the key decision makers. Punjabis helped Sikhs and British over last 200 years just as they helped American- NATO against Pakhtuns in Pakhtunkwa and Afghanistan. I won’t go into the details around The creation of Pakistan in 1947 which was setup as a bulwark for west and pre-requisite for legitimization of UN and creation of Israel in 1948. I don’t agree with Taliban and their policies on various aspect such as education of women. However, on the Durand line issue, Pakhtuns stand with Afghanistan- it is in the right here.
@ that is a Punjabi view.. you played the same game with poor bengalis and you do to Pakhtuns and Balochs.. even 10-15% Pakhtun may serve in this mercenary army means nothing even if core decision makers are Punjabis…Pakhtuns served in the British army as well as being a “martial race” but doesn’t mean anything to us.. it Doesn’t mean that Punjabistan is allowed to make economic gains using Pakhtun blood, lands and steal resources even against the British law system Islamic republic of Pakistan operates under. Do you agree with the business conglomerate the mecernary pak army has setup? Uou disgrace with your generals saying they used proxies and terrorist on Pakhtuns lands? You want brotherly and without visa and culture ties with your Sikh Punjabi cousins but you disagree with my Muslim Pakhtun brother being at peace? Again the old narrative has been debunked that Pakhtuns serve in the army this allows the Punjabi army to divide and conquer Pakhtuns. Punjabistan are very disconnected from Pakhtuns as well as Islam.
Hasan Nisar when angry on napaks: ان کو اپنی بوئی ہوئی ہر فصل کاٹنی پڑے گی ہم بد غلیظ بہ ظفوقات حضور حزمت بیگم الزفرات الحلیم الدمت آپ کے شبیب بن گئے ہیں۔ ہم جہالت میں مگن ہو گئے ہیں بیگم با مشرف بیگم البد الثمریت الکباب شبرستان
PK: "Hmare pechwadon me khufia haath HAH begum uz bamuqammal, mazeed e musalsal" Maulana tariq jamil: Zawalshuda Ghair Mohazab Ghair Tarbiyat qaumon ka yeh masla hai ke apne ilzam auron pe dalte hain Napaks blame others for their own inequities
@JangBahadur-zn1ft Ajeeb--o-gareeb badzehniat:"Dukan pakodon ki....... baatein karodon ki" Napak nakam Ghair Mohazab riasat uz bharpoor pudina - bade jzbe se kalme pad pad ke, tokri bhar ghaas kha kha ke mulk bana tha - LEKIN afsosssssss PK waar gaya: Ya Allah apni habib k sadqe KPK, Balochistan, Sindh ke MAZLOOM muslmano ki madad farma aameen
Problem is neither you nor any country in the world can ever "depend" upon a rogue terror country like pakistan who just one dream in last 7 decades to destroy India and capture kashmir !!!
As a pakistani, i will clearly blame it on pakistani army. Pakistani army is always looking for a war but never face to face , but as a third party so that they could get some international money. In a face to face battle , the pakistani army has never won.
Pakistan rejoiced when Taliban took control of Afghanistan as they thought that it will be beneficiary to them. There is no good or bad Taliban dear friends, they are only extremists , somehow it is Pakistan's karma that's hitting them hard .
Taliban was created by Pakistan to destabilize Afghanistan! It’s extremism etc to depopulate Afghanistan of its youths in order for Pakistan to economically control Afghanistan. Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
As a Pakistani, I’m sick and tired of Pakistan Military adventurism. Unless military generals will be punished as war criminals, they’ll keep what they’ve been doing for decades.
Are you blind? Can't you see nefarious agenda of Afghan Taliban and TTP? Are you not aware that Afghanistan don't accept Durand line? Why do you turn blind eye when it comes to sacrifices of our army jawans? Get out of hate and propaganda. If Afghanistan and any other country will harm Pakistan you think we should not respond?
15 million Pashtun live in Afghanistan. 45 million Pashtun live in Pakistan. Its laughable that Afghans want to monopolize the Pashtun identity. If anything, Pashtun of Afghanistan should join Pakistan to unite the Pashtun nationality. No way Pashtun of Pakistan would want to join the God forsaken, perpetually at war Afghanistan. The current situation started when 16 Pashtun soldier of Pakistani border force FC were killed by Afghan backed TTP. Pakistan has had enough of this double game by Afghanistan. From now on, there will be an overwhelming response against the hideouts of TTP in Afghanistan. If this does not stops, i would not be surprised if TTP backers & facilitators in Afghan Taliban will also be held to account. I am astonished at the host. He is surprised at the escalation when Ambassador Sadiq was holding talks in Kabul but not surprised at TTP killing 16 Pakistani Pashtun soldiers when Ambassador was on his way to Kabul for those talks.
Very well said. As a Pashtun from Pakistan, we dont want to be with Afghanistan. There are more persian speaking people in Afghanistan than the pashtuns. Afghans have been fighting with eachother for power from past 500+ years. Brothers killing brothers and all. Recently they have been putting the blame on Pakistan.
@@hshakeem Reality check. Can any Panjabi go and live in north or south waziristan? Or marry a Pushtoon? While Afghans can live there and marry each other. Go start the war. You will see Partition of Pakistan will start. Pashtoons of Pakistan will join Afghanistan or form Pashtoonistan. Live in reality not in fantasy.
America and West should not get involved in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Their aims are to split this region with more fighting. Afghanistan and Pakistan can fight or make peace. Simple
Taliban was created by Pakistan to destabilize Afghanistan! It’s extremism etc to depopulate Afghanistan of its youths in order for Pakistan to economically control Afghanistan. Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
As a person of indian heritage its time for the region to have dialogue for peaceful resolution. This whole sub continent has had hundreds of years of conflict. Need to draw a line and move on for the sake of all the innocent people (Afghanistan, Pakistan, India, Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Bhutan) This region can be incredibly rich and powerful if they work together!
Everyone still trying to provoke the poor Taliban, leave them people alone! Real quick to put a name on them! The people of Afghanistan are wonderful humans!
Obaidullah calling TTP a local terrorist group and scape goating by Pakistan. Maybe he should reread his history in his university. The 2014 Peshawar School massacre by the TTP involved one Chechen, three Arabs and two Afghan terrorists massacring 132 children. So how is this a local Insurgency when 2 Afghan nationals were involved?
You munafik terrorist pakistani! Stop making bulshit lies up! That attack was carried out by your punjabie terrorist army and killed all our Pashtun children
@@sherryp3452 then how did the terrorists escape from Pakistani prison? It was a false flag in order to build public consensus for military operations on Pakhtuns.
remember, Pakistan supported Taliban as a part f Afghan resistance from 1980s when USSR was in Afghanistan, then supported Taliban when Bin Laden was there and fighting against Northen Alliance . Then again supported and kept Taliban alive when US stayed till 2021. Their official Pakistanis ministers on record gave accepted supporting Taliban against US forces . Pak ISI chief was the first foreign dignitary to visit Afghanistan when Taliban won against Afghani Government. He did a big photo-op with tea cups in his hand along with Taliban. Even after all this , Pakistan is getting hammered by same Taliban shows you how flawed Pakistanis foreign policy was and still is.
Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
The fighting a stop wants China buys down to their extortion they don't want them shipping stuff through there without them getting a piece of the action
As an Afghan myself, I love my Pakistani Muslim brothers and Sisters. But I condemn that Pakistani puppet government bombed innocent civilians in Afghan land. We are both brothers in Islam. Love and Respect from Afghanistan to my all my Muslim brothers and sisters in the world. Long Live Islam - Allahu Akbar
Being a Pakistani, Pakistani govt and army is absolutely wrong in this matter. I support Afghanistan in this situation. Shame on Pakistani govt and army..
It doesn't matter it always the policy of the nations surrounding Afghanistan to never allow it to rise. Iran, Pakistan and other countries will never allow Afghanistan to become a threat to it's nation and it's borders. If you where not fighting them it would Iran, if not Iran then Tajikistan, if not them Turkmenistan and so on.
