I love Keith's and Nicole's friendship development from "i don't have time to chit chat" To "i love you too sweetie" And the downfall of Zach's and Josh's friendship from "hey buddy how is it going?" To "if you mess this up ill rain hellfire upon you"
“It takes a very advanced skill to mess up these ingredients” has the same vibe as “you should find other means of honoring your father” Shoot, its been a year everyone. Thanks for this.
I would actually love to see a lot of the try guys' attempts and ideas executed by a professional chef/dress maker/etc. Or made by them with the help of a professional. That way they would actually learn something! As funny as their without instructions videos are, I want some closure! Or progress! Please 🙏
The hilarious progression of Keith and Nicole being kinda snippy with each other at the start and having a lovely time by the end. Meanwhile Zach and Josh start off having a good time with good vibes and then it devolves into shouting and frantic squabbling
Roy Choi says he's not made for TH-cam but he is the cornerstone of this episode - he's bringing credibility, humor, savageness, one liners, mannnnnn please come back hahahaha
Seeing Roy eat something that Josh didn’t get to actually make but had to put his name on and present as his own was the best part of this. Poor Josh. 🤣😂
I wanted to crawl into a hole and die FOR him. I’m not even a good [former] chef, but the idea of wanting to honor a heroes food and letting someone else execute it blind… I’d rather lose a body part. Not like a pinky toe like a foot.
@@zerocraic3966 Not only that, but finding out half way through that the person who inspired the dish will be judging it is just the best coincidence ever!
@@TheRaptorJezuz how could I leave that out! I was so busy debating what size body part I’d amputate in exchange for never having to experience this personally 🤣
I've finally pinned down what Ned's irritating energy is in cooking videos. He's like a smug, 10 year old child who cooked one thing with the support of a parent once, was gushed over by family and now tells all of his friends what an amazing chef he is. A judge? The best cook of the try guys? Let's be real, I've seen him make some truly astounding mistakes in cooking challenges on the channel - not just baffling from an experienced cook's perspective, but from a common sense, 'don't you know how the world works around you' perspective. Also, God bless Zack, he's doing his best
Yeah I can see where you're coming from, honestly for me there's just something way deeper about him that kinda unsettles me, not to be overdramatic, I only notice it within videos made in like the last year but, idk, dude gives me really weird vibes, something just feels off with him, I'm not gonna use any terms he just seems to get legitimately angry and take things way too seriously in a weird way, you notice it a lot in the without a recipe videos when he'll get extremely upset when something happens, and then seem like...idk, really quite and cold and angry at negative reviews in a way that seems like it isn't a joke, he looks like he's taking it all way too seriously. I can't give a better explanation but I genuinely find it hard to watch parts of videos with him in them from the past year now, once you see it you can't unsee it and it just makes me feel really uneasy
Agree ! I took a break from watching them for awhile and eventually got back into it a year or 2 later on so rewatched shows and I was like man why’d I ever stop?! Then I got to episodes where it was chaotic but still fun but then someone was overly trying to be funny chaotic wnd it’s was ned 😣🤣🤣 then I realized the only times he was funny is when he wasn’t trying ! Like his background comments like “zendaya? From thr big foot movie ?” 😂 like such a dad thing ! But yeah he got annoying but I missed the guys and catch up with the other videos sadly then the news broke of ned this year and I’m just so glad now he’s gone 😂
I have ALWAYS felt similarly about Ned. But it's not just with cooking. It was his entire person. He's smug about everything, has always had this undertone of conceit. His cooking, his mediocre ass, his glorious family that he willingly fucked over, his career that he pissed on... such a prancy priss.
Keith and Nicole got robbedd. They communicated quite well compared to Josh and Zach and based off the final products Keith's dish looked pretty good and edible
The judge would eat Zach's food again as a dip, but not Keith's food. If there was a chip, they would eat Zach's food. But they wouldn't go back to Keith's food no matter what.
how did you guys pair the chefs so perfectly i feel like josh gives off zach energy so much and nicole and keith were like two parents whos kids are friends and she was giving him a recipe for a barbecue or something
They are two of the chefs that work for Rhett and Link for Good Mythical Morning! They also have a podcast called "A Hotdog is a Sandwich", and they both have their own spinoff channel from Mythical called Mythical Kitchen if you want to see more content from them!
Gotta side with Keith on the whole "You based the winner on a hypothetical?" comment. Should've been more based on the final product and from the sounds of it they had waayyyy more issues consuming Zach's than they did with Keith's.
yo fr, i'd rather sit confused eating subpar cheeseburger wellington than struggle eating almost sundubu jjigae with RAW ginger chunks every few bites. at least the wellington was a fully realized dish, zach just literally butchered (albeit very entertainingly) josh's recipe 😭
Exactly. Wasn't the whole point figuring out who was better at communication and execution of the instructions??? This was the most unfair judged try guys video ever and I'm bummed
as a vegetarian i would’ve chosen keith’s dish over zachs so very easily. it looked edible. it was actually following instructions to the best of the ability, and keith tried with the plating. and none of the judges said “it doesn’t smell right” or “my last try guys ever” to the dish. i don’t know where the ganged up hate came in for keith, but he truly was robbed of that win. that being said i do love zach but it was so unfair.
I can’t believe zach essentially won because he was making an established dish that *could* have been passable in another universe! Nicole was making up a recipe on the fly and it was enjoyable!!! Or at the very least Roy could swallow it lol
@@roulettetime9549 I said this above, but I think that Zach and Josh were set up. There is no "not setting this up" reason to have given the box that would make Josh choose to try to coach the one Try Guy whose character can't cook at all (though we've seen Zach the person cook in videos) through making a Korean dish when Roy is a judge.
They judged it based on wether they would eat it again at all, something can be technically fine and something you wouldn't eat again in favor of something else (and tbf, they said they didn't enjoy eating either)
Sorry but Keith & Nicole should have won, it should be based on the dish at hand, not what you imagine it could have been. In the same vein you could be like, “If we had some burger buns this would have been a really unique burger!” The video was entertaining but the judgement was pretty unfair.
Nicole was ROBBED. That cheese burger Wellington turned out great. And all the judges said it was not bad and edible enough, they all ate quite a lot. They could barely eat Zachary with all the raw ginger, and odd ratio of flavours 💀
Nicole was SUCH a delight in this episode. By the time she tried the dish, she was so resigned to whatever that she had, that she loved it. I'm happy for her and Keith's weird giant beefy pancake thing.
The judge would eat Zach's food again as a dip, but not Keith's food. If there was a chip, they would eat Zach's food. But they wouldn't go back to Keith's food no matter what.
Because his first bite had expectations. Every bite after that was absent of those expectations, and he could taste it for what it was. Not that difficult to comprehend. I've had the same experience with what I thought was a mini berry smoothie (it turned out to be a beetroot health shot...)
Roy Choi is PERFECTLY MADE for TH-cam. He’s witty and knowledgeable and really engaging. He should continue collabing and do more TH-cam! Loving this series!!!
