how about this: 1 perk change per video. so, you must evaluate whether to remove one from the first build, or to wait for the second incase something worse shows up. i think that could be interesting...
I like this idea, but I would also say to add back the Any perk slot and to make sure whatever he replaces something with has some synergy with the build. I feel if there isn’t that restriction he might just want to replace the perk with Corrupt every time lol
I'd like to see you can change a perk but to a similarly themed perk, like don't just change furtive chase to deadlock or whatever, go for another obsession or stealth type perk.
Add back in the possibility to get an “any” slot, as well allowing a single perk change per video. The only rule for the perk swap is that it has to create synergy with at least 2 perks you already got 😁. Love u tofu
5:48 - For RBT activation, as long as you've started the animation to place the hat before the gen pops, the hat is active. I've had some where I've literally hit the button at the same time as the gen popping and it was active when they got unhooked. 14:46 - "Steven, why?" Even when Tofu says it I still hear Vulpixia, lol. As for the perk changing... that was kinda what the Any slot was for. I'd be against just replacing a perk at will because sometimes you've had games where a perk you though was absolutely pointless in the build has actually been useful, and that's one of my favorite parts of these videos.
What I think you could do is that if you don’t like a perk, you could randomize the perk you don’t like again. Basically you would remember the current build, hit the randomize button for the perks, and choose the new randomized perk.
I feel a fairly decent idea would be to reroll again, and be able to swap in a single perk from the new build, it keeps the random energy but doesn't make a build that's completely unplayable likely
If possible, to keep the theme with being a randomized build I recommend giving yourself 3 randomize 'tokens' you can spend to re-roll a single perk. It could be fun to see you roll the dice on if you keep a mediocre perk or roll into a really, really good perk
I like to watch you struggle with whatever perks it gives you. I think it's the magic of it, watching how the knowlegdable player close to 10k hours you are manage to get the best out of the build.
So idea for a perk change, you have to also spin a wheel or roll a D4 dice to see which perk you change before you randomize the build and then whatever you get you HAVE to change that perk but you can put whatever you think will synergize with the rest of the perks. That way it’s randomness for your random perk wheel
I think that if you feel that the perks are all dog doodoo, you can try and change one, but only to try and synergize the build. Another option is rolling 4 more perks and swapping in one of the new 4, perhaps the one in the same position? No take backsies though.
always love the randomizer videos Tofu 💗 i don't agree you should take one perk and choose another that you like, in my opinion that takes away the magic of the randomness
i think its cool to change a perk just to actually make it into a build just because if it's 4 crap perks then it isnt much of a build lol. or hows about these two suggestions, maybe if the build has perks that contradict one another then maybe then you can for sure swap. The other idea is maybe you can re roll 1 perk and that can keep the random factor to it
I agree that some videos are hard to watch but you is what makes it enjoyable. However, your sanity while playing is something I consider. Picking a perk to make the build work beats the Random goal of the video. My two suggestions is, either do a reroll with the randomizer and whatever rolls again in that slot you can replace it with. If that does not work than select one of the 4 random ones that got rolled. However, you can not go and pick one out of all the perks only one of the ones that rerolled in the second options and you can only replace one perk. My two cents
Hi Tofu! What about the ability to change one perk, with the caveat you must try to make as coherent a build as possible with the provided perks, rather than just picking whatever perk you want (which would probably end up being a slow down perk lol)? Another commenter also mentioned '1 perk change per video' so you have to decide when to use it, which I also like.
Always fun to watch even when you have a rough game. One idea is when you win a randomizer video, you get to a rerandom to use one perk in a future match.
This might be a little weird but what if you give yourself like 4 tokens, and that allows you to change anything in the build but only 4 times between both killers (so like add-ons, offerings are also included) So you have to be smart in how you change it and what you want to change. If 4 is too much maybe just 2?
I like these videos because you get to see how unpopular perks work in match (I only have time for a couple games a week, so that's very helpful for me). If the build is entirely trash then I'd say change one though.
what if you re-randomized one perk? so its either take the build as is or if you re-roll it you have to take the new perk? still random but gives you a little more control?
