Ok but why don't you provide any statistical data for tangible comparison? Like population density in these areas? Overall animation style and narration are good.
@@razzmatazz33everything he said is nonsense . Devoid of any facts . God forbid that he didn’t read the 1841 census . If he did , his entire argument would be dead It, and emigration problems in 1860-1891 , 1930s, 1950s and 1980s all steam from there and the economic shortcomings of the West in part due to geography - poor land for farming
Did you just jump from the Normans (From modern France BTW) to the Famine, COMPLETELY ignoring the English invasion and everything that led up to and caused the famine?
Why bother . You haven’t a clue either . The population of Ireland jumped massively between 1750-1841 under English rule In fact, half the country actually lived in the West of Ireland . Galway, Roscommon and Mayo were top 10 most populous counties . Cork no 1 by a country mile and Kerry too, all of whom each had 250,000 plus in 1841 British made the famine worse. The video explicitly pointed that out . He failed to acknowledge that the West actually had a large population and he didn’t really explain why it declined while many counties in the east and Dublin Increased
Bingo. That’s Americans 7 minutes in, doesn’t address the question , in fact could have just said the famine , point out that most of the population did like along the west and south and asked a different question. What happened. Answer - famine and subsequent economic shortcomings for the next 60 plus years . Done in 5 minutes Waffling about Normans 😂🤡🤣🤡😂
I wouldn't call west deserted. Yes the density is lower but during the summer many will go there for holidays and many also have second homes there. It's just industry and service based jobs are primarily located on the east coast.
The population of the area you’ve highlighted red (the ‘empty bit’) is home to around 2.5 million people, it’s certainly not empty. Not to mention the fourth, fifth and sixth largest settlements respectively are all found in that area with metro populations of 250,000, 150,000 and 100,000. There’s three of the highest national level hospitals in the region, alongside at least five general hospitals and many clinics, there’s at least five tertiary education universities, the fourth busiest airport on the island, not far behind the third - and one of two in Europe with US Immigration Pre-Clearance. All but two of our major motorways and railway lines extend for most of their path in the red area before heading to Dublin, two of such motorways and rail lines exist only in the red area. Any gas or oil reserves we have are on the west, as is most of our hydroelectric power, as is the longest river. Do some research rather than perhaps relying on AI
The population used to be distributed mostly evenly, although it was more populous around Limerick and Cork area (Munster). Then the British famine happened.
By British famine do you mean the one that happened at the same time as the one in Ireland which caused large death and mass migration from places like Cornwall and Devon? I'm assuming that part of the story doesn't get told too much though cause "bad Britain" right?
@choughed3072 are you seriously playing that game . yes British bad the policy's of the time caused million plus lives in ireland and some riots in Cornwall
Actually, around mayo , Galway and Roscommon, all of who had populations of 250,000 plus each in 1841 . Cork had 850,000 plus . And Limerick had about 330,000 (less than Galway and Mayo) So that theory of a history that not many lived on the west coast ends the video immediately . Donegal was also a top 10 county in 1841 with 296,000 . Kerry had a similar population
This is a halfway decent video. No statistical data, cero numbers, half baked history that has nothing to do with the topic of the video or you didn’t tied it well into an argument for it to make sense, just stock footage and nice maps (which didn’t show the mountain ranges very well either).
Around 4.5 million people live in the shaded area where its supposidly "impossible to live" Thats about the same population as the states of Wyoming, Vermont, Alaska, North Dakota, South Dakota and Delaware combined.
Great video for a young channel, your production quality is really good. But, you could have done without the long multi-minute history lesson at the beginning. Either way, I love your concept and I subscribed.
Thanks for sparing me from watching this. I was turned off by the inane narration style and was looking in the comments if it was just me. I'm not even a native English speaker and even I hate this pseudo-cool attitude.
"... thanks to cool cats like St. Patrick..." Are you trying to be hip? Because it sounds desperate. Most of you narration is. Fire your writer and do it yourself.