The Cheeseburger Wellington looks and sounds amazing, especially given the inherent problems caused by the disconnect between brain and hands. Zach and Josh's sundubu, on the other hand, actually had the judges pulling faces of disgust. Literally the only reason they won was because the judges were like "Well, I would eat it if someone who knows what they're doing had made it." I respect Josh, I like his recipes, and I would respect the decision had he himself prepared it, but Zach's execution just didn't warrant a win. Keith and Nicole were _robbed_ .
Not if "someone else made it", but if there were chips they would still eat again. While they wouldn't go back to eat Keith's food again no matter what.
They literally saw it and laughed at it. Like... that wellington looked like some of Keith's best work on the channel! And they saw it and laughed at it! Why?
I was REALLY hoping Nicole and Josh would get the chance to redeem themselves and cook a separate dish to serve the judges afterwards as like a "here's what we're both capable of ACTUALLY" to both the judges and viewers (who are new to nicole and josh) because these two are both VERY talented and accomplished chefs.
"Today we will be judging on *presentation, taste and execution* " Presentation: Keith clearly did a better presentation even if he didn't cut it up (even included lettuce and tomatoes like a real cheeseburger!). Every bowl that Zach prepared was sloppy and messy Taste: C'mon now, Chef Roy could barely swallow the first bite for the sundubu Execution: LITERALLY HAD CHUNKS OF GINGER. Zach almost contaminated the whole kitchen with raw pork and could barely keep up with Josh's instructions. Keith did everything accordingly and cooperated well with Nicole Tldr: Keith and Nicole were R O B B E D
At first I was like “Okay idk about Nicole” then I was like “holy mother I love Nicole” I was like “this guys kinda cool” then I was like “josh has the patience of a saint.”
i'm so sick of keith getting robbed in these cooking challenges. the judges actually ATE his dish and their biggest complaint was that it was too dense to eat more of. roy couldn't even swallow the first bite of zach's
Honestly the chef set Keith up for failure, beef Weldon is one of the hardest dishes to make and you’re not meant to have fully cooked meat inside of it. And she hasn’t even made it herself and expected Keith to do it successfully.
ehh. i don’t think eugene matched her “aggressive” personality well. his role is the “dark” one of the group but he’s actually very tame/shy and he doesn’t really have that aggressive edge to him. when you have someone more meek matched with someone more intense aggressive it doesn’t really work, but when it’s two intense people like nicole and keith it’s funny
Keith was robbed! Zach winning by 5 different hypotheticals basically should have been a clue that the dish was horrible. "If your dish was done like A-Z then it would be good" doesn't scream winning dish to me
@@prettyfemme you can literallly tell keith and nicole the judges were saying is not bad and such and for zach and josh they literally struggled and roasted the crap of it
I guess the only thing I could think is, that while Nicole's dish was "cheeseburger inspired" none of them got that feel from it, despite it being actually good to eat. And Josh's, while it didn't taste good, it was clearly following a specific Asian dish and it executed on that more. But I think taste still has to be a major factor in deciding who wins things like this Also the fact that Roy couldn't even really bring himself to eat Josh/Zach's dish.......like......yeah And finally Ned said that's "good" if you don't eat all of the ingredients, meaning the whole dish cannot be enjoyed, only the broth basically, which of course tastes good and flavorful because they put a lot of spices in it
I esp. love that Zach clearly said he hates being told what to do and doesn't listen or follow directions. It was doomed from the start. I am so ps'd he even won, lol
Zach in a kitchen is painful. I love him, but how has he not picked up a single cooking skill by now.... Well... I guess nothing exploded so.. Can't wait for more of this!
I'm starting to get the vibe that it's an act. Ned literally has a cookbook out and when he's participating he's just as "bad" as everyone else. He makes noob mistake after noob mistake.
@@kaldo_kaldo yup been thinking the same. Love Zach but get actually frustrated with him in the kitchen sometime. Like, his "character" is to be bad and throw out all the rules even though he definitely knows some now.
Was dying laughing when Nicole was telling Keith what a great job he was doing, and Josh just goes "Zach is asking where the water is and I don't know what to tell him" lmao
hahaha so let me get this straight. Josh won because if they changed the recipe, took out the stuff that didn't work, got a the smallest amount on a chip (and pray there wasn't any ginger in it) it's edible But Nicole lost because it was weird that it was inspired by a cheeseburger and didn't taste like a cheeseburger? rigged
I feel like a lot might of gotten cut out of this, because in this final cut, the judging on the one that ended up winning was all bad and the other seemed at least passable from the judging. Nicole's idea seemed inventive though not as tasty as it sounds, but the execution was pretty good besides the flat outside and unevenness of ingredients inside. Josh's idea sounded really good, but the execution broke down in many places. Weird to judge on a theoretical outcome, though, kind of dismisses the point of this format.
I am looking forward to comments like this smothering me for the next couple of months. It was bad enough when the Yogscast booted a bunch of their guys and nobody ever shut the fuck up about it for like a year - now I can't even escape the bullshit drama in my OTHER favourite channel.
Really? I've disagreed with some of the wins on other cooking videos but this was truly a slap in the face. I don't know if it was editing, but it looked like Keith and Nicole had this one in the bag the whole video then got judged on unfair criteria of "if we could change what we didn't like about it." Was the same consideration given to the wellington? They could have made it more like a cheeseburger or more like a wellington just as easily.
@@danielleking262 I didn't understand the drama behind that part; Zach spends a bunch of time complaining that he has raw pork on his hands so he can't do anything and lets his stuff burn?
@@danieljungers8094 I guess because time was crucial that he had to keep stirring or continue cooking because they were running out of time but he stupidly just didn't bother go washing his hands first, so he couldn't touch anything.
@@martian8979 No, lol. I just don't get why Zach couldn't run to the sink to quickly wash off, or maybe just grab a towel to hold the pot?? There could've been so many solutions here. 🤦♀️😆
So to be clear, one dish was "extremely easy to make" and was inedible, with chunks of raw ingredients, with a bad presentation, and the other was "not as puffed as I'd like", very difficult to make, well cooked, and beautifully presented. One team was in control and competent. One team was a nightmare. And you gave the win to the inedible food that looked bad and wasn't cooked. Sure sure. Makes total sense. WTF
Literally! All those hypotheticals they put in like wtf the point of it was to be the END result and not some “omg imagine what if could be” actually had me so angry
Sounds a lot like the 2016 Presidential election/candidates... we handed our country to inedible, badly presented nightmare fuel for four years because the other option wasn't exactly how we wanted it to be... lolsob... it's gorram allegorical....
@@oinkpersonpeeps1692 "Imagine what it could be?" Exactly! Josh made a dish so common that Koreans eat it for breakfast, lunch and dinner...as opposed to Nicole's reimagining of Beef Wellington.