I personally prefer that you keep what you roll. I think that’s in the spirit of the challenge. If you start getting to make changes, then where do you end up drawing the line?
about the changing perks, I was thinking that maybe once you get the build, if a perks is completely useless, you could copy everything from that build except for that perk, reroll and choose a new perk from the re-randomized ones, idk if I explained it well, hope so lmao
You can change 1 perk per buld but only if its absolutely worthless (hangmans trick on all killers still stays, but only on pyramidhead not because he cant use it) and change it with a perk that is the same tier (dont just change underlenting with pop or something like this)
if you want, you can have one chance to change the perk but use the randomizer to decide the new perk to replace it so you keep the randomizer aspect going
That 2nd game is just a video essay on why I'll always be a killer main first & most. My goodness what a cluster. I hope you go back and try that purple add on cause it's one of the more wacky ones & I think its a ton of fun.
I think you can change 1 perk. For example if you don’t like the top right perk you would press the random button again and whatever it is you replace the old top right one
What if you just rerolled one more time for ONE perk? Like even if the randomized doesn’t let you, write down what you HAD, reroll and replace one of them?
As for replacing a perk if its bad or has no synergy, i feel like the only way to keep it feeling random is to randomize it again and take That specific perks slot on the next randomzation and then choose between them or something like that
How about this. You take 3 perks from the build, then re-randomize. Then you pick one perk from the new 4 perks to replace it with. Gives you some control without removing the randomizer aspect.
How about re rolling untill you get one of each type of perk? One slowdown, one chase, one tracking and one utility? It's still random but it gives you at least SOMETHING to work with. Or, keep the worst perk and build around it trying to get value?
I don't mind either way honestly. Maybe flip a virtual coin in addition to the randomizer. Heads you get to replace a perk, tails you don't. Keeps the spirit of the randomizer while allowing for you to make the build better.
I've said that in the last video, that imo it would be great to choose a perk that has synergy with the build. And honestly, i think that would also help people know what perks go well with each other.. Like it would help them create new builds?
I have a suggestion for future movies and randomizing. Pick a random killer, then you have to take One of their three exclusive perks on the build, for example, if you got the Doctor, then you would have to take either overwhelming presence, overcharge, or monitor and abuse. After that, you get three rolls on the randomizer for perks, each time you roll, take one of the four perks and add it to your build. After three rolls and a killer exclusive perk, there's your build. it's not completely random yet not completely exclusive either, and you stand a better chance of putting together a build that makes sense.
The way we usually do it is to re-roll a perk and pick what comes up in its spot. Unless it's a perk you already have from before that's what you take, else you just reroll it again until you get a fresh perk. That way it's still random, but you got at least a chance of taking something awful and maybe getting something better.
I think changing out one perk is a good idea, it would help with the problem that a lot of the randomized builds end up being basically perkless. some people say it isn't fun if it isn't completely random but it also isn't really fun if the build does nothing and being able to swap a perk would help with that.
I think if the build is unusable, you should do a number generator of 1-4 where if you get the numbers 1/2, thats the amount of perks you can change but if you get 3/4, then you have to use the randomize generator to give you a different build (but same killer + addons as the first). Hope this wasnt confusing, love your content !! 💖
You could keep the randomness and still allow a reroll, just roll again on the website. Use the first random build allowing yourself to replace one perk, but it has to be a perk from the second roll on the site.
I know this might not completely fix the problem but what if you pick the perk you wanna change then you reroll the Perks and you pick from one of the 4
What if you take the best 3 perks and then roll again and take the best 1 of the second roll to replace the worst one of the first roll. That way it still feels random-ish?
What I have noticed about the randomiser you use is it seems to disproportionately favour the weaker perks. How many of these videos now have we seen Furtive Chase? I used this randomiser before for some of my survivor games and three rolls in a row I got Distortion and Aftercare!
i'd have it so yeah, you can replace a perk, but whatever perk you change it to can't be used outside of rolling it for the next 20 attempts. That way, there's a massive negative to replacing a perk.
