A friend of mine said to me “ without check and balance freedom is free doom” I add this to his saying “without check and balance and rule of law freedom is free doom” Hermela I thank you your hard work for change. I thank your mother for raising you to become a guiding light. I love your guest.
Derege Demissie, you’re one special analyst. We would have been in a much better place if our leaders could have listen this well and implement that right to everyone. God bless you for giving us this eloquently spoken insight sir. Thank you Hermela for having him in your show.
I would like to thank both of you! Very important concepts I perceived and I believe many can have better understanding about structure of a democratic and federalism nation. Hermela I have the same background as you and I knew how TPLF used and using our people! We need to end these arrogant and racist rule. You are a hero and keep it up! Long Live Ethiopia 🇪🇹
You deserve a lot of support. You are doing a wonderful job at being a journalist in an era where being neutral is considered unmarketable. Thank you for everything.
Our amazing brilliant daughter, you are a hero. History will remember you. Your brilliant mom must be very proud!!! She did a great job raising you. Thank you 🙏
I love what you bring to the table. It is of good taste and great quality. Keep it coming. Journalism at its best. Thank you. What an amazing discussion. I pray the children of tigray region soon will be educated in the matters of Mama Ethiopia..stand as 1!
I am impressed by this intellectual discussion. When intellectuals are silent, cadres take over and countries het destroyed. When you hear more about Ethnic federalism and its danger, I am surprised how we survived so far. It’s an ethnic prison. As Derege said, we need to think of Ethiopia 300 years from now.
That sums it all. Nice ending btw, I was just getting warmed up. Keep up the excellent job @Hermela 👏🏽 and what an intellect scholar @Derege 👍🏽 Ethiopia 🇪🇹 forever ♥️
I wish Ethiopia would be led by this kind of intellect and wisdom . You are right most of this ethnic merchant is a means to become rich and send their children best school in USA and some of them live here too but their people are under misery . Thank you both
Ethiopians should not experience less rights in any region of Ethiopia. The current system is closer to segregation; segregation is anti-democratic and isn't federalism. Ethiopia needs to scrap the old constitution and create a constitution that supports proper and REAL democracy. This ethnic politics and tribalism is antiquated, moronic and DEADLY. Edit: It's odd how the ethnic leadership live in Western nations that practice actual life, liberty and fraternity but don't practice this in Ethiopia. It seems like these very leaders gain from this divisive politics... No wonder Ethiopia is dysfunctional to this day. So many lives lost due to the failure of leadership...
So much love and respect from Eritrean! You didn’t follow the crowd rather you tried to find out the truth! So much administration for your boldness! You are so brave sister! Hope, we had so much like you are back home!
Great interview Hermela. The battle aint be easy as this has been the dogma of tplf for more than four decades and many cadres have 'illegally' benefited throughout the country. Unfortunately, we are at a generation who is deeply brainwashed and the contrast is sharp. Brave keep this torch moving
You are absolutely true and that's what I have been saying. The system is so messed up created to divide and conquer for over 30 yrs ppl have been brainwashed it might take another 30 years and generational change before things start working.
can you continue part 3 discussion it’s so interesting issue.because what is mean Federal Government or central Government especially in past 30 plus years.how effective the country .
Brilliant discussion. "The court system got tested whether it can avoid conflict or not every time" that right there is the key contrast between developed democratic countries and developing countries
WoW, didn’t hear such awesome explanation on federal system in a while. Good one. Those illiterate people who keep saying federalism don’t know what the real federalism is. Let them learn here.
By the way what made worse the Ethiopian Ethnic federalism is that the nationalized land belonging to Government, which after Ethnic federalism belongs to that Ethnic Government (to those in power by the name of that Ethnic group), anyone individually living in that region has no right, specially those not belonging to that region.
In this constitutions, it is belived that ethinc amharas were not involved/partipated in the constructing process. Because these peole living almost across all part of ethiopia. It is just used to be as an apartheid for most of ethiopians.
My, My, Hermela good to hear from you my sister. What happened to#nomre movement? Please keep doing what you’re doing. Don’t let that Dictator to control you!
#nomore was dead on arrival. Aby Ahmed told her in her face when she visited Addis. He knows very well Ethiopia or Africa in general won’t last one month without the western aid..