Keith: "okay, mom" Nichole:"I love you, honey" Keith: " I love you, tooo" Meanwhile in the other phone booth: Josh: "Zach, If you f*ked me on this, i swear to god, I will just rain hell fire on you"🔥🔥🔥
I was recently thinking “Aw I love without a recipe but I feel like they’ve nearly run out of categories so it’ll probably end soon” and then you make this and it’s JUST AS AMAZING I’m obsessed. Thank you for keeping that chaotic cooking hole in my heart filled 🥰
they’re doing a very similar show (no recipe road-trip) for the food network so i assume they won’t be able to post w/out a recipe on youtube for a while :/
Also: they could have a series of them actually learning to do the things they made (food, clothes, wigs, etc.) and being instructed by professionals. Or having professionals execute their ideas. I would looove that for a lot of things! I need closure
So instead of basing the winner on the criteria, they threw all that out the window and based it off of "would they eat this if it was made correctly." Justice for Nicole and Keith. But for real, this is a great series and I hope this continues. I love it.
Y’all should reverse it! The try guys taste a dish where they have no idea what it is. The chefs are listening to the try guys describe what they’re eating and try to recreate it.
I love how Nicole had really similar vibes with Keith throughout the whole presentation. The "maybe you should try it that way" or "well i don't know what you are talking about" or "this tastes great, what?". The screaming bit was perfect! That's some quality duo right there
WHAT?!!? They liked Zach’s only if Zach didn’t make it, and it was a completely different dish?? They couldn’t even properly eat it. This is the first time this judging decision was pure bullshit
Their only criticism was the ground beef with cheese didn’t taste like a cheeseburger. What?! And the puff pastry didn’t puff. Meanwhile there was raw ginger in every bite and the trash part of scallions.
Me too!! I knew he was good for the try guys right away when he appreciated eugene for using pig’s blood in his cinnamon rolls. That’s a kind of crazy genius that’s accepted with the Try Guys.
It's still so funny to me that Try Guys is probably now becoming one of the biggest cooking channels when they don't even know how to cook. I think I'll consider their cooking shows the winner of all cooking shows when they get Gordon Ramsay to judge. JUST IMAGINE.
Gordon Ramsay would step into the building and like Obi-Won that shit "There's been a disturbance in the force. A great tragedy has occurred" just from the lingering memories of the horrors the guys have made
Man I am pissed about Ketih's dish being shit on but ho boy I absolutely LOVED Nicole being in this. She's hilarious and charismatic. Her bickering with Josh was so fucking funny that made my day.
I love that Nicole spends most of her phone booth time looking into the camera. She's like, "I don't know if this is gonna turn out well, but what I do know is how to 👏work👏that👏camera."
I can’t believe they based the decision off of a hypothetical. I think Keith and Nicole did so much better communicating and the end product was actually what they had tried to make.
With other judging type videos, whether i agree with the result or not, I usually don’t get upset. However with this one I am because clearly Keith and Nicole communicated well and their dish seemed more edible since the judges ate it more than the other one. This resulted made no sense
@@remythefatrat I don't like it when he pretends to be more clumsy than he actually is, especially in such a blatant way. If he actually fucks up is funny, but if he has to pretend then it's not. I love videos where they cook (bc the judging part is always interesting) but this one was too scripted. I felt uneasy at times, especially when they pretended to fight (Zach with Josh or Nicole with Josh), that was so lame. Her losing the coin was much more funnier and that was unscripted. Try Guys' value is spontaneity, they don't do as well with scripted bits, I don't understand why they keep insisting, it's too staged. They're not actors so it's clear they're pretending and it gets annoying. And dropping the eggshell is the clear example of how playing dumb is not funny.
I felt like when it came down to the judges judging Nicole and Keith’s dish the judges said meh the whole time and there was no positive about it. However, when they got to Josh and Zack’s judging they all collectively knew the food was going to be bad and they tried so hard to find and say positives about it. Loved the episode up until the judging part!
They talked shit and said good things about both wtf u on about watch the video again lmao they said good and bad things for both made fun of both like?
@@gnats4109 I feel like Nicole played into Keith's weakness of being overly ambitious, which usually seems to be what gets him in Without a Recipe. He's definitely more competent, but this was a hard dish!
Zach acts chaotic on purpose. He literally try’s to do a bad job on purpose. Ned was eating the burger Wellington as if he had never seen food before in his life yet still trash talked it the whole time. I’m confused.
Gordon would literally scream at half the guys like it's HK and comfort the other half like it's Masterchef Kids. All while cry laughing into his hands that they're all walnuts everytime he got off the phone.
This was hilarious. That being said, the mental gymnastics they went through so Nicole and Keith would lose were over the top. If you think it’s funnier when Keith loses just say so 😌
It seems to me that they gave Zach and Josh the win because they were clearly sabotaged. They knew that with that box, Josh would go to Korean food and only then told him that Roy Choi would be one of the judges.
They hated the execution and presentation of both and preferred the taste of the korean dish. I think you're doing mental gymnastics to imagine Nicole and Keith should have won
@@oliviarecommends Sabotaged? As Chef Roy said, it really takes an expert to mess up something so simple like sundubu. Keith's dish clearly required more expertise and he pulled it off (somewhat) whereas Zach somehow messed up a soup! AND they won despite Rpy Choi being one of the judges, I don't see how they were "clearly sabotaged"
@@kaldo_kaldo Also, they relentlessly criticized Keith's dish in every aspect and didn't say anything positive about it yet they somehow managed to say smtg positive for everything in Zach's dish and completely ignored the horrible execution and presentation? I call bs.
I think everyone would appreciate it if the Try Guys genuinely tried their hardest and had honest judging BASED ON THE RHETORIC IN THE BEGINNING OF THE VIDEO. This is such a fun concept, please don't ruin it with "OMG WE CANT COOK ANYTHING AT ALLLL" and making deliberate mistakes. Real efforts are more entertaining. I love you guys
Nicole losing her quarter in the absurdly shaggy carpet is one of the funniest unscripted things that could have happened in this video
It really was!! 🤣🤣 Feels like a very Nickelodeon style game show era show, with a twist of Food Network for funsies. I do hope they do more! 💜
The fact that this is the top comment and I’ve been waiting for it the whole video lol
Wasn't funny unless you're 5 years old
Omg right and then she ends it with "ur ugly " to the other chef 🤣🤣🤣🤣
When was it?
“Get over yourself Ned” -prophetic words from Keith
Me coming back to this video to see if anyone commented about this 😂
@@Nicoleticfrenetic same
lol just seeing this and i said the same thing HA
I already see clickbait videos about this guy - I can't even escape the drama in the comments.
I was thinking more of the "this is my last Try Guys video" in the beginning, even though it wasn't Ned who said it xD
I love Keith's and Nicole's friendship development from "i don't have time to chit chat" To "i love you too sweetie" And the downfall of Zach's and Josh's friendship from "hey buddy how is it going?" To "if you mess this up ill rain hellfire upon you"
omg rightt so wholesome LOL
😅
The fight between Nichole and Josh that just ends with Nichole going “you’re ugly” is the most sibling energy thing I’ve ever seen
8:15
“Josh please help me find the quarter IM SWEATING, IM SWEATING” 💀
Lily’s legacy.
Are they not related?
@@9090lillypad do they look related to you…
“It takes a very advanced skill to mess up these ingredients” has the same vibe as “you should find other means of honoring your father”
Shoot, its been a year everyone. Thanks for this.