I'd like to see you have the ability to re-roll one perk into another random perk once per build/video. The return of the 'any' slot could also be fun. Love the vids! :D
You can swap it out but only with a perk that comes with the killer so you only have a slight chance of making it better and you still don’t get to just pick and choose which perk you choose is still limited
Keep the perks random. Or make it So there are "any" perks , idk if you turned that off or not. But that would allow you to choose your own perk while still making the rest of the build random.
Keep them all random. I would vote for more gameplay with perks that "fits" the killers you play. Keeping the perks that follows the killers is fun imo. Adding perks you feel fit the lore of the killer would be awesome.
Love the piggy game. Always makes me happy to see her. Not sure about the changing builds thing. Though maybe a general “trying to get underused perks to work” serious instead might be really neat?
Changing one perk would be a good idea. Pure randomness of perks is less interesting than giving you a chance to figure out a fourth perk that would make the whole build work. You should extend the rule to add ons: Tofu can change one perk or one add on of the build.
How about you can change 1 perk but you have to do random perks and then you chose 1 out of 4 random perks that you got on a second roll and put it in on initial random build? If you can understand what i mean.
I think run one game with the random perk, then switch one to make it a viable build. I’d like to learn how to pair perks better, so this would really help to illustrate great ways to do it!
Another way to handle the anti-synergy with randomized perks without downright choosing one could be locking a perk in, randomizing again, locking in another and so forth until you have 4.
I say play the randomizer the first time the way it comes out. See what you can synergize with the perks and the next match run the same build but change one of the perks to teach synergy. I hope that all made sense lol. I think it would be fun to learn new things that can go together
If it’s for the sake of getting synergy and maybe making the build somewhat viable, it’s worth swapping one.. makes the game interesting instead of seeing a bunch of dog poop builds and maybe helps shed some light on some different perks/synergy that we don’t ever see if it’s outside of the meta!
If you're going to change a perk I suggest doing it for one of the two games. Not both, just to see what kind of matches you have and get more feedback.
I'd say keep it random all over. Or, as suggested, one slot as any. So you get 3 random perks, and can choose a fitting 4. for that. I think it would keep in the spirit of randomizer videos, where, for me, the fun is, that it is random. But with the perk you choose, you can have a good talk/thoughtexperiment about your plans and what would fit the build you got. I would prefer that over 'you get to choose which perk you want to swap' But at the end of the day, its your videos. Do as you want :)
I say the perk you are hanging has to be from the same killer and or one of the common perks Say you get furtive chase, you can only change it to a ghost face perk. If you get thrill of the hunt you get to choose between any of the common perks
If you do decide to change 1 perk, I think the rule would have to be something to make it more creative.... for example, you don't want to just throw corrupt on each time, even though it would be tempting. So maybe you could make a rule to say you have to create synergy with the perk directly above (or below) the one that you're changing.
I don't think you should be able to swap to a perk of your choosing. It takes away from the randomness so it becomes "Random perk builds* (If we like the perks and if we don't we can change it anyway)". This is also similar to the reason why you disabled the "any" perk in the first place, because you didn't think being able to select a perk felt very random.
if you're going to swap out one perk you should roll a die 1-4 to see which perk you get to swap out, i.e. if the die lands on 3 you can swap the third perk for any of your choice, etc.
I think having the ability to reroll 1 perk per build, but if you do. You must keep the perk you rerolled,hence you could get something worse and have to stick with it.
how about this: 1 perk change per video. so, you must evaluate whether to remove one from the first build, or to wait for the second incase something worse shows up. i think that could be interesting...
I like your idea
@@caniboopthesnoot4216 well thank you!