You where spoiled when America invaded Afghanistan. They paid for and took the burnt of your job. But now that America is gone, this what you must do keep the Afghans from invading your country. Other nations will do the same. Afghan is very poor country with really bad resources so the Afghans are always looking to come into your territories. Soon you be supporting opposition groups within Afghanistan.
@HellBot-gi5si national policy doesn't means to control a country by fight, national policy should be based on soft side as well, Afghanistan is not a threat yess there are some concerns with it but it can be handled diplomatically, now Pakistan killed innocent people in Afghanistan and Afghanistan targeted our military, can this handle by such an action as Pakistan is taking against Afghanistan? never.. Being a Pakistani I know the intentions of pak army and present day govt bro..
India will not be happy with a neighbour country lead by these psycho taliban and specially when they get nukes. today's Pakistan is much more stable for india
Well it is not. Listen to Dr. Israr Ahmed (R), he was himself Pakistani. He said Pakistani system is Kafir system made by Lord Michael. He further said, Pakistan was created in the Name of Islam and it has no right if does not implement Islam. He said, Pakistan will be divided and merge in Afghanistan. He predicted many things in the light of Quran and Hadith.
Mr Obedulla I was lecturer too had been teaching overseas. I listened to your presentation and analysis, I am proud of you and Wishing you more successes.
British raj najaz awalad naPak fouj killing pukhtoon and Baloch so they control mineral in KPK and Balochistan. while jealousy from Afghans government on their success. Pakistani public hate naPAK military and consider Afghans as brother.
@relaxingmusic8618 which part of Pakistan ur represent or where u from? Do u have any pain of pukhtoon and Baloch who dies every day and their home is bombed by British raj naPak kuttah fouj.and women kidnapped by ISI n Punjab also killing of muhajar 1992. All is killed by British raj najaz awalad also what is the name 1st army chief
@durgeshsingh5220 joty ki nok pr rkta hon ESI azadi ko jisme koi rule of law nie sirf gharib ki chmrhi utari jaa rhii he.... Azadi nie delayi he, Muslim qom ko 3 tukrho me divide kia he.... Lanat Quaid e Azam and all those landlords who divided the subcontinent for their personal and political goals....
Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
Afgans and Pakistanis, you are two brothers who have stood for each other at tough times. There is Shaitan only who makes you fight each other. And Shaitabs in thiese comments also. So be aware do not die a dirty death.
As as an Afghan, I've seen several skirmishes big and small taking place across the boarder between the state of Afghanistan and Pakistan. I'd say, we should lend ears to each other and provide efficient information for settling all on going hostilities across the border. I want the board of Al Jazeera to hold penal with seniors from political spectrum of both countries.
Both afghanistan and pakistan are sharing their brotherly love ❤️ 😍 💖 for each other. We hope 🙏 that this 🙏 love and feelings increase to a greater level.
Is Afganistan stupid? Pakistan will ruin afghanistan if war, its not americans, pakistan is there forever they live there, their military have kept India in check for decades. Mybe afghanistan should do as pakistan say and talk to the lunatics about it or pay the price.
@mostafasamadi3530we know where you get your power , not from daal but from enjoying young fresh boys and then going to war , afghan civilians should keep their boys safe from the boy loving taliban pedos like you, and as far you taking on Pakistan…. Plz stop being delusional , in minutes your Afghanistan is off the map😂😂😂😂😂 delusions of grandeur , you should thank Pakistan you are not part of Russia right now it’s only because of Pakistan you namak haram
Best foreign policy by Pakistani Generals, India is enemy, now Afghans are enemy, and no friendly relations with Iran either, so all three sides are enemies, only friendly side is south which is Arabian Sea.
Pakistan has become a joker in its political grounds and there is practically Europeans and Americans are functioning the government. Afghans have struggled a lot their democracy.
Let me summarize the difference between Afghan Taliban and Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan for the unversed. * Afghan Taliban: Want an extremely strict Shariah-compliant emirate in AFGHANISTAN. Pakistan fully backs them because it wants an excessively Islamized Afghan society to play second fiddle to itself and serve as its backyard. For Pakistan, the Afghan Taliban are valiant freedom fighters fighting for the real cause of Islam. * Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan: Want an extremely strict Shariah-compliant emirate in PAKISTAN; Pakistan (a country that was incidentally created to uphold Muslim traditions and religious values in the Indian Subcontinent) vigorously opposes them because it does not want the same system for its own people that it wants for the Afghans. For Pakistan, the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan are violent terr0rists defaming Islam. So basically, Pakistan very conveniently contrastingly treats the two Talibans fighting for the same end-goal, albeit in different territories.
Guy's in AL JAZEERA, WHAT PAKISTAN CLAIMS ON AFGHANISTAN IS EXACTLY WHAT INDIA ACCUSES PAKISTAN ON CROSS BORDER TERRORISM FROM THEIR POJK. PAKISTAN IS TREATED BY THEIR OWN MEDICINE 😂
@@rajakhan-lr1yxMughals came from Uzbekistan and later born and died in Modern day Uttarpradesh/Delhi region, they have nothing to do with modern Pakistan.
Another westerner pushing sectarianism ideologies. This neither an ethnic nor a religious issue. The PAK army is funded and supported by UK/US and is abusing local ppl. Just like local ppl revolted against Assad of Syria, so local ppl have been revolting against PAK army.
@@ranveergodara6221 God bless you. When I die and my soul leaves here, I know that any new soul that is born will be as worthy of life here be it hindu, christian or jew. Later hate can attach itself to us like mud. Knowledge gives us the wisdom to clean ourself of hate, like soap and water.
Primary problem is the Durhan line which was made into Pakistan border. This like artificially divided the Pashtun areas into two. Logically Pakistan should have returned these areas to Afghanistan. The problem now is Pakistan has known this from the very beginning, so they have worked overtime in destabilizing Afghanistan from the time of its creation so that the claim can fizzle out or keep Afghan government so weak that they cannot do anything about it.
@@mirzasaadhamza You may have had a point if there was a thing called Pakistan with a national Identity of many within one. But let's be serious, Pakistan is essentially the punjabi in power asking others to serve them or be under their thumb. This has been the case for all of Pakistan's history. This was the reason why Bangladesh broke off. Here is the simplest solution to change Pakistan to what you imagine Pakistan to be. Put in land reform and limit how much land each person can hold. Institute Land redistribution. This will take away the established Pubjabi/Landlord dominance in Pakistan, and the rest will automatically will change.
@@curio78 So here is solution. Merge Afghan Pashtoon areas into Pakistan it will become almost huge Pashtun population in Pakistan. Your complaint of Punjabi majority will also be resolved. You might not know, in Pakistan only two groups hold the power within bureaucracy and politics, number one are Shias and second one are Pashtoons. Rest of all Pakistanis are subjects to Pashtoons or Shias. So I think we need more pashtoons in Pakistan go keep this balance otherwise we are fearing that Pakistan will become another Syria very soon. Syria remained under control of a tiny minority for 53 years and same is feared in case of Pakistan.