LOL !!!!
LMFAOOO
I'm so glad you reminded me of that line.
LMAO you win best comment
Where is that from? Google is being rather tight-lipped.
Zach and Keith mocking Ned's dirty face holds a whole new meaning, and joy, for me.
they were trying to tell him to wipe his mouth
and wipe his dirts literally@@cottage-core_
I would love to see Josh and Nichole make the dishes that they were attempting here. If not for our entertainment, for Josh's ego
omg yes
That would be great. Using the same ingredients. Maybe on their own channel?
Yes, I would love for them to have their redemption.
I would actually love to see a lot of the try guys' attempts and ideas executed by a professional chef/dress maker/etc.
Or made by them with the help of a professional. That way they would actually learn something!
As funny as their without instructions videos are, I want some closure! Or progress! Please 🙏
YES PLEASE and Bring back Roy to try it again!
The hilarious progression of Keith and Nicole being kinda snippy with each other at the start and having a lovely time by the end. Meanwhile Zach and Josh start off having a good time with good vibes and then it devolves into shouting and frantic squabbling
Yeah xD
From "cut the chit chat"
To
"I love you, honey."
@@HexenkoeniginVonAngmar then there’s the opposite: from “Hey Zach, how ya doing buddy”, to “If you f*** me on this, I will rain hellfire on you”.
“zach. just. work. with. me.” “okay sooo”
Roy Choi says he's not made for TH-cam but he is the cornerstone of this episode - he's bringing credibility, humor, savageness, one liners, mannnnnn please come back hahahaha
He’s good, and honestly he’s one of the most qualified being a well known chef.
I was thinking the same lmao its the opposite, he's perfect for TH-cam!!
I think he knows he's made for TH-cam.
I'm so glad they brought him back!!
HES LITERALLY MADE FOR YT his bluntness and straight forwardness and authenticity IS WHAT WE NEED
Seeing Roy eat something that Josh didn’t get to actually make but had to put his name on and present as his own was the best part of this. Poor Josh. 🤣😂
You can tell it's killing him inside, I love it. 😂😂😂
I wanted to crawl into a hole and die FOR him. I’m not even a good [former] chef, but the idea of wanting to honor a heroes food and letting someone else execute it blind… I’d rather lose a body part. Not like a pinky toe like a foot.
@@zerocraic3966 Not only that, but finding out half way through that the person who inspired the dish will be judging it is just the best coincidence ever!
@@TheRaptorJezuz how could I leave that out! I was so busy debating what size body part I’d amputate in exchange for never having to experience this personally 🤣
Yeah he died inside 😭
33:35 Nicole screaming at the judges with Keith silently hyping her up in the background is peak older sister little brother energy
YES! 😂😂
I loved it lol
And Zack joined in too 😂😂
It's usually Keith screaming at the judges lol glad he got to cheer Nicole on
He’s 6 yrs older than her, but I still agree 😆
Chef Roy: This is my last Try Guys ever...
Correction: This is Ned's last Try Guys ever
🔥🔥🔥
OMFG
I just gotta say I'm here for the Ned slander 🤣
Technically the diving board one was his last one
Because reading is what? Fundamental!
Seeing Nicole yell like Keith is truly terrifying because I feel like she’s always so cheery 😂
I love that she was like.... Still cheery while yelling 😂
@@AriaGemsbok you could tell she was digging deep for that whole bit 😂
Absolutely false
Hey brotha, I’m 20 years old grinding hard to get out the hood, I can’t be 30 with nothing to show for so i smoke weed on my youtube channel ☝️☝️
While she was yelling how three judges were taking it respectfully 😂😂
This is the same Try Guys without a recipe but with the intensity and competitiveness of Mythical Kitchen- perfect.
It just needed Rhett & Link as judges as well since they're the experts on eating questionable foodstuffs, lol!
Only clicked on this video because I saw Josh and Nicole in the thumbnail lol
Nicole and Keith as competitors are an absolute POWER DUO. it's like having two keiths but one of them knows what they're doing.
The perfect way to describe their energy!
Nicole really pulled off a loser yelling Keith at the end! HAHA
💀😂 well put
I wanna see more of them together so bad
Love this comment lol
Petition for Roy Choi to be a contestant in a future episode!
This comment deserves more attention
Partnered with Keith
Oh my god this would be incredible
More of these phoning it in please!!!
I AGREE
Roy is so brave to come back and judge again
Update: they broke Roy Choi AGAIN
I missed him! I was so happy to see him back and I hope we see him again soon.
@@kathleenuclear he’s one of my favorite guest judges! It’s like he’s not trying to be funny which makes it funnier lol
Probably Roy rethinking all his life choices after filming this one
When was the first time? Please let me know asap
@@anuhyekyayy8618 without a recipe season 1 iirc
When Nicole said "you're ugly" to josh to finish her argument, I LOST it. Such schoolyard energy a I love it
lolol I had to rewind to check if I had heard right.
That’s exactly what Mythical Kitchen is in a nutshell. Bunch of schoolyard kids with great culinary skill
timestamp?
@@malcfoy
The whole argument 8:22
Just the specific part 8:37
“Roy, if you want to kick me in the nuts in the parking lot, I accept”. Josh, never stop being you.
I really hope Chef Roy comes back he is hilarious
this makes a lot more sense after watching what zach produced. i thought josh was just down to clown
@@katac7286 if anything, Josh was over confident in Zach's abilities at the start 😃
DEAL
As a Asian inspired chef I felt him to my core andnim a lady but I'd let him kick me in the balls too 😂
I've finally pinned down what Ned's irritating energy is in cooking videos. He's like a smug, 10 year old child who cooked one thing with the support of a parent once, was gushed over by family and now tells all of his friends what an amazing chef he is. A judge? The best cook of the try guys? Let's be real, I've seen him make some truly astounding mistakes in cooking challenges on the channel - not just baffling from an experienced cook's perspective, but from a common sense, 'don't you know how the world works around you' perspective.
Also, God bless Zack, he's doing his best
Yeah I can see where you're coming from, honestly for me there's just something way deeper about him that kinda unsettles me, not to be overdramatic, I only notice it within videos made in like the last year but, idk, dude gives me really weird vibes, something just feels off with him, I'm not gonna use any terms he just seems to get legitimately angry and take things way too seriously in a weird way, you notice it a lot in the without a recipe videos when he'll get extremely upset when something happens, and then seem like...idk, really quite and cold and angry at negative reviews in a way that seems like it isn't a joke, he looks like he's taking it all way too seriously.