I like this idea too. It gives Tofu some level of control, while keeping it pretty random.
this is exactly what I was going to suggest. that way it keeps some of the randomness
I like this idea, but I would also say to add back the Any perk slot and to make sure whatever he replaces something with has some synergy with the build. I feel if there isn’t that restriction he might just want to replace the perk with Corrupt every time lol
I'd like to see you can change a perk but to a similarly themed perk, like don't just change furtive chase to deadlock or whatever, go for another obsession or stealth type perk.
Trust me he would do dog shit synergy over picking any stand alone strong perk. That’s why I wouldn’t care to see him pick a perk to synergies
No. Just put "any" back on so you can have that opportunity, occasionally.
It's not random if you're picking the perks.
This 100%
yes
Yes, I loved 'Any' when he used it to grab a perk that made the other perks have some sort of synergy.
Add back in the possibility to get an “any” slot, as well allowing a single perk change per video. The only rule for the perk swap is that it has to create synergy with at least 2 perks you already got 😁. Love u tofu
agreed
Agreed
this is my favorite one that ive seen
OhTofu's voice 🤝 The survivors
Dissapearing when The Spirit starts phasing
Underrated comment under all these answers to my question, fucking 10/10
5:48 - For RBT activation, as long as you've started the animation to place the hat before the gen pops, the hat is active. I've had some where I've literally hit the button at the same time as the gen popping and it was active when they got unhooked.
14:46 - "Steven, why?" Even when Tofu says it I still hear Vulpixia, lol.
As for the perk changing... that was kinda what the Any slot was for. I'd be against just replacing a perk at will because sometimes you've had games where a perk you though was absolutely pointless in the build has actually been useful, and that's one of my favorite parts of these videos.
What I think you could do is that if you don’t like a perk, you could randomize the perk you don’t like again. Basically you would remember the current build, hit the randomize button for the perks, and choose the new randomized perk.
I think you should keep it all random. It’s nice to see it completely random, sometimes it works out pretty good.
Agreed! Imagine if he changed out hangman trick in the first game and didn’t get all of that value!
@@ARMouser absolutely. I figure I’m learning from these randomizers as well…. A lot of the perks I never thought about lol.
@@ARMouser I prefer fully randomized as well, but he definitely would have exchanged furtive chase in the first game ^^
I feel a fairly decent idea would be to reroll again, and be able to swap in a single perk from the new build, it keeps the random energy but doesn't make a build that's completely unplayable likely
yes agreed, that's a great idea
This, actually, is an interesting idea.
That would be lovely
Beats the purpose of being random.
The randomizer had an “any” spawn. I think unless you get in your spin, choosing a perk is not in the spirit of the challenge.
Agreed. Thats the challenge of the randomizer of making dogshit perks work and to play with what you get
I think that first game is proof that just trying to use the random perks can result in some great moments. That's what I love about this series!
I feel like one full perk re-roll would be fair. Keeps the build fully random still while also giving you another chance for some synergy, good or not
No changing perks! random build is great, even better when you have a bad, non-synergizing build
If possible, to keep the theme with being a randomized build I recommend giving yourself 3 randomize 'tokens' you can spend to re-roll a single perk. It could be fun to see you roll the dice on if you keep a mediocre perk or roll into a really, really good perk
I like that it’s always full random, it’s pretty interesting to do these builds
I like to watch you struggle with whatever perks it gives you. I think it's the magic of it, watching how the knowlegdable player close to 10k hours you are manage to get the best out of the build.
I dont like changing a perk because i like when its completely random🤷♂️
I love this series the most, I think. Watching it has become almost nostalgic. Great work as usual Tofu
6:28 they both got their headtraps off in the span of a single second
Completely random is better. But choose whatever you feel comfortable, Tofu. Always support you, much love
As long as OhTofu keeps OhTofuing, I don't mind any change at all. The series will stay very fun
So idea for a perk change, you have to also spin a wheel or roll a D4 dice to see which perk you change before you randomize the build and then whatever you get you HAVE to change that perk but you can put whatever you think will synergize with the rest of the perks. That way it’s randomness for your random perk wheel
I love the talking about hangman’s being bad and it legit saved you like twice
I think that if you feel that the perks are all dog doodoo, you can try and change one, but only to try and synergize the build. Another option is rolling 4 more perks and swapping in one of the new 4, perhaps the one in the same position? No take backsies though.