I had no idea how pernicious that constitution is. Everyone was outraged about Clause 39, but some of us didn’t fully realize the poison in the whole document
Hermela I admire what you are doing and what you have done for Ethiopia. Unfortunately, the enemies of all Ethiopian people are not only the TPLF group but also the ONEG(OLF) group and its partner the Abiy Barbarian Ahmed Ali's group are also the enemy of Ethiopia. 2338+ Ethiopians civilians were massacred by the Abiy savage group and by ONEG(OLF) group in Wellega. I think at this time, the Abiy Savage genocidal group is more dangerous than the TPLF group.
The "kilil" admisteative type has created more ethnic consciousness and division. The regions must be redesigned in a way one region is made up of various ethnic groups so that they will learn and adapt to coexist and live together. That is how the Eritrean government designed in 1990s whereby the nine Provincial or "Awraja" type of administration were arranged in terms of Six regions. For example, Gash Barka includes some Kunama, Tigre, Tigrigna etc speakers. In that way, social cohesion could be created
First,let’s see if that come to fruition when you have constitution, democracy and election. That’s why he is ruling Eritrea with iron fist until he creat Eritrean identity..menelik, Haile selasie, mengustu tried that in Ethiopia in the name of Amhara( even though some of them were not Amhara) not only they failed, they made Amhara people the enemies of a lot Ethnics, especially the one that border with them like Oromo Tigray Benshangul, and Kimant. Secondly you are trying to compare apples and oranges. Eritrea has 9 ethnic with one overwhelming majority ethnic(60-65%) and seven of the ethnics don’t make up 10%. Meanwhile Ethiopia has 82 plus ethnic groups. The largest ethnic group is only 30-35% followed by 28%, 6%, 6%, 4%, 4% and 70 plus ethnic groups make up less than 10% Thirdly Ethiopia ethnic groups we’re living peacefully for 3 decades in various region until these unitary ideologies resurfaced thanks to ESAT(media) and Aby Ahmed( government). The sad part is the average working Amhara person living across these regions is going to pay the heavy price. The number one responsible for these are the so-called diaspora Amhara activist and some assimilated Amhara( Birhanu Nega,Hermela ) preaching in the name unitary Ethiopia. We all know what unitary Ethiopia mean. Lastly for the Amhara people, worry about your people first just like the rest of the other ethnic groups are doing. Then we are going to have a healthy progress. Peace to all ethiopian and Africa in general.
Thank you Heremela to take the initiative to discuss about the most crucial issue of Ethiopia. Yes, of course, the main cause of all these problems in our country is the fallacy of the constitution. It advocates hates among natuons rather than building a nation. Bring new opinions to your stages. God bless🙏
Hello in Ethiopia there is a rule of low the low working for ministers government officials and the leaders besipicly the courts judges mostly very very corrupted even they telling come with your hard not on your foot it’s discussing this leadership support it so far may be he scared about it now a days he becomes dictator ship 🚢
The Ethiopian government keep silent on addressing this ethinic federalism meaning to the ppl . We prefer geographical federalism but they don’t apply it !!! Some oromo Ppl think their region is not region and is a country!!! They forgot they came in 17 th centuary to Ethiopia and claim every land belongs to them !!! That is barbaric ….
This mentality is the root cause of Ethiopia problem..instead coming with real constructive solutions, u start to dehumanizing and degrading an entire ethics. What a disgusting and disgraceful human being you are.
Proud oromo! Good thought but for some , what about when a Somali or oromos wasn't considered as citizens of the country , for the last 135 years it is obvious those nation states trying to find their own identity beside that specially the oromos contains 40% of the population and 40% of the areal, it wise to look at finfine or(AA) More than 700000 oromos are displaced only the last 30 years and lost everything what about them need clarification, As an Oromo the Ethiopian concept is only Amhara domination nothing else, let all nation states to choose their destiny I could be the right way. Eritrea choose their own destiny why not oromos or somalis,
The Constitution is not beneficial for Ethiopian people designed by TPLF now they don’t want to abolish because they think it benefit the Oromo but it is the contrary to everyone Kelel it is to separate people in a wrong way I hope the Parliament & the Court work on it before the People
Why don’t you ask Abby to Change the constitution? People are killed because of that not they are hated to each other. You can do better dear but talk about past
I don’t think this is his area to discuss about Federalism and constitution . He is everywhere not trying to Underestimate his knowledge but still is no his area.