The APS tragedy and the subsequent launch of Zarb-e-Azb by the Pakistan Army were pivotal moments in Pakistan’s determined efforts to eliminate terrorism. The operation successfully dismantled the operational capabilities of the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), significantly reducing the militant threat. While global recognition of Pakistan’s sacrifices and efforts has been limited, international powers have nonetheless acknowledged and appreciated Pakistan’s operations, such as Zarb-e-Azb, for their effectiveness in combating terrorism and restoring peace to the region. Furthermore, the success of Zarb-e-Azb has resulted in a dramatic reduction of cross-border terrorism, with such activities now almost nonexistent. However, despite this achievement, the instability in Afghanistan and Central Asia continues to pose challenges. As Afghanistan and its neighboring states, including Pakistan, struggle with political transitions and the rebuilding of both executive and legislative institutions, it becomes increasingly vital to prioritize human rights and regional stability within a broader global framework. Historically, a silent agreement existed between India and Pakistan in the early years after independence, whereby India’s RAW (Research and Analysis Wing) was allowed to collaborate with Pakistan to expel forces from the western borders. Over time, however, this agreement faded, and the strategic interests of both countries diverged. In recent years, Pakistan has faced growing concerns about RAW’s potential to engage in covert operations within its territory. The Foreign Relations Wing of the ISI (Inter-Services Intelligence) plays a crucial role in maintaining diplomatic intelligence and ensuring that external interference, particularly by India, does not destabilize Pakistan. The evolving regional dynamics and the need for strategic foresight demand that ISI’s foreign intelligence wing continues to be vigilant, adhering to the understanding that India’s RAW must not use regional instability as a pretext to deploy activities in Pakistan. In this context, Pakistan has a critical role to play in leading the region out of this crisis. This requires aligning with international norms and frameworks, particularly those articulated within Commonwealth programs. Commonwealth member states have long upheld the principles of democratic governance, human rights, and the rule of law. Programs such as the Commonwealth Charter and the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative provide a foundation for fostering peace, security, and the promotion of human dignity in post-conflict regions. These frameworks encourage member states to collaborate on issues like counterterrorism, human rights protection, and transitional justice, offering pathways for Pakistan and its neighbors to strengthen governance, accountability, and cooperation. By leveraging these Commonwealth-backed legal and policy frameworks, Pakistan can enhance its diplomatic leadership in promoting peace and security, not only within its borders but across the broader region. Furthermore, Pakistan can work alongside both Commonwealth and non-Commonwealth states to ensure that regional conflicts do not escalate into global crises, positioning the country as a proactive, responsible player in international efforts to combat terrorism and protect human rights. This will allow Pakistan to transcend its role as a passive actor and lead efforts to rebuild a more secure and just region, in line with global humanitarian and security goals.
Can someone tell me why the Pakistani government thought that overthrowing the afghan government and replacing them with the Taliban was a good idea? To me it looks like incompetence?
Taliban was created by Pakistan to destabilize Afghanistan! It’s extremism etc to depopulate Afghanistan of its youths in order for Pakistan to economically control Afghanistan. Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
Well Pakistan has the right to retaliate, if for decades Talibans are hitting Pakistan, and now if after so long Pakistan has carried operation, what's wrong with that. Talibans don't want to implement shariat law, they just want a piece of land, cause this isn't according to islam.
Taliban was created by Pakistan to destabilize Afghanistan! It’s extremism etc to depopulate Afghanistan of its youths in order for Pakistan to economically control Afghanistan. Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
Speaking of "War Crimes" the NATO forces killed more Afghan civilians during the 20 years long war waged by NATO in Afghanistan. Were those not war crimes?
UmmahChummah to NapakSHAITANI foj "Goli kyon chalayi.......namaz padne waale ko container se KYON GIRAYA" Napak foj e fquddat kiya 2QaumiBaqwasiat thusssssss: APNE HI mard e mujahid, mard e momineen, sadiq or ameen giraye Pirzada par tashadud, or nasheman pe bijliyan.
The afghan rep is such well spoken and made lot of good points!
He's well spoken, but he's being purposefully misleading. The TTP is attacking Pakistan from Afghanistan, and the Afghan taliban is openly helping them, they're not even trying to keep it a secret.
For him to say that Pakistan doesn't have the right to prevent attacks on its soil launched from Afghanistan is absolutely a lie.
Especially when you consider Afghanistan is a country led by a band of illiterate caveman that were used as cannon fodder against the Soviet invasion. 😂
Yes you right specially if you hear his accent one can understand who is actually playing the game 😂
This regions advocacy is not as simple as it appears. This area has been hot 🔥 since ancient times and Accent has nothing to do with what each region wants or needs.
Shifting locative power both sectarian and political around this region, along with displaced emigrated population back to country of origin has made the situation more chaotic.
Lot going on in this region.
If you call pointing finger at others,and not having the decency to remember ur own wrong doings, not remembering that ur own 4 fingers points back at you, than ok agree with,these talibans talks about following Islam,they made some promises, that they did not follow, Pakistan army made these talibans, if Pakistan army really wanted to harm the talibans, they would do it with out any issue, talibans are using ttp, bla as a bargaining chip,not forgetting Indian proxy terrorism against both countries and its citizens
"Taliban have broken the shackles of slavery!" - ex-Pakistan PM Imran Khan. As you sow, so shall you reap.
they did , and pakistanis will , you dont know nothing
@@aayankhattak384what is there to know 🤔
There is still too much slavery in Islam, needs to end. Both sides are wrong.
80% Pakhtun are in Pakistan and only 20% in Afghanistan. Pakistan should make Afghanistan its province and overthrow Taliban mercenaries.
Mirzasaad haram if pakistan is so nar then take his land sacchin gargill jammu kashmeer from india second pakistan i pashthon 90%wants to live with afghanistan not with punjabi pakistan so this dream of punjot never become true till day of judgement inshallah
Aljazeera who you will side with?afghanistan or pakistan?😂
😂😂😂😂😂
@@emperor615Pakistan army never win war never lose election 😁
dude its a news channel
@@beingsage-t03yah bhi Kah do neutral New channel hai 😁😁😁😁
@@HarshKharwar-jp6nf there is no such kind as neutral in this world, but that doesn't mean we have to pick sides in any conflict.
Indians stand with ours Afghan brothers and sisters.
Yes, the world knows rss is behind this violence
In comment section 😂
@@bunchofcells 🤣🤣
@@Igloo683 I can feel ur pain, but listen, Afghanistan is v weak...
@@bunchofcells We Indians have always extended a helping hand to Afghanistan in its journey of rebuilding and progress. Whenever there is a food shortage, we send them wheat to ensure no one goes hungry. We contribute to their infrastructure by building dams, schools, and hospitals, providing the foundation for sustainable development. Afghan students are welcomed in India to pursue higher education, gaining knowledge and skills that empower them to contribute to their nation’s growth.
Additionally, India has consistently supported Afghanistan in times of crisis, offering humanitarian aid and technical expertise. Cultural exchanges and people-to-people connections further strengthen our bond, highlighting a relationship built on trust, mutual respect, and shared history. Our efforts reflect India’s commitment to being a reliable and compassionate partner in Afghanistan's progress.
Pakistanis have been killing their civilians since 80s. What do you expect from Afghans ..chocolates?
As a Pakistani i condemn the strikes that Pakistan did on Afghan village we are ashamed of our country's government
speak for urself traitor
مر جا بیغیرت مردود
I am ashamed of you who does not care about Pakistanis forces killings. Learn about gorilla war then draw your opinion for who is to blame for civilians casualties. 😡
@Freespch get lost we pashtuns are there target since independence of Pakistan! The army kills innocent and blame us for it and then kills more innocent people
Pakistani rulers and generals have always been fake and greedy except Liaqat Ali Khan, general Ayub Khan, general Zia ul Haq and maybe Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, and of course IMRAN KHAN. May Allah Subhanah Ta'alah grant Imran Khan long and healthy life and may Allah grant Imran's wish to make Pakistani citizens independent and proud.....Ameen❤❤❤ LAA'NAT on the fraudsters and liars and the corrupts and Zaalims who are ruling and corroborating with each other at present.❤
As a Pakistani, I believe that what the Taliban are doing to Pakistan today is the result of Pakistan's past actions. In 1979, when the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan, the United States, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan collectively brainwashed madrassa students and encouraged them to participate in the Afghan jihad. In this way, these three countries succeeded in driving the Soviet Union out of Afghanistan. However, they failed to decide what to do with the Taliban afterward.