I can't give a better explanation but I genuinely find it hard to watch parts of videos with him in them from the past year now, once you see it you can't unsee it and it just makes me feel really uneasy
Well the higher they are the harder they fall...he'll probably never have anything to boast about in his life agaib
Exactly. This man did not deserve a cookbook
Agree ! I took a break from watching them for awhile and eventually got back into it a year or 2 later on so rewatched shows and I was like man why’d I ever stop?! Then I got to episodes where it was chaotic but still fun but then someone was overly trying to be funny chaotic wnd it’s was ned 😣🤣🤣 then I realized the only times he was funny is when he wasn’t trying ! Like his background comments like “zendaya? From thr big foot movie ?” 😂 like such a dad thing ! But yeah he got annoying but I missed the guys and catch up with the other videos sadly then the news broke of ned this year and I’m just so glad now he’s gone 😂
I have ALWAYS felt similarly about Ned. But it's not just with cooking. It was his entire person. He's smug about everything, has always had this undertone of conceit. His cooking, his mediocre ass, his glorious family that he willingly fucked over, his career that he pissed on... such a prancy priss.
Keith and Nicole got robbedd. They communicated quite well compared to Josh and Zach and based off the final products Keith's dish looked pretty good and edible
Yes! I agree (not that i'm not happy for Josh and Zach)
The judge would eat Zach's food again as a dip, but not Keith's food. If there was a chip, they would eat Zach's food. But they wouldn't go back to Keith's food no matter what.
how did you guys pair the chefs so perfectly i feel like josh gives off zach energy so much and nicole and keith were like two parents whos kids are friends and she was giving him a recipe for a barbecue or something
Exact reason why they are working together.
They are two of the chefs that work for Rhett and Link for Good Mythical Morning! They also have a podcast called "A Hotdog is a Sandwich", and they both have their own spinoff channel from Mythical called Mythical Kitchen if you want to see more content from them!
Gotta side with Keith on the whole "You based the winner on a hypothetical?" comment. Should've been more based on the final product and from the sounds of it they had waayyyy more issues consuming Zach's than they did with Keith's.
yo fr, i'd rather sit confused eating subpar cheeseburger wellington than struggle eating almost sundubu jjigae with RAW ginger chunks every few bites. at least the wellington was a fully realized dish, zach just literally butchered (albeit very entertainingly) josh's recipe 😭
Agreed
I thought keith had it in the bag (although really poorly, but still!)
Exactly. Wasn't the whole point figuring out who was better at communication and execution of the instructions??? This was the most unfair judged try guys video ever and I'm bummed
Maybe Keith’s on to something when he said Roy Choi doesn’t like him lol
as a vegetarian i would’ve chosen keith’s dish over zachs so very easily. it looked edible. it was actually following instructions to the best of the ability, and keith tried with the plating. and none of the judges said “it doesn’t smell right” or “my last try guys ever” to the dish. i don’t know where the ganged up hate came in for keith, but he truly was robbed of that win. that being said i do love zach but it was so unfair.
I can’t believe zach essentially won because he was making an established dish that *could* have been passable in another universe! Nicole was making up a recipe on the fly and it was enjoyable!!! Or at the very least Roy could swallow it lol
Hmmm a white male won over a minority woman. Nooooo!!!!! 😐😐 Stupid
EXACTLY like, what happened between shots to make them choose zach and Josh's???
@@roulettetime9549 I said this above, but I think that Zach and Josh were set up. There is no "not setting this up" reason to have given the box that would make Josh choose to try to coach the one Try Guy whose character can't cook at all (though we've seen Zach the person cook in videos) through making a Korean dish when Roy is a judge.
They judged it based on wether they would eat it again at all, something can be technically fine and something you wouldn't eat again in favor of something else (and tbf, they said they didn't enjoy eating either)
I’m glad Keith got partnered with someone who could rage for him in the most enjoyable way possible
Nicole was so immediately ready to fight the judges lmaoo she was the perfect macht for keith
right?? it was so funny
Good thing Ned was only a judge in this one. I have a feeling he would've cheated
Bro - 💀💀
HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA DOUBLE HOMICIDE
Baaazing!
😂😂😂😂😂
Doh! 💀
I love the completely unnecessary nuisance of the payphones with quarters haha
I'm old enough to remember pay phones🙄
And the ball in a cup!
@@gabiluch87 I hope they have different mini games in future episodes but with the same level of randomness
Sorry but Keith & Nicole should have won, it should be based on the dish at hand, not what you imagine it could have been. In the same vein you could be like, “If we had some burger buns this would have been a really unique burger!” The video was entertaining but the judgement was pretty unfair.
Agreed, the judging was bs!!!
Nicole was ROBBED. That cheese burger Wellington turned out great. And all the judges said it was not bad and edible enough, they all ate quite a lot. They could barely eat Zachary with all the raw ginger, and odd ratio of flavours 💀
Nicole was SUCH a delight in this episode. By the time she tried the dish, she was so resigned to whatever that she had, that she loved it. I'm happy for her and Keith's weird giant beefy pancake thing.
Edit: WHAT THE HECK HOW DID THEY LOSE
@@scoober4386 THE CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT HAHAHAHA I UNDERSTANS YOUR PAIN
+
He didn’t even want to swallow the soup!! How could they win?!
Exactly! It makes no sense.
FIXED!
Watch from 30:09 then everything will make sense to you .... It is just a show, enjoy!!!
The judge would eat Zach's food again as a dip, but not Keith's food. If there was a chip, they would eat Zach's food. But they wouldn't go back to Keith's food no matter what.
Because his first bite had expectations. Every bite after that was absent of those expectations, and he could taste it for what it was. Not that difficult to comprehend. I've had the same experience with what I thought was a mini berry smoothie (it turned out to be a beetroot health shot...)
Roy Choi is PERFECTLY MADE for TH-cam. He’s witty and knowledgeable and really engaging. He should continue collabing and do more TH-cam!
Loving this series!!!
The Cheeseburger Wellington looks and sounds amazing, especially given the inherent problems caused by the disconnect between brain and hands.
Zach and Josh's sundubu, on the other hand, actually had the judges pulling faces of disgust.
Literally the only reason they won was because the judges were like "Well, I would eat it if someone who knows what they're doing had made it."
I respect Josh, I like his recipes, and I would respect the decision had he himself prepared it, but Zach's execution just didn't warrant a win.
Keith and Nicole were _robbed_ .
Not if "someone else made it", but if there were chips they would still eat again. While they wouldn't go back to eat Keith's food again no matter what.
they were so rude about keiths dish without it even being served yet. You could see how much keith cared
They literally saw it and laughed at it. Like... that wellington looked like some of Keith's best work on the channel! And they saw it and laughed at it! Why?
@@FlurarInuyi Ned laughed at it the most if you look closely. The others were smiling or just staring.
I was REALLY hoping Nicole and Josh would get the chance to redeem themselves and cook a separate dish to serve the judges afterwards as like a "here's what we're both capable of ACTUALLY" to both the judges and viewers (who are new to nicole and josh) because these two are both VERY talented and accomplished chefs.
Was looking for this comment!! I agree lol I woud have loved to see Josh's ACTUAL concept for his dish, 😂
I…third this comment, I wanna see josh and Nicole kick ass on every food adjacent-channel
SAME! For josh at least
"The mind of a chef partnered with the hands of an idiot." HAHAHAHAHAHAHA THIS IS AN EXCITING NEW SERIES!!!
