Real world? Looked like country lanes and urban, no motorway. I'm sure they might do ok for short, low speed trips - but why would you invest 50% more in an EV van over a diesel? (and who can afford to do that?)
Thanks for that, very reasuring numbers. I have a 75kWh Vivaro on order that I plan to convert to a camper so any information on these vans is very interesting. Can not wait to get the van but it's going to be quite a wait.
That's what I thought and the general view is that vans (well all EVs) use a lot more energy when loaded up, so I wanted to test this as I've always thought they didn't use that much more when I've loaded vans up in the past. So this test shows the difference is only 8% and not the >50% often claimed!
Hi Matt,thanks for the very informative video,it just proves how good electric vehicles are and that to they can be driven economically with or without a lot of extra wieght in them.I own an MG zs ev and since owning it from new it's tought me to be an ecnomical driver without having to hyper mile.Hurry up with your next video.
Thanks. Many new drivers complain that the range is less than they were expecting, but then they ignore their driving efficiency and just look at range. Look at this and then you see they are driving far too inefficient and using that power! Drive better (which doesn't mean slower) and you can get the manufacturer's WLTP figures in the summer from most vehicles. As for videos, there's about 500 on the channel already...most with very low views, so plenty there to keep you busy. Next video out next Friday. Plenty stacked up to keep them coming out every week over the winter.
❤😊thank you 👍 most interesting, especially as I'm thinking of getting an electric van for as a camping van I've been driving electric cars for over 10 years
60mph is the max speed for a commercial van over 2tonnes max gross weight…on a dual carriageway, so I would be wary of mentioning you are doing 65mph on camera, 70mph only on Motorways, , also note it’s 50mph on A&B roads.👍. PS great video…👍🇮🇲
Thanks for this lovely long video Matt, been a busy week so had to wait to enjoy it. Is it just the Toyota version that has no brake light on regen? I didn't realise they did an all electric van but it seems whatever ev they produce there always has to be some perverse peculiarity to make a new ev driver think they not very good or dangerous as in this case. Anyway this is a great idea and I think an hour or just over is a good enough test and a great format for follow up videos, thanks for taking the time to make it. How oddly prescient your Queen Elizabeth mug was, gave me goose bumps to realise that you couldn't have known she was going to pass away at the time of recording. I nice little tribute nonetheless. Cheers Matt.👍
Thanks. All versions of this van, i.e. the Vauxhall, Citroen & Peugeot are all the same and do not operate the brake lights on regen. Nor do other Stellantis vehicles like the Vauxhall e-Corsa.
@@GoGreenAutos oh really?! Gosh I didn't realise, someone somewhere assured me that regen was always marked by brake lights. I shall be alert to that on the road and with future purchases. Thanks again Matt. 👍
There was an interview on fully charged a few years back and all the 50kWh Citroen, Peugeot and Vauxhalls set the regen level to the maximum allowed before they needed to brake lights on.
@@stevejordan4299 But the regen is pretty strong on these vans (in B mode) and you can come to almost a stop from any speed. Certainly much stronger than some other EVs which do put on the brake lights.
Morning Matt, I watched this video to help me make my decision to buy a 50kwh Vivaro-e and found it very useful. I run a pressure washing business so I have a steel frame bolted to the chassis to carry a 500lt buffer tank (usually 30%full), two reels and a petrol driven washer. Thereafter I carry all manner of bins, drums and a jerry can. All told it weighs about the same as your test (given I weigh nearly 100kg) and I’m getting 2.5 miles per kWh. I reckon on having access to 40kwh as long as it trickle charges (at 10 amps) to 100% most nights. Consequently I start with a theoretical 125 mile range. It’s quite a mindset change to accept I start each day with a finite level of energy and it has been a bit alarming on occasion, but I’m confident I can plan and behave a way around it. It’s a December 2022 example and had 9 miles on the clock when I bought it. I paid £14,900 plus VAT for it and treat it as a working tool. At 25p per kWh it costs me £10 to drive all day and I avoid public chargers if I can. If I spent on a charger, I could reduce the cost of overnight charging, but would be at the cost of a higher rate at all other times of the day, so I’ve settled on accepting it will cost me £200 a month max, probably less as daily charging might not require topping up by 40kwhs. Cheers Geoff
A charger and an off peak tariff will pay for itself. You'll be saving 18p pkWh on the van charging alone and then if you load shift other household appliances that more than offsets the slightly higher day rate. We put our washing machine and dishwasher on at night (they have built in delay functions) and this alone saves loads.