You can substitute a perk from the shrine of secrets for a shrine showcase type thing. That'll give you two options at least.
That second game summed up the soloQ experience so beautifully :')
That sounds fun! :) I think you should be able to change one of the perks :)
Its entertaining to watch you try to get value out of random questionable perks, and still having hope for good luck draws on actually good perks.
always love the randomizer videos Tofu 💗
i don't agree you should take one perk and choose another that you like, in my opinion that takes away the magic of the randomness
i think its cool to change a perk just to actually make it into a build just because if it's 4 crap perks then it isnt much of a build lol. or hows about these two suggestions, maybe if the build has perks that contradict one another then maybe then you can for sure swap.
The other idea is maybe you can re roll 1 perk and that can keep the random factor to it
I agree that some videos are hard to watch but you is what makes it enjoyable. However, your sanity while playing is something I consider. Picking a perk to make the build work beats the Random goal of the video. My two suggestions is, either do a reroll with the randomizer and whatever rolls again in that slot you can replace it with. If that does not work than select one of the 4 random ones that got rolled. However, you can not go and pick one out of all the perks only one of the ones that rerolled in the second options and you can only replace one perk.
My two cents
i think being able to make the build viable without losing what made it random is ok, like changing a perk to one with more synergy
Hi Tofu! What about the ability to change one perk, with the caveat you must try to make as coherent a build as possible with the provided perks, rather than just picking whatever perk you want (which would probably end up being a slow down perk lol)? Another commenter also mentioned '1 perk change per video' so you have to decide when to use it, which I also like.
this episode had so many WTF moments :D it was amazing :D and I think all random is better than changing it.
Always fun to watch even when you have a rough game. One idea is when you win a randomizer video, you get to a rerandom to use one perk in a future match.
That last match was truly a roller-coaster of emotion lol
This might be a little weird but what if you give yourself like 4 tokens, and that allows you to change anything in the build but only 4 times between both killers (so like add-ons, offerings are also included) So you have to be smart in how you change it and what you want to change. If 4 is too much maybe just 2?
I like these videos because you get to see how unpopular perks work in match (I only have time for a couple games a week, so that's very helpful for me). If the build is entirely trash then I'd say change one though.
Tofu use your powers to make a killer that's just one Bee. I will never stop trying to make this happen.
what if you re-randomized one perk? so its either take the build as is or if you re-roll it you have to take the new perk? still random but gives you a little more control?
Yes you should totally pick one perk because it makes it more interesting and also you get to try to make some fun synergies
I personally prefer that you keep what you roll. I think that’s in the spirit of the challenge. If you start getting to make changes, then where do you end up drawing the line?
about the changing perks, I was thinking that maybe once you get the build, if a perks is completely useless, you could copy everything from that build except for that perk, reroll and choose a new perk from the re-randomized ones, idk if I explained it well, hope so lmao
You can change 1 perk per buld but only if its absolutely worthless (hangmans trick on all killers still stays, but only on pyramidhead not because he cant use it) and change it with a perk that is the same tier (dont just change underlenting with pop or something like this)
if you want, you can have one chance to change the perk but use the randomizer to decide the new perk to replace it so you keep the randomizer aspect going
Feel like it's a 50/50 flip every randomizer video you have that Furtive Chase pops up😂😂
You can change one perk to add some synergy it makes the video much more fun usually I don't give feedback back you've been asking for a bit 😉
That 2nd game is just a video essay on why I'll always be a killer main first & most. My goodness what a cluster. I hope you go back and try that purple add on cause it's one of the more wacky ones & I think its a ton of fun.
I think you can change 1 perk. For example if you don’t like the top right perk you would press the random button again and whatever it is you replace the old top right one
What if you just rerolled one more time for ONE perk? Like even if the randomized doesn’t let you, write down what you HAD, reroll and replace one of them?