Limerick is no fun anymore, I miss Stab city and Angela’s Ashes . Booo . Now it’s just a nice normal lovely city ..booo (always was a nice city - town)
Really poorly informed video. The 'central mountains' - whatever they are - do not act as a buffer against the Atlantic weather: the centre of Ireland is largely flat. And the English invaded in the 12th century, not the 11th century. And they weren't really English anyway - they spoke French and maintained French customs. I could go on... There's so much innacuracy in this video. But it's well meaning, at least, and done with heart.
Nah, many of the Normans like De Burgh, Butler etc WERE ENGLISH . Their families were settled in England about 100 years before coming to Ireland . Even Strongbow and his Norman Welsh pals had land in England for 50-100 years before coming over Don’t go blaming the Frenchies
As a Galway man you're right, nobody lives here, I am a figment of the imagination
Ok but why don't you provide any statistical data for tangible comparison? Like population density in these areas? Overall animation style and narration are good.
because this guy just pumps out AI slop
lol infuriating he didn’t mention population once
@@razzmatazz33everything he said is nonsense . Devoid of any facts . God forbid that he didn’t read the 1841 census . If he did , his entire argument would be dead
It, and emigration problems in 1860-1891 , 1930s, 1950s and 1980s all steam from there and the economic shortcomings of the West in part due to geography - poor land for farming
Misleading, the west coast is not that deserted, Derry, Sligo and Limerick are there to name a few, the west coast is just more rural than the east
Did you just jump from the Normans (From modern France BTW) to the Famine, COMPLETELY ignoring the English invasion and everything that led up to and caused the famine?
Why bother . You haven’t a clue either . The population of Ireland jumped massively between 1750-1841 under English rule
In fact, half the country actually lived in the West of Ireland . Galway, Roscommon and Mayo were top 10 most populous counties . Cork no 1 by a country mile and Kerry too, all of whom each had 250,000 plus in 1841
British made the famine worse. The video explicitly pointed that out . He failed to acknowledge that the West actually had a large population and he didn’t really explain why it declined while many counties in the east and Dublin Increased
@@gavintuesday4959 wow Gavin, you really put me in my place. Well done you.
i live on the west coast of Ireland
no you dont, nobody lives there
So did well over 1 .5 million people in 1841 . The clown who wrote the video didn’t know that though
And yet here we are. I can see the west coast from my window. I must be daydreaming.
Ya nobody in galway or limerick got me like 'yo where did everyone go?'
Or: How to stretch something to be said in one sentence to 8 minutes of wasted time
Is it that bad? I switched off after 1.5 minutes
Bingo. That’s Americans
7 minutes in, doesn’t address the question , in fact could have just said the famine , point out that most of the population did like along the west and south and asked a different question. What happened. Answer - famine and subsequent economic shortcomings for the next 60 plus years . Done in 5 minutes
Waffling about Normans 😂🤡🤣🤡😂
indeeed in west cork its very stark the further west you go the more sparsely populated it gets
"nobody" is a silly title.
I wouldn't call west deserted. Yes the density is lower but during the summer many will go there for holidays and many also have second homes there. It's just industry and service based jobs are primarily located on the east coast.
The population of the area you’ve highlighted red (the ‘empty bit’) is home to around 2.5 million people, it’s certainly not empty. Not to mention the fourth, fifth and sixth largest settlements respectively are all found in that area with metro populations of 250,000, 150,000 and 100,000. There’s three of the highest national level hospitals in the region, alongside at least five general hospitals and many clinics, there’s at least five tertiary education universities, the fourth busiest airport on the island, not far behind the third - and one of two in Europe with US Immigration Pre-Clearance. All but two of our major motorways and railway lines extend for most of their path in the red area before heading to Dublin, two of such motorways and rail lines exist only in the red area. Any gas or oil reserves we have are on the west, as is most of our hydroelectric power, as is the longest river. Do some research rather than perhaps relying on AI
The population used to be distributed mostly evenly, although it was more populous around Limerick and Cork area (Munster). Then the British famine happened.