Excellent content. I bought an i3S recently and now I’m looking to buy an e-dispatch for my pressure washing business. I normally drive around with half a 500lt (250kg) tank of water, the washer (100kg) and frequently sand and other consumables plus myself (another 98kg), so I’m most encouraged. Given I serve the SO postcode area, I’m now wondering if a 50kwh version will do the job? Thank you for taking the trouble to assess the efficiency with and without a load. 👍
These are meant to be final destination delivery vehicles,so you should be testing them around housing estates and town centres,how are they for getting in and out hundreds of times a working day
If this van is based on a Stellantis vehicle, putting it in Eco mode reduces motor power to 80%, so your comment early in the video about the effects of that mode is inaccurate. Legislation dictates that only EV's with "one peddle" strength regen need put on the brake lights on the overrun, so your comment about briefly tapping the brakes to warn the Audi tailgating you, is a good tip :)
The power difference between Eco and Normal modes is hardly noticeable in these vans. Yes, I understood that it was an EU legislation that dictates brake lights coming on, however, in B mode, these vans do have pretty strong regen and is "one peddle" strength. Its very strange they have omitted this.
You don’t put the brake lights on with a petrol/diesel engine when engine braking so why would you expect to put the brake lights on when regen braking? It’s the same thing. There are plenty of cars that don’t put brake lights on with regen. That probably only applies to EV’s with one pedal driving. Fascinating to see what efficiency you got. I have an e-expert van that has done 34,500 miles. If I get >3.0 mi/kWh I’ve had a really good day. You’ve out driven the WLTP range from the manufacturer and that quoted in EV Database. The best I’ve seen whilst owning the van has been 3.0 mi/kWh. I also note that the temperature was 23 degrees. Average for this van is 2.7-2.9 mi/kWh on a van type journey involving motorways and dual carriageways driving about 60-65mph in summer/spring and winter. That’s an average speed around 45mph. The efficiency rockets above 13 degrees and drop to about 2.4-2.6 in winter when it really drops. I slow down to 56-60mph which helps with efficiency. Try running ECO in winter. Heating is next to useless in ECO mode when it’s -1 and below outside! ECO to NORMAL mode efficiency is about 0.1 to 0.2 mi/kWh variation. I bought some heated seat covers but I believe now heated seats are fitted as standard. Also headwinds are a big factor in efficiency. You learn to “lorry surf” to help with range in headwinds. All told though I love the van and the EV driving experience. Won’t be going back to an ICE vehicle.
With regard to the brakelight during regen discussion: I used to use engine braking in my diesel Vectra extensively with similar deceleration rates to the highest regen modes in EVs I've driven, Drivers should always leave sufficient space in front of a vehicle to react to anything, I know many don't but then there's always the opportunity of a personal injury payout 😉 Neither of the two EVs I've driven the most; Smart ForTwo ED (451) and Mitsubishi i-Miev activate their brakelights in their strongest regen modes (I tested them on a long straight road at night with a number of reflective signs that would reflect brakelights). I wonder if the Regen brakelight activation has been a piece of legislation introduced after a particular date?
I believe there is legislation on this and there's a certain G force when the brake lights should be activated. Neither the Smart or i-MiEV have particularly strong regen, so could not be reaching that deceleration limit anyway. However, these Stellantis vehicles can, yet no brake lights. I'm surprised they can get away with this.
The idea of no inertia activated brake lights for regen would make me nervous if using it aggressively. I wonder in what meeting did someone say, 'It'll be ok'.