If you have a basic understanding of civics and have eyes, ears and a brain to see and comprehend what is happening in Ethiopia, you would come to the similar conclusion as the gentleman in this video.
Federalism is here for a long time. Not the kind of TPLF federalism. but the one where Killils gets more autonomy. Please, don't fool yourself. Amharas Superiority is buried forever. Tigray said No! Oromoos said No! It's dead forever! Nobody carries Amhara thing whether it's name or culture as an identifier hereafter. I changed my name to Oromo name 10 years ago. Nothing that looks like imiye utopia and Amhara is found in my home. I read Afaan Oromoo Bible and listen Afaan Oromoo music
The country now is burning and we losing so many lives, so I don't think this is the time for this talke, you all could start talking about unity country and call for pace. I am from Tigray and I don't see you Hurmalla talking in the right niche for Ethiopia you only making Name for yourself but not adding anything to help the country. I don't care about Africa at this moment because my country going through hell and Africa can wait.
A friend of mine said to me “ without check and balance freedom is free doom” I add this to his saying “without check and balance and rule of law freedom is free doom” Hermela I thank you your hard work for change. I thank your mother for raising you to become a guiding light. I love your guest.
Derege Demissie, you’re one special analyst. We would have been in a much better place if our leaders could have listen this well and implement that right to everyone. God bless you for giving us this eloquently spoken insight sir. Thank you Hermela for having him in your show.
I would like to thank both of you! Very important concepts I perceived and I believe many can have better understanding about structure of a democratic and federalism nation.
Hermela I have the same background as you and I knew how TPLF used and using our people! We need to end these arrogant and racist rule. You are a hero and keep it up!
Long Live Ethiopia 🇪🇹
We are proud of you Hermela for educating us what we should know facts about Ethiopia. We thank you so much
You deserve a lot of support. You are doing a wonderful job at being a journalist in an era where being neutral is considered unmarketable. Thank you for everything.
Our amazing brilliant daughter, you are a hero. History will remember you. Your brilliant mom must be very proud!!! She did a great job raising you. Thank you 🙏
I love what you bring to the table. It is of good taste and great quality. Keep it coming. Journalism at its best. Thank you. What an amazing discussion. I pray the children of tigray region soon will be educated in the matters of Mama Ethiopia..stand as 1!
I am impressed by this intellectual discussion. When intellectuals are silent, cadres take over and countries het destroyed. When you hear more about Ethnic federalism and its danger, I am surprised how we survived so far. It’s an ethnic prison. As Derege said, we need to think of Ethiopia 300 years from now.
We are proud of you Hermela for educating us so important information about our country. We thank you so much.
Thanks for sharing 👍👍👍
You make very good videos.
I love this type of video.
That sums it all.
Nice ending btw, I was just getting warmed up. Keep up the excellent job @Hermela 👏🏽 and what an intellect scholar @Derege 👍🏽
Ethiopia 🇪🇹 forever ♥️
I wish Ethiopia would be led by this kind of intellect and wisdom . You are right most of this ethnic merchant is a means to become rich and send their children best school in USA and some of them live here too but their people are under misery . Thank you both
Thank you for shading light on the broken system
What an incredible thoughtful discussion.
Please come again
and educate us. Thanks . 🙏
Ethiopians should not experience less rights in any region of Ethiopia.
The current system is closer to segregation; segregation is anti-democratic and isn't federalism.
Ethiopia needs to scrap the old constitution and create a constitution that supports proper and REAL democracy.
This ethnic politics and tribalism is antiquated, moronic and DEADLY.
Edit:
It's odd how the ethnic leadership live in Western nations that practice actual life, liberty and fraternity but don't practice this in Ethiopia.
It seems like these very leaders gain from this divisive politics...
No wonder Ethiopia is dysfunctional to this day.
So many lives lost due to the failure of leadership...
Over 1800 dead! In 2 days!