My favorite DBD series on YT :)
As for replacing a perk if its bad or has no synergy, i feel like the only way to keep it feeling random is to randomize it again and take That specific perks slot on the next randomzation and then choose between them or something like that
How about this. You take 3 perks from the build, then re-randomize. Then you pick one perk from the new 4 perks to replace it with. Gives you some control without removing the randomizer aspect.
How about re rolling untill you get one of each type of perk? One slowdown, one chase, one tracking and one utility? It's still random but it gives you at least SOMETHING to work with. Or, keep the worst perk and build around it trying to get value?
I don't mind either way honestly. Maybe flip a virtual coin in addition to the randomizer. Heads you get to replace a perk, tails you don't. Keeps the spirit of the randomizer while allowing for you to make the build better.
I’ve never seen a game go to hell into a hand basket for survivors than game 2. Holyy
I've said that in the last video, that imo it would be great to choose a perk that has synergy with the build. And honestly, i think that would also help people know what perks go well with each other.. Like it would help them create new builds?
I have a suggestion for future movies and randomizing. Pick a random killer, then you have to take One of their three exclusive perks on the build, for example, if you got the Doctor, then you would have to take either overwhelming presence, overcharge, or monitor and abuse. After that, you get three rolls on the randomizer for perks, each time you roll, take one of the four perks and add it to your build. After three rolls and a killer exclusive perk, there's your build. it's not completely random yet not completely exclusive either, and you stand a better chance of putting together a build that makes sense.
“This genrushing problem is really getting out of control”😭😭😭😂😂😂
8:28 Oh Tofu, the long lost brother of Chewie
The way we usually do it is to re-roll a perk and pick what comes up in its spot. Unless it's a perk you already have from before that's what you take, else you just reroll it again until you get a fresh perk. That way it's still random, but you got at least a chance of taking something awful and maybe getting something better.
I think changing out one perk is a good idea, it would help with the problem that a lot of the randomized builds end up being basically perkless. some people say it isn't fun if it isn't completely random but it also isn't really fun if the build does nothing and being able to swap a perk would help with that.
I think if the build is unusable, you should do a number generator of 1-4 where if you get the numbers 1/2, thats the amount of perks you can change but if you get 3/4, then you have to use the randomize generator to give you a different build (but same killer + addons as the first). Hope this wasnt confusing, love your content !! 💖
I wonder what is your graphics in dead by daylight to make it brighter
I've stated before I think changing our one perk would be ok, but I like the others suggestions of just adding the 'any' option back in. GG's Tofu!
You could keep the randomness and still allow a reroll, just roll again on the website. Use the first random build allowing yourself to replace one perk, but it has to be a perk from the second roll on the site.
Why not do both?
Do one match with the random build
And then switch stuff out on the second match?
I know this might not completely fix the problem but what if you pick the perk you wanna change then you reroll the Perks and you pick from one of the 4
What if you take the best 3 perks and then roll again and take the best 1 of the second roll to replace the worst one of the first roll. That way it still feels random-ish?
What I have noticed about the randomiser you use is it seems to disproportionately favour the weaker perks. How many of these videos now have we seen Furtive Chase?
I used this randomiser before for some of my survivor games and three rolls in a row I got Distortion and Aftercare!
i'd have it so yeah, you can replace a perk, but whatever perk you change it to can't be used outside of rolling it for the next 20 attempts. That way, there's a massive negative to replacing a perk.
I think you should be able to re-randomize only one perk and having only one opportunity or something like thst
What if you choose 1 of your perks and then hit reroll and can o ly replace it with 1 of the new 4 perks you rolled into?