"Today we will be judging on *presentation, taste and execution* "
Presentation: Keith clearly did a better presentation even if he didn't cut it up (even included lettuce and tomatoes like a real cheeseburger!). Every bowl that Zach prepared was sloppy and messy
Taste: C'mon now, Chef Roy could barely swallow the first bite for the sundubu
Execution: LITERALLY HAD CHUNKS OF GINGER. Zach almost contaminated the whole kitchen with raw pork and could barely keep up with Josh's instructions. Keith did everything accordingly and cooperated well with Nicole
Tldr: Keith and Nicole were R O B B E D
For real! I’m annoyed about this BS decision.
Agreed
genuinely dont get how zach won. loved the video but the result was bull
Completely agree
i agree i thought for sure nicole and kieth won that as oooo zachs was just a complete mess all around
At first I was like “Okay idk about Nicole” then I was like “holy mother I love Nicole”
I was like “this guys kinda cool” then I was like “josh has the patience of a saint.”
@@PhilVaive
Mythical Kitchen: In which Josh is Zach and Nicole is still Nicole!
I really hope this becomes a series, especially with Mythical kitchen! Competitive try guys and competitive chefs? Yes please, I need more of that!
The pain in Nicole's eyes when she asked for a clean bowl just killed me
😂
Josh: Are your cooking muscles warmed up?
Zach: If this requires muscles, we are in serious trouble
Meanwhile the previous video was Zach gaining like 20lbs of muscle
I don't understand why they were laughing at Keith's dish! It looked pretty good!!!! 😂
Also how did he lose????
i'm so sick of keith getting robbed in these cooking challenges. the judges actually ATE his dish and their biggest complaint was that it was too dense to eat more of. roy couldn't even swallow the first bite of zach's
no literally
A billion percent!!
Honestly the chef set Keith up for failure, beef Weldon is one of the hardest dishes to make and you’re not meant to have fully cooked meat inside of it. And she hasn’t even made it herself and expected Keith to do it successfully.
Don’t take it so seriously y’all. It’s for entertainment
Whole heartedly agree
If Eugene was paired with Nicole we would've had a whole new level of energy in the video 😂🔥
Omg yes please lol
Ok but the crazy recipes of Josh and Eugene vs the more traditional styles of Nicole and Ned
@@Ari-ep2ub damn you're right. They would've probably creating a whole new cuisine 😂
What are you talking about? She and Keith were vibing. I loved their dynamic.
ehh. i don’t think eugene matched her “aggressive” personality well. his role is the “dark” one of the group but he’s actually very tame/shy and he doesn’t really have that aggressive edge to him. when you have someone more meek matched with someone more intense aggressive it doesn’t really work, but when it’s two intense people like nicole and keith it’s funny
This is a GENIUS format. Not to mention, the best crossover on the internet
Should tell that to @sorted food then....
@@snigdhabharadwaj3591 omg can we get sorted, mythical and try guys together?! That would be the ultimate combo!
Haven't enjoyed a Try Guys video so much in a while.
"Zach seems like he absorbs knowledge really well"
**Camera cuts to Zach looking at a spoon** 😂😂😂
😅
Keith was robbed! Zach winning by 5 different hypotheticals basically should have been a clue that the dish was horrible. "If your dish was done like A-Z then it would be good" doesn't scream winning dish to me
Okay but Nicole channeling Keith's energy with him as her hypeman was pretty worth it
Keith and Nicole got robbed! Theirs was perfectly edible, and the other couldn't even be swallowed without picking out chunks of ginger!
How do u know u werent there to try it lmao
@@prettyfemme you can literallly tell keith and nicole the judges were saying is not bad and such and for zach and josh they literally struggled and roasted the crap of it
@@knightbot23 Exactly! And they ate a lot of it! So it can't be that bad! And it looked good 😄
I guess the only thing I could think is, that while Nicole's dish was "cheeseburger inspired" none of them got that feel from it, despite it being actually good to eat. And Josh's, while it didn't taste good, it was clearly following a specific Asian dish and it executed on that more. But I think taste still has to be a major factor in deciding who wins things like this
Also the fact that Roy couldn't even really bring himself to eat Josh/Zach's dish.......like......yeah
And finally Ned said that's "good" if you don't eat all of the ingredients, meaning the whole dish cannot be enjoyed, only the broth basically, which of course tastes good and flavorful because they put a lot of spices in it
And yet they kept eating it despite the chunks of ginger
I said “OH NO” out loud when Josh got Zach and I think that was the right response
I esp. love that Zach clearly said he hates being told what to do and doesn't listen or follow directions. It was doomed from the start. I am so ps'd he even won, lol
As soon as I knew Zach had to make rice, I thought it was all over for them xd
I haven’t started watching the video yet, but I saw your comment and liked it because I know enough to agree.
Nicole embodying keiths energy when yelling is fantastic. I love her and her big sister energy so much.
The Mythical Kitchen and Try Guys crossover I didn’t know I needed, but really needed!
Exactly!!!
Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaas
For real
I would love to see this done again, it was incredibly entertaining!
Exactly what we all need
Zach in a kitchen is painful. I love him, but how has he not picked up a single cooking skill by now.... Well... I guess nothing exploded so..
Can't wait for more of this!
I was thinking the same thing
I'm starting to get the vibe that it's an act. Ned literally has a cookbook out and when he's participating he's just as "bad" as everyone else. He makes noob mistake after noob mistake.
@@kaldo_kaldo yup been thinking the same. Love Zach but get actually frustrated with him in the kitchen sometime. Like, his "character" is to be bad and throw out all the rules even though he definitely knows some now.
@@musical_kait it was actually so bothersome this episode :(
@@carmiebbt I felt so bad for Josh 😭
Was dying laughing when Nicole was telling Keith what a great job he was doing, and Josh just goes "Zach is asking where the water is and I don't know what to tell him" lmao
Lol her repeatedly telling Keith 'SIZE DOESN'T MATTER" had me laughing
I demand a rematch, Keith and Nicole should have won. They actually ate it and clearly liked it more???? this gotta be rigged
I wouldn’t say they “liked” it 😂
Yeah! The judges didn't spit any of it out, for one
hahaha so let me get this straight.
Josh won because if they changed the recipe, took out the stuff that didn't work, got a the smallest amount on a chip (and pray there wasn't any ginger in it) it's edible
But Nicole lost because it was weird that it was inspired by a cheeseburger and didn't taste like a cheeseburger?
rigged
ikr, I agree !!!!!!
well SOMEBODY is salty about something they had no stake in...
@@aff77141 shut up alf
Yes!!! I was fuming. They were literally offended by Josh's but Nicole still lost? Made no sense.
Honestly! They literally said it was good when they had it with lettuce, it’s dumb
"Today we will be judging on *presentation, taste and execution* "
*Proceeds to throw everything out of the window during actual judging*
It’s because Rosanna was leading the charge
I feel like a lot might of gotten cut out of this, because in this final cut, the judging on the one that ended up winning was all bad and the other seemed at least passable from the judging.
Nicole's idea seemed inventive though not as tasty as it sounds, but the execution was pretty good besides the flat outside and unevenness of ingredients inside. Josh's idea sounded really good, but the execution broke down in many places. Weird to judge on a theoretical outcome, though, kind of dismisses the point of this format.