Thank u so much my Hermella , for asking such hood question and u r very special. God bless u all
My two favorite people talking common sense about Ethiopian politics.
Love and respect To Hermela.🙏
Proud of you Hermi!
We ye thank you for inviting Ato Derege. Highly needed discussion. Keep it up hermye.
Brilliant talk. May The Lord God👑 heals Ethiopia and her People in Jesus Almighty Name 🎯
So much love and respect from Eritrean! You didn’t follow the crowd rather you tried to find out the truth! So much administration for your boldness! You are so brave sister! Hope, we had so much like you are back home!
This man is speaking my mind.
Thank you Hermelay shukor !!!
Great interview Hermela. The battle aint be easy as this has been the dogma of tplf for more than four decades and many cadres have 'illegally' benefited throughout the country. Unfortunately, we are at a generation who is deeply brainwashed and the contrast is sharp. Brave keep this torch moving
You are absolutely true and that's what I have been saying. The system is so messed up created to divide and conquer for over 30 yrs ppl have been brainwashed it might take another 30 years and generational change before things start working.
Great job hermela. I like your effort to bring light from the darkness! .Whatever happens dont stop!
Thank you for speaking the truth
Derege my admiration for your positive thinking and knowledge is too much.
Thanks for sharing 👍👍👍
You make very good videos.
I love this type of video.
The son of the iconic military General, Demissie Bulto. Thank you Dereje 🙏
both of you did great
You are touching the heart of the matter!
የኢትዮጵያ ሕገ መንግስት TPLF ለራሱ እንደሚመች አድርጎ የቀረፀው ረጅሙን አላማውን የማስፈሚያ ዘዴ ነው አማራ በተለይ በመላው ኢትዮጵያ በተለያየ የስራ መስክ ተበትነው ሲስሩ ባሉበት ቅም አመታት የኖሩበት የተዋለዱበት ንብረት ያደራጁበት እንደእንስሳ መታረድ ምንይባላል ዘር ዘር ጥቁር ጤፍ ከነጭ መለየት ይቻላል በምቀኝነት ብቻ ሳይሆን ጥቂት እሊቶች በውቀት ሳይሆን በዘር ስልጣን ስለፈለጉ ና በበላይነት ሀገርን ለመግዛት እንዲያመቻቸው ነው በውቀት በመልካም አስተሳሰብ ና ስነምግባር ማስተዳደር ስለማይችሉ ሀገሩ የሙታን ምድር ሆነች ፈጣሪ ይፍራድ 🙏💚💛❤️
ምርጥ ኢቲዮጲያዊ ውድድድ ነው ማረግሽ
Big respect for Hermela
Hermela for President you are so awesome 👏 thank you for informing us
ሄርሜላ የእኔ ቆንጆ በስላም ነው የጠፋሽው እናትሽ ደህና ናቸው እግዚአብሔር ይመስገን ስላየውሽ ደስ ብሎኛል
Keep the good battle till the sun come up to full day. Thank you.
Hermele 🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️
can you continue part 3 discussion it’s so interesting issue.because what is mean Federal Government or central Government especially in past 30 plus years.how effective the country .
I couldn't hear the whole talk, is anywhere l can get the remaining part? Thank you,
Oh geez I don’t know what happened. Will upload remainder shortly.
@@HermelaTV thank you 😊
Big big....respect our sister!
Great discussion from this two wonderful Ethiopians love and respect to both ! reasonable minds.
You are A hero for all Human Race.
You are self-actualized and beutiful women of the world. I have big respect for you and your family at all.
Brilliant discussion. "The court system got tested whether it can avoid conflict or not every time" that right there is the key contrast between developed democratic countries and developing countries
WoW, didn’t hear such awesome explanation on federal system in a while. Good one. Those illiterate people who keep saying federalism don’t know what the real federalism is. Let them learn here.
Thank you my sister 😘
By the way what made worse the Ethiopian Ethnic federalism is that the nationalized land belonging to Government, which after Ethnic federalism belongs to that Ethnic Government (to those in power by the name of that Ethnic group), anyone individually living in that region has no right, specially those not belonging to that region.