1. Van speed limit on single and dual carriageway national speed limits are 50 and 60 respectively 2. Regen must show brake lights at a deceleration of 1.3 m/s2 which is 0.132563 G.
Worst thing about eletric cars is when new model comes with better range , your car is wothless and everybody want the new one witch the better range :) . they need to think again how they do this , better idea is to have replaceable battery and slots in the car and you can configure your range what you need ! if you need only go 100 km you can take 2 battery with you of 8 battery slots , then you can control the power that you need , if you buy this 75 kw car you always carry the hole battery whatever you need it or not , always drive wery heavy , they need to rethink battery cars , best to have universal battery , you can have everywhere on gas stations . this idea is no good and make you loose alot money when the new better range comes out .
Thanks we are considering getting one of these vans The Peugeot for a camper that is when if Peugeot New Zealand eventually imports them unfortunately they are only considering importing the 50 KWh and not the people mover versions which is what we would prefer What range do you think we would get on the open road in summer? Cheers
An electrician on TH-cam was talking to a bt guy who was driving one of these in central London, must have had the larger battery as it was meant to do over 200 miles. By the time they put all their kit in the back and ladders on the roof, they were getting 70 miles out of the thing before it needed charging, rubbish really.
I suspect the main issue here is not the weight, but the driving style. I see this all too often. Its very easy for a new EV driver to enjoy the torque and drive their new EV very inefficiently and much faster than they were driving their previous diesel van. With the lack of noise, vibration etc, you don't get the same sense of speed in the new electric vehicle, hence it feels slower than you're actually doing. Ladders and roof racks will increase consumption and reduce range a bit though. But there's no way, that cargo weight and ladders on the roof will reduce the range of a 75kWh van down to 70 miles. That is mostly down to the driver.
With respect, if you were driving a diesel & took your foot off the throttle, using the engine to slow the vehicle, after changing down a gear, you'd be driving like your in B mode, would you not? The breaks wouldn't activate either!
Engine braking in a diesel is only about 1/10th of what B mode is. B mode is like putting the brakes on harder than you would most of the time. In normal mode (i.e non-B mode) the "engine" braking in this EV is still about 2-3 times stronger than engine braking in a diesel. So in this mode, the brake lights don't need to come on, but in B mode, they really should do and do in all other EVs.
It's just turned a year old. Due to legacy manufacturers with dealerships I'm afraid. They would't sell them unless the dealerships can service them every year! It was only an inspection service at £79 inc VAT.
At last. A good demonstration of what the van can do in the real world.
Thanks.
Real world? Looked like country lanes and urban, no motorway. I'm sure they might do ok for short, low speed trips - but why would you invest 50% more in an EV van over a diesel? (and who can afford to do that?)
Thanks for that, very reasuring numbers. I have a 75kWh Vivaro on order that I plan to convert to a camper so any information on these vans is very interesting. Can not wait to get the van but it's going to be quite a wait.
Be interesting to see the progress of that . Are you going to film it ?
Thank you. The best real world demonstration of EV vans I’ve seen.
Cheers. Glad you found it useful. There's others on the channel too.
Very important topic as the ability to carry all the required equipment is essential to making the transition feasible. Thanks for sharing.
That's what I thought and the general view is that vans (well all EVs) use a lot more energy when loaded up, so I wanted to test this as I've always thought they didn't use that much more when I've loaded vans up in the past. So this test shows the difference is only 8% and not the >50% often claimed!
50% for towing i think
Finally a good overall view on the consumption when "using" it.. Thanks!
Glad it was helpful
Hi Matt,thanks for the very informative video,it just proves how good electric vehicles are and that to they can be driven economically with or without a lot of extra wieght in them.I own an MG zs ev and since owning it from new it's tought me to be an ecnomical driver without having to hyper mile.Hurry up with your next video.