The same Taliban later inflicted a humiliating defeat on the United States after a 20-year war in Afghanistan. While the U.S. only suffered economic losses, Pakistan has endured countless economic, social, financial, and human losses, which are far from being resolved anytime soon.
Ram ji had 60k wives, did he have 60k kids? were his wives allowed niyog?
US was only defeated once, in Korean war. Other than that, all their wars had objectives differant to what they publically stated. Afghanistan was about dope and giving cover for China to take control of 3 trillion dollars in mineral rescouces to take over the world once the deep state in US destroys America.. Iraq was about creating a land corridor so Irael and Iran could have war of Biblical End Times by eliminating Sadam.
The United States crushed the Taliban in every major military battle. Way more Tablian died then Americans. The American people did not want to be in Afghanistan. The war was not popular, and that is why the americans left. If the Americans wanted to stay they would still be in Afghanistan. Read a book once in a while.
@@Fun-facts143 Afghans were never loyal to Pakistan, they Invaded Pakistan with full force during 1961 , It has nothing to do with Soviet Invasion or Afghan Jihad.
They hated Pakistan since beginning while eating and living in Pakistan as refuge
@@cornealdata3843That’s the part the non-Americans don’t understand. They are so dumb
I am from Saudi Arabia and I support our innocent Afghan brothers............PKstan cannot be trusted, hence we have stopped issuing visas to their nationals
Thnks for your support inshallah we will be free from this tyranny of Pak istan
You people have no moral standing nor courage you have abandoned Palestinians .You are shameful people feeling afraid from Israel .
Arab colonization destroyed Afghanistan.
Well done sir 👍
@Dawntimes20487 triggered pakistani crying 😂😂
Kurdistan stand with Afghanistan like pakistan support tyrkey
❤❤❤❤❤
Herbiji kurda ❤ from Afghanistan 🇦🇫
Turdistan doesn’t exist
Turkey will never allow Kurdistan and is much stronger than Kurds. So better just live in peace with Turks.
Thank you brother pakistan is a fake state plus pakistan was created by British empire on Afghan and Indian land fuckistani was made to create problems in the region and for Islam fuckistan army is puppet army and slave army of America and west.
This is a double game of Pakistan. They needs dollars from u.s
exactly
@@allparis8067💯👍🙏
Nonsense...so Pakistan attacking Afghanistan for money ( dollars) Ridiculous 😅😅😅
Nit Pakistan but taliban n taliban also take dollars from iran for not doing terrorist activities in iran
Shame on you Afghani Namak Haram... Afghani Taliban are getting heavy Indian funding for supporting TTP.
As a Pakistani, I can not support the strikes they carried out. Firstly, they should've defended their posts and border. Secondly, bombing carelessly like that makes you as bad as the israelis.
They have lot of bombs so they clearing stocks on taliban
U should read about jordanian history.
you are exactly the reason why pak Army is not releasing IK. saale stop spreading anti pakistan rhetoric.
@puraLusa so? Jordanian king is a puppet of west and always supported isreal 🙄
True, Pakistanis are really bad army. How can you kill women, children and civilians. Shame.
I have no respect for puppet states. Pakistan should focus on regaining its sovereignty and less on the Taliban.
Pakistan does not need your respect.
Jonny! Do you know who your father is? let me guess, are you from one of those countries who ran like a mad dog from Afghanistan? If yes than do you know your soliders used to wear nappies while posted in the areas in question. So shut up
Yes I know bro only IMF respect go free kashmir and eat some dall
what are you talking about? they have to focus after those people attack on civilian and military establishment almost every week.....it is one of the nuclear powers not a puppet states like india
@@TalhaTahir-by6nypakistan needs US dollars
The Taliban did not say they attacked Pakistan, but that they carried out attacks in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and that they do not consider this region to be part of Pakistan!
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
When and who said do?
Any proof?
"Goro se Azadi dekar LORO ke haato mein watan de di" - Qaid e Azam.
@@durgeshsingh5220 "Angrezo ki ghulami karna aur railway tracks pe goo karna humara riwaaj hain" - Chandragupta Maurya & Mahatma Gandhi ca. 1942
Irony died a thousand death when that Lady from Foreign Affairs of Pakistan said that they are concerned of Terrorist Hideouts in Afghanistan 😂😂😂
paki hide bin Laden, every body knows this just georg W. Bush ddnot knows this.
Because they want money from USA so that they can give there imf loans the military of Pakistan is in control of everything and they killed a lot of pashtons and baloch people so most of the people want freedom from this military regime
Pak army selects the country’s
so called Prime minister with the single most important aim of raising funds by begging around the world just for supporting the army’s lavish lifestyle
and who elected Afghanistans leaders? Who elected Khamenai in Iran? Who elected Xi in China? who keeps electing mass murderer Modi?
We are proud of Pakistan army, it removes criminals for us, we love our military.
Go to hospital check your brain checked by good doctor
@Questionizer-m7hWhich army !! They don't do anything except running the businesses and raping killing everyone including Baluchis.
@Questionizer-m7hwhy???
@Questionizer-m7hthanks for pizza from USA, papa jones pizza is the best, thanks to Pak army
Wonder why Al-Jazeera lacks the guts to mention "China Administered Tibet" like they do for Kashmir? Hypocrisy such as this takes away your credibility.
Al Jazeera is running on their money 😂
@@amitabhabhattacharya4051 Well Al - Jazeera is near YOUR region , what are you gonna do about it????
TTP "tehreek-e-taliban-pakistan", pakistan army itself created TTP, trained them, deployed them, now they are blaming afghanistan and others for all the mess. They can never admit the truth.😂🤣
You dont have enough brain capacity to understand the truth
The term “Afghan” is/was used to represent the diverse ethnicities living in Afghanistan (Pashtuns, Tajiks, Baloch, and Uzbeks) However, when discussing the Durand Line, the argument is often framed exclusively from a Pashtun perspective, equating “Afghan” with “Pashtun,” as Pashtuns inhabit both sides of the border By this logic, Uzbekistan could claim all Uzbek-majority territories in Afghanistan, and Tajikistan could do the same for Tajik-majority regions etc. This selective reasoning highlights clear hypocrisy from Afghans
@@saadali5689 thats not true at all. The term “Afghan” was used to describe the Pathans or Pasthuns that inhabited that area. Taiks, Uzbeks, and others immigrated to Afghanistan from their own lands creating what is modern day Afghanistan. It’s been a melting pot of cultures that fused and transformed into whats Afghanistan today. But the original Afghan was the ancient Pathan or whats known today as Pashtuns. Many Tajiks fled to Afghanistan in the early 1800s and early 1900s when the Russians invaded.
Uzbeks and Tajiks have nothing to do with people north of the border, thats why no one fought to join them in 43 years of war. Pakistan on the other hand lost 60% of the country after its forces to surrendered in Dacca in 1971. This is because Pakistan is a British construct like Levantine countries Israel and Syria and can actually be partitioned, logically so between India and Afghanistan for Punjabi unity with their indian brethren.
@@saadali5689 actually it's called graveyard of empires
The greatest lie of liberalism is that diversity is a strength.
The difference is, that Tajik and Uzbek came to Afghanistan as immigration from those regions that are called today Uzbekistan, Tajikistan. Just talk to some elderly people in badakhshan province they will tell the whole story how some of their forefathers were drowned in in the Amu river while crossing it into Afghanistan.
Its not new for Pakistan to play a double game like they send diplomat for talks n then attack , remember Kargil war , then PM Nawaz Sharif were in India that time 🤨
Don't you indians have a polluted river to clean up!
Pakistani foreign minister at that time Sha Mehamood Qureshi was in 🇮🇳 india while Pakistan attacked India in Kargil...
Pakistani can not be trusted
Teri behen Ghar Bhi Aaya the Pakistan??