I was having such a good time watching the intro…then I saw Ned 💀
I am looking forward to comments like this smothering me for the next couple of months. It was bad enough when the Yogscast booted a bunch of their guys and nobody ever shut the fuck up about it for like a year - now I can't even escape the bullshit drama in my OTHER favourite channel.
Bro....same
@@jesselindsey9760 touch grass.
@@jesselindsey9760 wait wtf happened w yogscast ??? i haven’t watched them in years
@@jesselindsey9760 relax
I still think Keith should have won, but I loved the premise of the game, and the pairing of Nicole and Keith was incredible, such ana amazing video
Really? I've disagreed with some of the wins on other cooking videos but this was truly a slap in the face. I don't know if it was editing, but it looked like Keith and Nicole had this one in the bag the whole video then got judged on unfair criteria of "if we could change what we didn't like about it." Was the same consideration given to the wellington? They could have made it more like a cheeseburger or more like a wellington just as easily.
Love how Zach is a dumpster fire in cooking even with an chef as his guide while Keith is thriving and yet still cant win.
Why is Ned being so critical??? Keith’s food was presented so well and I bet it tasted fine.
because he knew he was gonna get cancelled...... LOL
Because he whines in every video trying to make himself look better?
Seems power corrupts Ned
I'm honestly surprised they didn't edit him out of THIS one. They did for the chocolate edition.
@@danielleking262 it’s because this video came out a week before they found out about him cheating. :/
Nicole describing herself as having 40 yr old mom energy was so on point!
She’s right (complimentary)
😂😅
Josh literally looked like he was on the verge of tears while they (Roy Choi) were judging the food, someone hug this man
I'll volunteer as tribute! Volunteer 🙋♀️
Chef: "you need a mug you can throw in the trash"
Zach: *gets his own merch mug*
And I was like "why throw in the trash??" Just wash the damn thing afterwards, wtf, lol
@@danielleking262 I didn't understand the drama behind that part; Zach spends a bunch of time complaining that he has raw pork on his hands so he can't do anything and lets his stuff burn?
@@danieljungers8094 I guess because time was crucial that he had to keep stirring or continue cooking because they were running out of time but he stupidly just didn't bother go washing his hands first, so he couldn't touch anything.
@@danielleking262 I would've just held the pot with my pork hand and wiped it later, is that weird? lol
@@martian8979 No, lol. I just don't get why Zach couldn't run to the sink to quickly wash off, or maybe just grab a towel to hold the pot?? There could've been so many solutions here. 🤦♀️😆
So to be clear, one dish was "extremely easy to make" and was inedible, with chunks of raw ingredients, with a bad presentation, and the other was "not as puffed as I'd like", very difficult to make, well cooked, and beautifully presented. One team was in control and competent. One team was a nightmare. And you gave the win to the inedible food that looked bad and wasn't cooked. Sure sure. Makes total sense. WTF
Literally! All those hypotheticals they put in like wtf the point of it was to be the END result and not some “omg imagine what if could be” actually had me so angry
@@oinkpersonpeeps1692 Right? Everyone is pissed off about this!!
Sounds a lot like the 2016 Presidential election/candidates... we handed our country to inedible, badly presented nightmare fuel for four years because the other option wasn't exactly how we wanted it to be... lolsob... it's gorram allegorical....
@@oinkpersonpeeps1692 "Imagine what it could be?" Exactly! Josh made a dish so common that Koreans eat it for breakfast, lunch and dinner...as opposed to Nicole's reimagining of Beef Wellington.
Literally. At this point, I'm almost 100% sure that Keith not winning is a bit they're running and it's really annoying.
Keith: "okay, mom"
Nichole:"I love you, honey"
Keith: " I love you, tooo"
Meanwhile in the other phone booth:
Josh: "Zach, If you f*ked me on this, i swear to god, I will just rain hell fire on you"🔥🔥🔥
😂👏👏👏
😅
Nicole: I love you, honey
Josh: I will rain hellfire on you
I love how they switched personalities in the end
I was recently thinking “Aw I love without a recipe but I feel like they’ve nearly run out of categories so it’ll probably end soon” and then you make this and it’s JUST AS AMAZING I’m obsessed. Thank you for keeping that chaotic cooking hole in my heart filled 🥰
they’re doing a very similar show (no recipe road-trip) for the food network so i assume they won’t be able to post w/out a recipe on youtube for a while :/
plus we get some Food Network ''Without a Recipe'' content sometime soon and I cant freaking wait
@@mirrrstery I believe it starts this upcoming Wednesday.
Also: they could have a series of them actually learning to do the things they made (food, clothes, wigs, etc.) and being instructed by professionals.
Or having professionals execute their ideas. I would looove that for a lot of things! I need closure
0:54 "This is my last Try Guys" while the camera focuses on Ned is a bit foreshadowing...
I noticed that as well 😂
Nicole just saying “you’re ugly” when she was out of insults 🤣
What part was that? I was looking for it after I saw your comment but I never heard her say that. What is the time stamp for it?
that had me deaddd lmfao
@@danielleking262 it’s in their argument around 8:30
@@nataliecox7668 ohh I totally missed that, hahaha. Thank you!
The fact that Josh and Nicole are the “celebrity chefs” is great
I haven't even watched this video, but I am already loving it. Some of my favorite creators collabing is always a good time.
So instead of basing the winner on the criteria, they threw all that out the window and based it off of "would they eat this if it was made correctly." Justice for Nicole and Keith.
But for real, this is a great series and I hope this continues. I love it.
Y’all should reverse it!
The try guys taste a dish where they have no idea what it is. The chefs are listening to the try guys describe what they’re eating and try to recreate it.
wait this is so fucking cool
This sounds so fun! I can already imagine Zac trying to describe how a dish tastes 😂
oh god i feel like this concept has been done before, I think it was worst cooks of america? really cool concept tho :)
I feel so bad for Josh having to present that dish to someone he truly respects in his field.
I laughed but God did I feel bad about it
😅
This was so chaotic and fun. Nicole delivering the Keith rant at the end was especially great!
And she built up to it, too. She started out slow, then REALLY started channeling Keith's meltdown energy. Very well done
She did it perfectly!
I love how Nicole had really similar vibes with Keith throughout the whole presentation. The "maybe you should try it that way" or "well i don't know what you are talking about" or "this tastes great, what?". The screaming bit was perfect! That's some quality duo right there
WHAT?!!? They liked Zach’s only if Zach didn’t make it, and it was a completely different dish?? They couldn’t even properly eat it. This is the first time this judging decision was pure bullshit
Honestly
It doesn’t make any sense
“If you gave me a chip it’d be good”
If you put the insides of Nicole/Keith’s on a bun ITD PROBABLY BE GOOD
Their only criticism was the ground beef with cheese didn’t taste like a cheeseburger. What?! And the puff pastry didn’t puff. Meanwhile there was raw ginger in every bite and the trash part of scallions.