Thanks. Many new drivers complain that the range is less than they were expecting, but then they ignore their driving efficiency and just look at range. Look at this and then you see they are driving far too inefficient and using that power! Drive better (which doesn't mean slower) and you can get the manufacturer's WLTP figures in the summer from most vehicles.
As for videos, there's about 500 on the channel already...most with very low views, so plenty there to keep you busy. Next video out next Friday. Plenty stacked up to keep them coming out every week over the winter.
@@GoGreenAutos Thanks for replying Mat.👍
❤😊thank you 👍 most interesting, especially as I'm thinking of getting an electric van for as a camping van I've been driving electric cars for over 10 years
60mph is the max speed for a commercial van over 2tonnes max gross weight…on a dual carriageway, so I would be wary of mentioning you are doing 65mph on camera, 70mph only on Motorways, , also note it’s 50mph on A&B roads.👍. PS great video…👍🇮🇲
Very interesting and some good tips.
Thanks
Thanks for this lovely long video Matt, been a busy week so had to wait to enjoy it. Is it just the Toyota version that has no brake light on regen? I didn't realise they did an all electric van but it seems whatever ev they produce there always has to be some perverse peculiarity to make a new ev driver think they not very good or dangerous as in this case.
Anyway this is a great idea and I think an hour or just over is a good enough test and a great format for follow up videos, thanks for taking the time to make it.
How oddly prescient your Queen Elizabeth mug was, gave me goose bumps to realise that you couldn't have known she was going to pass away at the time of recording. I nice little tribute nonetheless. Cheers Matt.👍
Thanks. All versions of this van, i.e. the Vauxhall, Citroen & Peugeot are all the same and do not operate the brake lights on regen. Nor do other Stellantis vehicles like the Vauxhall e-Corsa.
@@GoGreenAutos oh really?! Gosh I didn't realise, someone somewhere assured me that regen was always marked by brake lights. I shall be alert to that on the road and with future purchases. Thanks again Matt. 👍
@@judebrown4103 It does on all other EVs, until these new Stellantis vehicles came along.
@@GoGreenAutos well what an odd retrograde step....🤔
There was an interview on fully charged a few years back and all the 50kWh Citroen, Peugeot and Vauxhalls set the regen level to the maximum allowed before they needed to brake lights on.
Sorry...can you reword that as its not clear what you're saying?
@@GoGreenAutos it was the reason all the PSG group cars don't put the brake lights on when using regenerative braking.
@@stevejordan4299 But the regen is pretty strong on these vans (in B mode) and you can come to almost a stop from any speed. Certainly much stronger than some other EVs which do put on the brake lights.
tx for this, quite interesting.
Superb test - thank you!
Glad you found it useful.
Morning Matt, I watched this video to help me make my decision to buy a 50kwh Vivaro-e and found it very useful. I run a pressure washing business so I have a steel frame bolted to the chassis to carry a 500lt buffer tank (usually 30%full), two reels and a petrol driven washer. Thereafter I carry all manner of bins, drums and a jerry can. All told it weighs about the same as your test (given I weigh nearly 100kg) and I’m getting 2.5 miles per kWh. I reckon on having access to 40kwh as long as it trickle charges (at 10 amps) to 100% most nights. Consequently I start with a theoretical 125 mile range. It’s quite a mindset change to accept I start each day with a finite level of energy and it has been a bit alarming on occasion, but I’m confident I can plan and behave a way around it. It’s a December 2022 example and had 9 miles on the clock when I bought it. I paid £14,900 plus VAT for it and treat it as a working tool. At 25p per kWh it costs me £10 to drive all day and I avoid public chargers if I can. If I spent on a charger, I could reduce the cost of overnight charging, but would be at the cost of a higher rate at all other times of the day, so I’ve settled on accepting it will cost me £200 a month max, probably less as daily charging might not require topping up by 40kwhs. Cheers Geoff
A charger and an off peak tariff will pay for itself. You'll be saving 18p pkWh on the van charging alone and then if you load shift other household appliances that more than offsets the slightly higher day rate. We put our washing machine and dishwasher on at night (they have built in delay functions) and this alone saves loads.