You're wrong. Nawaz Sharif was in Pakistan. But that was a conspiracy against Pakistan as you saw coup right after kargil venture of Pakistan Army on the orders of a few traitor generals. Pakistan being an atomic power RAW AND MOSSAD conspired against Pakistan 😢
The main issue driving the tense relations between Pakistan and Afghanistan is the Durand Line. Pakistan has consistently used religious terrorism as a tool to destabilize Afghanistan, including areas across the Durand Line where Pashtun Afghans reside. Pakistan seeks to eliminate Afghan nationalism by utilizing proxy terrorist groups, possibly believing that this tactic will help maintain weak, anti-nationalist governments in Afghanistan and disrupt the unity of Afghans across the imaginary Durand line. While we may be weak, we will never give up on the dream of reuniting our land and people as one.
Thanks for this info.
@@engr_rahimi96 well explain
afg is already broken. blaming pakistan for the racism in your state is silly. pakistan also has tactical nukes your dream is a wishwash. improve the country you have, the land you have. but you wont.
Nationalist pashtuns wants one regime but there is security law 🖤
@@npb1748your country gave bases to Americans to bomb Afghanistan you npc clown you guys also created and funded Isis and Al qaeda we aren’t dumb 😂 you don’t have no nukes everyone knows that you just have the title from your daddy cia to keep India in check 😂
We urgently need the enforcement of international laws. Otherwise we don't need to talk about war crimes, crimes against humanity or genocide.
The UN is too busy responding to hamas propaganda. So cry all you want to, but please shut up.
16 Taliban killed 26 injured and 3 Pakistani soldier injured
Latest report
Pakistan army has given threat to Taliban that if TTP once again from Afghanistan soil than Pakistan will capture Wakhan Corridor
I am Pakhtuns from Pakhtunkwa which is under Pakistani occupation. Pakhtun in Pakhtunkwa don’t recognize this artificial line draw. Across the chest of two Pakhtun Muslim brothers. Pakistan’s mercenary army is dominated by those of Punjabi ethnicity who are the key decision makers. Punjabis helped Sikhs and British over last 200 years just as they helped American- NATO against Pakhtuns in Pakhtunkwa and Afghanistan.
I won’t go into the details around The creation of Pakistan in 1947 which was setup as a bulwark for west and pre-requisite for legitimization of UN and creation of Israel in 1948.
I don’t agree with Taliban and their policies on various aspect such as education of women. However, on the Durand line issue, Pakhtuns stand with Afghanistan- it is in the right here.
Pashtoons are one Pashtoons. And no one can separate them. As said by khan Abdul Ghafar Khan in 1973 in Kabul. We do not recognise any Duran lines
What about taliban terrorist groups arent they Pakhtuns Ur Unlces Brothers Fathers dont u own them is their Sins washed😂
You are on the right side of history be proud of yourself when you are around so many gul khans who got brainwshed by naghme taraane.
That's funny ...I come from army family and I see half of army is Pashtun 🤦..... Even Musharraf was muhajir
@ that is a Punjabi view.. you played the same game with poor bengalis and you do to Pakhtuns and Balochs.. even 10-15% Pakhtun may serve in this mercenary army means nothing even if core decision makers are Punjabis…Pakhtuns served in the British army as well as being a “martial race” but doesn’t mean anything to us.. it Doesn’t mean that Punjabistan is allowed to make economic gains using Pakhtun blood, lands and steal resources even against the British law system Islamic republic of Pakistan operates under. Do you agree with the business conglomerate the mecernary pak army has setup? Uou disgrace with your generals saying they used proxies and terrorist on Pakhtuns lands? You want brotherly and without visa and culture ties with your Sikh Punjabi cousins but you disagree with my Muslim Pakhtun brother being at peace? Again the old narrative has been debunked that Pakhtuns serve in the army this allows the Punjabi army to divide and conquer Pakhtuns. Punjabistan are very disconnected from Pakhtuns as well as Islam.
We will never see an air strike on the eastern border of Pakistan. Which is the biggest and inception enemy of the country WHY ?
Hasan Nisar when angry on napaks: ان کو اپنی بوئی ہوئی ہر فصل کاٹنی پڑے گی
ہم بد غلیظ بہ ظفوقات حضور حزمت بیگم الزفرات الحلیم الدمت آپ کے شبیب بن گئے ہیں۔
ہم جہالت میں مگن ہو گئے ہیں بیگم با مشرف بیگم البد الثمریت الکباب شبرستان
PK: "Hmare pechwadon me khufia haath HAH begum uz bamuqammal, mazeed e musalsal"
Maulana tariq jamil: Zawalshuda Ghair Mohazab Ghair Tarbiyat qaumon ka yeh masla hai ke apne ilzam auron pe dalte hain
Napaks blame others for their own inequities
@JangBahadur-zn1ft Ajeeb--o-gareeb badzehniat:"Dukan pakodon ki....... baatein karodon ki"
Napak nakam Ghair Mohazab riasat uz bharpoor pudina - bade jzbe se kalme pad pad ke, tokri bhar ghaas kha kha ke mulk bana tha - LEKIN afsosssssss
PK waar gaya: Ya Allah apni habib k sadqe KPK, Balochistan, Sindh ke MAZLOOM muslmano ki madad farma aameen
"Goro se Azadi dekar LORO ke haato mein watan de di" - Qaid e Azam.
Eastern border pe tumhare asli original abbu baithe hain.. Sidhi flight Milti hai waha 72 hoor tak 😂
If Afghan Taliban can defeat NATO. Then why they can not eliminate the TTP? If they can't then we Pakistan has the right to depend ourselves.
I mean...The Taliban just toppled the developing Afgan government after NATO forces left Afghanistan.
@randombritishperson. Left???
Or frustrated and run away.
Achieved nothing in loss of 3000 billion dollar and 100 of thousands died in 20 year of war.
😂they left not defeated. Bin Laden was killed.
Problem is neither you nor any country in the world can ever "depend" upon a rogue terror country like pakistan who just one dream in last 7 decades to destroy India and capture kashmir !!!
It was Pakistan who defeated the soviet with the help of US and US with the help of US 😂😂❤❤
As a pakistani, i will clearly blame it on pakistani army. Pakistani army is always looking for a war but never face to face , but as a third party so that they could get some international money. In a face to face battle , the pakistani army has never won.
"Goro se Azadi dekar LORO ke haato mein watan de di" - Qaid e Azam.
Noxious two faced looter army looting its own people since the false nation was created
Pakistan rejoiced when Taliban took control of Afghanistan as they thought that it will be beneficiary to them. There is no good or bad Taliban dear friends, they are only extremists , somehow it is Pakistan's karma that's hitting them hard .
tik tok... time is close benchooot
Taliban was created by Pakistan to destabilize Afghanistan! It’s extremism etc to depopulate Afghanistan of its youths in order for Pakistan to economically control Afghanistan.
Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
You're right ✅💯❤️
@eanayatullahasad2341 Get out of Pakistan 🇵🇰 Afghani Namak Haram....
As a Pakistani, I’m sick and tired of Pakistan Military adventurism. Unless military generals will be punished as war criminals, they’ll keep what they’ve been doing for decades.
Are you blind? Can't you see nefarious agenda of Afghan Taliban and TTP? Are you not aware that Afghanistan don't accept Durand line?
Why do you turn blind eye when it comes to sacrifices of our army jawans?
Get out of hate and propaganda.
If Afghanistan and any other country will harm Pakistan you think we should not respond?
People like you should be punished by spreading fake news and fitna?
@@physicistandmathematician5770then dont go begging to IMF,.send your mashallah Pak army to run your country, stop licking your pak army
You have been poisoned against your army
You wil literally condemn pak army even if its not their mistake
peace vs peace = masterpeace
15 million Pashtun live in Afghanistan.
45 million Pashtun live in Pakistan.