Honestly I'd take a whole season of this, this entire concept was hysterical and wonderful. XD
I've been WAITING for Josh to return to the try guys since his debut as a judge on Without a Recipe!! Loving the Mythical-Guys collab so much!
Josh chaotic energy vibes well with the guys
Me too!! I knew he was good for the try guys right away when he appreciated eugene for using pig’s blood in his cinnamon rolls. That’s a kind of crazy genius that’s accepted with the Try Guys.
on which without a recipe vid did he judge??
@@-Bente- cinammon rolls
@@gabiluch87 thank you!!
It's still so funny to me that Try Guys is probably now becoming one of the biggest cooking channels when they don't even know how to cook. I think I'll consider their cooking shows the winner of all cooking shows when they get Gordon Ramsay to judge. JUST IMAGINE.
Gordon Ramsay would step into the building and like Obi-Won that shit "There's been a disturbance in the force. A great tragedy has occurred" just from the lingering memories of the horrors the guys have made
Man I am pissed about Ketih's dish being shit on but ho boy I absolutely LOVED Nicole being in this. She's hilarious and charismatic. Her bickering with Josh was so fucking funny that made my day.
This is brilliant! It’s better than a lot of tv shows right now
It REALLY is! Couldn't agree more!
Agreed, that’s why the inventors of this format, Sorted food, are so brilliant
The montage of Keith and Zach making fun of Ned’s sauce on his face made my night 😂😂😂
Love this so much! All the sass and chaos I am here for
I feel like the chefs should make their dish the way they intended after and then have the judges try them to compare!
I was left wanting something like that too! Especially after they tried out the soup
I was thinking the same thing!
I was thinking the same thing
This literally HURT watching Roy Choi just destroy Josh. I hope Josh gets a chance to cook for Roy on his own.
I love that Nicole spends most of her phone booth time looking into the camera. She's like, "I don't know if this is gonna turn out well, but what I do know is how to 👏work👏that👏camera."
I can’t believe they based the decision off of a hypothetical. I think Keith and Nicole did so much better communicating and the end product was actually what they had tried to make.
Yeah, I feel like Keith and Nicole should have won, so true.
I agree 100%. Was actually going to make the same comment before I saw yours.
I dunno. Beef wellington really doesn't look like that xD
I totally agree 💯 percent!!!!!
@@na3rial But it was "Hamburger" Wellington.
I would LOVE to see Roy Choi on an episode of Mythical Kitchen (maybe food fears) so Josh can "redeem" himself.
I like the idea. I just don't know if Roy Choi has any actual food fears. He certainly has developed "Try Guys cook" - fear...
The food fear is letting zach and Keith cook
The cheeseburger wellington looked so good I'm mad Nicole didn't win. A bowl of spicy ketchup chili won instead.
With other judging type videos, whether i agree with the result or not, I usually don’t get upset. However with this one I am because clearly Keith and Nicole communicated well and their dish seemed more edible since the judges ate it more than the other one. This resulted made no sense
usually zack’s eccentric energy is fun to watch, but when he intentionally dropped the eggshell in the plated bowl, i had to stop.
@@flclhack yeah same it was just kinda idk annoying
i think thats the point lol its a funny game show, it doesnt have to make sense, it just needs to be entertaining
@@remythefatrat I don't like it when he pretends to be more clumsy than he actually is, especially in such a blatant way. If he actually fucks up is funny, but if he has to pretend then it's not. I love videos where they cook (bc the judging part is always interesting) but this one was too scripted. I felt uneasy at times, especially when they pretended to fight (Zach with Josh or Nicole with Josh), that was so lame. Her losing the coin was much more funnier and that was unscripted. Try Guys' value is spontaneity, they don't do as well with scripted bits, I don't understand why they keep insisting, it's too staged. They're not actors so it's clear they're pretending and it gets annoying. And dropping the eggshell is the clear example of how playing dumb is not funny.
I feel like Josh should have the opportunity to make Roy something himself as payment for this. Poor man.
I felt like when it came down to the judges judging Nicole and Keith’s dish the judges said meh the whole time and there was no positive about it. However, when they got to Josh and Zack’s judging they all collectively knew the food was going to be bad and they tried so hard to find and say positives about it. Loved the episode up until the judging part!
It's the sad curse of Keith, I'm convinced Keith is cursed to always be underappreciated. Love you Keith, sorry about your curse.
They talked shit and said good things about both wtf u on about watch the video again lmao they said good and bad things for both made fun of both like?
@@gnats4109 I feel like Nicole played into Keith's weakness of being overly ambitious, which usually seems to be what gets him in Without a Recipe. He's definitely more competent, but this was a hard dish!
Zach acts chaotic on purpose. He literally try’s to do a bad job on purpose. Ned was eating the burger Wellington as if he had never seen food before in his life yet still trash talked it the whole time. I’m confused.
Not gonna lie, I’d love to see Gordon Ramsey lose his mind trying to do this with the try guys 😂
He would explode 😭😭🤣🤣 or treat them the way he does the kid chefs from his shows. Lmfao
He would obliterate them LMAO
Gordon would literally scream at half the guys like it's HK and comfort the other half like it's Masterchef Kids. All while cry laughing into his hands that they're all walnuts everytime he got off the phone.
Unless it was for charity, he would never lol
YES
This was hilarious. That being said, the mental gymnastics they went through so Nicole and Keith would lose were over the top. If you think it’s funnier when Keith loses just say so 😌
It seems to me that they gave Zach and Josh the win because they were clearly sabotaged. They knew that with that box, Josh would go to Korean food and only then told him that Roy Choi would be one of the judges.
They hated the execution and presentation of both and preferred the taste of the korean dish. I think you're doing mental gymnastics to imagine Nicole and Keith should have won
@@oliviarecommends Sabotaged? As Chef Roy said, it really takes an expert to mess up something so simple like sundubu. Keith's dish clearly required more expertise and he pulled it off (somewhat) whereas Zach somehow messed up a soup! AND they won despite Rpy Choi being one of the judges, I don't see how they were "clearly sabotaged"
@@kaldo_kaldo Also, they relentlessly criticized Keith's dish in every aspect and didn't say anything positive about it yet they somehow managed to say smtg positive for everything in Zach's dish and completely ignored the horrible execution and presentation? I call bs.
@@kyo6322 Okay. Sabotage wasn't the right word. I should have said "set up" like I did in other posts
Roy Choi, oh my god. He's so good. Really, really hoping for him to actually come back again. I'm crying laughing.
I think everyone would appreciate it if the Try Guys genuinely tried their hardest and had honest judging BASED ON THE RHETORIC IN THE BEGINNING OF THE VIDEO. This is such a fun concept, please don't ruin it with "OMG WE CANT COOK ANYTHING AT ALLLL" and making deliberate mistakes. Real efforts are more entertaining. I love you guys
Yeah Eugene has the right idea rn, the schticks are getting old lmao
Totally agree
@@stevierose8749 When did he say that. Not that I don’t disagree with him. I just don’t remember saying him that
I think they genuinely try. They just suck🤣🤣🤣🤣 That's the beauty of it
idk how you could say that when Keith at least really and truly did try his best here.