Imo you should take one of the perks to make synergy which could help highlight some of the "bad" perks
I'd like to see you have the ability to re-roll one perk into another random perk once per build/video. The return of the 'any' slot could also be fun. Love the vids! :D
How do you KEEP getting Furtive Chase?? It feels like it's in almost every random build video
You can swap it out but only with a perk that comes with the killer so you only have a slight chance of making it better and you still don’t get to just pick and choose which perk you choose is still limited
Keep the perks random. Or make it So there are "any" perks , idk if you turned that off or not. But that would allow you to choose your own perk while still making the rest of the build random.
Holy shit! Hangmans value AND a RBT kill! That was absolutely pog
I wonder if new lethal pursuer would make hangman's trick actually a good tracking perk
Keep them all random.
I would vote for more gameplay with perks that "fits" the killers you play. Keeping the perks that follows the killers is fun imo. Adding perks you feel fit the lore of the killer would be awesome.
Love the piggy game. Always makes me happy to see her.
Not sure about the changing builds thing. Though maybe a general “trying to get underused perks to work” serious instead might be really neat?
Crate of Gears Value Lmaoo GG Ohtofu
Changing one perk would be a good idea. Pure randomness of perks is less interesting than giving you a chance to figure out a fourth perk that would make the whole build work. You should extend the rule to add ons: Tofu can change one perk or one add on of the build.
How about you can change 1 perk but you have to do random perks and then you chose 1 out of 4 random perks that you got on a second roll and put it in on initial random build? If you can understand what i mean.
I think run one game with the random perk, then switch one to make it a viable build. I’d like to learn how to pair perks better, so this would really help to illustrate great ways to do it!
Another way to handle the anti-synergy with randomized perks without downright choosing one could be locking a perk in, randomizing again, locking in another and so forth until you have 4.
Would the new monsterus shrine be good on pig?
I say play the randomizer the first time the way it comes out. See what you can synergize with the perks and the next match run the same build but change one of the perks to teach synergy. I hope that all made sense lol. I think it would be fun to learn new things that can go together
If it’s for the sake of getting synergy and maybe making the build somewhat viable, it’s worth swapping one.. makes the game interesting instead of seeing a bunch of dog poop builds and maybe helps shed some light on some different perks/synergy that we don’t ever see if it’s outside of the meta!
If you're going to change a perk I suggest doing it for one of the two games. Not both, just to see what kind of matches you have and get more feedback.
I'd say keep it random all over. Or, as suggested, one slot as any. So you get 3 random perks, and can choose a fitting 4. for that. I think it would keep in the spirit of randomizer videos, where, for me, the fun is, that it is random. But with the perk you choose, you can have a good talk/thoughtexperiment about your plans and what would fit the build you got.
I would prefer that over 'you get to choose which perk you want to swap'
But at the end of the day, its your videos. Do as you want :)
1:04 no.. thats the whole videos point.. and if you do that its gone. Absolutely agree with 1:34
I say the perk you are hanging has to be from the same killer and or one of the common perks
Say you get furtive chase, you can only change it to a ghost face perk.
If you get thrill of the hunt you get to choose between any of the common perks
You could try to change a perk per video, or you could turn on the "any" option, so that when you get that you could pick your perk.
If you do decide to change 1 perk, I think the rule would have to be something to make it more creative.... for example, you don't want to just throw corrupt on each time, even though it would be tempting. So maybe you could make a rule to say you have to create synergy with the perk directly above (or below) the one that you're changing.
"Coo day grah"? So you're telling me it's not "Cup of grapes"? What is life.. Kappa Great content as always Tofers
I don't think you should be able to swap to a perk of your choosing. It takes away from the randomness so it becomes "Random perk builds* (If we like the perks and if we don't we can change it anyway)".
This is also similar to the reason why you disabled the "any" perk in the first place, because you didn't think being able to select a perk felt very random.
I feel like a good re roll idea would be to either reroll the killer or perks but not both
if you're going to swap out one perk you should roll a die 1-4 to see which perk you get to swap out, i.e. if the die lands on 3 you can swap the third perk for any of your choice, etc.
I think having the ability to reroll 1 perk per build, but if you do. You must keep the perk you rerolled,hence you could get something worse and have to stick with it.