Its laughable that Afghans want to monopolize the Pashtun identity. If anything, Pashtun of Afghanistan should join Pakistan to unite the Pashtun nationality. No way Pashtun of Pakistan would want to join the God forsaken, perpetually at war Afghanistan.
The current situation started when 16 Pashtun soldier of Pakistani border force FC were killed by Afghan backed TTP. Pakistan has had enough of this double game by Afghanistan. From now on, there will be an overwhelming response against the hideouts of TTP in Afghanistan. If this does not stops, i would not be surprised if TTP backers & facilitators in Afghan Taliban will also be held to account.
I am astonished at the host. He is surprised at the escalation when Ambassador Sadiq was holding talks in Kabul but not surprised at TTP killing 16 Pakistani Pashtun soldiers when Ambassador was on his way to Kabul for those talks.
Very well said.
As a Pashtun from Pakistan, we dont want to be with Afghanistan. There are more persian speaking people in Afghanistan than the pashtuns.
Afghans have been fighting with eachother for power from past 500+ years. Brothers killing brothers and all. Recently they have been putting the blame on Pakistan.
Gulkhan punjabie puppets you living on occupied land of afghanistan which is peshawar punjabies won't accept you have no country to go to
Pakisatan is an artificial country with no future with the likes of island owning General Ranis…
@@hshakeem Reality check. Can any Panjabi go and live in north or south waziristan? Or marry a Pushtoon? While Afghans can live there and marry each other. Go start the war. You will see Partition of Pakistan will start. Pashtoons of Pakistan will join Afghanistan or form Pashtoonistan. Live in reality not in fantasy.
@@decaf8126
stay as a slave of Punjabis until death Freedom is not for you
America and West should not get involved in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Their aims are to split this region with more fighting. Afghanistan and Pakistan can fight or make peace. Simple
The entire Islamic world is in a heat.
Some new babies will be born.
@captainnemo8072 :-)
Colonial Racist countries have destabilized the world. Dimwitted citizens in the west are not smart enough to realize it.
Britain has invented one thing in the history of mankind. And that is 'Border dispute'. 😅😆
"When you keep snakes in your backyard don't think it will only bite your neighbours".....the words that will haunt pakistan forever
And you lindus should stop harbouring terrorists BJP too
Taliban was created by Pakistan to destabilize Afghanistan! It’s extremism etc to depopulate Afghanistan of its youths in order for Pakistan to economically control Afghanistan.
Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
As a person of indian heritage its time for the region to have dialogue for peaceful resolution. This whole sub continent has had hundreds of years of conflict. Need to draw a line and move on for the sake of all the innocent people (Afghanistan, Pakistan, India, Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Bhutan)
This region can be incredibly rich and powerful if they work together!
Everyone still trying to provoke the poor Taliban, leave them people alone! Real quick to put a name on them! The people of Afghanistan are wonderful humans!
Obaidullah calling TTP a local terrorist group and scape goating by Pakistan. Maybe he should reread his history in his university. The 2014 Peshawar School massacre by the TTP involved one Chechen, three Arabs and two Afghan terrorists massacring 132 children. So how is this a local Insurgency when 2 Afghan nationals were involved?
Like a typical scape goating pakstani, you're ignoring the large number but focusing on the lowest number.
You munafik terrorist pakistani! Stop making bulshit lies up! That attack was carried out by your punjabie terrorist army and killed all our Pashtun children
That was an inside army job.
@@SK-iy3vi ofcourse you would know since you work in the army. Stop with the conspiracy theories.
@@sherryp3452 then how did the terrorists escape from Pakistani prison? It was a false flag in order to build public consensus for military operations on Pakhtuns.
remember, Pakistan supported Taliban as a part f Afghan resistance from 1980s when USSR was in Afghanistan, then supported Taliban when Bin Laden was there and fighting against Northen Alliance . Then again supported and kept Taliban alive when US stayed till 2021. Their official Pakistanis ministers on record gave accepted supporting Taliban against US forces . Pak ISI chief was the first foreign dignitary to visit Afghanistan when Taliban won against Afghani Government. He did a big photo-op with tea cups in his hand along with Taliban. Even after all this , Pakistan is getting hammered by same Taliban shows you how flawed Pakistanis foreign policy was and still is.
Pakistan created Taliban coupe to destabilize Afghanistan but it’s back firing now after Pakistans expansion into Afghanistan
Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
@@user-zv8gd3jl7q LOL Afghans invaded Panjabi Hindko land in KPK.
India stands with Afghanistan 🇮🇳❤🇦🇫
Both TTp and modi are kafir. One is boss other is agent tout.
🙏👍💯
End of all arguments.
India with Israel 😂
@@MostuMontu yes true ☺️
That's why the u.s. left all the weapons when leaving and not running away.
u.s. wants this border to heat up.
😂
The fighting a stop wants China buys down to their extortion they don't want them shipping stuff through there without them getting a piece of the action
@@asadhaque846 What are you gonna do about it? They gonna dance while you sit and watch 🇺🇸
As an Afghan myself, I love my Pakistani Muslim brothers and Sisters. But I condemn that Pakistani puppet government bombed innocent civilians in Afghan land.
We are both brothers in Islam.
Love and Respect from Afghanistan to my all my Muslim brothers and sisters in the world.
Long Live Islam - Allahu Akbar
Likewise my brother and agree 💯
What about your government. Probably worse and uneducated than a donkey .
You will be the first to get deported 😅
Your religion keeps your people in the dark ages with nothing to give our world!
Islam will die in the end!
We really need to unite under 1 flag 🏳️ I love Afghanistan as someone from Pakistan
The answer is simple - Both of them are extremely peaceful!
Being a Pakistani, Pakistani govt and army is absolutely wrong in this matter. I support Afghanistan in this situation. Shame on Pakistani govt and army..
It doesn't matter it always the policy of the nations surrounding Afghanistan to never allow it to rise. Iran, Pakistan and other countries will never allow Afghanistan to become a threat to it's nation and it's borders. If you where not fighting them it would Iran, if not Iran then Tajikistan, if not them Turkmenistan and so on.
You where spoiled when America invaded Afghanistan. They paid for and took the burnt of your job. But now that America is gone, this what you must do keep the Afghans from invading your country. Other nations will do the same. Afghan is very poor country with really bad resources so the Afghans are always looking to come into your territories. Soon you be supporting opposition groups within Afghanistan.
@HellBot-gi5si national policy doesn't means to control a country by fight, national policy should be based on soft side as well, Afghanistan is not a threat yess there are some concerns with it but it can be handled diplomatically, now Pakistan killed innocent people in Afghanistan and Afghanistan targeted our military, can this handle by such an action as Pakistan is taking against Afghanistan? never.. Being a Pakistani I know the intentions of pak army and present day govt bro..
if you want peace with your neighbour ,don't strike in their territory
Yes sir. It's that simple.
Afghanistan should not send terrorists in Pakistan 🇵🇰 who kill innocent people of Pakistan 🇵🇰
Pakistani army should not have targeted civilians population, the strikes have killed children, women & many innocent men. This should stop now.
Obaidullah Baheer, what a g, may Allah bless you with even more success
ameeeeeen
If TTP's goal is to establish an Islamic State in Pakistan according to this person from Pakistan means Pakistan is not really a Islamic state 😂
India will not be happy with a neighbour country lead by these psycho taliban and specially when they get nukes.
today's Pakistan is much more stable for india
😅
It's not
Well it is not. Listen to Dr. Israr Ahmed (R), he was himself Pakistani. He said Pakistani system is Kafir system made by Lord Michael. He further said, Pakistan was created in the Name of Islam and it has no right if does not implement Islam. He said, Pakistan will be divided and merge in Afghanistan. He predicted many things in the light of Quran and Hadith.
😁😁😁
Yes but the Afghan attacks are not against women and children.
Mr Obedulla I was lecturer too had been teaching overseas. I listened to your presentation and analysis, I am proud of you and Wishing you more successes.