Would u pls let us know why the Ethiopian Gov couldn’t change this the divisive TPLF constitution to make us one as before
Extraordinary!
In this constitutions, it is belived that ethinc amharas were not involved/partipated in the constructing process. Because these peole living almost across all part of ethiopia. It is just used to be as an apartheid for most of ethiopians.
The wise man....🙏👏
My, My, Hermela good to hear from you my sister. What happened to#nomre movement?
Please keep doing what you’re doing. Don’t let that Dictator to control you!
#nomore was dead on arrival. Aby Ahmed told her in her face when she visited Addis. He knows very well Ethiopia or Africa in general won’t last one month without the western aid..
Insightful
❤️❤️❤️💪💪💪
I had no idea how pernicious that constitution is. Everyone was outraged about Clause 39, but some of us didn’t fully realize the poison in the whole document
Ich möchte Hermela als Präsidentin für Ethiopien. Hermela ist mutig ehrlich und spricht mit aus der Seele ❤️❤️
شكرا لك هيرميلا!
TPLF or any ethnic fascism is colonialism with black skin.
❤🙏❤
Hermela I admire what you are doing and what you have done for Ethiopia. Unfortunately, the enemies of all Ethiopian people are not only the TPLF group but also the ONEG(OLF) group and its partner the Abiy Barbarian Ahmed Ali's group are also the enemy of Ethiopia. 2338+ Ethiopians civilians were massacred by the Abiy savage group and by ONEG(OLF) group in Wellega. I think at this time, the Abiy Savage genocidal group is more dangerous than the TPLF group.
How Can the Federal Government Gives Federal Right to States that Can only Guarantee the basic rights based on ethnicity ?
Hermela you are our Ethiopian queen love you .w proud of you .
The Ethiopian system of. unknown appartied to the rest of the world 🌎
😍😍🥰🥰🥰😍😍😍🥰🥰
The "kilil" admisteative type has created more ethnic consciousness and division. The regions must be redesigned in a way one region is made up of various ethnic groups so that they will learn and adapt to coexist and live together. That is how the Eritrean government designed in 1990s whereby the nine Provincial or "Awraja" type of administration were arranged in terms of Six regions. For example, Gash Barka includes some Kunama, Tigre, Tigrigna etc speakers. In that way, social cohesion could be created
First,let’s see if that come to fruition when you have constitution, democracy and election. That’s why he is ruling Eritrea with iron fist until he creat Eritrean identity..menelik, Haile selasie, mengustu tried that in Ethiopia in the name of Amhara( even though some of them were not Amhara) not only they failed, they made Amhara people the enemies of a lot Ethnics, especially the one that border with them like Oromo Tigray Benshangul, and Kimant.
Secondly you are trying to compare apples and oranges. Eritrea has 9 ethnic with one overwhelming majority ethnic(60-65%) and seven of the ethnics don’t make up 10%. Meanwhile Ethiopia has 82 plus ethnic groups. The largest ethnic group is only 30-35% followed by 28%, 6%, 6%, 4%, 4% and 70 plus ethnic groups make up less than 10%
Thirdly Ethiopia ethnic groups we’re living peacefully for 3 decades in various region until these unitary ideologies resurfaced thanks to ESAT(media) and Aby Ahmed( government). The sad part is the average working Amhara person living across these regions is going to pay the heavy price. The number one responsible for these are the so-called diaspora Amhara activist and some assimilated Amhara( Birhanu Nega,Hermela ) preaching in the name unitary Ethiopia. We all know what unitary Ethiopia mean.
Lastly for the Amhara people, worry about your people first just like the rest of the other ethnic groups are doing. Then we are going to have a healthy progress.
Peace to all ethiopian and Africa in general.
Hello everyone ❤️
💛🧡💚👍👍
Our future lies on the likes of Hermela Haregawi and Dereje Bultu...thank you guys🙏
Thank you Heremela to take the initiative to discuss about the most crucial issue of Ethiopia. Yes, of course, the main cause of all these problems in our country is the fallacy of the constitution. It advocates hates among natuons rather than building a nation. Bring new opinions to your stages. God bless🙏
Dividing regions by race or ethnicity never ends well. Specially in a country with low literacy rate like Ethiopia.