By British famine do you mean the one that happened at the same time as the one in Ireland which caused large death and mass migration from places like Cornwall and Devon? I'm assuming that part of the story doesn't get told too much though cause "bad Britain" right?
@choughed3072 are you seriously playing that game . yes British bad the policy's of the time caused million plus lives in ireland and some riots in Cornwall
Actually, around mayo , Galway and Roscommon, all of who had populations of 250,000 plus each in 1841 . Cork had 850,000 plus . And Limerick had about 330,000 (less than Galway and Mayo)
So that theory of a history that not many lived on the west coast ends the video immediately .
Donegal was also a top 10 county in 1841 with 296,000 . Kerry had a similar population
This is a halfway decent video.
No statistical data, cero numbers, half baked history that has nothing to do with the topic of the video or you didn’t tied it well into an argument for it to make sense, just stock footage and nice maps (which didn’t show the mountain ranges very well either).
Around 4.5 million people live in the shaded area where its supposidly "impossible to live"
Thats about the same population as the states of Wyoming, Vermont, Alaska, North Dakota, South Dakota and Delaware combined.
"impossible to live there"...I live in the west of Ireland and its awesome.
I LIVE IN THE WEST BUT WONDER WHY I STILL LIVE THERE.
It's niiiice?
Like this is difficult for anyone to work out... There's lots going on to the East, there's sweet FA going on to the West, for about 2000 miles.
Great video for a young channel, your production quality is really good. But, you could have done without the long multi-minute history lesson at the beginning. Either way, I love your concept and I subscribed.
Loads of people live in the west what a load of BS
Thanks for sparing me from watching this. I was turned off by the inane narration style and was looking in the comments if it was just me. I'm not even a native English speaker and even I hate this pseudo-cool attitude.
@@olafweyer859 i live in Ireland my whole life i can assure you about half the population live in the red area
@@45pints87and double that number just before the famine
"... thanks to cool cats like St. Patrick..." Are you trying to be hip? Because it sounds desperate. Most of you narration is. Fire your writer and do it yourself.
ah yes galway and limerick arent a thing
If only Galway wasnt a thing
Limerick is no fun anymore, I miss Stab city and Angela’s Ashes . Booo . Now it’s just a nice normal lovely city ..booo (always was a nice city - town)
Didn’t bother watching this but it has a pretty insulting title for the hundreds of thousands of people who live in the west of Ireland.
Someone educate this spoofer as to where much of the population lived in 1841 … it WAS NOT along the east coast !!
What about Kilkenny Laois and Carlow.....
Seriously what about them ? Boring counties , even Kilkenny city
maybe because its more rural. Most people live in the cities, like everywhere in western europe
Far from empty, just less crowded than the east coast 😂
Ireland never ate though mane
BS, lot's of people living mid or west..cmon dude
well produced video. garbage information and boring.
This is so so incorrect 😭😭😭😭
trade, anyone can look at this map and answer this question.
Subscribe here for good luck! :) Click here to subscribe: bit.ly/3roBYW5
Utter skutter!
Sorry but I find the compare annoying
The most Yank video I've ever seen.
Nobody was in Ireland 33,000 years ago haha.
Really poorly informed video. The 'central mountains' - whatever they are - do not act as a buffer against the Atlantic weather: the centre of Ireland is largely flat.
And the English invaded in the 12th century, not the 11th century. And they weren't really English anyway - they spoke French and maintained French customs.
I could go on... There's so much innacuracy in this video. But it's well meaning, at least, and done with heart.
Nah, many of the Normans like De Burgh, Butler etc WERE ENGLISH . Their families were settled in England about 100 years before coming to Ireland . Even Strongbow and his Norman Welsh pals had land in England for 50-100 years before coming over
Don’t go blaming the Frenchies
The British