Both sides shout allahu akbar
British raj najaz awalad naPak fouj killing pukhtoon and Baloch so they control mineral in KPK and Balochistan. while jealousy from Afghans government on their success.
Pakistani public hate naPAK military and consider Afghans as brother.
Don't impose your point of view on all of us.
@relaxingmusic8618 which part of Pakistan ur represent or where u from? Do u have any pain of pukhtoon and Baloch who dies every day and their home is bombed by British raj naPak kuttah fouj.and women kidnapped by ISI n Punjab also killing of muhajar 1992.
All is killed by British raj najaz awalad also what is the name 1st army chief
😂😂👍
Pakistan always. Support n. Help Afghans. But. Some. Stupid. Don't. Want. Peace
Brotherly disagreement. Temporary
As a Pakistani i would say that our own Army is responsible....
"Goro se Azadi dekar maine Watan LORO ke haato mein de di" - Qaid e Azam.
@@durgeshsingh5220man look at your own country we just have couple of Imrandus but u 😂
@durgeshsingh5220 yes Punjabi jagirdar lury....
@durgeshsingh5220 joty ki nok pr rkta hon ESI azadi ko jisme koi rule of law nie sirf gharib ki chmrhi utari jaa rhii he.... Azadi nie delayi he, Muslim qom ko 3 tukrho me divide kia he.... Lanat Quaid e Azam and all those landlords who divided the subcontinent for their personal and political goals....
@@hamzabangash4956 So afghans not recognizing the border is not a problem??
Born in Islam means,
You must love wars.
Amazing how ppl like you watch geo-poltical channels but you learn nothing and remain as ignorant as before.
Christian Russia
vs
Christian Ukraine ?
@@yasminea7149
Hmm are you dreaming?
@@JannBelovedJanzMore like u seeing a nightmare 😂
@AliChadhary420
😂😂😂😂
Durand Line is a border not only between 2 nations, but 2 civilisations, hungry Central Asia and prosperous South Asia.
Lol
When did Pakistan become prosperous 😅😅😅
Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
@@user-zv8gd3jl7q Durand Line stopped Pashtuns from encroaching on Indian land.
@@user-zv8gd3jl7q sikhs and mughals had kpk before the british arrived in the region and no expansion happened into afgan territory after 1947
I like the Afghan guest. He was eloquent and had his thoughts clear and concise.
Afganistan has some great professors.
Afgans and Pakistanis, you are two brothers who have stood for each other at tough times. There is Shaitan only who makes you fight each other. And Shaitabs in thiese comments also. So be aware do not die a dirty death.
The Taliban in Afghanistan have enough troubles. They need to concentrate on their own country.
Well-done baheer
Thanks Baheer ❤
Pak doing atrocities in afgan so i stand with afgan
Im indian❤
As as an Afghan, I've seen several skirmishes big and small taking place across the boarder between the state of Afghanistan and Pakistan. I'd say, we should lend ears to each other and provide efficient information for settling all on going hostilities across the border.
I want the board of Al Jazeera to hold penal with seniors from political spectrum of both countries.
well spoken Afghan rep.
Both afghanistan and pakistan are sharing their brotherly love ❤️ 😍 💖 for each other.
We hope 🙏 that this 🙏 love and feelings increase to a greater level.
Afghanistan people don't want war please stop let us Live in peace 😢
Full support to Afghanistan from Pakistan occupied KPK ❤❤❤
You're Namak Haram Afghani...
23:25 Panjabi laibor ❌ panjabi isi military ✅
First of all, remove that atheist filthy word from Afghan. Then talk. And yes punjabi filthy terrorist army
Chal ab 2 Nan laga afghadu
Is Afganistan stupid? Pakistan will ruin afghanistan if war, its not americans, pakistan is there forever they live there,
their military have kept India in check for decades. Mybe afghanistan should do as pakistan say and talk to the lunatics about it or pay the price.
Russia Amerika England they all tried it and know you think Daal can do something 😂😂😂
@mostafasamadi3530we know where you get your power , not from daal but from enjoying young fresh boys and then going to war , afghan civilians should keep their boys safe from the boy loving taliban pedos like you, and as far you taking on Pakistan…. Plz stop being delusional , in minutes your Afghanistan is off the map😂😂😂😂😂 delusions of grandeur , you should thank Pakistan you are not part of Russia right now it’s only because of Pakistan you namak haram
@mostafasamadi3530they only came to loot afghan resources and they came back after enough looting 😂
@mostafasamadi3530pakistan is not going anywhere you can get a befitting reply if you decide to do any misadventure 😂
Who's keeping India in check in Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka & Myanmar?
Best foreign policy by Pakistani Generals, India is enemy, now Afghans are enemy, and no friendly relations with Iran either, so all three sides are enemies, only friendly side is south which is Arabian Sea.
Muslim ummah in fighting itself instead of fighting their common enemies
Can't your ummah doesn't survive without fighting?
Let me break the news for you. The muslim ummah has been fighting each other since the beginning of Islam.
Jumma Chuma ...Ummah Ummah.
Muslim Ummah =Arab nationalism 😂
Taliban and TTP before attack on Army school in Peshawar and innocent children , now why crying about airstrike ?
Jung Mein kafiron ke bacchon ko maarna bhi halal hai. Pakistani army ko taleban Kafir samajhte Hain.
benchoot your own army did it namak harami dog
Both are tarriest country
Good points raised by Obaidullah Baheer.
Pakistan has become a joker in its political grounds and there is practically Europeans and Americans are functioning the government.
Afghans have struggled a lot their democracy.
Let me summarize the difference between Afghan Taliban and Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan for the unversed.
* Afghan Taliban: Want an extremely strict Shariah-compliant emirate in AFGHANISTAN. Pakistan fully backs them because it wants an excessively Islamized Afghan society to play second fiddle to itself and serve as its backyard. For Pakistan, the Afghan Taliban are valiant freedom fighters fighting for the real cause of Islam.
* Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan: Want an extremely strict Shariah-compliant emirate in PAKISTAN; Pakistan (a country that was incidentally created to uphold Muslim traditions and religious values in the Indian Subcontinent) vigorously opposes them because it does not want the same system for its own people that it wants for the Afghans. For Pakistan, the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan are violent terr0rists defaming Islam.
So basically, Pakistan very conveniently contrastingly treats the two Talibans fighting for the same end-goal, albeit in different territories.
The truth is that both talibans DO NOT know anything about Islam!!! They are paid criminals and Pakistani Army supports both sides!!!!!!’
Popcorn🎉
Excellent points raised by Obaidullah Baheer Sb, he's the sanest of the three!!!
As an indian we always stand with our afghan brothers and sisters
Guy's in AL JAZEERA, WHAT PAKISTAN CLAIMS ON AFGHANISTAN IS EXACTLY WHAT INDIA ACCUSES PAKISTAN ON CROSS BORDER TERRORISM FROM THEIR POJK. PAKISTAN IS TREATED BY THEIR OWN MEDICINE 😂
Peace Vs Peace= Master-Peace
Let me guess panjeet 🤮🤢
PaXistani army is in Surrender mode as always 🤩
The tea was fantastic 500 years of mughals ruled you 🤫
Abhinandan ne India ki naak ktwa de thi 😂
@@rajakhan-lr1yx all the mughals have passed away now LOL, India's economy is doing much much better than your Pakistan LOL
@@rajakhan-lr1yx Only because of gunpowder and artillery from Ottomans. Mughal empire was at it's peak when the Marathas and Sikhs defeated them.
@@rajakhan-lr1yxMughals came from Uzbekistan and later born and died in Modern day Uttarpradesh/Delhi region, they have nothing to do with modern Pakistan.
Well done Ubaidullah with a wise and spot on expressing the issues and root causes of the problems.
This is one more Fanatic VS fanatic problem. Nothing more.