Absolutely true!!
Hermela 🥰😘💋💋
ሔርሜላ የኔ ልእልት ስወድሽ!!
Give the teachings of his Majesty. We don't want no devil philosophy. African Unity.
Yes he is right but you need two things for that to happen
It is education and development
Who has power to make constitution of Ethiopia
Hello in Ethiopia there is a rule of low the low working for ministers government officials and the leaders besipicly the courts judges mostly very very corrupted even they telling come with your hard not on your foot it’s discussing this leadership support it so far may be he scared about it now a days he becomes dictator ship 🚢
Down with Abiy and down with TPFL and down with Shene!
Abiy Ahmed ali stop Amhara Genocide inoromyia inregion
Melese Zanawi was extremely cruel man
❤️🇪🇹❤️
Abiy ahmed ali stop Amhara Genocide in oro myia inregion
ሄርሜላ፣የኔዘመንሀቀኛ፣ሀገሯንአክባሪ፣ጀግናሤት፣ፈጣሪ፣እረጂምእድሜይሥጥሸየኔቆጆ
The Ethiopian government keep silent on addressing this ethinic federalism meaning to the ppl . We prefer geographical federalism but they don’t apply it !!!
Some oromo
Ppl think their region is not region and is a country!!! They forgot they came in 17 th centuary to Ethiopia and claim every land belongs to them !!! That is barbaric ….
This mentality is the root cause of Ethiopia problem..instead coming with real constructive solutions, u start to dehumanizing and degrading an entire ethics. What a disgusting and disgraceful human being you are.
right
Proud oromo! Good thought but for some , what about when a Somali or oromos wasn't considered as citizens of the country , for the last 135 years it is obvious those nation states trying
to find their own identity beside that specially the oromos contains 40% of the population and 40% of the areal, it wise to look at finfine or(AA)
More than 700000 oromos are displaced only the last 30 years and lost everything what about them need clarification,
As an Oromo the Ethiopian concept is only Amhara domination nothing else, let all nation states to choose their destiny I could be the right way.
Eritrea choose their own destiny why not oromos or somalis,
I love you Hermela
How come this Gentleman doesn't mention Somali Region.
Abiy Ahmed Ali stop Amhara Genocide in oromyia on region
The Constitution is not beneficial for Ethiopian people designed by TPLF now they don’t want to abolish because they think it benefit the Oromo but it is the contrary to everyone Kelel it is to separate people in a wrong way I hope the Parliament & the Court work on it before the People
Time to talk about the big elephant in the room, the 'constitution'!
Why don’t you ask Abby to Change the constitution? People are killed because of that not they are hated to each other. You can do better dear but talk about past
The first ethnic federalism in the world.
"Neither federal, nor democratic" WOW.
I don’t think this is his area to discuss about Federalism and constitution . He is everywhere not trying to Underestimate his knowledge but still is no his area.
Lol is that what you could comment? Who cares?
what is the lawyer missing in this discussion? And, can you share your legal expertise on the matter?
If you have a basic understanding of civics and have eyes, ears and a brain to see and comprehend what is happening in Ethiopia, you would come to the similar conclusion as the gentleman in this video.
Federalism is here for a long time. Not the kind of TPLF federalism. but the one where Killils gets more autonomy. Please, don't fool yourself. Amharas Superiority is buried forever. Tigray said No! Oromoos said No! It's dead forever! Nobody carries Amhara thing whether it's name or culture as an identifier hereafter. I changed my name to Oromo name 10 years ago. Nothing that looks like imiye utopia and Amhara is found in my home. I read Afaan Oromoo Bible and listen Afaan Oromoo music
Correct, amhara supremacy belongs in the history.
He kind of looks like Guss from Breaking Bad
Besides your gust is half a sleep it was a good subject
Ethiopia should be evicted from the United Nation because it follows apartid
for hermela, her mother abiy pay dollars
The country now is burning and we losing so many lives, so I don't think this is the time for this talke, you all could start talking about unity country and call for pace. I am from Tigray and I don't see you Hurmalla talking in the right niche for Ethiopia you only making Name for yourself but not adding anything to help the country.
I don't care about Africa at this moment because my country going through hell and Africa can wait.