Excellent content. I bought an i3S recently and now I’m looking to buy an e-dispatch for my pressure washing business. I normally drive around with half a 500lt (250kg) tank of water, the washer (100kg) and frequently sand and other consumables plus myself (another 98kg), so I’m most encouraged. Given I serve the SO postcode area, I’m now wondering if a 50kwh version will do the job? Thank you for taking the trouble to assess the efficiency with and without a load. 👍
Glad you found it useful.
These are meant to be final destination delivery vehicles,so you should be testing them around housing estates and town centres,how are they for getting in and out hundreds of times a working day
In that respect, exactly the same as the diesel version.
@@GoGreenAutos I drive the ePartner,eCombo,Dispatch and Vivaro versions of these vans for the RM and they are excellent vehicles for this purpose
If this van is based on a Stellantis vehicle, putting it in Eco mode reduces motor power to 80%, so your comment early in the video about the effects of that mode is inaccurate.
Legislation dictates that only EV's with "one peddle" strength regen need put on the brake lights on the overrun, so your comment about briefly tapping the brakes to warn the Audi tailgating you, is a good tip :)
The power difference between Eco and Normal modes is hardly noticeable in these vans.
Yes, I understood that it was an EU legislation that dictates brake lights coming on, however, in B mode, these vans do have pretty strong regen and is "one peddle" strength. Its very strange they have omitted this.
You don’t put the brake lights on with a petrol/diesel engine when engine braking so why would you expect to put the brake lights on when regen braking? It’s the same thing. There are plenty of cars that don’t put brake lights on with regen. That probably only applies to EV’s with one pedal driving.
Fascinating to see what efficiency you got. I have an e-expert van that has done 34,500 miles. If I get >3.0 mi/kWh I’ve had a really good day. You’ve out driven the WLTP range from the manufacturer and that quoted in EV Database. The best I’ve seen whilst owning the van has been 3.0 mi/kWh. I also note that the temperature was 23 degrees.
Average for this van is 2.7-2.9 mi/kWh on a van type journey involving motorways and dual carriageways driving about 60-65mph in summer/spring and winter. That’s an average speed around 45mph. The efficiency rockets above 13 degrees and drop to about 2.4-2.6 in winter when it really drops. I slow down to 56-60mph which helps with efficiency.
Try running ECO in winter. Heating is next to useless in ECO mode when it’s -1 and below outside! ECO to NORMAL mode efficiency is about 0.1 to 0.2 mi/kWh variation. I bought some heated seat covers but I believe now heated seats are fitted as standard.
Also headwinds are a big factor in efficiency. You learn to “lorry surf” to help with range in headwinds.
All told though I love the van and the EV driving experience. Won’t be going back to an ICE vehicle.
With regard to the brakelight during regen discussion: I used to use engine braking in my diesel Vectra extensively with similar deceleration rates to the highest regen modes in EVs I've driven, Drivers should always leave sufficient space in front of a vehicle to react to anything, I know many don't but then there's always the opportunity of a personal injury payout 😉
Neither of the two EVs I've driven the most; Smart ForTwo ED (451) and Mitsubishi i-Miev activate their brakelights in their strongest regen modes (I tested them on a long straight road at night with a number of reflective signs that would reflect brakelights). I wonder if the Regen brakelight activation has been a piece of legislation introduced after a particular date?
I believe there is legislation on this and there's a certain G force when the brake lights should be activated. Neither the Smart or i-MiEV have particularly strong regen, so could not be reaching that deceleration limit anyway. However, these Stellantis vehicles can, yet no brake lights. I'm surprised they can get away with this.
The idea of no inertia activated brake lights for regen would make me nervous if using it aggressively. I wonder in what meeting did someone say, 'It'll be ok'.
Exactly. Other Stellantis vehicles, like the Vauxhall e-Corsa, are the same too.