All Patriotic Afghans in Iran should leave today to defend their country, before it is too late, Pakistan belongs to Afghanistan.
Allah & aljajeera both are in full confusion bcoz both are islamic countries😂
😂😂😂😂
Bhai kisi ke god ke baare me aesa MTT bola kar !
But both eat gau mata kabab 😋
Cow god😂 Monkey god😂 donkey god😂 snake god😂 Black mom god😂 many head god😂 blue god😂 mouse god😂 looks like you are confuse onch aur nich zaat
The problem is that water and oils never mixed together. same pashtons and Punjabi never lived together and will mixed together.
India won independence thanks to the Afghan people.
Another westerner pushing sectarianism ideologies. This neither an ethnic nor a religious issue. The PAK army is funded and supported by UK/US and is abusing local ppl. Just like local ppl revolted against Assad of Syria, so local ppl have been revolting against PAK army.
@@MrMKiani we Indians respect Afghan people, very hard working people in Delhi and in many parts of our country
@@ranveergodara6221 God bless you. When I die and my soul leaves here, I know that any new soul that is born will be as worthy of life here be it hindu, christian or jew. Later hate can attach itself to us like mud. Knowledge gives us the wisdom to clean ourself of hate, like soap and water.
What you talking about.....Punjab was part of Durrani Empire before the Sikh Empire
Primary problem is the Durhan line which was made into Pakistan border. This like artificially divided the Pashtun areas into two. Logically Pakistan should have returned these areas to Afghanistan.
The problem now is Pakistan has known this from the very beginning, so they have worked overtime in destabilizing Afghanistan from the time of its creation so that the claim can fizzle out or keep Afghan government so weak that they cannot do anything about it.
80% Pashtuns belong to Pakistan. I think Afghani land should be annexed by Pakistan and made as province of Pakistan as part of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. 🇵🇰
@@mirzasaadhamza You may have had a point if there was a thing called Pakistan with a national Identity of many within one. But let's be serious, Pakistan is essentially the punjabi in power asking others to serve them or be under their thumb. This has been the case for all of Pakistan's history. This was the reason why Bangladesh broke off.
Here is the simplest solution to change Pakistan to what you imagine Pakistan to be. Put in land reform and limit how much land each person can hold. Institute Land redistribution. This will take away the established Pubjabi/Landlord dominance in Pakistan, and the rest will automatically will change.
@@curio78 So here is solution. Merge Afghan Pashtoon areas into Pakistan it will become almost huge Pashtun population in Pakistan. Your complaint of Punjabi majority will also be resolved. You might not know, in Pakistan only two groups hold the power within bureaucracy and politics, number one are Shias and second one are Pashtoons. Rest of all Pakistanis are subjects to Pashtoons or Shias. So I think we need more pashtoons in Pakistan go keep this balance otherwise we are fearing that Pakistan will become another Syria very soon. Syria remained under control of a tiny minority for 53 years and same is feared in case of Pakistan.
Afghanistan isn't just pashtoons either though, there are many different groups from Persians to Turks, not just pashtoons.
@@mirzasaadhamza Who wants to be colonised by the lungi wearing spawn of the British Raj?
Religion of Peace
Are you Muslim
@G7R-t7q Are you?
The APS tragedy and the subsequent launch of Zarb-e-Azb by the Pakistan Army were pivotal moments in Pakistan’s determined efforts to eliminate terrorism. The operation successfully dismantled the operational capabilities of the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), significantly reducing the militant threat. While global recognition of Pakistan’s sacrifices and efforts has been limited, international powers have nonetheless acknowledged and appreciated Pakistan’s operations, such as Zarb-e-Azb, for their effectiveness in combating terrorism and restoring peace to the region. Furthermore, the success of Zarb-e-Azb has resulted in a dramatic reduction of cross-border terrorism, with such activities now almost nonexistent. However, despite this achievement, the instability in Afghanistan and Central Asia continues to pose challenges. As Afghanistan and its neighboring states, including Pakistan, struggle with political transitions and the rebuilding of both executive and legislative institutions, it becomes increasingly vital to prioritize human rights and regional stability within a broader global framework.
Historically, a silent agreement existed between India and Pakistan in the early years after independence, whereby India’s RAW (Research and Analysis Wing) was allowed to collaborate with Pakistan to expel forces from the western borders. Over time, however, this agreement faded, and the strategic interests of both countries diverged. In recent years, Pakistan has faced growing concerns about RAW’s potential to engage in covert operations within its territory. The Foreign Relations Wing of the ISI (Inter-Services Intelligence) plays a crucial role in maintaining diplomatic intelligence and ensuring that external interference, particularly by India, does not destabilize Pakistan. The evolving regional dynamics and the need for strategic foresight demand that ISI’s foreign intelligence wing continues to be vigilant, adhering to the understanding that India’s RAW must not use regional instability as a pretext to deploy activities in Pakistan.
In this context, Pakistan has a critical role to play in leading the region out of this crisis. This requires aligning with international norms and frameworks, particularly those articulated within Commonwealth programs. Commonwealth member states have long upheld the principles of democratic governance, human rights, and the rule of law. Programs such as the Commonwealth Charter and the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative provide a foundation for fostering peace, security, and the promotion of human dignity in post-conflict regions. These frameworks encourage member states to collaborate on issues like counterterrorism, human rights protection, and transitional justice, offering pathways for Pakistan and its neighbors to strengthen governance, accountability, and cooperation.
By leveraging these Commonwealth-backed legal and policy frameworks, Pakistan can enhance its diplomatic leadership in promoting peace and security, not only within its borders but across the broader region. Furthermore, Pakistan can work alongside both Commonwealth and non-Commonwealth states to ensure that regional conflicts do not escalate into global crises, positioning the country as a proactive, responsible player in international efforts to combat terrorism and protect human rights. This will allow Pakistan to transcend its role as a passive actor and lead efforts to rebuild a more secure and just region, in line with global humanitarian and security goals.
There is no peace with that kind of people
Paktunistan is under pak occupation
Pakistan ! Kashmir is in a different direction !?!
😂😂😂
"Goro se Azadi dekar Watan maine LORO ke haato mein de di" - Qaid e Azam.
Failed state of Pakistan
Narco state !
I am from Khyber pass ... Pak is doing very bad 👎
A renouncing of Islam and a reverting to your more peaceful religions could help.
Al Jazeera shouldn't bring the
Government agent to talk
In the ,inside story ,
Can someone tell me why the Pakistani government thought that overthrowing the afghan government and replacing them with the Taliban was a good idea?
To me it looks like incompetence?
Taliban was created by Pakistan to destabilize Afghanistan! It’s extremism etc to depopulate Afghanistan of its youths in order for Pakistan to economically control Afghanistan.
Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
Well Pakistan has the right to retaliate, if for decades Talibans are hitting Pakistan, and now if after so long Pakistan has carried operation, what's wrong with that.
Talibans don't want to implement shariat law, they just want a piece of land, cause this isn't according to islam.
Taliban was created by Pakistan to destabilize Afghanistan! It’s extremism etc to depopulate Afghanistan of its youths in order for Pakistan to economically control Afghanistan.
Indian settlers occupied Afghan territory led by the British and called it Pakistan / British establishment of Pakistan 1947. Pakistan expanded its occupation taking half of Afghan land like Israel and now they want whole of Afghanistan! These are Historic facts ! Taliban will never let this expansion happen or Afghans.
Speaking of "War Crimes" the NATO forces killed more Afghan civilians during the 20 years long war waged by NATO in Afghanistan. Were those not war crimes?
UmmahChummah to NapakSHAITANI foj "Goli kyon chalayi.......namaz padne waale ko container se KYON GIRAYA"
Napak foj e fquddat kiya 2QaumiBaqwasiat thusssssss: APNE HI mard e mujahid, mard e momineen, sadiq or ameen giraye Pirzada par tashadud, or nasheman pe bijliyan.