1. Van speed limit on single and dual carriageway national speed limits are 50 and 60 respectively
2. Regen must show brake lights at a deceleration of 1.3 m/s2 which is 0.132563 G.
Clearly this brake light 'rule' isn't being deployed by PSA/Stellantis as these vans, the e-Corsa and other EVs are not doing this.
Worst thing about eletric cars is when new model comes with better range , your car is wothless and everybody want the new one witch the better range :) . they need to think again how they do this , better idea is to have replaceable battery and slots in the car and you can configure your range what you need ! if you need only go 100 km you can take 2 battery with you of 8 battery slots , then you can control the power that you need , if you buy this 75 kw car you always carry the hole battery whatever you need it or not , always drive wery heavy , they need to rethink battery cars , best to have universal battery , you can have everywhere on gas stations . this idea is no good and make you loose alot money when the new better range comes out .
Thanks
we are considering getting one of these vans
The Peugeot
for a camper
that is when if Peugeot New Zealand eventually imports them unfortunately they are only considering importing the 50 KWh and not the people mover versions which is what we would prefer
What range do you think we would get on the open road in summer?
Cheers
Obviously depends on driving economy. But assuming "open road" means, no regen, I'd guess about 3mpkWh, so around 135 miles.
An electrician on TH-cam was talking to a bt guy who was driving one of these in central London, must have had the larger battery as it was meant to do over 200 miles.
By the time they put all their kit in the back and ladders on the roof, they were getting 70 miles out of the thing before it needed charging, rubbish really.
I suspect the main issue here is not the weight, but the driving style. I see this all too often. Its very easy for a new EV driver to enjoy the torque and drive their new EV very inefficiently and much faster than they were driving their previous diesel van. With the lack of noise, vibration etc, you don't get the same sense of speed in the new electric vehicle, hence it feels slower than you're actually doing.
Ladders and roof racks will increase consumption and reduce range a bit though.
But there's no way, that cargo weight and ladders on the roof will reduce the range of a 75kWh van down to 70 miles. That is mostly down to the driver.
Re-Gen is no different to changing down to a lower gear in a manual car/van ... No brake lights showing but the vehicle is slowing down
I believe the last 25% goes down faster than the first 25% on these batteries.
With respect, if you were driving a diesel & took your foot off the throttle, using the engine to slow the vehicle, after changing down a gear, you'd be driving like your in B mode, would you not? The breaks wouldn't activate either!
Engine braking in a diesel is only about 1/10th of what B mode is. B mode is like putting the brakes on harder than you would most of the time. In normal mode (i.e non-B mode) the "engine" braking in this EV is still about 2-3 times stronger than engine braking in a diesel. So in this mode, the brake lights don't need to come on, but in B mode, they really should do and do in all other EVs.
Thank u
Glad it was useful.
GOOD LAD I NOTICE YOUR LISTENING TO LBC , FASTEST GROWING TALK STATION , VERY INTERESTING VIDEO THO
That's great! Just wish we could buy these in the US , especially if the range gets close to 300 miles.
Hello 🤗👋👋, I am Sam. If you have some time I want to discuss with you about the business.
Cheapest Toyota electric Van brand new is £36,000 with VAT... sole trader uses van for business and pleasure. Seriously...........
The EV is £5,500+VAT more than the 2.0l diesel versions. So yes, they are more, but hugely. Get a 1 year old one and the prices are on par.
5k miles and it needs a service? Wtf???
New spark plugs or oil change?
Ridiculous.
It's just turned a year old. Due to legacy manufacturers with dealerships I'm afraid. They would't sell them unless the dealerships can service them every year! It was only an inspection service at £79 inc VAT.
My ev went in for a service at 1 year. It was at 9k miles. It was just an inspection and tyre rotation. 56 quid, bargain
@@stulop I just had an MoT on my car. Passed with flying colours. No service yet. Repairs, but no service.
@@SirHackaL0t. OK.... But it is good to service for your vehicle when required. Oil changes etc
@@AdrianMcDaid true, changing the engine oil is important - if you have an engine. As my last post mentioned.